Building The Perfect Survivor: All-Stars Cast
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 вер 2024
- Some of the Survivor: All-Stars casts were duds and how the tribes were split up seemed to not make too much sense. So what if we jumped into a time machine and fixed it? What if we had unlimited power? Why not?
Patreon - / onceuponanislandchannel
Facebook - / onceuponanislandchannel
Twitter - / upon_island
Instagram - / once_upon_an_island_ch...
Email - ouaichannel@gmail.com
So much better! Basically cutting the dead weight on the season and replacing them with better players / characters and then of course BALANCING THEM OUT.
He should have put Jonny FairPlay on though
@@eastonburnor4018 In place of who?
The fact that Vecepia and Sean have yet to come back after all these years is literally so mind boggling to me
I completely agree. Vecepia needs a second shot.
Maybe with this new POC rule thing they can finally give Sean his second chance finally
Do Vecepia and Sean want to return?
@@gromitmuggromitmuggromitmug Sean doesn’t
@@gromitmuggromitmuggromitmug i think vecepia said she wanted to be on s40
it makes me kinda sad thinking about how big of a character [REDACTED] was, and how everyone loved him and felt so sorry that he fell into the fire.
Little did we know, future him deserves worse than falling into a fire
Don't need to redact that scumbag's name. Let everyone know how awful Michael Skupin is.
@@ironmantim33 Call Chris Hansen
I love when he's going over the list of people being considered and uses first and last names for every player except Big Tom, Boston Rob, and Greg lmao just Greg.. idk why but that made me laugh
Wow no Amber is so bold, also Kelly Goldsmith is a super interesting player I would love to see again. No Big tom is pretty bold as well, he always seems like such a good time
the producers definitely relied on a season's popularity more than an individual player when they originally casted All Stars proven obviously by high numbers from the first three seasons while the last four a season had no more than two. so I love the way that you set this up probably the most fair way I've seen so far of All Stars...
Everyone forgets Deena from Amazon. Deena is fantastic! She’s a great character and good strategic player. Deena should have been in second chance ballot.
I'm surprised you don't have at least 10 thousand subscribers.
So so close! When I do hit 10k, I have a video I have been waiting to release for you all!
@@OnceUponAnIsland Can't wait!
@@OnceUponAnIsland SUPRISE! More than double 10,000! Congratulations, I and many others really appreciate and love your content!
I honestly feel like the All Winners tribe will be interesting because Sandra and Brian would almost definitely go at it and the other four would have to pick sides (Vecepia and Tina most likely picking Sandra due to Brian in Thailand, the other two men could go either way)
I had the same immediate thought about Sandra and Brian
I think about Brian playing modern survivor. May I ask: who thinks he'd play good, who thinks he'd play bad. I personally feel he'd be pretty bad for several reasons: his seasons rep, his edit, and his inability to make real bonds. I know it worked in Thailand, but in this case, his game is so well known that no one would buy it
@@fnafsummoners5679 I agree with you, mostly because he lacks the ability to make genuine social connections. It worked in Thailand, but people have seen Thailand and know that he’s super fake
@@baileylynn5562 Exactly, and, if he played again, and tried to make real relationships, no one would buy it because of Thailand. Hell, even if he was in a Fans vs Favorites, Rookies vs Vets, Old School vs New School type of seasons, Brian would lose anyway, because of his Thailand game, no one would Align with him. His best chance is to play up being a Goat or be a challenge beast to not get voted out
@@fnafsummoners5679 I don’t even think he’d make it far enough to have the opportunity to play up the role of a goat. He’d have to win out to have any chance of making it to the end
My cast would be:
Saboga:
Richard Hatch
Ethan Zohn
Brian Hedik
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Tina Wesson
Vecepia Towery
Mogo Mogo:
Colby Donaldson
Lex van den Berghe
Sean Rector
Susan Hawk
Kathy Varick-O'Brien
Helen Glover
Chapera:
John Carroll
Rob Cesternino
Rupert Boneham
Teresa Cooper
Jerri Manthey
Shii Ann Huang
Now onto Bransteele to simulate this season!
No Boston Rob=no good.
No Boston rob wow
It would be fun to watch Sandra & Brian play again each other
This is definitely John carroll’s burner account
Just ran this cast in a simulator and Brian,Vecepia and Sandra made a three-person alliance and went to the final 3. With The queen being the queen. Which means Sandra is a massive target if she goes on Heroes vs Villains
Think it's hilarious that the Final Three of All-Stars were the three most questionable choices, especially in light of better character and players they overshadowed (Sean Rector, Collen Haskell, Elisabeth Hasselbeck). Like all three of them were even buddies with the person they were replacing so
Rob was questionable as a strategist, but it made sense to cast him as a character. Amber and Jenna Lewis did not make any sense.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Boston Rob and Jenna Lewis were friends before the game started. All Stars was a prelude to Winners At War and how outside relationships affect the game
Idk if colleen & Jenna Lewis or Elisabeth & amber are really that close
Sean was not good television. John Carroll was better than him, Boston Rob was 10 times better than him and even Hunter Ellis was better.
Yes Jenna Lewis and Amber were questionable, but I think both proved to be perfect choices and definitely made a legacy for themselves.
@@duvall5jd Sean is good TV, maybe it isn't a huge loss over Boston Rob but definitely John Caroll and Hunter Ellis ain't better than him.
"this tribe must be the least fun to watch" HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE???? With Sandra there?? She'll fight Hatch as soon as the dude takes his pants off.
also I think Tina and Sandra would bond and make a great good cop/bad cop duo
It would be fun to watch Brian & Sandra play together too it will never happen though
What do you think of this new cast? Who would you put on your own revamped All-Stars cast?
What about Jenna L?
You should do a prediction list with this cast
@@bennymcshea2448 What about her?
@@spookyricherd456 Someone posted a brantsteele below that plays out the season. Boston Rob, Sandra, and Rupert are the final 3. Sandra beats Rob 6-1.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Oh nvm I thought you were considering everyone from the original cast
Love your picks, I loved Heidi a lot and am sad she never played again. I fully agree with giving her a spot over Amber. I remember when I first started All-Stars I was so dumbfounded they had picked Amber of all people. She really wasn't that memorable on Australian Outback for me. In the end though she did really shine in All-Stars and am glad she made it in the end, but I do also love the idea of an alternate world where Heidi played again
Borneo: Kelly W, Sue, Rudy, Richard
Outback: Tina, Colby, Skupin, Jerri, Elisabeth
Africa: Ethan, Lex, Tom, Kelly G
Marquesas: Kathy, Vecepia, Rob
Thailand: Shii Ann, Brian
Amazon: Jenna, Heidi, Rob C
Pearl Islands: Rupert, Sandra, Jonny Fairplay
Surprised you didn’t even consider Burton. I wouldn’t have put him on but I totally would have considered him
Could you do a video on Chris D. He is one of the most underrated winners and players of all time.
Vanuatu is after All-Stars and all winners are guaranteed story videos :)
@@OnceUponAnIsland didn’t Jeff date a contestant from that season
@@iamkonner4813 Yeah, I think Julie.
@@iamkonner4813 Sounds about right to me.
@@lukassvoboda4107 Most likely S9 Chris
I absolutely agree with this list, good video I like how it’s different.
If I could do my own all-stars cast... it would probably be something like this:
Mogo Mogo: Richard Hatch, Sandra Diaz-Twine, Colby Donaldson, Kelly Wiglesworth, Rob Cesternino, Tina Wesson
Saboga: Rupert Boneham, Jerri Manthey, Rudy Boesch, Kathy Vavrick O'Brien, Lex van den Berghe, Shii Ann Huang
Chapera: "Boston" Rob Mariano, Sue Hawk, Jon "Jonny Fairplay" Dalton, Teresa "T-Bird" Cooper, Sean Rector, Heidi Strobel
Who was cut from the canon season?
-Ambuh
-Jenna L
-Big Tom
-Alicia
-Ethan
-Jenna M
You didn't even mention Deena?? This is a travesty
Oh no!!!
I would’ve loved to see Deena or Rob win Amazon.
@@simonbrady3899 honestly though, they were both ahead of their time and the most strategic imo (Rob was next NEXT level but still)
@@OnceUponAnIsland 10/10 list aside from that
Rob should have
I wanna see t-bird again!!!
Fun fact: I was born 2 weeks before Survivor: The Amazon aired on TV
Feel old yet?
Fun fact, I was ten when Borneo aired. I have felt old for a while ;)
Once Upon An Island well, now I feel younger
@@OnceUponAnIsland fun fact I was just born when Tocantines came out
I wasn’t born until season 9 👍
I would definitely also consider Burton. Doubt he'd make the final cut but still
Yeah I would consider him too but probably only room for like one or maybe two people from pearl islands at the time since it was the previous season
your videos are so thought out and well edited !!! here before 10K but can’t wait so see your channel continue to grow !!! keep up the great work !!
Thank you so much Dana!
My Cast
Chapera (Winners): Richard, Tina, Ethan, Vecepia, Brian, Sandra
Mogo Mogo (Finalists or Near-Finalists): Sue, Colby, Lex, Kathy, Rob C, Elisabeth
Saboga (Characters): Jerri, Big Tom, Boston Rob, Rupert, Shii Ann, Heidi
Here is how I'd like the tribes to be split. Yellow might seem a little to strong but in any challenge dealing with pure strength I don't think they'd be able to handle Colby or Rupert respectively.
Red Tribe: Brian, Rupert, Rob C, Vecepia, Sue, T-Bird
Yellow Tribe: Ethan, Boston Rob, Gervase, Tina, Shii Ann, Jerri
Green Tribe: Rich, Colby, Lex., Sandra, Kathy, Heidi
What do you think of my Survivor Second Chance 2?
Rick Devens - 38 Edge of Extinction
Christian Hubicki - 37 David vs Goliath
Davie Rickenbacker - 37 David vs Goliath
Domenick Abbate - 36 Ghost Island
Devon Pinto - 35 HHH
Jay Starret - 33 Millennials vs Gen X
Rodney Lavoie - 30 Worlds Apart
Hayden Moss - 27 Blood vs Water
Reynold Toepfer - 26 Fans vs Favourites
Matt Elrod - 22 Redemption Island
Older considerations
Ian Rosenberger - 10 Palau
Rafe Judkins - 11 Guatemala
Elaine Stott - 39 Island of Idols
Lauren O’Connell - 38 Edge of Extinction
Chrissy Hofbeck - 35 HHH
Jessica Blain - 33 Millennials vs Gen X
Cydney Gillion - 32 Survivor Koah Rong
Caroline Rivera - 30 Worlds Apart
Trish Hegarty - 28 Cagayan
RC Saint-Amour - 25 Phillipines
Sabrina Thompson - 24 One World
Taj George - 18 Tocantins
I never again want to see Rodney. He is an asshole
How I think this season would go
18. Sue Hawk
17. Shii Ann Wang
16. Teresa Cooper
15. Richard Hatch
14. Kathy Vavrick O’Brien
13. Rupert Boneham
12. Heidi Strobel
11. Brian Heidik
10. Jerri Manthey
9. Gervase Peterson
8. Ethan Zahn
7. Tina Wesson
6. Vecepia Towery
5. Colby Donaldson
4. Lex Van De Berg
3. Sandra Diaz Twine
2. Rob Mariano
1. Rob Cesternino
Here’s my Cast:
Saboga Tribe (Winners)
- Richard Hatch (Borneo, Winner)
- Tina Wesson (Australia, Winner)
- Ethan Zohn (Africa, Winner)
- Vecepia Towery (Marquesas, Winner)
- Brian Heidik (Thailand, Winner)
- Jenna Morasca (Amazon, Winner)
Mogo Mogo (Finalists)
- Susan Hawk (Borneo, 4th)
- Colby Donaldson (Australia, Runner up)
- Lex van den Berghe (Africa, 3rd)
- Kathy Vavrick-O’Brien (Marquesas, 3rd)
- Rob Cesternino (Amazon, 3rd)
- Sandra Diaz-Twine (Pearl Islands, Winner)
Chapera (Wild Cards)
- Gervase Peterson (Borneo, 7th)
- Jerri Manthey (Australia, 8th)
- Teresa Cooper (Africa, 5th)
- Rob Mariano (Marquesas, 10th)
- Shii Ann Huang (Thailand, 10th)
- Rupert Boneham (Pearl Islands)
Yes, I do know that Sandra won Pearl Islands. I put her on Mogo Mogo because A, I wanted to include every winner, B, there wasn’t enough room for every winner on Saboga, and C, Sandra didn’t know she won at the time of filming All-Stars.
I hope you do Todd and Earl videos soon!! This video is already so cool btw
All winners are guaranteed a story video!
Interesting idea. Not sure I agree with all of the cast members that you picked, but it would be an great season I bet.
Chapera:
Boston Rob-Keep
Rob C-Keep
Big Tom-Replace with Gervase
Sue
Amber-Replace with Christy
Alicia-Replace with Elisabeth( or Colleen or Tijuana)
Saboga:
Rupert-keep
Rudy-keep
Ethan-keep
Jenna Lewis-replace with Deena
Tina-keep
Jerri-keep
Mogo Mogo:
Lex-replace with Fairplay
Colby-keep
Richard-keep
Jenna M.-replace with Sandra
Shii-Ann-keep
Kathy-replace with Kelly Goldsmith(or Helen)
My cast would be:
Men:
Colby-2
Rupert-7
Ethan-3
Rob-6
Rich-1
Lex-3
Rudy-1
JFP-7
Sean-4
Women:
Sue-1
Helen-5
Sandra-7
Jerri-2
Colleen-1
Vecepia-4
Tina-2
Kathy-4
Kelly-3
10:43 "he's a potentially solid asset on the tribe"
I literally had to skip back and listen again bc the first time I could swear he said "he intentionally sold acid to a tribe" lmao I have no idea why my brain heard that the first time but I'm dying 😂
You should do one for heroes vs villains
I plan on doing one for every returnee season :)
The way bb22 turned out the same way as Survivor All Stars
What about burton?
My Cast For SURVIVOR All-Stars
Season 1 :
1. Richard
2. Greg
3. Sue
4. Rudy
Season 2 :
1. Colby
2. Jerri
Season 3 :
1. Ethan
2. Lex
3. T-Bird
Season 4 :
1. Vecepia
2. Neleh
3. Sean R
Season 5 :
1. Shi Ann
Season 6 :
1. Jenna M
2. Rob C
3. Heidi
Season 7 :
1. Sandra
2. Fairplay
Heidi and Jerry on the same tribe!!! Wow, if they worked together that is a combo I see winning the game, Rob and Gervase I could see joining them and targeting Shii ann or Rupert but I could see him trying to flip Jerry on Heidi, wow that has my head going with all the possibilities.
Commenting for the algorithm!
'The first and so far only deaf contestant..." Nina Poersch: AM I A JOKE TO YOU?
Nina didn't play during seasons 1-7.
I’m a little late but here’s my dream cast:
Saboga-
Hatch
Tina
Kathy
Darrah
Lex
Savage
Mogo Mogo-
Colby
Big Tom
Alicia
Vecepia
Jonny Fairplay
Sue
Chapera-
Sean R
Jerri
Ethan
T-Bird
Sandra
Boston Rob
Maybe not these exact tribes, but definitely the people
I'll do a 20 person cast, because there's enough iconic players/characters to make it work
Males: Hatch, Rob C, Fairplay, Brian, Ethan, Lex, Colby, Rupert, Boston Rob, Big Tom
Females: Tina, Sue, Jerri, Sandra, Vecepia, Shi-Ann, T-Bird, Kathy, Colleen, Jenna M.
Admittedly, this cast is lacking in diversity, but that's largely due to the limited choices available from those first 7 seasons. Back then Survivor usually only casted 2-3 minority players on a season, so there's just far less possible options. My cast seems to align with their usual standard at the time, as I have 3 minority players (Shii-Ann, Sandra, and Vecepia). While, I considered Gervase, Alicia, and Sean Rector I just couldn't put them over the other choices I had. I'd probably have Alicia and Sean Rector at the top of my alternates list though. Otherwise, I think the cast has a great collection of personalities and game play styles. All 6 winners are featured, which gives them more of a chance imo, and there's a lot more strategic threats than the original cast (adding Brian and Fairplay helps here), which makes guys like Rich and Rob C stand out a little less. It also works better in terms of balancing the amount of players from each season than the original all stars (my cast has 3 from Borneo, 3 from AO, 4 from Africa, 3 from Marquesas, 2 from Thailand, 2 from Amazon, 3 from PI)
From a tribe division standpoint, I'd make it look something like this:
Chapera: Rob M, Big Tom, Ethan, Fairplay, Colby, Sandra, Sue, Jenna, Vecepia, Colleen
Mogo Mogo: Rob C, Lex, Hatch, Brian, Rupert, Jerri, Tina, Kathy, T-Bird, Shii-Ann
You should do one of these for a Rivals season and one for a Duos season.
I've actually been toying with the idea for years that maybe they could do Rivals vs. Duos season. One tribe made up of 5 pairs of classic rivals, and one tribe made up of 5 pairs of classic duos. And, yes, I know "but then it's not the same for everyone it's not fair" well first off.. since when is survivor fair? And second, there are pros and cons to both when you really think into it. I think it could be really cool and fun and *different* and I really think it could work.
I hope for Survivor: Vanuatu you’re able to do story videos on Ami, Eliza, Twila, and Chris
01:03
Once upon an Island: Characters we did not care about as much made it further
Me: NOT RUPERT RIGHT??!!??
I would say Rupert was the only person in the final 7 that most people cared about.
@@OnceUponAnIsland I care about Rob and Amber way more than Rupert.
In my simulation of this cast Colby, Ethan and Lex reach the final three in an alliance, Ethan wins the last Immunity Challenge and takes Lex to the final 2, and Lex won in a 5 - 2 vote, with T-Bird and Brian voting for Ethan; and Vecepia, Sue, Tina, Sandra and Colby voted for Lex, also the Winners dominated the pre-game, winning every immunity challenge in the original and absorbed tribes, it was until the tribe swap that some winners ended in different tribes and Rich was voted out first of the winners.
But in the original Allstars, Lex was on a tribe with Colby and Ethan and he cut both of them. Why would the new cast dynamics change that out of curiosity? Lex would want to cut Colby before the merge just like he did on original Allstars and he was too scared of Ethan beating him again. I just can't see any situation where Lex wouldn't cut them due to his entire mindset and the strategy he came into the game with. I'm just curious how your simulation accounts for things like this.
@@bunny_0288 I don't know, I literally used the brantsteele survivor simulator, I didn't take any decision, it was all decided by computer, my comment wasn't serious at all.
@@TheMattHardyFan21 Ohhhh I didn't know it was a computer simulator. That makes a lot more sense lol Thanks for the reply! I was just curious how it worked
I would include Tammy here since she is a fun character who I think is a smart player as well as fun TV
Who would you cut for her?
The Helen Glover and Deena Bennett erasure... :(
Imagine Ethan Zohn with Bryan Heidik play something like Good and bad cop gameplay in this season.... could be funny and interesting duo ...
1. Richard
2. Rudy
3. Susan
4. Kelly
5. Colleen
6. Tina
7. Colby
8. Jerri
9. Elisabeth
10. Ethan
11. Lex
12. Tom
13. Kathy
14. Shii Ann
15. Rob C
16. Sandra
17. Rupert
18. Jonny Fairplay
Saboga
Kelly 1
Sean 4
Lex 3
Rupert 7
Jenna 6
Jerri 2
Chapera
Rob m 4
Sandra 7
Heidi 6
John 4
Gervase 1
Amber 2
Mogo mogo
Colby 2
Teresa 3
Ethan 3
Sue 1
Shi ann 5
Jnfp 7
Interesting idea... I like playing (and watching) this kind of games
1) what would be your cast if you didn't include previous winners at all? (it could improve game dynamics when we now know how boring it was to see the decisions - "you're winner? Get out")
2) Could the show be better if the original cast was split differently into their tribes? (Boston Rob and Rob Cesternino in different tribes for example)
3) You wondered why Sean wasn't included when he was such a great character and you miss him as well - do you wonder now why that happened? :)
not mentioning Rob and Amber wouldn't be together in RL with you deciding abut the cast :)
Saboga: Rich, Tina, Ethan, Brian, Jenna, Sandra
Mogo Mogo: Sue, Colby, Lex, Kathy, Rob C, neliea
Chapera: Jerri, Boston Rob, Heidi, Rupert, Kelly Goldsmith, FairPlay
Even though I love your contest - "Shii Ann isn't that grat at strategy or reading people"... Correctly predicted Amber as a winner, calling out Penny as a snake in Thailand (the only person who flipped on a majority from Sook Jai), changed from the person who was a target on every single tribal council in Thailand o a one that was only voted for at her last trible council, trying to flip on her alliance in which she would have been 5th just to ensure she would make final 6 in Thailand I would also point as a good strategic view which, of course, due to a twist can be seem as a dumb move but I think it was a good one if you look up into the past seasons.
I think she was really bad social player because of which she had no chance to change her position at final 6 in All-Stars (especially since she wasn't that great in Thailand), but apart of that I think she had a lot of potential and she was really good, especially since she wasn't that good in challenges (thankfully she wasn't that bad). She definitely isn't the best player every but she was good in general and had a lot of good ideas so this comment in my opinion as a bit of too far in trying to downgrade her abilities to play the game.
I think Shii-Ann and most of the Thailand season are too often overlooked. I think the season was poorly edited because I think the cast was actually very likeable.
@@mhmmhoneybee It's funny to me because as soon as Shii-Ann got voted out, I wanted Jake to win so bad and was so disappointed when he got voted out.
I simulated this on BrantSteele and this was the winner: (I will include the fan-favorite because that became a thing this season)
Winner: Sanda Diaz-Twine Fan favorite: Boston Rob Mariano
Someone else did the brantsteele as well and had Sandra beat Boston Rob 6-1.
Mine was Sandra beating Brian but I forgot what the vote was
I think it would be very interesting to see Boston Rob and Andrew Savage on the same tribe.
I would Have put Brandon Quinton up for consideration, I know he wasn’t a huge character, but He was still one of my favorites
Stronger cast than the original.
But T-Bird and Lex are on the same tribe.
Good point. I don't know how I missed that.
@@OnceUponAnIsland I mean Lex might be mad at t-bird for votin him so it could work
Didn’t Lex and T-Bird play together?
Pupupipis italian deli here ill take your order
So I've been playing this on Bransteele and I needed to share the fact that on episode 7, there was a deadlock tie between Ethan and Boston Rob so they had to make a rock draw and out of all people (Ethan, Heidi, Rob and Vecepia, yeah Chapera got decimated) it was VECEPIA who got the purple rock draw
It's not much but it made me laugh a lot
Deena would have been fun, good second chance contender
You should make your own cast for a Heroes vs Villains 2. You should probably only use players from seasons 21-40, but it’s your cast.
Yes! He should do a "perfect" Heroes vs Villains 1 cast out of players from 1-19 and then a brand new dream cast for Heroes vs Villains 2 from seasons 21-40. 2 awesome video ideas :)
@@bunny_0288 All he really has to do is replace Amanda from the original cast with Elisabeth. Done.
@@kellydaunis I would replace Candice as well. I hate Candice. I think Amanda is a better player than Candice is, but I'd be fine with Amanda getting replaced too. I'm sure there were some better candidates out there lol.
Ok I have to say it... your intro song is the melody to a Scandinavian children’s song😁😂
They use Drunken Sailor as a kids song? That is epic.
@@OnceUponAnIsland yup😝😂
Men:
Hatch
Gervase
Colby
Big Tom
Ethan
Lex
Boston rob
Rob Cesternino
Rupert
Had to cut Rudy ( too old now), Mike Skupin, Jeff Varner, Sean rector, Brian heidik( would never want him back even though he was a dominant player the things he did were terrible), Jonny fairplay( he’s funny however probst hates him probst & production hate Brian heidik too that’s why I wouldn’t include him) I could see Using Sean rector or maybe Jeff Varner as alternates
For the women:
Colleen- she’s realistically probably going to decline though
Sue
Jenna Lewis
Jerri
Tina- even though I think she’s pretty similar to t-bird
T-bird-like I said she’s pretty similar to Tina
Kim powers- even though she’s not on this list I would really love to see her play again I would add her to my personal list
Kelly goldsmith- I probably would ha e her as an alternate however will just say because Jenna morascas mother was dying she backed out
Shii-Ann- just to include somebody from all 7 seasons like they wanted to do
I don’t think Kelly wiglesworth would want to play again at least not then, I would probably consider amber as an alternate, I don’t want to see Elisabeth hasselback play again, with Kathy that’s a tough one I could see her maybe being an alternate or maybe cut at the last minute, I could see neleh & Heidi being considered as alternates too, I wouldn’t put vecepia only because she isint a very popular winner, probst & production didn’t find her that interesting, she kind of backed into her win & she was also pregnant at the time so she wouldn’t be able to do it anyway
Cool idea maybe when you get to fans vs favourites You should do the same thing
I absolutely plan on doing this for any season with returnees :)
don't forget mogo mogo boat
What about Jeff's helicopter? It beat Mogo Mogo boat in a poll I conducted.
I wish you did a video on the story of Kathy in Season 4. She was the first to go far into the game without a partner, and was a part of overthrowing the Rotu Four.
Kathy was a big part of Marquesas. The Patrons pick who I make story videos about and at 100 Patrons I am letting them pick any player from any season.
Hey, I know that these doesn't has nothing to do with the video, but I have a question. What do you think will be the theme for the 50th season? , I thought that the most ambitious idea would be an All Winner season, but we already see that. So you have any idea?
Anyways, great video man.
If I had my choice, preferably a season of rivals. Put 5 pairs of rivals on each tribe, don't separate them.
Legends
I would keep a lot of the same cast because i decided to eliminate unrealistic options. I kept Jenna L. because she was a prominent character on borneo and to have someone on Pagong represented. Alicia and Shii Ann were 2 people I kept because of diversity and for Shii Ann's case have someone on Thailand on the season since she's basically one of the only people on Thailand that were all-star worthy. I kicked out Amber and Boston Rob for more diversity were i replaced them with Sean and Deena. I think both seemed willing to want to play again at the time. Sean i don't think is a controversial pick. I included Deena because the amazon was a popular season at the time so i decided to add a 3rd player on that season since we didn't need 5 people from the outback.
The biggest mistake producers made for all stars was casting Jenna Lewis. Christy from Amazon, Darrah from Pearl Islands, Neleh from Marquesas, and Kelly from Africa all would’ve been better alternatives than Jenna Lewis. If she wasn’t on this season, it would’ve been better.
I really wish we could have seen Brian come back. If only he didn’t ask for extra money. Say what you want about him in real life, but we haven’t seen a player before or since Brian that is able to calculate human interactions in such a sociopathic, smooth way. He’s such a great villain and he is a force out there on the island. It’s a shame.
Richard (borneo)
Colby (australia)
Ethan (africa)
Lex (africa)
Sean (marquesas)
Rob m (marquesas)
Rob c (amazon)
Fairplay (pearl islands)
Rupert (pearl islands)
Tina (australia)
Jerri (australia)
Theresa (africa)
Vecepia (marquesas)
Kathy (marquesas)
Helen (thailand)
Shii ann (thailand)
Heidi (amazon)
Sandra (pearl islands)
Christy Smith wasn't the only deaf person in Survivor. There was Nina from Worlds Apart. Unless you were saying she was the only deaf castaway in the first 7 seasons.
At the beginning of the video I do say we are in 2004 and recasting for season 8.
I would've killed for this exact cast.
IMO big tom, and Rudy should be on the cast (Big tom cuz he was in the top 4 in America's Tribal council, and Rudy because he was the fan favorite from Borneo, and could swap spots with Gervase)
I’d replace Gervace with Sean & I think there’s a pretty good cast, I also think one of the other guys should be cut in favour of FairPlay, seems ridiculous that the shows biggest villain wasn’t on all stars
My All-Stars (I went with 20 and I now some of these people would never come back)
Women: Alicia Calaway, Colleen Haskell, Helen Glover, Heidi Stroebel, Jenna Morasca, Jerri Manthey, Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien, Sue Hawk, Teresa Cooper, Tina Wesson
Men: Colby Donaldson, Ethan Zohn, Gervase Peterson, Greg Buis, Lex van de Berghe, Richard Hatch, Rob Cesternino, Rudy Boesch, Rupert Boneham, Sean Rector
I'm surprised you left out Neleh. First successful flipper!
Vecepia flipped before she ever did when she voted out Boston Rob.
Neleh was a vote away and a good final tribal council away from winning the game.
I would do a all winners vs. all losers (aka first outs)!
Varner was on big brother?
My Cast but there will be 20 people
People I wanted to be in the cast
Season 1
Richard Hatch
Sue
Rudy
Kelly
Greg
Colleen
Gervase
Dr Sean
Season 2
Elisabeth
Amber
Tina
Colby
Jerri
only person I feel should at least be considered is Helen Glover, she is a beloved character with a lot of bite
I did a brantsteele on this and Heidi won
I personally loved the all star season
I still want christa to return, i think the argument of being from a trio with sandra and rupert would give her a good storyline and they seem to be going for nerdy girls more in recent seasons
Can you do a video on the perfect Caramoan favorites since it definitely could be better?
I plan on doing this for every returnee season.
For survivor allstars (I am doing this as if they filmed it after Jenna's moms death) I would have a giant cast of 24 people so that the façade of having a limited cast of 12 with only 2 tribes could play for a while.
Tribe 1- Richard, Tina, Vesepia, Sandra, Ethan, Brian
Tribe 2- Rob, Amber, Hidiek, Sean, Rupert Jenna
Tribe 3- Rob C, Fairplay, Lex, Kelly, Jerry, Shian
Tribe 4- Kathy, Big Tom, Sean R, Colleen, Burton Elisabeth
Tribes 1 and 2 compete for 6 rounds till merge
Tribes 3 and 4 compete for 6 rounds till merge
The merge tribe competes for 2 rounds until final 10 merge.
That’s a really cool idea!
I wanna see Elizabeth back
She’s too famous now
Me too, but I recently read an interview and she said that she would never come back. She said she was young and brave when she went on Survivor in Australia and that that part of her life was definitely over. I was bummed to hear that. She does speak very fondly of the experience overall and she took a lot out of it.
Ok, where is the official Brantsteele for this season? Thanks. haha
This is a great cast, however there’s one big hole. Sandra didn’t know she won yet, at the time of filming
No Alex Bell or Dave Johnson from Amazon?!
Who would you drop for them.
I'm just an abnormally large Amazon fan but no Deena Bennett nor Alex Bell?
idc about anyone else i just want to see Robb Z and Greg Buis again lol
I simulated this on Brantsteele and Jerri won.
If I had to remake the All Star cast I would make it be 21 players, 3 from each season. (keep in mind that this is my opinion)
Borneo: Richard, Rudy, and Sue (This might work, but without Jenna L, it could have been interesting and I'm sorry for not including her, as I said, I needed 3 from each season)
Australian Outback: Tina, Colby, and Amber (Ok, this was a really hard one, obviously I wanted to included Jerri but I wanted to keep Amber in it to keep the winner and because Amber and Boston Rob is too amazing to get rid of.)
Africa: Ethan, Lex, and Big Tom (I'm keeping this one solely because this is 3 people used for the original and I didn't know who else)
Marquesas: V, Kathy, and Boston Rob (I added V, because, duh, she's the winner, and I didn't want to replace Kathy or Rob.)
Thailand: Brian, Helen, and Shii Ann (This was also kind of a hard one. I added Brian because he won, but I added Helen because she could have gave some good story to the season, and I just kept Shii Ann because why not.)
Amazon: Jenna, Cesternino, and Heidi (I kept Jenna and Cesternino because, come on, they were amazing that season. I added Heidi because, what's Jenna without Heidi? Also, I would wonder what would happen if Heidi made it farther than Jenna due to her quitting the game.)
Pearl Islands: Sandra, Jonny Fairplay, and Rupert (These 3 were my all-times favs for the season, they were all perfect for an All-Star spot. I kept Rupert because, come on, it's Rupert. I added Sandra because she's a winner, and I added Jonny Fairplay because he is definitely and All Star, you can disagree, but it is my opinion.)
Now, for the tribes.
All of Chapera, Mogo Mogo, and Saboga would have the same 6 people (besides Jenna L, Alicia, etc.) with some extras added.
For Chapera (minus Alicia) I'd add Helen and Sandra. I would love to see all 7 of these guys interacting
For Mogo Mogo, I'd add Jonny Fairplay. I can already see the interactions between Hatch and Fairplay already!
And for Saboga (minus Jenna L and Jerri) That leaves Brian, Heidi, and V. That would give the winners an advantage on that team now, but I feel that Brain would betray them.
As for the elimination order, I'd keep Tina first boot in a 4-3 vote Tina-Rudy, Brian, Heidi, Rupert, and Rudy voting for Tina, Ethan, Tina, and V voting for Rudy, as the winners on Saboga had formed an alliance, but Brian betrayed. For second boot, I'd keep Rudy in a 4-2 vote Rudy-Ethan, winners+ Heidi band together. Third boot, of course Jenna quit the game, leaving Heidi devastated. They actually did an immunity challenge, and I think I'm going to have Saboga get their first win, sending Mogo Mogo to tribal. This is where I think Jonny Fairplay will see his end. Fairplay and Colby would band together to try and dethrone Hatch, but were unsuccessful and lost to a 5-2 vote Fairplay-Hatch. Fifth boot is then Cesternino, in a 6-1 vote Cesternino-Sandra, Boston Rob manipulating him to vote Sandra to save his own ass. But, then comes the first tribe switch, dissolving Saboga, before the swap having 6 on Chapera, and 5 from Mogo Mogo and Saboga. 2 people being sent to Chapera, being Rupert and V. 3 people being sent to Mogo Mogo, being Ethan, Heidi, and Brian. Sixth boot would then come to Hatch, where they were actually successful in booting him this time in a 5-3 vote Hatch-Colby. Seventh boot would be Sue after quitting due to the events at the previous immunity challenge. They would have an immunity challenge that sent both tribes to tribal (much like the Vanuatu challenge). Eighth boot coming from Chapera and being Sandra in a 4-3 vote Sandra-Boston Rob. Ninth boot being Brian, from Mogo Mogo in a 3-3-1 tie, being rocked out because the votes were between Colby-Ethan with random vote from Shii Ann, actually voting for Brain. Tenth boot would be Colby, voted out in a 4-2 vote Colby-Heidi. Eleventh boot being Ethan in a 4-1 vote. Then, the second tribe switch happened. Everyone but Amber had switched their tribes, keeping the Amber-Boston Rob separation. Twelfth boot is actually Heidi after telling her tribe to vote her off because she couldn't handle the pressure of being in the game without Jenna, in a 4-1 vote Heidi-Amber, wanting to vote off Amber because of her obvious alliance with Boston Rob. Then comes the merge into Chaboga Mogo, and now, the start of the jury. Thirteenth boot would then be Lex in a 5-2 vote Lex-Amber. Fourteenth boot being Kathy in a 6-2 vote Kathy-Amber. Fifteenth boot being Helen in a 5-2 vote Helen-Boston Rob, Helen and Shii Ann teaming up to go against Boston Rob. Sixteenth boot being Shii Ann in a 5-1 vote Shii Ann-Amber. Seventeenth boot being Big Tom in a 3-2 vote Big Tom-Amber, V and Big Tom actually joining forces. Eighteenth boot being Rupert in a 3-1 vote because Boston Rob had told V that their friendship meant more than the alliance with Amber (which was a lie) and told her to vote with them and vote for Rupert. And after Amber won immunity, the clear nineteenth boot was V. The people who voted Boston Rob were V (because of their friendship), Kathy, and Rupert, the rest, being Helen (after being bitter and angry at Rob), Lex, Shii Ann, and Big Tom, deeming Amber the winner still.
That's how I think Survivor All-Stars would have went down with this cast.
21# Tina Wesson [Voted Out Day 3]
20# Rudy Boesch [Voted Out Day 6]
19# Jenna Morasca [Quit Day 9]
18# Jon Dalton/Jonny Fairplay [Voted Out Day 9]
17# Rob Cesternino [Voted Out Day 12]
16# Richard Hatch [Voted Out Day 15]
15# Susan Hawk [Quit Day 17]
14# Sandra Diaz-Twine [Voted Out Day 18]
13# Brian Heidik [Voted Out Day 18]
12# Colby Donaldson [Voted Out Day 19]
11# Ethan Zohn [Voted Out Day 21]
10# Heidi Strobel [Voted Out Day 24]
9# Lex van den Berghe [Voted Out Day 26]
8# Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien [Voted Out Day 28]
7# Helen Glover [Voted Out Day 30]
6# Shii Ann Huang [Voted Out Day 33]
5# Tom Buchanan [Voted Out Day 36]
4# Rupert Boneham [Voted Out Day 37]
3# Vecepia Towery [Voted Out Day 38]
Runner-up: Rob Mariano [Day 39]
Winner: Amber Brkich [Day 39]
I think Helen should have been in the mix.
Definitely. I wouldn't put her on, but I did hear her on RHAP say she was called for the season.
I’m not really a huge fan of Teresa being on the same tribe as Lex, seeing as they were both on Africa, but oh well.