He didn't get to pick what there were. There were only those 3 options. He said, "empty bishop square." As in, there wasn't a piece there. So he gave hermione the safest piece to protect her. Harry a piece that's easy to escape with. And himself the worst option out of bravery.
True, the mistake was there in the books, though :D, there, Ron announced what pieces they will be and the corresponding magical pieces left the chessboard to make room for them.
Great content but I don’t think Ron was able to choose what positions they needed to fill, bishop, castle, and king were empty when they walked up to the board
“Queen size castle” - proceeds to highlight the kingside castle, thus throwing off the entire video. After he judged 12 year Ron for making “VERY bad decisions”.
IMO Ron played brilliantly. He essentially had 3 piece in addition to King that he can't lose. And he almost succeed in doing so only to lose himself at end. This is super hard. Try playing a game online and forfeit whenever you lose that bishop knight or rock and you will not be able to stay on your current rank.
3:28 And he missed the simple idea of putting one of his friends on the king. Even in checkmate the king would not be destroyed because capturing the king is an irregular move.
There’s a black rook in the right of the shot for reference, where it appears to be sitting. There’s also a black bishop on the left of the shot which looks identical to the white bishop on C1.
4:23 move black rook to c1 than it must be eliminated by white rook from b1 than Harry can eliminate this rook going to c1 1 rook and 2 bishops are stronger than 1 queen
Going into an endgame where you can't trade your rook, knight, or bishop seems like a horrible idea. That said, if this were a casual online game, I probably would've played that
@@Dariusz_1.618 I mean you can't trade the other rook, because the other rook is Hermione. So if, for instance, you get a chance to pin the white queen to the king...too bad, you can't.
@@Thete You can trade rook for rook. And actually King can't move. So only options for white, after black Rc1 ( instead of Rc3 ), are Rc1 or Qd1. Sacrificing rook is followed by black Nh3 ( Ron ) and it is win for black. 1. ... ; Rc1+ 2. Qd1 ; Nh3# or 1. ... ; Rc1+ 2. Rc1 ; Bc1 I don't understand why Rc3 is played, then obviously followed by Qc3 and either next move - Bc5 or Nh3 can be eliminated by white queen
What are you saying when you said "the easiest is to sacrifice harry to declare.....what? It sounds like your saying "declare me" and my subtitles say me but that's not it.😂 my ocd is bothering me. I have my ear to the phone and still can't make it out. You also said the bishop is taking to H3 "me?" What does that mean?
Edit: nvm, I missed the "declare mate" I have a question... isnt the horse on a3 a checkmate than just check? When discussing sacrificing harry's piece. The white king cant move to a1 cuz of bishop on white nor c1 becuase hermione as the rock blocks that.
No. It’s not checkmate until the other side has no other move that will take the king out of check. In this case, white has the queen, which takes Ron.
You got it all WRONG DUDE! Harry Potter is the DARK SQUARE BISHOP of Black as what you pictured, but Hermonie is NOT the rook on the king side! She’s the other rook on the QUEEN SIDE cuz her square standing on is WHITE at 3:14!! A8 rook!! & RON is the KNIGHT RIGHT NEXT TO HARRY OR KING SIDE G8 KNIGHT!! You got it wrong dude
Right and if Ron would choose anyone as King, it would be Harry as you know from the end of the scene Also in my opinion, at least one rook has to be unplayed, because often one of them dies
Check 2:56, you’ll notice the black queen is on a white diagonal, meaning the film producers without realizing misplaced the entire board. Then they shot the later scenes and switched the pieces they were playing.
He didn't get to pick what there were. There were only those 3 options. He said, "empty bishop square." As in, there wasn't a piece there. So he gave hermione the safest piece to protect her. Harry a piece that's easy to escape with. And himself the worst option out of bravery.
In the book he chose those spots
True, the mistake was there in the books, though :D, there, Ron announced what pieces they will be and the corresponding magical pieces left the chessboard to make room for them.
Great content but I don’t think Ron was able to choose what positions they needed to fill, bishop, castle, and king were empty when they walked up to the board
#2spooky4me
Knight
You're right
True
In the movie, yes, but in the book it says those pieces walk off the board.
This shows that Ron made decisions that not only won the game but made sure Harry was conscious enough to continue to Voldemort
“Queen size castle” - proceeds to highlight the kingside castle, thus throwing off the entire video. After he judged 12 year Ron for making “VERY bad decisions”.
i noticed as well lol
They didn't want to animate Harry smashing the queen on the last move :D
Nerd mode: Ron is not the king because the rider is missing on the knight
The very last move is true, that it wasnt checkmate. But my guess is that this was resign from white. Or so to speak. It wouldn't have changed outcome
Thank you for this. Enjoyed it
Loved the vid! I'm learning how to play chess and I remembered this scene ! Great game btw, imo great decisions were made
@antonietaovalle1484 how’s your chess skills 10 months later?
He did make the move, you can see the queen on the ground next to him after he calls checkmate. I guess it was just cut.
So how tf Magnus remember this game lol
IMO Ron played brilliantly. He essentially had 3 piece in addition to King that he can't lose. And he almost succeed in doing so only to lose himself at end. This is super hard. Try playing a game online and forfeit whenever you lose that bishop knight or rock and you will not be able to stay on your current rank.
Well I suppose they skipped the queen sacrifice because likely there wasn't a good way to have Harry take her
If u see in back there is bishop..who will still strike harry back..so they did not win
@@victorchoudhury3538what bishop?
@@victorchoudhury3538 wrong
3:28 And he missed the simple idea of putting one of his friends on the king. Even in checkmate the king would not be destroyed because capturing the king is an irregular move.
he couldnt choose which squares where available
@@moon-pw1bi He could, he sat on a knight, didn’t he? He could have taken either Harry‘s or Hermione‘s square.
@@chessplayer1202 yes because you can ride horses. You want him to rid a king? I don't think that's pg
@@moon-pw1bi It‘s not about aesthetics, it’s about using your head.
@@chessplayer1202 yes but you physically can't ride the king (in a pg way)
Harry may have called "Checkmate" incorrectly, but i think White just resigned at that point.
4:32 THE ROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOK
Good content in light of the new video game
No dissapointment taken. The White Queen resigned because even magical pieces can see mate in 1 xD
Idk, somehow i got weird feeling like memories that harry have talk about chess with the crying ghost, merry beth i guess....
at 1:36 - that's not a bishop on c1 it's a rook, you can look up the isle of lewis chess pieces and then compare to what you see in the film
There’s a black rook in the right of the shot for reference, where it appears to be sitting. There’s also a black bishop on the left of the shot which looks identical to the white bishop on C1.
shout out to International Master Jeremy Silman for creating this Chess sequence
can someone please correct me but if you can see checkmate x number of steps ahead you can call checkmate in x and the match is over?
7:16 Magnus carlson if he ever loses his world no.1
Ding Ding Ding
Magnum Carlos
Ron said queen side castle and put Hermione on the kind side😭
Ron asumed that the Queen will go for him instead of Harry, easiest mistake to make.
ron checked the king
Ron Checked the king, The queens only option was to take him.
You could also take the king sword falling as a resignation
The best
Harry needed to buy a new chessboard everytime!
Or he just used the repair spell everytime
@@totowolff69420 true comedy
in the movie there was no empty square so kinda messed up. also im curious how harry could destroy queen with bare hands :)
3:38 harry just vanishing with the ios interface is very funny
Imagine if you licked it?..the sculpture would then come alive and sword you to death😂😂😂..like the chest scene in Harry Potter the Sorcerer Stone😂
4:23
move black rook to c1
than it must be eliminated by white rook from b1
than Harry can eliminate this rook going to c1
1 rook and 2 bishops are stronger than 1 queen
@tellme5167
Rc1+ is check, so you must eliminate threat ( Rc1 and therefore Bc1 ),
cover with queen ( Qd1 followed by Rd1 ) or escape king Kg2.
Going into an endgame where you can't trade your rook, knight, or bishop seems like a horrible idea. That said, if this were a casual online game, I probably would've played that
@@Dariusz_1.618 I mean you can't trade the other rook, because the other rook is Hermione. So if, for instance, you get a chance to pin the white queen to the king...too bad, you can't.
@@Dariusz_1.618 After Rxc1, there's no mate threat because white has Rxc5 if Harry tries to give a check there.
@@Thete
You can trade rook for rook.
And actually King can't move.
So only options for white, after black Rc1 ( instead of Rc3 ), are Rc1 or Qd1.
Sacrificing rook is followed by black Nh3 ( Ron ) and it is win for black.
1. ... ; Rc1+
2. Qd1 ; Nh3#
or
1. ... ; Rc1+
2. Rc1 ; Bc1
I don't understand why Rc3 is played, then obviously followed by Qc3
and either next move - Bc5 or Nh3 can be eliminated by white queen
i doubt, that rooks were the best choice. i would rather said, take rook-pawns or knight-pawns and defend them like a king
What are you saying when you said "the easiest is to sacrifice harry to declare.....what? It sounds like your saying "declare me" and my subtitles say me but that's not it.😂 my ocd is bothering me. I have my ear to the phone and still can't make it out. You also said the bishop is taking to H3 "me?" What does that mean?
"The easiest is to sacrifice Harry to declare mate."
bc4+ qxc4 nh3#
the second one is:
"The bishop is taken and knight h3 mate"
ron should have moved harry in D5
Edit: nvm, I missed the "declare mate"
I have a question... isnt the horse on a3 a checkmate than just check? When discussing sacrificing harry's piece.
The white king cant move to a1 cuz of bishop on white nor c1 becuase hermione as the rock blocks that.
No. It’s not checkmate until the other side has no other move that will take the king out of check. In this case, white has the queen, which takes Ron.
Грррроооооб
You got it all WRONG DUDE! Harry Potter is the DARK SQUARE BISHOP of Black as what you pictured, but Hermonie is NOT the rook on the king side! She’s the other rook on the QUEEN SIDE cuz her square standing on is WHITE at 3:14!! A8 rook!! & RON is the KNIGHT RIGHT NEXT TO HARRY OR KING SIDE G8 KNIGHT!! You got it wrong dude
Right and if Ron would choose anyone as King, it would be Harry as you know from the end of the scene
Also in my opinion, at least one rook has to be unplayed, because often one of them dies
Check 2:56, you’ll notice the black queen is on a white diagonal, meaning the film producers without realizing misplaced the entire board. Then they shot the later scenes and switched the pieces they were playing.