Georg Lukács and the Development of Western Marxism (Makers of the Modern World)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- Our website: www.justandsinn...
Patreon: / justandsinner
This video is part of our "Makers of the Modern World" series. Here, I discuss György Lukács and Western Marxism as it impacts our culture.
i love that his name is basically a translated rendition of George Lucas
It's actually the other way around
@@jakobson219 He is star struck but at least he stumbled into intellectual space seeking to follow George Lucas
Started to listen because it seemed like a fair treatment. However I was soon disappointed and I stopped.
You seemed to be puzzled why anyone well-to-do would side with poor and working people, suggesting it may be due to psychological issues. A strange reaction for someone from the Christian tradition, which on the surface honors people who help those in need.
Agsin you are puzzled why a Jewish businessman like Lukacs's father would convert to Protestantism. Have you never heard of the anti-Semitism that prevailed at that time? Sadly, Lutherans often participated.
You laughed at the fights between factions of the communist movement. As you know, Christianity has a long history of fights between the denominations, including multiple wars and murders.
At that point I stopped listening because your talk was edging into propaganda rather than a serious intellectual examination.
Americans could improve on their communication skills by learning to be brief.
Your personal attacks on marxist thinkers are childish, actually very childish, typical of religious dogmatists.
It doesn't matter who the thinker is, you have to evaluate IDEAS on their own merit.
Socrates was an abhorrent fellow to his contemporary athenians and was so immoral that they had to make him drink hemlock.
Mr. Bishop, if you want people to take your paleolithic stories written by hebrew temple priests seriously, you better start presenting something that people usually call A COUNTER-ARGUMENT.
Pointing out the personality flaws of the thinker do not amount to the negation of his ideas and arguments, presenting a counter-argument does.
Now, i know it is a subtle thing to understand, but I have hope for you.
PRAISE THE LORD.
I have a lot of sympathy with a lot of the ideas presented here, and am fairly Anti-Capitalist and even Revolutionary, but I have to say that your vitriolic comment here is not doing much to help the Cause.
@@scythermantis Ah, well it is just a little bit of tough love.
@@saimbhat6243 Hahaha fair enough
Maybe I've seen the light
Let's hang out and be graffiti artists and arsonists together!
@@scythermantis I like sports. A Soccer game ??
I got 45 minutes into this video before I realized it wasn't about Star Wars or its creator.
I feel like I was tricked by the title into learning something useful. You win this round, Dr. Cooper, you win this round.
Solid rundown but the subjective editorializing was, well, unsurprising Western Anglo moralizing and ignorance. Go travel and live with the ppl, especially outside of the cities, where socialists govt's exist, or even where they don't, and your "the working class doesn't support Marxism" assertion runs into serious problems. But you and your ilk won't ever do that.
Also, would it hurt to pronounce Gramsci's name correctly? God forbid we ditch our North American "accents" occasionally for the bare minimum effort of saying someones name. Touch grass Doc.
As one in academics, your explanation and connection to theology is helpful. Thank you for this series. Can you also do Levinas?
They are Hegelian so the idea you can completely get rid of Western culture is wrong. The idea is that within the western imperialist culture exists the proletarian culture and that by critiquing western culture, you neutralize the oppressive elements. You can never really start over under this worldview. You're always synthesizing the past with praxis
Who financed communism in Russia and throughout the world??
I appreciate this series very much. It is very helpful in understanding where these ideas are coming from. Thank you for your time and effort. It is truly a blessing.
This series is an invaluable contribution to Christian thought. It gives us the language and understanding necessary to interact with the hazards of the modern age
Thank you!
Correction: Marx and Engels are not deterministic, although they did believe in searching for "laws of motion" in scientific processes. If you look at Gramsci's critique of Bukharin for example, many of the arguments he makes against Bukharin's theory of historical materialism are backed up with quotes from Marx and Engels. This is important as well in Lenin's Philosophical Notebooks, which develops the Hegelian character of Marx's thought. So these terms, teleology and determinism, are in fact concepts that a good Marxist criticizes. The goal is to develop a materialist theory that can explain the world we live in, and that is open to developments in economics, culture, philosophy, science, and so on, but that is NOT deterministic.
That's your reading. Don't insist that, dude.
I agree with you, this video interprets Marx as a mechanical materialist, which is a mistake many people make about Marxism, and in fact Marx was mercilessly critical of the mechanical materialists who came before him
This is a really cool series, I actually liked this one better than the Marx video… probably because I’d never heard of this guy before. Keep it up!
What a lucid critique of Marxism around 1:00:00!
Also, it's fascinating how White Privilege (and the various "privileges") is talked about in the same way as Lukåcs did the proletariat. You know, white privilege blinds white people and the perspective of people of color is more true because they understand both the oppressor's worldview and their own... but also if the particular non-white person doesn't agree with the activist, they are "internalizing racism" and need to come to understand their true plight (which, the [often] white activist clearly understands for them). Same Theory, different people.
And both are true.
I have to commend you for all the work you are doing for this series on Marxism and Marxist thought. This is most enlightening and will serve as a handy source to point others to in order to learn what they are dealing with. Knowledge is empowerment. I also agree with you that as Christians we would much rather be focused solely on Law and Gospel but we can’t ignore what is happening around us. The West is becoming Marxist.
Hello there Dr Jordan Cooper Another enlighten content and more thought provoking material to think about ✝️❤️
I loved this--many thanks. I would have appreciated a description of the kind of sex education that Lukacs tried to impose during his term of office. I have searched but can't find one.
Workers tend to be too busy working to plan a revolution, not that hard to figure out.
Erős vár a mi Istenünk! Thank you for the superb presentation, your pronunciation of the surname Lukács is great, György is [ˈɟørɟ], often shortened to Gyuri.
The stress is on the first syllable, though. LOO-kutch.
Brother, a heartfelt thanks for delving into this material. I don't think I would ever have the chance to read this gentlemen, so I appreciate your attempt to increase my understanding.
I like this series, keep up the good work.
Critical Theorists telling us what our problem is 🤔 Does not the Scriptures do that 🙄
Do you really have to learn German to read Hegel?
Are your Powerpoint presentations available online?
Not currently.
@@DrJordanBCooper I suggest that you have them available on your website as PDF or Google slides. It will be a great way to educate people since people will share your presentations. Add a link to your videos on your presentations. A great way to increase subscribers and people take it seriously when there are written documents.
Are you Jordan Peterson?
The interpretation of Luckacs’ humanism is just wrong. That is not what humanism means generally; “humanism “ and the “ humanities disciplines” are not synonyms. There’s much in Christianity that is sympathetic with humanist ideals, and there is a Christian humanism that dates back to the Renaissance.
It is also worthwhile distinguishing revolutionary Marxists from “the Left” and totalitarianism, which is also erroneously presented as synonyms or a slippery slope here. We should not forget that Democratic Socialists-who are also “Left”- were always considered the enemy of the Marxists because they were reformists, not revolutionaries and saw a role for capitalism and liberal political economy regulated-for ethical reasons-with social welfare safeguards.
@@spcphdthe amount of lazy and ignorant thinking around this issue is overwhelming
I really appreciate this series. I especially found this discussion of Lukács valuable - it seems that he and Gramsci had similar ideas at similar times (I don't know if they knew of each other's work or if one built on the work of the other), but I was not as aware of the parallel before this presentation.
They were born only six years apart. I know that Gramsci does cite Lukács in the Prison Notebooks, but I am not aware of whether or not Lukács was familiar with Gramsci's work during Gramsci's lifetime. He certainly was afterward.
Too much talking about your series what you've done what you plan to do how you figured out the pronunciation of Lukac's name nursery on Mark's of thinker is coming from.... Just get to the topic.
In the original Hungarian, it's pronounced like George, but instead of the "or" sound in the middle, it's "uh", like G-uh-rge.
This series is very interesting. I'm looking forward to the future entries. Thank you.
Your breadth and depth of interests is impressive, but more importantly very useful
I love his work on War in the Stars: Hope restored volume IV
Maybe 1818 isn’t a typo at all, he’s probably a time traveler
Really appreciate this content. Thank you!
buen video bro lo voy a usar como referencia para una de mis tareas de Ciencias políticas y sociales
very understandable and useful. Thank you.
By all means repeat yourself again.
I love this series! Can't wait for the next one :)
Well done! 59:53
I didn't have a good opinion of Lukacs. Now I have a worse one.
Bless your heart