YOUTUBE Q&A: Gf/bf Haram? Why 100 Lashes? Atheism? Still a Muslim? Music? | Dr. Shabir Ally

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 279

  • @cultural_fanatic
    @cultural_fanatic 4 роки тому +38

    One of the most reasonable, educated, and balanced scholars I've ever seen! May Allah bless him! 🙏

    • @sarahy.274
      @sarahy.274 3 роки тому

      check out Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl, he's also amazing

  • @camarnold7936
    @camarnold7936 5 років тому +136

    love shabir i am a muslim convert and i am turned off by conservatism and i love Shabirs take on islam it strengthens my faith

    • @TruthaboutIslam
      @TruthaboutIslam 5 років тому +2

      Watch Christian Prince on UA-cam

    • @subzero3056
      @subzero3056 5 років тому +1

      @Rayyan Hussain
      Thank you

    • @thegreatest1176
      @thegreatest1176 4 роки тому +20

      @@TruthaboutIslam christian prince doesnt even know his own bible, big lol

    • @dota2blendezt686
      @dota2blendezt686 4 роки тому

      Cam Arnold "Revert" brother

    • @mnnm1989
      @mnnm1989 4 роки тому +2

      "turned off by conservatism" so you dont like the way muslims used to live for ages and rather take his new washed down view on things? doesnt seem honest to me. the scriptures didnt changed neither...

  • @kylechau8594
    @kylechau8594 8 років тому +79

    I love these videos! Definitely answered some very relevant questions. More videos please. inshallah

  • @ahmad._.k2572
    @ahmad._.k2572 8 років тому +32

    thank you for answering my questions, may Allah bless the people who work on this chanel.
    amen

    • @ysfabd100
      @ysfabd100 8 років тому

      +Ahmad ._. k i would advice you to ask a real scholar that follows the quran and sunnah on the understanding of the sahaba . seeking religions knowledge from youtube stars will not end well for us in this world or hereafter

    • @ahmad._.k2572
      @ahmad._.k2572 8 років тому +4

      +sim crd that's the best part of asking for an advice you can ask more then one person, BTW he is a scholar. the girl is the ''UA-cam star'' and I'm asking the scholar.
      thanks for the heads up :)

    • @user-es7vb6fs9o
      @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому

      Ahmad ._. k Allaah says in Soorat Luqmaan (interpretation of the meaning):
      “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]
      The scholar of the ummah, Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: this means singing. Mujaahid (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: this means playing the drum (tabl). (Tafseer al-Tabari, 21/40).

    • @user-es7vb6fs9o
      @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому

      Ahmad ._. k The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said:
      “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).

    • @mdasaduzzaman2947
      @mdasaduzzaman2947 7 років тому

      Sim crd @ You can consider asking a scholar that follows the Quran and Sunnah on the understanding of the sahaba. But don't without neglecting the risk of prone to be a IS soldier.

  • @caits3272
    @caits3272 6 років тому +21

    So reasonable and measured. I love this show! I learn so much.

    • @sarahy.274
      @sarahy.274 3 роки тому

      check out Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl, he's also amazing

  • @jameswells9011
    @jameswells9011 5 років тому +6

    Wonderful video! I especially like how this one was produced with the question from the viewer displayed. Dr. Shabir's explanations are the best! They make so much sense and are backed by multiple sources.

    • @sarahy.274
      @sarahy.274 3 роки тому

      check out Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl, he's also amazing

  • @thmallik
    @thmallik 5 років тому +5

    All the answers I find in these videos are very competitive, contemporary and logical. Respect.

  • @pulsarstargrave256
    @pulsarstargrave256 6 років тому +5

    I LOVE DR.SHABIR, he has such a wonderful and reasonable approach to scripture, one based on common sense instead of dogma!

    • @sarahy.274
      @sarahy.274 3 роки тому

      check out Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl, he's also amazing

  • @kalijasin
    @kalijasin 8 років тому +45

    Most of us want more Q & A videos.

    • @ysfabd100
      @ysfabd100 8 років тому

      +Jason C. he says "For the believer it is the law of god that needs to be implemented " yet in another video he says cutting off the hand of a thief ( which is in the quran) is outdated. please explain this contradiction

    • @kalijasin
      @kalijasin 8 років тому

      sim crd I made no such statement in this thread.

    • @ysfabd100
      @ysfabd100 8 років тому

      Sorry I was replying Shabbir ally pls forgive me

    • @kalijasin
      @kalijasin 8 років тому

      +sim crd It's okay. No problem. :-)

    • @user-es7vb6fs9o
      @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому

      Jason C. Allaah says in Soorat Luqmaan (interpretation of the meaning):
      “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]
      The scholar of the ummah, Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: this means singing. Mujaahid (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: this means playing the drum (tabl). (Tafseer al-Tabari, 21/40).

  • @ahmadabdullahjameel
    @ahmadabdullahjameel 4 роки тому +10

    Wallahi, this is probably one of the most influential islamic channel on UA-cam, We're so blessed to have Scholars like Dr. Shabir, Thanks a lot for enlightening us & guiding this ummah in the right direction !

  • @sevilla7ful
    @sevilla7ful 3 роки тому +3

    These videos are amazing and so helpful and informative. They have encouraged me so much in my faith. I was feeling so down but now Alhamdullilah I have renewed hope.

  • @meganbailey4188
    @meganbailey4188 5 років тому +61

    Hahaha
    Came here for serious learning
    Lost myself when sister said "cool"
    Hahahaha
    Thank you for sharing the knowledge and the laughter :P

    • @subzero3056
      @subzero3056 5 років тому

      Never noticed that

    • @lkuk874
      @lkuk874 4 роки тому

      Bf

    • @amed.abraham
      @amed.abraham 3 роки тому

      Hahaha ... it's the simple truth, nothing complicated ... cool! :D

  • @erikahammerramalho1025
    @erikahammerramalho1025 5 років тому +5

    I really like and respect Dr. Shabbir and thank you so much for this channel, so helpful and enlightening. May God bless you and your family. JazakAllahu kheyr 💐

  • @RehanNWL
    @RehanNWL 7 років тому +6

    MashahAllah Sister, JazakAllah Khair to you and brother Shabir.

  • @shadowisblue1340
    @shadowisblue1340 4 роки тому +3

    I was in a long distance relationship..we were so much close and was best friend before... Then suddenly we broke up and it was from her side bcz of a family issue..as we were in a long distance relationship..no intimate things happend between us... I am born muslim but didn't have much knowledge about islam.. And i used to think it's not that much haram or something to be in a relationship.. Actually i didn't even prayed except jum'aa... But when she left me i started praying and supplicating to Allah that to give her back to me(ASAP as a gf)...bcz i missed her a lot and truly loved... Than i suddenly found some videos on islam.. I started learning a lot than before.. And understood Rltnship is haram.. But i was still praying to Allah to give her back if as a friend..but i decided if she come back want relationship i will try to make it halal through marriage and if she want friendship(as she asked at the time of brkup to be a frnd) i'll give it bcz i thought it's may be not that much sin to be friend.. after 2 month suddenly she came back and wanted friendship so i give it her as decided.. But by the time passed i get to knw that even talking to girl without reason is also prohibited.. So i decided to leave her.. And i did few days back...and i stopped talking to other girls... But some days after i again started to miss her and i'm feeling like i still love her.. I knw it sounds dumb...like I want her in halal way by marriage but it's not possible... I'm so much broken now...can't even concentrate in my prayers. So will someone suggest me what to do in that situation.. I don't want to continue any kind of haram things...I just want to be a religious person... Pray for me that Allah may give me proper hidayah.. Keep me in the right path... And plz suggest me how can i overcome that broken situation and can stick to my deen.

    • @Ken_77
      @Ken_77 2 роки тому +1

      Assalam walikum
      You can talk with her but your intention shouldn't be bad nor you should commit adultery and as per I saw especially in Indonesia you can handshake with girls in bussiness meeting also ..only if she agrees to do so and remember Allah watching you so your thinking and intention shouldn't be bad nor her
      And love isn't a sin
      Rest Allah knows best

  • @estherniqab8324
    @estherniqab8324 3 роки тому +1

    I enjoy the level headed manner in which you speak and how you show similarities between Islam and Christianity without speaking against it. The clarity and manner of which you speak is highly commendable. I enjoy your videos immensely.

  • @aminahshahid8878
    @aminahshahid8878 5 років тому +5

    I love this Scholar's humbleness

  • @teteazote2457
    @teteazote2457 5 років тому +17

    The "cool" part tho😁😂

  • @fasilatsanusi7431
    @fasilatsanusi7431 4 роки тому +2

    Thank you Dr. It is good to know each other before marriage and not based on the recommendation of someone else to avoid problem in the future.

  • @deadsimpleali5540
    @deadsimpleali5540 2 роки тому +1

    Always very informative and sensible discussion by Mr Shabir.

  • @nazree1975
    @nazree1975 3 роки тому +2

    Love videos from Dr Shabir.... alhamdulillah.. Islam is way of life as per what teach from Quran..

  • @tasnimsobur2056
    @tasnimsobur2056 8 місяців тому

    All of my respect to him. The most reasonable scholar and his answers are simply perfect. I came across many scholars and i think he is the most reasonable out of all. May allah bless him. His videos strengthens my faith in islam.

  • @perkca8587
    @perkca8587 8 років тому +3

    salam Dr. Shabir I truly enjoy Q&A videos. please we need more .

  • @cody7875
    @cody7875 7 років тому +11

    Whoever is responsible for the thumbnail for this video needs to be lashed, severely. They made the good man Ally look deranged.

  • @esfanintan
    @esfanintan 3 роки тому +4

    how can music be haraam when Quran recitation is so musical.

    • @trywinx1993
      @trywinx1993 3 роки тому

      Its not musical, tajwid is not music, its the recitation of the Qur’an

    • @ahmedmohammad7300
      @ahmedmohammad7300 3 роки тому

      Exactly
      It's the same thing.
      Something nice to the ears which touches your soul through the way it sounds and is understood.

    • @nazree1975
      @nazree1975 3 роки тому

      Exactly....!

    • @dontinsultme4821
      @dontinsultme4821 3 роки тому

      @@ahmedmohammad7300 musical instruments are haram not music or poetry

    • @salmanbaluch1664
      @salmanbaluch1664 3 роки тому

      @@dontinsultme4821 music is haraam

  • @deepthinker8153
    @deepthinker8153 4 роки тому +3

    Dr Shabir is my favorite scholar.

  • @sabr7413
    @sabr7413 4 роки тому +1

    I really like Dr. Shabi Ally points on view and interpretation. Mashallah

  • @columnistatpootoharbpo726
    @columnistatpootoharbpo726 5 років тому +1

    Allah bless you. You are too awesome, genuine and close to many muslims. Best wishes for you, your contributions, your family. Respect from Pakistan! Very good role model for us here as well.

  • @estherniqab8324
    @estherniqab8324 3 роки тому

    You have the most open and unbiased explanations I have heard. I truly enjoy your videos.

  • @user-es7vb6fs9o
    @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому +3

    Allaah says in Soorat Luqmaan (interpretation of the meaning):
    “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]
    The scholar of the ummah, Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: this means singing. Mujaahid (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: this means playing the drum (tabl). (Tafseer al-Tabari, 21/40).

    • @ahmedibnadam5038
      @ahmedibnadam5038 7 років тому +3

      ibn Abbas' authority and Mujahid's authority - these are Sahaba. The Sahaba have the authority to interpret the Qur'an. Who else is better to tell us what the verses mean??

    • @dontinsultme4821
      @dontinsultme4821 3 роки тому

      @@mdasaduzzaman2947 sahabas not us
      Are you better than companions no right

  • @mdhabiburrahman-theprogame3131
    @mdhabiburrahman-theprogame3131 5 років тому +5

    I got one important question please answer so the question is
    Is it harem to upload Videos on youtube on as a Muslim

  • @bruhziz3503
    @bruhziz3503 2 роки тому +2

    May Allah SWT guide us all

  • @asimrafidhaque9984
    @asimrafidhaque9984 4 роки тому +7

    3:38 Cool XD

  • @theCooldl
    @theCooldl 3 роки тому +1

    Cool... Shabir is her father... She probably forgot that they were talking to an audience not father and daughter talked

    • @sarailyas8401
      @sarailyas8401 2 роки тому

      She practices hijab and in one interview when she asled him if it was mandatory Dr Shabir said no it wasnt. Then why she does it?

  • @sekolahonlineteknikotomotif
    @sekolahonlineteknikotomotif 4 роки тому +2

    I still don't understand how is the Islamic way to find a spouse. It seems illogical, difficult way to conduct.
    I mean, I live in Poland, and majority of the women here are Christian and a very minority of them may be Muslims (but they're virtually unseen!).
    So how is it possible to get to know each other if interaction is even prohibited!?
    Please, I know that doing khalwat is close to zina, but how can I get a spouse if my interaction is even restricted?
    Any help or suggestions would be very appreciated 🙏

    • @ML-jw8kf
      @ML-jw8kf 2 роки тому

      At work. At public events. At family gatherings. Work is one of the best ways, as you really get to know the person's character. This is exactly how Khadija (RAN) choose our Rasul (PBUH).

  • @OmarAbdulAzeez4714
    @OmarAbdulAzeez4714 4 роки тому +1

    Instead of saying cool our beloved prohet directed us to say specific words when amazed..happy..sad ie..maa shaa Allaah..subhana Allaah ..ALLAAHAKBAR etc..

  • @WarriorAthletix
    @WarriorAthletix 8 років тому +8

    Dear Dr. Shabir, what is the "sheehab" mentioned in the quran? the one that shoots jinns the shooting star? how could a star detach itself and kill a jinny? why would it in the first place? very curious. p.s your videos on the mathematical miracle of the quran have given me so much faith in this divinely balanced book bless up Dr shabir I hope one day I get the honor of shaking your hand. a great man who speaks the truth

    • @Yameen200
      @Yameen200 8 років тому +1

      +WarriorLife I hope that u are not basing your faith on just mathematical miracles, there were some ppl they believed everything like the Quran is correct on embryology, then some atheiists said hey the greeks knew this already and then they said no this not the book of god, so its very dangerous thing to base faith on mere mathematical miracles.

    • @karkooshy95
      @karkooshy95 8 років тому +7

      +WarriorLife You're incorrectly carrying implications based on English translations and applying them on an Arabic text. The English language lacks many words that Arabic has a specific and distinct term for. For example, in English you need two words to describe a "female camel", but Arabic has a single term (ناقة/Naqa) to describe the same being.
      Likewise, English might use two words ("shooting star") to describe this bright object that we can sometimes see traveling across the sky at night... but Arabic can describe the same object with a single word ("sheehab"). And the term sheehab doesn't carry connotations of it being some kind of "star", like the English expression might imply to someone unaware of the context.
      As for the why would it question, I don't see how this is problematic. It's only an issue if you're actually able to see jinn, in order to confirm that the shooting stars aren't targeting them lol. An if-then statement is only demonstrably false if you can present cases where the premise is true, but the conclusion doesn't follow.

    • @WarriorAthletix
      @WarriorAthletix 8 років тому +3

      +Yameen200 I see where you are going with this however numbers will never be subject to interpretation, 25 will always be 25... 1 + 1 will always equal 2... bless up : )

    • @WarriorAthletix
      @WarriorAthletix 8 років тому

      +karkooshy95 I appreciate you taking the time to explain it me, however I still don't understand and would like a deeper explanation. my question is what is the Sheehab and why does it exist? bless up : )

    • @Yameen200
      @Yameen200 8 років тому

      WarriorLife Yes but there are some that may be sceptical and say Shakespear also has matheamtcal miracles ? why shoulndt i believe that is from God. or one may say how do we know the Prophet Muhammad SAW didnt just plan it all from the start to fool the later ppl.

  • @fasilatsanusi7431
    @fasilatsanusi7431 3 роки тому

    Great discussion

  • @mongoosekhan3079
    @mongoosekhan3079 4 роки тому

    “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).

    • @ML-jw8kf
      @ML-jw8kf 2 роки тому +1

      Dude, Many of the Sahih Hadiths have errors and are deeply problematic. Do not take Hadiths as the word of Allah. Hadiths are written by man and hence bound to be with error.

  • @mohammedazimmapkar7754
    @mohammedazimmapkar7754 4 місяці тому

    For Umar Ali, Brother I am no scholar, but to my layman understanding, I would prefer 100 lashes on earth anyday with asking forgiveness of Allah s.w.t rather than burning in hell. Surely Allah s.w.t will judge us all, but isn't it better that our sins are forgiven on earth itself rather than us being put into Jahannam?

  • @nuckchorris6351
    @nuckchorris6351 8 років тому +4

    Mashallah

  • @ovaiszohan3766
    @ovaiszohan3766 3 роки тому +1

    Thank u Dr shabbir aly.... U r the only one muslim scholar whom I've some belief left in 😅.. Rest all other scholars claim thr opinions to be "Islam"

    • @saniatamanna7763
      @saniatamanna7763 2 роки тому +1

      Yes same thing. Other scholars take some indirect Hadith and tell their opinion.

    • @ovaiszohan3766
      @ovaiszohan3766 2 роки тому +1

      @@saniatamanna7763 yup... I had actually left Islam bcoz of it... But thnx to Dr shabbir aly... I reverted back... And i try to guide those who are perplexed regarding Islam

  • @zahednow
    @zahednow 3 роки тому

    -Regarding the answer for bf/gf he didn't specify that it would be halal only if a mahram is present in between their interactions.
    -Regarding the question for not praying, the simple answer is yes he is muslim but non-practising. And since he is not a practising muslim means either his faith is very weak or his utmost believe of Judgement day is very weak (because no sane person who knows his actions will be rewarded/punished will act so lazily).

  • @ahmedabdelkerim9542
    @ahmedabdelkerim9542 6 років тому

    Thank you for good advice
    شكرا جزيلا

  • @abdulazeez1580
    @abdulazeez1580 5 років тому +1

    I once went to my non muslim friend's house. It was the time for my obligatory prayer and there wasn't a mosque nearby. Inside the house also people are walking here and there. So the only clean place which I thought was suitable to offer namaz was the prayer room they had. But it had many images of hindu God in front and on the walls. I was not sure whether it's ok to pray there, so I specifically added in my niyah that oh Allah, my prostration being done is in front of you and not these images. So i prayed over there. My doubt is will my prayer be accepted in such case? Have I committed a sin?

    • @ahmedmohammad7300
      @ahmedmohammad7300 3 роки тому

      Isn't Allah the all knowing?
      Then why would HE count your deed as a sin? When you practiced your due diligence already.

    • @Ken_77
      @Ken_77 2 роки тому

      No it won't cause you didn't prostate to the Hindu God's your intention were to pray to allah not hindu gods and Indeen He knows what you were doing

  • @suhanrahman8279
    @suhanrahman8279 4 роки тому

    I love Dr.Shabir Ally

  • @khaakkhaak2944
    @khaakkhaak2944 6 років тому +1

    i love dr shabir ally

  • @mohamedameen309
    @mohamedameen309 8 років тому +3

    Assalamu'alaykum! Would non-muslims who have suffered a lot in this worldly life such as from poverty, cancer etc end up in hell? If so, how does God be just and compensate them?

    • @Yameen200
      @Yameen200 8 років тому +4

      +Mohamed Ameen It depends, its a difficult question, It depends on their level of understanding and rejection of the truth. When the Quran speaks of disbelieevrs it does not refer to Non Muslims, but if the non muslim was a rejector and against the religion or God and counts as a disbeliever but they suffered many problems it is hard to say what could happen.

    • @mohamedameen309
      @mohamedameen309 8 років тому +4

      Yameen200 Jazakamullahu Khayran for your reply. One thing's for sure that there would no injustice on that Day. Hopefully the issue would be clarified by the Shaykh as well :)

    • @Geralt_of_Rivia7
      @Geralt_of_Rivia7 4 роки тому +1

      @@Yameen200 Wa Alaikum Assalaam.. from my understanding, it seems that Allah will pardon those who already suffered in this world like the Jews during the Holocaust due to them already having been tormented. And in addition, Allah is the Most Merciful. And Allah knows best.

    • @Yameen200
      @Yameen200 4 роки тому

      @@Geralt_of_Rivia7 I dont know hey. Im very sceptical, the quran is filled with torture verses, so sadistic its like anything u believe thats incorrect u will burn and boil. I dont think there is any god who cares about ppls sufferings.
      Morality is a gray area. Divine Justice is even harder. I dont know how its even possible to fix thede issues

    • @Geralt_of_Rivia7
      @Geralt_of_Rivia7 4 роки тому

      @@Yameen200 like there are different stages of Heaven there are indeed different stages of hell.. only the most wicked of people will be put in the deeper layers. The Quran refers to the punishment that these people will receive. Those in the shallower layers may not even have to suffer at all.. but instead ponder about their sins and mistakes and ask God for forgiveness. But Allah knows best, this is simply my understanding which many people and scholars share. It seems completely rational to me personally. Everyone will be given complete justice and it shall be exactly what each soul deserves. We must remember that God is the most Merciful, not just to Muslims or those who have been given divine guidance or even to all those who believe in him, nay, to ALL his creation.

  • @aqilyusri132
    @aqilyusri132 3 роки тому +1

    I'm not really a believer. But, I have much respect to him than that Z.N.

  • @sheemabhat3468
    @sheemabhat3468 5 років тому +2

    Asalamu alaikm brother....which book should i consult to know those verses of the Quran which has scientific background in order that i may understand?
    Humble request!
    And is there a any particular book where all scientific verses are detailed?

    • @thanaa9530
      @thanaa9530 4 роки тому +1

      Wa alaikum asalam :) I definately recommend this website
      www.miracles-of-quran.com/
      It basically goes through all the scientific miracles of the Quran whether they are complex or easy to understand in nature :)
      Definately learnt alot from this website and was very easy to understand, Alhamdullilah :)

    • @yooshatarique019
      @yooshatarique019 3 роки тому +1

      Quran and science by zakir naik

    • @sheemabhat3468
      @sheemabhat3468 3 роки тому +2

      @@thanaa9530 jazakalla khair kaseera dear.May Allah reward you abundantly. Are u on Facebook then let me know. I wud request you there such talented.

    • @sheemabhat3468
      @sheemabhat3468 3 роки тому +1

      @@thanaa9530 how can i get all the Christian material as a comparative study to Ahle kitaab

    • @thanaa9530
      @thanaa9530 3 роки тому

      @@sheemabhat3468 wa iyyaki sister, i have to admit though that now my views on scientific miracles in the Quran have changed considerably (in the sense that i now believe it is VERY risky to prove the Quran is the word of Allah (swt) through using evidence of scientific mitacles). I know this may sound very contrary / opposite to the general ummah however il post a link to a video that really helped me to understand this inshaAllah 😊

  • @nasromohamed2429
    @nasromohamed2429 8 років тому

    Very beneficial

  • @xllab1
    @xllab1 5 років тому +3

    The thumbnail 😅

  • @ifrasheikh3135
    @ifrasheikh3135 6 років тому +1

    what did he just said quran has left some of the judgements to the mankind ..then why did Allah send his phophet saw .he just talks out of his own desires ..i urge u if u wanna learn true religion plz dnt listen to this devient ..he is leading the ummah astray

  • @andallahelansary1517
    @andallahelansary1517 5 років тому

    thank you . love it .

  • @mohammadi5199
    @mohammadi5199 8 років тому +1

    What should be the Muslims responds to gay people adopting child.

  • @airh5
    @airh5 5 років тому +5

    "cool"

  • @m.n.m.nabeel6366
    @m.n.m.nabeel6366 3 роки тому

    Hi Dr. Shabir said that what was not said explicited prohibited maybe permissable and in terms of music maybe if it doesn't go against islam it could be permissable (something close). I heard from another scholar, other than hadith all 4 schools of thought have explicitly mentioned that music is haram other than the drum based on the buhari hadith where it talks about people will try to make adultery, alcohol and instruments of music halal. If schools of thoughts says no, we should abide by them right?
    (Please keep me posted, if there was a response to this?)

    • @ML-jw8kf
      @ML-jw8kf 2 роки тому +3

      Because schools of thoughts are exactly that - Schools of thought. They are not ultimate, not absolute. They are also interpretations. Also remember they are classical schools of thought.

    • @cf5397
      @cf5397 Рік тому

      You should stop laughing and anytime you do you need to fall on your face and beg forgiveness.
      Sound reasonable? That's what you're asking for.

  • @AliShah.336
    @AliShah.336 6 років тому

    I Love, enjoy and admire Dr. Shabbir's wealth of Knowledge and his interpretation of reasoning, and I am thoroughly attentive to his explanations. Could you please ask Dr. Shabbir about his views and explanations on the "Tree of Life" and "The Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil". I have a difficulty in understanding it's literal meaning but I believe that an allegorical context would bear more fruitful meaning to this Biblical and islamic Narratives.

  • @Mscursed2
    @Mscursed2 8 років тому

    more videos like this! inshallah

  • @moolamdisarker3368
    @moolamdisarker3368 6 років тому

    Every child is born to Islam (Muslim), then his parents make him a Jew, a nasara or a murtipooj/doll prostrate " (Bukhari and Muslim).Hadith

  • @dyousaf4862
    @dyousaf4862 5 років тому

    Asalam o alikum please guide about missed prayers JazakAllah

  • @shakilsultan1097
    @shakilsultan1097 4 роки тому

    Zajakallah Khair.

  • @ALANSARYVlogsDUBAI
    @ALANSARYVlogsDUBAI 4 роки тому

    Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha......! Coool ! Remembering her body language i can't stop laughing.....

  • @joustiev
    @joustiev 4 роки тому

    Asalamualaikum
    My question is if anyone loves someone too much ...but is not allowed for nikkah becz of age is it allowed to talk with him/her in decent way.

    • @beewirks
      @beewirks 3 роки тому

      the best thing you can do is cut communication and wait until you both are ready and insha'Allah you two are naseeb. I myself am going through the same thing and it is difficult but I trust Allah will guide us back together in this dunya or in the akhirah.

  • @humanhuman295
    @humanhuman295 5 років тому +1

    DR SHABIR ALLY, With due respect, you try to defend each and everything but totally ignore the contribution of humans who spent and invested their time in research for mankind that today you are also beneficiary of using you-tube, phone, tv, plane , internet , health and so on .even u are living in non Muslim country with full freedom and chanting/defending about Quran and islam with lots of twist and turns and illogical answers. sorry!! if you are really logical then help people to love logic and reasoning rather than blind faith off course a religion

  • @makingthematrix
    @makingthematrix 4 роки тому +2

    No dating, no romance, no time for figuring out who you want to be with... You will never experience a big and beautiful part of life, you guys.

    • @atikadutt4795
      @atikadutt4795 4 роки тому

      You have a choice if you want to marry them. You can go on halal dates with a parent or sibling.

    • @makingthematrix
      @makingthematrix 4 роки тому +1

      @@atikadutt4795 : It's a very sad, limited alternative.

    • @reihino6347
      @reihino6347 4 роки тому +1

      Dating is fleeting and usually ends in hurt feelings and heartbreak anyway. Why go through that when you can get to know each other in a halal way without putting everything on the line. Its better for all parties and usually ends with people spending their lives together.

    • @makingthematrix
      @makingthematrix 4 роки тому +1

      @@reihino6347 : I completely disagree. Dating is a beautiful, important part of life. You can find someone you will love for the rest of your life. And even when it doesn't, it can be the beginning of a friendship or a moment in your life you will remember fondly.

    • @atikadutt4795
      @atikadutt4795 4 роки тому +1

      makingthematrix ok but if you do something that can ruin your life, and what if someone hurts you so much that you go thru depression or any other mental disorder? God is trying to help us so that we don’t go through pain. Please stop trying to tell us something we don’t care about.

  • @shayaandanish5831
    @shayaandanish5831 4 роки тому

    I'd just like if you say "not acceptable by Allah rather than Islam"

  • @tauhid9983
    @tauhid9983 5 років тому

    As for belief and action... though they are distinct they are interelated. I mean practically speaking if someone beliefs and doesn't pray: WHY THE HECK NOT?? There can be time issue but that's a different case... one who prays atleast once a day atleast says something to remember Allah they are OKAY! But someone who doesn't pray at all due to ignorance and laziness, but still beliefs thats kinda contridictory, right? I mean u don't pray > u ignore Allah > Allah ignores u > therefore no belief. Simple equation. But hey this what I think! I don't know what the Quran say... so if someone disagrees please comment away.
    ps: I kinda think Dr Shabbir is raising the issue with regard to not praying because to time... cuz a muslim not praying at all due to ignorance and laziness is UNBELIEVABLE!

  • @lynnyip73
    @lynnyip73 3 роки тому

    Why are there numerous contradictions in the Quran and why are muslims hypocrites in practicing the ideologies of Ialam. For example, the quran claims there should be NO compulsion in religion, sura 2:257. The fact of the matter is that in many muslim communities, apostates are murdered for leaving islam. The quran, hadiths and sunnas teach that when muslims are in the majority with power and numbers, unbelievers are to be executed, exiled , converted to islam or in the case of Jews and Christians, become second class citizens(dhimmies ) and pay taxes for protection. Regarding insulting Mohammad, did he not have a women executed for writing unflattering poems about him? Why can a person get away with insulting Allah but be murdered for drawing a cartoon about Mohammad. Please explain. Thank you.

  • @legitvideos8392
    @legitvideos8392 5 років тому

    Muslims taking charity from non Muslims is Haram or halal? In worse financial condition?

  • @mdyusuf3174
    @mdyusuf3174 5 років тому

    please give me advice that how to stop the sinning which repeats over again again after some interval

    • @faiz9335
      @faiz9335 4 роки тому

      Remember Always ....ALLAH is watching us.
      Fear of ALLAH

  • @rajibhossain9918
    @rajibhossain9918 3 роки тому

    Your girlfriend falls under the category ma malekat aymanakum. 50 lashes if she does Fahisha or Zina

  • @armathstudy8737
    @armathstudy8737 6 років тому

    very beautiful vedio

  • @dsmvfl363
    @dsmvfl363 8 років тому +6

    Modern music has many haram things in it, and I don't mean like haram in subject matter like most may assume, but in a scientific matter. Modern music is used as a implicit conditioning tool, it is sold as an opiate to society, it is brainwashing us to the most scientific definition of the term. At the most basic level it is selling us unhealthy Perspectives of things like happiness or sadness, and makes us worship things like ones self and ones emotions. Here's a test, see if you can have true Kushu in your salah and still listen to modern music regularly. this stuff is ruining our psychology, that is why it is haram

    • @dsmvfl363
      @dsmvfl363 8 років тому

      that's because that is what these industries want you to see, that it is for your benefit and not your harm, it seems awfully convenient that no one is funding the publications of studies that examine the conditioning effects of music on society, and if your muslim, look at the hadith on Seeth, one of the sons of Adam.

    • @dsmvfl363
      @dsmvfl363 8 років тому +1

      Andalus101 the studies say that music stimulates your brain, all the studies that say it is a positive simulation are financed by biased backers

    • @dsmvfl363
      @dsmvfl363 8 років тому

      Andalus101 it doesn't look good when you resort to ad hominems to argue, also ask yourself if the reason you are so adamant to defending modern music is not a result of implicit conditioning. Read the hadith of Seeth if you truly care and remember that i only critique music to protect the members of my faith from being misguided, i am not merely attacking music out of some hatred or irrationality, i only want what is best for us.

    • @user-es7vb6fs9o
      @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому

      Saad S Allaah says in Soorat Luqmaan (interpretation of the meaning):
      “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]
      The scholar of the ummah, Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: this means singing. Mujaahid (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: this means playing the drum (tabl). (Tafseer al-Tabari, 21/40).

    • @user-es7vb6fs9o
      @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому

      Saad S The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said:
      “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).

  • @saidrogerrm8896
    @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

    what about the profet ,,,????? he become profet at 40 of aged and was not islamique maried to khadidja and he does not to do zina cose he got many womans 12 or more

  • @esfanintan
    @esfanintan 3 роки тому

    would a non-muslim have a chance to go to heaven?

  • @rosalinddavies8466
    @rosalinddavies8466 2 роки тому

    Ahh then it’s permissible to speak to member of the opposite sex not secluded or haram activities and they aren’t actually married to you

  • @RobenArjen
    @RobenArjen Рік тому

    Lashes are prescribed if fornication is seen not just by talking or meeting

  • @mohammedaslampasha743
    @mohammedaslampasha743 4 роки тому +1

    @3:38 COOL 😂😂😂😂

  • @donboklangsohkhia2089
    @donboklangsohkhia2089 4 роки тому

    If Jesus was just a prophet..then Why his disciples heal a lame man in Jesus name ?? (Act chapter 3)

    • @atiqullahishaqzai2454
      @atiqullahishaqzai2454 4 роки тому

      People can heal in the name of a devil does that makes him god....
      Everything Jesus peace me upon him did was in the name of god the one and only ... he said that himself.

  • @tashtean
    @tashtean 7 років тому +2

    cool 🤓

  • @user-es7vb6fs9o
    @user-es7vb6fs9o 7 років тому +6

    The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said:
    “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).

  • @TheMarekduda
    @TheMarekduda 6 років тому

    What about in the quran 40:60 is tha for real ? Plz someone explain

    • @silent2708
      @silent2708 5 років тому

      Yes, but don't see it in a negative context. Allah is threatning you with hellfire out of love. Allah does not want you to go anywhere else to seek for things because Allah knows wherever/whomever you go to, it won't be granted. Allah says ask me and I'll give! Allah is Al-Waahab (The giver of gifts).
      In the same way a parent may say, if you ever need financial help come and ask me for money! or I swear hellfire will fall upon you. They don't say this to threaten, but out of love. They fear they if you go through financial difficulties and you don't tell them you may end up going to commit suicide due to the pressures and that'd hurt them would it not? etc..

  • @saidrogerrm8896
    @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

    MY DAD IS DEAD OVER 25 YEARS WHAT ABOUT HIS RUNNING AFTER GIRLS ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,???????????????? SHOULD WE GIVE HIM 100 LASHES TOO ??????? OR IS HELL DOIYING IT ?????????????????????????????????????????????

  • @richardcrosby6682
    @richardcrosby6682 7 років тому +2

    Dr. Shabir looks hilarious in the thumbnail.

  • @esfanintan
    @esfanintan 3 роки тому

    why one do I heaven?

  • @yahawahyaohu5238
    @yahawahyaohu5238 4 роки тому

    ! revealed Myself to those who did not ask for Me; I was found by those who did not seek Me. To a nation that did not call on My 'Shúam' (Name), I said, 'Here am I, here am I.' - YaoshuaYÁOHU (Isaiah) 65:1

  • @marinusadrianus2886
    @marinusadrianus2886 4 роки тому

    U have to make a Quran 2.0 like the Christians were u don’t kill people if they leave their believe

  • @MaksudulShadatAkash
    @MaksudulShadatAkash 4 роки тому

    Cooool

  • @aymanalij
    @aymanalij 4 роки тому

    So Coldplay is good, but Lil Wayne bad. Cool!

  • @rameezrazzak
    @rameezrazzak 6 років тому

    Hige can of Dr. Shabir Ally - I wish he didn't choose to dwell into fiqh issues, especially when hos views go against fiqhi rulings with centuries of scholars backing them.

  • @SirPax1000
    @SirPax1000 8 років тому +2

    Is it Halal to keep dogs as pets?

    • @ziad9596
      @ziad9596 8 років тому +1

      u can but the angels won't come in ur house and if they lick something u have to wash it 7 times and one of them using sand

    • @ziad9596
      @ziad9596 8 років тому

      Perways Hussein
      lol bro u asked me to provide hadith about the licking not pets
      its not the hadith's problem that u came to that conclusion, aisha r.a had a poppy but then jibreel a.s complain so they didnt allow it to live inside their home

    • @ziad9596
      @ziad9596 8 років тому

      Perways Hussein
      u do know it has been proven scientifically that thats the only way to clean from a dog's lick

    • @ziad9596
      @ziad9596 8 років тому

      Datu Pax Ali Mangudadatu
      actually i take back what i said islamqa.info/en/69777 some said its halal some said its haram, u should research it more, allahu a'lam god knows best but for now its better to stay away from things udk until u know 100%

    • @ziad9596
      @ziad9596 7 років тому

      Andalus101
      who runs islamqa?

  • @saidrogerrm8896
    @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

    WHY 100 LASHES IM CHILD OF FORNICATION AND MUST OF THE WORLD IS . EVEN MUSLIMS TOO DO ZINA ....................

    • @QuranSpeaks
      @QuranSpeaks  3 роки тому

      Did you watch the actual video before commenting?

    • @saidrogerrm8896
      @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

      @@QuranSpeaks I DONT HAVE TO WATCH THE COMPLETE VIDEO MY ANSWER IS THAT MOST OF MANKIND ARE FROM ADULTERES OFSPRING AND ALL DOOMED TO HELL

  • @Magic818100
    @Magic818100 6 років тому

    The problem is man has created God in his own image

  • @NRFP
    @NRFP 2 роки тому +1

    BF FGF is haram but right hand process/malakat aymanukum(war captive women)is halal. lol

  • @OmarAbdulAzeez4714
    @OmarAbdulAzeez4714 4 роки тому

    No offence bt imam ur wrong islam is poison to the heart n distracts your heart n u can commit son by hearin n loose focus in saalah equally to movies are haraam cause u can make sin ie zinna ny hearing n seeing disadvantages out weighs the advantages...instead of wastin time with all this..do dhikr..humans purpose on earth was worship period

  • @BoyOfTheFuture4987
    @BoyOfTheFuture4987 8 років тому +1

    Her dress up reminds me of Arno with Assassin outfit for Assassin's creed untiy

    • @kalijasin
      @kalijasin 8 років тому

      +Uzumaki Naruto Aisha's outfit is provided by www.ILoveModesty.com

    • @Geralt_of_Rivia7
      @Geralt_of_Rivia7 4 роки тому +1

      That's pretty random but I can't say that I disagree with you lol

  • @eddiematenkotribute3454
    @eddiematenkotribute3454 3 роки тому

    i want to sample the goods before marriage

  • @BoyOfTheFuture4987
    @BoyOfTheFuture4987 8 років тому

    My question
    Who did Qabil marry

  • @saidrogerrm8896
    @saidrogerrm8896 4 роки тому

    I CAN NOT UNDERSTAND THE PUNISH LAWS OF GOD IM MESELF BORN OUT OF ADULTERY AND MY CHILDREN TO HOW GOD CAN PUNISH MY PARENTS AND FOREFATHERS AND MESELF THAN ,,,,,,,????????????? HE GOD CREATED ME IN SIN AND PIGEATING SO MY PARENTS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @aboowe4801
      @aboowe4801 3 роки тому

      Try to directly ask a scholsr of Islam

    • @saidrogerrm8896
      @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

      @@aboowe4801 THE FACT IS THAT MILJOEN OF PEOPLE ARE BORN DAILY PIGEATING AND NOT KNOWING ISLAM THAT MEANS THAT ISLAM IS NOT FOR EVRYBODY .BUT WHY MAKING A DRAMA IF GOD DOESNT LIKKE SOME OF HIS CREATURES ?????? AFTER ALL WE ARE HIS CREATION AS THE DEVIL IS ALSO WHOM MISLEAD HUMANITY . I FEEL SAD AND DEPRESED AND WILL GO TO HELL FOREVER AND I WISH I WAS NEVER BORN IF ETERNALY HELL WAITS US BYE BYE TAKE CARE

    • @aboowe4801
      @aboowe4801 3 роки тому

      @@saidrogerrm8896 You are David wood fan right? That's a red flag. Shouldn't have talked to a 6million iq guy like you.
      Anyway, peace be upon you and may Allah guide you

    • @saidrogerrm8896
      @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

      I M THANKS GOD A BELIEVER IN HIM GOD BUT NOT FAN OF DAVID HOWEVER AS MUSLIM WITH KATHOLIK BACKGROUND DAVID SAYS MANY TIMES THE TRUTH TOO AND I LIKKE DR SHABYR ALSO HE IS THE PERFEKT EXEMPLE OF REAL MUSLIM BEHEAVER SALAAMA BROTH ALLAH WILL JUDGE US ALL AMIN

    • @saidrogerrm8896
      @saidrogerrm8896 3 роки тому

      I LOVE CHRISTIANS AND MUSLIMS COSE IM FROM MIX RELIGIOUS BACKGROUND AMIN