Saw Tim perform this at his last show in LA. He actually apologized for it, saying it was self-indulgent, that it was very personal about his relationship with music. The theatre was absolutely still throughout the sound, then erupted after letting the music fall silent. Tim was wiping tears from his face, as were most of us in the audience. I can never choose a favorite “Tim song”, they’re all so outstanding in different ways. But this ...
This song is so ironically beautiful and melancholy. It's probably my favourite. I feel like I'm looking into his...soul? ...or mind. Or heart. It makes me want to give him a hug ❤. More than happy to pay for Tim to bring beauty to the stage.
This finally made sense to me on the third listen. Minchin is pondering the question of whether he's purely a comedian; exploring why he doesn't do "serious music." He pokes fun at himself, suggesting it's sour grapes (the "could totally have her if I wanted" stuff)... but also accuses the audience of "paying to see satire and rage." This meta-song is his little rebellion against his own rebellious repertoire.
he doesn't see himself as a comedian, at least not in the first instance. He sees himself as a musician who sometimes does comedy. The comedy was more of a pathway into doing other things that he's interested in.
Me: I won't cry this time Also me: *cries eyes out* this song isn't even sad, it's just so relatable and true, it gives you a warm fuzy feeling inside, *continues to cry alone*
I would guess that many others, as I, came to this page to listen to "Come Home Cardinal Pell" after the news today. Interesting that he gave us an alternative song to listen to today. Minchin staying 10 steps ahead. Can't wait to see "Upright".
My very first thought on hearing the Pell news was of Tim Minchin. .. gutsy and sooooo appreciated ... thanks Tim Minchin ... and on we go .......... may we all display our courage skills and commitments to this world ..... best hopes and wishes to all affected by institutional and individual abuses 🐞
This was the first song of tims that I got to see him perform in person when he came to York on his most recent "unfunny" tour and it was a beautiful song for him to open with. Got to hear a lot of songs I've never heard before and a very different side of him compared to the comedic side I've watched countless times. It was a beautiful 2 hours in a small opera house with about no more than a couple of thousand people. He's so unbelievably talented
Oh, Tim - How do you not faint, overwhelmed, each time you realize that you are Tim Minchin, who has such talent and such power over all of us?? Do you pinch yourself, amazed that you are you? I would!! I can't imagine what it must be like to be you, with all of THIS within you! "Beauty" is one of the most haunting, melancholic, consuming pieces of music ever written!! Thank you!!
How in the sweet everlasting fuck did I get a compulsion to search for Tim only 8 minutes after a video was uploaded? God must be taking a break from cataracts
Hehe, I don't know if it's a lie, but it's a magnificent punchline for sure (contradicting the words previously sung and turning the irony into irony about irony or something)
Interesting to see this. I can't stand most non-metal music and I think it's because it feels insincere, dishonest, safe, and uninteresting. I like Tim's music though. Even though it's ironic, it's more truthful than most "sincere" love songs.
@@nashthrashington9749 Interesting, I didn't think about metal this way. I'm not a metal fan, though I like some songs. I think I'll keep that in mind next time I listen to one.
I don't know why they didn't have one or two of the string section join in for the second half of this song. Maybe they thought the song was already too beautiful?
Huh. I don't really know what to think about this, or how to feel. I'll probably have to listen to it / read the lyrics a few times before I even scratch the surface. Innuendo that feels out of place, but feels purposely so. Layers of metaphor and shifting intention. Emotional lyrics and delivery, though precisely which emotion is hard to pin down. It's rather profound, I think. I'm not sure yet.
Maybe she just got hacked by the computer kids who told you she's a fan cos they have a digital connection to her computer algorythms and she watches you sing songs from time to time on the You Tubes - plus her and her civil partner enjoyed your O2 Arena gig some years back. Kind regards from The Dark Side.
Beauty is a harlot She will dance with any bastard She's undiscerning in her choice of partners I could have her of course if I wish But I object to her promiscuousness Beauty just doesn't do it for me For beauty is a harlot An easy lay for lazy artists I won't be fooled by her vulgar charm It is the easiest trick in the book Music's the worm and beautys the hook And I know you would swallow her whole But Im not here to satisfy souls For beauty is a siren Trying to draw me from my chosen mission I won't be tempted by her seductive singing On principle I refuse to be party to her abuse It is not my job to squat in the gutter Sharing the teat with you beauty drunk suckers You paid to see satire and rage I swear I won't let beauty set foot on this stage For beauty is a siren A spotlight hungry superficial harlot She will toy with your defenceless heart and leave you Tear streaked when the lights come on You look around to find her gone And despite your sighs you've not a clue That as you fell from her she stole from you
If you're physically beautiful, life is different. If you accept - even thrive on, and perhaps rely on - the favours it grants you, you might have a less active mind, because innovation and imagination are borne from the need to make the most of what natural talents you have.
I didn't even consider this was about physical beauty. To me it's about his music. He even states his audience has come to see satire and rage. And it's an easy lay for lazy artists.
Beauty is a harlot She will dance with any bastard She's undiscerning in her choice of partners I could have her of course if I wish But I object to her promiscuousness Beauty just doesn't suit me For beauty is a harlot An easy lay for lazy artists I won't be fooled by her vulgar charm It is the easiest trick in the book Music's the worm and beautys the hook And I know you would swallow her whole But Im not here to pander to souls For beauty is a siren Trying to draw me from my chosen mission I won't be tempted by her seductive singing On principle I refuse to be party to her abuse It is not my job to squat in the gutter Sharing the teat with you beauty drunk suckers You paid to see satire and rage I swear I won't let beauty set foot on this stage For beauty is a siren A spotlight hungry superficial harlot She will toy with your defenceless heart and leave you Tear streaked when the lights come on You look around to find her gone And despite your sighs you've not a clue That as you fell for her, she stole from you For beauty is a harlot She will lie with any two bit artist And for all those other bastards She seems to come so easily But she comes too hard for me
@IHasNoLife Productions he is using the context of beauty being a lazy theme to follow in art, whilst simultaneously writing a song about beauty in a way that hits theme perfectly, but then he follows it up saying that it's difficult for him to personally convey beauty. I guess it's not laugh out loud funny, just clever.
Not sure this song is quite as deep as everyone seems to interpret. I think he's just trying to explain why he chooses to be intellectual and funny rather than try to be a rock star. 'Fame is beauty'.
But then, the last few lines. "For all those other lucky bastards..." Plus, if you know his history, he didn't start off trying to be a comedian. He was trying to be a rock musician and it never took off. Comedy is what makes his kind of irony palatable to the public, but it's not what he really wanted to do. I think he's being genuine here, but part of what he's expressing is sour grapes.
I think he's actually saying he's quite happy to deliver both beauty and satire (he is delivering one of the most beautiful songs here), though people pay him for satire and rage, and he gets labeled as a comedian. He doesn't want to be pigeonholed.
Its a rare talent to be able to sing "she comes so hard to me" and still sound deep
Because it's true in multiple levels, not just the comedic one.
It's a deep ass, bro.
I like how this song that makes fun of songs about beauty is one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever heard
I think that's the point.
Tim is probably the most talented dude i know who uses all of it ironically
woosh
Saw Tim perform this at his last show in LA. He actually apologized for it, saying it was self-indulgent, that it was very personal about his relationship with music. The theatre was absolutely still throughout the sound, then erupted after letting the music fall silent. Tim was wiping tears from his face, as were most of us in the audience. I can never choose a favorite “Tim song”, they’re all so outstanding in different ways. But this ...
BrynPoo KC I envy this story right here almost two fucking years later 😂😂
A song about rejecting beauty in art, that is excruciatingly beautiful.
There is something about Tim's voice that soothes you like a lullaby.
One of the best songs ever written.
The funniest part for me is that Tim is actually a really beautiful guy! Maybe he doesn't see it but I sure do 😊
Can't believe I'd never heard this one before. Brilliant song.
This song is so ironically beautiful and melancholy. It's probably my favourite. I feel like I'm looking into his...soul? ...or mind. Or heart. It makes me want to give him a hug ❤. More than happy to pay for Tim to bring beauty to the stage.
This finally made sense to me on the third listen. Minchin is pondering the question of whether he's purely a comedian; exploring why he doesn't do "serious music." He pokes fun at himself, suggesting it's sour grapes (the "could totally have her if I wanted" stuff)... but also accuses the audience of "paying to see satire and rage." This meta-song is his little rebellion against his own rebellious repertoire.
"This meta-song is his little rebellion against his own rebellious repertoire."
Yes!
Loved him in Season 6 of Californication! His dicotimous life is evident in full bloom in his role on the series.
he doesn't see himself as a comedian, at least not in the first instance. He sees himself as a musician who sometimes does comedy. The comedy was more of a pathway into doing other things that he's interested in.
Me: I won't cry this time
Also me: *cries eyes out* this song isn't even sad, it's just so relatable and true, it gives you a warm fuzy feeling inside, *continues to cry alone*
I would guess that many others, as I, came to this page to listen to "Come Home Cardinal Pell" after the news today. Interesting that he gave us an alternative song to listen to today. Minchin staying 10 steps ahead. Can't wait to see "Upright".
My very first thought on hearing the Pell news was of Tim Minchin. .. gutsy and sooooo appreciated ... thanks Tim Minchin ... and on we go .......... may we all display our courage skills and commitments to this world ..... best hopes and wishes to all affected by institutional and individual abuses 🐞
I get chills everytime I listen to this song. Tim, you're truly something special.
This was the first song of tims that I got to see him perform in person when he came to York on his most recent "unfunny" tour and it was a beautiful song for him to open with. Got to hear a lot of songs I've never heard before and a very different side of him compared to the comedic side I've watched countless times. It was a beautiful 2 hours in a small opera house with about no more than a couple of thousand people. He's so unbelievably talented
It's like my 100th time listening this but it still makes me emotional
Oh, Tim - How do you not faint, overwhelmed, each time you realize that you are Tim Minchin, who has such talent and such power over all of us?? Do you pinch yourself, amazed that you are you? I would!! I can't imagine what it must be like to be you, with all of THIS within you! "Beauty" is one of the most haunting, melancholic, consuming pieces of music ever written!! Thank you!!
How in the sweet everlasting fuck did I get a compulsion to search for Tim only 8 minutes after a video was uploaded? God must be taking a break from cataracts
Spot on humanist’s observations. Self-revelatory.
Beautifully raw.
You're beautiful. Thank you, Tim.
Can’t wait for all the apologies to Tim from the Pell supporters....
won't be happening, nothing will convince them their imaginary sky fairy reps are pure evil.
Don't hold your breath, that's for sure
Was there a recent development?
@@matthewrandell5055
Look up Pell conviction for sexual child abuse / rape.
6 years and hes appealing call that justice (sick fucker)
That last line is one of the most beautiful lies I’ve ever heard.
Hehe, I don't know if it's a lie, but it's a magnificent punchline for sure (contradicting the words previously sung and turning the irony into irony about irony or something)
Beautiful !!! :)
Amazing!
I've only heard this song a few times before, lovely to hear it again!
Breathtakingly gorgeous.
Just gorgeous 💔
Wow.. that song is so serious, but with the Tim's voice.. i bet i can listen to that forever.. thank you so much!!
So happy to hear your music again! I first heard one of your songs a few years ago and I always find myself rediscovering them and their beauty
This is so touching it makes my heart seize. *sigh*
Poignant and perfect. ❤
Wow! It is brilliant.
Thank you for releasing these on UA-cam - they're almost as delightful as they were in person. Can't wait to see you back in NY!
Best song ever
This song always brings me to tears! I love it so much!
Como sempre brabo!
What a song!!!!!!
Tim, will you ever give your German audience a chance to see you live on stage over here?
If so, Stuttgart would be a very nice place. ;-)
Stuttgart is a very nice place. I've performed there. I loved touring Germany.
This song kinda explains why I love a lot of metal music, it's intentionally ugly and difficult.
Ironically beautiful.
Interesting to see this. I can't stand most non-metal music and I think it's because it feels insincere, dishonest, safe, and uninteresting. I like Tim's music though. Even though it's ironic, it's more truthful than most "sincere" love songs.
@@nashthrashington9749 Interesting, I didn't think about metal this way. I'm not a metal fan, though I like some songs. I think I'll keep that in mind next time I listen to one.
Damn you, Tim, damn you !
I was suppose to see you in Adelaide for my 18th birthday absolutely devastated that I couldn't go
Hello Tim You are Totally Aesome.
I will get to see you one day.
He's a clever bugger....!
Deep deep deep♡♡♡♡♡
Dammit Tim! Ya couldn't end it without a double entendre! XD
I didn't expect the... beauty
Damn.
Love the irony of this song
Beauty is for lazy artists
I won't let beauty set foot upon this stage
Whilst singing one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard...
Tim Minchin, please don’t leave Tassie out of your tours!
I prefer this one where he pronounces beauty the British way, emphasising the T does something powerful to the song for me
Bless beauty....she's a beast....just another bog standard Manic Depressive
I don't know why they didn't have one or two of the string section join in for the second half of this song.
Maybe they thought the song was already too beautiful?
It’s possible. The violinist on the right at 3:12 is certainly being moved.
Please come to Toronto! Whoops! Good thing my Mother will not see this. I didn't ask you properly. Tim, will you please come to Toronto?
Huh. I don't really know what to think about this, or how to feel. I'll probably have to listen to it / read the lyrics a few times before I even scratch the surface. Innuendo that feels out of place, but feels purposely so. Layers of metaphor and shifting intention. Emotional lyrics and delivery, though precisely which emotion is hard to pin down. It's rather profound, I think. I'm not sure yet.
I think he'd like that
"Innuendo that feels out of place, but feels purposely so"
You nailed it.
Yeah he's pretty deep.
Deep as, bro.
@@hiitsme6214 Yeah I know this bit
Tim Minchin can you write a song about Pells private jail cell
That's an quite an old record and song.. We want new songs! :)
What's a "two bit artist"? One who writes four chord songs?
Don't two bits get three chords at max?
Maybe they use 3/4 tempo
@@isaacpianos5208 1 bit = two possible values (0 and 1), 2 bits = 4 possible values (00, 01, 10, 11)
Fuck.... 3:08💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
Maybe she just got hacked by the computer kids who told you she's a fan cos they have a digital connection to her computer algorythms and she watches you sing songs from time to time on the You Tubes - plus her and her civil partner enjoyed your O2 Arena gig some years back. Kind regards from The Dark Side.
She's Not There
Beauty is a harlot
She will dance with any bastard
She's undiscerning in her choice of partners
I could have her of course if I wish
But I object to her promiscuousness
Beauty just doesn't do it for me
For beauty is a harlot
An easy lay for lazy artists
I won't be fooled by her vulgar charm
It is the easiest trick in the book
Music's the worm and beautys the hook
And I know you would swallow her whole
But Im not here to satisfy souls
For beauty is a siren
Trying to draw me from my chosen mission
I won't be tempted by her seductive singing
On principle I refuse to be party to her abuse
It is not my job to squat in the gutter
Sharing the teat with you beauty drunk suckers
You paid to see satire and rage
I swear I won't let beauty set foot on this stage
For beauty is a siren
A spotlight hungry superficial harlot
She will toy with your defenceless heart and leave you
Tear streaked when the lights come on
You look around to find her gone
And despite your sighs you've not a clue
That as you fell from her she stole from you
bless you José
such a shame that the quality on this is not so great. Weird for his official channel...
If you're physically beautiful, life is different. If you accept - even thrive on, and perhaps rely on - the favours it grants you, you might have a less active mind, because innovation and imagination are borne from the need to make the most of what natural talents you have.
I didn't even consider this was about physical beauty. To me it's about his music. He even states his audience has come to see satire and rage. And it's an easy lay for lazy artists.
She🤔
lmao!!!
That's staggering. It.... hurts to listen to. I can't put it any other way.
If Beetlejuice & Lars Ulrich of Metallica mated...
WAT?!
Beauty is a harlot
She will dance with any bastard
She's undiscerning in her choice of partners
I could have her of course if I wish
But I object to her promiscuousness
Beauty just doesn't suit me
For beauty is a harlot
An easy lay for lazy artists
I won't be fooled by her vulgar charm
It is the easiest trick in the book
Music's the worm and beautys the hook
And I know you would swallow her whole
But Im not here to pander to souls
For beauty is a siren
Trying to draw me from my chosen mission
I won't be tempted by her seductive singing
On principle I refuse to be party to her abuse
It is not my job to squat in the gutter
Sharing the teat with you beauty drunk suckers
You paid to see satire and rage
I swear I won't let beauty set foot on this stage
For beauty is a siren
A spotlight hungry superficial harlot
She will toy with your defenceless heart and leave you
Tear streaked when the lights come on
You look around to find her gone
And despite your sighs you've not a clue
That as you fell for her, she stole from you
For beauty is a harlot
She will lie with any two bit artist
And for all those other bastards
She seems to come so easily
But she comes too hard for me
I see Tim is going through his Jim Carrey phase by uploading his serious songs. "I want people to leave thinking, 'wow, that guy is really deep.'"
Hard to focus now that I realized you look like Beatle Juice
Come on Tim, where's the big gag at the end? I kept waiting for the next line to be "oh wait, that's my wife, see ya!"
I mean he's comedic, but not a clown. not everything he does needs a "ba dum tss" at the end.
The whole song is a "gag." It's not about a woman.
(she cums so hard to me) hehe. its serious and funny. comedic genius
I guess the gag in this one was that he was singing from the heart, he tricked me too XD
@IHasNoLife Productions he is using the context of beauty being a lazy theme to follow in art, whilst simultaneously writing a song about beauty in a way that hits theme perfectly, but then he follows it up saying that it's difficult for him to personally convey beauty. I guess it's not laugh out loud funny, just clever.
Not sure this song is quite as deep as everyone seems to interpret. I think he's just trying to explain why he chooses to be intellectual and funny rather than try to be a rock star. 'Fame is beauty'.
But then, the last few lines. "For all those other lucky bastards..." Plus, if you know his history, he didn't start off trying to be a comedian. He was trying to be a rock musician and it never took off. Comedy is what makes his kind of irony palatable to the public, but it's not what he really wanted to do.
I think he's being genuine here, but part of what he's expressing is sour grapes.
I think he's actually saying he's quite happy to deliver both beauty and satire (he is delivering one of the most beautiful songs here), though people pay him for satire and rage, and he gets labeled as a comedian. He doesn't want to be pigeonholed.
T wat
Hey Tim, if you and your wife ever split up, I think the young girl in the orchestra behind you has fallen for you hard.