Man I fucking love this. The more I look into the good and evil album the more I appreciate it not just from a musical standpoint, but from the lesson hidden within it, that humanity is a sum of all its parts, the good & the evil. we live on the &; in the place that separates these seemingly opposite worlds and ideas, we are capable of both. and in a beautifully poetic way, even tally hall seems to be both happy and sad about this fact, leading to a bittersweet trio of songs that ponder, question, & accept out contradictory existence. and how just maybe, if we learn to embrace the paradox we might become greater than the sum of our parts, greater than good or evil, we will be the *rulers of everything*.
It is incredible, as my own personal journey continues I find even more meaning to the words of this song, it’s almost as if music attains deeper, and deeper depths the closer we come to understanding ourselves, & the world around us. And the more we truly accept and embrace it, reguardless of it’s faults, or how they make us feel. while paradoxically and confusingly still embracing our instinctual rejection and fear of the things we cannot truly control, change, or understand. Because that too, is a part of life. and to deny my own fear and confusion at my own words would be disappointing, after coming so far and getting so close to the “truth”. even my future shame at these cryptic words (that I shall try to avoid thinking about once I post this reply… to my own comment… sheesh) should be embraced, because in life the only thing I can ever be is what I am, and by being myself without any concern for how the outside world shall see my internal dialogue, I hope to find peace with being a piece of a greater whole. which I am never meant to know or understand, but just be a part of, and enjoy :)
@potato boy I mean, there is a philosophical theory that you are in essence everyone who has ever lived, ever will live, and is living right now. This life hasn't treated me the best, but I know it's certainly better than my others assuming that theory is true.
@@BlueBerry20071to be fair there are philosophical theories about just about everything, also I know I started the reply with to be fair but I am not trying to deny that I just can’t think of a way to Segway into the comment otherwise.
I feel like I watched the big bang happen so many times in seconds, and the recreation over and over, that I ended up in some god realm. Actually I'm writing a story about this as I type this!
This sounds better than v3. Probably bc it actually says something when put together and that Fate of the Stars was one of Tally Hall's last ever songs.
I discovered Tally Hall by coincidence in late 2021, and what a wonderful rabbit hole this is. And may I add, here you have compiled the songs that grab me the most.
all of the lyrics that i copy/pasted (warning, wall of text) [A Lady] I know a lady Good & Evil Showed me that I was a gentleman Wait for the girl to blossom into Colors that grow where you can [&] Love of the son Came back again To make it clear that He never said it would meet demand Shame on a martyr Claiming friends from Either perspective of & Weak & Strong & Wet & Dry & Right & Wrong & Live & Die & Sane & Gone & Love & Not & All the &s that we forgot so Sing while you hear it Don't deny it Leave if you can't stand the thought of it Come back again To make things stand With no disrespect to the & High & Low & New & Old & Stop & Go & Hot & Cold & John & Yoko Dark & Light It's almost time to say goodnight to it They took a lesson From their fathers Told them that they were the same command Wait for their minds To make complete Their lives stuck beside every & Words & Numbers & Sound & Silence Stop the peace & Keep the violence No & Yes & We digress It lives with sad & happiness Oh God Big bad Betty of the 'pocalypse She opens her lips & it goes like this When the golden rule & the jungle meet There'll be nothing to love & There'll be no one to beat Oh the things we know The things we don't The things we think we can will & won't We're loath to gather that nothing's left We're all together & we're all bereft Capitalists & communists You did the hokey-pokey & it went like this You hate each other & you love yourselves It might be heaven & it might be hell Oh the things we do The things we say Oh the things we wish we could wash away [Fate of the Stars] To leave from this tale follow closely ahead Prepare to exist by the living & dead Too slow or too kind or too wary of those too at ease Past all the buried impressions of then Sullen drawn eyes and expressions to mend Continued through mirrors left broken to sing and be heard Through when it seems all the senses are lost to absurd So the part where we are Trapped in active depart In the fate of the stars No not one who we are No control pumping heart Button pressed mind in art Mind control Mind restart To leave from the present with no source of sound They laugh because silence is never around Ignored and forgotten the past may continue to breathe Feared not a rest by this desolate friend Whose patience revealed what intent comes to send With a stare at a hole in the world comes a lust to be high Above all the dark nested clouds that keep guard of the sky So the part where we are Trapped in active depart In the fate of the stars No not one who we are No control pumping heart Button pressed mind in art Mind control Mind restart Step onto the ferris wheel Round for day & night Lost in what's forever more Complacent in its reasons for Give & Take & Sleep & Wake & Pray for Day & Night to come Again we see there's certainty in What we feel and what we've heard Again we see there's certainty in Expectations all the same --- this is mostly for my own convenience
I'm thinking of a version of this where the entire cult is made up of robots and the lady in "a lady" is both the creator of the cult leader and "the &" and the last change would be that the cult is also attempting a robotic uprising alongside worshipping "the &"
Dude... now I'm thinking of other scenarios and other plots in the same universe with alien bugs and lizard people with overarching themes and akdkdmrijtifjfimdidkdmdj THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS COMMENT
Oh gosh... I remember looking at this like a year ago, back when I couldn't even tell Miracle Musical and Tally Hall apart, and this video made me think that these three songs were the whole album, lol.
To be fair, these songs would probably work well as one song, considering they have their own narrative, they clearly compliment eachother nicely, and even their titles match up. I know you've probably already found this out. This reply is just in case you didn't
I mean, I don't think they chose to, since even if they did they wouldn't be getting the money from it since all three songs are licensed and copywritten.
I realise this video is 3 years old but was there something confirming that these three songs were linked? Like, 'A Lady' and '&' obviously have the same melody but where does Fate of the Stars come in? I mean, it's a nice mixture either way, I actually like the structure of A Lady/&/Fate of the Stars since it's like the song is going from calm to wild and back to calm with the guitar creating kind of a bookend, but where did it come from exactly?
the end of Fate of the Stars has the same melody as A Lady and & ("give & take & sleep & wake & pray for day and night to come..."), so the break between the end of & and Fate of the Stars would be like a bridge in the 11-minute song
Honestly, rocking chair, that is what fate of the stars sounds like, It keeps it's pace the exact the same, but the music trys to fight it, but you cant kill it unless you kill the music.
I think that would have worked if & was much later in the album but with where & is I think having Lady about halfway through the album away works better than having them so close to each other
I'm grateful I know their music since 2018. For me, this is one of the best discoverings I've ever made on the Internet, if not the best. It's truly sad that I never got to see Tally Hall irl, as each one found their own way on 2011, but for me, they're still one of the most goated music groups on history; my favorite one
Just out of curiosity, why place them in this specific order? To me, A Lady always felt like the perfect little intermission in the middle of the album
I'm sorry, but it's still the wrong order. "A Lady" has the same melody throughout. "&" has that melody only in the first half. After 3:30, it switches. Meanwhile, during "Fate of the Stars," it doesn't start the "A Lady" melody until 9:52. So the proper order would be [Fate Of The Stars / A Lady / &] and it would keep the melody together at the centre of the song.
You're entitled to your opinion. I listened to all possible iterations several times and this was the one I found most satisfying, with a sustained intro and outro. & ends very abruptly and isn't a great finale to an 11-minute journey. Feel free to make your own video and see which people prefer!
My guess it that & is in the middle of fate of the star with that weird drop in the middle and A lady in red was only a sort of trailer for the story of both of these songs
it’s surprising that nobody’s mentioning how in & it says “Big Bad Betty of the ‘Pocalypse,” and along with that, the names of these songs combined says “A Lady & The Fate Of The Stars”
Could somebody explain how Fate of The Stars link up with the other two songs..? It feels like a standalone thing, but then again I'm not much of a literacy/story person lol
The title of this song is literally 'A lady and fate of the Stars' when put together, and I think that's beautiful
Avymmm Plays bruh everybody can see the “/‘s”
@@Ohmman "when put together"
@@Ohmman Angry much?
What's that even supposed to mean
gotta remember the ampersand
Man I fucking love this. The more I look into the good and evil album the more I appreciate it not just from a musical standpoint, but from the lesson hidden within it, that humanity is a sum of all its parts, the good & the evil. we live on the &; in the place that separates these seemingly opposite worlds and ideas, we are capable of both. and in a beautifully poetic way, even tally hall seems to be both happy and sad about this fact, leading to a bittersweet trio of songs that ponder, question, & accept out contradictory existence. and how just maybe, if we learn to embrace the paradox we might become greater than the sum of our parts, greater than good or evil, we will be the *rulers of everything*.
It is incredible, as my own personal journey continues I find even more meaning to the words of this song, it’s almost as if music attains deeper, and deeper depths the closer we come to understanding ourselves, & the world around us. And the more we truly accept and embrace it, reguardless of it’s faults, or how they make us feel. while paradoxically and confusingly still embracing our instinctual rejection and fear of the things we cannot truly control, change, or understand. Because that too, is a part of life. and to deny my own fear and confusion at my own words would be disappointing, after coming so far and getting so close to the “truth”. even my future shame at these cryptic words (that I shall try to avoid thinking about once I post this reply… to my own comment… sheesh) should be embraced, because in life the only thing I can ever be is what I am, and by being myself without any concern for how the outside world shall see my internal dialogue, I hope to find peace with being a piece of a greater whole. which I am never meant to know or understand, but just be a part of, and enjoy
:)
🤯
@@potatoboy6094 damn, that alot to read and swallow all at once but hey, good for you, i hope you live a great life
@potato boy I mean, there is a philosophical theory that you are in essence everyone who has ever lived, ever will live, and is living right now. This life hasn't treated me the best, but I know it's certainly better than my others assuming that theory is true.
@@BlueBerry20071to be fair there are philosophical theories about just about everything, also I know I started the reply with to be fair but I am not trying to deny that I just can’t think of a way to Segway into the comment otherwise.
Will nobody bring up how fate of the stars is terrifying but still beautiful..?
Hello
I feel like I watched the big bang happen so many times in seconds, and the recreation over and over, that I ended up in some god realm. Actually I'm writing a story about this as I type this!
@@neb2901 first time trying acid?
the mind electric?
3:23
This sounds better than v3. Probably bc it actually says something when put together and that Fate of the Stars was one of Tally Hall's last ever songs.
v3? What is v3?
what is v3?
what is v3? v3?
holy shit danganronpa
we still don’t know what v3 is
i love how the video is mostly just fate of the stars
I like how the tally hall related videos comment section is mostly tally hal
the hal is tallying omg
Omg it tally hal
She lady on my & till I fate of the stars
I discovered Tally Hall by coincidence in late 2021, and what a wonderful rabbit hole this is.
And may I add, here you have compiled the songs that grab me the most.
Welcome to the cult, might as well song while you hear it and don't deny it.
a rabbit hole you say... im pretty new here, few recommendations will be appreciated!
@@MrHouserobot ha ha
run.
@@MrHouserobot do u know miracle musical?
@@rodrigocarnavale9044 miracle musical is great, joe hawley's solo album isn't bad either
all of the lyrics that i copy/pasted (warning, wall of text)
[A Lady]
I know a lady
Good & Evil
Showed me that I was a gentleman
Wait for the girl to blossom into
Colors that grow where you can
[&]
Love of the son
Came back again
To make it clear that
He never said it would meet demand
Shame on a martyr
Claiming friends from
Either perspective of &
Weak & Strong &
Wet & Dry &
Right & Wrong &
Live & Die &
Sane & Gone &
Love & Not &
All the &s that we forgot so
Sing while you hear it
Don't deny it
Leave if you can't stand the thought of it
Come back again
To make things stand
With no disrespect to the &
High & Low &
New & Old &
Stop & Go &
Hot & Cold &
John & Yoko
Dark & Light
It's almost time to say goodnight to it
They took a lesson
From their fathers
Told them that they were the same command
Wait for their minds
To make complete
Their lives stuck beside every &
Words & Numbers &
Sound & Silence
Stop the peace &
Keep the violence
No & Yes &
We digress
It lives with sad & happiness
Oh God
Big bad Betty of the 'pocalypse
She opens her lips & it goes like this
When the golden rule & the jungle meet
There'll be nothing to love &
There'll be no one to beat
Oh the things we know
The things we don't
The things we think we can will & won't
We're loath to gather that nothing's left
We're all together & we're all bereft
Capitalists & communists
You did the hokey-pokey & it went like this
You hate each other & you love yourselves
It might be heaven & it might be hell
Oh the things we do
The things we say
Oh the things we wish we could wash away
[Fate of the Stars]
To leave from this tale follow closely ahead
Prepare to exist by the living & dead
Too slow or too kind or too wary of those too at ease
Past all the buried impressions of then
Sullen drawn eyes and expressions to mend
Continued through mirrors left broken to sing and be heard
Through when it seems all the senses are lost to absurd
So the part where we are
Trapped in active depart
In the fate of the stars
No not one who we are
No control pumping heart
Button pressed mind in art
Mind control
Mind restart
To leave from the present with no source of sound
They laugh because silence is never around
Ignored and forgotten the past may continue to breathe
Feared not a rest by this desolate friend
Whose patience revealed what intent comes to send
With a stare at a hole in the world comes a lust to be high
Above all the dark nested clouds that keep guard of the sky
So the part where we are
Trapped in active depart
In the fate of the stars
No not one who we are
No control pumping heart
Button pressed mind in art
Mind control
Mind restart
Step onto the ferris wheel
Round for day & night
Lost in what's forever more
Complacent in its reasons for
Give & Take &
Sleep & Wake &
Pray for Day & Night to come
Again we see there's certainty in
What we feel and what we've heard
Again we see there's certainty in
Expectations all the same
---
this is mostly for my own convenience
That’s alota &s
@@rhyschomps gotta respect the &'s
its love of the s*n :)
@@tristanraine what?
@@YeOldenImbecile on the official lyrics it's written "Love of the s*n" so it's unknown if it's Sun or Son
For some reason, I think of a cult that worships a being known as "The &", and the lady mentioned in "A Lady" is "The &".
Katie Squid is the Lady "Big bad Betty of apocalypse?
I'm thinking of a version of this where the entire cult is made up of robots and the lady in "a lady" is both the creator of the cult leader and "the &" and the last change would be that the cult is also attempting a robotic uprising alongside worshipping "the &"
Dude... now I'm thinking of other scenarios and other plots in the same universe with alien bugs and lizard people with overarching themes and akdkdmrijtifjfimdidkdmdj THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS COMMENT
Ian Mando someone has quite the imagination
@@rosecatuwu the "big bad Betty of the apocalypse" is an important Homestuck character
Oh gosh... I remember looking at this like a year ago, back when I couldn't even tell Miracle Musical and Tally Hall apart, and this video made me think that these three songs were the whole album, lol.
To be fair, these songs would probably work well as one song, considering they have their own narrative, they clearly compliment eachother nicely, and even their titles match up. I know you've probably already found this out. This reply is just in case you didn't
@@gadgetj5279 i have indeedfound that out by now, but thank you anyways :)
No problem :D
I can think a whole history with this song order
Im trying to make a 11 min remake of a animation i did abt history with this
Hell yeah Tally Hall is still relevant :D
THIS BAND IS STILL RELEVANT GOD DAMNIT
DO YOU LIKE HOW I DANCE? I'VE GOT ZIRCONIUM PANTS that name is beautiful
@@BeanieGoth consequential enough to slip you into a trance >:D
DO YOU LIKE HOW I DANCE? I'VE GOT ZIRCONIUM PANTS do you like how I walk? Do you like how I talk? Do you like how my face disintegrates into chalk?!
Beanie Goth I have a wonderful wife, I have a powerful job, she criticizes me for being egocentric
I really love this version! I listened to both, and I really like the transition between & and Fate Of The Stars in this one.
I use this video for boiling spaghetti...
give me some
Is the spaghetti for your monthly spaghetti bath?
Was it bussin?
@@clubbyvasighn4615 i swear if it isnt, that was andrew who did that right?
@@whenthegaming9916 yea
A Lady: 0:00
&: 1:03
Fate of the stars: 4:17
ok, who the heck puts mid-roll ads on music??? lmao
I mean, I don't think they chose to, since even if they did they wouldn't be getting the money from it since all three songs are licensed and copywritten.
Not me
The albums theme is duality for anyone who didn’t already know.
i love when tally hall said ¨its tallyhalling time¨ and tallyhallied all over the place
💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻
Take a hit every time he says and, then listen to fate of the stars :)
The only way to listen to fate of the stars is high out of your mind
I realise this video is 3 years old but was there something confirming that these three songs were linked? Like, 'A Lady' and '&' obviously have the same melody but where does Fate of the Stars come in? I mean, it's a nice mixture either way, I actually like the structure of A Lady/&/Fate of the Stars since it's like the song is going from calm to wild and back to calm with the guitar creating kind of a bookend, but where did it come from exactly?
the end of Fate of the Stars has the same melody as A Lady and & ("give & take & sleep & wake & pray for day and night to come..."), so the break between the end of & and Fate of the Stars would be like a bridge in the 11-minute song
sorry to ask since it’s completely unrelated, but whats the pride flag on the left side of your pfp? just wondering.
Kinda looks like Femfluidflux flag
Honestly, rocking chair, that is what fate of the stars sounds like, It keeps it's pace the exact the same, but the music trys to fight it, but you cant kill it unless you kill the music.
@@marijazaiceva8099 huh?
I think the end of Fate of the Stars could transition very well into Stranded Lullaby from Hawaii Part II!
The Lady should've been right behind Never meant to Know in the Good & Evil Album
no
I think that would have worked if & was much later in the album but with where & is I think having Lady about halfway through the album away works better than having them so close to each other
Thanks for both versions m(_ _)m
OA
I'm grateful I know their music since 2018. For me, this is one of the best discoverings I've ever made on the Internet, if not the best. It's truly sad that I never got to see Tally Hall irl, as each one found their own way on 2011, but for me, they're still one of the most goated music groups on history; my favorite one
Thank you Sir! This is an awesome compilation!!
This is so good thank you for making this !!
trilogy of Good & Evil
The half holy trinity of good and evil
amazing work
I'm getting Over the Garden Wall vibes, but it has nothing to do with the show lol
Stfu
The Moss Is also one that has those vibes according to the comments
Yeah, especially with A Lady.
Snazzy Cactus no
Jaoheah do you mean. Cosmo Sheldrake’s song? Is there another awesome song called The Moss (I’m just trying to find more good artists)?
This is fantastic
holy crap i found you
@@LemonadeyMeow oh crap you did!
You did it!
I wish the vocals in the end were a bit longer in Fate of The Stars.
tally hall is wonderful.
At this point, we all have to ask ourselves,
_How the hell did we get here?_
From all of those "Ruler of Everything" memes.
@@TubbyFatfrick no
dogelore
Letting the days go by.
@@Fishcrab letting the water hold me down
Listening to this song and imagining an entire fanfiction ordered into segments is incredible
I always thought that a lady was supposed to come in a bit after the end of &
You are awesome
This makes me want to explore the world for some reason
Just out of curiosity, why place them in this specific order? To me, A Lady always felt like the perfect little intermission in the middle of the album
Good (A lady) and (&) Evil (Fate of the Stars)
8:06
for me, don’t mind this
I have light mode on and i saw ur pfp and i thought there was a damn hair on my screen 😭
A lady and & should just be one song tbh
nuh uh
I'm sorry, but it's still the wrong order. "A Lady" has the same melody throughout. "&" has that melody only in the first half. After 3:30, it switches. Meanwhile, during "Fate of the Stars," it doesn't start the "A Lady" melody until 9:52. So the proper order would be [Fate Of The Stars / A Lady / &] and it would keep the melody together at the centre of the song.
You're entitled to your opinion. I listened to all possible iterations several times and this was the one I found most satisfying, with a sustained intro and outro. & ends very abruptly and isn't a great finale to an 11-minute journey. Feel free to make your own video and see which people prefer!
if that were right i'd be pretty disappointed because then the titles don't spell out an actual phrase :(
ZephyrEmbyr You don't have to keep the order to make the phrase, you know
It is a loop!
My guess it that & is in the middle of fate of the star with that weird drop in the middle and A lady in red was only a sort of trailer for the story of both of these songs
if this was just 1 song it'd be tally halls' siberian breaks
it’s surprising that nobody’s mentioning how in & it says “Big Bad Betty of the ‘Pocalypse,” and along with that, the names of these songs combined says “A Lady & The Fate Of The Stars”
Beautiful
Could somebody explain how Fate of The Stars link up with the other two songs..? It feels like a standalone thing, but then again I'm not much of a literacy/story person lol
The usage of &
9:21 I SEE THE SHADOWS IN MY ROOM
part of this sounded like wet hands by c418 for a secound.
my beer would grasp it.. and say fuck it.. haha in a no matter,,
I’m kinda sad this has ads on it
11/10
"A Coincidence of Contradictions"
Wait this video is 7 years old how are the segments named after zonai devices in totk
What is blue yapping about?
I might be stupid
This song reminds me the "IT" movie and i don't know why
yeah '&' does give me IT feels. maybe bc the word 'it' is said alot
RipleyandWeeds u think?
sameeeee
dON'T DRAG THAT STUPID FANDOM TO THIS MASTERPIECE!!!1!!!11!!
Mby one of the songs within the tracklist of "IT" has a similar melody or song text.
Here is 2024.
1:02
The starter lemimotif from a lady in & at 2:29 is my favorite part, how it isnt anyone else's shocks me overall i love tally hall now
Good & Evil Complete [A Lady / & / Fate Of The Stars] does tghis mean anything
love you my friend.. just do it like nike.. ps..
Listen to the date of the stars in x
1.5
Sounds absolutely incredible
A lday like
npol my freind...
do it a ldady like with it..
666 likes and 6 dislikes. 20,668 veiws.
a loop
object show fans wya? (ifykyk)
ua-cam.com/video/S9bpPWfiMLw/v-deo.html
is it just me or is fate of the stars just a pink floyd wannabe
3:23