Im jealous of all the people who arent gonna find this show til its finished already cause they get to binge it. Theyll never understand the pain of us in real time viewers having to wait a week between these under 1 hour episodes
THE WRITTERS OF THIS SHOW are as cruel as the creatures They are just feeding on our hope. That Is why they killed tillie Very cruel show But i love it
Or complacency. If the one thing he could return to comes to him, he has no real reason to leave. I think either way, the entity or fromville itself is manipulating him into something.
That's a good point, he's basically been there his whole life. I do think if anyone is involved Victor would make sense, but I hope they show more of his time there alone.
Victor isn't comfortable at all, hiding is still not comfort, it's seeking refuge. and also think about it, cans of peaches, he's been there 40 years. we've never really seen him eat, canned peaches are good 2-5 years not 40 years. and the monster in the cave said to him "we will have to make you stay here" not "kill you", people theorise he's a monster, and people also theorise Donna is a monster or monster mole, as her last name isn't revealed and her past is not shared via flashback, and Tabitha couldn't remember her last name for Henry to search missing persons, we don't know her last name. as well as we don't know Accosta's first name.
i think the only way to save the children is by going back in time in 1600 and stop the ritual from happening in which all the children were sacrificed in some ritual. As we already know that time travel is possible going through the far away trees. I think if jade or henry will go through that tree they will reach in 1600 somehow and then they had to stop the ritual from happening which will also save the children and will also free the town from the curse.
@@saurabhtripathi7915 that's debatably in the past. It's not 100% at this point if Boyd time travelled or just travelled because he opened the door and was in the present. Should he have opened the door to the past aswell if he was in the past already? Julie definitely time travelled to the time of Boyd stuck in the chimney but she didn't even step in a tree.
I hope it turns out the Henry is actually the one that caused the death of everyone in the town, other than Victor. It was a price he paid to go back home and Victor has just forgotten about it.
@@IndicaKing-i3x but y all the houses on henry's side of the street look like fromville but on the other side of the street more modern? also y did victor tell sara that Eloise's favorite playhouse was the one sara lives in, which happens to be the same color and style as henry's? so is sara Eloise reincarnated? she is brave and sneaky....is fromville all occurring in henry's house in a parallel dimension or wild dream or wild children's storybook? y does Miranda's painting of the talisman have one being as opposed to 2 like fromville? hmm
I think the reason why the tree didnt work for the other guy who ended up in the pool is because they took down all the glass bottle with numbers, the numbers are a like a compass
Or he didn't took the right number with him ;) when tabitha left she had victors box and there was a number in it. so the numbers could be coordinates to places. that's why miranda hung them around the tree ..
Do you consider boats vehicles? On the painting it is depicting people arriving on boats encountering the tree. Since there’s train tracks logic would say there’s been people who got stuck there from trains as well. I wonder if we will ever see trains or a train station.
Absolutely agree, the boy in white sent her to collect Henry in a way. Also, why did everyone forget that Tabatha found the same bracelet in Henry’s car that she said Jim gifted to her. Henry might be older version of Jim. Finally, Henry’s and Jim’s eye color is exactly the same. From might be a memetic hazard like in SCP foundation.
Why has Henry not acknowledged Eloise? I think like Thomas Eloise is a deceased child of Henry and Miranda. Henry painted the paintings in the basement. I think he did the bottle trees and I don't think Miranda has any dreams. I think it was Henry. If the cycle keeps repeating, when a new batch of people get trapped are they manipulated to sacrifice their children? Was Miranda putting Victor in the cellar to hide him from Henry and from being sacrificed? Did Henry go to Fromville and escape and was Eloise a sacrifice? Did Miranda know of the time loop and try to save the kids to go back in time to undo the first sacrifices to save her children too? Henry believed Victor was dead. We have not seen the spiders since they bit Boyd. Did the spiders invade the town and massacre the townsfolk or did the townsfolk try to escape via trees and fall like the rock and fall to their death and then spiders ate them? Victor didn't bury the bodies.
@@MultiChaz1I understand why he wouldn't want to talk about Eloise. That's his child and he is 100% sure that she is dead. I Dont think he'd want to talk about her to Victor cause it could open old wounds. He mentioned her when Victor brought her up when he showed him her grave and it hurt him a lot especially after finding out what happened to her. It makes sense why he doesn't want to talk about her.
No real answers ever given, we learn things that don't really serve the big picture, and when they do, it doesn't mean anything, like the kids put all their hope into the roots and then that made the faraway tree. Yea, what does that reveal tell us? NOTHING! What does that mean? That means nothing, that doesn't help us understand anything. So yea, this show is just stringing us along.
I think it tells us something. People can make stuff happen. Out of hope (food, animals, talismans) or fear (giant spiders, cicadas). That is why the monsters want to break Boyd, because the hope of the populaion depends a lot on how strong Boyd is. He litteraly makes the town stronger. There are rules to this place, people receive different pieces of the puzzle and roles to fill. The big picture is they must understand what they can do with the informations in order to understand and defeat the entity who is playing them all / or there are different forces at stake and the entity is using the monsters (in the past were people) and an there is an other entity bringing back more people in town to defeat the entity
I think confirmation of hope being a fuel and focus was revealing. Lots of clues about hope being an important aspect of the town, the children having hope from the lullaby’s and the possibility of being saved. Whoever is pulling the strings clearly needs to keep hope alive to get to their end game.
The show isn’t done so. If they do it right, This show is a marathon to the answers. It’s green lit for season 4 and that’s not the final season so there much more time for them to bring it all together
And Henry said Miranda already spoke about saving the children from the tower but Victor said he told his mom about the children in the tower and that’s when she went and got killed trying to go find them but wouldn’t she have already known since she was painting it so nothing would have been new to her whatever the boy and white said that Victor heard
I think Victor's mom was leaving Henry. Why wasn't he with them that day? Everyone's marriage is on the rocks in this place so it's not hard to believe this was the case with Henry too. Victor is just too young to remember how bad it was. Maybe he was an alcoholic. Everything they mention is mentioned for a reason in this show.
Boyd relationship wasn’t on the rocks if I remember correctly Donna wasn’t in a relationship she was with her sister I don’t think this theory checks out
Maybe you are able to go back to Formville if you had loved ones inside. Tabitha had her family. It links her to it. And she's allowed out coz she can't truly escape if her family is inside. She won't leave them behind
The connection with Miranda is still there. I'm sure she was the one behind the lunchbox having the address. It's typical mom instruction I don't think Miranda and Eloise are dead
What is the BIW doing? Is he trying to get everyone home by playing a game or is he trying to keep the story going by playing a game? As of right now, we need to know if he wants to help the people, the children, the monsters, or the place if not one or all.
think it would be cool if the dad was faking, and turned out to be the main villain. Maybe the real dad died and the tall dark boss villain is in disguise as the dad
They show Henry with Victors drawings behind him in some scenes,it’s always a drawing of a white boogie man character.I think Miranda was leaving Henry because he is an alcoholic,and was doing bad things.Victor drew his father in another form,as a monster.He drew pictures of things he didn’t want to forget.Not a regular drawing of his father,but as he truly saw him as.(A monster)
I think that Ethan is the reincarnation of Victor, Victor is the reincarnation of the boy in white that is the first child in the ritual not being sacrificed. Both the reincarnations are in the town because Victor is from the old timeline and he is still alive. Tabitha is the mother of Ethan and the reincarnation of Miranda, Miranda is the mother of Victor and the reincarnation of the first woman that don’t do the ritual (mother of child in white). Julie is the sister of Ethan and the daughter of Tabitha and she is the reincarnation of Victor’s sister Eloise (i think that she is still alive too). As we have seen in the last episode, Jade (and not Jim) is the reincarnation of Tabitha’s husband in a past life, and the reincarnation of the husband of Miranda I don’t remember who was but it’s not Henry but a man that she meet in Fromville, like Jade and Tabitha
In conclusion, i think they have to go in Farmville to find eachother, maybe because the first couple in the past life meet there. To confirm this we have seen the death of Jim in the last episode because he isn’t really connected with the story. Sorry for my english but it’s not my language. What are you think about my theory?
I don't think its time travel whats happened. It feels more like time is just warped inside the threshold and when they finally start COMMUNICATING with each other they will really start to figure things out even if that means finding out that there is no more home other than Fromville
Yes. If I remember correctly, as Tabitha and Henry were in the ambulance, Acosta showed Tabitha the lunchbox saying she was the one they've been after.
Victor’s Mom or his sister probably wrote the address in the lunchbox….pretty sure they mentioned that it belonged to his sister. I remember doing this with mine as a kid.
Miranda got ripped apart before she entered the tree based on what we saw. So she might’ve been the one that needed to go but didn’t make it and then they had to wait for the next cycle.
I have a theory..... the more we like the show the longer everyone is trapped in fromville and the more people will die... hear me out. If we stop watching the show it will be canceled and they will be forced to wrap it up early thus saving lives and suffering!!!
I believe Victor is the mastermind behind Fromville. Being the oldest resident, he has an intimate knowledge of the town's intricate details. He seems to anticipate events like massacres, knowing exactly how many graves to prepare in advance. Victor is also highly selective about the information he shares, timing it precisely to influence others. He often disappears from town, retreating to secret hideouts. Victor's actions suggest a deeper agenda. For instance, he told Tabitha about the bottle tree and the lighthouse, fully aware it would lead her back to the real world. He even gave her his lunchbox with his father's address intentionally, likely to ensure his father would end up in the town. Furthermore, the boy in white appears to be working under his direction. In season 3, episode 8, Victor seems to be crafting a story about Christopher and might manipulate Jade into using the bottle tree to rescue the ankhoey children. It's also highly probable that Victor's father is working with him. Otherwise, why didn't he let Tabitha to get out of the car before the crash? It seems he was intentionally leading her to the bottle tree and into the town. But the arrival of the ambulance medics and Officer Acosta was likely unintended. That might explain why the medics were killed immediately, while Officer Acosta was lucky to survive-though perhaps not for long. Victor’s knowledge of the faraway trees seems precise, as he knows exactly which tree leads to which location. This allows him to manipulate events and teleport people to specific places. Remember when Dale ended up in the concrete wall of the swimming pool? That likely happened because Dale did something unexpected and could disrupt Victor's plan.
He can't be he only arrived there as a child and this has been going on for centuries. He is very important alright & has a massive role to play but it all good
Personally I think this is a very dumb take. I don’t think the show writers are looking to demonize children and adults with autism by making them *actually* evil masterminds. That doesn’t make any sense. You should really do some introspection on your aversion to people who are neurodivergent. They are more likely to be victims than perpetrators.
@@sunshinesc90unless the actors are literally faking autism and lyin the whole time Henry and everybody in Maine that interacted with Tabitha seemed totally suspicious even the phone call why even the friend asked why would you do that the priest Lee Tabitha to Henry getting her to open the lunch box before she left the church
I don't know what explanation they want to make for the show but they certainly have grasped the essence of trauma and its effects. About that part saying the answers are at the beginning that's generally what happens in life. The answers are always in the beginning and rooted in childhood trauma, even more in abuse. All of the characters clearly have childhood trauma and when you have it sooner or later it will get you to the fallen tree. You'll be stuck, unable to move on with life. You'll be in a state of constant fear and haunted ( and hunted) by nightmares. So many are surviving in Fromville in plain sight in an invisible struggle to the eyes of others
That's why I think this is all a crazy therapy VR session made by jade software company. Jade is an Ai that doesn't know he is an Ai and that's why there are so many useless npc ppl in the background. I don't actually believe this. But it would be funny if it was.
Martin and Henry look a lot alike,I saw Victor dressed in Yellow, and he looked like the man in yellow,just an older version of him.Tabitha is Henry's wife and Victor's mom,reborn,in my opinion lol
Ar the end of this show I believe they will all just be back in whatever vehicle they were in before they arrived at Fromville and the tree will not be there anymore.
I wonder on the theory of fromville needing to be balanced. Would Tabitha still be included with the numbers even though she left? Henry and Acosta would be accounted for with the 2 EMT's I assume. Way off topic but it's mentioned about Tabitha leaving Fromville as a tether and it makes sense in that aspect.
I think Tabitha needed to go and get the Police Officer girl. I think she has an important role to play. Henry is just tagging along to help his son with the Boy IW's plans. Victor's head is too scrambled and needs a boost. The gun - the Police Officer needs the gun for something. She got it back but not the bullets. Why that gun?
How could the boy in white be in the real world? I don't think Tabitha was in the real world, i think Henry planned on her to come get him. He seems really comfortable being stuck in from.
Paintings don’t really change if they’re in a climate controlled environment. Plus it’s TV so technically they are recently painted. 😅 What do think happens to paintings? They would not deteriorate in a balanced environment. It’s also only been 40-50 years. They weren’t exposed to the outside elements but inside an air conditioned and heated home.
@@jaeshasway generally speaking, people dont keep painful reminders. they pack them up or get rid of them. after 40-50 years they would at least be dusty. and in terms of it being TV, if the props department wanted them to look old they would look old. but they dont, they look fresh. I dont get how you can think so hard about it and not realize that. I think he's the one who has the visions and does the paintings, the basement is set up as his studio.
I wonder why nobody is talking about the priest when Tabitha went to the real world cause how did he know the baby Tabitha lost was a boy and not a girl
I'm starting to think that maybe the Boy In White has a nefarious agenda and in one of the scenes in s5 (or whenever it finishes) , there is film of him morphing into a red blob or 'Thomas's' voice comes out of his mouth. Could be wrong, lets see. I'm not sure of the backstory but it could happen🤔.
but y all the houses on henry's side of the street look like fromville but on the other side of the street more modern? also y did victor tell sara that Eloise's favorite playhouse was the one sara lives in, which happens to be the same color and style as henry's? so is sara Eloise reincarnated? she is brave and sneaky....is fromville all occurring in henry's house in a parallel dimension or wild dream or wild children's storybook? y does Miranda's painting of the talisman have one being as opposed to 2 like fromville? hmm
If Jade was supposed to go through the tree then why didn't the boy in white make himself known to Jade and direct him to go through the tree? Especially when the boy in right was right there in front of the tree with Jade.
Marinda didn't get to make it through the tree she was deleted before entering and Tabitha is marinda the question is who is the guy in the yellow and will the boy in white help them escape the man in yellow
Maybe when victor his mom and sister left how about that was his lunch box from school and he took it with him when they left and just like a lot of parents do they write their kids name and address on or in their belongings in case it gets lost
The boy in white clearly evil he dances and plays on dead bodies right after the massacre as if that’s what he wanted also Victoria is a liar and he clearly made mistakes which will be an ongoing thing have to stay open with what really happened because his story contradicts Henry story meaning one is lying
Miranda didn’t know about the children. She didn’t know about the children until Victor told her so Miranda couldn’t have painted the pictures. Henry had to have painted the pictures.
When the boy in white said you have to go to the beginning to find the ending I think that victor, Tabitha and jade has to go through the faraway tree to the beginning to free the children so they all can be released. I found out information from another channel that the numbers could be French sheet music. Jade plays the music on the violin this could release the children, and free everyone
Now That "Victor's" Memory Has Been Shown to Be "Wonky", It's Hard to Tell What *REALLY* Happened in "Victor's" "FromVille" "Past".🤔 (& TheWay The "TownsFolk" BeHave Like *Fenced-In-Sheep,* is Beginning to Make Me Lose Interest in TheShow.😒) HopeFully "Boyd" "Rounds-Up" an (MidEvil-Weapon)"Armed-Posse" to Search for "Fatima", & See What Some "Hack&Slash" "Melee" Weapons Can Do...Finally!💥
"Victor" Gave His "LunchBox" to "Tabitha" for "Supplies" & Because He Didn't Want Any Harm to Come to Her. "Victor" "Projected" His Feelings Towards His "Mother" *AT* "Tabitha", When He Gave Her "TheLunchBox".
The problem with this show. Everything is scripted. Characters are like puppets, everything everyone follow the light of The Boy in White or Ghost Lady or A mysterious voice. Its just borring. Peoples of Fromville are lemmings/Sims/Pnj....stop i want real twist, real climax, real turnover.
Im jealous of all the people who arent gonna find this show til its finished already cause they get to binge it. Theyll never understand the pain of us in real time viewers having to wait a week between these under 1 hour episodes
Fr
😂 I'm mad at myself for catching up too quick. I feel the pain of day 1 fans.
THE WRITTERS OF THIS SHOW are as cruel as the creatures
They are just feeding on our hope.
That Is why they killed tillie
Very cruel show
But i love it
With all the plots going, 45 min is cruel and unusual punishment
Binging leaves no room for creativity. Patience is entertainment!
I think Henry is just the key to unlock Victor. Victor was too comfortable living in fromville, and needed hope that there is an outside world
Or complacency. If the one thing he could return to comes to him, he has no real reason to leave. I think either way, the entity or fromville itself is manipulating him into something.
That's a good point, he's basically been there his whole life. I do think if anyone is involved Victor would make sense, but I hope they show more of his time there alone.
Those monsters said Victor if you wanna stay here, you either going to work or go to school 😂@@natanoodle3303
Victor isn't comfortable at all, hiding is still not comfort, it's seeking refuge. and also think about it, cans of peaches, he's been there 40 years. we've never really seen him eat, canned peaches are good 2-5 years not 40 years. and the monster in the cave said to him "we will have to make you stay here" not "kill you", people theorise he's a monster, and people also theorise Donna is a monster or monster mole, as her last name isn't revealed and her past is not shared via flashback, and Tabitha couldn't remember her last name for Henry to search missing persons, we don't know her last name. as well as we don't know Accosta's first name.
Victor was already looking for answers before his dad pulled up. He was out with Sarah talking bout finding jasper
Just finished season 1-3 in like 2-3 days best binge watch ever … we need s4 ASAP
Miranda didnt go through the tree because smiley killed her before she got in the tree. Did you miss that episode?
Same thought 😂
i think the only way to save the children is by going back in time in 1600 and stop the ritual from happening in which all the children were sacrificed in some ritual. As we already know that time travel is possible going through the far away trees. I think if jade or henry will go through that tree they will reach in 1600 somehow and then they had to stop the ritual from happening which will also save the children and will also free the town from the curse.
not only with the trees .. julie was around too when it happened
What episode do they time travel through a tree?
@@peterd3215 Boyd going through the faraway free in S1 final episode and end up in the tunnel in the past where there was Martin chained up.
@@saurabhtripathi7915 that's debatably in the past. It's not 100% at this point if Boyd time travelled or just travelled because he opened the door and was in the present. Should he have opened the door to the past aswell if he was in the past already? Julie definitely time travelled to the time of Boyd stuck in the chimney but she didn't even step in a tree.
@@peterd3215 spot on trees are more teleportation for me
I hope it turns out the Henry is actually the one that caused the death of everyone in the town, other than Victor. It was a price he paid to go back home and Victor has just forgotten about it.
@@msdmckayEverything's fine but can u tell me who's man in yellow man when it appeared?
That would be f*cked up if that was the case lol.
It waa Christopher who killed everyone in the town, from season 1…
Ever notice Henry's place is decorated like the houses in Fromville?
I swear I was thinking the exact same thing as i watched this video. Theres more to Henry and Victor..
That was the style of house in Maine, and I'm sure after his family went missing, he wasn't too concerned about updating the house.
@@IndicaKing-i3x but y all the houses on henry's side of the street look like fromville but on the other side of the street more modern? also y did victor tell sara that Eloise's favorite playhouse was the one sara lives in, which happens to be the same color and style as henry's? so is sara Eloise reincarnated? she is brave and sneaky....is fromville all occurring in henry's house in a parallel dimension or wild dream or wild children's storybook? y does Miranda's painting of the talisman have one being as opposed to 2 like fromville? hmm
I think the reason why the tree didnt work for the other guy who ended up in the pool is because they took down all the glass bottle with numbers, the numbers are a like a compass
Or he didn't took the right number with him ;) when tabitha left she had victors box and there was a number in it. so the numbers could be coordinates to places. that's why miranda hung them around the tree ..
True or he gotta go in the tree at night like everyone else did lol
The number was vic address @@fourfistsforfunk
I think everyone has a role and his wasn't to escape
Only certain people can get to the lighthouse Dale is not one of them
I feel like Henry was the key to unlock Victor, Tabitha and Jade’s memories.
Interesting you only get to fromville in a vehicle.
Yeah, no walking, no helicopter, no plane because that’s to similar to lost
Do you consider boats vehicles? On the painting it is depicting people arriving on boats encountering the tree. Since there’s train tracks logic would say there’s been people who got stuck there from trains as well. I wonder if we will ever see trains or a train station.
Once you see the tree, there is no going back. You can walk to town or drive there in your car.
@James-i8g4g yeah u can get to the tree by boat or driving. It's just that driving is the most popular
If you walking it Lessings the chance of even making it to town cause if night hits while your in route your cooked
Absolutely agree, the boy in white sent her to collect Henry in a way. Also, why did everyone forget that Tabatha found the same bracelet in Henry’s car that she said Jim gifted to her. Henry might be older version of Jim. Finally, Henry’s and Jim’s eye color is exactly the same. From might be a memetic hazard like in SCP foundation.
What NO keep thinking
Yesss she was getting suspicious of Henry and asking questions right before the crash happened.
well it got answered that tabitha is the reincarnation of miranda(herny's wife and victor's mother) and she learned she made that.
Everybody at FROM has a previous connection or connected to someone who does. Except a few ppl .
Why has Henry not acknowledged Eloise? I think like Thomas Eloise is a deceased child of Henry and Miranda. Henry painted the paintings in the basement. I think he did the bottle trees and I don't think Miranda has any dreams. I think it was Henry. If the cycle keeps repeating, when a new batch of people get trapped are they manipulated to sacrifice their children? Was Miranda putting Victor in the cellar to hide him from Henry and from being sacrificed? Did Henry go to Fromville and escape and was Eloise a sacrifice? Did Miranda know of the time loop and try to save the kids to go back in time to undo the first sacrifices to save her children too? Henry believed Victor was dead. We have not seen the spiders since they bit Boyd. Did the spiders invade the town and massacre the townsfolk or did the townsfolk try to escape via trees and fall like the rock and fall to their death and then spiders ate them? Victor didn't bury the bodies.
Bro that’s a whole point. He has literally only talked about Miranda and victor
@@MultiChaz1he did ask about Eloise when he asked Victor if that was her grave
@@MultiChaz1I understand why he wouldn't want to talk about Eloise. That's his child and he is 100% sure that she is dead. I Dont think he'd want to talk about her to Victor cause it could open old wounds. He mentioned her when Victor brought her up when he showed him her grave and it hurt him a lot especially after finding out what happened to her. It makes sense why he doesn't want to talk about her.
No real answers ever given, we learn things that don't really serve the big picture, and when they do, it doesn't mean anything, like the kids put all their hope into the roots and then that made the faraway tree. Yea, what does that reveal tell us? NOTHING! What does that mean? That means nothing, that doesn't help us understand anything. So yea, this show is just stringing us along.
I think it tells us something. People can make stuff happen. Out of hope (food, animals, talismans) or fear (giant spiders, cicadas). That is why the monsters want to break Boyd, because the hope of the populaion depends a lot on how strong Boyd is. He litteraly makes the town stronger. There are rules to this place, people receive different pieces of the puzzle and roles to fill. The big picture is they must understand what they can do with the informations in order to understand and defeat the entity who is playing them all / or there are different forces at stake and the entity is using the monsters (in the past were people) and an there is an other entity bringing back more people in town to defeat the entity
@jeanjeanjean2541 well that's a lot of speculation ,it cojld be true but it seems like that's a lot of things we are no where near finding out. Idk
I think confirmation of hope being a fuel and focus was revealing. Lots of clues about hope being an important aspect of the town, the children having hope from the lullaby’s and the possibility of being saved. Whoever is pulling the strings clearly needs to keep hope alive to get to their end game.
The show isn’t done so. If they do it right, This show is a marathon to the answers. It’s green lit for season 4 and that’s not the final season so there much more time for them to bring it all together
Martin looks likeHenry now to me. If he reveals hewas [is] a Marine! That will clench it.
😂😂😂😂
since i saw a picture in victors room with a white monster with the same hair style as victors dad i was 100% sure henry is evil
😂😂😂😂
And Henry said Miranda already spoke about saving the children from the tower but Victor said he told his mom about the children in the tower and that’s when she went and got killed trying to go find them but wouldn’t she have already known since she was painting it so nothing would have been new to her whatever the boy and white said that Victor heard
I think Victor's mom was leaving Henry. Why wasn't he with them that day? Everyone's marriage is on the rocks in this place so it's not hard to believe this was the case with Henry too. Victor is just too young to remember how bad it was. Maybe he was an alcoholic. Everything they mention is mentioned for a reason in this show.
Boyd relationship wasn’t on the rocks if I remember correctly Donna wasn’t in a relationship she was with her sister I don’t think this theory checks out
There’s no proof at all that she had left him. It was supposed to be a day trip. He was drinking because he had lost his entire family.
Have to die to get out.
Maybe you are able to go back to Formville if you had loved ones inside. Tabitha had her family. It links her to it. And she's allowed out coz she can't truly escape if her family is inside. She won't leave them behind
The connection with Miranda is still there. I'm sure she was the one behind the lunchbox having the address. It's typical mom instruction
I don't think Miranda and Eloise are dead
I think Henry is either Martin or the man in yellow…
How do we know that Christopher didn’t go through the tree? Just because he thought it was a lie doesn’t mean he didn’t go through anyway…
What is the BIW doing? Is he trying to get everyone home by playing a game or is he trying to keep the story going by playing a game? As of right now, we need to know if he wants to help the people, the children, the monsters, or the place if not one or all.
3:03 victor has already sId he found his mom right outside the tree and she didn't make it to the tree
Like he said she could have dropped under the tree like the stone he threw with Ethan
Henry has memories with Miranda. Maybe it's not something in Victor he's there to unlock but something Miranda told Henry that they need
I actually think it Victors nightmare and he has used these people to bring his family back. I think Acosta is Eloise.
I think she is too young ,I say she is in her mid to late 20s , Eloise was maybe couple years younger than Victor , and he seems maybe mid 40s?
Lmfao 🤣 what
Henry is not evil he got to many touching moments already at least 5 moments
If Tabitha is Miranda reincarnated or if she’s just having her memories then maybe we will get memories of what she saw during the acid trip?
think it would be cool if the dad was faking, and turned out to be the main villain. Maybe the real dad died and the tall dark boss villain is in disguise as the dad
They show Henry with Victors drawings behind him in some scenes,it’s always a drawing of a white boogie man character.I think Miranda was leaving Henry because he is an alcoholic,and was doing bad things.Victor drew his father in another form,as a monster.He drew pictures of things he didn’t want to forget.Not a regular drawing of his father,but as he truly saw him as.(A monster)
I think that Ethan is the reincarnation of Victor, Victor is the reincarnation of the boy in white that is the first child in the ritual not being sacrificed. Both the reincarnations are in the town because Victor is from the old timeline and he is still alive. Tabitha is the mother of Ethan and the reincarnation of Miranda, Miranda is the mother of Victor and the reincarnation of the first woman that don’t do the ritual (mother of child in white). Julie is the sister of Ethan and the daughter of Tabitha and she is the reincarnation of Victor’s sister Eloise (i think that she is still alive too). As we have seen in the last episode, Jade (and not Jim) is the reincarnation of Tabitha’s husband in a past life, and the reincarnation of the husband of Miranda I don’t remember who was but it’s not Henry but a man that she meet in Fromville, like Jade and Tabitha
In conclusion, i think they have to go in Farmville to find eachother, maybe because the first couple in the past life meet there. To confirm this we have seen the death of Jim in the last episode because he isn’t really connected with the story. Sorry for my english but it’s not my language. What are you think about my theory?
I don't think its time travel whats happened. It feels more like time is just warped inside the threshold and when they finally start COMMUNICATING with each other they will really start to figure things out even if that means finding out that there is no more home other than Fromville
I want to know who martin is ans why he knew Julie and not Boyd
Is Victor the boy in white? Or is he related to thr boy in white
henry has always been on my sus list even above tilly
Whatever happened to the lunch box? Did it come back with Tabitha?
Yes. If I remember correctly, as Tabitha and Henry were in the ambulance, Acosta showed Tabitha the lunchbox saying she was the one they've been after.
Lol and Victor still got that Glock on him lolol
@@1Bandt lol
Victor’s Mom or his sister probably wrote the address in the lunchbox….pretty sure they mentioned that it belonged to his sister. I remember doing this with mine as a kid.
Miranda got ripped apart before she entered the tree based on what we saw. So she might’ve been the one that needed to go but didn’t make it and then they had to wait for the next cycle.
I have a theory..... the more we like the show the longer everyone is trapped in fromville and the more people will die... hear me out. If we stop watching the show it will be canceled and they will be forced to wrap it up early thus saving lives and suffering!!!
I believe Victor is the mastermind behind Fromville. Being the oldest resident, he has an intimate knowledge of the town's intricate details. He seems to anticipate events like massacres, knowing exactly how many graves to prepare in advance. Victor is also highly selective about the information he shares, timing it precisely to influence others. He often disappears from town, retreating to secret hideouts.
Victor's actions suggest a deeper agenda. For instance, he told Tabitha about the bottle tree and the lighthouse, fully aware it would lead her back to the real world. He even gave her his lunchbox with his father's address intentionally, likely to ensure his father would end up in the town. Furthermore, the boy in white appears to be working under his direction. In season 3, episode 8, Victor seems to be crafting a story about Christopher and might manipulate Jade into using the bottle tree to rescue the ankhoey children.
It's also highly probable that Victor's father is working with him. Otherwise, why didn't he let Tabitha to get out of the car before the crash? It seems he was intentionally leading her to the bottle tree and into the town.
But the arrival of the ambulance medics and Officer Acosta was likely unintended. That might explain why the medics were killed immediately, while Officer Acosta was lucky to survive-though perhaps not for long. Victor’s knowledge of the faraway trees seems precise, as he knows exactly which tree leads to which location. This allows him to manipulate events and teleport people to specific places. Remember when Dale ended up in the concrete wall of the swimming pool? That likely happened because Dale did something unexpected and could disrupt Victor's plan.
He can't be he only arrived there as a child and this has been going on for centuries. He is very important alright & has a massive role to play but it all good
Personally I think this is a very dumb take. I don’t think the show writers are looking to demonize children and adults with autism by making them *actually* evil masterminds. That doesn’t make any sense. You should really do some introspection on your aversion to people who are neurodivergent. They are more likely to be victims than perpetrators.
He’s autistic.
@@sunshinesc90 super dumb but its rage bait
@@sunshinesc90unless the actors are literally faking autism and lyin the whole time Henry and everybody in Maine that interacted with Tabitha seemed totally suspicious even the phone call why even the friend asked why would you do that the priest Lee Tabitha to Henry getting her to open the lunch box before she left the church
Entities didn't kill people in hospital car maybe try to hide Henry identitt
I don't know what explanation they want to make for the show but they certainly have grasped the essence of trauma and its effects.
About that part saying the answers are at the beginning that's generally what happens in life. The answers are always in the beginning and rooted in childhood trauma, even more in abuse.
All of the characters clearly have childhood trauma and when you have it sooner or later it will get you to the fallen tree. You'll be stuck, unable to move on with life. You'll be in a state of constant fear and haunted ( and hunted) by nightmares.
So many are surviving in Fromville in plain sight in an invisible struggle to the eyes of others
That's why I think this is all a crazy therapy VR session made by jade software company. Jade is an Ai that doesn't know he is an Ai and that's why there are so many useless npc ppl in the background.
I don't actually believe this. But it would be funny if it was.
Martin and Henry look a lot alike,I saw Victor dressed in Yellow, and he looked like the man in yellow,just an older version of him.Tabitha is Henry's wife and Victor's mom,reborn,in my opinion lol
Ar the end of this show I believe they will all just be back in whatever vehicle they were in before they arrived at Fromville and the tree will not be there anymore.
I think the numbers on the tree is what ur suppose to use as a location time or place Tabatha had Victors mom address in that lunch bag
The address would’ve likely been in the lunchbox from when Victor was a child.
Did I miss something? Why didn't it occure to anyone in the town to just cut apart the tree in the road to leave?
What About Tabitha Was Suppose To Bring Acosta Too!!
You're already too late my man, we've already figured it out, fair try though, tbh
I wonder on the theory of fromville needing to be balanced. Would Tabitha still be included with the numbers even though she left? Henry and Acosta would be accounted for with the 2 EMT's I assume. Way off topic but it's mentioned about Tabitha leaving Fromville as a tether and it makes sense in that aspect.
Why was Henry not brought there with his family originally if he's important.
I think Tabitha needed to go and get the Police Officer girl. I think she has an important role to play. Henry is just tagging along to help his son with the Boy IW's plans. Victor's head is too scrambled and needs a boost. The gun - the Police Officer needs the gun for something. She got it back but not the bullets. Why that gun?
Smile, just keep that in ur head with the season coming to a head, also with a lot of Red
Spoilers aint big or clever, mr richard splash
Did she save the "child", who's name is Victor?
Yes ,he is the new Tillie...
I think Henry is the Old Man on the Wall... in a future time
How could the boy in white be in the real world? I don't think Tabitha was in the real world, i think Henry planned on her to come get him. He seems really comfortable being stuck in from.
Maybe he's just happy to be reunited with a son he lost long ago, and now doesn't want to lose again.
Why wasn't Henry on the field trip ??
Season 3 episode 10 explains who was supposed to save the children.
I thought the tree worked for Tabitha because Victor gave her his lunch box.
Henry is sus af.
those paintings looking real fresh.
Paintings don’t really change if they’re in a climate controlled environment. Plus it’s TV so technically they are recently painted. 😅 What do think happens to paintings? They would not deteriorate in a balanced environment. It’s also only been 40-50 years. They weren’t exposed to the outside elements but inside an air conditioned and heated home.
@@jaeshasway generally speaking, people dont keep painful reminders. they pack them up or get rid of them. after 40-50 years they would at least be dusty.
and in terms of it being TV, if the props department wanted them to look old they would look old. but they dont, they look fresh. I dont get how you can think so hard about it and not realize that.
I think he's the one who has the visions and does the paintings, the basement is set up as his studio.
I wonder why nobody is talking about the priest when Tabitha went to the real world cause how did he know the baby Tabitha lost was a boy and not a girl
What if at the end of this season the town turns back into the 1600’s and they’re all in shock ! But it’s to stop the cause of all this
I'm starting to think that maybe the Boy In White has a nefarious agenda and in one of the scenes in s5 (or whenever it finishes) , there is film of him morphing into a red blob or 'Thomas's' voice comes out of his mouth. Could be wrong, lets see. I'm not sure of the backstory but it could happen🤔.
I think it was always victor 😮
but y all the houses on henry's side of the street look like fromville but on the other side of the street more modern? also y did victor tell sara that Eloise's favorite playhouse was the one sara lives in, which happens to be the same color and style as henry's? so is sara Eloise reincarnated? she is brave and sneaky....is fromville all occurring in henry's house in a parallel dimension or wild dream or wild children's storybook? y does Miranda's painting of the talisman have one being as opposed to 2 like fromville? hmm
If Jade was supposed to go through the tree then why didn't the boy in white make himself known to Jade and direct him to go through the tree? Especially when the boy in right was right there in front of the tree with Jade.
Marinda didn't get to make it through the tree she was deleted before entering and Tabitha is marinda the question is who is the guy in the yellow and will the boy in white help them escape the man in yellow
Wanst that the second ambulnace that ended up in the town.
Henry is Ethan!!!!!
Hoe do we Victor's mom is dead? We haven't seen a body she can be in the real world now
Have you even look at the show
Miranda didn’t make it into the tree she was killed by the monsters :) also Boyd Entered and didn’t die so is Sarah And Julie
you have to be invited to the tree to survive
The boy in white is victor. The man in yellow is Ethan
Nah
Maybe when victor his mom and sister left how about that was his lunch box from school and he took it with him when they left and just like a lot of parents do they write their kids name and address on or in their belongings in case it gets lost
Why are you spitting right now you’re definitely right
The boy in white clearly evil he dances and plays on dead bodies right after the massacre as if that’s what he wanted also Victoria is a liar and he clearly made mistakes which will be an ongoing thing have to stay open with what really happened because his story contradicts Henry story meaning one is lying
Miranda didn’t know about the children. She didn’t know about the children until Victor told her so Miranda couldn’t have painted the pictures. Henry had to have painted the pictures.
White boy - Henry
Victor - Henry
Tabitha - Henry
Director - Henry
As it stands laker guy!!
When the boy in white said you have to go to the beginning to find the ending I think that victor, Tabitha and jade has to go through the faraway tree to the beginning to free the children so they all can be released. I found out information from another channel that the numbers could be French sheet music. Jade plays the music on the violin this could release the children, and free everyone
I would’ve nevertheless returned
Now That "Victor's" Memory Has Been Shown to Be "Wonky", It's Hard to Tell What *REALLY* Happened in "Victor's" "FromVille" "Past".🤔
(& TheWay The "TownsFolk" BeHave Like *Fenced-In-Sheep,* is Beginning to Make Me Lose Interest in TheShow.😒)
HopeFully "Boyd" "Rounds-Up" an (MidEvil-Weapon)"Armed-Posse" to Search for "Fatima", & See What Some "Hack&Slash" "Melee" Weapons Can Do...Finally!💥
"Victor" Gave His "LunchBox" to "Tabitha" for "Supplies" & Because He Didn't Want Any Harm to Come to Her. "Victor" "Projected" His Feelings Towards His "Mother" *AT* "Tabitha", When He Gave Her "TheLunchBox".
Victor is dreaming that's all
Smiley killed miranda
The problem with this show. Everything is scripted. Characters are like puppets, everything everyone follow the light of The Boy in White or Ghost Lady or A mysterious voice. Its just borring.
Peoples of Fromville are lemmings/Sims/Pnj....stop i want real twist, real climax, real turnover.
I thought this was common sense. They let her go so she could go get Henry.
This current season is crap. Three seasons down and still carrying the very same questions from season 1.
You're just not a smart person.
There are fundamental questions that won't be answered until the end of the show. Are you that ignorant?
Haha is this satire? Fooled me into a view :)
i think Tily is the kimono lady and Henry is Martin
This was horrible and boring made no sense
If Victor didn't told Miranda maybe msaaccare Wil never happened in first place