classical singer reacts & analyses: PIANO MAN - FORESTELLA (포레스텔라)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 187

  • @SirHairless
    @SirHairless  2 місяці тому +61

    Super strict copyright with this one - you can find the unfiltered version on my Patreon: www.patreon.com/posts/forestella-piano-111289106
    If you like Korean artists, check out this reaction next ua-cam.com/video/BiLFg7jEpv0/v-deo.html

    • @Eedey
      @Eedey 2 місяці тому +10

      Woorim is doing his military duty .

    • @silviagallia9953
      @silviagallia9953 2 місяці тому +1

      Hey man, I understood your sensitivity in terms of music that’s why I would like to suggest you The tale of Jenny and Screetch (full) by Ren. I think you gonna love it. These songs plus Hi Ren are really amazing.

    • @jimchallender4616
      @jimchallender4616 2 місяці тому +1

      Your analysis is exceptional. I usually enjoy reactions, but yours is a thorough well-done analysis, I actually learned a few things. Well Done!! Thanks

  • @adriaries68
    @adriaries68 2 місяці тому +60

    Estimado Hairless ,Yessss es Worimi !!!el grabo partes del bajo y se nota mas en el estribillo y al final !!!Su voz es unica !!gracias x reaccionar a Forestella!!!!Sabemos q grabo su parte en las 2 semanas q tuvo de vacaciones del Servicio Militar !!❤❤❤

  • @NadineShon-lz8km
    @NadineShon-lz8km 2 місяці тому +53

    Loved your analysis! Forestella holds the unique record of most consecutive wins on the Immortal Songs2 King of Kings special in this show's history. They were special guests on this show instead of contestants. Loved the nostalgic feel to their interpretation. The audience looked thrilled to see Forestella back even without Woorim.
    Toward the end there was a little of Ko Woorim in the backing tract. I think the applause was the audience reaction as they recognized Woorim’s voice. Looking forward to his return- 9 months to go!
    I would be interested in your reaction to Kang HyungHo’s solo performance of Phantom of the Opera on Immortal Songs 240720

    • @3173alejandramartz
      @3173alejandramartz 2 місяці тому +12

      They have so many records in this show. Such an incredible team.

  • @김영은-v8r
    @김영은-v8r 2 місяці тому +23

    와~~~어떻게 딱 듣자말자 이런해석을 해석을하시는지... 진짜 놀라워요 😂다른 음악분석가들가는 레벨자체가 틀려요!!!
    포레스텔라분들이 꼭 이 채널을 봤으면 좋겠어요
    포레 음악 감사평 정말 감사합니다 ❤❤❤

  • @anjelikashaximardanova
    @anjelikashaximardanova 2 місяці тому +20

    Sir Hairless! Как же приятно слушать Вас! Какой Вы обаятельный! Отличный анализ и реакция! Столько деталей, столько акцентов, загляденье! Настолько здорово раскрываете тему, что вопросов вообще не остаётся!
    Forestella конечно красавчики, но в этой реакции я заслушалась Вами! Вы лучший! 🫶

  • @infinite1ification
    @infinite1ification 2 місяці тому +27

    I was in tears when I heard Woorim’s bass voice at the end!
    I miss him so much😢

  • @사라야게따
    @사라야게따 2 місяці тому +79

    배두훈은 뮤지컬 배우를, 조민규는 성악가를, 강형호는 록커를~
    각각의 예술가들을 존경하는 의미의 의상과 음악을 보여줍니다.😊

  • @lelysparra484
    @lelysparra484 2 місяці тому +71

    Woorim aún está en el servicio militar, por eso no aparece allí, sin embargo, al final se escucha su voz pre-grabada. #Forestella🌳✨ los mejores, Los amo ❤️🎵🎶🇻🇪💕🇰🇷

  • @Liz-w2d
    @Liz-w2d 2 місяці тому +28

    Great reaction as always. Wonderful performance and it was great and fitting to hear Woorim’s voice. He needed to be there one way or another. This was a celebratory performance since they have won King of Kings 6 times and still hold the record. I thought it was fantastic how they embraced their different styles right down to the clothes. You have Mingyu the classic band leader, Doohoon the musical actor and Hyungho the rocker. It is the uniqueness of the 4 members that makes Forestella the best and add their individual amazing talents and vocal ranges and you get the best quartet around.
    I’m curious about Hyungho’s last note he hit at the very end. It sounds like it’s way up there.
    Keep reacting to Forestella. I love your analysis ❤

  • @JulieGarozzo
    @JulieGarozzo 2 місяці тому +9

    Thank you for your analysis of this new Forestella song so full of surprises including Ko Woo Rim’s voice at the end. Can’t wait for your next one.

  • @11716musicny
    @11716musicny 2 місяці тому +52

    Love your reviews. Love Forestella

  • @joyrobinson4585
    @joyrobinson4585 2 місяці тому +22

    I really enjoy the music of Forestella. Gorgeous harmonies in Piano Man as in all their work even with Ko Woorim missing this time. Thanks for this.

  • @delitrejo2338
    @delitrejo2338 2 місяці тому +62

    #Forestella son increíbles la forma en que interpretaron esta hermosa canción fue sublime!! La firma en que mostraron tres géneros musicales diferentes en una sola canción fue increíble para después fusionarse en una sola ❤❤❤ La música Rock de #KangHyungHo , Lo Clásico de #ChoMinGyu y La Balada Romántica y teatro musical de #BaeDooHoon fue impresionante!! Los tres con estilos diferentes fusionándose como uno solo y de fondo la gran voz de #KoWooRim fue tan emocionante que nos sacó las lágrimas lo esperamos el próximo año de regreso 🥰!! Forestella Rey de Reyes ayer, hoy y siempre!! Saludos desde México 🇲🇽🥰

    • @3173alejandramartz
      @3173alejandramartz 2 місяці тому +11

      Ellos son la esencia del crossover hecha persona.

    • @luzandreaestrada6869
      @luzandreaestrada6869 2 місяці тому +5

      Totalmente de acuerdo contigo son los mejores y como dices siempre rey de reyes 🥰🥰🥰🇲🇽❤️🇰🇷

    • @delitrejo2338
      @delitrejo2338 2 місяці тому +2

      Si son Master of Masters ❤❤❤❤

  • @ruthgaete7790
    @ruthgaete7790 2 місяці тому +29

    Gracias por tu reacción ❤ 🌳☘️🌿🍃 Forestella⭐️🌟☀️🌞los mejores del mundo❤❤❤❤ admiración total desde Chile🇨🇱🇨🇱🇨🇱🇨🇱

  • @patricialopez-kt9gg
    @patricialopez-kt9gg 2 місяці тому +32

    Gracias por reaccionar a Forestella!!! Como siempre muy interesantes tus comentarios 🇦🇷 ❤❤❤❤

  • @JanHiner-xx4uy
    @JanHiner-xx4uy 2 місяці тому +27

    Love Sir Hairless's reaction to this performance!! They are great as usual even without the bass singer away at military service.

  • @mariachaverri7607
    @mariachaverri7607 2 місяці тому +43

    Amazing as always Forestella ❤❤🎉🎉

  • @bortexo
    @bortexo 2 місяці тому +30

    Tem uma apresentação mais recente do Kang Hyung Ho cantando a música fantasma da ópera.Muito bom também ❤

  • @natalyaemeleva5675
    @natalyaemeleva5675 2 місяці тому +34

    Ура! Значит я правильно услышала минусовку басса.
    У вас всегда подробная и прекрасная реакция❤

  • @juliachoi1458
    @juliachoi1458 2 місяці тому +17

    Forestella is amazing always!!!! 🌠🌌🎼🎵🎶🎻🎹📻🌸💮🏵🌹🌺🌻🌼🌷💐💐💐👍👍👍👍💓💞💜💙💚🧡❤

  • @venetta-sh7su
    @venetta-sh7su 2 місяці тому +26

    Sir Hairless! What a surprise this review is of a brand new release! 🤩😃 And only 3 Forestellas but that's conscription for you! I had never heard of them before I saw them on your channel. Thank you Sir H for the introductions, education and for yet another amazing reaction and analysis!! 👏 👏👏👌👌👌🙏🙏🙏

  • @smallmoments957
    @smallmoments957 2 місяці тому +28

    Wow! That was beautiful! I like when you do recent videos, it is always a nice surprise. Great r/a, and as always, thank you!

  • @LuzContreras-z3e
    @LuzContreras-z3e 2 місяці тому +42

    Como siempre muchísimas gracias por tu completo análisis, me encanta como puedes ver y escuchar detalles que ningún otro reactor ve. Sí!!! #kowoorim cantó con su maravillosa voz para esta canción una.preciosa sorpresa para sus fans❤ nos emocionamos y sorpendimos. El concepto de era la música en diferentes épocas por eso #baedoohoon un showman. #chomingyu época medieval y nuestro hermoso rockero #kanhyunho #pitta tiempo moderno. Espectaculares como siempre, versatiles como nadie, únicos para el planeta❤

  • @clover3k
    @clover3k 2 місяці тому +12

    I enjoyed the Forestella reaction today as well.
    Yes, they are trio for a while. But in this performance they were quartet. They brought woorim's voice through prerecording ❤
    "Immotal Song 2" is a program where junior singers cover the songs of legendary senior singers to determine the winner. And the winners who are selected every week gather to play the king of kings twice a year.
    Forrestella is a team that participated in the King of Kings eight times and won six times, and showed this "Piano man" performance in the first half of 2024 as an invited singer before the ceremony.

  • @j.f.3342
    @j.f.3342 2 місяці тому +24

    Regarding your comment regarding the conscious use of different types of singing styles by the individual members: It is actually one of FORESTELLA's INTENTIONS to further dissolve the boundaries between the different "classes" of music even more. They are known to have very different musical backgrounds and different musical preferences, which also applies to their fans. In order to keep everyone as happy as possible, they (originally a classical crossover vocal group) changed agencies in 2021 and decided to include more contemporary music in their repertoire. There are many classical crossover groups, but FORESTELLA is an exception here. Unlike other "classical" crossover groups that add rock/pop elements to classical arrangements but remain in the classical genre, FORESTELLA takes a different path. Thanks to their extremely adaptable voices and talents, they are able to shine in any genre. Starting from a wide variety of contemporary music, especially pop and rock, they mix a wide variety of genres and styles in often unusual ways. Both in terms of the choice of instruments, the conscious use of classical singing techniques and the clearly accentuated use of classical vocals. (Which is still considered a "no go" in pop and sometimes sounds a little unusual to some). But as you have already said: IT WORKS and the number of international fans from all areas of music is constantly increasing.

    • @manaciel
      @manaciel 2 місяці тому +3

      Well said! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

    • @ninalopesbrasil
      @ninalopesbrasil 2 місяці тому +2

      👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

  • @janetlawson4482
    @janetlawson4482 2 місяці тому +4

    Beautiful rendition of Piano Man, a song that will always remind me of home, nostalgia eastern Long Island. I always thoroughly enjoy your Forestella reactions, I love their musicality.

  • @nilviacastro8576
    @nilviacastro8576 2 місяці тому +7

    Es Woorim....!!!! Lo extrañamos.... queda poco.... paciencia.. espero que hagan un gran concierto en línea como bienvenida. Gracias por tu reacción. Saludos desde Chile 🇨🇱. En este lejano país también amamos a Forestella ❤❤❤❤

  • @juheelee8645
    @juheelee8645 2 місяці тому +40

    섬세하고 전문적인 리엑션 감사합니다
    덕분에 노래에 대해 더 정확하게 이해하게되었어요
    이번에 포레스텔라가 커버한 곡은 많은 정성과 노력이 들어간 노래였네요

  • @CrzyJen
    @CrzyJen 2 місяці тому +71

    Woorim is there in spirit, since they have recorded him for background vocals. (Yes, that’s him in the backing track)
    They each are representing different musical eras, their clothes, their backgrounds, their dancers… Hyungho has the Elvis outfit with the rock band, classic 50’s rock background and the modern street dancers, Mingyu has the ‘Prince Eric’ outfit with the stained glass and strings behind him and the dinner party waltzers, Doohoon has the elegant suit next to the piano with the newsies dancers. They definitely had a lot of fun with the visuals here.
    Mingyu’s “Doll” like look is most definitely his classical training coming to the front (although he no longer considers himself an Opera singer/vocalist, the training remains).
    I love that we get to hear so much more of Doohoon’s Baritone sound with Woorim gone, but I still think we will all be happiest when Woorim is back with them. Mingyu even goes on to say how much he misses Woorim (while tearing up) in the short interview they do after the performance.
    They were given high praise before this performance, as this is the intro to the “King of Kings” special episode of the Immortal Songs contest and Forestella currently hold the record for most consecutive wins in the show’s history. They truly are Immortal Song’s “King of Kings”. ❤🌲💫

    • @AinurErkman
      @AinurErkman 2 місяці тому +7

      Спасибо за чудесный комментарий ❤

  • @tedkim5771
    @tedkim5771 2 місяці тому +23

    Amazing

  • @María-f4j9z
    @María-f4j9z 2 місяці тому +21

    Hola, la voz de Woo Rim aparece en varios momentos pregrabada!!! Fue una hermosa sorpresa poder escucharlos a los 4 juntos!!!

  • @Maria...-mo5qm
    @Maria...-mo5qm 2 місяці тому +7

    I like a lot the original version of this iconic classic and also enjoyed this nice rendition by Forestella - these guys are so talented! This was a great reaction/analysis of a ‘fresh and cool’ material; thanks Sir Hairless - you’re also very talented!☺

  • @Liz-w2d
    @Liz-w2d 2 місяці тому +69

    I forgot to also mention that luckily Woorim was able to get into the military band unit. So he is still singing all the time. We’ve been able to see some performances. ❤

    • @3173alejandramartz
      @3173alejandramartz 2 місяці тому +13

      I think that only him could make so many people of different countries interested in military acts of South Korea😅

    • @ninalopesbrasil
      @ninalopesbrasil 2 місяці тому +4

      @@3173alejandramartz that’s true 🤣🤣🤣 I’m Brazilian and never being so interested on what is going on on military in there or on where I’m living now, but I’m paying close attention on what’s going on on South Korean Military Band these days and watching every single video! It sounds crazy to say it 🤣🤣🤣

    • @3173alejandramartz
      @3173alejandramartz 2 місяці тому +2

      @@ninalopesbrasil IKR? 😆
      I'm from Argentina. It's so weird, but I'm watching a lot of formal acts about things that I really don't know much about just for him. Only Woo-rim 😅😅😅

    • @ninalopesbrasil
      @ninalopesbrasil 2 місяці тому +3

      @@3173alejandramartz yeah! That’s it! 🧸🥰
      Greetings Alejandra 😊👋🏽

    • @hildommar
      @hildommar 2 місяці тому +2

      Yep, ❤ he’s almost like their poster boy for K-Military 😅❤Even in Korea more of his fellow citizens discovered him at some of the military band events and now he is helping with services for recruiting and answering questions for new recruits together with PS season 4 winner Libelante’s leader, Kim Jihoon.

  • @CrzyJen
    @CrzyJen 2 місяці тому +16

    BTW… you KNOW how happy I am that you are back with a Forestella video. It’s what brought me to your channel and it’s what had me sign up for your patreon. You + Forestella = 100% WIN

    • @SirHairless
      @SirHairless  2 місяці тому +3

      Wooo thank you!!

    • @SirHairless
      @SirHairless  2 місяці тому +4

      Make sure you watch the unfiltered version over on Patreon 🎬

  • @sabryc808
    @sabryc808 2 місяці тому +14

    Thank you for this reaction. I love this song from forestella : If I leave, hijo della luna, legend never die, shape of you, bad romance, a moonlight night of Silla, we are the Champions, Bohemian Rhapsody, show must go on

  • @bortexo
    @bortexo 2 місяці тому +22

    É muito bom ouvir suas análises musicais, são muito ricas e me faz ver a música de uma outra maneira e com detalhes que não percebi antes e é melhor ainda quando e Forestella cantando.
    Saudações do Brasil ❤
    Melhor

  • @AinurErkman
    @AinurErkman 2 місяці тому +17

    Всегда с нетерпеньем жду ваш анализ к выступлениям Форестеллы🎉 Надеюсь, следующий тоже не за горами. Очень хочется посмотреть вашу реакцию на песни A STORY SADDER THEN SADNESS, MAMA(EXO) и другие. Спасибо🫶

  • @yunsoochoi8893
    @yunsoochoi8893 2 місяці тому +7

    Hi, nice to meet you!
    I am so happy to be able to meet Forestella through you.
    You always make us so, so happy.
    Thank you so much~^
    ❤🧡💛💚💙💜🤎

  • @terrycupp6687
    @terrycupp6687 2 місяці тому +18

    Watched this on your Patreon page unfiltered, it’s always nice to see the performers because their bodily movements typically reflect their vocals in some way. I grew up with Billy Joel, he is such a brilliant songwriter and performer. I loved the counter tenor’s vocal tone, it actually reminds me quite a bit of Mitch Grassi’s tone, light, but with roundness, body and clarity although I think his vibrato is generally faster than Mitch’s. Still, I hear a lot of similarity in their voices. All in all, a well-balanced performance by all 3 singers, lots of dynamics which helped keep the piece interesting. Enjoyed your breakdown as usual 😊

  • @SilvanadeLima1961
    @SilvanadeLima1961 2 місяці тому +34

    Excelente análisis as ever! Woorim también aparece pregrabado, para deleite nuestro🎉. Hermosa versión de una canción imprescindible!

  • @Mariacastillo-ms1mn
    @Mariacastillo-ms1mn 2 місяці тому +20

    Gracias por tus reacciones a forestella ❤. Ellos son geniales y realmente hacer armonías extraordinarias. La voz del bajo que se escucha si es la voz de woorim que grabo porque no puede presentarse físicamente con forestella porquevesta cumpliendo su servicio militar que en Corea es obligatorio. Woorin regresara en 9 meses más y los escucharemos al fin a los 4 juntos nuevamente ❤

  • @LuzContreras-z3e
    @LuzContreras-z3e 2 місяці тому +6

    Yo que soy de la nueva generación me quedo con esta hermosa versión, fresca con arreglos rockeros y armonias exquisitas, #forestella planteó la idea de cantarla y representarla en 3 estilos musicales siglo XVI #chomingyu, música contemporánea showman #baedoohoon y rock #kanghyunho, #kowoorim está cumpliendo con su servicio militar pero vuelve en mayo 2025, FORESTELLA fue invitado de honor de INMORTAL SONGS por ser los actuales REY de REYES incluyeron la voz de woorim pregrabada cuando estuvo de vacaciones 2 semanas del ejército y asi hacerlo presente en la actuación, fue mágico y una sorpresa que tenian para todas sus fans, un detalle maravilloso, gravias SIR por este lindo análisis como siempre me encantas y re espero siempre con #forestella ❤ saludos desde chile 🇨🇱💕🎸🎻🎹🎤

  • @행복배달인쑥쌤
    @행복배달인쑥쌤 2 місяці тому +47

    우림이가 비록 군대에 있지만 우리는 그의 자리를 느낄 수 있습니다
    그는 지금 여기 이 노래에 함께 하고 있거든요😊

  • @karannewton3481
    @karannewton3481 2 місяці тому +8

    Wow! One of my favorites from Billy Joel. They did it justice. Thanks for sharing this with us.

  • @susanleigh7618
    @susanleigh7618 2 місяці тому +27

    Beautiful as always. Forestella is the best. I could also hear Woorim at the end. Perfect!!

  • @정례유-r8u
    @정례유-r8u 2 місяці тому +33

    구독했습니다 당신의 리액션이 참 마음에 듭니다.

  • @elliehart-2point0
    @elliehart-2point0 2 місяці тому +60

    As the three singers take solo melody turns, it's easy to hear what background skill each has: musical theatre (Dohoon), opera (Mingyu), and rock (Hyungho). Then they switch it up!

  • @maryjohn3807
    @maryjohn3807 2 місяці тому +25

    Thank you Sir Hairless for reacting to this latest cover of Forestella! I was one of the people who made the suggestion. I did not think that you would get to it so quickly. So happy you did! And I loved it. The joy on your face as you watched was so great to see. You observe things most others don’t and we love to hear it. Thank you for breaking it all down for us. 👏👏
    Your questions on the background vocals, Woorim and the program they performed in, seem to have been answered in the comments!
    The song has such a good feel to it and with the Forestella voices, it’s just ethereal! Looking forward to your next Forestella reaction. As you have read in the comments, there are a lot of people who love your Forestella reactions. Hoping we won’t have to wait too long.

    • @SirHairless
      @SirHairless  2 місяці тому +6

      It was your comment on my August ratings video that prompted me - thanks

    • @maryjohn3807
      @maryjohn3807 2 місяці тому +5

      @@SirHairless Thank you!

  • @mori-g2c
    @mori-g2c 2 місяці тому +9

    여러 리액션을 봤지만 정말 우아하고 고급스러우며 전문적인 리액션에 감탄합니다. 감사합니다. 포레스텔라 리액션을 기대합니다.

  • @11716musicny
    @11716musicny 2 місяці тому +58

    Yes woorims voice

  • @산호-q5x
    @산호-q5x 2 місяці тому +29

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @Bearlover1995
    @Bearlover1995 2 місяці тому +26

    Gosh, I LOVE your reviews. Yes, it is simply AMAZING how they MAKE those intricate notes work. Different voice types, but stunning timbres and vibratos. Voice and breath control, dynamics, unexpected change of key, so good. Such a pleasure to listen to Forestella. Actually, it's a luxury. They are truly vocal acrobats. Oh, you said it all and I agree with you. A few months ago I said that they remind me of Bach, especially when I listen to 'Air on a g string'. Thanks for your reaction. ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @marie-joseepaulzak1936
    @marie-joseepaulzak1936 2 місяці тому +7

    It was definitely Ko Woorim where you heard him, quite certainly pre recorded, as he is currently serving his military service until May 2025. His voice is unmistakable!

  • @miryeongk
    @miryeongk 2 місяці тому +39

    Thank you @SirHairless for reviewing this video! The Korean verbiage you see in the beginning which is typical in live performances are attributions to the artist and featured musicians (in this case, dance team, guitar soloist, grand pianist, etc.). You are right that there was no live harmonica. The pre-recorded bass you're hearing is in fact Koh Woo Rim who has been absent for the past year due to his mandatory military service (South Korea still has conscription since they're still technically at war). The other members who are much older have already fulfilled their active military duty and have continued in the interim as a trio.

    • @SirHairless
      @SirHairless  2 місяці тому +13

      Amazing, thanks for clarifying!

  • @여행가-p3r
    @여행가-p3r 2 місяці тому +17

    전문적이고 자세한 분석 감사합니다~❤❤❤

  • @miryeongk
    @miryeongk 2 місяці тому +19

    @SirHairLess: Please consider reviewing "Bad Romance" in October since they performed this song based on a Halloween theme. For the holiday season, they also performed a live rendition of "Greensleeves" in partnership with an art museum to promote the cultural and performing arts.

    • @CrzyJen
      @CrzyJen 2 місяці тому +7

      YES BAD ROMANCE!! Perfect for October!

    • @manaciel
      @manaciel 2 місяці тому +7

      ​@@CrzyJenI can't agree more! It's for Halloween indeed!

    • @j.f.3342
      @j.f.3342 2 місяці тому +2

      Yeees, incredibly creative, they turned the song completely on its head!! Their most successful song so far, 20 million views within two years testify to it.

  • @EllaSilentDragon
    @EllaSilentDragon 2 місяці тому +19

    The original is already so perfect, that I was skeptical that this could work. 😅 But the addition of the flute and the strings and the harmonies sound pretty. 😊
    But there are some parts in this that gave me a sudden 80s Top Gun feeling. (That Intro and the guitar). Weird. 😅 And I miss the original drums.
    But all in all I liked it. 😊
    Loved your analysis. You have quite the range as well SH ❤

  • @MaryShieldsPhD
    @MaryShieldsPhD 2 місяці тому +26

    You made my day! I found the video itself yesterday. So happy to see you do this so soon! As always, fantastic R & A!
    A bit of context: If you look at the stage, not only are the singers dressed differently, but they do so to represent different timelines: Bae Doo Hoon (singing in a bar context), Cho Mingyu (dressed in a 17th century (?) costume, with the stained glass and strings behind him), and Kang Hyung Ho representing a rock star (with the neon lights, the guitars and drums, etc.). One of the things I love is that you nailed it in your R & A!
    Ko Woorim is doing his mandatory military service and is about half-way through. I'm pretty sure that's his voice on the backing track, but from what I understand, he won't be appearing with them in person for another 9 months. I think his service is over sometime toward the end of May, 2025. In the interim, the other three are still performing. I must admit that I've not listened to many of this year's performances, but this is the first time I've heard the bass come in as a backing track. It's nice that he's present in some way, even though he can't be there in person.
    BTW, Kang Hyung Ho actually IS a rock star: can't wait until you do some of his solo work as Pitta. Please start with his (Pitta's) newest version of Phantom of the Opera, which won him another award. It's in this video: ua-cam.com/video/x-o7o8OKGrM/v-deo.html. The actual song starts near the 4 minute mark, although if you turn on cc in English, you'll get some great context for it. I recommend watching the whole video for the context. It's really touching. The keyboardist is a keyboard genius. He is also the musical director for Pitta's tours this year.
    The keyboardist is Oh Eun-cheol. This video also gives some sense of Kang Hyung Ho's range....

    • @SirHairless
      @SirHairless  2 місяці тому +3

      Great, thanks for all of this Mary!

  • @gongjulie
    @gongjulie 2 місяці тому +4

    Subscribed because I just love your forestella reactions! More forestella please!!!

  • @송수아-e8c
    @송수아-e8c 2 місяці тому +19

    포레스텔라 리액션 감사합니다 ❤

  • @elviedelarosa5028
    @elviedelarosa5028 2 місяці тому +6

    Thank you for a very thorough analysis and reaction to Forestella's performance of Piano Man.

  • @rdm122
    @rdm122 2 місяці тому +38

    Ko Woorim tornerà il 18 maggio 2025, al termine del servizio militare (obbligatorio in Corea del Sud). Però alla fine del brano si sente la sua voce registrata ❤
    Sentiamo tutti la sua mancanza, anche i suoi compagni, e questo è stato un bellissimo regalo per noi ❤
    Aspettiamo con impazienza la reunion ...

  • @JJey-wd6ku
    @JJey-wd6ku 2 місяці тому +23

    덕분에 안들리던 것도 더 잘 들리고 넘 좋았어요 감사합니다 ^^

  • @sofeelgood5864
    @sofeelgood5864 2 місяці тому +20

    We can't be on the show because of the army of Go Woo-rim, so he participated with his voice only

  • @사라야게따
    @사라야게따 2 місяці тому +27

    너무 힐링되네요❤❤❤❤❤

  • @maryangelpr
    @maryangelpr 2 місяці тому +4

    Tha bass voice that is heard in different parts of the song, specially very clear at the end of the song, sounds like Ko Woorim, probably recorded and included.

  • @BettyMoore-bb9kb
    @BettyMoore-bb9kb 2 місяці тому +6

    I love this rendition of The Piano Man and that we get to hear Ko Woorim in the backup track. He will back with the group by the end of May 2025.
    Thank you for your wonderful, informative reactions of Forestella’s music!

  • @DancingWithTonya
    @DancingWithTonya 2 місяці тому +2

    Forestella is EPIC! LOVES them!!

  • @iparguladil2521
    @iparguladil2521 2 місяці тому +2

    More forestella reaction please I really like your judge ❤❤

  • @funnyp376
    @funnyp376 2 місяці тому +18

    전문적인 분석 감사합니다 ❤
    일반인이 듣기는좀 어렵지만 구체적인 설명 감사합니다 😊

  • @rodrw1igO-uew6h
    @rodrw1igO-uew6h 2 місяці тому +6

    Wow 💕 Thanks!
    I enjoyed your Detailed analysis!! AWESOME 🫰 ~~!!👆

  • @pennyc.638
    @pennyc.638 Місяць тому +1

    I have to tell you Sir Hairless, you are so amazingly entertaining that you even bring tears to my eyes with your reactions to the fantastic Forestella! Truly a talented observer!! I never knew that a 'reaction/analysis' man could be so 'captivating'--which has made me a fan!!👍👌🥰💕

  • @Megl_guhr2ou9v.l
    @Megl_guhr2ou9v.l 2 місяці тому +2

    Thanks for the interesting Analysis!! Your wonderful Voice!!💜 Lol 😆

  • @GrandmasGotGraceLW
    @GrandmasGotGraceLW 2 місяці тому +5

    November 9, 1973 -- just 20 days before my 24th birthday -- that's when Billy Joel released the song. I had been living in Soldotna, Alaska, but had been in an auto accident involving a two-year-old-ish moose (I didn't hit him, or the reverse, but I DID hit the only tree in the vicinity, while trying NOT to involve the two-ton-ish moose), and broke my right arm OFF (under the skin) at the wrist. Ultimately, while healing, I went back and stayed for a while with my mom and dad (and my first two kids) in Valdez, while my husband (who became my ex-husband a few years later) was commanding the National Guard unit, in Seward.
    So...when this song came out, I was in a household with a great piano (bought by my dad, especially for my mom). Valdez still didn't have TV, but I was raised listening to the radio to hear new music. Mom and I heard the song for the first time, together, and she immediately began to pick up on it. You see, HER life had been pretty much spent as the "Piano Woman," though she BEGAN playing music on the violin and also played six or seven other instruments, as well.
    I had gotten my right arm back into condition enough to play a (somewhat slower than usual) version of "The Birth of the Blues" (a great one for learning to reach at least an octave, while your arm is still in a restrictive position in a heavy cast). So the two of us spent quite a bit of "special" time playing and singing both of those songs (not at the same time, obviously), while my two little ones danced around the living room to the music and the family parakeet was also learning to sing a new song that my dad had been teaching him: "All I Want for Christmas Is My Two Front Teeth." Seriously! So when Sammy heard us singing one of the other songs (and others by the wayside) and playing the piano, he just HAD to chime in with his own notes and rhythms that didn't match any of the songs on which we were concentrating. Sometimes we just had to put his cage cover on, so he'd drift off to sleep. Then Mom would shake her finger at Daddy and say to him, "See what you've done to him, Frank?!" Then we'd all get a good laugh.
    So...yeah...rather strange memories regarding that song, but I will ALWAYS love it, Forestella did a totally WONDERFUL job with it, and your Reaction/Analysis was really GREAT. WOW!!! Thank you! 😀

  • @gavinbehavin
    @gavinbehavin 2 місяці тому +4

    Thank you for the superb insightful reaction and analysis. You put in so much effort and it is quite noticeable. Kudos to you. Woo Rim voice was prerecorded so you did hear him even though he was not there. He will be back In May done with his military obligation. Great great analysis. Thank you. Best to you always Sir. It was so good I subscribed.

  • @S.K-eg3ps
    @S.K-eg3ps 2 місяці тому +6

    トリオでもやはり素晴らしいですね!来年、コウリム氏が戻って来たらまた素晴らしいパフォーマンスが観られて、あなたの満足気なreactionが期待出来ます😊

  • @daleenengelbrecht4861
    @daleenengelbrecht4861 2 місяці тому +5

    Sublime!! Ellie tx for the information. Love them and the acapella groups you regularly play and explain to us. (Has to through this out there although you know by now. Once a Pentaholic always a Pentaholic) TX for everything you explain to us. We really hear so much more due to your expertise. You are so appreciated. Greetings from South Africa. If ever something doesn't really make sense, I am Afrikaans. O for interesting sake; we have 11 languages. ❤❤

    • @manaciel
      @manaciel 2 місяці тому +1

      Forestella has some Zulu lyrics in their version of Shape of you. Take a watch!

    • @daleenengelbrecht4861
      @daleenengelbrecht4861 2 місяці тому +1

      @@manaciel OK TX

  • @frankreyes2000
    @frankreyes2000 Місяць тому +5

    Thank you for your reaction and analysis of this wonderful song. Forestella members are known as "The Kings of Harmonies" and perform each song this way. They take their harmonies to an extraordinary level. Each performance blows your mind. You're fascinated by the perfection of their vocal arrangements and artistry. You found yourself mesmerized by the grandiosity of it all.
    I have included below some recommended songs that are masterpieces of art. They won't ever disappoint you.
    1.-Mama (Original: EXO) - ua-cam.com/video/RJJUG0vM1Co/v-deo.htmlsi=2FGa3g95IsD2igAJ
    2.-Time in a Bottle - ua-cam.com/video/rJ6bVs1_058/v-deo.htmlsi=1AKae_ttLF8_lOYF
    3.-The Sky and the Dawn and the Sun - ua-cam.com/video/42IZop_OV-A/v-deo.htmlsi=XhntBkF5Of8hjodg
    4.-Angel - ua-cam.com/video/c_JCnseNfbM/v-deo.htmlsi=BYnqy8sqCHgoHg87
    5.-Hijo de la Luna - ua-cam.com/video/LJc7wXa9JG8/v-deo.htmlsi=sM-YX6RqyiUb2CzB
    6.-The Sound of Silence - ua-cam.com/video/facu-I30uWE/v-deo.htmlsi=h2xpHuxj2hxCN961
    7.-Inner Universe - (They sing in Russian, English, and Latin). ua-cam.com/video/-oBEEuS8OM0/v-deo.htmlsi=nIGtmV1ncRlsKTeq
    8.-Champions - ua-cam.com/video/r2JyHuhbtzY/v-deo.htmlsi=dD2iqkgEJqqS2yxf
    9.-Magic Castle - ua-cam.com/video/tbMp8B3w_wo/v-deo.htmlsi=Ot_04Vsv4aejN8sy
    10.-My Eden - ua-cam.com/video/enqkJ6buSIE/v-deo.htmlsi=4yMtWvQbyxcwyW0s
    I'm really looking forward to watching other Forestella reaction videos from you.

  • @lubmo9129
    @lubmo9129 2 місяці тому +6

    Yeesss.. thank you for reading my comment! ❤❤❤😊😊
    You are my fav reactor tbh
    The base voice is kwr.. he is in the army now.. and sometimes he records his voice for them

  • @manaciel
    @manaciel 2 місяці тому +11

    Thank you for your wonderful review and analysis to Forestella again!
    In this performance each of Forestella represented a showman, a rockstar, a medieval artist to celebrate every artist of all genres. Seems they were involved in directing the stage as far the head of the Page Dance Project (dancer team mainly of modern dance collaborating here) said at her post.
    thepagedance 불후의명곡 피아노맨 첫 스탭회의때 형호, 두훈,민규씨 한분씩 무대구성에 대해 준비한 내용 들으며 스텝들. 우리,어쩌지? 이 아이디어 실현시킬수 있을까..... 하며 많은 고민을 주었던 무대연출. 본부장님. 나. 의상팀 서로를 바라보며 할수있어 할수있다고 서로를 위로하며 촬영전까지 단톡방에서 계속 실시간 진행상황 공유하고 수정 또 수정 확인하고 마침내 완성된 무대. 촬영 당일 무대 리허설 끝나고 느낀것. 참 포레는 어떻게든 하고싶은 이야기를 실현해내고마는 사람들이구나. . 대단하다 감탄했었다. 오늘 본방송후 댓글보니 많은팬분들이 알아봐주고 계시는것보니 내가 다 뿌듯하다 (댓글다찾아보는편ㅋ) 크로스오버그룹 중 나에게 단연 탑 포레스텔라 덕분에 또한번 크로스오버의 벽을넘다 힘들었지만 해냈다. 우리댄서들 더페이지댄스 더운날씨에 정말 수고많으셨습니다, 감사합니다
    (I hope this transition works for better understanding.)
    The Pagedance Immortal Songs PianoMan
    The stage production struggled a lot since the first staff meeting when each of us listened to HyungHo, DooHoon, and Mingyu about the plans they prepared for the stage composition. We, the director, I (dancer team), the costume team were like "what should we do?" thinking, "Can we make this idea come true?" We looked at each other and comforted each other that we could do it. We continued to share the real-time progress in the chat room until the shooting, making corrections and checking the corrections, and finally, the stage was completed. I thought, "WOW, Forestella is a group of people who can make the story they want to tell come true no matter what." . I admired them. I'm proud to see that many fans are recognizing ttat (I'm looking for all the comments) and I'm proud to be one of the best crossover groups in the world Forestella. Thanks to Forestella, it was hard to overcome the barrier of this crossover, but we did it. Our dancers ThePageDance did a great job in the hot weather, thank you!
    And Ko WooRim's voice in backing track made this performance even more perfect!
    I recommend Shape of you for your next Forestella journey. You will see how Forestella use their bass exceptionally. I saw no other group using their bass (if they have a bass in the group) in such a unique way like Forestella. And they sang it in English, Spanish and African Zulu! Before watching Forestella's version, check Ed Sheeran - Shape Of You (Latin Remix) Ft Zion & Lennox, Ed Sheeran - Shape Of You (Cover by Ndlovu Youth Choir and Grammy-winning flutist Wouter Kellerman), as their references of Spanish & Zulu.

  • @ryuinnovator
    @ryuinnovator 2 місяці тому +3

    As you analyze, they were meant to be presenting various type of musicians and merging all. this show is now King of Kings in every 6 months of Immortal Songs 2, so that they performed for all participants like various type musicans, that is, chanting for other musicians.

  • @YolandaMarilynOlivaresRodrigue
    @YolandaMarilynOlivaresRodrigue 2 місяці тому +3

    Ellos realmente son fabulosos...me encantan..#Forestella para el mundo.

  • @anaordonez372
    @anaordonez372 2 місяці тому +3

    Yes, Woorin is backing track. Now he is in a military service. The performance was beautiful.

  • @catherinejang1436
    @catherinejang1436 2 місяці тому +21

    당신의 음악 감상은 전문적이어서 제가 미처 듣지 못한 것들을 강의하듯 잘 알려주는군요. 음악을 듣는 귀가 발달하셨어요. 많은 리액션 중에서도 보기 드물게 훌륭합니다.앞으로도 좋은 리액션 기대하겠습니다.
    구독과 좋아요는 당연히 누르고 갑니다. 자주 봐요~~!!

  • @초희-g6x
    @초희-g6x 2 місяці тому +33

    우림은 군대갔어요 앞으로 8~9개월 후에나 볼 수 있어요

  • @스카이골드
    @스카이골드 2 місяці тому +10

    깊이있고 전문적인 자세한 음악적 분석 감사합니다. 잘 보고 있습니다. 구독도 하였어요.
    SirHairless 가 분석해주는 forestella의 'Time in a bottle' 추천합니다.
    정말 듣고 분석할 것이 많을꺼에요. 분명히 재미있을껍니다.
    제가 가장 좋아하는 곡입니다.

  • @delitrejo2338
    @delitrejo2338 2 місяці тому +3

    #Forestella maravillosos!! Y la voz de #KoWooRim en los coros fye espectacular y fui feliz de escuchar su voz, siempre junto a sus hermanos ❤❤ maravillosos!!! ❤️🇲🇽🥰😀

  • @0aeonflux
    @0aeonflux 2 місяці тому +13

    yes Woorim is in the aemy till next year but i 'm pretty sur an another reactor teacher paul is ok with its Woorim e're hearing in backtrack at the end

  • @미아패로우
    @미아패로우 2 місяці тому +16

    💚💚💚💚

  • @kroe8137
    @kroe8137 2 місяці тому +23

    우와 흥미로운 리액션 감사합니다!

  • @보리덕후
    @보리덕후 2 місяці тому +6

    Thank you for your analysis and reaction. Forrestella is great as a group, but also as a solo artist for each member. I recommend Kang Hyung-ho's "Phantom of Opera," Cho Min-gyu's "Speechless" in eight languages, and Go Woo-rim's "Stars."

    • @ninalopesbrasil
      @ninalopesbrasil 2 місяці тому

      And let me add the recently DooHoon released Dear (OST to kdrama Black Out) and Loving You Keeps Me Alive (from musical Dracula).

  • @SeoHan-Sol
    @SeoHan-Sol 2 місяці тому +3

    Thank you for the sound analysis. As Forestella fans, our fandom name is SOOPBYEOL.
    Our youngest member, KO WOORIM, is currently on military service. There is less than 1 year left until his term ends.
    That's why this video doesn't exist.⭐🌳🐇🐥🐈🐻

  • @cherarbre8843
    @cherarbre8843 2 місяці тому +5

    Sir~ your professional analysis and the way of speaking reminds me of my favorite Dr. Higgins from 'My Fair Lady' 🤩
    Of course, you are not harsh, but a very kind and gentle person.^^
    I really enjoy listening to your poetic narrative tone in British English.🙌
    And I appreciate that you recognize and value the natural talent of Forestella
    and the fierce effort they put into each song they release.
    So, please continue to respond to Forestella. It will be very valuable.
    Thank you so much! 🙆‍♀

  • @ryuinnovator
    @ryuinnovator 2 місяці тому +2

    I'm just waiting of your reaction!! Here we go~

    • @ryuinnovator
      @ryuinnovator 2 місяці тому +2

      You make Forestella more and more attractive!!

  • @들꽃-y2r
    @들꽃-y2r 2 місяці тому +25

    ❤👍🔔

  • @11716musicny
    @11716musicny 2 місяці тому +15

    Try looking at Thriller too

  • @겨울봄그림r
    @겨울봄그림r 2 місяці тому +4

    곡 해석이 정말 탁월하시네요.
    덕분에 몰랐던 걸 많이 알게되네요.
    snow globe도 부탁드려요. ^^

  • @jooyeonjeong1464
    @jooyeonjeong1464 2 місяці тому +3

    You are a teacher who makes me know 'FORESTELLA better.
    It's also interesting that whenever I stopped appreciating it, it quite overlapped with what I thought was impressive.
    For example, Cho Min-gyu's voice that comes after playing the flute... Or the climax in the second half! 😉

  • @Alexsam9506
    @Alexsam9506 2 місяці тому +21

  • @analobos4901
    @analobos4901 2 місяці тому +25

    Sir Hairless....sí..se escuchó Woorim..