Islam and colonialism with Professor Aria Nakissa
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 кві 2022
- Islam and the cognitive study of colonialism: The case of religious and educational reform at Egypt’s al-Azhar www.cambridge.org/core/journa...
You Can Support My Work on Patreon:
/ bloggingtheology
My Paypal Link:
www.paypal.com/paypalme/blogg...
Mr. Paul you have "Masha Allah" a treasure mind; bringing all the eminent scholars to your blogging theology helped transmit genuine knowledge. Thank you...
May God give him the reward for his effort
Just real wonderful.. Wonderful and most wonderful, Salam from your Palestinian brother. ماشالله تبارك الله
Wa alaykumu s-salam
Salam my Palestinian brother from Holland, may Allah free Palestine from its occupiers, amine
you are always in my thoughts and my prayers❤🤲
A phenomenal conversation, and really illuminated my thoughts.
These colonialists took the human rights , not gave it. And today it is most dangerous kind of colonialism. Wake up!
“ Glory gold & gospel “
This is the chant that their ancestor yelling when they arrive in my country , malaysia.
They gave "human rights" too but these rights are destructive to any normal society
Understanding how the Western regime secularizes and subverts the Muslim world is also helpful in understanding how they've been subverting Western populations. Of course, it's still a big global agenda, with LGBT, feminism, sexual liberation, abortion, progressivism, etc. being pushed the world over by the US, the global NGO complex, etc.
@@swampthing9940 what is right with lgbtq?
@@swampthing9940 it's simply immoral
@@swampthing9940 morality is not objective my friend. This attitude is the problem in the first place
@@swampthing9940
Morality for Muslims is Objective and is dictated by God via his Revelation Quran.
The UN promotes via NGOS in lands it's not existent.Kinda like forcing Western Culture on their Culture, that's what wrong.
Thanks for this, Paul. Amazing stuff!👍
This is such an important episode, absolutely mind blowing and explains so many things 🤯
Your channel is more educational than lots of academic classes/ degree. Noticed some comments with time line im regards the different topics, would love if you can make that for all videos
Brother Poulwillim thank You for bringing best issues in every programs...
A beautiful, thoughtful, and insightful discussion between two brilliant intellectuals. May Allah Swt bless both of you in dunya and Akhrah. Ameen. Dear Paul; all of us enjoy your amazing discussions on various topics so much. Plz continue those wonderful talks with intellectuals across the globe…..may Allah Swt bring forth a lot of Khair for good deeds for ummrah from these discussions
Alhamdulillah
really insightful and informative! thank You both ❤
Your energy is beyond comment.
From the get go I love this. Thank you again!
Fantastic meeting. Thanks gentlemen
Brother Paul is a shining brilliant gem in the community. May his work be accepted by the highest
That was beautiful to watch thank u Paul 🙏
Never heard of him, but thanks for introducing him to us. Very interesting thoughts to contemplate.
Great insight,Thanks👍💯
This was a really good interview
This brother example things beautifully mash Allah
Great contribution by Paul who brings think tankers, researchers and scholars in matters which are of interests to most of us, expanding our horizons and enlightening our souls. Extremely grateful to Paul for taking so much time and effort in this regards. Great service to ummah, a Sadiqa jariya InshAllah. May Allah (swt) give Paul the strength to continue this excellent work. MashaAllah. Asma.
I really learn a lot from this Channel, Paul.
Salaam only one God and it's Allah SWT love here from South Africa Johannesburg pray 5 times a day
Fascinating absolutely fascinating
Interesting conversation
Amin! What a brilliant description of the 'real' world we are experiencing today!
Dear Brother Paul. Shukran for your amazing work and guests. Colonialism works through 3 key institutions: parliamentary democracy, corporations and the nuclear family (Sameer Dossani). I guess you can add education to this list. Another to add to the list is the very thing that sustain us 3 x day- food: its production, distribution, sale and waste. Part of colonialism was up access land, natural resources and cheap labour. Colonial-capitalist agriculture broke farmers relationship with the land and nature and consquestly with people through modernising to achieve high yield, high profits. This has had a huge impact on the environmental-soil, groundwater, biodiversity, whole ecosystems. The food produced now 200 years later accounts for between 30 - 50% of total greenhouse gas emissions and the single largest contributer to climate change, more deadly than coal and oil combined. Unlearning and relearning farming is key to address the colonial architecture. Local and indigenous farmers are at the forefront of this knowledge and practise.
We Muslims have a lot of unlearning and relearning to do. Jumah Mubarak to the you Paul and those listening to this🤲🏽💚🌙
*Abu Hurairah said that he heard the Messenger of Allah *, say to Thaubaan , "How will you be when the nations will call each other upon you as those who are dining call each other to their dish?" Thaubaan asked, "...0 Messenger of Allah, will that be because we will be few (in number)?" He e; said, "No, rather at that time you will be many, yet AI-Wahn will be cast into your hearts." "And what is AI-Wahn, 0 Messenger of Allah?" The Prophet'S`," said, "Your love for the world and your hate for fighting." (Ahmad)*
Another amazing episode well done!
Brother Paul the silver fox look suits you haha
Keep up the good work brother
May the all mighty increase you the way he decides is best for you
Thank, Brother Paul for bringing in this very informative topic. I seem to focus on this critical thinking story. Critical thinking is not being 'critical of'. Critical thinking is a very good quality to develop in even a child as then one cannot just feed him any dogma. He might take longer to develop a good relationship with his creator, but such a relationship will then have a very strong Foundation.
MashaAllaah
I never saw links you mention that you're providing below. Where are they?
Article no longer available freely. Can anyone suggest a link where I can read the article
What a brilliant eye opening discussion? Is there a way out from this centuries old brain conditioning which has taken its firm hold?
These gentlemen need to collaborate with Daniel Haqiqatjou.
Salam'aleykum, Ramadan Kareem, Ramadan Mubarak to you all. Thank you Paul for bringing out this very fundamental topic of colonialism. To the contrary of Muslims, western conquests would always be lead in total disrespect of the nation's on place. One example is the colonial destruction of Madagascar s culture by racist french Jules Ferry. Not a Muslim place but still a typical example.
How so ? Very interesting
Lord Cromer ( 1841- 1917 ) rapprochement with Sheikh Muhammad Abdo, Qassem Amin, Morcos Fahmy, Ahmed Lotfi Al-Sayed. With the direct encouragement of the British Consul General, who was enthusiastic about the process of modernizing Egyptian society, calls were launched to improve women's conditions and push them to participate in the community. The book by Morcos Fahmy entitled "Women in the East" appeared, followed by Qasim Amin's famous book, "Women's Liberation". An explicit call to action
The Egyptian writer Mustafa Lutfi Al-Manfaluti In his book "Looks and Lessons", he objected to Lord Cromer's descriptions of the Islamic religion by saying: "We do not dispute Lord Cromer or his ilk among those who challenge Islam in their belief, but we would love them not to dispute our belief, and to give us freedom in that what they gave themselves." .
In his book entitled "The Return of the Hijab", Sheikh Muhammad Ismail Al-Muqaddam, one of the most important scholars of the Salafist call in Egypt, explains the relationship between Imam Muhammad Abduh on the one hand and Lord Cromer on the other, stressing that it was based on common interests.
The Azhari scholar, Muhammad Abduh who had been exiled outside Egypt after his participation in the Urabi Revolution, returned to his homeland again, after the approval of the British Consul General .The presenter considers in his book that Abdo returned the favor to the experienced British politician, after he changed the Al-Azhar curricula,
A good talk on colonisation - enjoyed it. Thank you Paul
You did try to get some clarity on the issue of “ fitra” but unfortunately we did not get much clarity from the speaker. What is against someone fitra could be a cultural norm for another. That is what your question was. It requires a full discussion - may be sheik Hamza or Peterson can address this ?
I don't think he didn't clarify it. He argued that the same impulses are just expressed in different ways across cultures.
Brother Paul is so productive I find it hard to catch up with all the interesting interviews. Slow down Paul, you're going too fast ! 🤣
Is there any research on Islam as colonial imperialism ?
Unable to download the paper. Asking for subscription 😥
sorry!
What's your email brother? I can send the pdf.
😊👍
👍
i cant access the article with my university email, can anyone pass it to me ?
What's your email brother?
@@ZedElite i already contacted nakissa
Thx bro
@@omarelfaroukkecir5805 alright no problem
When will this colonialism end
The only legacy of colonialism is the language left behind,
Islam is diverse and is in many languages all over the world...
Jazakhalla khair, Allah huackbar...
Very interesting topic...the only problematic thing for me is that he reduces everything to biology (materialism), but it must the western academic approach
good point
He is an anthropologist. Remember that. We can dissect a condition in many ways. He tried the way what he is best at. Nobody did it before. So this is a new approach to explain such issues and we should learn multi faceted approach on different issues.
Hi Paul, are u aware that your channel is advertising Tel Aviv Pride week?
islam colonialized the world. Just benefit for all human being rather than now with secular rules world and more than half human being was suffer. Coz human laws is subjective fit to who wanted.
Islam never colonized.More like imparialism
🤣😂🤣 go read and travel the world son.
ua-cam.com/video/Ojv1_m6-PEY/v-deo.html
Check this out. You'll find your misconceptions are addressed.
The guest has a similar if not the same pilosophical outlook as Daniel Haqiqatjou. I agree with him though
The host or the guest?
@@juxtapositionMS thanks I edited that
@@ishxyzaak You are very welcome. But I don't think Daniel has a similar view. I think Daniel believes exactly what Quran and Hadith say but when it comes to presenting some wisdom of Islam he uses this kind of argument to convince people in an intellectual manner, in the same field people are roaming now.
I'm happy Edward Snowden has a new career now, under Aria Nakissa name, and is no longer in Russia.
Once again, a wonderful and thought-provoking talk. Thank you. Certainly, the Western "Age of Reason" or Age of Enlightenment" energized the colonial period. Seeing it as an important part of the civilizing process of the successful West, it fueled and still fuels the spread of 'civilization', it seems to me. Ideally, today the West funds schools that students may choose to attend or not to attend. Naturally, those schools will reflect Age of Reason values and methods of analysis. As I understand it, the Age of Reason has led directly to the creation of democratic institutions, in that, equal rights for genders, races, religions, ethnicities simply make sense for general wellbeing and efficiency. On free expression, I think we sometime view a business' (eg Twitter) desire to not do business with a person is counter to free speech. I withdrew my financial support of a certain opinion maker and was accused of being opposed to free speech. I submit that they can say what they want. I am just not inclined to pay them to say it.
Those days I've started the reading of Lost Islamic history by Firas Akatheeb. It describes how western Europe managed to fool the ottoman by letting the empire turn asleep because of the long dark ages the west used to keep itself in. Then one day they wake up with mountain of gold taken from the Americas, and kind of military superiority. Then they managed to defeat the Turks many times and each times managed to take profit of the Muslim policy on religious minorities and forced the Turkish to go further and recognise their Christian minorities as under western laws and immune to Turkish law. Then after a while a group name Young Turks seduced by the liberal unholy way of life managed to take the power and made it possible the final dismantling of the ottoman empire. So to say this is not any age of reason at the heart of the story, but plunder of gold from South America rather at the beginning.
@@tomasino3572 as someone from turkey I must confess ottomans left muslim world to dark period. the schools were weak and people were jobless while in istanbul and anatolia and sultan were in lusury. Tulip period we call it. however in Egypt a ottoman renegade was making progress because he was free form the sultan this is why people love him. he made progress. however again second source I can give directly from Barbaros Hayrettin pasha s own writings. sultan kanuni ordered him to write his life in record so its from him directly. he shares his disgust of palace intrigues just before biggest naval war of their time which they won but thanks to him leaving the palace and making all of the corrupt people to panic and obey his decisions otherwise sultan would kill them all for making his pirates abandon them . these all add up. then ottomans became old man. and caliphate was taken just as it is stated in hadith of prophet muhammad sav.
@@tomasino3572 learn the difference tho, modern turks are not the same as ottomans, Turkey is a modern secular project whereas Ottoman Empire a direct inheritance of the Islamic paradigm and rule.
Are you praising secular/liberal project or am i getting you wrong?
@@Mr.Jasaw13 I'm not intending to praise anything. The point I'm trying to make is that sometimes services provided by the, so called, "West" are voluntarily received and are not forced on recipients. Parents need not send their children to schools funded by the West, for instance. No one is forced. It is natural that Western values are represented in these services. Also, twitter and facebook and others are businesses. If they restrict what may be said on their sites, they are not restricting a right of free speach. You can say what you want but not necessarily through their businesses.
Thanks, brother Paul. The Quran catogorally states that the fitrah is a natural innate state of man. Is the Quran the only religious book that carries such a catogorical statement. After all, it is now an accepted fact as proff. Aria claims, of all human beings.
سوريا لولا التدخل الغربي و سرقة ثرواتها من قبل الاستعمار الأمريكي و الروسي و الإيراني والتركي و حامي مصالحهم الطاغية لما وجِد مشرد أو مهجر أو محتاج
فثرواتها مسروقة و المليارات التي تم تجميدها بحجة غضبهم عن الطاغية يستفيدون منها ويستغلونها فالطاغية الدكتاتور يحارب شعبه بحرمانه من أقل حقوقه و من الكهرباء و الماء و الوقود
No Muslim, who knows his history correctly, calls Ottoman rule as Turkish and consider it colonialism. That’s because it was a Muslim state that spread Islam and protected Muslims and their lands. The prophet (PBUH) praised the Muslim ruler who would bring Constantinople (Istanbul now) to the Muslim domain. That ruler was an Ottoman. The good things of that state are numerous but let me mention only one. During that time, a Muslim would be able to travel across Muslim lands freely, Only after its collapse, he needs to have a score, even more, passports to do the same! We’ve lost Palestine after we have lost the Ottoman state. Hope this encourages you to read your history again with Islamic glasses on your eyes. If you’re a non-Muslim, please do the same but put on objective lenses.
Is Prof. Nakissa muslim himself?
Is Professor Nakissa a Muslim brother? Unclear
Yes
Our Creator Allah Almighty the One and only True Eternal Living God says:
(30. So devote yourself to the religion of monotheism-the natural instinct Allah has instilled in mankind. There is no altering Allah’s creation. This is the true religion, but most people do not know.)
Sourate 30 ar-rum ayah 30 from the Holy Quran.
Russia is not a western Country...russia is eurasian like china ,persia india
I am pretty sure that Allah is not referred to as a "Spirit" like this guy is constantly alluding to??
The oldest colonialisation and oppression is the islamic one.
No one discusses the human cost of that colonialisation.
And the body bag's are still piling up daily as the colonialisation is being perused (kashmir, Sudan etc...)
Pietermartizburg KZN South Africa 🌍
Hindian spotted 🤡😂
The "human cost" of "Islamic colonisation"... "the body bags" are "still piling up DAILY"...
The fact that you used KASHMIR and Sudan as examples...
Let me try not to laugh for a moment.
Have you considered a career as a children's fantasy writer?
Is the professor Jewish?
What makes you think so?
@@juxtapositionMS Aria sound like a very common Jewish name. I knew more than one person with that name. It's spelled in multiple ways.
@@Ak-lq7yl He is a Muslim.
Paul: very sad that west killed natives in US and australia
Also Paul: no mention of islamic slave trade or other islamic colonial/oppression projects where millions of non muslims died.
nothing new to see here.
Because Paul doesn't buy fake propaganda story created by western colonialists to justify their oppression on human fellow human beings.
Proof your position or acknowledge your emotions got you
@@yusufnasiru1709 1. read about islamic slave trade. there are books available.
2. read about armenian genocide by ottomans.
3. read about forced conversions of christian children by ottomans
4. read about islamic invasions and rule of india/afghanistan/pakistan
what is wrong with emotions? you love your parents out of logic?
@@yusufnasiru1709 paul can act as sophisticated as he wants but we see through him. he is just as bigoted as the muslims he associates with, he only hides it better.
@@treehigh5156 please provide academic resources. Saying read and read is not good enough. Moreover, if Muslims were violent to any level closer to Westerners, then how do you explain that Hindus still constitute 80% of population in India after more than eight centuries of Muslim rule with more than a billion people. Compare that to indigenous people in America, Australia and New Zealand. Compare that to the extermination of tens of millions of people in those areas. What about the colonial history of Britain, Belgium, France, Germany and Holland, etc, in Africa and Asia? How many millions of people died during it?
Human Rights > Tyranny
Human beings avoid ‘filth’ specifically that which causes disease.
Human beings avoid antisocial behaviors like theft, because no society can function without order, activities universally viewed as immoral are chaotic for societies, but can mutate to condemn functionally mundane behavior, eg. homosexuality.
28:19 very interesting.
33:57 just like caliphate and sharia
34:39 western colonialism doesn’t explain why western academia have produced greater outcomes that that of the islamicate world. Empiricism requires skepticism.
It’s not to defend every action taken in the name of liberalism, but all ideologies act to protect themselves. It’s the reason why sharia is so ‘liberal’ with the death penalty. It’s a bit hypocritical to cry fowl, when sharia is way harsher on criticism of islam, than almost any liberal is on islamism.
In secular liberal societies, you can be a self proclaimed muslim. What would happen to a self proclaimed atheist in a sharia state? 🪨🪨🪨
ua-cam.com/video/tYVi368vSYc/v-deo.html
This is explanation on the rise of Islam from non muslim experts.
Try watching , Sir
( Do Christians And Jews and "OTHER" non-Muslims go to Heaven? )
Quran 2:62
'' Those who believe (in the Quran) and those who follow the Jewish (scriptures) and the Christians and the Sabians->ANYAllah< Is The Protector Of Monasteries, Churches, Synagogues And The Mosques )
Quran 22:40
[They are] those who have been evicted from their homes without right - only because they say, " Our Lord is God " And were it not that God checks the people, some by means of others, there would have been demolished monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques in which the name of God is much mentioned. And God will surely support those who support Him. Indeed, God is Powerful and Exalted in Might.
Note: Why did Allah protected Churches and Synagogues if they worship false Allah ?
( Why Are There So Many Different Religions In The World ? )
Quran 5 48
''...... If God wanted He could have made all of you a single nation.( ie single religion ) But He willed otherwise in order to test you in what He has given you (ie Scriptures) therefore try to excel one another in good deeds. Ultimately you all shall return to God then He will show you the truth of those matters in which you '' >DISPUTE verb < not noun like other religions
Islam mean "submission" to God
( The above verse saying is that God will not accept a religion from the >MUSLIM< and the Non-Muslims but total "submission" to God )
Question: How Can Muslim And the Non-Muslim "submit" to the God?
Answer: Be kind to other human beings and Do not lie, Do not steal, Do not cheat, Do not hurt others, Do not be prideful and Do the charity work.
Note: If you obeyed all the ABOVE Allah-God's moral laws "YOU" submitted to God.( ie Islam mean "submission" to God )
The only people who will enter Paradise those who '' Submitted to God '' ( ie by good deeds )
God does NOT accept your religion of birth but only ''Your Total'' Submission to Him.
( God Allows Interfaith Marriages And Eat Food From the Christian And Jew And Vice Versa )
Quran 5:5
''This day [all] good foods have been made lawful, and the food of those who were given the Scripture (ie Christian and Jew) is lawful for you and your food is lawful for them. And [lawful in marriage are] chaste women from among the believers (ie Muslim ) and chaste women from among those who were given the Scripture (ie Christian and Jew) before you, when you have given them their due compensation, desiring chastity not unlawful sexual intercourse or taking [secret] lovers. And whoever denies the faith - his work has become worthless and he in the Hereafter will be among the losers.''
Note: > Only < Islam allows interfaith marriages (>14 hundredsSame God< but They are >ALL Corrupt< more or less, some more than others from their original foundational teaching. The older religion are MORE corrupted than newer religion.
Question to Muslim and Christian:
Does God / Allah only answer your pray ?
And God / Allah does not answer non Muslim / non Christian pray?
Did Allah '' Canceled '' all other religions Judaism and Christianity?
Quran 5:48
'' And We have revealed to you [O Muhammad] the Book in truth, confirming that which preceded it of the Scripture ( ie New and old Testament ) and as a criterion over it. So judge between them by what Allah has revealed and do not follow their inclinations away from what has come to you of the truth. >>>TO EACH OF YOU WE PRESCRIBED A LAW AND A METHODone nation>differ qualified < for to enter Paradise )
On the day of judgement God will ''NOT'' judge humanity bases on Sunni Muslim sect VS Shia Muslim sect ''NOR'' by Muslim VS non-Muslim >but< Doer of Goods VS Doer of Evils.
'' YOUR " birth in the Muslim's family is NOT a > qualification < for to enter the Paradise.
'' YOUR " religion / sect / foot long beard is NOT a > qualification < for to enter the Paradise.
The > qualification < to enter Paradise is > Faith in God and Good Work
@Mejej Jdjjd Indian
Salam
The Quran was written by Christians in the Middle East. The Bible has context. The Quran does not, because Christians who wrote the Quran already had the Bible, so the Quran at the time already had a context.
When those Christians for some reason threw away the Bible, and started using only the Quran and invented stories that came later about the "last prophet", a prophet from an insignificant town Mecca, who supposedly lived years ago, then they became Muslims.
There were no Muslims in the 7th century, only Arabs who were Christian. Muhammad "the prophet" did not exist, and the Quran was no revelation. Otherwise, the Quran would not contain so many scientific, historical, and logical errors.
I THINK YOU NEED A BIG SLEEP BECAUSE YOU LOOK LIKE A ALCOHOLIC
LMAO how many Christians you know who reject the Bible or the Trinity ?
Stop coping cross worshipper there were no Christians in the Hijaz but in Najran and the areas around Yemen.
You're full of scientific, historical, logical and personal errors
ok salty
And the NT was written in a Greco-Roman context by hellenized jews or hellenized gentiles
Most likely the historical jesus never existed and if he did the historical jesus has nothing to do with the mythological christ worshipped by the church
The gospels are not the inspired word of God and the gospel writers to this day are anonymous
Lastly the 4 "cannonical" gospels contradict one another and are filled with historical and scientific errors
Lmao same energy as the theory that The roman catholic church created islam. Utter ignorance with no backing