What I believe happens in these episodes is that Nicole just has everything planned out prior, but Josh just enters into the kitchen and whatever first idea comes into his mind he goes with it😂
Cream of tartar is an acid that crystalizes on the bottom of wine barrels. It's used when you want to add acid to something without changing the flavor. It's used here to help coagulate the protein in egg whites to make them whip faster.
And it's in baking powder to provide the acid required to neutralise the bicarbonate of(baking) soda to produce the CO2 bubbles. Baking soda is used if the recipe already has enough acid to neutralise it (lemon juice, brown sugar, etc.)
It was also the first molecule shown to be tetrahedral and led to the discovery that molecules are 3 dimensional, after Louis Pastuer discovered that the lab made Potassium Bitartrate he made to counter the high cost of wine-derived Cream of Tartar turned out to be slightly different in shape than it’s natural counterpart.
i feel like Josh could do the cursed foods from The Good Place way better than Babish did i also feel like the complex philosophical interrogations in The Good Place would make Josh melt away like a vampire pelted with holy water balloons
That's kinda what I was thinking. Nicole's looked like a normal food with a subtle reference to peeps. Meanwhile Josh looks like he fully understood the assignment and ran with it, despite the risks.
This episode was super entertaining and fun, but just a bit of constructive criticism, the cuts between Nicole and josh were a bit harsh a lot of the time, so I would recommend putting the person reacting in the corner, like you did at 10:34. The cut to the full shot of the other person works fine when they talk for a while, but it's a bit much for short comments in my opinion. I still loved the episode but it would have made it a little easier to watch :) sorry if any of this came off as aggressive or rude, this is all meant with love
Completely agree, it was actually starting to annoy me. Three four times is cool but a comment on every other sentence is distracting, I actually couldn't follow what they were doing in the kitchen
There are a lot of opinions on the cutaway bits, so here's mine: the frequency of them just felt like there was this idea that the other person needed to commentate on almost everything the one cooking said, even when there was really nothing to say. I never minded the "confession booth" gag in older videos, and I do like Josh and Nicole ribbing each other's recipes when competing, but this video would benefit from cutting a lot of them. Example: Josh talks about shot-put. Nicole: "Josh is talking about shot-put again." Didn't feel like that bit had to be there.
Yeah I think so. Both together should watch back and comment as they go. It's really disjointed with one person interjecting every two seconds. I don't know. Maybe just not my thing. Still fun tho. I like content
@@samwil212 yeah when they banter back and forth, it’s funny. When it’s just Nicole commenting alone it makes her sound judgmental and angry. I’m pretty sure that wasn’t their intent but that’s what it makes me feel. I think they used to do this style video more when they started this channel but I haven’t seen it in a while. I’m okay if it goes away again lol
@@hideyourloveaway128 i don’t think she means it seriously. it’s just banter between two friends. but the way this was edited by only showing her rude remarks on every little thing josh says makes it unenjoyable and really puts a damper on things
I do appreciate that they're trying stuff And I thought it would be good at the beginning of the video when they first started doing it But yeah no Fair idea, maybe wonky execution? Reactions are making a big comeback, but not like this.
Josh's pizza reminds me of the description of Todd's clown-dentist business: "a cotton candy nightmare of Freudian invention that shakes one to the core"
I absolutely love Nicole. She's incredible, I have a massive crush on her. But the cutting back and forth with witty quips every 1.7 seconds while Josh is cooking is really irritating.
You guys don’t have to like everything they do, so I say just pass on the series, let them experiment creatively like they want to, and everyone’s happy 😊
@@voyager1568 You do realize that they want to know when people don't like something, right? You think we should just let them keep making their videos worse and lose viewership? What is wrong with you?
Episodes with Josh and Nicole are always some of my favorites because I love the juxtaposition of their wildly different personalities, and it's fun to see just how differently they tackle challenges like this!
Nicole just got publicly shamed. OMG there was absolutely no way Josh should have won with that pizza, but he was totally right. Nicole you must fight your instinct and run towards, and not away from the food crime.
if she had followed the brief as it was a peeps pizza and I notice the last few times she not followed the brief and avoided using the crime ingredient - where Josh goes mad with it lol
The answer was in front of her the entire time. Make the peeps into a mascarpone cheese to add to her already cheesy dish. Also either larger chunks of glazed ham or the ham as presented and some pepperoni to evoke pizza more.
I wonder if it is possible to get MORE jump cuts? I feel like we're getting shorted a good dozen or so. More jump cuts, less fluidity! Yay, jump cuts! (Insert sound of '80s hair band guitar riff here...and a jump cut!)
I busted out laughing so hard when Josh said Nicole puts egg wash on her face and sits in the parking lot with tinfoil which is why her skin is so good.
Just adding my comment to the “commentary style doesn’t work” camp. The snarkiness feels really forced and uncomfortable, and I mourn for the supreme chaos we could have had if Josh and Nicole were collaborating on a peepza.
I disagree. I think the snarkiness is exactly correct, especially after all the hotdog is a sandwich podcasts I've listened to (which is every single one of them). This was much MUCH more organic than you give it credit. And I loved the style used here.
This format would work great as a "Josh goes to x" adventure or challenge. and probably far less cuts back and forth. I like the rippin' on josh feature though. classic banter.
Not sure if the Nicole narration is helpful in this episode…you guys should make a series in which Nicole and Josh watches old Mythical Kitchen videos and react to them. However, my smol brain can’t comprehend Josh cooking and somebody reacting at the same time.
I would prefer if she were either there in person or was in a picture in picture thing most the time because the cutting back and forth felt like too many cuts just to hear her commentary.
Love Nicole. Hate the interrupting style they tried here. Totally understand trying to find new ways to edit videos and keep people engaged, but this sucked.
Watching Josh cooking his blue monstrosity had me crying with laughter! There’s a reason you don’t see blue things on menus…. Nicole, excellent chef though she is, didn’t embrace the horror of peeps. She deserves ridicule, shaming and shunning for not submitting to their lurid charm. All in all I don’t care who won - one of the funniest cooking videos I’ve seen!
Every time they do an episode with all these cutaways a quarter of the comments are about people hating it but they apparently don't care because they keep doing it.
Nicole doesn't seem to follow the spirit of the challenge and hides the main ingredient behind tons of other ingredients, while josh puts the main ingredient in the foreground so you know what it is.
@@williamsmith00 i was able to get to 8 minutes this time! it really is upsetting though because i love this channel, especially josh and not being able to watch him talk and cook is sad. also, the way she’s belittling him constantly puts a damper on things
Thank God Josh made an innuendo out of “sharing the ham”. As soon as she said it my innuendo gland activated, and I knew Josh was experiencing the same sensation.
Absolutely agree. Love Nichole, but the constant cuts made this unwatchable for me. 3:59 was the point I stopped the video and decided to just skip this one.
I actually really love the commentary lol. I guess they could just use the overlay more to make it more like a reaction video instead of cutting between between the two and interrupting the flow.
"How are you in charge of me?" That's a question I ask about my own boss all the time. For context, this is the man who was whipping around on the forklift, pedal to the metal, talking on a cell phone, while carrying a 1,200 pound filtration unit on the forks. I have no idea why or how he's still alive. I have more stories.
I've been commenting for a year now about them opening up a restaurant. Where everything on the menu is something the guys tasted and liked it. And that's a lot of food. Good Mythical KITCHEN.
not Josh being right about baking power's makeup... I'm a pastry major in college right now, and I can confirm that baking powder can be made with cream of tartar as cream of tartar is an acid, which baking powder consists of baking soda mixed with an acid.
I was thinking they need even less of Nicole and more of Trevor. Nicole is boring and won't commit to the challenges. Her dish didn't even have peeps on it. she just melted the peeps into sugar and made a glaze.
The f they’re gonna jump in this much it needs to be an overlay or something like a face cam while lowering the main audio. The current set up is very aggravating.
155. There are 155 cuts to the other person in this 29 min video. Plus all the picture in picture comments that I didn't even count. What the hell. 81 cuts to Nicole while Josh is cooking. 56 cuts to Josh while Nicole is cooking. 18 cuts to Josh and Nicole while Mike is judging. These last cuts are a little more understandable.
These are amazing, I love everything about this. But yes Nicole you can’t hide from the challenges!! It’s gotta SCREAM whatever weird combo you doing! That’s why josh keeps winning
The only way peeps are edible are when roasted over a camp fire like a normal marshmallow. It crystallizes the sugar & makes a glassy crunchy casing. Yum
Why is nobody talking about the guy who 3D printed a gear cover for the stand mixer? Whoever you are, I love that it bothered you enough to go through all of that.
It's like with food fears, how Josh would lean into the flavour palate of a gross ingredient, making the final dish taste good without masking the original flavour... I feel like Josh takes a similar philosophy here and leans hard into the fundamental aspects of the food crime. While yes, it means he ends up making an unholy abomination of a food crime. It's at least a tastier food crime than the one they started with.
i appreciate that he switched the elements around. the peep-coloured meringue on top was savory and the sauce was peep. it's actually brilliant in its chaos.
I feel like that's the spirit of the show! Not to make something unrelated that tastes good, that's easy, the challenge is to turn the original gross thing into something good without making it unrecognizable
Nicole turned this into Josh's official comedy roast special, right out the gate 😂 "Trash raccoon... Oh my gosh, he likes it" "Actin' like he's at a wine tasting" "OoOhHh. _Suuper_ artisanal. Peeps and bacon jam..." "Josh is talking about shotput again. _love_ when that happens..." "He's disappointed in himself. YESS."
@@hideyourloveaway128 Tbh I usually feel that way about her prissiness (big Josh & Emily fan) But it was def played for laughs, calling her out for being cowardly with gross mashups (there's nothing appetizing about peeps on pizza)
The format really doesn't work. Have them be together and have that normal chaotic energy. The cutaways feel too scripted and don't honestly seem like something they might honestly say, especially Nicoles segments since she doesn't seem that needlessly negative normally, so either removing them or making them more natural and less frequent IMO seems the best way forward.
I honestly think the addition of the cutaways takes away from the unbridled chaos of the peepza, and it would be less time and budget to have them both in the kitchen, with one cooking an the other riffing on them, itd get a nice back and forth.
Josh really said “why stop at food crime when it could be a food felony “
We saw the same video. We know.
a food war crime
@@beebeecee669 that was unnecessary
A food life sentence
LMFAO
Nicole: "I can fix him!"
Josh: "I can make him worse."
What I believe happens in these episodes is that Nicole just has everything planned out prior, but Josh just enters into the kitchen and whatever first idea comes into his mind he goes with it😂
I wouldn't doubt it
It's how I cook, it serves well.
This is the reason why Josh is the better chef.
Lol she's got it all planned out then Josh comes in and blows all her plans out of the water to where she has to improvise.
But that is Josh. At least he doesn't have that Mustache any more.
There's something transcendent about Josh's tone when he says "we've got some lovely... greening on the crust..."
Cream of tartar is an acid that crystalizes on the bottom of wine barrels. It's used when you want to add acid to something without changing the flavor. It's used here to help coagulate the protein in egg whites to make them whip faster.
Good comment. I like facts
And it's in baking powder to provide the acid required to neutralise the bicarbonate of(baking) soda to produce the CO2 bubbles. Baking soda is used if the recipe already has enough acid to neutralise it (lemon juice, brown sugar, etc.)
@@Tarantulah nice, another fact. I like that
Thank you so much for this comment! So helpful!
It was also the first molecule shown to be tetrahedral and led to the discovery that molecules are 3 dimensional, after Louis Pastuer discovered that the lab made Potassium Bitartrate he made to counter the high cost of wine-derived Cream of Tartar turned out to be slightly different in shape than it’s natural counterpart.
That look on Nicole's face right as Mike says "but peeps" and she realizes she's gonna lose is PRICELESS!!!
Josh's pizza looks like something the lost boys would've had in hook.
Exactly my first thought was "BANGERRANG!"
Joshio! Joshio! Joshio!
YES YES YES!
You just have to believe it’s edible
@@dclarkmusic Exactly!!
This gives me such vibes of Chidi in the good place: "YOU PUT THE PEEPS IN THE CHILI POT AND MIX IT ALL AROUND"
YES!! I kept thinking that the entire video!
Have you Binging with Babish make it? It’s deeply disturbing, but also beautiful.
i feel like Josh could do the cursed foods from The Good Place way better than Babish did
i also feel like the complex philosophical interrogations in The Good Place would make Josh melt away like a vampire pelted with holy water balloons
@@TurbopropPuppy 😂😂
Only Josh could take a normal food crime and make it into a food organized crime.
Nothing about Josh is organized
Josh knows how to make abominable things taste good.
Nicole just knows how to cook generally.
That's the difference.
It's that and that Nicole tries to hide the food crime element while Josh just dives in head first
That's kinda what I was thinking. Nicole's looked like a normal food with a subtle reference to peeps. Meanwhile Josh looks like he fully understood the assignment and ran with it, despite the risks.
Nicole is a fantastic cook, but Josh is the madman pulling the strings behind discontinued food necromancy and the the "will it X????" monstrosities.
It’s because she went to culinary school, he didn’t
I want the Mythical Kitchen to do a full meal from the Robin Williams Hook movie.
Babish did that awhile ago, really fun video.
Push this comment to the TOP
Would make for a good April Fools video.
This episode was super entertaining and fun, but just a bit of constructive criticism, the cuts between Nicole and josh were a bit harsh a lot of the time, so I would recommend putting the person reacting in the corner, like you did at 10:34. The cut to the full shot of the other person works fine when they talk for a while, but it's a bit much for short comments in my opinion. I still loved the episode but it would have made it a little easier to watch :)
sorry if any of this came off as aggressive or rude, this is all meant with love
I agree
Completely agree, it was actually starting to annoy me. Three four times is cool but a comment on every other sentence is distracting, I actually couldn't follow what they were doing in the kitchen
Agreed. I really like both of them, but it was pretty jarring.
So true. I hope they see this
Fully agreed, so jarring and ruins the watchability. Would be great to have the "VH-1 Pop-Up Video" treatment, with the screen-in-screen
Josh: you know me
Nicole: yeah i do (happy tone, regretful look, awkward laugh)
Nicole: don’t eat my food.
Mike: don’t invite me to your wedding. I died 😂
He didn't even HESITATE 😂😂
Haha savage 😅😅
Jaw dropped. That was a burn 😂😂😂
Revenge is dish best served while judging the food of the one who wronged you.
Insert surprised Pikachu meme face 😂
There are a lot of opinions on the cutaway bits, so here's mine: the frequency of them just felt like there was this idea that the other person needed to commentate on almost everything the one cooking said, even when there was really nothing to say. I never minded the "confession booth" gag in older videos, and I do like Josh and Nicole ribbing each other's recipes when competing, but this video would benefit from cutting a lot of them. Example: Josh talks about shot-put. Nicole: "Josh is talking about shot-put again." Didn't feel like that bit had to be there.
He bloody loves talking about shot put though
I agree I’m an ass so I couldn’t even watch the episode with those cuts constantly, but hope others enjoy it.
This is like watching a low effort reaction video
So true
What a glorious win 😂 I am convinced that Josh is either magic or has the luck of the Irish.
I enjoy the food crimes ep but this would work better with the pair watching the vids back together so there is some back and forth.
Yeah I think so. Both together should watch back and comment as they go. It's really disjointed with one person interjecting every two seconds. I don't know. Maybe just not my thing. Still fun tho. I like content
@@samwil212 yeah when they banter back and forth, it’s funny. When it’s just Nicole commenting alone it makes her sound judgmental and angry. I’m pretty sure that wasn’t their intent but that’s what it makes me feel. I think they used to do this style video more when they started this channel but I haven’t seen it in a while. I’m okay if it goes away again lol
I think they should stick their heads in one of the corners so it’s less jarring what they say
Yeah I actually turned this one off because I found the cuts every couple seconds to be really annoying
@@saturnshort7210 yes, exactly. This episode was horrible because of these cuts.
"We're gonna gently fold"
~continues to vigorously stir~
God.
Damnit.
Josh.
This is just basically Nicole complaining about josh without him knowing
@@hideyourloveaway128 i don’t think she means it seriously. it’s just banter between two friends. but the way this was edited by only showing her rude remarks on every little thing josh says makes it unenjoyable and really puts a damper on things
It's more like roasting than complaining
"Your cart is empty, man." Is my new favorite Nicole quote.
Maybe having Nicole in the corner would work for the reactions, rather than cutting back and forth? It's just a lot of cuts
I did not enjoy it
I do appreciate that they're trying stuff
And I thought it would be good at the beginning of the video when they first started doing it
But yeah no
Fair idea, maybe wonky execution?
Reactions are making a big comeback, but not like this.
for a second i thought you meant put her in the corner of the room and have her heckle Josh
Yeah too disjointed.
@Rimone Media lol are you talking about link?
Josh's pizza reminds me of the description of Todd's clown-dentist business: "a cotton candy nightmare of Freudian invention that shakes one to the core"
__intense breathing__
Happy cotton candy day daddy
I absolutely love Nicole. She's incredible, I have a massive crush on her. But the cutting back and forth with witty quips every 1.7 seconds while Josh is cooking is really irritating.
I couldnt even finish the video. It was too annoying.
Yes my god I can’t do this video
ya it ruined it man
You guys don’t have to like everything they do, so I say just pass on the series, let them experiment creatively like they want to, and everyone’s happy 😊
@@voyager1568 You do realize that they want to know when people don't like something, right? You think we should just let them keep making their videos worse and lose viewership? What is wrong with you?
Episodes with Josh and Nicole are always some of my favorites because I love the juxtaposition of their wildly different personalities, and it's fun to see just how differently they tackle challenges like this!
Nicole just got publicly shamed. OMG there was absolutely no way Josh should have won with that pizza, but he was totally right. Nicole you must fight your instinct and run towards, and not away from the food crime.
if she had followed the brief as it was a peeps pizza and I notice the last few times she not followed the brief and avoided using the crime ingredient - where Josh goes mad with it lol
The answer was in front of her the entire time. Make the peeps into a mascarpone cheese to add to her already cheesy dish. Also either larger chunks of glazed ham or the ham as presented and some pepperoni to evoke pizza more.
@@rdp16rulez Exactly she didn't commit to the challenge
Josh definitely needs to write a cookbook called "50 Shades of Brown".
I wonder if it is possible to get MORE jump cuts? I feel like we're getting shorted a good dozen or so. More jump cuts, less fluidity! Yay, jump cuts! (Insert sound of '80s hair band guitar riff here...and a jump cut!)
Anymore jump cuts and they would've had to put an epilepsy warning lol
i love that they both know each other well enough to call exactly what they're gonna do
"I'm down to play slap the jug", careful Nicole.
I busted out laughing so hard when Josh said Nicole puts egg wash on her face and sits in the parking lot with tinfoil which is why her skin is so good.
Just adding my comment to the “commentary style doesn’t work” camp. The snarkiness feels really forced and uncomfortable, and I mourn for the supreme chaos we could have had if Josh and Nicole were collaborating on a peepza.
Yes, I just want to focus on the cooking, not some boring comments no one asked for
I appreciate the attempt at commentary but you're right. They should at least have the other person in the kitchen with them. But just watching on...
I disagree. I think the snarkiness is exactly correct, especially after all the hotdog is a sandwich podcasts I've listened to (which is every single one of them). This was much MUCH more organic than you give it credit. And I loved the style used here.
Agree 💯
Mike needs to be incorporated waaaaay more often, I dig his vibe.
This format would work great as a "Josh goes to x" adventure or challenge. and probably far less cuts back and forth. I like the rippin' on josh feature though. classic banter.
Banter would suggest there's some interaction between the two. This is just scripted responses....
@@MarMar828 it's not scripted, they watch each other's video and responds to it. Basically a reaction video.
Actually correction: it's a mix of both
Felt like a worse style of reaction video, live banter would have been a much nicer watch
@@demitriussmith741 they're writers made most of the lines you can tell
Not sure if the Nicole narration is helpful in this episode…you guys should make a series in which Nicole and Josh watches old Mythical Kitchen videos and react to them. However, my smol brain can’t comprehend Josh cooking and somebody reacting at the same time.
Yea I dont get it.. why isnt she just there and mess with him in person?
I would prefer if she were either there in person or was in a picture in picture thing most the time because the cutting back and forth felt like too many cuts just to hear her commentary.
Love Nicole. Hate the interrupting style they tried here. Totally understand trying to find new ways to edit videos and keep people engaged, but this sucked.
Is it just me or did some of the comments feel borderline rude at some points too?
Yeah.. I really dislike this editing style. Super disjointed
Josh: *throws piece of tomato on peepza*
Nicole: “why did he do that?!”
Me thinking: “cuz that peepza is trash”
Nicole: don’t eat my food.
Mike: don’t invite me to your wedding.
*Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaammmmmmmmnnnn
Jeeeeez this episode is very cut-to-nicole-banter-heavy 😅 the sarcasm vibes are STRONG with this one 😅😅😅
Very annoying
I love the way Josh says "eggs". It's almost like he's trying to stretch it into multiple syllables.
Ayyggs
@@MaybeDelanieDied Ayyyegzzz
Watching Josh cooking his blue monstrosity had me crying with laughter! There’s a reason you don’t see blue things on menus….
Nicole, excellent chef though she is, didn’t embrace the horror of peeps. She deserves ridicule, shaming and shunning for not submitting to their lurid charm.
All in all I don’t care who won - one of the funniest cooking videos I’ve seen!
Every time they do an episode with all these cutaways a quarter of the comments are about people hating it but they apparently don't care because they keep doing it.
Ok we gotta acknowledge the cinnamon stick spin that Josh did on the side of the pan. That was impressive
YES! I had to search to see if anyone else caught it. That was freakin magical.🤩
graceful and effortless
Nicole: "He's so obsessed with me."
Half of viewers: "Um......"
Pretty sure she said more, but they cut her off for the lolz
Oh god...there's fan art isn't there...
So Josh "folding" in the food coloring to the merengue was definitely just stirring, right? Lol
I thought the same thing
Josh`s pronosiation of khachapuri was amazing, like a true Georgian
I appreciate the format. A suggestion that might work better is fewer cutaways and more small pop-up talks in the corners of the video instead.
They tried that too I believe, and it was sooo much worse than this.
Nicole doesn't seem to follow the spirit of the challenge and hides the main ingredient behind tons of other ingredients, while josh puts the main ingredient in the foreground so you know what it is.
Josh's looks like the imaginary pie the lost boys gave Peter in Hook
Unpopular opinion: I hate the episodes with 1000 cut aways like this. I can't watch them, but when the crew is together in person, I enjoy the show
I agree it is a little annoying it would be better if she actually was there
Not so unpopular. The jump cuts are rough.
I absolutely agree. Its a really terrible format and quite a few of them have made me stop watching around 4-5 minutes in.
@@williamsmith00 i was able to get to 8 minutes this time! it really is upsetting though because i love this channel, especially josh and not being able to watch him talk and cook is sad. also, the way she’s belittling him constantly puts a damper on things
i loved seeing nicole get roasted at the end lmao
"lets give this nightmare a try" "thats what all my ex boyfriends say" underrated joke
Nicole: “What are you doing in my house.”
Josh: “I WANT WAFFLE FRIES”
That tiktok sound pretty much sums up their dynamic
Thank God Josh made an innuendo out of “sharing the ham”. As soon as she said it my innuendo gland activated, and I knew Josh was experiencing the same sensation.
I love Nichole but this edit was SO DISTRACTING.
Absolutely agree. Love Nichole, but the constant cuts made this unwatchable for me. 3:59 was the point I stopped the video and decided to just skip this one.
Yeah not for me either. And the constant insults wasn't too fun either
I actually really love the commentary lol. I guess they could just use the overlay more to make it more like a reaction video instead of cutting between between the two and interrupting the flow.
Nicole, Josh great combo. More cutaways than a family Guy episode... Too much.
"How are you in charge of me?" That's a question I ask about my own boss all the time. For context, this is the man who was whipping around on the forklift, pedal to the metal, talking on a cell phone, while carrying a 1,200 pound filtration unit on the forks. I have no idea why or how he's still alive. I have more stories.
Love the Josh v Nicole aspect that the food crime videos bring. The snickle and now the peepza. Need more
The smash cuts to the commentary every 10-25 seconds really made the episode hard to watch
I've been commenting for a year now about them opening up a restaurant. Where everything on the menu is something the guys tasted and liked it. And that's a lot of food.
Good Mythical KITCHEN.
Josh is high as a kite during his commentary part and I'm not mad about it. 10/10 of course you look sober dont worry josh
First time watching their vids?
Nicole - Replaces sugar with melted Peeps. Groundbreaking...
That’s Josh’s new nickname - FlavorDaddy 🤣
Whoever edited this video was just railing monster energy drink. This is crazy!
I looked at Josh’s pizza and thought: “You’re doing it Peter!”
I'm so glad I wasn't the only one who thought that. It made me want to start a brightly colored food fight.
I love the way the wine is seamlessly weaved through the episode. Plus it's definitely sponsored more than just Nicole's 22nd.
Why is he your boss? Cause his unhinged madness is exactly what the show needs. xD
not Josh being right about baking power's makeup... I'm a pastry major in college right now, and I can confirm that baking powder can be made with cream of tartar as cream of tartar is an acid, which baking powder consists of baking soda mixed with an acid.
Automatic DQ for Nicole when you don't use hardly any tomato and you don't even have the main elements of a pizza. Could've beat josh "barely trying"
I love Josh, I really do, but man, there needs to be more Nicole. She's just great every time
Insulting ugly babies speaks to me on a physical level.
I was thinking they need even less of Nicole and more of Trevor. Nicole is boring and won't commit to the challenges. Her dish didn't even have peeps on it. she just melted the peeps into sugar and made a glaze.
they are the perfect complement to one another. she's logic and he's chaos. i love their dynamic
“Gauze On a Decapitation Wound” is my favorite Cannibal Corpse song
I was laughing so hard while Josh was making the pizza worse and worse I couldn't breathe. TY TY
Gonna be honest, the reasons Nicole is shocked that Josh is in charge of her are the exact reasons for it.
to be fair, the purpose of food is not to look good. the purpose of food is to taste good.
The f they’re gonna jump in this much it needs to be an overlay or something like a face cam while lowering the main audio. The current set up is very aggravating.
“Because when I think of pizza, I think of lemon meringue pie!” 🤣🤣
I get so confused by the cuts to Nicole every 5 seconds. Idk if I like this editing format.. but I love the show none the less.
Josh’s food crime took a misdemeanor and ran it all the way out to multiple felonies.
Someone said an organized food crime
Law and Order Food Crimes
Please please please if you do this again you need to go back to the editing of the Snickle episode. That was done well. This is just too much man
That start with Nicole made me spit out my tea.
155. There are 155 cuts to the other person in this 29 min video. Plus all the picture in picture comments that I didn't even count. What the hell.
81 cuts to Nicole while Josh is cooking.
56 cuts to Josh while Nicole is cooking.
18 cuts to Josh and Nicole while Mike is judging. These last cuts are a little more understandable.
How many of those 29 minutes was Nicole talking
This is a perfect example of how good editing should be invisible.
"You fight fire with fire!" Josh says, as they are literally fighting fire with marshmallows.
These are amazing, I love everything about this. But yes Nicole you can’t hide from the challenges!! It’s gotta SCREAM whatever weird combo you doing! That’s why josh keeps winning
Josh's lack of respect for cheese coverage and crust size makes me think pizza is his weakest dish to make.
I was personally shocked that he didn't even consider dying the sauce neon red or something. It sounds like something he would do.
The only way peeps are edible are when roasted over a camp fire like a normal marshmallow. It crystallizes the sugar & makes a glassy crunchy casing. Yum
JOSH COOK FOR PIPPIN AGAIN PLEASE
IM BEGGING GIVE US THE CAT CONTENT
Why is nobody talking about the guy who 3D printed a gear cover for the stand mixer? Whoever you are, I love that it bothered you enough to go through all of that.
Josh and Trevor should recerat berries and cream Starburst and do the little dance they would smash it.
The back and forth with the reaction comments is my favorite format.
The editing on this is so jarring
Josh's existence makes me feel 100% better about myself. I do text back. In person, when I see you, verbally
It's like with food fears, how Josh would lean into the flavour palate of a gross ingredient, making the final dish taste good without masking the original flavour...
I feel like Josh takes a similar philosophy here and leans hard into the fundamental aspects of the food crime. While yes, it means he ends up making an unholy abomination of a food crime.
It's at least a tastier food crime than the one they started with.
i appreciate that he switched the elements around. the peep-coloured meringue on top was savory and the sauce was peep. it's actually brilliant in its chaos.
I feel like that's the spirit of the show! Not to make something unrelated that tastes good, that's easy, the challenge is to turn the original gross thing into something good without making it unrecognizable
Nicole : Unless you want to get me drunk before...
Me : Yes
This was hard to watch - I wish they would edit out the random interjections and just let us watch each person present their recipe.
Nicole got robbed. Mike was a biased/crooked judge. I want a recount.
You guys made a meta reaction video, this is a strange format from mythical lol
Nicole turned this into Josh's official comedy roast special, right out the gate 😂 "Trash raccoon... Oh my gosh, he likes it" "Actin' like he's at a wine tasting" "OoOhHh. _Suuper_ artisanal. Peeps and bacon jam..." "Josh is talking about shotput again. _love_ when that happens..." "He's disappointed in himself. YESS."
@@hideyourloveaway128 Tbh I usually feel that way about her prissiness (big Josh & Emily fan)
But it was def played for laughs, calling her out for being cowardly with gross mashups (there's nothing appetizing about peeps on pizza)
The format really doesn't work. Have them be together and have that normal chaotic energy. The cutaways feel too scripted and don't honestly seem like something they might honestly say, especially Nicoles segments since she doesn't seem that needlessly negative normally, so either removing them or making them more natural and less frequent IMO seems the best way forward.
There are so many cuts when Josh is cooking I can't even finish this video
I LOVE spotting “thing & thing” restaurants in Portland 😆
I don't want to see Josh and Nicole fight over who can make the best thing I want to see them collaborate to make the worst thing.
I think Josh already did
I honestly think the addition of the cutaways takes away from the unbridled chaos of the peepza, and it would be less time and budget to have them both in the kitchen, with one cooking an the other riffing on them, itd get a nice back and forth.