This and That: 2020 Four Continents Championships
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лис 2024
- This week, Yuzuru Hanyu, Jason Brown, Yuma Kagiyama, Rika Kihira, Wakaba Higuchi, Young You, Sui and Han, Chock and Bates, Hubbell and Donohue, Gilles and Poirier, Peng and Jin and Kirsten Moore-Towers and Michael Marinaro melted the ice at the 2020 Four Continents Figure Skating Championships. We break down all the action in the latest edition of 'This and That'.
Subscribe to this channel for everything all of your figure skating fan needs.
Access exclusive TSL content (including live shows), listen to audio versions of our latest episodes and support TSL by becoming a Patron: / theskatinglesson
If you like these videos, please help TSL by shopping with our Amazon Affiliate Program. If you click this think and then purchase anything on Amazon, a small percentage of your purchase will help grow TSL and get you more of the content you love:
amzn.to/2PTTn4h
If you're shopping in the UK:
amzn.to/2TAUJjD
If you're shopping in Canada: amzn.to/2DUmTkP
The goal of The Skating Lesson (TSL) is to share our passion and knowledge of the sport with all of you. Whether you call it figure skating, ice skating, Eiskunstlauf, фигурное катание, 피겨 스케이팅, フィギュアスケート, 花样滑冰, 花樣滑冰, patinage artistique, pattinaggio artistico or patinaje artístico, we hope you'll share your passion with us as well. isu figure skating, dancing on ice - Спорт
TIMESTAMPS:
00:45 - Alexa Scimeca Knierim & Chris Knierim’s withdrawal
01:06 - The Commentator
**4CC Mens**:
02:22 - Yuzuru Hanyu ft. Ashley Wagner (05:10), Nathan Chen (13:10)
14:20 - Overview of Men's field
14:51 - Jason Brown ft. coaching styles
22:03 - Vincent Zhou, Camden Pulkinen ft. Karen Chen (24:49)
25:47 - Tomoki Hiwatashi
28:38 - Canadian men: Nam Nguyen, Keegan Messing
30:58 - Roman Sadovsky
31:44 - Keiji Tanaka vs. Yuma Kagiyama
33:48 - Japanese men
34:26 - Kazuki Tomono
34:44 - Han Yan
35:18 - Junhwan Cha
36:21 - Boyang Jin
36:47 - back to Han Yan
**4CC Pairs**:
36:57 - Alexa & Chris Knierim
41:00 - Jessica Calalang & Brian Johnson ft. Ashley Cain-Gribble & Tim LeDuc
44:23 - Haven Denney & Brandon Fraizer + the Florida situation + DIDIER IS NO MORE (44:39)
48:17 - Tarah Kayne & Danny O'Shea
51:20 - Evelyn Waugh & Trent Michaud ft. Jenni Meno & Todd Sand
53:28 - Lyubov Ilyushechkina & Charlie Bilodeau
55:44 - Kirsten Moore-Towers & Michael Marinaro
1:00:18 - Dave’s rant on North American skaters
1:01:40 - back to KMT & Michael ft. Dylan Moscovitch, Aly Raisman (1:03:46)
1:05:00 - Wenjing Sui & Cong Han
1:06:04 - Cheng Peng & Yang Jin ft. Bradie Tennell (1:06:17)
1:06:35 - Alexa & Chris
**4CC Ice Dance**:
1:06:48 - Madison Hubbell & Zach Donohue
1:09:25 - Madison Chock & Evan Bates
1:09:59 - H&D vs. C&B
1:14:00 - Piper Gillies & Paul Poirier
1:15:45 - Shiyue Wang & Xinyu Liu
**4CC Ladies**:
1:16:13 - Wakaba Higuchi
1:18:20 - Kaori Sakamoto
1:20:22 - Rika Kihira
1:23:42 - Young You
1:24:01 - Eunsoo Lim
1:25:20 - PAUSE PAUSE, IT'S DAVE’S MOMENT!! (Skating drama)
1:27:39 - Yelim Kim
1:27:49 - Bradie Tennell + can the U.S. ladies get 3 spots at Worlds? / Worlds predictions
1:29:35 - Resurgences + leopard-print skates
1:30:17 - Satoko Miyahara + (Bavarian Open, Russian Junior Nats vids tomorrow)
1:30:53 - Eunsoo
1:30:58 - Amber Glenn
1:31:49 - Karen Chen
1:32:27 - Canadian ladies: Alicia Pineault, Alison Schumacher, Gabby Daleman + Dave gets passionate about instigating skating drama
**Other**:
1:34:56 - Dave’s moment of the week
1:35:08 - Jonathan's moment of the week
Thank you
Thank you!
Thank you!
Thanks!
Thankx! Jonathan needs a travelling Mike
13:28 “I said Nathan” no you said Jason 😂
yup sorry Dave but you said Jason three times
Did I??? I am exhausted. It is possible.
RKS CA meanwhile I will defend Jonathan’s honor when he is clearly correct 😂
I say potato, you say potato.
@@a9029k thanks for pointing that out...not the first time unfortunately. Still...love Dave 😍
Thank you always for your honest opinions! I don't always agree, but I enjoy hearing them.
About Yuzuru, I'm suspecting his return to Chopin might have been his way of "testing" the judges. If he skated again his SP that had been so highly rewarded, how would the judges score it now? It was a very risky move because he would have to skate it not only cleanly but perfectly, which he did. In my opinion it was the best Chopin he ever skated.
The results? He did not get perfect GOE on any of his jumps, although he previously did and totally deserved this time as well. His components were lower than before, showing the judges' reluctance to give him 10s when that performance was literally PERFECT.
This judging wouldn't have been a problem if the strictness on the GOEs and PCS were applied fairly to ALL skaters.
What had been causing Yuzuru to get into his head in my opinion was that while he had not been getting the GOEs and PCS he used to get, Nathan's had been rising like crazy. Yuzuru is getting +4s on his perfect 3As while Nathan is also given +4s just for landing average 3As. Nathan is getting 9.0-9.5 for transitions while, as the Chopin SP at 4CC showed, judges are capping his transitions at 9.5. The TP is calling Yuzuru's flat edge on his flip but never Nathan's.
If scores were given more according to the rules, it might have been "Yuzuru's quality vs Nathan's technical ability," but the scoring til now and at 4CC proved that that is not to be expected.
Yuzuru 11 months ago said that he wanted to win no matter how the rules were changed, that he would adapt to the rules in order to win. Now he's saying that he just wants to skate in his ideal way, and if the judges don't like it, there's nothing he can do about it. It seems he has given up on the judges and that's very sad, but I hope this change in his mindset will allow him to perform more freely and show us another stunning Chopin and Seimei at Worlds.
Ak Blades - you put it perfectly! It's not about Yuzuru's scores being too low (there should always be place for 'something even more' and raising his scores wouldn't even solve the issue), but it's about other skaters being scored too high in comparison. The ISU graph which shows average GOE development through the years in Nathan's case is ludicrous and in no way reflects what we see in reality (2018: 0.5 --> 2019: 2.5???).
I've been saying that technical elements should be scored by AI these days (with already existing technology + human supervision), and I firmly believe that few year from now we will look back thinking how the current system was "a thing"... Imagine - no undetected under-rotations, all perfectly in-time captured per-rotations, all relevant jump measurements and categorized quality transitions: this will be game changer for future generations!
I also do agree with you that such judging must feel so disheartening and that the fact that Yuzuru continues to skate with arguably more complex programmes each time is inspiring in itself! It's true that he used to say "I want to be in position where skating clean I know - I'll win" and now even with higher BVs this doesn't seem to be a way to reason anymore...
And finally, I do not understand complaints saying that he "always skates for the record" (like it's a bad thing), or that he is "desperate to win" . I mean, hello - FS is a competitive sport and this guys shows up to win like everybody else! To me - this is a quality of a TOP athlete and true sportsman (even if it is with some added skating drama ;)).
I agree.. while he never talk anything about missjudging, but he is an insightful man, he knew something went wrong when something just wrong... he wont recycled those programs without any reason.
But i still believe in him. He and his team will figure it out... how to win the competitions.
Even if RIka's music didn't suit her this season, it's still better to figure that out now when she's young than during Olympics season. She needs to skate to different types of music to challenge herself artistically.
The super/golden grand slams is a THING. Yuna used to be known for that,as the ONLY and FIRST skater who won it all. Hence why they called her The Queen (with the never off for podium in all her competition time as well though). Then, alina won it all last year and hanyu did it yesterday. Alina fans celebrated it as well, so it s not exaggeration that yuzu fans want to celebrate it as well
Yuzuru is actually the 7th skater to manage that career golden slam after Yuna, Tessa & Scott, Aljona Savchenko, Maxim Trankov and Alina.
@@XimenaSu1609 But he's the 1st man to win it I mean male single skater
@@artemisadelaluna9901 True, I'm so glad he finally got it :)
@@XimenaSu1609 Me too, I hope this gives him some peace of mind and confidence
@@XimenaSu1609 Not sure what the golden slam is, exactly, but didn't Davis and White win GPF, 4CC, Worlds and Olympics?
Who cares about the Oscars?! TSL is on.
Priorities!
When moonlight got the oscar, i said wtf, and since that i never been interested in the ceremony
FCC was held in Seoul, South Korea. Koreans got all major Oscars. Coincidence? I don't think so
RKS CA Yay! For my People!
@@TheSkatingLesson Sorry, love you, but the Oscars will always win. 🤷
My moment of the week was 💯 Jason Brown delivering two exceptional programs after skating lights out at nationals. Made my heart feel things.
rika deserves another gold medal for her guts wisdom and quick thinking when she changed her free program while competing infront of thousands of people to compensate for the loss of the 3A.
Yes Jonathan!! Jun-hwan Cha's ina bauer is a thing of beauty!!
Debbie Bums I really hope he does well at worlds !!!
The NBC analysts need to do some homework before announcing again. I'm speaking specifically of Johnny Weir. During the ladies free skate of Chen Hongyi of China, Johnny made the statement that no Chinese lady had ever landed on the podium at the Olympics. I'm sure that Chen Lu would object to that. She was the on the Olympic podium not once, but twice, in 1994 & 1998 as the bronze medalist. I'm surprised Tara didn't correct Johnny during the live broadcast seeing as she was podium mates with Chen Lu in 1998, but maybe Tara suffers from short term memory??
What is amazing about this is that Tara didn't say something. She never shuts up.
@@mrsampulliam cause she knows she doesn't know anything about chinese fs
Keith H I was thinking the same thinking the same thing!
Tara doesn't remember who Michelle Kwan is, so probably.
Tara dont know anything about anything except what is on the script.
The commentator said terrible things about Jun’s TRADITIONAL KOREAN HAT. Like “he finally got the message (that it looks ugly)” when it slid off. Fire him. Seriously.
@@evanperilstein5308 He wasn't wearing it to make some fashion statement or to look good, he was wearing it because he's KOREAN and it's a traditional KOREAN hat and the competition is in KOREA. Also, a fan gave it to him and he always loves to show his fan gifts in the kiss and cry. The point wasn't for it to look good lmao, it was for fun and just because the commentator didn't like it didn't mean he had to make such ignorant comments, especially when he's commentating on a Korean competition.
Can we please do a big fundraiser for them to hire Mark Henretty to comment EVERYTHING for ISU? Please! The commentator is Paul Alster, he wasn't great at Euros, but this was really too much to take. Some of my favorite moments from his commentary: "I'm afraid he was a bit awkward on the landing" (30% underrotated plus landed with a step out and hand down), "She unfortunately lost her way" (popped jump), "You can hear the cameras going off like hungry woodpeckers".
Shelf Life 💯
yessss, I love me a scottish accent!
Please no Hanretty.He stutters and stumbles his words too much😱
"I'm afraid he was a bit awkward on the landing" (30% underrotated plus landed with a step out and hand down).
LOL Sounds like Canadian commentators. Their commentary is SO nice and SO polite because they're afraid of offending skaters that it simply isn't objective anymore. Canadian nationals was very much like that.
A thought from my fantasy world- I'd love to see Yuzuru skate to an adapted version of Yoshiki's "Anniversary" honoring Japan's Emperor and Empress' s 10th. He is so proud of his country and its culture...and with Yoshiki being one Japan's greatest rock stars, as well as a classical composer.... I think Yuzuru would give an epic performance.
Yuzuru is the first single man to achieve Super Slam? That's great
Yes
Plushenko and Lysacek had also won every major tournament.
Both were missing a junior gold medal for Super Slam, Plushenko JGPF (did not exist), Lysacek JWC (has the silver medal)
I love Dave lease at 1:00:18 when he starts ranting about USA skaters. 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
Emily Tan 😘😘😘😘
I cannot hear Jonathan which is usually the other way around.
He didn't have the best audio today. He is not at home.
Personally, if I was Yuzu next year, I'd forego the Grand Prix series and start my season after the Grand Prix. He's more than earned it and it would help his body. Come back w/new programs, do the 4A, and retire. He's dealt with enough.
Good idea. The 4A would be a very nice way to finish his competitive career.
I just want to him to be happy with himself. He has obtained all gold medals and achieved something that no other male skater has achieved before. As of late, I think he became more stressed and seemed desperate to catch up with more difficult technical content. The judges and scoring is no longer on his side. Media continuously pin and sell rivally between him and Nathan. I can't imagine what is in his head during the competition.
@@yohanes2034 I completely agree with you
Thank you. But I doubt he will. I don't think he can wants to dissapoint his fans.
@@tb4522 He probably doesn't, but I don't think his body can take another full season especially with the tech content he is now trying to do - it's too much.
Speaking of people who needed who needed to go back to old programs, it wouldn't have hurt Kaori Sakamoto. I fell in love with last year's programs. This year's seemed half assed and like she's just going through the motions
I love her current FS. But, yeah, I agree that she isn't doing it justice, which is unfortunate because I think it really suits her stylistically. I get the sense that part of the problem might be her conditioning. But who knows. Disappointing season for her.
@@arose10 Since she's training a quad I feel her problem most likely is she's getting in her own head. She's my favorite Japanese lady and I hope she can get over this hump especially with all of the stiff competition in the ladies field.
@@beazy1248 Unlike in Russia, it doesn't seem like there's much up-and-coming competition in Japan, so she might still have a window to pull it back together. I'm pulling for her, too.
Kaori´s Piano was out of this world. Despite the fact you would expect this years´ programs energy to be her style it is actually the opposite. The lyricism of From the first moment and Piano brought out the best from her. I hope Richaud comes up with something similar next season. Otherwise I agree, this season was a disaster for Kaori, I felt like they didn’t even try. And please forget the 4T, it’s nowhere near close landing
@@gogroregogoror I don't know, I had so much hope for this program when Benoit posted his video of her training it back in early October. But she was never able able to bring to competitions the same energy and attention to detail that she showed in that clip. Bellabell might be right, perhaps she was just distracted by her jump content (and struggles), or overly focused on gaining the 4T, and thus the rest of her performance lagged.
30:26 Omg the two shots behind the scenes with Nam were the best! I kept hoping for more after the everyone-squish-into-one-chair and the handstand.
Lmao
Yuma! He blew me away and I'm so excited to see him develop
So great!
Yes it's true. and the FS song is same song of his father's FS program at Olympic !!
His father is unfortunately half body paralysis as he got sick now, and he cried when Yuma got bronze medal at senior National. So heart moving moment !
Yes it's true. and the FS song is th same song of his father's FS program at Olympic !!
His father is unfortunately half body paralysis as he got sick now, and he cried when Yuma got bronze medal at senior National. So heart moving moment !
I'm so happy for Jason Brown to be doing so well with his new coaching team. His triple axel does look better than ever, it has great spring and nice power to it. I missed the Knierims in the free skate. The pairs field didn't seem all that deep when they withdrew and there were only 2 pairs in that warmup group, and then Lubov and Charlie didn't look anything like they did earlier in the season. What was with all the throw doubles. Alexa & Chris definitely could have won bronze here over KMT/MM if they had actually done a SP spin and a free skate. I hope they're okay and that this was just precautionary so they're healthy for Worlds. Everything about them is better than it's ever been aside from the jumps and to me it might help them to go back to doing salchows in the short. That has always been Chris's better jump, and Alexa can adjust to anything. But there must be a reason why they put the toes in instead, so who knows.
I believe this competition will be a good springboard to doing well for Bradie and Jason at worlds. I'm hoping Chock and Bates have a good showing.
I agree
I love that Jason won silver with a single popped quad and deserved it.
I have nothing to say about Hanyu here--I guess you would consider me a Fanyu. I don't think so--I think that skating is a ridiculously subjective sport and Hanyu blows my mind. I've been watching skating since the '80s and no one before him ever made a similar impression on me. Maybe I'm crazy.
OMG! What happened to Roman? I want to see him move forward.
In many other ways I thought this was the most watchable and entertaining competition of the season. The men's field was terrific.
I think the thing with the Fanyu is that if you make even the slightest critique of Hanyu, they literally want to kill you 🤣🤣🤣
For example, whenever anyone mentions how Yuzuru recycling his programs/creating programs that are all veeerry similar etc, you get murdered by BUT HES THE 2X OLYMPIC CHAMPION GREATEAT OF ALL TIME
Like yeah I get it he is technically superb and artistically spectacular but nobody is perfect, him included 🤣🤣
@@helenaprout1061 Nevermind. My whole point is those who are indifferent to him will never understand the quasi-hysteria of fanyus. People yelling that fanyus are annoying is waste of everyone's time. No one has ever sold out venues like he does. There has to be a reason--subjective, emotional, or a sign of mass mental illness? You tell me. But going after people for being overwrought and hyper-emotional will solve nothing; it makes everyone feel bad. I don't think the majority of over-the-top Yuzu fans would honestly claim he is perfect. The fact is they have a unique response to his particular ability to reach them on a transcendent level. And they try to explain that by pinning it on his amazing skating skills when in fact the mystery element is some combination of extremely high skill level, artistic sensitivity, and showmanship. Supposedly that is all part of the sport and how it is judged.
Agree with everything you’re saying about Yuma Kagiyama. And right now he’s getting Junior PCS in my opinion (unfairly) and he still scored over 270 points total. If he was senior, his PCS would be approaching 9.0 average at this point. I will say that I have heard that he and his team did not expect to be in this position so soon, so that’s part of the reason why I think they are OK with him going to junior worlds, and turning senior next year. My understanding is that he was going to skate junior next year as well, but the latter half of the season has dissuaded them from that. But yes I agree Dave, sent him to senior worlds now, have him move up, and get that experience with two world championships before the next Olympics.
Dave’s rant has made my day, my week, my life!!!🤣🤣🤣
sywillis62 ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Every time Dave punctuates a statement with "Okay?" take a drink! 😜😘
Stephen Barnowski 😘
I would get smashed
45 secs in and I'm 4 shots deep!!!!
I agree with you about Hubbel and Donahue’s egos. You can tell from his insta stories that he *loves* the way he looks. It’s entertaining.
@@evanperilstein5308 I agree. He's a good looking guy but his ego ruins it. Still, I get a good chuckle from it!
I met them and talked a minute or two at the friends of figure skating brunch, Madison was very elegant looking with tall heels. They were very sociable and sweet to everyone wanting autographs and pics but there was definitely an aloofness too. Kaitlin and Jean-Luc are so real and down to earth, along with Madison and Evan.
@@debbied2715 Thank you for the insight! I'm glad to hear they were all friendly.
@@mustyfan1584 it was such a nice time getting to see them as "normal" people sharing meals and stories. They always thanked us members for supporting US figure skating. It was the highlight of my trip!
I love the way he looks too 😂
I need to hear that Gabby Daleman story now lol 😩
Yay! Another This and That!!! I smashed that Like button and now ready to listen to the figure skating best critics David And Jonathan!
I agree with Zach needing to control his poker face. He acts like he’s Scott Moir, but with very little of the technique, grit, performance quality, and partnering ability.
I loved this discussion!! I really hope Hanyu wins one more WC, but we can all see the tilt towards the next Olympics and Hanyu having the focus shifted away from him; this can't be easy to know when you still have the desire to compete. Certainly the best WC team for next month would have been Hanyu/Uno/Kagiyama. I was so impressed with Rika's sang froid in changing her jumps mid-program even in that awful swamp-colours dress. Young You's 3A was wonderful.
Picture this: Mariah Bell and Eunsoo Lim at Skate America in Las Vegas
I would be obsessed!
I can’t tell if Dave was a) tired b) on caffeine 3) or both? He was just not having it today especially w H&D and I loved every moment of it. So spot on. I loved them so much few years back but my god! Have some manners in the back stage! And it wouldn’t hurt to get better programs. I love it when Dave says... “otherwise they should just quit!” I was like🤣
Evan Perilstein 💯
Thank you! I was tired and drinking caffeine.
His manspreading is so gross...
@@Melissa-yr7fm It really is...
1:00:26 was the rant that I knew I needed but had never had it delivered, thank you Dave 😤
Alessia 😘
4CC showed that C/B aren’t getting kicked off the world podium without major error (that fall was not one) and rightly so! They were the only one of the top 6 who actually went with a new style for the FD and it’s the best dance program of the season. I am praying they can beat S/K for silver because their programs are so boring. So many people are predicting G/P as spoilers for worlds but I don’t see it- they haven’t been scored like a top team all season and they couldn’t beat H/D’s crap programs without them making errors. If worlds isn’t P/C, S/K, C/B in some order I’ll be surprised.
Side note: completely agree about H/D’s egos and attitude problems.
I think with the Canadian crowd behind then, they will overtake the Russians for bronze. Imo, the judging panel at worlds will have looked at what happened in Euros as corrupt judging to the core. Chock/Bates is solidly in 2nd.
Chase Blue I’d love for that to happen but I’m not sure. S/K are definitely going to be more vulnerable with a non-Zhulin judging panel but mainly to C/B I think. G/P had a significant PCS gap from the other 5 teams at the GPF and they’re not getting as much GOE either. They wouldn’t have even got 4CC silver if it wasn’t for H/D making mistakes. I don’t think international judges are getting behind them as a top team. Even with a better worlds panel I think S/K will get on the podium unless they make mistakes, even though they could (hopefully) lose to C/B.
Chase Blue from your lips to God’s ears. I hope it’s P/C, C/B, and either G/P or H/D
@@MrChaseBlue Thats interesting considering that it was American tech controller who gave the french low levels. And since you're talking about corruption in judging system - most judges at worlds will be from MFD side so obv they'll support and give high levels and GOEs to their teams. If thats not corruption then i dont know what is. I get that when you lose its easier to blame the corruption on everything, but believe it or not its not all about that. Canadians should worry about not let Stepanova and Bukin overtake them for the 4th place considering the scoring they receive this season it doesnt look like they will, but then again - home advantage. So please dont tell me about fair judging here.
Totally agree about H/D.
I think Hanyu should skate to “who wants to live forever” by Queen.
keely kazakova who wants to skate forever 😂
ahahahahahaha brilliant
The music would actually work really well as it's his level of dramatic 🤣🤣🤣
@@helenaprout1061 LOL yes!! and he could do some sword pantomiming, which he seems to love doing so much (sword, violin... you name it). that way he would feel comfortable and like 'himself' while skating the program, and it would help weaning him off seimei and chopin XD
@@biari8599 omg yaaaas🤣🤣
I feel like Hanyu constantly reusing his Seimei program has made the special effect of the program dwindle (this is his third season now with it)
i disagree hardcore. imo it gets better every time i watch it. but each to their own!
Yeah...
I think Hanyu should skate to “Who wants to live forever” by QUEEN
It's shortened, so the first 3 jumps were so close together.
He decided to change the program at the end of December which was so late that he didn't have other choice but to bring back something that he used before. He said he was thinking about new programs but there was simply no time to do it. He probably should have changed Origin in the summer. Things kept piling up after that when he couldn't skate to the program as he wanted it to. Skate Canada was the exception.
I don't judge him as he has already 2 OGMs in his bags and he could stop competing any time he wants to. Imagine how hard it is for him to train rigolously every day and he is 25 now, he has been slin seniors since he was 15. I think he needed some motivation to continue after PC and thought two tribute programs would be a good motivation. But he then may have realised they aren't really his programs. I am sad he didn't realise it earlier. I guess he wanted to skate them really well, which he did with Otonal but he couldn't do with Origin.
He looked more comfortable in Chopin and Seimei at 4CC because these programs are really his, he can show his skating in them. If he continues skating next year I will be curious what programs he will be bring.
Nah, I enjoyed Seimei but not as much as Chopin. Not because I have seen it several times but because he was sort of off when he did it. Completely different with Chopin where he is fully committed to it. Whatever distracted him made a big difference. Not an excuse, that's just how Yuzu performs.
I’m not a crazy Yuzuru fan, but I would love to see Prince again. Give me Jason Brown anyday.
Alexa and Chris-I have never in my life seen a skater just stop and stand still when they missed an element-and it was a spin! He could've stepped into the sit spin at least. It wouldn't have been great but him just staring at her spin was super uncomfortable. And KMT's attitude in the kiss and cry was such a turn off.
Grisgris * regarding KMTs attitude she’s clearly upset she made mistakes. Perhaps compete at her high level of figure skating and make mistakes and see how you feel when your program is done and missing out on a gold medal. She is human and is entitled to feelings whether they are good or not. Competing at this level of skating can be emotional.
I guess you haven't watched much pairs then. When this happens, the one partner can't really do much other than stand there because it's almost impossible to get back into sync with your partner and gain levels. Watch Pang and Tong from the 1999 Skate Canada SP. That's one of the big ones I remember. I think this happened to Marissa and Simon one year at Nationals too.
I could see that, if it weren't for the fact that his demeanor has always kind of been like this. Alexa is the one with all the energy and Chris is laid back and very calm. He also seems shy. He's not going to yell and act all emotional in the kiss and cry like Alexa does. They have two very different personalities. Who knows though.
He’s definitely quiet. Met him in Colorado about 10 years ago. Nice guy had some cool conversations.
Junhwan gave a beautiful performance this time! I saw the men’s free skate live at 4 continents and his skating was so beautiful and memorable. He showed that he can deliver a clean performance at big competitions. I really hope he works on his jumps more and gives a great performance at Worlds.
13:12 haha you definitely said "Jason"
Oh definitely and I was like WHAT?! Haha
Indeed. I was confused!
Yeah, his insistence that he said "Nathan" was pretty gaslightey!! 😝
Dave and Jonathan, Do you have a way to contact the USA Figure skating association to help Nathan find a good costume designer?
Dave's rant....LOL...love it
Jonathan unleashed a beast!!!
Guys, I cannot emphasise enough how important visuals are. Your content is unique. You also need visuals as dividers between different topics, 'cause 2 hours is too long to watch all at once. I'm a fan of yours and this is positive feedback.
I LOVE you guys! Serious commentary cloaked/delivered w humor, SNARK (tell us how you really feel, Dave!), & it's So. Bloody. Enjoyable. Also, you are both so knowledgeable af about figure skating hx, & you care deeply. I've learned a ton since I subscribed to TSL & I start my Mondays off w you both. Don't always agree (where's the fun in THAT?!?) but always watch. Btw, it's my opinion that Yuzu has let Nathan take up a long term rental spot in his head, while Nathan just DOESN'T CARE. He's already thinking about life after skating, as seen in multiple interviews beginning from at least last season, & it seems that skating doesn't define him. Works like a dog, does his best at the particular comp he's at, then done, flush, on to the next. Good for him!
Oh my goodness, Jonathan! Thank you so much for saying what you did about Tomoki and his facial expressions. I just don’t understand it. His *skating* has so much personality, but his face is absolutely nothing. His eyes are dead. He looks like he’s just going through the motions. Last year he was having fun with that Pirates program, and he was having a good time. Smiling, and almost LIVING the music. This season, I think he thinks that dramatic means “no emotion“. There’s literally nothing going on and it detracts from his performance so much.
Also, and I know this is going to sound mean so please don’t @ me: I think his PCS will go up at least a couple points if he didn’t have a haircut that looks like it was done in two minutes at Supercuts. GURL. Why is it always sticking up in spots??
Brent's Lucky Slot Channel omg yes!! His hair was like all the same length sticking straight out. Someone please give him some products at least!
I actually like the Petrushka program choreo, but it's clear he doesn't get it & he's not performing it at ALL. I mean, back in the dark ages, before we had UA-cam, I could understand a skater not being able to see an example of the ballet/musical/movie you're skating to, but come on! Watch it on UA-cam at least once. Yes, Chaplin & La Strada clips are on UA-cam too. 🙄
I don’t understand the outrage over Yuzu repeating Chopin&Seimie? Like if this is how he’s going to mentally prepare himself then let it be. It’s not like the programs are bad, they’re iconic and like wine, it ages beautifully.
right! apparently the other programs didnt feel like him and thats why he switched back to his olympic season programs.
Because he's used these programs for 4 and 3 seasons, respectively. I'm fine with one reuse now and then, but in this case he's replacing two recycled programs with two different recycled programs. There is some expectation that people will come up with original material.
@@ColonelGreen But we are one month away from the Worlds, the season is almost over! What can you do about it???
@@evanperilstein5308 Theoretically, ofcourse. I understand your expectation. But is your statement realistic enough? Anyways, I really don't want to start an argument with you. Thank you for the reply! I only felt sorry for this skater.
This season he brought back his quad lutz, quad loop, ratified a 4Teu3F, and when challenged he tried to hailmary a 3A-3A. He clearly worked on at least rotation for a quad axel. He made his footwork on jumps and transitions more complex. I don't know why some people don't take the long view and see this as original material development.
When training a musical instrument, you play piece after piece prescribed by your teacher every couple of months (or so) but after you reach a certain level, development isn't about being able to play a piece or even about playing more difficult pieces (though in this analogy, Yuzuru is still playing more difficult pieces via his transitions imho!) but the quality of playing - whether the music is Mary Had A Little Lamb or Mozart, you can HEAR a quality when a famous pianist plays vs lower level player. Professional musical players can spend weeks, months, years studying the same musical piece and understanding it in different ways. Sure, I would love to see more different types of programs because he's just such a GOAT I would just love to see it, and I think being able to interpret wider ranges of pieces is a great way to grow, but it's not like he's stopped working (I have eyes, the quality of skating is observable) and he's at a point in his career that is the equivalent to settling into being a professional jazz player who works on honing depth of jazz skills rather than split time to also become a master of classical music, pop music, broadway music. And his area of strength is probably skating skills, jumps, and certain types of music only, he isn't really going to be to become a Jason Brown or a Satoko to music.
It's also going to be difficult to find the right fit in music that could live up to Chopin and Seimei, let alone have time to get a choreographer in and build it up to standard that Yuzuru strives to get it to in such a short timeframe. Like some writers produce books every year, some work on a manuscript for seven years before it's finished, which often produce different types of works.
Calalang and Johnson needs to go to worlds. Period.
I agree. It is their time.
20:45 so interesting that Johnny said the same thing during the broadcast. That Jason made the mistake he did, going for the quads too late in his development. You have a beautiful program that you don't want messed up with iffy jumps, and you can just barely make it score wise without the jumps. So mentally it is hard to take that risk and throw them now
Yes, you can always see how it will go on the entrance to the jump. During the pattern, you can see Jason slow down just like Johnny did. He doesn't have his usual attack. It is likely subconscious.
Yeah, I appreciated the loyalty to his 1st coach, but this is the reason skaters have to change sometimes. Not every coach can teach everything.
That pair review was everything wow, you both snap, love you both.
Looking forward to the Gabby Daleman story!
Are you going to Montreal? You should do a meet and greet and a skating lesson round table 😁😁
Celine Dion sings, 'My heart will go on' at almost every concert. That's her masterpiece...So why is it frowned upon when figure skaters do the same?
The Men short program was fantastic, best segment in years everyone after and including Yuma was on point| So exciting!!!! Also loving that Hanyu is doing a best of exhibition tour this year ( Parisienne Walkways, Hope and Legacy , Semei, Notte Stellata )
And i´m with Jonathan in this one... Chopin SP is a joy to watch , because is the 4th iteration ( i liked the OG version the most with the combo in the beat before the final stepseq) i was kind over this one but after seeing i accepted.... probably the best short program ever!
I love you guys every time I Watch figure skating I think of your comments 🥳😄
@RKS CA haha! Too True
Jonathan, you forgot your Shoma
I waited all day for this. Thank you
All the drama of and surrounding Hanyu, his fans, and Wendy...I mean Dave tip toeing as to not offend is quite amusing when you contrast it with Nathan simply living his life and going about his business so seemingly nonchalant.
I honestly love how chill Nathan is. He gets so much rabid hate from certain Fanyu's over his scoring that he has no control over and he goes out there, skates and leaves and goes back to have fun at Yale.
Its amusing how for skaters who are good in components but lack in the technique department, fans will use the whole " but figure skating is a blend of technique AND artistry!"...which it is...BUT when you have a skater likr Nathan who is the opposite who lacks in components but very heavy in the technique department...that statement never gets used even though it still applies. And artistry is only several factors in components (Interpritation, Performance but you still have Skating Skills and Transitions).
@@birdtiredoflife5360 I think that is one of my favourite things about him. Skating is not life or death for him; it's just something he does in this stage of his life. And I know people get annoyed about how much they talk about him going to Yale but I'm not going to be worried about him after he eventually retires as you can tell he's looking ahead. He has a life outside of skating which is something that so many skaters struggle with realizing
I actually really like Ekaterina Kurakova! I think she’s so special!!! I hope she can work hard to clean up her technique. But she’s a little diva and the skating world always needs at least one.
I believe that Mariah and Bradie have the ability to get the US three spots. Let's see it.
I can't leave out my girl, Wakaba. I hope she gets the triple axel down because she's gonna need two of them. Skyfall with two triple axels...baby. She will get the gold medal she should have had in 2018.
If the only thing they have to do to get 3 spots is finish ahead of Wakaba, it's very doable given what she tends to score. I think Wabaka also could place ahead of both of them so who knows.
Bradie and Mariah can finish ahead of Young You too. She’s not been that consistent with the 3A and imo, the judges at worlds might not be as thrilled to give her such high PCS as she was here. Bradie would’ve most likely beaten her if the competition wasn’t held in Korea
I don't mind the sound issues at all. I just appreciate you both taking the time to cover skating for all us skate nerds! 💙⛸️💙
I think the Knierim's ship has sailed. Chris looks Done and he'll never be a secure jumper. Alexa is younger and can probably make it another 2 yrs, but Chris isn't going to make it another 2 yrs.
I love how updated you keep us on all the skating news. Can you tell us more about Cya Live? I'd love to hear all the content there too!
What is the "alleged" Gabby Daleman story??? I wanna knoooow :-)
Currently missing Mai Mihara :(
💔
Yeah, what happened to her? Last I heard she was injured. Is there something else wrong too?
@@scriabina She's not injured persay, she has arthritis. :(
Dave, the Russian girl represented Poland as you say (18:00) is Ekaterina Kurakowa, I think it will be much more professional if you can name her by her name. They are athlete they all deserves it !
This year is the best the Knierims have ever looked aside from jumps. Things like the twist have gotten even better. They look more sophisticated and top class. They might want to do 3S in the short, as it’s Chris’s best jump. A couple of the wild pops Chris did on the 3T looked a bit jarring to his body. I know Raf’s technical changes aren’t easy to get used to, and I don’t love the way he has them entering that 3T. Try to work with Chris’s natural timing instead of against it. I’m proud of them for working hard at it. And I forgive them for many of the jumps because the rest is so good and I appreciate their quality.
I understand what Dave is saying about focusing on the most important events and maybe skipping 4CC, but I don’t like so much talk about age in pairs. It’s the oldest discipline with much longevity, and there was a recent Olympics when most of the podium was in their early to mid 30s. Alexa and Chris are one of the most athletic pairs and he throws her a mile high. Alexa is in her prime and is a youngin compared to Deanna Stellato who is doing well herself. Chris’s body has always been more fragile, so they need to be strategic with the lifts and jumps they choose. If they’re motivated, they can find a way, and I’m glad they went to Four Continents and wanted to compete. With that being said, I could see any skater on that much of an emotional high from Nationals needing more than 5 days to prepare for the next event.
On another note, I would like them to be a little nicer to themselves sometimes and a little less moody. Focus on the positives and try not to let the negatives be the focal point of your day. Don’t worry about fluke errors. And be appreciative of the opportunity you have to skate. They seem to be in good spirits lately and I hope this withdrawal doesn’t derail them. I hope they’re healthy for Worlds because they deserve to be there.
It just seemed so strange to me that US Figure Skating didn't send Cain and LeDuc to 4CC rather than the Knierims (unless they wanted to go; but why would they exactly - for the points?). A bad call whomever made it. Cain/LeDuc should have had to prove themselves here and against the pair who beat them at the US Championships but whose season ended at 4CC: Calalang/Johnson.
Pairs don’t usually skip this event unless they have an injury situation. It’s basically seen as the rest of the world’s version of Europeans, so skaters usually make it a priority, although we have seen some withdrawals over the years. It’s also a very good prize money opportunity. It was, however, extremely close to US Nationals this year so the skaters basically had less than a week to come down from Nationals and prepare for this. Definitely not easy. It’s unclear if that had anything to do with their withdrawal though, they may have felt fine, I don’t know. If Cain and LeDuc were to be sent, it should have been in place of Kayne and O’Shea.
I can’t hear Jonathan 😩
His blue tooth wasn't the best this week, but it does work.
@@TheSkatingLesson let him use wired headphones
I expected to see Ryom and Kim here. Any idea why they weren't at 4CC? Because it was in Seoul, possibly?
I think they should have let the US pair teams to fight it out here. The Knerims are on fumes at this point
No, they actually look really strong, jumps aside. Aside from random bizarre mistakes at one of their fall events and the short program here, they've had a pretty strong season with several strong scores. Winning Nationals was a big emotional high for them, so if they were emotionally drained a week later for 4CC, it would be understandable. They seemed fine though and wanted to compete. The missed spin was a silly fluke and I don't know what the withdrawal was about.
I would’ve named the knerims to the world team , told them to rest and made the next 3 in the standings at nationals duke it out here for the second spot. Highest point total between the two events wins, much like Dave said previously.
Last post I swear: Delilah didn’t *infer* you were a murderer. She *implied* it. The person who is active (the speaker, in this case Delilah) is the one implying. The person who is drawing the implication (the listener, as in us) is the party who is inferring.
So class, Delilah implied Dave was a murderer. And we inferred that she really did mean it. LOL. Grammar police is moving on.
Brent's Lucky Slot Channel I made a mistake, Brent. I am sure you have never done speaking extemporaneously and I am glad that I gave you an opportunity to feel superior.
Never!!
Real tea though, this is the second time I’ve heard you say it, so… I thought it was a thing of yours. 👍🏻
Lol. I spy a fellow English major. Although seriously, forgot this. Lol.
I disagree about Tomoki. I love his programs and interpretation.
Sorry, but Hanyu going back to programs for the 4th time doesn't say he's "reinvigorated". It screams desperation. He's looking for a program he doesn't have to think about because there is so much else going on in his head. He's out of ideas. You also can't recapture the past. He was five years younger when he did those routines at the 2015 GPF.
With Jason, I don't know how much potential there is without a quad toe. In 2016, mens skating scores were so low but drastically all increased in 2017 and 2018. As we approach the penultimate year and olympic year, I think mens skating can increase in scores and ability. I would stay Jun Cha has much more potential with a quad and a combo that ends in a loop.
And with Yuma, reminds me of sending Shoma to jr. worlds in 2015. and for men of the future, I think not to forget about Gogolev.
I really love Rika's programs and I like the way she uses her upper body to interpret the music. Facial expressions isn't the only means to interpret the music.
Wakaba's programs this season are empty.
They have few transitions and interpretation is noticeable only during step sequence.
Kaori's programs, on the other hand, suit her fiery type of skating nicely.
I love Bradie's short and I think it's the best senior ladies program this season.
I think Piper and Paul should have won the ice dance competition considering Chock and Bates major error.
Sui and Han didn't skate at their best at the last 4CC either. I think they'll peak at Worlds.
Interesting observation in the dynamics of the cricket club family 😂 I guess sometimes u just get closer to mom than to dad 🙃 it’s all abt chemistry
ANyone know why John Kerr "allegedly" wasn't working with Silvia and John Zimmermann prior to all the cipres shenanigans?
This is not the best that he is repeating the program but he is skating his 10th senior and 12th international season, so if he wants to repeat something he can do that. Do any of you remember any man that has ever skated 12 seasons without even skipping a gp series? I am not fanyu but I have a feeling that he is expected too much.
He himself said he wanted to feel comfortable and otonal and origin were not comfy for him and he had no time to do new programs.
Anyways I hope he will come up with two new good programs for next season
P. S. I am rooting for Rika a lot lot
I don’t think competing for a long time gives you an excuse to not skate to the standards that everyone else is expected to skate to.
Stephanie Lloyd so what are those standards that apparently is known to you but not to hanyu? And yes being a figure skating icon for 10 years gives you that right
@@snowangel7980 well his skating is still one of the best out there, so by all means he is skating to the standards everyone else is and sometimes he does go above and beyond....repeating programs has nothing to do with the actual skating he is doing, if that's what you have a problem with.
@@mariamrusishvili1724 No. Seniority doesn't give you a right to be lazy.
Stephanie Lloyd lazy? Seriously? You think to pick up your broken body after winning 2 fucking gold medals at OG and keep pushing and studying new types of quads is lazy be my guest I have nothing to tell you. Again I would prefer to see new programs but if these two programs are the ones that make him continue then let it be.
It was wrong to repeat otonal and origin from the beginning and this change was just to repair the first mistake. Probably there was no time to get new programs
Dave! You have yet to divulge the Gabby story and it's not archived on Patreon. Would luv to hear it!
Of all the judging oddities, none of them (for me) touched the British judge giving Jason Brown an 8.25 in skating skills.
As a Brit I was wholly embarrassed about that.
The 4CC was generously scored. The top 10 in the Ladies all got SB's!
not all rika didn't
sorry, whoops yeah she did im comparing to her last season's NHK scores i misread that as PB
@@MC-sd6dp Didn't she score higher at this season's NHK? It was just by a fraction of a point, I think.
To be fair, Worlds is also scored generously. This happens at most events throughout the year. Scores rise.
Love Yuma! He does land his quad toe like a feather!
100%
Hubbell and Donahue rub me the wrong way. I wonder if they’re houses are covered with mirrors. They need a humbling moment like Chock and Bates did with the injury. Or maybe they need a good volunteer experience., meditation retreat, work with a mission or spend time on a kibbutz.
Earlier I saw skating was on TV, so I checked to see if my dad had any blank VCR tapes, he did, I unwrapped it and popped it in. Just finished watching it. We don't have the VCR remote so I had to sit through the commercials. I enjoyed the commentary, though. Happy for Jason Brown!
Yuzu needs to stop putting all his combos in the second half tbh. He's trying to out TES Nathan, which is hard to do on pure BV. He should just rely on his ability to get high GOE. And Chopin as fine, but Seimei was not good as the original version. The programs again weren't the problem.
It's also 30 sec shorter. I also wondered if he might have had some flashback since he seemed to have trouble in the same spots as at the Olympics
Maybe for others the programs don't have any effect on the skater but for Yuzu it does. He has a specific way of attacking a program. Imo, it's all psychological. Yuzu was distracted and was not calm, thus messing up.
@mish098aimer Yes he was nervous for that reason as well but I think it was more about him being distracted. I mean Chopin was fine and it doesn't exactly make sense why he couldn't have done the same for Seimei. He did mention it was because he was distracted. I read somewhere it has to do with the ice.
@@pennyinheaven him and yuma were talking about the ice in the green room iirc (japanese media showed a clip)
@@Sayu277 Didn't see that clip but yeah. And also Yuzu consistently flopped his jumps in the same area.
u guys know he did a 4Lz at the gpf right? cause u talked like he was trying for the first time lol
Yes. I am aware.
@Sally Vee at Rostelecom 2017, he landed a quad lutz with overall positive GOE
I'm not even sure he's doing a real 4lutz. Look at the NBC slow-motion replay of his attempted LP 4lutz at 4CC and you'll clearly see he's totally cheating the edge and doing a flutz. There needed to be an edge call on that.
@@L1623VP lol what? :D:D no, he has wrong edge on Flip (marked as "!" this time), but he has a perfect outside edge on Lutz.
@@capdar6479 Go look at it in the NBC slow motion replay close-up. There is NO way he's doing a lutz in his 4CC LP. His blade goes perfectly vertical and then cheats inside before the takeoff. It's NOT a back outside edge at all.
I had to pause your discussion to go out to my backyard and watch another incredible rocket launch! One of the few redeeming factors of living in FL! The comments section has been fun so far.
Dave Han did say that he slipped Hui dress when throwing her so this is why she had to double it.
Interesting!
Jonathan, I barely could hear your saying please fit it the next time
It is a discussion concerning use of old programs and I don"t see the hatreds towards Yuzuru. People against the repeated use of old programs for more than two seasons, the words they used are prefer and wish. Where are the hateful words?
We used to criticize Michelle Kwan to repeated East of Eden so many times!
I wish Yuzu would try a completely new style for once
@mish098aimer excuses *excuses*
Hanyu fans are full of them.
I can't even picture what a new style would look like for Yuzu. He's really making himself look like a has-been next to Nathan, who keeps experimenting with new music genres and styles.
@Sally Vee LOL, I agree that Nathan REALLY needs some new costumes! How does Vera Wang keep doing him wrong?!?
@@christinethorp3684 Gawd I do hope Nathan gets rid of those for worlds, Vera needs to start listening to the fans. I know Nathan isn't a fan of skin tight but he doesn't seem comfortable in these either! We should organize and present Vera and Nathan with real fan options!
@Sally Vee Costumes are literally irrelevant to a program. Stop trying to equate the two.
I think Young You should take a page from Alyssa Liu's book and get on the phone with Nicole Bobek to discuss the components for that Evita free program, just a thought.
Combined Euros/4CC Results for the Top Contenders at Worlds
1) Alena Kostornaia (240.81)
2) Anna Shcherbakova (237.76)
3) Rika Kihira (232.34)
4) Sasha Trusova (225.34)
5) Mariah Bell (225.21)*
6) Young You (223.23)
7) Bradie Tennell (222.97)
8) Wakaba Higuchi (207.46)
9) Yelim Kim (202.76)
10) Alexia Paganini (192.88)
11) Satoko Miyahara (191.43)*
Mariah's score is from U.S. Nats as she didn't compete in 4CC, though Bradie saw her score increase from U.S. Nats to 4CC, so I don't think Mariah's 4CC score would have been too far off from what she did at U.S. Nats, assuming the same performance. Satoko's score is from Japan Nats.
A few observations from all this...
• Rika is very much a threat to get in the way of a 3A season sweep. Could she even have her "Zagitova Moment" and come out on top? Unlikely, but not out of the realm of possibility.
• Sasha is the wild card. She would of course blow her Euros score out of the water with clean skates. It hasn't happened yet this season; we'll see if she can finally put it all together.
• U.S. is well positioned to earn back three spots. (Knock on wood.) I feel like we know what we're getting with Bradie. Mariah would have to bomb and Wakaba or Yelim would have to have the skate of their lives to mess things up.
Feel free to correct me if I got any of my information wrong or am missing anything.
If Rika doesn't pop her first 3A, she is right up there with Kostornaia. Of course, Kostornaia had a mistake, too.
@@skatefan9495 Yeah, I was thinking about that, though it's tricky when you start playing that game. But it does go to show that there are plausible scenarios where Rika could come out on top. I wouldn't necessarily bet my money on it, but I also wouldn't be shocked to see it happen.
Wakaba has only been healthy for a couple of months. If she keeps improving she only needs to be clean, and with a 3A can even make a mistake.
@@joeyartk "Only needs to be clean and land a jump she's never landed in competition before." That's asking a lot. I'm not saying it can't happen but, like I said, it would require this to be the skate of her career (thus far).
@@arose10 I didn't say she needs the 3A if she's clean. I said that gives her a cushion. She has far more talent than Tennell or Bell.
The commentator is the ISU commentator? I know they had him off on the ISU stream for the pairs short but how did you avoid him for the other events?
Orser or Raf? who would be better for yuma?
He is doing well now. He just needs political pull to get the worlds and the podium. The federation can help with that too.
Fanyu made up the super slam???? FYI, IOC was the one who announced that he was the first male single skater to achieve it. Yuna kim also achieved it in 2010. You consider yourself a skating fan without reading Yuna Kim's wiki page?
I think they didn't say "made up" wich means create?? They say "made it A THING" wich means give it such a big importance? English is not my maternal language so I could be wrong.
You have to remember that the JGP is relatively new, as is 4CC, so this is not something that was possible until recently. It is something that was invented by the megafans of Yuna and Yuzu. It is indeed impressive, but it is a designation without much longevity.
TheSkatingLesson true that GPF and 4CC has only been around for 20 years, which is not very long compared to the other competitions but the six titles that is included in the super slam is defined by the IOC, not the fans.
Did anyone hear the equestrian announcer mutter, "f*ck" during Chock/Bates free dance? Loved it
The only major contender missing? What about Shoma Uno?
I cannot hear a word Jonathan is saying.