Pakistanis are not interested in anything that comes anywhere near being intellectual. We just want to make money, either by begging or any other means.
@@javedsiddiqui1870 That's sad my friend. Hope Few people like them who are attending and people like you can do justice to ur nation. Hope from india ❤️
I thank Ali Warisuzzaman ji from the depths of my heart for this retrospective of Sahir's poetry. It requires a deep knowledge of the subject and language to make the audience appreciate sny shayar. The quality of the presentation is much much better in quality than a similar retrospective on Sahir done by Javed Akhtar a couple of years back. Very much appreciated.
At the end of the day, all muslim persons involved in Hindi film industry were basically dreaming of Ghazwa e Hind and slyly included Allah in their films
I know this for a fact with 200% accuracy that Urdu did not originate from Hindi. It was actually Hindi that can be said to have originated from Urdu (although it is not as simple as that considering the dialect Hindustani). No one reads comments so I will keep it at this. But, Urdu did not originate from Hindi, as was stated in the very beginning.
It was not Hindi.. according to my reading and understanding... The language was "hindustani" from which Hindi and Urdu both took the current form and with time these 2 evolved., My mother tongue has much older tehzeeb and history than urdu and hindi both.. ie Bengali.(just a fact, nothing to do with the current topic)
@@shonty1985 Yes I agree I mentioned Hindustani. But I'm not aware whether the term is a relatively newer invention, or did it also exist back in the day.
@@javedsiddiqui1870 According to our history books... Hindustani was there since Gupta Empire and with Turks and Persian invasions, things changed and language evolved.
Same as denying simple fact that your forefathers were Hindus and are converted, Urdu came into existence when Persian who were persecuted in Iran had problems speaking Hindi thus it's a mixture of that fact checked ( but you keep believing what you believe it makes you happy just like it has privious generations
Program on sahir by Javed Akhtar in rekhta was a glorious diversity and interrogative by huge audience
it's sad to see the amount of people attending the session on late great sahir ludhiyanwi.
If it was in India... Things would have been different.
Pakistanis are not interested in anything that comes anywhere near being intellectual. We just want to make money, either by begging or any other means.
@@javedsiddiqui1870 That's sad my friend. Hope Few people like them who are attending and people like you can do justice to ur nation.
Hope from india ❤️
@@shonty1985 I think we need to consider the whole human race as a nation, to be honest. We need to succeed together as human beings.❤
@@javedsiddiqui1870 I second that 👍
Thanks TBH for this session.
The attendance is indeed thin, but what matters is quality, not quantity.
I thank Ali Warisuzzaman ji from the depths of my heart for this retrospective of Sahir's poetry. It requires a deep knowledge of the subject and language to make the audience appreciate sny shayar. The quality of the presentation is much much better in quality than a similar retrospective on Sahir done by Javed Akhtar a couple of years back. Very much appreciated.
Plz ap log bhi rekhta k zakhire ko bda kre contribution den.....Taki subcontinent k students isse labh le ske...
At the end of the day, all muslim persons involved in Hindi film industry were basically dreaming of Ghazwa e Hind and slyly included Allah in their films
Nice talk, but comparison of Sahir with Fayyaz Hashmi seems sort of unfair. The later was a hackneyed filmi poet sans any social awareness or pathos.
Sahir was a great poet. 🙏🏽👍🏼
I know this for a fact with 200% accuracy that Urdu did not originate from Hindi. It was actually Hindi that can be said to have originated from Urdu (although it is not as simple as that considering the dialect Hindustani). No one reads comments so I will keep it at this. But, Urdu did not originate from Hindi, as was stated in the very beginning.
It was not Hindi.. according to my reading and understanding... The language was "hindustani" from which Hindi and Urdu both took the current form and with time these 2 evolved.,
My mother tongue has much older tehzeeb and history than urdu and hindi both.. ie Bengali.(just a fact, nothing to do with the current topic)
@@shonty1985 Yes I agree I mentioned Hindustani. But I'm not aware whether the term is a relatively newer invention, or did it also exist back in the day.
@@javedsiddiqui1870 According to our history books... Hindustani was there since Gupta Empire and with Turks and Persian invasions, things changed and language evolved.
Same as denying simple fact that your forefathers were Hindus and are converted, Urdu came into existence when Persian who were persecuted in Iran had problems speaking Hindi thus it's a mixture of that fact checked ( but you keep believing what you believe it makes you happy just like it has privious generations
@@pinxtownington4645 💩💩💩