Wish You Were Here, Side 2 [Pink Floyd Reaction] Have a Cigar, Shine On You Crazy Diamond: Parts 6-9
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 чер 2024
- Dev's first time reaction hearing Pink Floyd's Wish You Were Here album (1975) concludes with the entire Side 2: Have a Cigar, Wish You Were Here, Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI - IX)
Our reaction with the music in 5.1 surround - • Pink Floyd-Wish You We...
This is Dev's first time listening to this album. Mike hasn't heard it in a LONG time. We are re-experiencing classic rock music, an album at a time, with fresh perspectives and active ears, so that Dev can learn and appreciate this music more, and so that Mike can relive his childhood.
00:00 - Introduction
02:55 - Have a Cigar
08:03 - Wish You Were Here
13:36 - Shine On You Crazy Diamond
25:57 - Album Wrap-Up
🔔 Don't forget to subscribe to our channel!
/ musicforbusypeople
💲 Exclusive videos and more on Patreon - / musicforbusypeople
💲 You can also give us a donation/tip by clicking on the ❤️Thanks button or through PayPal - paypal.me/powerforbusypeople
Donations of $5 or more will receive recognition in our next video.
🎸 Wish You Were Here LIVE reaction - • Wish You Were Here LIV...
🎶 Wish You Were Here playlist - • Shine On You Crazy Dia...
✅ Instagram - / gaming4busypeople
✅ Discord - / discord
This video contains the following music:
🎵 Have a Cigar by Pink Floyd (1975) - • Have A Cigar
🎵 Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd (1975) - • Wish You Were Here
🎵 Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI - IX) by Pink Floyd (1975) - • Shine On You Crazy Dia...
#musicreaction #pinkfloyd #WishYouWereHere #HaveACigar #ShineOnYouCrazyDiamond #reaction #songreaction #firsttimehearing #firsttimereaction #firsttimelistening
© 2023 by Music for Busy People. All rights reserved.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
![Wish You Were Here LIVE [Pink Floyd Reaction] + Welcome to the Machine, Foo Fighters: Have a Cigar](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KgEtFjXrCkw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Wish You Were Here LIVE [Pink Floyd Reaction] + Welcome to the Machine, Foo Fighters: Have a Cigar](/img/tr.png)
![Us and Them, Brain Damage [Pink Floyd Reaction] Eclipse-First time hearing The Dark Side of the Moon](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_XofN6ljt9w/mqdefault.jpg)
![Shine On You Crazy Diamond [Pink Floyd Reaction] Parts 1-5, First time hearing Wish You Were Here](/img/n.gif)
Thank you to the following community members who subscribed after this video was published. I wish we could thank you all.
_Bobby P., Jungliat pil, Thomasmoro61, valkyrie70, DTenacity, Ken D., Gianluca F., djmadmanny1, Philippe B., Nate R., WMalven, Domenico C, Pierre C., John D., Demented avenger, Jerry T., Johnpaul A., Liam O'Dhomnalla'in, EATherridan, Paul F., Wim van G., Ken M., jahinkson, Cristian A., Demynas_
Roy harper and the band where great friends,Roy has some great material out there too,as doesn’t his son nick who is pretty amazing check him out.
Gilmour's solos, yes, but can we please stand back in awe and contemplate the genius that was Richard Wright?
Thank you for listening to the whole album side!! It's how they were made to be heard, and you get something many other "reactors" miss because of their fixation of singles!!
That was actually Richard Wrights cough. And when he heard it on tape he realized he needed to quit smoking, and he did quit. But he still died of lung cancer in 2008 RIP Richard. just an FYI.
That's actually an interesting piece of trivia
@@vickjr98 The story I heard was that it was David Gilmour, and he was the one who quit smoking as a result. That fact seems more plausible because I've heard interviews of David Gilmour where he says that while he was touring with Wright on his 2006 solo tour, he'd see Wright nervously smoking backstage before going out to play.
The story I heard was that it was David Gilmour, and he was the one who quit smoking as a result. That fact seems more plausible because I've heard interviews of David Gilmour where he says that while he was touring with Wright on his 2006 solo tour, he'd see Wright nervously smoking backstage before going out to play.
will I did hear it from an interview with the band members. I really don't know who is right but thanks anyway.@@SteveMenardDesignDXM
FLOYD FOREVER!!! ONE OF THE THE GREATEST BANDS EVER, PERIOD.🥁☮☘
Nice to find someone who listens to this without talking crap every two minutes, nice 🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃🇬🇧🙃
I think Harper's vocals did a good job representing the temptations of the business, and trying to stay true to your path while being pulled and pressured to change what you are for trinkets and treasure.
'I didn't like it much as a kid but like it now as a more mature person'. That made me laugh, love you guys 🧡
Love their sarcasm!! ;) "we can hardly COUNT!"
$ $ $
Smokin doobies in my buddy’s basement for the first time when this came out.Waited for the record store to open. It’s all coming back to me now✌️❤️
Floyd have a deep emotional depth to their music
Hats off to Roy Harper
Weird fact. Not as weird as Syd Barrett showing up but anyway. In 1975 I owned a couple mbination turntable and radio player, it was pretty decent quality but would never tune in to FM stereo broadcasts. The single and only time it actually connected to a stereo FM show was the preview of WYWH on the BBC Radio 1 show hosted by Alan Freeman in 1975!!
I had just bought a quad receiver for over $400 in the 70's and this album. when the front channels went out after Cigar I was PISSED. then WYWH came on it blew me away. there might have a fatty involved too. Dave once said this was his favorite album even dealing with Roger. Heard Floyd live seven times and this song played all over the world , one thing that always happen is the crowd sing to this no matter were it's played. 6 thru 9 so many brain cells lost.
You got to love the dramatic ending. So emotive
11:04 It's called melodic phrasing. In this context, it's vocal phrasing. David is vocalizing every note he's playing. Jimi Hendrix did this often.
I remember hearing an uninterrupted full album preview on UK BBC Radio 2 in the experimental BBC quadraphonic broadcasting in 1975. Still remember thinking WTF and the stereo system had failed when transitioning from Have A Cigar to Wish You Were Here was happening 😀
The AM radio thing at the end of "Have A Cigar" leading into WYWH, is significant of what we all did, (including myself), as young guitarists back in the 60s.
I am 67 years old today and when I very young, me and my friends, who were playing guitar, were doing the exact same thing that Gilmour and Barrett were doing,......
....We would listen to the radio, (virtually exclusively AM radio), to learn our favorite songs, by trying to play along with them, we would figure out the chords and the solos!
That's what's going on with the AM radio thing between the first two songs on side two, it is meant to represent that part of their youth. The first acoustic guitar is coming from the radio, and the other acoustic, a much clearer tone, is either Syd or David, symbolically, or both of them trying to learn the song.
Likely meant to be Syd I think, because the guitar is the intro to WYWH.
Keep in mind, Dave Gilmour and Syd Barrett were friends even before Pink Floyd.
I’m reluctant to think of any OTHER person on the globe who should have sung “Have a Cigar” besides Roy Harper. It’s like the song was made for him.
Gilmour could definitely....
Love that the tracks just segue seamlessly from one to the next so it's impossible to know where one stops and the next starts. And I almost prefer Shine 6 to 9 over 1 to 5, certainly the lead up to the sung verse.
The transition from first to second is to reprecent a radio being dialed in
As you do not seem to know, in the segue after "Have A Cigar" it moves to the song being heard on AM radio, followed by a brief excerpt of a talk show on BBC Radio 4 then there is an orchestra playing part of Tchaikovsky's Symphony No 4.
The final riff Rick plays is from the early Pink Floyd track "See Emily Play" by Syd Barrett
Saw Floyd in 1988 in London. Nice
The last 8 notes you hear at the end as it fades out, is Rick Wright doing an homage within the entire homage. It's a melody from "See Emily Play" which was a Syd Barrett track.
Welcome to the machine is the best song on the album
I wonder if it was the "gre-EEN" bit which made them switch out Waters. The transition from the cold steel breeze into Wright's hopeful horns is one of the best things ever.
I believe you need to listen to the studio versions first then the live. With the studio versions you get the great engineering. Don’t get me wrong the live versions are just as great, but the studio versions are how they are intended to be listened too.
Great reaction. The subtle acknowledgments of some of the lyrics was spot on. I always thought the songs Welcome To The Machine into Have a cigar was so well done. The elevator, the party, and right in thick of it the sleazy record executive. "We're so happy we can barely count."
Great reaction guys.
For me, Wish You Were Here (the song) is about Roger and David. Roger just came up with the song because they needed a song to fill out the album. It’s about him and Dave and how they tour and tour and tour but their friendship started to suffer and this is the beginning of their drift apart.
Mike that long fade out was meant to be just the synth but the last 20/30 seconds is the tribute to Syd that Richard Wright just came up with while he was recording his organ part. It’s a variation on one of Syds songs.
I saw Roy Harper sing Have A Cigar for Pink Floyd at Knebworth July 1975.
I've heard the bootleg for that and it's fantastic to hear him play it live with the band!
Join the club my friend. Did you get your free dose of the blue haze when it descended just as evening was falling? Great day: interesting and varied line-up of acts (Linda Lewis, Roy Harper & Trigger, Chris Spedding, Captain Beefheart and the Steve Miller band), fabulous weather and a hugely chilled-out crowd. Magic Times Indeed.
@@Kriegsgefangener31 Yes it was a great line up. Didn’t a couple of Spitfires fly above the crowd just as Floyd hit the stage????
@@malcshone4409 One Spitfire, one Hurricane. 😎
@@Kriegsgefangener31 Coolio!!😎✈️✈️
if you're going to watch them live you need to see the reunion set they did at live 8 in 2005. the last time all four played together. it was the day hell froze over, and pigs flew.
The last part is a tribute to Syd with 'See Emily Play'
18:25 love this band!❤ It's a nice, progressive intro, then suddenly it's a beautiful waltz to introduce the vocals. Perfect, really.
Thoroughly enjoyed this reaction, though I must be honest and admit that the music is the main reason for my enthusiasm. But take heart -- the ratio is only 60 / 40 . Certainly you wouldn't expect a higher rating in your favor when listening to Pink Floyd, would you? Of course you wouldn't.
Because you two are laid-back cool meek people with a firm grip on reality. And this makes you both very likable. Y'all's love for music is infectious and inspiring. Not sure why you don't have more subscribers. But just keep on doing what you are doing. Build the channel ... they will come. And I hope you guys get rich from this channel. 😊
I can't think of any other album just came after The Dark Side of the Moon. That is why I think WYWH is the greatest album of Floyd.
The creativity that underpins this album is on such a level that is so way above anything else that was happening in 1975 and to this day it is one of the best albums ever released.
If you've never heard Roy Harper's own music I'd heads up 'Stormcock' 1971-if nothing else for your interest some of Jimmy Page''s best acoustic guitar playing features on 'One Man Rock and Roll Band', while 'Me And My Woman' is a lovely suite orchestrated by David Bedford (Mike Oldfield collaborator).
David Gilmour wrote a song that was recorded on Roy Harper and Jimmy Page's album: Whatever Happened To Jugla. The song is called Hope.
It was also recorded as a different song on Pete Townsend's White City album with David Gilmour. It's called White City Fighting.
Does Gilmour actually play the arpeggiated riff on White City? Because it sounds like his playing. Also liked the Deep End concert he did with Townshend.
@@RobXHEphotosPs37.29 I'll have to listen. Two great players...
Yes. I would say it's him. That first lick is him.
Wow. High Quality video.❤❤
22:30 and on is the essence of life.
Parts of Shine on You Crazy Diamond really hark back to the Meddle album. That is an album worthy of reaction. It contained both the psychedelic prog rock that brought the band to notice and some stuff that wandered well away from that. More than any other Floyd album of that era. To me Dark Side of the Moon feels like it should have come after Wish You Were Here and not between it and Meddle.
This whole album is about their friend Sid and the bands distain for the players in the music industry. Sid suffered from mental illness and eperimented with acid until he could no longer function. After Dark Side of the Moon came out, David realized how much the people on the industry had actually stolen from the band (leaving them almost broke after making the biggest selling album in history).....thus Have a cigar is a slap back at the industry. They then started recording at Abby Road studios where Animals became a huge success for them. But in the end this particular album was about how much they loved and missed their friend Sid....RIP Sid ......oh yeah David Gilmore made sure that Sid was financially taken care of for his entire life. When Sid passed away in 2006 ....35 years afyer leaving the band he actually had a net worth of 500,000 dollars❤
It’s Syd and Gilmour 👍🏻
This album is a great story....starting with the success of The Dark Side of The Moon....the record label pushing for more and the members really missing their frieng Sid. Have a cigar tells most of it. The band was burned by company executives and by their manager. This album is a big middle finger to them! The whole second side goes back to their roots of psychedelic music and sounds that Sid would have loved. After this was completed, the bandvstarted recording at Abby Road studios. Rodger and David started having creative differences but pulled off another great one with Animals. By the time. The Wall came out, Davids solos were almost non existent and Rodger sand almost everything. The final Cut is where they parted ways when Rodger wanted to put cuts on it that didn't make it to The Wall...that's when they parted ways. Richard Wright left but rejoined the band once Waters was gone. Although their last albums couldn't match the success of the 70's they still managed to pack arenas across the world and continued to do so for many years....The Pulse concert was one of the most amazing voncerts EVER! I saw them twice in the 70's at Madison Square Garden and I was moved forevet.....Rest in peace Sid snd Richard.
That wind always said desolation to me
.
Thank you so much for a nice and honest reaction, well done! Sound, pictures and comments is right on track, -and those flames in the background are just genious. I look forward to the next versions, both live and cover. Sorry I can't support your channel moneywise, don't trust the Internet any more...
excellent reaction, with no pause, just feeling ando hearing...and then your comments. i love it
It’s been super-exciting to see Dev in particular develop a way of talking about - and thinking about - these artists and their works. Enjoying this journey with you both.
듣는거 만으로도 예술의 경지 그자체!!!
You should check out the Pink Floyd albums A Saucerful of Secrets, The Soundtrack from the Film More, Ummagumma, Atom Heart Mother, Meddle, and then Obscured by Clouds. It's completely fascinating to listen to bands evolve especially with Pink Floyd since Obscured by Clouds is the album released right before Darkside of the Moon.
ce sont vraiment des profesionels perfectioniste ,ils influence encore aujourdhui de nombreux groupes ,super😊👍
I believe the cough was from Richard Wright.
I've heard that he was so horrified on hearing it that he gave up smoking. Whether it's true or one of those myths that builds up over time I don't know.
I always heard it was Dave. 🤔
I vaguely remember one of the band members mentioning that it was Rick. I could be wrong.
@glennbrock6560 it could very well have been Rick, and I could be wrong. Rick always seemed to be the heavier smoker. I'm curious now, gonna search it. lol
Yeah, I always heard it was Rick Wright and I have seen Rick on film in a studio with a cigarette burning in an ashtray on his keyboard..
Very Well Done, High Quality, High Class! Great Info! Thanks!!
13:13 it could be Antarctica, it could be the Gobi Desert. The desolate sound of persistent wind is in harmony with the overall theme of the album and is a great introduction to Syd's theme: Absence
Just struck me that Have A Cigar seems to have influenced the style on the Animals album that follows a year or so later. Very much Rodger Waters style songs as he was kind of taking more & more control of Pink Floyd artistic output
The end of this album was basically the end of this epoch of Pink Floyd, and that's why it feels and sounds so poignant.
Sure, these same four went on to make Animals and then The Wall, but it just wasn't the same. It became almost like a Roger Waters solo project with David, Nick and Richard collaborating as studio musicians. Don't get me wrong, there is certainly plenty of great music on both of those albums, but the unique spirit and "vibe" of the band from 69-75 was noticeably absent.
I'm your 100th like! So I guess that part in Cigar with the extra beat is 9/8? That's how it counts for me anyway.
And yes - I sang along LOUDLY to the "chorus" part 🙂
I was thinking 5/4, 4/4, 5/4, 4/4, or 2 measures of 9/4
It wasn’t David that coughed but Richard wright. He quit smoking after that but unfortunately years later died of I believe cancer from smoking
Pretty sure it was Dave who coughed and it made him quit smoking. Rick did die of lung cancer, unfortunately.
Hi, I agree that it was Rick Wright, he always had a cigarette burning in an ashtray on his keyboards ( old videos).@@ianfortier6796
I definitely know which one of you two is Pink! :)
25:47. Emily tries but misunderstands
After Syd quit the band Gilmore s sound took over
This is not Roger Waters singing, but Roy Harper as guest.
I liked Roy Harper's "Life Mask" album which featured members of Led Zeppelin so I bought a couple others by him and they just sounded goofy to me. I always thought David Gilmour sang WYWH.
Dave sings WYWH, Roy sings Have A Cigar. Roger couldn't do it, Dave had a crack at it but said it didn't quite seem right, so he went to the next room over where Roy was recording and asked him to give it a try. It came out best and Dave loved it, but Roger was pissy about his take not being the one used. It may have been the spark which lead to the feud, now that I think about it.
@@ianfortier6796 Thanks. I got those two backwards. I'll listen to Have A Cigar with fresh ears this time.
@@JimboKM You're welcome, Jimbo.
They didn't ask Harper (known best for having a song on Led Zeppelin III named for him) to sing Have a Cigar. He offered his services after seeing them struggle with it. You see, the song was pitched too high for Roger to sing it properly, without having to change the key, and thus, the entire song. So, rather than starting over, they let Roy have a crack at it. Everyone thought it was Roger and they didn't give Roy Harper credit for over a decade. If anyone is interested in the whole story, straight from the horse's mouth, here you go: ua-cam.com/video/UsmJxXut_N0/v-deo.html
I definitely always thought it was Roger. Harper seems to have captured some of his inflections
Odd that you missed out the closing track 'Welcome To The Machine' from the Side 1 video, and also didn't include it at the begging of the side 2 video as the two songs (WTTM and Have A Cigar) link in to one another?
UA-cam does not always tolerate several copyrighted songs in one video. Here is our _Welcome to the Machine_ reaction - ua-cam.com/video/keQVlWLcb80/v-deo.html
@@MusicforBusyPeople ooh, thanks - I missed this video. Nice reaction to it too (not sure about the cover version at the end though - I much prefer the original!)
stupid question.. did you listen OK with your Headphones only placed on the back of your ears ?
The headphone speakers hang over the ears and sound better than you would think, as long as the room is quiet.
@@MusicforBusyPeople Make and Model please ! X
@@guiltseeker Koss KSC75
@@MusicforBusyPeople thanks mfbp xxx
This dissatisfaction with things wasn't limited to this instance - Roger simply wasn't 'feeling it' when they were recording "Animals", which is why David is playing bass on "Pigs" and "Sheep". That's why there are so many bends evident - as good as he was, Roger didn't have the skills to pull that off.
Roger Waters is never totally satisfied with anything. That's him in a nutshell.