Question Time | 30th November 2023
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 лис 2023
- Fiona Bruce presents topical debate from Doncaster in South Yorkshire. On the panel are cabinet office minister Esther McVey MP, Labour's shadow environment secretary Steve Reed MP, Liberal Democrats' foreign affairs spokesperson Layla Moran MP, comedian Zoe Lyons and journalist and broadcaster Andrew Neil. Live on iPlayer at 8pm.
Copyright (C) BBC, BBC News, BBC One, BBC Worldwide, 2023. If you would like me to remove this video, please contact me, not UA-cam.
Hey! It would be greatly appreciated if you could buy me a coffee in lieu of all the videos I have uploaded. Everything here is free, worldwide. It really helps, Thank You.
www.buymeacoffee.com/politica...
Satisfying to see McVeigh’s “job” laughed out of the studio. Well played, Doncaster
Esther McVey loves the sound of her own voice..... I don't think anyone else does.
Fine looking woman though
@@Tayloradrift😵💫😵💫😵💫
@@Tayloradrift Should have gone to Specsavers.
@@Tayloradrift Yes, but apart from her looks she has nothing. She is a vile person who waged war on the sick, disabled and poor.
@@Tayloradrift. Really ? Do you like Suella too ?
I can't listen to Esther McVey. She's our Sarah Palin 🥴
👍
haha, just made the same point separately, didn't see your comment before i made it.
Minister for Common Sense sounds like a joke, then again the tories are also a bit of a joke.
The most intelligent sounding audience I've seen on QT.
Go watch the Belfast show
In other words they all agree with you.
@@Ridersonthestorm8899 can't be too hard not to agree with Israels genocidal tendencies
Layla M. Peace for all❤❤❤✌️✌️✌️ thank you...
What about the 8000 Palestinians children who died due to Israeli air strikes? Why can’t we say stop and NO to these children killing ?
Was it 8000 how do you know? Deny Hamas and give back all the hostages.
Honestly...The Ministry for Common Sense is like something straight out of Monty Python. That Ester McVey is as much a genius as Nadine Dorries, or Liz Truss....where do i end. So much for the white men with grey hair making a mess of things argument!
Misogynist comment
They all remind me of middle class drunks. Crying into their chardonnay, because no one understands them.
so far we have a ministry for common sense, a mr. cleverly and a miss truss plus a man doing survival in the jungle called nigel.....forage
Fiona Bruce does her best - but allowing certain members of the panel to run unchecked over the Gaza/Palestine issue only divides and inflames people further, And the minister for common sense - well, she didn't seem to have any and just repeated the same old tory narrative,
Why Fiona Bruce interrupted Layla when she was making the point about Hong Kong migrants.
Because she is incompetent
Who, Fiona or Layla?@@rooks4ever
Does Fiona Bruce prefer stand up comedy to being a serious political arbitrator .Is there no Robin Days or Dimblebys any more?
And Dimbleby wasnt funny?! 😅
Esther McVile hoping to get promoted to the Minister for Funny Walks in the Xmas Musical Chairs LOL
IT'S NEVER THE TORIES FAULT FOR THE MESS.
ALWAYS COVID, WAR IN UKRAINE OR SOMETHING ELSE.
I agree but the Left is still blaming Thatcher when she's been out of office for 33 years.
Esther, minister for common sense. I believe she should be minister with out sense. She always interrupts other speakers. Learn some politeness. Greetings from Australia.
You dont have to have strength in a situation, you just have to stand for justice.
Thanks for the upload.
33:30 Obese man can't figure out that both refusing to suitably train & pay natives as well as poaching those already paid for to be trained from poorer countries are both Wrong & should be stopped.
English Children set to be a Minority in English Schools in 12 years.
The English in England in a mere few decades
All Britons in the UK (& Isles as a whole) only a few short years after that.
Still an unbroken Omerta on even mentioning it.
We Were Never Asked
We don't have enough children in this country. You need young people to pay taxes, so that pensioners can have pensions, healthcare, social care. Our financial model is built on the requirement to have a decent proportion of young people compared to old.
The government could stop immigration, but if they did the economic system would collapse
@@tomcapping2136
15 years ago The Independant was reporting* that the Actual total UK population figure was between 77 & 80 million, compared to the official total figure of 65 million at that time.
*based on analysis reported by the major food retailers - but seperately also corroborated by reported sewage engineer analysis.
There were over half as many again non Irish EU Nationals that apploed for settled status after the Leave vote than the Governments prior figures had estimated to be in the country & that was a demographic that had nothing to hide.
The latest official ONS stats only acknowledges a total population of 68 million & that's despite the Home Office officially issuing over 500k immigration visas in 2021 & over 1.2million in 2022.
The same official stats project that since 2018 90% of UK total population growth by 2050 will be due to immigration & that calculation doesn't account for those non natives of foreign extraction here before 2018, or the massive (15mil?) undercounting generally.
The generally touted fact saying migrants contribute more than they take out of the econony is an extrapolation of a study on skilled European migration onto anyone in the world that turns up here & so is totally false. (Obviously so when you look at social housing & how many cross the net tax contribution threshold & that's even before the huge amounts housing the chancers that have broken in that contribute nothing in tax).
It's not difficult to conceive of a system that would have allowed for and strictly controlled large amounts of short term foreign workers, (without their children and families), and obligations on businesses and institutions here to train up, apprentice and employ Natives and British Citizens.
The way follows the will and the will of the power elite is that we should be replaced by a disorganised mass from across the world that are used to lower standards.
@@GodsOwnPrototype I don't know whether or not the population is 15 miillion more than the official number, I'm sure it's some amount higher, but I am not clear why you are so happy to believe that particular article (that I don't even know if it exists), and at the same time dismiss a load of other articles and sources that say the opposite? What is it that makes this particular article so credible when in putting such faith in it you are dismissing many more articles in that and other newspapers that say sometihing different?
I also don't know whether immigrants overall are net contributors or not, but your 'all you have to do is look at social housing' is a vague and anecdotal argument- I could just say 'all you have to do is look at all the hard working immigrants and how little benefits they get', and I'm making completely the opposite argument, with exactly the same authority as you are, right? Therefore maybe saying 'all you have to do is look at it' is not a sound foundation to build a belief like this on, for either perspective.
My point in my previous comment was that we have an increasing number of retired people, who need a lot of health and social care, and that if they are no longer working, you need young people working to pay the tax to cover the things that taxes get spent on. I don't see how you can disagree that reitred people who use public services are being partially covered by younger people, and therefore we need a good number of young people to keep that arrangement going,
Even if there was 15 million illegal people in the country then it would be good to get that reduced, to get them in work, or deported, etc., but it wouldn't actually be relevant to my argument, as it wouldn't change the fact that you need young people to pay for old people, if you are going to have an NHS, state pension, etc.
@@tomcapping2136
UA-cam being what it is, linking to external sources hasn't really been possible for years.
Just Steelman either position looking for the best sources for & arguments against each position & see where you end up.
The schools own demographic reporting has for years shown a consistent 1% annual demographic shift from native population to those of foreign extraction in their ethnicity stats & that currently has Britons in English schools set to be a minority in 12 years; which means absent any countervailing action the reality of native minoritisation is locked in.
I've yet to encounter any stats to contradict that in the direction of it happening later, let alone never happening.
No one can say these demographic policies of minoritisation were proposed in any speech or manifesto, let alone received a mandate by Britons voting for their minoritisation.
No one can say that it is a natural occurence, given how much institutional effort goes into supressing the native population's unhappiness about it & propaganda gaslighting that it both isn't happening, doesn't matter whether it is & is of course a good thing to occur anyway.
Demography is The most reliable of the social sciences & the trends have been discernable for years & the milestones well noted along the way, so there is no argument of ignorance to this occurence.
My father is the youngest of 4 sons, none of his brothers had children, he had 9 & his 8 surviving children have given him 30 grand children. (I'm his 3rd & my 5th child is his 30th).
He's never been even close to wealthy, nor have I & the most well off of my siblings stopped at 2 children & takes loads of holidays abroad.
It's about priorities & choices.
As is the government allowing millions of foreign people to break into the country, or remain well past their permitted time, or just be issued visas* to come & bring their families anyway & spending billions more housing them than they have on the leveling up budget for the whole of the North.
(*Like The Young Working Indian Visa scheme Rishi Sunak just set up.
Be a young adult citizen of the world's most populous nation, have a bachelor's degree issued by any of their institutions of variable degrees of vigour & integrity, have 2 thousand pounds in the bank: now have a UK work visa)
It would cost less, and save more years of life for the eldery, to set up winter care homes in North Africa for all pensioners to reside in for the winter months.
Much as it would to expand the British diplomatic & aid footprint & fascilities in every developing country & give protection & provisions to refugees of all kinds locally.
Britain industrialised & explored & connected the world giving only 5 years of compulsory education between the ages of 5 & 10, mostly on proper grammar in English & Latin & Logic both linguistic & mathematic & lots of physical exercise.
Just cutting the compulsory age of school from 18 down to 14 & pushing companies to provide training & apprenticeships would solve many problems.
You can cycle through most of the world's able young people coming to work for a time in Britain without giving them benefits out of the taxpayer funded public purse, (especially housing), or leave to remain & chain migrate dozens of their family members here, or positions of influence & leadership in our institutions.
There are numerous other ways of running a society without strip mining it & replacing the native population.
They just haven't been the ones chosen.
Show me an entirely secular region of the world and I’ll show you peace.
Wot next for Esther after Minister for No Sense? A slot on GBN beckons.
Brilliant first question
Andrew Neil is definitely mad.
He’s the only one there with more IQ and knowledge than the rest of the panellists put together… that’s why he looks mad to you.
Never trust,GBN
Where I work, in the last 2 years have brought in cheap labour, and some are getting more money than people who have worked there for a while/ including myself, some can't speak English properly. Wish they would stop the favourtism.
Isreal / Gaza . The average English person doesn’t give two hoots . This is England 🏴. We care about our shores and our own children being targeted like in Manchester
They called Nelson Mandela a “terrorist”, until it was universally accepted that what drove him to terrorism, Apartheid, was far more the terrorism.
ministry fer common sense!?!, now i've haerd ever thing.
"Common sense"
sounds better than
Reality Facts of what going on team.😂
Andrew is the only talking pragmatic common sense …..he could nentor Esther!!
Terrible spelling and grammar
Pragmatic common sense - that’s almost funny. He’s right wing enough to be the new Tory leader. His competence, if you can call it that, is criticising the two equally rebarbative main Party’s.
Are you serious Christine??...Neil is a egomaniac who, as an editor and as a commentator, has backed and argued for almost every crackpot right wing freemarket economic experiment that the Tories have tried over the last 40 years that have put the UK in the terrible state it is in now!
Andrew's take on this is an emerging right wing take. Especially coming from conservatives tired of supporting israel..."let it play out"
So they can say "we didn't support it"
They have given the gift of Net Zero to every part of the country!
07:43 - you can see ester die inside
At 20:00 the gentleman is confused about 'trickle down economics' and what he describes is local economic development.
EstherMcVey gives somewhat (?) better account of herself, here where serious, than when she’s grinning…elsewhere 🤥 hic!
All care homes in England are privatized, I am at a loss trying to spot a profit potential in caring for our older members in society ? I can reluctantly imagine that unfortunately there’s a certain kind of person who’d be capable of putting their own entitlement before the well being of others ,
31:50 What a cringey eye roller
If there are borders, there are just laws on entry & where there are laws their being broken creates an injustice for the society they protect and an illegality has occurred due to a person or persons being present in the country illegally & so having a negative impact on the communal bonds.& shared goods of the people they are imposing themsleves upon.
Thanks for posting this.
There's no point commenting about :
1. How little common-sense the Minister of Common Sense has.
2. Gaza.
No one is listening.
What's sad is I agree
Minister of common sense has no common sense
We are listening. We the people are listening. And it's time to hold our politicians to account.
Andrew is spot on on Gaza issues
Why isn't anyone talking about ending the occupation? Without that peace can never happen?
Because the UK media is too obsessed with giving Israel the green light.
Andrew Neil just called Hamas Nazis, even though the Israeli govt has laid both siege and apartheid for decades to the Palestinians.
What occupation? Israel ethnically cleansed itself out of Gaza in 2005
And what about Cornwall, missed out in the list expounded. « East and West.. »
"I'm just in shock". Oh be quiet. You beat your husband up.
Andrew Neill was right, he didn’t beat around the bush but he was being realistic, very sadly.
He's a mummified lich brought to sentience by a cursed relic and won't even be around to see the results of his doomer narratives and policies so he should do like every other desiccated bag of bones with one foot in the nursing home and the other in the mouth of a starving maggot; exit stage left immediately and let the younger generations clean up the messes he made.
The shadow lab guy looks like that little weasels liberal leader
No one opens their heart to people here.
Go to it Andrew! Thank God YOU are there to contest the b/lies of the American in the public with his pro Hamas guys propaganda!
Well said Andrew Neil.
He spoke like a Primary 7 pupil trying to impress his classmates.
The work place is unbearable in all sectors . We want to work with people who understand us when we speak . Understand our banter and jokes . Get real hey unbelievable
UK.. government London/ Labour or conservative which ever party failed over the last decade sick how these idiots are still getting paid as politicians..bring back Gordon brown..the man with common sense. These idiots got everything wrong &still talked about COVID.Esther t*sh.
Can't believe I'm saying this, but vote lib dem I guess. That's the first time I've heard a leading politician talk sense on Gaza
Replace it with hope?😅
Idealistic but no way in touch with reality. If you want to replace an ideology the way she says she wants to, then you have to remove the root of the old one first. Israel is doing that. It's painful to watch but it has got to be done. Then they can deradicalise the place, same as what was done in Germany and Japan after WWII
bring jeremy clarkson on the show
Andrew Neil is the only person who sees the reality and is not dreaming
He's a hypocrite he mentioned the 3 people killed by Palestinians but ignored the 8 years old kid shot in the head by an IDF sniper,. two-state will happen there is no way the hypocrite could veto this they are already exposed and naked even the Chinese look more democratic than the hypocrite.
Yes I agree. Out of all of them
On the panel…, he had his finger on the pulse. He’s very good and articulate
You're offended? I'm still waiting to hear your argument.” Christopher Hitchens.
Andrew saying Palestinians want to kill Israelis only because they are Jews.. and that Palestinians voted in Hamas (in 2006, over 50% the population are under 18) and would vote them in in the West Bank now - is he so ignorant or is he choosing to ignore the fact that probably well over half the population of Gaza have had close family members or friends killed by the IDF. Is he choosing to ignore the land grabs by the settlers in the West Bank? In some cases people literally having their houses stolen by settlers. Of course he is choosing to ignore these issues because surely one with his career could not be so ignorant.
The absurdity of the host to act surprised when an audience member suggests the IDF, who have killed 15,000 civilians inc 6,000+ children (or as bbc would say people under 18), bombed hospitals, been filmed driving tanks dragging wounded/dead bodies up the road etc etc might call the IDF terrorists. The unoriginal catchphrase of "Israel has the right to defend itself" (Do they teach this at Day 1 of Politician school?) just does not cut it. The media have lost so much credibility since the pandemic and are losing more every time they move their lips in front of a camera these days. Thank god for the rise of independent media.
Thank you, I was looking for the sanity in the vile comments supporting Neil's inhumane commemts
What did he say that was inhumane?@@rooks4ever
Well said. I don't know how Laila Moran kept her temper....Neil is so ignorant.
The over fed twat gets his facts from the BBC.😂
@@cseosborn892 Any defence of Israel is inhumane. Unless you have not seen what they are doing, this should be your only excuse, in that case. You shouldn't comment.
Migration numbers are too low
33:17 The average pay for a junior doctor is £55k
Rubbish! My daughter is a junior doctor and earns nothing like this.
@@colinarcher8516 In that case she must be below average.
13:37.
Wow andrew o neale stand up, spot on.
Just remember lst war 60000 were kill in one day
As usual a cherry 🍒 picked audience. ✌🏽🇵🇸🇧🇩
Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱🇬🇧🇮🇱
🎉Always money for
Wars.🎉
Nothing left for the
NHS😢
Surprised yet?
Plenty for NHS consultants pay rises and gold plated pensions.
A Chinese guy bring anti immigrant.. 🤦🏾♂️
He sounded pretty English to me, based on his accent at least!
@@sabaidaniel555
The English are an ethnic group of the British Isles in the North West region of Europe.
The Chinese are an ethnic group of the Central Far East region of Asia.
They are different from each other and there are those of both ethnicities that possess British citizenship and those that do not.
I have no problem with people of foreign extraction objecting to uncontrolled mass immigration, especially those that almost certainly jumped through all the hoops to do so legally, integrate and contribute, which by the sound of it this gentleman largely has.
I think the Chinese are the most successful immigrant group in the UK, alongside the Indians so it makes sense
He could have been born in England. @@GodsOwnPrototype
I think Jews are the most successful immigrant group. @@KJ-js7pi
Palestine could surrender, or, it could have put its civilians and kids out of harms way before it attacked Israel on Oct 7th. The adults do not act in "the best interests of the child" but in the best interests of hamas.
Andrew Neil is the only person with actual common sense on the panel. If only he still had his show.
Theres no hope and no solution..... great input
He's a relic from the days when the BBC still had any credibility.
You are so right. He's the only one who talks common sense
He's clearly correct, though.@@keiranmorrisart
@@RogerJJSmith 'clearly' often = gaslighting
Andrew Neal was outstanding on the panel.
Calling for genocide from his ivory tower? Odd definition of fantastic
@@jn4126I must of missed that part....you should report it (with timestamp) to youtube and they will take this video down for hate speech. Then report the BBC to Ofcom...calling for genocide is unaceptable..........just kidding...obviously you're a crank.
You must be deaf if you think that's what he did. @@jn4126
How?? What he said was shocking. Imagine him during slavery or during the holocaust?
@@charsobishi people like you are exactly the people who commited slavery and the holocaust.....still somehow comfortable in your moral superiority. Quote me one sentence from Mr Neal that has any equivalance with either.
It DID NOT start on October 7th.
Israel started this trouble, genocide and human rights abuses of the Palestinians, many, many years ago.
It DID NOT start on October 7th!
ah. laylas feelings were hurt at the end :-) victim mentality all over...
there's no wealth in the south... London is mostly poor
I wish lowkey was on that panel he would have been spitting straight facts
Finkelstein and Zomlot too
Who the f is lowkey......the fact you say he 'spits facts' suggests he's a knob.
Ahhh the yoof of today, learning their history from thicko tiktokers and rabid anti semites
Isn't it a little bigoted to introduce an MP saying she is of Palestinian descent. I have never heard a Jewish MP say they are of Judean descent, or in fact any other descent.
Theres no solution..... great input clown
Andrew Neil, if only there were more like you. Sensible and articulate. The UK needs reasonable people.
42:56. Surely The right of self-defense belongs to the Palestinians who have been usurped, subjected to endless cycles of massacres, brutality, degradation, ethnic cleansings on a regular basis, etc, since the past 70+ years by a settler colonial state - the term agreed - by Theodor Hertzl and other past Zionists, masterminded by Britain - Churchill's pet colonial project because he believed in the right of the superior race to supplant that of an inferior one or rule over. He viewed Arabs as inferior and the "Aryans will prevail". He mean't the English.
They say Arabs are inferior but in truth I think they feared that they are superior. We are equal and that's what Arabs believe. Did you know Muslims are taught that everyone is born Muslim, they just don't recognise it. They believe we are all brothers and sisters, nobody is superior.
Ahhh the perrenial victim narrative. As if everything was done to them and they had no responsibility for the situation they're in today. The poor helpless people that waged war against their neighbours, yet lost every time. The poor helpless people that refused every form of two state solution that was ever offered to them. The poor, helpless people that initiated 2 intafadas against their neighbours then whined and complained about the security measures put in place to contain them. The poor, helpless people that condition their children to hate Jews and to propagate violence. Stop peddling lies.
Quite!
In 1947 a theocratic state was formed by the English and anyone who was not of that religion was killed and dispossessed of their land. Over one million murders because someone had a different religion. I don't hear anyone condemning Pakistan, I wonder why?
@@registeredmental many countries were created from scratch or had their borders redrawn in the wake of WWII, each time leading to mass displacement of people and lots of death. These things happened in contemporaniety with the formation of Israel, and the movement of between 540000 and 700000 Palestinians was small, comparatively, and the number of deaths compared to what happened during these other displacements was minute. Why, then, is it Israel that has its legitimacy challenged, denied its right to defend itself (either implicitly or explicitly) and is held accountable for an "ethnic cleansing" that it didn't even perpetrate?
Retaliation is NOT self defense!!
It is when you are oppressed
People calling for a ceasefire are absoloutley deluded, there was a ceasrefire already and looked what happened. It's a politics show in the UK, we don't need an account of her family personal issues tbh. Thinking 'hope' will save this ahaha. Islam needs to reform like Christianity did...
Totally right. Obsession with the moribund beliefs of Islamic states , is the root of the problem.
You haven't got a clue. I notice Neil didn't mention the fact that Israel have killed over 200 Palestinians in the West Bank during this so called truce including an 8 year old Palestinian boy who was shot in the back of the head two days ago by the Israeli Occupying Forces.
@@cseosborn892no, Zionists are the root problem. Before they moved in, muslims, christians, and Jews all lived in peace.
How did christianity reform?
Andrew Neil is sensible and objective. We need more journalists like him!
Agree. Didn't he trade his reputation in order to get GB News over the line?
Andrew Neil objective? Hardly. Just another right wing friend of capital. Criticising the incompetent, misanthropic and mammon loving Government and the equally inept opposition is like fishing in a barrel. Good to see that roadkill marking is still doing its job too.
I assumethat is a joke? Neil and his ilk have, almost without exception, backed every nonsensical, crackpot economic experiment the free market right have tried on since Thatcher, selling off UK assets, privatisations, shifts of wealth from the working people to the rich etc...the very policies that have run the country into the ground. his old boy nonsense here is ridiculous..lets things play out he says....if only he were there on the receiving end of 'things playing out." he might well change his tune and start thinking.
No, he took a job and was promised a specific type of product to helm, then received something different, so he resigned.@@kiriakoz
@@DancinJim i'm pretty sure he could've guessed that it was going to be classic gammon fodder. that's completely on him, it's Murdoch owned ffs. He helped set up Fox News, so he could've guessed imo.
The Ester is a beauty, she could have her on slot on GB news.......
You must be desperate mon
@@user-ob4wo9po2y hell yeah, she's the perfect fit for that GB Farage channel thingy....
Why? Physically she’s objectively very attractive.@@user-ob4wo9po2y
Takes all sorts.
Andrew Neil was the only person with a fully functioning brain in the entire room !
Old white guy saying there's no hope...😂 ok mate.
He has the experience of a lifetime in politics to draw upon. Numpty
There is a reason why white supremacists always support Isreal.
Andrew Neil sounds hammered
Didn't the Palestinians vote for Hamas?
I believe only 40% of the population back in 2006 voted for Hamas. That was 17 years ago. Considering 45% of Palestine's population are under 18, that means they were less than a year old when Hamas were voted in. So, no, the current Palestine did not vote for Hamas.
But recent polling showed 75% of the population strongly in favour of them. However, it's hard to say how much fear and coercion was involved in that.
@@Supercapraia I'm not sure. From what I've read: "We find in our surveys that 67 percent of Palestinians in Gaza had little or no trust in Hamas in that period right before the attacks," said Amaney Jamal, dean of Princeton's School of Public and International Affairs. It might have increased slightly for those who are in anguish over losing loved ones. But equally they might be resentful at Hamas for putting their loved ones in such a position.
And the Israelis voted for Netenyahou.
Andrew Neil the only one talking facts about Gaza & IDF. People all over the world are demonstrating supporting Palestinians. Countries are in support of Israel’s right to defend itself. All this is irrelevant because Israel said what they were going to do when Hamas brutally attacked their people. That’s when hope went. It’s just like if a country attacked the USA (to which I wouldn’t recommend) the UK which is one of its closest allies would have no influence.
This is where the you are wrong and the lack of education is clear.
Prior to that event Palestine has been under a BRUTAL occupation for over 70 years. It's essentially a concentration camp where Israel is ethnically cleansing them from their land.
Also look at who created and funded Hamas in the first place......Israel.
FYI - I have done humanitarian work in Palestine for over 7yrs so I know exactly what I'm talking about.
Israel shouldve known what their actions of ethnic cleaning in Gaza wouldve done in the long term for not just Israelis but for Jews around the world
According to international law, lsra3l does not even have the right to defend itself. So everything they did in retaliation are ALL considered war crime. Retaliation on their OCCUPIED territory, bombing hospitals, schools, refugee camps. Murdering children, women, the elderly. Commiting inhumane genocide against innocent civillians. Why is lsra3l not being condemned, why is netanyahu not being condemned. IDF is obviously a t3rr0r1st org. The UN's official definition of a t3rr0r1sm is: "criminal acts, including against civilians, committed with intent to cause death or serious bodily injury, or taking of hostages, with the purpose to provoke a state of terror in the general public or in a group of persons or particular persons,"
IDF fits the description.
@@nochi4699 To put it bluntly it’s a bloody mess my heart is breaking especially for children. If you feel the Israelis out to ethnically cleanse then Hamas has played into their hands. It’s a totally hopeless situation.
@@nochi4699what on earth are you on about, ethnic cleansing? The population in Gaza had grown exponentially since the 40s. Israel left Gaza, in fact they ethnically cleansed themselves oug of the equation!
This is now a war, with military aims. The aims are to destroy the military infrastructure and remove hamas. That is also not ethnic cleansing.
Women like Layla Moran should not be in politics
Brilliant analysis of Gaza from Andrew Neil at the end. What a clown Moran was in response, vilely offensive too - she's an MP???
Time stamp? Are you being sarcastic? Confused
@@bendevere8525must be, seeing as she was giving updates about her family, who work for the UN. She's the best person on the panel to talk about it.
Which part of what Layla said offended you? That the killing of innocent civilians should stop?
@@babymonalisa Hi. No. The part where she idiotically asked Andrew Neil after his brilliant analysis whether he was happy with the present situation. Vile.
Based on what? Doesn't give any political or diplomatic credence to her position at all, if anything it may discount her from remaining objective on the issue, that's why victims don't judge in their own trials contrary to intuition.@@rooks4ever
I don't agree with the comment that Leila and Andrew clashed. He was outright rude and disrespectful. Leila was calm disciplined and flabbergasted by his outburst
Exactly Neil was a vile person who basically saying that he supports Israel and all its war crimes.
Total balder dash.
Totally agree, he was horrible.
Layla should change her surname by deed poll. Only one letter difference needed to accurately represent her to others.
No empathy at all for having an innocent family murdered by Israel?
Xenophobic much, dancinjim?
Andrew Neil is dead right on Gaza
Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱🇬🇧🇮🇱
The people need a party that represents them and the Country. Nothing but Lies from these Criminals
I bloody HATE that thing McVeigh
Extremely rude.
@@cseosborn892 she's vile
Well said Andrew Neil, Moran is deluded
At least one of the audience needs arresting for Terrorist sympathy! lol
Not sure which audience member but yes i guess if you defend the bombing of dozens of hospitals and murder of multiple jouralists that is terrorist sympathising. It's strange that most of the media don't stand up for their colleagues murdered by the IDF