I Made The Worst & Best Beatles Album Using One Song Per Album ! 2023 Version

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 104

  • @ClockworkMusics
    @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +6

    Hi everyone, thanks for the support on the video, this video is a combination of two of my favourite videos from 2023, I have uploaded a 2024 version of the best album now, with my new opinions, some of my takes in this video are interesting, and some of my spelling mistakes and confusion with songs is questionable, however o hoped you enjoyed it. ❤

  • @iamliterallyme
    @iamliterallyme 2 місяці тому +55

    My personal tracklist:
    The love part (Falling in love):
    1- I Saw Her Standing There
    2- All My Loving
    3- A Hard Day's Night
    4- Eight Days a Week
    The breakup part (Falling out of love):
    5- Yesterday
    6- I'm Looking Through You
    7- For No One
    The instrospective part (Looking inside at yourself):
    8- Strawberry Fields Forever
    9- Fixing a Hole
    The extrospective part (Looking outside at the world):
    10- The Fool on the Hill
    11- While My Guitar Gently Weeps
    12- Revolution 1
    The retrospective part (Falling back in love):
    13- The Long and Winding Road (Naked Version)
    14- Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight/The End

    • @yeehawo7
      @yeehawo7 2 місяці тому +1

      lowkey fire

    • @shaynickerson1020
      @shaynickerson1020 2 місяці тому +1

      Great track picks, plus making a cohesive story out of random songs, could work as a compilation

  • @ericleiter6179
    @ericleiter6179 2 місяці тому +2

    I think the two Past Masters "albums" should have been included or at least the #1 album from 2000...there's so many great singles to choose from, it's not fair to exclude these from a complete or ultimate Beatles album imho...but having said that, this video/project was alot of fun and has got me making my own lists now, thank you!!!

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@ericleiter6179 thanks for the support I have just released a video on past masters If you wanna check it out :)

    • @ericleiter6179
      @ericleiter6179 2 місяці тому +2

      @ClockworkMusics I will...thanks for sharing your enthusiasm for The Beatles with everyone like this!!!

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@ericleiter6179 no worries thanks for watching the videos

  • @ostrelephant
    @ostrelephant 2 місяці тому +48

    I died inside when you confused It's All Too Much with You Like Me Too Much (It's All Too Much is my favourite Beatles song ever)

  • @01real1
    @01real1 2 місяці тому +1

    The Best:
    1. Anna (Go to Him) - cover
    2. Not a 2nd Time
    3. Tell My Why
    4. I'll Follow The Sun
    5. Yesterday (of course)
    6. In My Life
    7. For No One
    8.She's Leaving Home
    9. Strawberry Fields
    10. WMGGWeeps
    11. Happiness Is A...
    12. It's All Too Much
    13. Octopuss's Garden (one of Ringo's, so everyone's included)
    14. Across The Universe

  • @ianh1984
    @ianh1984 2 місяці тому +8

    "You can't do that" is one of the best early beatles songs, it's definitely my fave from A Hard Days Night. I would go as far as to say "A Hard Days Night" is the song I like the least from the album.

  • @SCHL0P
    @SCHL0P 2 місяці тому +14

    1. Please please me
    2. All my loving
    3. A hard days night
    4. Eight days a week
    5. Help
    6. In my life
    7. Tomorrow never knows
    8. A day in the life
    9. Strawberry fields forever
    10. Bungalow Bill
    11. Hey Bulldog
    12. Something
    13. Let it be

    • @TomsRetroGames
      @TomsRetroGames 2 місяці тому +9

      This guy picked bungalow bill. I respect it

    • @heatherqualy9143
      @heatherqualy9143 2 місяці тому +1

      @@SCHL0P Daaaaaaaaang! That is probably a 90% match to mine!

    • @rdrrr
      @rdrrr 2 місяці тому +1

      No "Yesterday" or "For No One"?

    • @SCHL0P
      @SCHL0P 2 місяці тому +1

      @@rdrrr I just enjoy help better, same goes with tomorrow never knows.

    • @rdrrr
      @rdrrr 2 місяці тому +1

      @@SCHL0P It's no criticism, I just have to have a good Paul ballad in there. Blackbird's another beautiful example.

  • @absurdcheesecake
    @absurdcheesecake 2 місяці тому +3

    My personal tracklist:
    PPM: I Saw Her Standing There
    WtB: All My Loving
    AHDN: A Hard Day’s Night
    BfS: No Reply
    H: Yesterday
    RS: In My Life
    R: I’m Only Sleeping
    SPLHCB: A Day in the Life
    MMT: Strawberry Fields Forever
    TWA: While My Guitar Gently Weeps / Helter Skelter
    (I put something from disc 2 because I feel like it makes more sense to pick a song per disc for a double album)
    YS: Hey Bulldog
    AR: Something
    LIB: Across the Universe

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@absurdcheesecake awesome track list, :)

  • @ilovegeorgeharrison66
    @ilovegeorgeharrison66 2 місяці тому +2

    I LOVE SAVOY TRUFFLE 😭😭😭

  • @ryanwhittier7314
    @ryanwhittier7314 2 місяці тому +8

    In my opinion, Till There Was You is heightened by George’s wonderful solo. Paul’s vocal is great but George’s playing really takes it to the next level.

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@ryanwhittier7314 I totally agreee that solo is immensely amazing, I tried learning it on the guitar but it’s hard, thanks for the comment :)

    • @rdrrr
      @rdrrr 2 місяці тому

      @@ClockworkMusics I listened to an AM radio broadcast of a Beatles performance from late 1962. The quality is obviously pretty poor but you can tell Harrison was already ripping it up on guitar back then. His performance of Ask Me Why is so tasteful. Wonderful use of the whammy bar.

  • @alanr4447a
    @alanr4447a 2 місяці тому +16

    23:48 I think "Revaluation 9" is better than most people realize, because they tend to confuse it with *"Revolution* 9"...

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      lol

    • @braudabo
      @braudabo 2 місяці тому +5

      @@ClockworkMusics I keep writing this, one shouldn't judge it as a "song", but as a collage. It has an interesting aesthetic and can be interpreted as a "soundtrack" of the rebellious year of 1968. At least it's the best thing Lennon/Ono ever did in this area.

  • @megatronusXZ
    @megatronusXZ 2 місяці тому +4

    My list:
    1. Misery
    2. All My Loving
    3. If I Fell
    4. What You're Doing
    5. You've Got To Hide Your Love Away
    6. In My Life
    7. Tomorrow Never Knows
    8. A Day In The Life
    9. Strawberry Fields Forever
    10. Don't Pass Me By
    11. Yer Blues
    12. Hey Bulldog
    13. You Never Give Me Your Money
    14. Across The Universe

  • @coyotejohenson7245
    @coyotejohenson7245 2 місяці тому

    My best:
    1. I Saw Her Standing There
    2. All I Gotta Do
    3. If I Fell
    4. Every Little Thing
    5. Ticket to Ride
    6. Norwegian Wood
    7. For No One
    8. A Day in the Life
    9. I am the Walrus (or Strawberry Fields, tough choice)
    10. Dear Prudence
    11. Cry Baby Cry
    12. Its All Too Much
    13. Her Comes the Sun
    14. Let it Be

  • @kennet7837
    @kennet7837 2 місяці тому

    My "best" track list (and keep in mind, I've included 2 extra songs, taken from Past Masters Vol. 1 and 2):
    1. I Saw Her Standing There
    2. Till There Was You
    3. I Want to Hold Your Hand
    4. A Hard Day's Night
    5. I'm a Loser
    6. Yesterday
    7. We Can Work It Out
    8. In My Life
    9. For No One
    10. A Day in the Life
    11. Strawberry Fields Forever
    12. Dear Prudence
    13. Helter Skelter
    14. Hey Bulldog
    15. Here Comes the Sun
    16. Let It Be
    My "worst" track list:
    1. A Taste of Honey
    2. Little Child
    3. Matchbox
    4. When I Get Home
    5. Honey Don't
    6. You Like Me Too Much
    7. Run for Your Life
    8. Good Day Sunshine
    9. Good Morning Good Morning
    10. Flying
    11. Wild Honey Pie
    12. Revolution 9
    13. Only a Northern Song
    14. Her Majesty
    15. You Know My Name (Look Up the Number)
    16. Dig It

  • @josephstone2112
    @josephstone2112 2 місяці тому +4

    I think you should also be allowed to choose a song from Past Masters since they have many amazing singles that don't appear on any albums.

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@josephstone2112I might do a video on past masters not sure how I would format it

  • @renatomuller3188
    @renatomuller3188 2 місяці тому +6

    Can't I make a triple album of best songs? If George could, why can't we?

  • @Freedom2111
    @Freedom2111 2 місяці тому +2

    My best album: Ask Me Why, Till There Was You, Any Time At All, I'll Follow The Sun, Ticket To Ride, In My Life, Here There and Everywhere, She's Leaving Home, All You Need is Love, I Will, Hey Bulldog, Here Comes The Sun, and Let It Be. There are so many great songs it's not easy to choose.
    If I could include non-album singles, From Me To You would replace Ask Me Why, and We Can Work It Out would replace Here There and Everywhere.

  • @gingerwoods616
    @gingerwoods616 3 місяці тому +3

    My best album. Please Please Me, Till There Was You, A Hard Day's Night, Eight Days A Week, Ticket To Ride, In my Life, For No One, She's Leaving Home, Penny Lane, Dear Prudence, Mother Nature's Son, All You Need Is Love, The Medley, Across The Universe.

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  3 місяці тому +1

      @@gingerwoods616 you have some amazing picks there, ever since I made that video my choices have definitely changed

  • @joeharris2659
    @joeharris2659 2 місяці тому +3

    ‘Revaluation 9’ 23:51

  • @fredericlatreille
    @fredericlatreille 2 місяці тому

    Best:
    1-I Saw Here Standing There
    2- All my Loving
    3- I'll be back
    4- I'm a loser
    5- Yesterday
    6- In my life
    7- Here there and everywhere
    8- A day in the life
    9- Strawberry fields forever
    10- While my guitar gently weeps
    11- Hey Buldog
    12- Something
    13- The long and winding road
    14- I feel Fine (past masters vol 1)
    15- Rain (Past Masters vol 2)
    worst:
    1-Misery
    2- Little Child
    3- Things we said today
    4- I don't want to spoil the party
    5- Tell me what you see
    6- You won't see me
    7- Yellow submarine
    8- She's leaving home
    9- Hello Goodbye
    10- Savoy Truffle (nonwithstanding Revolution 9 and Wld honey pie)
    11- Yellow submarine (again)
    12- Maxwell's Silver Hammer
    13- Dig It
    14- Thank you girl (past masters vol 1 [nonwithstanding the German versions of 4 songs])
    15- You know my name (look up the number) (Past masters vol 2)

  • @dj71162
    @dj71162 2 місяці тому

    Instead of choosing the best songs, I've decided to choose my favourites:
    1. Baby, It's You
    2. All My Loving
    3. I Should Have Known Better
    4. What You're Doing
    5. Tell Me What You See
    6. The Word
    7. She Said She Said
    8. Getting Better
    9. Baby, You're a Rich Man
    10. Happiness Is a Warm Gun
    11. Honey Pie
    12. Yellow Submarine
    13. Oh! Darling
    14. I've Got a Feeling

  • @brennanreviews
    @brennanreviews 2 місяці тому +1

    Yer Blues is way too underrated

  • @Pwecko
    @Pwecko 2 місяці тому +3

    This sounds like mission impossible.

  • @sergei_mikhailovich
    @sergei_mikhailovich 2 місяці тому

    My list (best album):
    *Please Please Me
    *All My Loving
    *A Hard Day's Night
    *I'll Follow the Sun
    *Help!
    *Norwegian Wood
    *Eleanor Rigby
    *Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
    *Happiness is a Warm Gun
    *Blackbird
    *Penny Lane
    *It's all too much
    *Something
    *The Long and Winding Road

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@sergei_mikhailovich fair play, that’s a great list, i love all them songs, though i need to listen to it’s all to much more :)

  • @uncleroyyokelson2334
    @uncleroyyokelson2334 Місяць тому

    Til there was you - not a Beatles song. It's from 'The Music Man'. The Beatles did do a wonderful cover of it.

  • @mariogandara2015
    @mariogandara2015 2 місяці тому

    “The worst Beatles album” turned out to be a great album!!!

  • @tonrap123
    @tonrap123 2 місяці тому +1

    Agree love dont pass me by

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@tonrap123 it’s an awesome song by ringo

  • @cameronf5647
    @cameronf5647 2 місяці тому

    For me
    Best Album
    1 - Twist and Shout
    2 - Till There Was You
    3 - A Hard Day’s Night
    4 - Eight Days a Week
    5 - I’ve Just Seen a Face
    6 - In My Life
    7 - Eleanor Rigby
    8 - A Day in the Life
    9 - Strawberry Fields Forever
    10 - Happiness is a Warm Gun
    11 - I Want You (She’s So Heavy)
    12 - I Me Mine
    Worst Album
    1 - Chains
    2 - Little Child
    3 - I’ll Cry Instead
    4 - Mr. Moonlight
    5 - Dizzy Miss Lizzy
    6 - What Goes On (hard to pick)
    7 - Doctor Robert
    8 - Within You Without You
    9 - Flying (only cause it’s a short instrumental)
    10 - Revolution 9
    11 - Sun King (Not even close to being bad)
    12 - Dig It

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      Tbf you have good taste, I kinda like mr moonlight and sun king, but it’s hard to choose a bad song

  • @Mr.GoldenDarkness
    @Mr.GoldenDarkness 2 місяці тому

    My list for the worst songs for each album on my opinion
    1. Boys (This song never like me)
    2. Not a second time
    3. Any time at all
    4. Everybody's Trying to be my baby (Same like boys, this song never like me)
    5. Tell me what you see
    6. The Word
    7. Doctor Robert
    8. Good Morning
    9. Flying
    10. Wild Honey Pie (I don't put Revolution 9 only because it's too obvious lolo)
    11. Everybody's Got Something To Hide Except Me And My Monkey
    12. It's all too much
    13. Her Majesty
    14. Dig It

  • @EggsAreGreat
    @EggsAreGreat 2 місяці тому +3

    i dont think people understand that the point of an album is to tell a story, or capsule a time period. if u combine all these songs youre basically just making a greatest hits album and not a 'perfect album'. even tho it might not seem like there is a lot of connection between the songs in the albums themselves, but trust me. It's been thought about and considered for hours. the order of the songs is really important. anyways great video🤍

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      i understand what your getting at, this video was made a while ago, and ive reuploaded it with another, i just thought it might have been fun to see how it would look, thanks for the comment. :)

  • @antayudi5428
    @antayudi5428 28 днів тому

    Make the somg rivalry between John and Paul.... across the universe vs here, there and everywhere etc

  • @funkycriminal
    @funkycriminal 2 місяці тому

    My personal:
    I Saw Her Standing There
    Not A Second Time
    I Should Have Known Better
    Baby's In Black
    I've Just Seen A Face
    Wait
    For No One
    A Day In The Life
    While My Guitar Gently Weeps
    Savoy Truffle
    Hey Bulldog
    I Want You (She's So Heavy)
    I Me Mine

  • @manoanimateoficial2978
    @manoanimateoficial2978 2 місяці тому

    20:57 here, you would choose "Revolution 9" and "Wild Honey Pie"

  • @willstooksbury1477
    @willstooksbury1477 2 місяці тому

    I don’t want to spoil the party is a banger

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@willstooksbury1477 I I like it more now :)

  • @rdrrr
    @rdrrr 2 місяці тому

    My "best"; assuming I'm allowed a single LP, which means about 22 minutes per side:
    Side A:
    1 A Hard Day's Night
    2 Help!
    3 Day Tripper
    4 Norwegian Wood
    5 Love You To
    6 Lucy in the Sky
    7 For No One
    8 Tomorrow Never Knows
    Side B:
    1 Come Together
    2 While My Guitar Gently Weeps
    3 Helter Skelter
    4 Blackbird
    5 A Day in the Life
    The order isn't chronological, I'm trying to make a tracklist that "flows"; the beginning and end of each "side" is important.
    No matter what songs I pick, I'm leaving an awful lot out. You could tell me I'm allowed 2 CDs - that's about 148 minutes of audio - and I'd still have to leave a ton of wonderful songs out.

  • @asger7442
    @asger7442 2 місяці тому

    why would you pick 2 songs from the white album because it’s a double album and then pick two songs from the same disc

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@asger7442 my mistake sorry, I’ve fixed it on my recent video :)

  • @abbarules
    @abbarules 2 місяці тому

    Beatles For Sale is not a weak album. It may be the weakest in their catalogue, but their weakest album is any other band's classic.

  • @braudabo
    @braudabo 2 місяці тому

    Quite far from my personal list, as I'm a huge fan of the Beatles' hard rocking, psychedelic, Sitar and experimental tracks. Tracks like You can't do that, The Word, Good Morning good Morning, Why don't we do it on the road, Revolution 9, Only a Northern song, For you blue would never appear in my Beatles negative list.
    My personal negativ list includes: Hold me tight, Tell me why (just because of the falsetto part, that squeaks like a fork on a plate), I need you (terrible arrangement and lame), You know me too much, The long and winding road (pretty boring and "schnulzig"), All together now. Out of competition the short tracks: Maggie Mae, Dig it, Her Majesty.

  • @TheAnalogMediaArchive
    @TheAnalogMediaArchive 2 місяці тому +1

    Your worst songs on Hard Day’s Night and Beatles for Sale would have been on my best album. Interesting how many different opinions there are on The Beatles.

  • @awesomeplungers2693
    @awesomeplungers2693 2 місяці тому +1

    You guys are all fools... This is easily the best list:
    1. Do You Want To Know A Secret
    2. Hold me Tight
    3. I'll Cry Instead
    4. What You're Doing
    5. I Need You
    6. Think For Yourself
    7. And Your Bird Can Sing
    8. Lovely Rita
    9. Baby You're A Rich Man
    10. Martha My Dear
    11. Savoy Truffle
    12. It's All Too Much
    13. For You Blue
    14. She Came In Through The Bathroom Window (Anthology 3 version)

  • @La_domniz
    @La_domniz 2 місяці тому

    you chose wrong on the white album, the songs you picked were from the same disc

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@La_domniz have done an updated 2024 version where I fix that mistake

  • @unstoppablebear6384
    @unstoppablebear6384 2 місяці тому

    honestly i'd say yer blues is one of the best song from white album (mostly bc of that AMAZING live version with eric clapton and keith richards). i donno why u dont like it that much(

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@unstoppablebear6384 don’t mind the song, this video is last years version, I like it more now

    • @unstoppablebear6384
      @unstoppablebear6384 2 місяці тому

      @@ClockworkMusics cool then!

  • @TomsRetroGames
    @TomsRetroGames 2 місяці тому

    I'll Be Back is so underated id put it at 2 or 3 best track on the album and so is i dont want to spoil the party

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@TomsRetroGames rn I love both songs, they’re on my new video which I uploaded this is my 2023 rankings

  • @STARR503
    @STARR503 2 місяці тому +1

    WE BRINGING THE DEAD BACK TO LIFE???

  • @heatherqualy9143
    @heatherqualy9143 2 місяці тому +1

    Wish you hadn’t included covers that they didn’t write. Then maybe All My Loving would have gotten its proper place. Our worsts have a lot of overlap, but you and I sure have a very different opinion of what their bests are!😕

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому +1

      @@heatherqualy9143 I have an updated video with my new thoughts, I’m not sure why I choose a cover lol. What are you fav songs

  • @KING7CANTONA
    @KING7CANTONA 2 місяці тому +1

    I always find it funny how lots of people love, 'here , there and everywhere', and long and winding road - genuinely two of my least favourites, next to Mr moonlight, I actually prefer revolution 9 😂 ,,, nah it's all a matter of personal taste , nice idea for a video 👍🏻😮

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@KING7CANTONA thanks I really appreciate that

    • @rdrrr
      @rdrrr 2 місяці тому

      I've heard some people call it "The Long and Whiny Paul" 😂
      _Ouch_ - but I kinda get it. It's Paul at his most indulgently sentimental. For some people it's just too much.

  • @medievalthebucket5248
    @medievalthebucket5248 2 місяці тому

    Why not wild honey pie instead of why dont we do it in the road (for worst)

  • @dkizxpt-su3ze
    @dkizxpt-su3ze 2 місяці тому

    The Beatles worst album is better than most bands greatest hits albums

  • @josephstone2112
    @josephstone2112 2 місяці тому

    My worst album choices:
    1. Chains
    2. Don't Bother Me
    3. When I Get Home
    4. I Don't Want to Spoil the Party
    5. Act Naturally
    6. What Goes On
    (I'm so sorry Ringo)
    7. Doctor Robert
    8. Good Morning Good Morning
    9. Flying
    10. Why Don't We Do It In the Road?
    11. Wild Honey Pie
    12. The Entire B-Side of Yellow Submarine, in a row
    13. The Medley, but all the songs are on shuffle (there are really no bad songs on Abbey Road, so this is a compromise)
    14. Maggie Mae
    DELUXE EDITION BONUS TRACKS
    15. Komm, Gib Mir Deine Hand
    16. Sie Liebt Dich
    17. You Know My Name (Look Up the Number)
    18. What's the New Mary Jane
    19. Revolution 9
    20. Yesterday, but it abruptly cuts to Dizzy Miss Lizzy halfway through.

  • @dorsetbear
    @dorsetbear 2 місяці тому

    Enjoyable video, even if I don't necessarily agree with all your picks. Just a wee word of advice though. You're overusing some words like "amazing" and "obviously", probably without even realising. Obviously every Beatles album is amazing, but you could possibly do with a thesaurus for some other synonyms.

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      @@dorsetbear thanks for the advice. :)

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  2 місяці тому

      if you wanna see my new version of this video then its out now, i have improved abit, as this was my first video :)

  • @Terry-o2j
    @Terry-o2j 2 місяці тому

    Tabasco Cat are a close 2nd to the Beatles

  • @captainpandaplayz4604
    @captainpandaplayz4604 2 місяці тому +1

    I would still enjoy the worst Beatles album

  • @gingerwoods616
    @gingerwoods616 3 місяці тому +1

    Didn't you do the same on a video a few weeks ago?

    • @ClockworkMusics
      @ClockworkMusics  3 місяці тому +1

      Yes I am re uploading some videos, the last one was singles, worst and best, but I am working on a huge video so I need to re upload. :)

  • @paul-herveriche3505
    @paul-herveriche3505 15 днів тому

    Razoir
    Merci

  • @SpaceCattttt
    @SpaceCattttt 2 місяці тому

    I wouldn't choose any of these for either list. Oh, and "You Like Me Too Much" is not on Yellow Submarine. It's on Help!

  • @gary6514
    @gary6514 2 місяці тому

    1. I saw her standing there. 2. All my loving. 3. If I fell. 4. Eight Days A Week. 5. You've Got to Hide Your Love Away. 6. In My Life. 7. Here There and Everywhere. 8. A Day In A Life. 9. Hello Goodbye 10. While My Guitar Gently Weeps. 11. Blackbird. 12. Hey Bulldog. 13. Something. 14. Long And Winding Road.