Claude with MCP is not better than ChatGPT. Not by a long shot. Even for technical users. Live demo
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 гру 2024
- Anthropic’s new Model Context Protocol (MCP) seems like promising steps towards expanding Claude with integrate with data sources, tools, and applications. But is it enough to make you switch from ChatGPT to Claude?
Let's explore together during live stream and find answers to questions like:
What exactly is MCP and how it works
How it stacks up against ChatGPT’s Custom GPTs and their powerful third-party integrations
Exploring potential use cases like integrating MCP with Bolt.New to enhance its capabilities
A live attempt to give Claude terminal access, essentially recreating ChatGPT Server Commander for Claude
Conclusions. Its hard to make it work, even for technical users, it fails without really explaining why.
Let’s see if MCP can bridge the gap between Claude’s superior model quality and the sheer functionality of ChatGPT. Tune in to find out if this could be the start of something big! 🚀
This stream concluded with me failing to make it work.
I made a mistake about misunderstanding how config file is used by Claude.
I did manage to make it work and will make follow up video next
Leave a comment if you want to be notified or subscribe.
I will publish link to video when its done in reply here.
So, for now I gave up a bit.
Here is a repo github.com/wonderwhy-er/ClaudeComputerCommander
It kinda works and kinda does not, will need to figure out why, asked for help in Antropic github for now
Even things that did work in live stream do not work anymore :D
While I did have moments when terminal commands worked
Sehr Gut Edwards
so will the preview be working soon
:D This video is not about bolt/oTToDev lol :D
It was actually really easy, just edited a jcongif this sounds like cope
@@societyofminds cope? With what lol? I am playing with them since and they still work very finicky.
This is beta release for technical people.
One example is Puppeteer mcp
It does not always load and blocks orher mcps to load.
Same happened with my terminal access mcp and turned out that they use stdout as communication channel. So if anything in your dependencies logs something mcps break...
All in all its tricky to develop for. CustomGPTs instead integrate with REST APIs and it just works...
Don't trust openai, xai will win this battle
@@eta2001carl why xAI and not google or chinise?
@@EduardsRuzga in largest model that is, xAI as x3 the compute and it is in training (gork 3) in execution that is a different story :)