What's wrong with the myth of progress? | Vandana Shiva

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
  • Vandana Shiva is a physicist and environmental activist.
    She talks about the shadow of technological and agricultural progress.
    You will find more information about Integral Economics on
    www.integral-economics.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 602

  • @JarrettBC
    @JarrettBC Рік тому +375

    ecocide. I want to share that word everywhere I can.

    • @ThekiBoran
      @ThekiBoran Рік тому

      Luciferian central bankers. Use that term.

    • @siobhanmulvey
      @siobhanmulvey Рік тому +12

      I agree - it captures the intensity w simplicity

    • @Vijay_16
      @Vijay_16 Рік тому +3

      Simple and powerful

    • @gopaulangappan8407
      @gopaulangappan8407 Рік тому

      Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful and innocent civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims on Allah's instructionsGreat ignorance
      Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Understand Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Deedat suffered a stroke of his tongue and suffered for many years for all the crocked arguments against Jesus
      Deedat does not mention the @joelsacks6760 read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      In Quran Allah explicitly and unambiguously authorized Muhammad and his Muslim followers to the war plunder and looting including 20% of captured women and children after wars
      Muhammad practiced slavery abductions human trafficking grooming of children and Allah authorised free sex to Muhammad and those who owned slaves
      It's all in Quran but as they are crimes committed against humanity by Muhammad and the Arabs Muslims
      Zakir Naik will not talk about the crimes of Muhammad
      Quran still advocates slavery abductions human trafficking slavery looting grooming of children and explicitly approved by Allah the God of Muhammad
      This behaviour is still evident of Muslims today in western democraciesRead The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Prophet Muhammad was authorized by Allah to recieve 20% of War looting and plunder which includes 20% of women and children captured after wars as slaves
      Allah also pronounced that Muhammad and his followers were entitled to free sex with slaves
      This is stated with no ambiguity in Quranabsolute and irrefutable proof that Muhammad is the AntiChrist and Islam is the Armageddon
      kindly view this video carefully and feel privileged to the sacredness of this knowledge ans share with your family and friendsRead The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Muhammad in Quran is authorized by Allah to 20%of all war looting and plunder after wars including 20%of all women and children captured after wars as slaves
      This is still endorsed and approved in Quran and is the Sunna for all times
      In essence the prophet Muhammad was a slave owner and practice of slaveryGreat ignorance
      Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Understand Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Deedat suffered a stroke of his tongue and suffered for many years for all the crocked arguments against Jesus
      Deedat does not mention the horrendous crimes committed by Muhammad
      Allah explicitly and unambiguously authorized Muhammad in Quran to 20% of all looting and plunder including 20%of women and children captured after wars were taken as slaves
      Muhammad in Quran practiced slavery human Trafficking abductions and trading of slaves
      Allah authorized the slave owners free sex with their slaves as an when they desired ie is rapeGreat ignorance
      Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Understand Read The History of Jihad from Muhammad to Isis by Robert Spencer reveals the eternal genocide of peaceful civilizations by Muhammad Quran Islam and Muslims
      Deedat suffered a stroke of his tongue and suffered for many years for all the crocked arguments against Jesus
      Deedat does not mention the horrendous crimes committed by Muhammad
      Allah explicitly and unambiguously authorized Muhammad in Quran to 20% of all looting and plunder including 20%of women and children captured after wars were taken as slaves
      Muhammad in Quran practiced slavery human Trafficking abductions and trading of slaves
      Allah authorized the slave owners free sex with their slaves as an when they desired ie is rape
      Muhammad always scheming for money and charity
      For a Muslim preaching mortality is the biggest hog wash
      First he must examine Quran
      ALLAH in Quran explicitly and unambiguously authorized Muhammad to recieve 20 %of all war looting and plundering including 20% of captured women and children as slaves
      Allah then tells Muhammad and Muslim slave owners to have free sex with slaves whenever they desired and could trade slaves ad property in the market place
      Effectively Muhammad in Quran is a slave owner slave raping human trafficking abductions and grooming young children for sex It's all in Quran
      How can Quran be from God
      Muslims use diverse methods to draw attention away from the horrendence crimes of Muhammad The fake messenger and gain credence for Islam

    • @4stim0
      @4stim0 Рік тому +2

      thought the same. Kinda gave me another form of awareness for the scale.

  • @Sahara-p9e
    @Sahara-p9e Рік тому +223

    A great warrior woman...A woman with true wisdom and knowledge

    • @romabatala
      @romabatala Рік тому

      Vocal warriors like J. Peterson and others; unfortunately we can not stop evil ones with the speeches

    • @krishnarao3768
      @krishnarao3768 Рік тому

      ​@@romabatalathat's also because people don't want to listen. People don't think for themselves, question policies, demand answers! We have become lazy observers.... Maybe not even observers. Because observation leads to some kind/level of thinking.

  • @marcosvialpando1391
    @marcosvialpando1391 Рік тому +190

    If only humanity made people like her our leaders, imagine the possibilities!

    • @sanjeevchauhan522
      @sanjeevchauhan522 Рік тому +8

      She is one of the reason of srilanks economic failure, suggestion to move to ecofarming caused food scarcity in srilanka.

    • @marcosvialpando1391
      @marcosvialpando1391 Рік тому +1

      @@sanjeevchauhan522 Interesting did not know that. What is your source on this info?

    • @pzan49
      @pzan49 Рік тому +25

      ​@@sanjeevchauhan522No, you are wrong.
      I'm from Sri Lanka. Farmers have been using organic and regenerative agricultural methods in Sri Lanka for thousands of years. Sri Lanka even exported surplus rice to neighbouring countries one thousand years ago. These methods create nutrition to the plant using a natural cycle that involves soil micro organisms and 78% of nitrogen available freely in the atmosphere.
      Continuous usage synthetic fertilisers, weedicides and pesticides made out of left over chemicals from oil, pharmaceutical and weapons industry has killed these natural organisms in the soil. Sri Lanka has been using chemicals for agriculture since 1960's. The soil in most farms is literally dead. Hence the transition from chemicals to organic cannot be made overnight. It must be done in several stages starting with reviving the soil first. But the easiest way to be organic is to use fresh unadulterated lands. Currently there are hundreds of such farms in Sri Lanka owned privately. However, as for most farms that have been using chemicals for over half a century, the story is different and it needs a systematic approach. This something even a 10 year kid would understand. But sadly the former president thought he can go full organic overnight and that ultimately led to his demise.
      So please don't spread misinformation.

    • @vendetta-groot0303
      @vendetta-groot0303 Рік тому +9

      Imagine if she become PM of India 🇮🇳 😳 ... she will work for betterment of humans and not religion or religious agenda ...

    • @rmrrao2675
      @rmrrao2675 Рік тому +6

      ​@@vendetta-groot0303India is doing great. Modern trains, stations, booming exports....
      Don't spread nonsense.

  • @netajiaich
    @netajiaich Рік тому +63

    She is talking about ecological economics which is a necessity now

  • @tomaskopolia1031
    @tomaskopolia1031 Рік тому +56

    You are the light in the dark, lady.
    Thank you.

  • @ameedave248
    @ameedave248 Рік тому +70

    What an intelligent lady

  • @PrincyPrincy-jh2fk
    @PrincyPrincy-jh2fk Рік тому +26

    Great analyzer and thinker...great Vandana ji! We need such dominant speakers to shake and make the system robust👏👏👏👏

  • @jonschaefer1463
    @jonschaefer1463 Рік тому +104

    True Wisdom. Thank you

    • @taazaspices7500
      @taazaspices7500 Рік тому

      When there was no development they call 3rd world.
      When developing they accuse of carbon emissions.
      When developed they complain of pollution & damage to the Nature.
      * How on earth western countries became developed without damaging the nature?
      * Why these questions are raised now when countries like India are progressing?
      * Why global warming advocates are silent on NATOs advancements ?

  • @Cali-ssippian
    @Cali-ssippian Рік тому +33

    I love it!! The ancestors are speaking through everyone! Y'all Betta listen to this woman.... It is beautiful...

  • @n9mone
    @n9mone Рік тому +7

    ❤❤❤ exactly I'm proud that I teach all my students this material

  • @theyogaangel964
    @theyogaangel964 Рік тому +23

    She only speaks Truth she has been given the knowledge❤

  • @gigidkar3200
    @gigidkar3200 Рік тому +53

    I respect this Lady

    • @rajthakkar7625
      @rajthakkar7625 Рік тому +6

      Me too....A rare woman who commands respect than a lot many who beg or plead for respect

  • @guruswamykarnam4411
    @guruswamykarnam4411 Рік тому +18

    The voice, clarity and crispy

  • @jimbogipson199
    @jimbogipson199 Рік тому +47

    You keep delivering your message soul that's a good message 🙏

  • @soumyapadmavathi7422
    @soumyapadmavathi7422 Рік тому +8

    Amazing lady. Need more leaders like her.

  • @jenniferloveless1169
    @jenniferloveless1169 Рік тому +154

    Can she become our next president, please?

    • @sanjayvaidya4925
      @sanjayvaidya4925 Рік тому

      Pl take her. Sri lanka wants to lynch her.

    • @pabs8
      @pabs8 Рік тому +15

      World Ambassador will be a better post. She cares about the whole planetas a living entity.

    • @manishmanish-wn3rd
      @manishmanish-wn3rd Рік тому

      ..she can't be president of any country bcoz people want gdp growth, jobs,export high, it's cycle which started 100 years ago till we get dangerous setback...people are not wise

    • @himanshukhinchi
      @himanshukhinchi Рік тому +8

      We do require such visionary leaders who take our country in the right direction rather than a popular direction.

    • @kabarque
      @kabarque Рік тому +3

      She would have been assasinated

  • @cheetahvolcano
    @cheetahvolcano Рік тому +75

    Vandana Shiva 🔥🔥🔥

  • @amunetbahiti9084
    @amunetbahiti9084 Рік тому +1

    Such a fearless warrior of a woman. Thank you for breaking things down for us all to understand ma'am. You are #celebrated #vandanashiva

  • @alfredxavier6785
    @alfredxavier6785 Рік тому +1

    👍👍👍.
    Such statements should reverberate across the globe to create awareness.

  • @sambahrain03
    @sambahrain03 Рік тому +18

    Very true people are overlooking devastative effects of technology,u have explained in detail,thank u vandana mam for such knowledge

  • @lalithathiru3171
    @lalithathiru3171 Рік тому +6

    Thank you for your soulful services

  • @sherylbolton5391
    @sherylbolton5391 Рік тому +1

    You are so right, may Yahweh expand your message to a very large audience amongst the younger generation. You speak pure wisdom

  • @shreeharikulkarni5614
    @shreeharikulkarni5614 Рік тому +15

    huge respect 🙏🏻👏👏

  • @aneesaosman3459
    @aneesaosman3459 Рік тому +16

    I love this lady

  • @crystalhealing847
    @crystalhealing847 Рік тому +3

    You are an integral human being and a fighter for our eco system ....the World loves you 🙏💖

  • @vaa7514
    @vaa7514 Рік тому +8

    Dominant narrative is very powerful and persuasive. She is absolutely correct.

  • @cobra4640
    @cobra4640 Рік тому

    Thank you for sharing and bring us more conscious to this problem. It seems like everything that is being mass produced is unhealthy, stripped of nutrients, chemicals enriched. The only solution is to grow our own food.

  • @ellamae6360
    @ellamae6360 Рік тому

    That’s why for me farmers should be supported financially and given many benefits. Those hands are gold.

  • @Honestandtruth007
    @Honestandtruth007 Рік тому +1

    So Right on Point Dr Shiva...👍👍🙌🙌. I don't have the Same education as you do but I can understand totally

  • @vanengelen31
    @vanengelen31 Рік тому

    We call that evil. Selfish humans who only care about money and are not one with nature. Me myself and I . Glad you're opening many people's eyes. Heal the world let's make it a better place ❤️💪🌍🌎🌏🌞

  • @intensepassion3382
    @intensepassion3382 Рік тому +1

    such an important message and it needs to spread worldwide.

  • @Vishal_437
    @Vishal_437 Рік тому +3

    Ecocide ... wow.. She is a warrior ❤

  • @anapantelic517
    @anapantelic517 Рік тому

    I hope your wisdom will prevail, so that sanity will rule on this tortured earth. We need you.

  • @suremaxtwo
    @suremaxtwo Рік тому

    This woman is so intelligent. I love her!

  • @MrPraveensagar
    @MrPraveensagar Рік тому

    Wow..what a mind-blowing perspective. What she says is right. When there is dominant narrative, look for shadows. This is secrets behind deception & dominant narrative ❤

  • @traceybaytops8681
    @traceybaytops8681 Рік тому

    I love this lady!! Powerful

  • @satindersinghgrewal3423
    @satindersinghgrewal3423 Рік тому

    Salute to you Madam,razor sharp Intellect and caring

  • @donfisher8035
    @donfisher8035 Рік тому +8

    Dang. 😢😢😢 Something has to change.

  • @VatemosiBasaga-rt5lo
    @VatemosiBasaga-rt5lo Рік тому

    Wonderful knowledge from a wonderful woman

  • @blastergoon4185
    @blastergoon4185 Рік тому

    She is a truly awakened woman

  • @zaravandy797
    @zaravandy797 Рік тому

    You are the best of the best .

  • @foundationbiologyclasses959
    @foundationbiologyclasses959 Рік тому +4

    She is from India and study biology and physics and whole life dedicated to prevent agriculture from chemical toxicology

    • @andrewooi82
      @andrewooi82 Рік тому

      Won't fix global hunger with that shit even though she complains about others trying to.

  • @SiriA535
    @SiriA535 Рік тому +12

    Well spoken 👏

  • @petrapepy1
    @petrapepy1 Рік тому

    I wish this woman would lead us all and clean up the mess we created

  • @LuisFarinhaFerreira
    @LuisFarinhaFerreira Рік тому

    This Lady is spectacular ❤

  • @MrDavfit
    @MrDavfit Рік тому +12

    truth in every word

  • @prishlavrghs
    @prishlavrghs Рік тому +4

    Ma'am I can listen to you all day. Every word is so correct.

  • @khazikhadir1939
    @khazikhadir1939 Рік тому

    As botanist I am mesmerized by her view's

  • @raggedflaggon9566
    @raggedflaggon9566 Рік тому +3

    Regenerative agriculture all the way. Just isn't as profitable to big business.

  • @theyogaangel964
    @theyogaangel964 Рік тому +9

    Exactly 🙏

  • @ananthmysore440
    @ananthmysore440 Рік тому +2

    True, the resultant effect is this

  • @tiacbendi-wc1lf
    @tiacbendi-wc1lf Рік тому

    The truth will set us free

  • @masalachai2423
    @masalachai2423 Рік тому

    I love You Vandana!

  • @mariemotivation1182
    @mariemotivation1182 Рік тому +9

    Thank you

  • @solveiglarsen33
    @solveiglarsen33 Рік тому +6

    Truth 🙏🌹

  • @geribaze382
    @geribaze382 10 місяців тому

    I just like this woman, and what she has to say.

  • @powerteja2332
    @powerteja2332 Рік тому +4

    Madam, you always tell the truth like hitting the nail on forehead.

  • @sherylvalentiner6115
    @sherylvalentiner6115 Рік тому

    Thank you Vendana Shiva!!!

  • @catchnrelease22
    @catchnrelease22 Рік тому +1

    Yo she be droppin' science and unspoken facts. Dis chick is very interesting.
    THIS OPINION.

  • @anjou6497
    @anjou6497 Рік тому +4

    I could listen to this lady all day. 🧡🌱

  • @vijaypawar3173
    @vijaypawar3173 Рік тому

    She has utterec a bitter Truth...!!

  • @DD-nf1yl
    @DD-nf1yl Рік тому +2

    People like these should be given the opportunity to join the government and make decisions based on their wisdom without playing vote bank politics. Respect 🙏🙏

  • @latashaspivey1152
    @latashaspivey1152 10 місяців тому +2

    I was just meditating on that the other day while walking home from work the other day. I literally took a picture of my self in the dark "My shadow image"! What I was thinking about before I took the picture is how we are ruining the planet not building upon it and checking in on my mental health. Things I need to hold on to and things to let go. Promised myself I will be a help not a hurt to the Earth and myself through this journey of life.

  • @dianederita2758
    @dianederita2758 Рік тому +3

    May your voice echo in every ear, in every mind land and in every man’s heart.

  • @motive8tion
    @motive8tion Рік тому

    Every time I see her speak I instantly stop and listen. This is an amazing woman.

  • @Sona-n5v
    @Sona-n5v Рік тому

    Good Morning !!! THEY WILL COME TO KNOW !!!

  • @debrajarnagin7101
    @debrajarnagin7101 Рік тому

    This woman is someone to listen too

  • @sagemurillo870
    @sagemurillo870 Рік тому +5

    Thanks for sharing Vandana Shiva...

  • @kathyheavner3585
    @kathyheavner3585 Рік тому

    She's absolutely 💯 correct

  • @YuriBaja
    @YuriBaja Рік тому +2

    God bless you. May all people hear your message and shake everyone to see the truth and be a force of positive change.

  • @Toniwatwin
    @Toniwatwin Рік тому +1

    Speak great mother speak 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🌾🌻🌾🌻💞

  • @yedukondaluupputella9270
    @yedukondaluupputella9270 Рік тому +2

    Ys ur100% correct

  • @emian722
    @emian722 Рік тому

    Yes, I don't understand why we have more technology and live is more difficult. We must have every a lot and easy life

  • @palomap.7740
    @palomap.7740 Рік тому

    best video I watched

  • @sal2ahmed
    @sal2ahmed Рік тому +4

    My fave lady.

  • @peacockLife
    @peacockLife Рік тому

    i agree, a very important discussion in today's world

  • @narender7106
    @narender7106 Рік тому

    This is fundamental to Dharma

  • @davidthompson8308
    @davidthompson8308 Рік тому +6

    Glad your on youtube

  • @annehenry861
    @annehenry861 Рік тому

    So very true.

  • @אסתראלקלס-ג4ו
    @אסתראלקלס-ג4ו Рік тому +1

    Smart woman ❤

  • @anitag3306
    @anitag3306 Рік тому +1

    Brilliant

  • @kabarque
    @kabarque Рік тому +10

    I am glad there are still people around like this lady.

  • @krishnarao3768
    @krishnarao3768 Рік тому +1

    Ma'am you are a great inspiration! You have my highest respect for what you do, the questions you ask, the logic you share in simple language! If only more people will question what's happening.... at least to themselves first! Sadly humanity has been robotised by so called technological advancement!

  • @CERPCERP
    @CERPCERP Рік тому

    This woman has envy for the innovators and inventors!!

  • @minervagonzales3787
    @minervagonzales3787 Рік тому +2

    So TRUE . WELL SAID & I second that.

  • @shodapad07
    @shodapad07 Рік тому

    Interesting. Learnt new word - Ecocide.

  • @jaggg.3821
    @jaggg.3821 Рік тому +1

    Because industrialized farming throws crops out when they produce too much; of any Farmed product!

  • @otienoagiro
    @otienoagiro Рік тому +4

    I laaav this!! Can I share this on my tiktok?

  • @NarenHYD
    @NarenHYD Рік тому +2

    This old lady should know one thing “Action speaks more than words”.

  • @agneskaszner8535
    @agneskaszner8535 Рік тому +1

    Always buy local and organic. Disease is more expensive ...

  • @zackcarl7861
    @zackcarl7861 Рік тому +1

    Roamanis get your own godda* country, and protect yourself, you can't keep roming around and stay together

  • @tien7742
    @tien7742 Рік тому +1

    May I add spermicide killed sperms==the ends of any species😂👍😅..

  • @davidfernandez8963
    @davidfernandez8963 Рік тому +1

    She has no idea what she talking about. Humanity is experiencing the best time in its existence. World poverty is lower than it's ever been. This is not to say there is no more room for improvement, but we certainly are far better than ever before.

  • @marieeanes6712
    @marieeanes6712 Рік тому +2

    ❤ Absolutely True

  • @pzan49
    @pzan49 Рік тому

    Indians need to bring Vrikshayurveda practices back to life. This is gonna change modern agriculture as we know it. Use of ai and these time tested methods in combination will help secure sustainable food production for the whole world.

    • @omnamahshivayaitaly8429
      @omnamahshivayaitaly8429 Рік тому

      I agree I studied Ayurveda massages, they are fantastic, you have a 5000 year knowledge to cultivate and spread into the World

  • @rahuls7039
    @rahuls7039 Рік тому

    The lady's name is *Vandana Shiva* ...
    You can search for her on the Internet.

  • @genevieveobote5371
    @genevieveobote5371 Рік тому

    So true

  • @Pch070
    @Pch070 Рік тому

    These are her words for India. There's no need to get offended if you're not from India.
    Yes, she said it right. There's too much destruction these days in the name of development. Wake Up India.

  • @googlrc
    @googlrc Рік тому

    Food production and food availability are different shiva, transportation of perishable food is also a factor

  • @janapeony8561
    @janapeony8561 Рік тому +1

    Vandana is one of the great leading women I love to listen and we need.Thank you Vandana for all you do for us.