Arundhati Roy With Howard Zinn Conversation18 September 2002

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 60

  • @Analysis_Paralysis
    @Analysis_Paralysis 4 місяці тому +5

    It's a pleasure to listen to two people who don't have inflated egos! This is a REAL conversation...

  • @reubenjoseph7228
    @reubenjoseph7228 4 роки тому +93

    Anybody watching during Corona pandemic and wondering how some of the things she has said is manifesting right now

  • @azadrasheed497
    @azadrasheed497 4 роки тому +30

    She's more,much more than an Indian Goddess.Love her books, essays,.Humanity runs in her views.She is the voice of sane, beautiful India..

  • @bethsanchezyoga55
    @bethsanchezyoga55 6 років тому +48

    Indian Goddess, thank you for appearing in these troubling times.

  • @MrRahul00710
    @MrRahul00710 3 роки тому +51

    Man I should have seen this video back then , I regret for casting my vote for such hate in 2014, this regret will stay forever

    • @sapandream
      @sapandream 3 роки тому +1

      Buddy don't worry you are not alone, u cast vote for them, I, at a very young age (around 13/14 years old) overwhelmingly said "oh our BJP own the election, of course thats due to ATAL BIHARI BAJAPAYEE JU. but still 🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️☹️

    • @JohnDoe-zj6xf
      @JohnDoe-zj6xf Рік тому

      What's the use of you being regretful, it's not the swing votes, it's the majority which has been indoctrinated to hate. It won't just go away. Radicalisation is permanent and it's here to stay in India.

  • @orupavam2010
    @orupavam2010 9 років тому +17

    Dear Arundhati..I am watching this video in 2015 and it is still very very relevent !! Proud of you!

  • @ParthibanTR
    @ParthibanTR 10 років тому +22

    I just completed 41 and I am very deeply realizing that "in India it is so much complicated that the longer I live here, the more confused I'm going to be" and die one day without accomplishing anything. Strangely, Arundhati is also 41 when she is saying it. Everything everything is so much screwed up here from education to politics to entertainment to family to dwelling... My original academic achievement documents are held up with an institution since 2005 and I'm writing and writing to people in the Parliament, to NAAC, to AICTE, to the University but all are like dead people sitting. This video is special to me because of Arundhati's narration about the girl's fear and perception and thereafter the learning, who is unprotected by a nuclear family. Salutes to your spirit to survive.

    • @Nexus-7.0
      @Nexus-7.0 10 років тому +1

      Yes, on top of what you said, I do believe there are also some strange social problems in India even in the 21st century. The Dalits are still being vehemently discriminated and God knows how many women are actually *raped* everyday over there? I really don't wanna know because I might just have a mental breakdown ..
      Many people *if not all*, including many of the govt. officials and politicians do not have any *civic sense* at all!
      I still don't understand why the Indian govt. doesn't want to extend a peaceful hand to the Maoists to discuss their needs and demands? Sit down and reason out the differences in a hope to put a final end to the very long conflict. Has that ever happened? Don't the Tribal people of India deserve the utmost respect because they are also connected to India and have roots going for thousands of years? It is high time that the Indian govt. does something *constructive* in handling the Maoist situation. Though I left India a looong time ago the human rights abuses, corruption and violent rapes are certainly getting the attention of the western world.

  • @idreeskanth7370
    @idreeskanth7370 8 років тому +16

    Howard was just a wonderful human being!

  • @vision_111
    @vision_111 4 місяці тому +2

    This is june 2024, and i have voted for bjp since 2014 to 2022, And i can confirm that each of the word she says, each of her worries, and assumptions about our country is 110% correct. Poison is in veins of our people as they are now bluntly voting for RSS not just BJP.
    She is a gem. People of RSS and BJP put UAPA on a person like her for a comment made 14 years back on Kashmir in 2010 in UPA's government when the situations were completely different and still are not very good as there are 3 terrorist attack in kashmir in last 1 month.
    She should be honoured but It's shameful and ridiculous for us Indians that the mind like her is faced by hate. People like her born in a century. She must be celebrated by people of our country not jailed.
    There are resons why a lot of Indians give up citizenship in India and leave for another democracy for good life.
    Ese kese bnega re viswguru... From Mother of democracy to motherhucker of democracy.. India is pleading inside.
    🇮🇳

  • @PetadeAztlan
    @PetadeAztlan 12 років тому +10

    Heavy insights by our beloved Brother Zinn about the U.S. middle class and our actually being in a class society.
    I love her closing comments. Extract: To love. To be loved. To never forget your own insignificance... To seek joy in the saddest places. To pursue beauty to its lair. To never simplify what is complicated or complicate what is simple. To respect strength, never power. Above all, to watch. To try and understand. To never look away. And never, never, to forget. ~
    @Peta_de_Aztlan

  • @sagahammer
    @sagahammer 5 років тому +9

    What a lovely woman.

  • @1llanfairbairn
    @1llanfairbairn 11 років тому +20

    lady you're lovely... don't ever be quiet

  • @subhransumohanty5382
    @subhransumohanty5382 Рік тому +1

    Respected viewers, I read all your commss with due attaintion, but My opinion is different. No doubt, she has become a renowed writter, thinker and speaker. But when I gone through her mind set deeply, I

  • @rodericklee4753
    @rodericklee4753 9 років тому +13

    She is one of a kind ...

  • @abhishekpaul9427
    @abhishekpaul9427 3 роки тому +4

    Legend arundati Roy..

  • @shivendradhanush3778
    @shivendradhanush3778 3 роки тому +3

    Fucking hell this was 2002😲

  • @ParthibanTR
    @ParthibanTR 10 років тому +14

    The protected cannot see, imagine, experience, live, enjoy, battle, defeat, lose, love, hate, talk, or create more than what the unprotected can.

  • @rajamadhu1118
    @rajamadhu1118 4 роки тому +8

    Beautiful Woman😍😎

  • @lalitganvir3336
    @lalitganvir3336 5 років тому +6

    You are great Arundhati i love you.

  • @friendlyfriend793
    @friendlyfriend793 8 років тому +8

    what a woman ! can i have a coffee please !!!

  • @Sandeepdhauni
    @Sandeepdhauni 2 роки тому +1

    Pyar ho gya h ❤️

  • @alohagrace2225
    @alohagrace2225 2 роки тому

    🔥💜🔥

  • @1828tolstoy
    @1828tolstoy 4 роки тому +3

    One of the great men of our time.

    • @sarahdeshay1394
      @sarahdeshay1394 4 роки тому

      M Tolstoy a man who devoted his entire life to standing up for the underdog and teaching the youth. What is more noble than that?

  • @enockfumbuka6843
    @enockfumbuka6843 10 років тому +7

    THE LAD IS FIGHTING THE BULL BY THE HORNS SHE IS A FEAR LESS WOMAN I HAVE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE.MAY SHE IS NOT AFRAID OF THE BULLETS WHICH KILLED THE GANDHIS ;BRAVO KEEP IT LADY SHE WILL SAVE HUMANITY !

  • @gopaalpande7167
    @gopaalpande7167 5 років тому +6

    Sometime talk about Pranoy roy, and his illgotten money

  • @mazumdar2379
    @mazumdar2379 11 місяців тому

    ওকে

  • @rastapandaz
    @rastapandaz 4 роки тому +2

    Anyone know the book she's quoting from???

  • @basudevchakraborty9750
    @basudevchakraborty9750 2 роки тому +1

    Why the number of dislikes is not showing?

  • @mohitmohlia8420
    @mohitmohlia8420 Рік тому

    watching this when BJP won election 6th time in gujrat

  • @rodericklee4753
    @rodericklee4753 9 років тому +1

    She is

    • @ShailendraSINGH-jk2ev
      @ShailendraSINGH-jk2ev 5 років тому

      So USA UK Europe are such marvelous countries...YOU reckons ...MIND my grammar

  • @Somegowdru
    @Somegowdru 3 роки тому

    Someone spreading false news about Indian modern Mahathma selfmade God Mr. Modiji 😄

  • @piyushkumar4338
    @piyushkumar4338 9 років тому +5

    I used to be big fan of aArundhati but then i realised that she has a very unidirectional way of thinking ......I mean she is right or may be right but she do not understand the views which is not hers....thats create problem as she keeps on collecting only those things in societies which are evil or she finds evils without any scope for new things to come in. After all she is a reformer in real sense as she criticizes the practices of the same society in which she was born and that what reformers do .

  • @mukhtarahmad5735
    @mukhtarahmad5735 4 роки тому

    Zin does not like Arundhati.But he can't say so directly .so small jibes here & there.C E M joad on democracy is still relevant.

    • @azadrasheed497
      @azadrasheed497 4 роки тому +5

      Mukhtar Ahamed.I disagree. Howard Zinn shows lov & respect for Arundhati & India.Anyway she is a credit to India.Howard Zinn credit to USA.

  • @MalvinderKaur-e7x
    @MalvinderKaur-e7x Місяць тому

    just one mediocre book written going on and on about that is wonder in itself. 'in which annie gives it to those ones"

  • @hasaneurope4603
    @hasaneurope4603 2 роки тому

    🙏