She brought the key down because the original is too high for her to sing but now this is too low for her and her voice becomes shaky on the low notes and there isn't enough control over them
@@iliyanamarei wow you're really smart no one knew that thanks for telling it kid💛but try to think maybe she just wanted to give a perfect performance.
i feel like madison should start bringing an honest friend or 2 to rehearsal with her because u know she sang just like this at rehearsal and everyone was like "OmG THaT wAs SO goOd". what she needs is someone to tell her when it isn't good. i feel like everyone around her sucks up to her and tells her shit is good when it's not for clout smh
I definitely prefer her studio version songs.. but I’ve seen the covers she’s posted on Instagram and they’re amazing. So I know she has the talent. I honestly think this song might just be a little harder to perform acoustically than they attended. Still love her though. Many artists sound bad live so 😂 although she doesn’t sound terrible, she could still use some work.
Summer Wright Actually many artists sound really good live, sometimes even better. They practice beforehand to make it sound good so they don't embarrass themselves but i guess this song might be a little hard for her cuz she has a naturally raspy voice and this song is super low pitch
Honestly, it really wasn't bad at all. This song is really hard to perform and she did great. Sure, the deep notes are not perfect. But it gives the song a little touch. Maybe upload a video of you singing and show us how to do it better. :)
She has a beautiful voice don't know why everyone hates on her... And many singers change some tunes in live versions it doesn't have to be identical to the studio version.
people are super pretentious about certain people's singing. you won't see anyone saying this on a yungblud song. It's a stupid double standard, Madison Beer is a really good singer
It’s so different from the spotify version I listened to. You can re-do and edit a studio version (you can also re-do insta covers) but she can’t do that here.
She sounds good and she can sing ! Some artists change the song style when they’re singing the song live just to have fun and experiment ! It’s her song & she should have the right to perform it the way she wants to
This is a hard song to sing but she should of practice her notes cause I believe she could do this flawless if she really tried but this is only 1 performance
This song isn't that hard to sing. There are a few short high notes. A few runs. It's a basic song. And it's HER song so she should be able to sing it GOOD
i love madison with all of my heart, and i gotta admit she was struggling singing ‘say it to my face’ at TRL and she definitely got better. the beginning was amazing, she ended it amazing too. so proud❤️❤️❤️
i was enjoying this video and when i saw this comments i was so surprised cause this for me is AMAZING she has unique vocals and here everybody is saying is bad when is not... but ok she killed that anyways this is her best song
i gotta vent yeah her notes might not have been perfect but that's only ONE performance and she's still starting for real this time, go watch her singing live dead or covers and she's honestly so underrated but y'all ALWAYS search for the worst things about her. also this is such a hard song to sing live and she's gonna figure it out
Honestly been saying that same thing about it being hard to perform. And the song is literally so new she still needs to find the best ways to perform it. Love love love Madison though 😍
Maor Nadav she's been doing this for 5 years and no progress... lmao she's not that great as a singer and not a very good person for that matter either
She’s not underrated? She can’t keep up with her own vocals in her songs because they’re enhanced/corrected. She’s perfectly fine where’s she’s at until she improves live.
Idk what y'all talking about. She had a couple rough spots but the rest was amazing. You can barely even notice the parts she forced a bit either. Haters gonna hate
I think people are over exaggerating when they say this whole thing is terrible. The first half was a little off but the second half I guess she started feeling it so it came natural. And plus, this songs melody goes kinda fast so singing it live is gonna make it sound a little forced anyway because you have to annunciate properly. In a studio version, the mixing of vocals helps the words that are sung kinda string together. This was not god awful bad. And she is not talentless.
If you present your song a certain way (The recorded version) you are expected to do just as good, if not better during a live performance, don't make a pathetic excuse for her.
Alexis Texas I call bullshit. When you're in a studio it's gonna sound different then it does live. hhaaaaha. If you don't like it don't listen.. but don't come at me just because I support her? She has a good voice period. Doesn't mean she has to prove it to strangers online. if u kno then you know.
Ellie Burgos hell ya she's beautiful but if u really think she sounds bad why are you even on UA-cam listening to her sing go listen to someone u like.. u don't have to reply to my comment saying rude shit. Go read a book
Lol, you are funny. I said you are EXPECTED to sound just as good if not better when you perform it live. This is very underwhelming and seems like she is forcing notes she can't sing out of her mouth. Yes she can sing but she obviously needs to rehearse more. And I didn't come for you but since you are a hardcore fan you seem to make her seem like she is at her best when really she is not, and I actually do really love Dead and Say It To My Face that's why I came here in the first place. And no, if you wanna perform a song live you prove you live up to the standards you made or seem like you made in the studio, otherwise you're a phony.
Those notes were hard. I understand her, I just love the song. I don't think that was too bad. I love her songs, Auto tune helps to make it sounds good and it works.
I dont know why everyone hates her , if you do get the fuck out ? She sings very good i love this performance . Why? It is a hard song she did her own version of it, she have a uniquie voice and her high notes are just awesome. You always expect perfect humans, go listen to some bad performance of big stars (beyonce rihanna ) . She is 100% live and she did it great.
Reading all these comments really makes me wonder, if you were up there preforming a song you just put out to the world that you’re proud of and you see hella people telling you how horrible it is how would you feel...
+ZnaMissFlora your comment is totally irrelevant.. you are on a video and you are posting nothing about the one who is in the video but dumb things. Get a life. See what you like and comment on the videos you like.
everyone saying she sounds really bad in this video well go there sing yourself the same songs and then you will see the hate comments then maybe you might shut up.....the notes for this song are very difficult to achieve and acoustic isnt always the way its supposed to be so shut up!
Okay, it doesn't sound the best, but I think she did pretty good for the song. This song is a technically difficult song to perform live so it makes sense. Of course she's not going to sound the same.
I really liked this performance, I just think since it was one of her first times performing this song she was nervous and tried to hard to hit notes she needs practice with. I feel like the more she practices the song and notes she will definitely sound like a goddess singing this song.
you know that singing good isn’t just about screaming high notes right ? okay, she has problems with very low notes but she wasn’t that bad as you describe her. she sings with intensity and anger, like the song speaks. this performance actually wasn’t that bad. she’s not the best acoustic , that’s it.
OHMY GOD 1:07 the background singers nooooo. ): i like Madison’s voice, this is not bad by any means but she can do so much better. She will get better of course, but this is her first performance of this song, so you can expect her to be nervous. the background singers either sounded nervous or were just off.. hopefully it was just an ‘off’ day for everyone
It's funny cuz some people are so quick to judge her but yet my question is if you had to do what she had to do and were put in her shoes then it's like....like some people should stop saying to stick to being pretty bc she's a good singer and has a lot of potential,she was just singing the lower key version so I'm sure it was hard,it's not that big of a deal
i think... the problem is that she forces her voice to go way too low. i notice that every time people actually think she does good in a live performance is when she adds some high notes. she sounds really good when she sings higher.
She brought the key down because the original is too high for her to sing but now this is too low for her and her voice becomes shaky on the low notes and there isn't enough control over them
but it was really better than i expected
I'm the only one who likes the performance?.
Keep improving Maddie, fighting!.
She's singing in a lower key, that's why it sounds weird
Berenice 05 cause she can't hit the notes live in the original key
@@iliyanamarei wow you're really smart no one knew that thanks for telling it kid💛but try to think maybe she just wanted to give a perfect performance.
i feel like madison should start bringing an honest friend or 2 to rehearsal with her because u know she sang just like this at rehearsal and everyone was like "OmG THaT wAs SO goOd". what she needs is someone to tell her when it isn't good. i feel like everyone around her sucks up to her and tells her shit is good when it's not for clout smh
true
mia marie so she needs me
Y
True
😂😂😂
I'm feel so bad , I love her and I know that she is good , but this was so bad
Lula Shoo it rlly wasn’t.
I definitely prefer her studio version songs.. but I’ve seen the covers she’s posted on Instagram and they’re amazing. So I know she has the talent. I honestly think this song might just be a little harder to perform acoustically than they attended. Still love her though. Many artists sound bad live so 😂 although she doesn’t sound terrible, she could still use some work.
Summer Wright Actually many artists sound really good live, sometimes even better. They practice beforehand to make it sound good so they don't embarrass themselves but i guess this song might be a little hard for her cuz she has a naturally raspy voice and this song is super low pitch
Honestly, it really wasn't bad at all. This song is really hard to perform and she did great. Sure, the deep notes are not perfect. But it gives the song a little touch. Maybe upload a video of you singing and show us how to do it better. :)
She has a beautiful voice don't know why everyone hates on her... And many singers change some tunes in live versions it doesn't have to be identical to the studio version.
wow i love her but that was BAD, she was forcing it too much...
I honestly thought it was really good idk what everyones talking about lol
people are super pretentious about certain people's singing. you won't see anyone saying this on a yungblud song. It's a stupid double standard, Madison Beer is a really good singer
It’s so different from the spotify version I listened to. You can re-do and edit a studio version (you can also re-do insta covers) but she can’t do that here.
.......no
She sounds good and she can sing ! Some artists change the song style when they’re singing the song live just to have fun and experiment ! It’s her song & she should have the right to perform it the way she wants to
She has a lot of potential but she kind of sounds congested?
Jane, its because this song is not for her
Sparkle Stone 😂 her song not for her
Jane Villanueva I think it's just her voice
Eliza, not because its her song thats mean its for her, its not like she make it, know the difference honey
Sparkle Stone hold up, I'm not getting defensive, I was just laughing at the irony
This is a hard song to sing but she should of practice her notes cause I believe she could do this flawless if she really tried but this is only 1 performance
i agree!
i agree, but the funny thing is that this is her song so it should not be a hard song for her... I think she needs to train her voice
This song isn't that hard to sing. There are a few short high notes. A few runs. It's a basic song. And it's HER song so she should be able to sing it GOOD
This is not a hard song to sing
It is hard song, it sounds easy but it's not. And even if it's her song it doesn't mean it's easy one for her because it's her's.
Everybody’s like, “This is so bad” and I’m just like... well, she can sing better than me🤷♀️
She sounds so forced and has a lot of wrong notes. It’s just not good
Marie Gilber exactly... like it sounds like she's trying too hard to belt out the tune
It actually is rlly good if you get your head out of your ass and listen.
larrocx Tell me where was this performance „really good?“ lmao
everybodys a critic , this was really good
Basic Meme true
her singing is actually good idk why people are always so salty over her performances.
i love madison with all of my heart, and i gotta admit she was struggling singing ‘say it to my face’ at TRL and she definitely got better. the beginning was amazing, she ended it amazing too. so proud❤️❤️❤️
The range for this song just does not fit her voice. She is a good singer THOUGH
i was enjoying this video and when i saw this comments i was so surprised cause this for me is AMAZING she has unique vocals and here everybody is saying is bad when is not... but ok she killed that anyways this is her best song
same !!
THIS WAS ACTUALLY SO GOOD SHUT UP YALL JUST WANNA HATE ON ANYTHING
anyone notice the background girl stare her down at the end hahah
if you pause at 2:56 everyones reactions are hilarious haha
That's the way she sings ! She's not forcing anything , you guys try singing this song , it's really hard , if u say she's a bad singer
Noyonika Chakravarti upload a coverrr
Noyonika Chakravarti good luck then. I hope its good!!!
if it’s hard to sing, why even make a ‘hard’ song in the beginning?
maybe we wouldn't sing it better, but also we are not calling ourselves singers
Noyonika Chakravarti I wanna see a cover
i gotta vent yeah her notes might not have been perfect but that's only ONE performance and she's still starting for real this time, go watch her singing live dead or covers and she's honestly so underrated but y'all ALWAYS search for the worst things about her. also this is such a hard song to sing live and she's gonna figure it out
I honestly didn’t think this was bad. BUT PREACH
Honestly been saying that same thing about it being hard to perform. And the song is literally so new she still needs to find the best ways to perform it. Love love love Madison though 😍
Maor Nadav she's been doing this for 5 years and no progress... lmao she's not that great as a singer and not a very good person for that matter either
she didn't performed for 5 years......... she legit started performing when dead came out. singing on livestreams doesn't count as a performance
She’s not underrated? She can’t keep up with her own vocals in her songs because they’re enhanced/corrected. She’s perfectly fine where’s she’s at until she improves live.
WTF IS THIS
hahahhahah
@Aniya Burse no shit sherlock
So bad. Thank god for auto tune
jayceefam3 it’s acoustic dumbass
Basic Meme '2
XD M8 good joke kiddo ;)
BasicMeme We know that...She/he just said "Thank god that auto tune exists so we dont have to listen to something as bad as this"
this wasn't even bad. people just hate because its a trend to hate on her voice no matter what it sounds like.
“Tell me tell me”😢😢😭. Maddi i love u so much
i’m the only that like it?
i like it too
nope, i like it too!
and like 813 other ppl
Aniam Payne I loved it, idk what’s so bad
no, i do too!! I'm confused why ppl don't like it, considering the fact that I think this was her best performance of this song
In this she doesn’t sound good... I love her but this was a little bit terrible
i like this better than the original actually wow ok
Idk what y'all talking about. She had a couple rough spots but the rest was amazing. You can barely even notice the parts she forced a bit either. Haters gonna hate
I think people are over exaggerating when they say this whole thing is terrible. The first half was a little off but the second half I guess she started feeling it so it came natural. And plus, this songs melody goes kinda fast so singing it live is gonna make it sound a little forced anyway because you have to annunciate properly. In a studio version, the mixing of vocals helps the words that are sung kinda string together. This was not god awful bad. And she is not talentless.
It's literally HER song ha she can sing it how she wants and still be a goddess by the end of the day.
Destiny Leith she just proved that the only reason she gets clout is because of her face.
If you present your song a certain way (The recorded version) you are expected to do just as good, if not better during a live performance, don't make a pathetic excuse for her.
Alexis Texas I call bullshit. When you're in a studio it's gonna sound different then it does live. hhaaaaha. If you don't like it don't listen.. but don't come at me just because I support her? She has a good voice period. Doesn't mean she has to prove it to strangers online. if u kno then you know.
Ellie Burgos hell ya she's beautiful but if u really think she sounds bad why are you even on UA-cam listening to her sing go listen to someone u like.. u don't have to reply to my comment saying rude shit. Go read a book
Lol, you are funny. I said you are EXPECTED to sound just as good if not better when you perform it live. This is very underwhelming and seems like she is forcing notes she can't sing out of her mouth. Yes she can sing but she obviously needs to rehearse more. And I didn't come for you but since you are a hardcore fan you seem to make her seem like she is at her best when really she is not, and I actually do really love Dead and Say It To My Face that's why I came here in the first place. And no, if you wanna perform a song live you prove you live up to the standards you made or seem like you made in the studio, otherwise you're a phony.
Completely out of tune
what this is horrible
Those notes were hard. I understand her, I just love the song. I don't think that was too bad. I love her songs, Auto tune helps to make it sounds good and it works.
The background singer were better…
Her notes are all wrong :/
contemptress it’s her song she changed it up a bit. Lots of people do that and it still sounds greatt
I like the song but she is really out of tune in this, you have to accept that.
contemptress no no yeah I know this wasn’t that great I love her and all but yeah this wasss but at least tried you know I’d be scared to even do that
Cause she can’t hit high notes
How can one person be so beautiful ? Her and Cindy are just too pretty
Aren't they two people then
I dont know why everyone hates her , if you do get the fuck out ? She sings very good i love this performance . Why? It is a hard song she did her own version of it, she have a uniquie voice and her high notes are just awesome. You always expect perfect humans, go listen to some bad performance of big stars (beyonce rihanna ) . She is 100% live and she did it great.
I like it stop complaining
She looks so different from her instagram? Wtf
Reading all these comments really makes me wonder, if you were up there preforming a song you just put out to the world that you’re proud of and you see hella people telling you how horrible it is how would you feel...
what an improvement! she really evolved
this wasn’t even bad?!! like MATE I BET YOU CANT EVEN SING HELLO WITHOUT SOUNDING BAD
Where can i get the top tho?
this is awful
what’s up what with ya’ll its actually pretty good
Fantastic voice and great performer!
2:38 she should sing the whole song like this..this way she can get away with it like Selena Gomez and everyone will love her
Richa Sharma selena is better than this kid
+ZnaMissFlora then why are you here?
to see you guys that how can live without brain.
stop the fucking compare Selena or Ariana with this girl. She can't eat shit. #sorrynotsorry
+ZnaMissFlora your comment is totally irrelevant.. you are on a video and you are posting nothing about the one who is in the video but dumb things. Get a life. See what you like and comment on the videos you like.
I loved this, I can't understand what ppl is talking about.
It wasn't even that bad, i don't get why y'all hating so much
I still don’t understand why people follow her, really. She has an average singing voice
What's wrong if she has an average voice?
Seems like u sing better than her? Huh then make a song ,show the world?
Everyone is saying she sounded bad but not to me, to be honest. Its a hard song to sing and she did her best. Nobody can sing this song like she can.
that was amazing ❤️
stop acting like vocal coaches. she sounds good . she's singing in a lower key .
why so much hate? i think she sounds good
Cut her some slack , the guitar and her voice are not in the same scale which is why it's sounding so 'forced'. It happens sometimes. She's human.
I'm probably the only one but I loved it. She's gonna get better I thought this performance was good.
why is everyone hating . she sounds great
when ur background singers sing better than u and they’re just humming
Why does she try to sing so low?? The chorus is so beautiful because it sounds natural
mc Richardson this version is in a lower key than the studio one that's why she sounds so low
Can people stop hating I bet ppl who r hating r just worse than her so shut up madison I luv u ur amazing 😊❤️
I actually loved it ♡
It's not that bad I don't get the comments .. at least she sing live and have a good voice ;) no auto tune like others
It’s too looowwwwww
everyone saying she sounds really bad in this video well go there sing yourself the same songs and then you will see the hate comments then maybe you might shut up.....the notes for this song are very difficult to achieve and acoustic isnt always the way its supposed to be so shut up!
This is actually really good shutup
Her voice is amazing I don’t know why y’all mad
love this !!
lol, you can see the looks on the back up singer face when she sings. the shade lmao.
She's singing it way lower than the studio version cause she knows that she can't hit those notes live
the real one was too high for her, so she made it a little lower which make her voice crack
Okay, it doesn't sound the best, but I think she did pretty good for the song. This song is a technically difficult song to perform live so it makes sense. Of course she's not going to sound the same.
I really liked this performance, I just think since it was one of her first times performing this song she was nervous and tried to hard to hit notes she needs practice with. I feel like the more she practices the song and notes she will definitely sound like a goddess singing this song.
the belting is good
I love her way to sing
How is this horrible? It wasn't amazing but damn it wasn't bad
I LIKE IT
Lol it’s actually so good xx
you know that singing good isn’t just about screaming high notes right ? okay, she has problems with very low notes but she wasn’t that bad as you describe her. she sings with intensity and anger, like the song speaks. this performance actually wasn’t that bad. she’s not the best acoustic , that’s it.
i like this a lot
so proud of her
okay but damnnn.. the backup singers are so good, they literally stole this show.. pure talent
can she pronounce situation ???
how can she sing so well for dead but this honey WAS A NO
this was really disappointing:(
I love it tho why is everyone so mean?
Damn I liked it😂these comments are ruthless tho. Different strokes I guess 🤷🏿♀️
OHMY GOD 1:07 the background singers nooooo. ): i like Madison’s voice, this is not bad by any means but she can do so much better. She will get better of course, but this is her first performance of this song, so you can expect her to be nervous. the background singers either sounded nervous or were just off.. hopefully it was just an ‘off’ day for everyone
This is why she’s a B list celebrity lol
I really liked this performance
It's funny cuz some people are so quick to judge her but yet my question is if you had to do what she had to do and were put in her shoes then it's like....like some people should stop saying to stick to being pretty bc she's a good singer and has a lot of potential,she was just singing the lower key version so I'm sure it was hard,it's not that big of a deal
i love it!!!!!! wooow
sounds pretty good
If she was not beautiful she could NEVER be popular even a bit with singing like this. im not sorry.
i think... the problem is that she forces her voice to go way too low. i notice that every time people actually think she does good in a live performance is when she adds some high notes. she sounds really good when she sings higher.
She was good! Stop hating on her
i loved it
I love rewriting her songs 🙌