.. 😂😂😂😂.. .. oopar waaley ne bhi kya ghazab ye khel kiya.. .. of d mslm.. for d mslm.. by d mslm.. pxtn bnaa ke.. .. musalmano ko hi pel diya.. 😂😂😂😂.. ..ek plan musalman bnaata h.. .. aur ek plan bhagwan bnaata h.. .. 😂😂😂😂😂..
Dr Sahab, many thanks for all the work you are doing. Have learnt so much from you.. I pray for your long and healthy life. Keep doing what you are doing... Take care
Jinnah, Munir, Peerzada, Moulvi Mushtaq, Iftikhar Chaudry, Faiz Isa. All legal stalwarts but alas the more things change the more they remain the same.
I'm so glad that Dr. Ishtiaq bears the truth of history. It's very congruent with what my family truthfully told me from 1910 (year my father was born) onwards.
سوال یہ ہے کہ بھارت تو سیکولر ریاست ہونے کا دعوٰی دار ہمیشہ سے تھا آزادی کے بعد بھی ان کا آئین سیکولر ہے ، تو پھر پاکستان کو سیکولر پاکستان بنا کر مسلمان کو کیا ملنا تھا ؟ اسے تو اسلامی ریاست بننا تھا ۔۔۔۔۔ اور اسلامی ریاست میں دوسرے مذاہب آزادی سے رہ سکتے ہیں، قائداعظم کا مطلب 11 اگست کی تقریر میں یہی تھا نا کہ وہ سیکولر ریاست کے حامی تھے اگر حامی ہوتے تو پاکستان کیوں بناتے سیکولر انڈیا میں ہی رہتے
You have written many books on the early years of Pakistan and you should know that Shah Din, Begum Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Shafi, Liaquat Ali Khan, Malik Ghulam Muhammad, Abdul Rab Nishtar, Mumtaz Doultana, Firoz Noon, Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, Sahibzada Yaqoob Ali Khan, Ayub Khan,Zia ulhaq ,Syed Ehsan, Nazir, all of them belonged to the cult of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.The policy of the government of Pakistan was not made by Jinnah but by Mirza Mahmood and the war in Kashmir was also started by the order and plan of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.
I’m happy that the role of Mian family of Baghbanpura has been discussed. I belong to the same family. I have read this book and this aspect struck me too. It’s good that you are discussing the events that shaped Pakistan.
Please make a detailed video on constitution of Pakistan. We want to know what it says? Only you can detailed us properly about it. Thanks and respect for you from deep of my heart❤
Sir, I get the impression that you act as an advocate for the pre-partition Indian National Congress. I understand that you feel strongly that what was then called the Indian Subcontinent should not have been divided into two countries. However, it has happened. Not only has the division taken place but so much time has passed since the event that four generations have come who have seen the two countries of India and Pakistan as fait accompli. The present-day Congress Party has also adjusted to the new realities and concentrates its efforts on the current political requirements of the Republic of India minus the territories of Pakistan and Bangladesh. To the best of my knowledge they do not invoke their pre-partition political stance in their menfisto or current political activities. Most of your programs are dedicated to this one topic. This is crying over spilt milk. It is like a 75 year old great-grandfather forcefully arguing with anyone who would listen that his own parents should not have married. What would happen if you and I were successfully convinced by him that the marriage of his parents was an evil thing and should not have happened? Can you and I un-marry his parents? If that marriage should not have taken place then what would be his own staus? What should be done about him, his children and grandchildren, as they all came about as a result of that marriage? I feel that you have made your views amply clear through your videos. Now it is time to move to the next stage. Your energies would be much better spent in playing your part in correcting the mistakes that have been committed. Please play a positive role by discussing solutions rather than bemoaning what has happened and can't be undone.
Well said. I believe this man is an agent of India and his mission is to dig against Mr. Jinah, Islam, making of Pakistan and to abide by the agenda given to him by his foreign masters. The question is what is his own contribution and sacrifices to construct and strengthen Pakistan? Please notice: Whenever he requires to open the comment section all of his Indian fans jump into it and start bashing and laughing at Pakistan, its founders and thanking him for his soul selling against Pakistan. Please count how many Indian commentators are on it and what are their intentions. I have a question for these Indian fans of Dr. Ishtiaq, that is: What if Dr. Ishtiaq turns against India, its leaders and Hindus and starts proving that Jinnah was great and it was all Hindus who are responsible for this divide and hatred between Hindu and Muslim, what would be their reaction and won't start hating their own hero who is called Dr. Ishtiaq?
Dear sir, Some enlightened people such like you need to pakistan in diplomatic as well as social education. And also drafting policies for the nation's. Thanks 👍 JAI Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳 JAI BOSE 🇮🇳 JAI BHIM 💙
Abdul Rab Nishter was forced to join Muslim League by the “powerful”after mid thirties. Originally he was from majlis e ahrar. All of them were living in an imaginary paradise. Amongst the leaders you don’t find commitment to democracy.
@@Billumian47 یہ قائداعظم کے اے ڈی سی تھے۔ ان کا قائداعظم سے آئین کے بارے سوال کرنا عجیب لگتا ہے ۔ قائداعظم سے کسی نے سوال کیا تھا تو آپ نے فرمایا آئین بنانا آئین ساز اسمبلی کا کام ہے۔
You have written many books on the early years of Pakistan and you should know that Shah Din, Begum Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Shafi, Liaquat Ali Khan, Malik Ghulam Muhammad, Abdul Rab Nishtar, Mumtaz Doultana, Firoz Noon, Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, Sahibzada Yaqoob Ali Khan, Ayub Khan,Zia ulhaq ,Syed Ehsan, Nazir, all of them belonged to the cult of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.The policy of the government of Pakistan was not made by Jinnah but by Mirza Mahmood and the war in Kashmir was also started by the order and plan of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.
Entire subcontinent mainly the intellgensia of India and Pak is highly obliged to you Sir Ishtiaq.Sahib for unearthing such historical facts. But, I, 86 yrs old Kashmiri who has suffered hugely due to this two-nation theory am receiving solitude with your successive historical events brought out for viewers.knowledge. My prayers for your healthy long life AABAAD.
2:43 😂😂😂😂.... Ap hur video main yahi prove krny main lgy rehty ho ...idealogy of Pakistan...ghalut hy ...maybe ...but ap ki koshish ya honi chahiy k Pakistan jis maqsad k liy bna wo kaisy hasil ho skta hy ... Pakistan to ban gya ... Hum ny Pakistan k liy kya kiya ?? Hum haq k liy kabi ni othay ...jis terha bangali krty hein .... Hum khud hud haram hein aur kehty hein k Pakistan aur two nation theory hi ghalut hy ...oooohhh bhai pehly apny girehban main jhanko k hum kitny Pakistani aur kitny musalman hein ....
یہ سوال جناب قائد سے علی گڑھ کے طلباء نے پوچھا تو آپ نے جواب دیا کہ ہمارا دستور تو تیرہ سو سال سے ہمارے پاس موجود ھے۔ قائد اعظم رحمت اللہ نے نو مسلم سکالر محمد پکٹل کی زیر صدارت ایک کمیٹی بنا دی تھی جو نوزائیدہ مملکت کیلئے قرآنی تعلیمات کے مطابق دستور کی سفارشات مرتب کریں۔ شاید ہر ہفتہ اس کی پروگریس بھی چیک کرتے تھے۔ غالباً سات میٹنگز بھی ہو چکی تھیں کہ قائد اعظم بیماری کی وجہ سے زیارت شفٹ ہو گئے ۔ مولانا مودودی کو بھی ریڈیو سے اسلامی نطام کے خدوخال واضح کرنے کیلئے تقاریر نشر کرنے کا قائداعظم رحمت اللہ علیہ نے کہا تھا۔ قائد کی بیماری کا بہانہ بنا کر کابینہ نے محمد پکٹل کا رابطہ منقطع کروا دیا۔ بالآخر وہ مایوس ہو کر پاکستان سے چلے گئے ۔ شاید پاکستان کا پہلا پاسپورٹ محمد پکٹل کا ہی بنا تھا۔
Dr Shb, Kam se kam SARC ko jinda kr usme ye bahas ki jaa sakti hai ki es khittey ko kaise theek kiya jaay. If Pak takes interest then it can be done easily.
It is high time you stop your bull shit about our beloved Pakistan and our beloved leaders. You have already collected enough revenue to try to leave this world in peace.
Sir as far as I remember reading this book of Begum Shahnawaz then I had read that Jinnah wanted to model Pakistan's constitution on the French Constitution of 1945...had this been happened Pak wouldn't have been a majoritarian religious state.
@@Billumian47 Sir it is mentioned on page 201 of this book.... Here is excerpt: "It was the same day that Mr Jinnah talked to me of a constitution for Pakistan. He told me that he had been working on a constitution for the last fifteen months and it was almost ready. He also said that he had based it more or less on the new French Constitution. I went all over New Delhi to get a copy of the French Constitution, but I could not find one." Reference: Father & Daughter: A Political Autobiography, page 201
As far as my knowledge, Mr Jinnah was Lawyer for property disputes . He seem to have no control over charting for destiny of newly born country he had fought for. Mr Jinnah lacked statesmanship. This is also becouse he had fought in the name of Islam and as such he had no option to talk on Democracy and Secularism in constituent Assembly. In fact in my opinion, two nation theory was not given by any Jinnah , Rahmat Ali,....... Two nation theory was established about 1400 years back and this is in fact one of foundation of Islam. Two nations are defined as Musalman and non muslims(Kafirs). I would like to know your take Sir 👏
Sir, A much awaited video for me being Pakistani Punjabi is "how Pakistani state impose Urdu language and genocide the regional languages especially Punjabi Language, Culture and Heritage in Pakistan!"
My father served as a senior civil servant with the newly formed Civil Service of Pakistan after partition. Our family migrated from Patiala. Growing up we used to hear a lot of stories from him about the chaotic nature of how the country was being run. There was no actual consensus as to a common National language as English had automatically been adopted as the main language of communication by the political elite and the bureaucracy. However there was a movement to promote Urdu by factions of the Muslim league as it was considered to be the language most widely spoken and understood by the Muslims of India and as a counter to India adopting Hindi as the main state language, adopting Urdu as the state language for Pakistan was considered to be a further validation of the two nation theory. The irony of course being that none of the major players and decision makers at the time were native Urdu speakers. Jinnah was a native Gujarati speaker although there is no record of him having ever made a single speech in that language. Liaquat Ali was from Haryana which was part of Punjab at the time. Nishtar was a pashtoon. Zafarullah was Punjabi. Suhrewardi, Fazlul Haq etc were Bengali. Almost the entire political elite at the time were not native Urdu speakers. Yet they all backed the decision as an extension of the two nation theory. Of course we saw the major backlash from the Bengalis when Jinnah made the announcement in Dhaka and then we had the language riots that were brutally suppressed. So a political decision which was also seen as a convenient necessity to gradually replace English and in theory to forge a common language of communication between the different ethnicities inhabiting the newly formed country. Of course this has come at great cost to the propagation of Punjabi but the only way to reverse that is to reject the two nation theory altogether
@@Rizvirambles I do agree there is no such thing like two Nation theory in the world, because we were the people who were living together more than 1000 years in the past so how's that possible that some day someone stood up and started chanting that Hindus and Muslims are the two Nations and they cannot live together peacefully!! But as far as Urdu is the national language is concerned, before the partition they were also the suggestions by the students of Aligarh who were actually the main culprits who started the movement of Pakistan their mother tongue was Urdu and they started chanting that Urdu should be the national language of a newly born state, and I heard this from a historian that even that time Bengali politicians opposed this suggestion! But for me being a Punjabi there is a huge regret for my community that how they became the front Man of Urdu language and We even eliminate Our Mother Tongue from Our Homes, not a single man at that time and even now who stand up against this unjust policy of Pakistan State, that Why Our Children are not studying Punjabi in their Syllabus, why Punjabi is not the official Language of Punjab?
KISSI WAQAT PLEASE ISLAMIC STATE AUR MUSLIM STATE PAR B BAAT KREIN KAYUN K JINNAH SAHIB MUSLIMS IN INDIA K LIYE SIASI AUR MUAASHI RIGHTS KI WAKALAT KARTAY THAY
Zahir hai, yeh jub tuk Pakistan aur iskay founder kay khilaf jhoot bolta rahayga, yeh tumhara hero bana rahaiga aur jis din iss nay India, iskay leaders aur Hindus kay khilaaf bolna aur sabit kerna shuru kia ussi din tum loge apnay iss aaj kay hero ko paagal aur jhoota kehna shuru ker do gay.
Ha said that he would not even piss on the fake muslims of the Indian subcontinent. He warned in private about the rabid radicalism prevalent among the Indian Muslim and did not want Turks to be associated with them. He felt that Indian Muslims were dirty, stinking, and unworthy.
O' Bhai Pakistan and Jinah hater. Pahlay India mein toilets to bana lay. Jagah jagah, sarkon per, patrion per shuru ho jaatay ho aur sari dunia mein badboo aur beemari phailaatay ho. besides, do you still remember what Churchil said about Gandhi?
You have written many books on the early years of Pakistan and you should know that Shah Din, Begum Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Shafi, Liaquat Ali Khan, Malik Ghulam Muhammad, Abdul Rab Nishtar, Mumtaz Doultana, Firoz Noon, Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, Sahibzada Yaqoob Ali Khan, Ayub Khan,Zia ulhaq ,Syed Ehsan, Nazir, all of them belonged to the cult of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.The policy of the government of Pakistan was not made by Jinnah but by Mirza Mahmood and the war in Kashmir was also started by the order and plan of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.
After watching Your So Many Videos about Pakistan I can Say Pakistan Own By Milatry They Need Constant Conflict with India To Remain in Power once Pakistan Milatry Gown from Power then Your And Mine Dream Peaceful relationship ind pak can Be True
Never. It is your lack of knowledge about the politicians of Pakistan and peoples of Pakistan. All the politicians from Jinnah sahib to present P.M. Shabaz Sharif including Imran Khan Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Mademe Banazir Bhutto F.M. Bilawal Bhutto Liaquat Ali Khan all are 8increase hate sentiments against Hindu nation and India . The normal not good relations between Pakistan and India are possible.
Sir,mein koshish karata hun ki mein aapki speech puri dekhun,aur dekhata bhi hun,aapse gyat hota hai ki aek jamin ko do hisson mein baantane wala aur lakhon logon ko marvane vala asali villain kaun tha 😒😒😒. Aek hi to DNA hum donon deshon ke logon ka hai,hum donon ke purvaj muslim nahin hindu hi the,bas kuchh majburiyon ne hamein alag kiya,yah sabhi bharatiya hindu jante hain.😌🙏
BHAI, TWO NATION THEORY DONO HINDUO AUR MUSALMANO MEI USS KE SUPPORTER THAY MAGAR JINNAH SAHIB NE USAY POLITICALLY ISTIMAL KIYA AUR ANGRAZO NE UNHE PAKISTAN DIA.
@@Billumian47 sir,angrejon ne jaan bujhakar separate nation apne fayde ke lie banaye,jab unki mali halat thik ho jayenge to ve ham fir kabbja kar lenge,lekin hamari kismat thik thi jinko Neharu ji jaise neta mile,ho sakata hai agar jinaah bimar na hokar na marate tab paakistaan ki jo haalat aaj hai,shayad tashveer alag hi hoti,mere hisab se ve kattar panthi muslim nahi the,baki aap vidvyan hain unhein aap behatar unhein samajhte hain 😌🙏
What is your real point of view? Instead of giving arguements from unverifiable incidents occured during last many decades gavind different context. Please eleborate what do you want?
Istiaq ji, Would you like to tell us why the Indian Muslims not be treated like the second largest majority instead of minority? You don't think that the demand for Indian muslims to be treated like minority is a fraud and injustice against real minorities? Why was there no minority status for Hindus in J&K even during the so-called pious jihadi rule of Congress, NC, and PDP? Islamists are responsible for the division of Indian motherland, Indian society, Indian identity, and Indian culture. Islam has not played any positive role in the Indian sub continent. Now, don't tell me that they built Taj Mahal and Qutub Minar.
LIAQAT ALI KHAN AUR USS K HUM NAWAON KO MANA JAI TO JINNAH SE BARA JOUTA INDIAN SUBCONTINENT MEIN NAHEIN THA JISS NEIN BANGAAL SINDH K DULLITS AUR PUNJAB K CHRISTIAN K SAATH ITNA MUDALAL JOUT BOLA K WO SUB MUSLIM LEAGUE K SUPPORTER BUNN GAI
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO MY CHANNEL AND MAKE YOUR FRIENDS DO IT TOO. IT IS FREE AND OPEN TO EVERYONE, THANK YOU IN ADVANCE.
How do I invite you to my channel as a guest?
Happy Teachers Day sir 💓 😊
@@Lubna.CandidSabhi broad minded logon ko ikatthe hona chahiye.
.. 😂😂😂😂..
.. oopar waaley ne bhi kya ghazab ye khel kiya..
.. of d mslm.. for d mslm.. by d mslm.. pxtn bnaa ke..
.. musalmano ko hi pel diya.. 😂😂😂😂..
..ek plan musalman bnaata h..
.. aur ek plan bhagwan bnaata h..
.. 😂😂😂😂😂..
@@Billumian47 I already have subscribed
ماشاءاللہ ، بہترین محقق ،
پاکستان کے نوجوانوں کے لیے اصل ماضی بیان کر رہا ھے،
Dr Sahab, many thanks for all the work you are doing. Have learnt so much from you.. I pray for your long and healthy life. Keep doing what you are doing... Take care
Great work, God will give u time to explain the truth
Sir, please remove the music. You don't need any background music.
I like music behind him
It is very distracting for a serious discussion.
Agreed
Agreed
Remove this - remove that , tum kaho to prof sab chaddi bhi utaar dein ? Problem Kya hai tumhara bhai 😅?
Imp point
Thank you Dr. Ishtiaq for your intensive research and information about the creation of Pakistan.
میرے تعمیر میں مضمر ھے صورت اک خرابی کی۔
Jinnah, Munir, Peerzada, Moulvi Mushtaq, Iftikhar Chaudry, Faiz Isa. All legal stalwarts but alas the more things change the more they remain the same.
Love from India
Excellent explained ❤❤
I'm so glad that Dr. Ishtiaq bears the truth of history. It's very congruent with what my family truthfully told me from 1910 (year my father was born) onwards.
سوال یہ ہے کہ بھارت تو سیکولر ریاست ہونے کا دعوٰی دار ہمیشہ سے تھا آزادی کے بعد بھی ان کا آئین سیکولر ہے ، تو پھر پاکستان کو سیکولر پاکستان بنا کر مسلمان کو کیا ملنا تھا ؟ اسے تو اسلامی ریاست بننا تھا ۔۔۔۔۔ اور اسلامی ریاست میں دوسرے مذاہب آزادی سے رہ سکتے ہیں، قائداعظم کا مطلب 11 اگست کی تقریر میں یہی تھا نا کہ وہ سیکولر ریاست کے حامی تھے اگر حامی ہوتے تو پاکستان کیوں بناتے سیکولر انڈیا میں ہی رہتے
You have written many books on the early years of Pakistan and you should know that Shah Din, Begum Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Shafi, Liaquat Ali Khan, Malik Ghulam Muhammad, Abdul Rab Nishtar, Mumtaz Doultana, Firoz Noon, Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, Sahibzada Yaqoob Ali Khan, Ayub Khan,Zia ulhaq ,Syed Ehsan, Nazir, all of them belonged to the cult of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.The policy of the government of Pakistan was not made by Jinnah but by Mirza Mahmood and the war in Kashmir was also started by the order and plan of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.
Pakistan
is a land of opportunity for the rich and powerful.
I’m happy that the role of Mian family of Baghbanpura has been discussed. I belong to the same family. I have read this book and this aspect struck me too. It’s good that you are discussing the events that shaped Pakistan.
Sir, Your talks have backing of research, facts and objectivity. The added background sounds are a distraction. Your broadcast is better without it.
Please make a detailed video on constitution of Pakistan. We want to know what it says?
Only you can detailed us properly about it.
Thanks and respect for you from deep of my heart❤
Sir, I get the impression that you act as an advocate for the pre-partition Indian National Congress. I understand that you feel strongly that what was then called the Indian Subcontinent should not have been divided into two countries. However, it has happened. Not only has the division taken place but so much time has passed since the event that four generations have come who have seen the two countries of India and Pakistan as fait accompli.
The present-day Congress Party has also adjusted to the new realities and concentrates its efforts on the current political requirements of the Republic of India minus the territories of Pakistan and Bangladesh. To the best of my knowledge they do not invoke their pre-partition political stance in their menfisto or current political activities.
Most of your programs are dedicated to this one topic. This is crying over spilt milk. It is like a 75 year old great-grandfather forcefully arguing with anyone who would listen that his own parents should not have married. What would happen if you and I were successfully convinced by him that the marriage of his parents was an evil thing and should not have happened? Can you and I un-marry his parents? If that marriage should not have taken place then what would be his own staus? What should be done about him, his children and grandchildren, as they all came about as a result of that marriage?
I feel that you have made your views amply clear through your videos. Now it is time to move to the next stage. Your energies would be much better spent in playing your part in correcting the mistakes that have been committed. Please play a positive role by discussing solutions rather than bemoaning what has happened and can't be undone.
Well said. I believe this man is an agent of India and his mission is to dig against Mr. Jinah, Islam, making of Pakistan and to abide by the agenda given to him by his foreign masters. The question is what is his own contribution and sacrifices to construct and strengthen Pakistan? Please notice: Whenever he requires to open the comment section all of his Indian fans jump into it and start bashing and laughing at Pakistan, its founders and thanking him for his soul selling against Pakistan. Please count how many Indian commentators are on it and what are their intentions. I have a question for these Indian fans of Dr. Ishtiaq, that is: What if Dr. Ishtiaq turns against India, its leaders and Hindus and starts proving that Jinnah was great and it was all Hindus who are responsible for this divide and hatred between Hindu and Muslim, what would be their reaction and won't start hating their own hero who is called Dr. Ishtiaq?
Uneducated People of Pak cannot be like Europe with free boarder's
Please make video about prisoners. What was government policy about them at partition. Were they also transferred or not.
Yes. This was also discussed between both governments and presioners were exchanged though the process was not smooth
❤
I believe that the India Should not be divided.
Nmskar,sir,
Dr sahib, your information on every topic is very true and accurate, --Narinder Sharma USA
Sir,
Please avoid the background music in future . It's disturbing.
Thanks.
Yoginder Khanna.
Dear sir,
Some enlightened people such like you need to pakistan in diplomatic as well as social education. And also drafting policies for the nation's.
Thanks 👍
JAI Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳 JAI BOSE 🇮🇳 JAI BHIM 💙
Yes it is a ideal Muslim state. Ruling class is living lavishly as after khilafate Rashida rulers were living lavishly.
Abdul Rab Nishter was forced to join Muslim League by the “powerful”after mid thirties. Originally he was from majlis e ahrar. All of them were living in an imaginary paradise. Amongst the leaders you don’t find commitment to democracy.
Very true.
Sir why your name Coming Billumian
Sir Shafi and Sir Shah Nawaz were Aarian.
Arain 😊are known to be self serving, selfish maggots.
Brilliantly presented. Always a treat to follow your vlog.
How can I invite you on my channel as a guest?
Tum apani bokwas bund kar salli. You are traitor to Pakistan and Pakistani people.
Very informative , thank you Sir.
🙏🙏🙏
Would also love to hear from you about mian ifthikaruddin, thr punjab congress president who joined muslim league in 1945 and wanted land reforms.
یعقوب صاحب احسن صاحب فوجی افسر تھے ان کو آئین کے بارے کیا پریشانی تھی۔
What a bizarre question!!!!!!!! So, as citizens should they not have any views on this?
@@Billumian47
یہ قائداعظم کے اے ڈی سی تھے۔ ان کا قائداعظم سے آئین کے بارے سوال کرنا عجیب لگتا ہے ۔ قائداعظم سے کسی نے سوال کیا تھا تو آپ نے فرمایا آئین بنانا آئین ساز اسمبلی کا کام ہے۔
Happy Teachers Day sir 💓 😊 ☺️ ❤️ 💖
You have written many books on the early years of Pakistan and you should know that Shah Din, Begum Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Shafi, Liaquat Ali Khan, Malik Ghulam Muhammad, Abdul Rab Nishtar, Mumtaz Doultana, Firoz Noon, Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, Sahibzada Yaqoob Ali Khan, Ayub Khan,Zia ulhaq ,Syed Ehsan, Nazir, all of them belonged to the cult of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.The policy of the government of Pakistan was not made by Jinnah but by Mirza Mahmood and the war in Kashmir was also started by the order and plan of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.
@aghawaseem3793 Your asking the wrong person
Very informative. Thanks.
Ghulam Muhammad became Governor general after Nazam UD Din who became prime Minister.
Entire subcontinent mainly the intellgensia of India and Pak is highly obliged to you Sir Ishtiaq.Sahib for unearthing such historical facts.
But, I, 86 yrs old Kashmiri who has suffered hugely due to this two-nation theory am receiving solitude with your successive historical events brought out for viewers.knowledge. My prayers for your healthy long life
AABAAD.
Sir, A request to do vlog on Mr. Jogendra Nath Mandal role in early Pakistan days and his resignation, and his return to India till his death.
Baigham Shah nawaz was a great lady ...
2:43 😂😂😂😂.... Ap hur video main yahi prove krny main lgy rehty ho ...idealogy of Pakistan...ghalut hy ...maybe ...but ap ki koshish ya honi chahiy k Pakistan jis maqsad k liy bna wo kaisy hasil ho skta hy ... Pakistan to ban gya ... Hum ny Pakistan k liy kya kiya ?? Hum haq k liy kabi ni othay ...jis terha bangali krty hein .... Hum khud hud haram hein aur kehty hein k Pakistan aur two nation theory hi ghalut hy ...oooohhh bhai pehly apny girehban main jhanko k hum kitny Pakistani aur kitny musalman hein ....
16:21 all is clear thank you, jinnah is my hero. Dont misintepret it please. Fatima kept quiet, His personel doctor makes it clear.
Sir ,a lecture on Bangladesh situation please
No sound
This lady apparently wanted Delhi to be part of Pakistan and regretted that the mughal culture which pakistan claims is left in hindustan....
یہ سوال جناب قائد سے علی گڑھ کے طلباء نے پوچھا تو آپ نے جواب دیا کہ ہمارا دستور تو تیرہ سو سال سے ہمارے پاس موجود ھے۔
قائد اعظم رحمت اللہ نے نو مسلم سکالر محمد پکٹل کی زیر صدارت ایک کمیٹی بنا دی تھی جو نوزائیدہ مملکت کیلئے قرآنی تعلیمات کے مطابق دستور کی سفارشات مرتب کریں۔ شاید ہر ہفتہ اس کی پروگریس بھی چیک کرتے تھے۔ غالباً سات میٹنگز بھی ہو چکی تھیں کہ قائد اعظم بیماری کی وجہ سے زیارت شفٹ ہو گئے ۔ مولانا مودودی کو بھی ریڈیو سے اسلامی نطام کے خدوخال واضح کرنے کیلئے تقاریر نشر کرنے کا قائداعظم رحمت اللہ علیہ نے کہا تھا۔
قائد کی بیماری کا بہانہ بنا کر کابینہ نے محمد پکٹل کا رابطہ منقطع کروا دیا۔ بالآخر وہ مایوس ہو کر پاکستان سے چلے گئے ۔ شاید پاکستان کا پہلا پاسپورٹ محمد پکٹل کا ہی بنا تھا۔
وہ علامہ محمد اسد تھے
سر یہاں آپ نے فرمایا کہ جناح نے دوھزار تیرہ کو مسلم لیگ جوائن کی ؟ یہ انیس سئو تیرہ تو نہیں ھے ؟ تصحیح کے لیئے عرض ھے شکریہ۔
IT IS AND IN THE VIDEO THIS WAS CORRECTED.
Thanks a lot Sir
Music backside very loud no need for that music Mazrat
Please remove the background score (music). It adds no value for the viewer.
Dr Shb, Kam se kam SARC ko jinda kr usme ye bahas ki jaa sakti hai ki es khittey ko kaise theek kiya jaay. If Pak takes interest then it can be done easily.
It is high time you stop your bull shit about our beloved Pakistan and our beloved leaders. You have already collected enough revenue to try to leave this world in peace.
That is right. Laikin iss bayghairat ko itna paisa aur zameer baichnay kay baad bhi na sharm aati hai aur na iska pait bharta hai.
Sir as far as I remember reading this book of Begum Shahnawaz then I had read that Jinnah wanted to model Pakistan's constitution on the French Constitution of 1945...had this been happened Pak wouldn't have been a majoritarian religious state.
I have the book, nothing of the sort is said there. Also, the French construction was a secular one.
@@Billumian47 Sir it is mentioned on page 201 of this book.... Here is excerpt:
"It was the same day that Mr Jinnah talked to me of a constitution for Pakistan. He told me that he had been working on a constitution for the last fifteen months and it was almost ready. He also said that he had based it more or less on the new French Constitution. I went all over New Delhi to get a copy of the French Constitution, but I could not find one."
Reference: Father & Daughter: A Political Autobiography, page 201
@@KnowledgeConcerningEverything THANK YOU, YOU HAVE RIGHTLY POINTED OUT THE PAGE. JINNAH WAS KNOWN TO SAY THINGS WITHOUT MEANING THEM.
As far as my knowledge, Mr Jinnah was Lawyer for property disputes . He seem to have no control over charting for destiny of newly born country he had fought for. Mr Jinnah lacked statesmanship.
This is also becouse he had fought in the name of Islam and as such he had no option to talk on Democracy and Secularism in constituent Assembly.
In fact in my opinion, two nation theory was not given by any Jinnah , Rahmat Ali,.......
Two nation theory was established about 1400 years back and this is in fact one of foundation of Islam. Two nations are defined as Musalman and non muslims(Kafirs).
I would like to know your take Sir 👏
@@govindgupta364
1400 years back ???
Were there any Muslims in those areas of bharath ??
Sir, A much awaited video for me being Pakistani Punjabi is "how Pakistani state impose Urdu language and genocide the regional languages especially Punjabi Language, Culture and Heritage in Pakistan!"
My father served as a senior civil servant with the newly formed Civil Service of Pakistan after partition. Our family migrated from Patiala. Growing up we used to hear a lot of stories from him about the chaotic nature of how the country was being run. There was no actual consensus as to a common National language as English had automatically been adopted as the main language of communication by the political elite and the bureaucracy. However there was a movement to promote Urdu by factions of the Muslim league as it was considered to be the language most widely spoken and understood by the Muslims of India and as a counter to India adopting Hindi as the main state language, adopting Urdu as the state language for Pakistan was considered to be a further validation of the two nation theory. The irony of course being that none of the major players and decision makers at the time were native Urdu speakers. Jinnah was a native Gujarati speaker although there is no record of him having ever made a single speech in that language. Liaquat Ali was from Haryana which was part of Punjab at the time. Nishtar was a pashtoon. Zafarullah was Punjabi. Suhrewardi, Fazlul Haq etc were Bengali. Almost the entire political elite at the time were not native Urdu speakers. Yet they all backed the decision as an extension of the two nation theory. Of course we saw the major backlash from the Bengalis when Jinnah made the announcement in Dhaka and then we had the language riots that were brutally suppressed. So a political decision which was also seen as a convenient necessity to gradually replace English and in theory to forge a common language of communication between the different ethnicities inhabiting the newly formed country. Of course this has come at great cost to the propagation of Punjabi but the only way to reverse that is to reject the two nation theory altogether
@@Rizvirambles I do agree there is no such thing like two Nation theory in the world, because we were the people who were living together more than 1000 years in the past so how's that possible that some day someone stood up and started chanting that Hindus and Muslims are the two Nations and they cannot live together peacefully!!
But as far as Urdu is the national language is concerned, before the partition they were also the suggestions by the students of Aligarh who were actually the main culprits who started the movement of Pakistan their mother tongue was Urdu and they started chanting that Urdu should be the national language of a newly born state, and I heard this from a historian that even that time Bengali politicians opposed this suggestion!
But for me being a Punjabi there is a huge regret for my community that how they became the front Man of Urdu language and We even eliminate Our Mother Tongue from Our Homes, not a single man at that time and even now who stand up against this unjust policy of Pakistan State, that Why Our Children are not studying Punjabi in their Syllabus, why Punjabi is not the official Language of Punjab?
KISSI WAQAT PLEASE ISLAMIC STATE AUR MUSLIM STATE PAR B BAAT KREIN KAYUN K JINNAH SAHIB MUSLIMS IN INDIA K LIYE SIASI AUR MUAASHI RIGHTS KI WAKALAT KARTAY THAY
Bas aap sach bolte rahiye ham aapko support karte rahenge.
Apne channel par koi agenda na chalne dein bas.
Zahir hai, yeh jub tuk Pakistan aur iskay founder kay khilaf jhoot bolta rahayga, yeh tumhara hero bana rahaiga aur jis din iss nay India, iskay leaders aur Hindus kay khilaaf bolna aur sabit kerna shuru kia ussi din tum loge apnay iss aaj kay hero ko paagal aur jhoota kehna shuru ker do gay.
Sir. 2013, nahi, 1913 mein join ki.
Yes, it was a slip of tongue.
Just slip of tongue.
AREY DIKRA 🐣 JINNAH IS DEAD 💀 AND BURIED A LONG TIME AGO ‼️ PLEASE 🙏 STOP ✋ THE POST MORTEM ☠️ AND START MOVING FAST FORWARD ⏩
Laikin yeh khoosat dikra aisa kabhi naheen karega keun keh yeh sirf wohi jhoot phailaata hai jiski ijaazat isak indian masters daitay hain.
What about zimmis declared in the early days of Islam forced to pay some tax being Non Muslims?
sir, is it true that kamal ataturk didn't want to meet jinna
Ha said that he would not even piss on the fake muslims of the Indian subcontinent. He warned in private about the rabid radicalism prevalent among the Indian Muslim and did not want Turks to be associated with them. He felt that Indian Muslims were dirty, stinking, and unworthy.
O' Bhai Pakistan and Jinah hater. Pahlay India mein toilets to bana lay. Jagah jagah, sarkon per, patrion per shuru ho jaatay ho aur sari dunia mein badboo aur beemari phailaatay ho. besides, do you still remember what Churchil said about Gandhi?
Not 2013, 1913 please
You have written many books on the early years of Pakistan and you should know that Shah Din, Begum Shah Nawaz, Muhammad Shafi, Liaquat Ali Khan, Malik Ghulam Muhammad, Abdul Rab Nishtar, Mumtaz Doultana, Firoz Noon, Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, Sahibzada Yaqoob Ali Khan, Ayub Khan,Zia ulhaq ,Syed Ehsan, Nazir, all of them belonged to the cult of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.The policy of the government of Pakistan was not made by Jinnah but by Mirza Mahmood and the war in Kashmir was also started by the order and plan of Mirza Mahmood Ahmad.
Who was Mirza Mahmood Ahmad?
Sir, could you please upload this video again without background music? Big fan of your work and knowledge!
After watching Your So Many Videos about Pakistan I can Say Pakistan Own By Milatry They Need Constant Conflict with India To Remain in Power once Pakistan Milatry Gown from Power then Your And Mine Dream Peaceful relationship ind pak can Be True
Never. It is your lack of knowledge about the politicians of Pakistan and peoples of Pakistan. All the politicians from Jinnah sahib to present P.M. Shabaz Sharif including Imran Khan Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Mademe Banazir Bhutto F.M. Bilawal Bhutto Liaquat Ali Khan all are 8increase hate sentiments against Hindu nation and India . The normal not good relations between Pakistan and India are possible.
Sir,mein koshish karata hun ki mein aapki speech puri dekhun,aur dekhata bhi hun,aapse gyat hota hai ki aek jamin ko do hisson mein baantane wala aur lakhon logon ko marvane vala asali villain kaun tha 😒😒😒. Aek hi to DNA hum donon deshon ke logon ka hai,hum donon ke purvaj muslim nahin hindu hi the,bas kuchh majburiyon ne hamein alag kiya,yah sabhi bharatiya hindu jante hain.😌🙏
BHAI, TWO NATION THEORY DONO HINDUO AUR MUSALMANO MEI USS KE SUPPORTER THAY MAGAR JINNAH SAHIB NE USAY POLITICALLY ISTIMAL KIYA AUR ANGRAZO NE UNHE PAKISTAN DIA.
@@Billumian47 sir,angrejon ne jaan bujhakar separate nation apne fayde ke lie banaye,jab unki mali halat thik ho jayenge to ve ham fir kabbja kar lenge,lekin hamari kismat thik thi jinko Neharu ji jaise neta mile,ho sakata hai agar jinaah bimar na hokar na marate tab paakistaan ki jo haalat aaj hai,shayad tashveer alag hi hoti,mere hisab se ve kattar panthi muslim nahi the,baki aap vidvyan hain unhein aap behatar unhein samajhte hain 😌🙏
Hindu aur Muslim mn ek bareek sa faraq hai k Hindu gaomata ke pooja krta aur muslim os ko kha jaata hai, iss problem ka koi solution ho toh bta dena
What is your real point of view? Instead of giving arguements from unverifiable incidents occured during last many decades gavind different context. Please eleborate what do you want?
You must know what this Indian agent up to, wants and assigned for.
Istiaq ji,
Would you like to tell us why the Indian Muslims not be treated like the second largest majority instead of minority? You don't think that the demand for Indian muslims to be treated like minority is a fraud and injustice against real minorities? Why was there no minority status for Hindus in J&K even during the so-called pious jihadi rule of Congress, NC, and PDP? Islamists are responsible for the division of Indian motherland, Indian society, Indian identity, and Indian culture. Islam has not played any positive role in the Indian sub continent. Now, don't tell me that they built Taj Mahal and Qutub Minar.
LIAQAT ALI KHAN AUR USS K HUM NAWAON KO MANA JAI TO JINNAH SE BARA JOUTA INDIAN SUBCONTINENT MEIN NAHEIN THA JISS NEIN BANGAAL SINDH K DULLITS AUR PUNJAB K CHRISTIAN K SAATH ITNA MUDALAL JOUT BOLA K WO SUB MUSLIM LEAGUE K SUPPORTER BUNN GAI
Very informative , thank you Sir.