@@flofaustineBelum tentu, Perfectionist itu bawaan untuk orang yang memiliki watak melankolis. Dan Mariah Carey ini memang memiliki watak Plegmatis-Melankolis
I feel sad that she’s thinking she’s failing the vocals… she is not, those crackles are life for me, the real Mariah, the history behind those crackles is a lot, and we appreciate that so much!❤ Thanks for giving us life for so many decades!
*for you to be on EVERYONES comment attempting to “correct” their opinions and TRUTH that she did IN FACT sound good, you are the one lying to yourself! which part sounded bad???? NONE. pitch was good and melody on point. and she even showcased low notes ALL WHILE PLAYING AROUND. ur comments are pathetic and unnecessary, STELLA!*
You have to Understand something : Mariah or any femal artist will feel insecure if the voice is hurt spacially after a long career where you are treated like a legend . She have nodules .Here in this video we see the nodules blocking the vocal cords from belting. And it hursts here when she can’t do it for her fan. So she feels bad about it. But that does not mean she can’t belt anymore . There was a lot of lives in concerts especially during Christmas where she belt the shit out of the song 🤓
i prefer that kind of singing with little raw spots and little cracks rather than any super high polished lip performance! i would chose everytime this...
Cuz she’s a 50 year old insecure mess who refuses to get therapy to cope with her demons and instead insists among other things to only take pics from her “good side” because someone some time told her to and she refuses to grow up and instead wallows in her insecurity forever and ever even now as a grown ass woman.
No seriously, 0:39 sounded so good even with the crack T_T It literally sounded the same as it was on the studio version but personally, I think it's better and sounded very raw.
This performance really showed what her current vocal status is. She could belt some D5s but would possibly crack, and indeed, she cracked up there. D5 is the highest she went here while doing a 100% live singing and sustained notes were dodged. 😢
Oh my gosh I love the final falsetto part like the original: That you with angelic falsetto vibrato voice killed me. I live for this...❤❤ I love you Mariah
I just miss this Mariah Carey. I was on her concert this Saturday 04/13/24. I miss her so much. I am a diehard MC fan.She just changed after 2022. She’s not even trying to convince everyone that she’s singing live. I love her so much but it just breaks my heart seeing not even try
Poor MC, she was really trying to spoil her fans here, but lost her confidence from one little crack… stage confidence has always been an issue for her because she’s been an perfection for decades.
I so wish she had sung more songs from The Emancipation of Mimi album, like this one, at the Adventures Tour; so many amazing cuts: Your Girl, Mine Again, One And Only, Joy Ride...
I’m not really sure why she doesn’t sing this song live more often. It is the best song on the album The Emancipation of Mimi I love circles. I blasted in my car all the time. I love that song. I’m just so disappointed that she never sings it alive.
Mariah awww❤❤❤ her vocal cords wasn't having it but we know she can saaang. Sometimes these happen when the artist is touring, singing and singing. Puts a strain on the vocal chords. She still pleased her fans. She seem so cool❤❤ They was just happy to be there. ❤❤❤
Mariah already gave us an amazing performances in decades. I am already satisifed seeing her on stage and hum. Her presence is more than enough for your ticket. Hahhahahah
WELL MY QUEEN MARIAH, I'M SORRY GURL BUT U DID THIS ON U. U MADE 90% OF YOUR ENTIRE CATALOG SO HARD TO SING, U SET THE STANDARDS SO HIGH, U POUR YOUR HEART AND SOUL IN EVERY SONG THAT U WRITE AND RECORD AND SO NOW WE YOUR LAMBS COULDN'T GET ENOUGH OF U 💜
She wasn’t expecting it. The musical director played the first 8 notes and she recognized it and just jumped into the song. She never sang it live before. She did a great job especially off-the-fly 😝🩵
![Mariah Carey & Michael Bolton “We Are Not Making Love Anymore” live [RARE] HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eqgLqvhddvg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K 60fps] Mariah Carey - Emotions (Live in Sydney, Butterfly Tour - 1998) Pro Shot](/img/n.gif)
She's too perfectionist
Perfectionist bisa jadi akibat trauma di masa kecil
@@flofaustineyes
@@flofaustineBelum tentu, Perfectionist itu bawaan untuk orang yang memiliki watak melankolis. Dan Mariah Carey ini memang memiliki watak Plegmatis-Melankolis
I feel sad that she’s thinking she’s failing the vocals… she is not, those crackles are life for me, the real Mariah, the history behind those crackles is a lot, and we appreciate that so much!❤ Thanks for giving us life for so many decades!
I know! I actually love her cracks. Mariah can do no wrong with her voice.
Her cracks are better than other artists out there .
agreed
I CANT BELIEVE SHE SANG THAT ON THE SPOT. You’re so lucky omg, she sounds incredible
She didn’t sing Circles on the world caution tour in Atlanta 😭 but she gave one hell of a show from being to end
*what lies? you can tell she held back but could’ve savaged shit .. it sounded beautiful*
I was there too..She was incredible..i cried.
The nervous rambling. 😭 Mariah, you sound beautiful! That crack just made everything better, the attempt actually sounded great!
When she starts singing in a lower register at 1:33 her tone becomes really beautiful. One of the best tones ever
i'm obsessed with this lower register. It's my new religion ! LOL! :D
I was looking for this comment ha ha ! So beautiful...
THE*
sometimes it sounds gorgeous when her voice cracks, oddly beautiful. love this song!
Ikr
It was beautiful, I think she could’ve powered thru and it would’ve SLAYED.. I think it made her lose her confidence 🥲
Her vocal cracks are soo beautiful....ugh why she kinda felt embarrassed. No one can sing like her
she sounded so good but unfortunately she didn't think the same
She got shy so quickly after the 2nd sentence 😭
*for you to be on EVERYONES comment attempting to “correct” their opinions and TRUTH that she did IN FACT sound good, you are the one lying to yourself! which part sounded bad???? NONE. pitch was good and melody on point. and she even showcased low notes ALL WHILE PLAYING AROUND. ur comments are pathetic and unnecessary, STELLA!*
You have to Understand something : Mariah or any femal artist will feel insecure if the voice is hurt spacially after a long career where you are treated like a legend . She have nodules .Here in this video we see the nodules blocking the vocal cords from belting. And it hursts here when she can’t do it for her fan. So she feels bad about it. But that does not mean she can’t belt anymore . There was a lot of lives in concerts especially during Christmas where she belt the shit out of the song 🤓
0:38 that's all we need. Periodt!
i prefer that kind of singing with little raw spots and little cracks rather than any super high polished lip performance! i would chose everytime this...
0:37 That was actually beautiful Mariah.... Ahhrgh. 😩🔥
It is a very difficult song, she sounded amazing!!!
Her low notes are as good as her high notes 🤩
That vocal crack ate!!! Slay…I just love her singing in general. Can’t wait to go see her
:38-:42 that's crazy that's how critical she is of her voice that she thought it was bad 😭😭😭 omg
REZVISION ENTERTAINMENT I feel so bad for her. The scrutiny she’s received over the years really has gotten to her.
I personally loved it
That hurts me she would have killed it if she had the courage to
@rock the bells girl boo. Go rock those bells in hell
@rock the bells you are on a Mariah video when clearly you have no good intentions for her. YOU go away.
The voice is BACK
Why did she have to get embarrassed because of one voice crack?😭 she sounded so good at the beginning when she was being confident.
Even her voice cracks sound better than 95% of the new girls singing. It actually sounded nice lol
Even the voice crack gave me goosebumps.
Totally. Even with the voice crack it sounds great because it is live and coming from the heart.
Cuz she’s a 50 year old insecure mess who refuses to get therapy to cope with her demons and instead insists among other things to only take pics from her “good side” because someone some time told her to and she refuses to grow up and instead wallows in her insecurity forever and ever even now as a grown ass woman.
Seriously! The voice crack really just sounded like raspiness to me.
this crowd is so DEAD BOO 😭😭😭😭 MIMI you deserved better and CIRCLES deserves so much better
princestory26 right? One of my favorites from emancipation
Excuse people for trying to hear the music instead of screaming over each other 🙄
It’s the fact that the crack sounded so good
She sounded so good 😭
No seriously, 0:39 sounded so good even with the crack T_T It literally sounded the same as it was on the studio version but personally, I think it's better and sounded very raw.
wow the DoOOown 0:39 sounds the same as the studio version
This performance really showed what her current vocal status is. She could belt some D5s but would possibly crack, and indeed, she cracked up there. D5 is the highest she went here while doing a 100% live singing and sustained notes were dodged. 😢
this isn't her current vocal status anymore though, pretty different now
@@instrumentsmrti sadly, in span of 2yrs after caution her voice got more deteriorated
@@TrisTan-wo7tf sir 2019 was 4 years ago
If only Trey and co were on board this could have been epic!
one of my favorite songs ❤️🔥
Oh my gosh I love the final falsetto part like the original: That you with angelic falsetto vibrato voice killed me. I live for this...❤❤ I love you Mariah
Omg she sounds amazing! So happy to see her perform this classic !!!!!!!!
Not sure why but this is on repeat in my house... 🎶Blot the sweat from my eye...eeeyyyee. Love this part!
I just miss this Mariah Carey. I was on her concert this Saturday 04/13/24. I miss her so much. I am a diehard MC fan.She just changed after 2022. She’s not even trying to convince everyone that she’s singing live. I love her so much but it just breaks my heart seeing not even try
She really wanted to sing it for the lambs but her nodules isn't feeling it 🥺
I feel for her. When her nodules are acting up you can tell when she goes for certain notes it causes pain on the vocal cords.
On the spot tone invention is everything!!!
😭😭😭😭 she finally sang it! Living for this Mariah!
I LOVED the Caution Tour
Poor MC, she was really trying to spoil her fans here, but lost her confidence from one little crack… stage confidence has always been an issue for her because she’s been an perfection for decades.
She got so shy 😭
Aww she got shy I wish she should’ve just went for it but it was great and she didn’t mess up she just got scared
@rock the bells bitch I’m tryna find the part of my comment when I asked for your opinion oh didn’t so fuck off think what u want
omg. looking at the comments - the lambs really are the best! so accepting & non judgemental.❤
I so wish she had sung more songs from The Emancipation of Mimi album, like this one, at the Adventures Tour; so many amazing cuts: Your Girl, Mine Again, One And Only, Joy Ride...
I will never forget this concert! ❤️❤️❤️ MIMI killed it 💓
I’m not really sure why she doesn’t sing this song live more often. It is the best song on the album The Emancipation of Mimi I love circles. I blasted in my car all the time. I love that song. I’m just so disappointed that she never sings it alive.
Damn even with the small crack on her voice she makes it sound so beautiful. I prefer raw than any play back.
I’m obsessed with this video! Hopefully she will doing some of Circles this year in the Emancipation residency. ❤
i just wanna yell at her "Just sing the song, kill us dahling"
She really wanted to give her fans the best.
I think she should re-record this song using her lower voice...it damn good
I live for moments like this!!! This is such a StoneGroove!
I would LOVE if she just did chill ass rare throwback stripped down shows o songs she hasn’t done
She sounds so fresh and good!!
Yes Mariah sannng
One of my favorite song from her.
Mariah awww❤❤❤ her vocal cords wasn't having it but we know she can saaang. Sometimes these happen when the artist is touring, singing and singing. Puts a strain on the vocal chords. She still pleased her fans. She seem so cool❤❤ They was just happy to be there. ❤❤❤
I cried that night💕
Aw Mariah sounded GOOD she kept stopping 😔
The media has knocked her confidence so bad but she can still sing the shit out of a song if she just closed her eyes
I gonna die!!!!My fav song ever!!! 😍😍😍
What happened?my world has changed . Has it changed? Trey what happened to the background?lol she's funny
it's kinda sad too
She’s Amazing! Love Her!❤
The fact that she slayed in so many octaves on a whim... whew
Mariah already gave us an amazing performances in decades. I am already satisifed seeing her on stage and hum. Her presence is more than enough for your ticket. Hahhahahah
WELL MY QUEEN MARIAH, I'M SORRY GURL BUT U DID THIS ON U. U MADE 90% OF YOUR ENTIRE CATALOG SO HARD TO SING, U SET THE STANDARDS SO HIGH, U POUR YOUR HEART AND SOUL IN EVERY SONG THAT U WRITE AND RECORD AND SO NOW WE YOUR LAMBS COULDN'T GET ENOUGH OF U 💜
Beautiful
I love that song!❤
Ohhhhhh i wouldveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee love this moment
ah memories 💕
I think she should continue singing
THE CRACK SOUNDED GOOOOOOOOOODDDDD
I really live her
Most people dont understand mariah voice cracks was the cherry on the top
She has mastered the art of deception, complete with adlib
and the tangents thru the song just to hide the fact of her voice imperfections 😢
Mariah Carey ❤❤❤❤❤
Hope One Day Mariah would sing this type of songs that she never performe anywhere.
That crack sounded so good tho 😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️
i'm so mad at her for this sis u were sounding good!
She really lost some of her confidence :(
As a fan and artist she wild
Yes voice crack !! You best sing Mariah!
The Konzert wasnt at 03.06.2019 !!!! one day before at 02.06.2019 was the Mariah Konzert in Hamburg
dr toffee you’re right, my error :)
😍circles😍
0:38 - 0:42 I know she can hit that note but the nodules said no :(((
💕
The voice crack sounded so pretty tho I feel bad for her
Oh Mariah . It’s okay . Just get that Check
Mariah is so festive lol
💕💕💕💕
やっぱマジで歌うめぇな。
Were the background singers mad? They weren’t singing
they didnt rehearse it
😢
The différence between studio And live...
Tem abaixar o tom para voz sair bem
IF she lowered half key it would be brilliant
Just sing a song 🎵.
She knew not to even attempt the climax lol , the tragic glam moment to deflect
i dont have a heart to watch the full clip. sorry 😢
Isn't she supposed to sing?
Why didn't she just lower the key?
She wasn’t expecting it. The musical director played the first 8 notes and she recognized it and just jumped into the song. She never sang it live before. She did a great job especially off-the-fly 😝🩵
Nervousness gets to her. She can’t always control what vocals comes out. Nervous rambling.
Que aburrido leer siempre en los comentarios. Cosas malas sobre su voz zzzzz.
You've been warned, it's live lipsynch
Falou, enrolou mais do que cantou. 🙄 Sdds da voz dela
Falsetto didnt work tonight lol