Which Camera Reigns Supreme? Hasselblad X2D or Fujifilm GFX100S
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 чер 2024
- My Photo Book: www.fototripper.com/chasing-a...
Find me on TikTok: / fototripper
In this video I wanted to see how two of the best medium format cameras in the world perform 'head to head' in a real life landscape photography shoot.
In order to make life much harder for myself I decided to drive 2000 miles to one of the most beautiful locations in New York. With crazies on the highway and the madness of summer crowds, this wasn't easy.
My lofty goal was to capture some 'book-worthy' images while putting both of these cameras through their paces in a typical shooting scenario but perhaps my expectations were a little unrealistic for the busiest time of the year.
Obviously these are both brilliant cameras but I was surprised to see some major differences in both the colour rendering and the performance of the image stabilization. This might just mean the end of tripods for waterfall photography.
With 200 megapixels at my disposal, I photograph one of the most spectacular scenes I've ever witnessed and you can share it with me right here in this video.
Crossing the US border is always a nerve-wracking experience and with no hotel booking we're going to need somewhere safe to park the camper, but where?
My first task was to collect the Fujifilm GFX100S that I'd rented and then get it configured for battle against the Hasselblad X2D. Luckily, Amanda was ready to carry the heavy load in her camera bag.
Hobbling up and down the stone stairs of the trail was agonizing for my bludgeoned leg but a true artist suffers for his art.
Will the GFX100s retain it's former glory or is there a new king in town?
There's really only one way to find out.
VIDEO CHAPTERS:
🔘Intro: 0:00
🔘Canada to USA Road Trip: 0:59
🔘Walmart RV Camping: 2:12
🔘Fujifilm GFX100S Unboxing: 4:49
🔘Comparison Starts Here: 6:48
🔘Image Stabilization Test: 12:00
🔘JPG Comparison SOOC: 16:15
🔘Magic Light Happens: 18:55
🔘Colour Rendering Comparison: 1: 20:17
🔘Colour Rendering Comparison: 2: 21:31
🔘Which Camera Would I Buy?: 22:00
Thanks for watching
Gavin Hardcastle - Fototripper
Affiliate Links To Items In This Video:
Hasselblad X2D Camera: amzn.to/43Qt29x
Fujifilm GFX100s Camera: amzn.to/3NHSKXq
My Hardback Book: www.fototripper.com/chasing-a...
My Ebook: www.fototripper.com/chasing-a...
Join My Newsletter: www.fototripper.com/newsletter/
My Home Renovation Channel: • We Bought A Church - D...
Get 20% Off Fotospeed Paper with coupon code GAVIN20
www.cybersportphoto.com/?aff=4
Music by Epidemic Sound share.epidemicsound.com/vwCTJ
Business: www.fototripper.com/contact-us/
My Twitter: / fototripper
My Rinsedagram: / fototripper
#landscapephotography #fujifilm #hasselblad - Наука та технологія
Order My Book Here www.fototripper.com/chasing-awe-landscape-photography-book-gavin-hardcastle/
What book? Landscape photography on location?
Gavin, still unbelievable to me that you have only 90k followers… your channel is one of THE best for photo beauty and a dapple of entertainment. As an Upstate NYer we are spoiled with having these amazing state parks just an hour away. If you have not been already, come back in the Fall and visit Letchworth… unbelievable colors.
Totally agree
The nice thing when I was photographing for a book and magazine articles back during the 90's, was that it was often devoid of people. I'd hate to visit it again today...because the crowds would certainly kill the magic for me.
Absolutely.
Thank you.
Wow. Fuji color science is already top top tier. But man, Hasselblad color is unbeatable.
The color of the brick wall in the zoomed in comparison seemed natural in the GFX image, but a greenish cast in the X2D. I was surprised you didn't comment on that, Gavin.
The shenanigans are why I’m here, on top of the comparison.
I skipped! No shenanigans for me.
I almost bought the Hasselblad. The colors are one thing, the interface, and leaf shutter is the main draw. Portrait shooters will appreciate the leaf shutter and colors. Forget the video function and just get a separate video camera! People say that you can just adjust the colors, but it is time wasted (and that's money).
The Fuji colors have a red tint that's similar to Canon. The X2D has beautiful natural tones and gradation.
The Hasselblad Natural Colour Solution - HNCS - is unbeaten. Nothing else can compete with that.
Honestly, this channel is the only UA-cam channel that has me and the wife both absolutely buckled laughing. Only found it relatively recently and we both sit and binge it. Last night we found the outtakes videos and I was up late watching them… so much so that I had 38 minutes sleep and because of that I have a face like a bucket of angry frogs 😂😂
Thanks for not only the incredible photography but such a unique take on what is usually such a dry and humourless genre.
Why would you be doing a side-by-side comparison and not use the same iso ,…and the same aperture setting ,…and same shutter speed in both cameras?
For anything photograpy, the X2D reigns supreme. The color science is outstanding.
Enjoyable video but in all honesty I find it largely misleading. In my opinion doing a comparison of color rendering with auto white balance on is completely useless. In every comparison there was a very noticable difference especially in tint and even exposure of the shots in some cases, which would make greens look totally different even if they had been done with the exact same camera. So while this was very calming to watch and I appreciate the "real life usage" approach, I think making the shots comparable in the first place by being technically correct is still in order.
A finally another Fototripper video, yeah. Was missing them!
This video gets better every time it is replayed! Just superb!
there is two pretty significant differences between the X2D and the GFX 100S
first one is the type of shutter used. The X2D is using leaf shutters inside the lens, making it a lot quieter and stable compared to the GFX 100S that uses a focal plane shutter. I don't know how well dampened the GFX's shutter is, but focal plane shutters introduce a lot more movement in the camera than leaf shutters, and with 102MP sensors, even with IBIS units, the slightest movement might be the thing tipping the edge between sharp and blurry.
I don't think it has to do with the ISO, but the shutter type.
Second difference is the lenses you can put on the camera. Hasselblad needs to put a leaf shutter inside each of their lenses, which is definitely adding cost and/or reliability issues since there is more moving parts in each lens. Fujifilm went the simple way, their lenses are just lenses, and the shutter is in the camera, reducing the cost, making them simpler without compromising image quality. The GFX lenses are also more numerous and versatile compared to the Hasselblad system, with access to good primes, but also good zooms.
So looking at both of these cameras, the X2D really falls into the "luxury" camera category, like Leica does: it's special (Leica does rangefinder, Hasselblad does leaf shutters), it achieves very good image quality and some people claim that they have the best color science of all cameras, so far it seems to be the case for both brands. But for both brands as well, there is a cheaper camera with the same sensor, very close image quality and much more pragmatic approach (Sony for Leica, Fuji GFX for Hasselblad)
Fujifilm might have little worse colors compared to the X2D, but their more fleshed out lens ecosystem, more affordable cameras, access to pretty good quality video in the 100S makes it a no brainer for a lot of people, just like the color science, superior stability and/or super fast flash sync speeds will make the X2D a no brainer for other people
Two excellent cameras at the top of the food chain.
Nice comparison.
Came to look for this. Leaf shutter is the difference for this handheld shots. I already witnessed this with GFX50S vs X1D (1st generation). X1D was remarkably more handheld friendly due to less vibration from the leaf shutter.
That said, I would still pick GFX00S over X2D. Just something which makes me think Fujifilm’s future is more financially secure compared to Hasselblad now owned by the Chinese….
Have tried both. The x2d gets better images in my hands -bought the x2d. It is also nicer to hold by a lot.
Amazed they let you both in the country!😂 great comparison. Really appreciate the observations and experience. I loved hassle film cameras and would love to own the x2d.
I think you missed some details. Even though the cameras have the same sensor, the color science is different, sooo... if you try to apply a preset, created for one, to the other, the results will be different from the start . I belive your comparison is flawed from that regard.
Is is a compatibility issue based in color profiles. It's just like in video editing when applying luts. u have to use a profile conversion before applying the luts.
Stunning images of a beautiful place. Thanks for the camera reviews. The location deserves best!
Great idea in taking bear spray into Walmart. You can clear the check out line a lot faster! Nice! I must try that at my local Walmart. 😂😂😂😂
This helped me pick the Hasselblad. Took it out to Bryce Canyon and Rocky Mountain NP the last couple of weeks and you weren’t lying about those colors. Incredible. I don’t even like processing my photos anymore because I don’t want to ruin these amazing Hasselblad files
Thanks great video all the way around. The X2D has been on my list for quite some time. The colors are incredible, and the imagestabilaztion is unbelievable , the menu as well. Overall if someone didn't fall in love with that camera I would be very suspicious. Thanks again great video.
Excellent video Gav, one of your best. I'd kill for that 'blad.
Two great cameras to get to use, but wow what a fantastic venue to be able to visit. Thanks
There's some issues with this comparison. 1) SOOC JPEG on Fuji means what film simulation? There's a bunch and all look different. 2) where as X2D ibis may be better than Fuji's, you need to do a bit more testing, especially as your posture changes a lot. I can achieve sharp 1s exposures with GFX100S with proper posture at 35mm focal length. Maybe I could achieve 3s with X2D, but if we are serious, one should not rely on IBIS at longer exposures than the 1/focal length -rule, unless in a emergency. It nice to have that option though. 3) Adobe RAW for some reason has really bad default settings for GFX100S, which makes awful colors and oversharpened detail as "SOOC RAW" conversion. Capture One is way better. I'd love to see X2D raw made with Phocus and GFX100s made with C1, as Phocus is fantastic with Hasselblad files and C1 is way better than Adobe RAW with GFX100s files. That would even out the RAW conversion SW factors, and leave us as with the "best possible image out of these" result. And don't get me wrong, I do like hasselblad color science a lot, but Fuji is way cheaper and way more accessible.
Thank you for the comparison. That was great!
I love going to the Glen. And we every time I’ve been there I start at dawn to get shots without ppl.
Fantastic conditions Jon, it’s a true joy when it works out so well.
Wow that 1st fall is stunning
Another great one! Thanks for the comparison.
WOWZA what a location! love your videos, good fun and informative, thank you
I love your content! Thanks for sharing.
Both cameras use the exact same Sony sensor. If there's a difference in the way the data from the sensor is processed, it can most likely be corrected in post. In terms of sharpness, it is the lens that really determines that (how exact the focus is, the lens elements and quality etc)
how can I can which sensor they are using? ıs there any website?
@@suatsekil Both use the Sony IMX461AQR sensor.
Thank you for coming to NYS .. most people are unaware of the beautiful landscapes here ❤
Nice Video Gavin And Fantastic Shots, I Believe That The Best Camera Would Be The One That You'll Never Have To Go On Photoshop To Edit. Straight From The Camera To The Wall :)
I’ve hiked there, it’s beautiful. Great photo’s!
Wow what a beautiful scene!…. Words don’t do it any justice
Wow amazing waterfalls great video
with the hasselblad it actually made everything more green, so much so that even the boulders and waterfall had a hint of green in them.
The image stabilization difference is probably because "Blad is now owned by DJI, and who know more about stabilization. Back in the darkroom days we always referred to images from Hassy and Leica as having 'presence' . Don't overlook using Google Photo's when you want to edit JPEG images. It's surprisingly powerful. I use it in the field, downloading to my tablet, via camera wifi, to view the JPEG images quickly, occasionally sending an image to social media. It's much faster than using Lightroom, superior to seeing the images on the camera back, and the tablet takes no real space in the backpack.
Nice video I enjoyed it. Can I ask what is your normal vlog camera that that your using?
Great content Gavin and amazing cameras BUT OMG waterfall heaven I live in Northumberland and we have some amazing waterfalls but nothing like that outstanding defo a book image in there 👌👌
Loved this one, Gavin! That waterfall is orgasmic. And that Hasselblad don’t ‘alf give me the ‘orn…
Oh my word, what a stunning location! The view back towards the staircase waterfall was beautiful. Very interesting comparison, I’m swaying towards the Hasselblad for image quality but got to be the Fuji if you need both photos and video. Looking good by the way Gavin, keep it up mate!
Many thanks!
great comparison Gavin both awesome cameras like you say.
Very helpful video and review. Absolutely love the Hasselblad colours. Image stabilisation in X2D is a game changer. This scene had a relatively limited range of colours so I suspect the difference will be even greater in images with greater colour range. Thanks for sharing and a great location as well.
Thanks for the video, Gavin.
Outstanding! Thank you
You finally came back in style... I miss the old place movies with old friends. Well you can't have everything.
As mentioned. earlier - the Hasselblad seemed to have a pretty strong green cast, while the fuji, a magenta one - all correctable in post, of course. However, Fuji offer more lenses for their system than Hasselblad - an important consideration??
Brilliant! Another great video . Your storytelling is as good as your photography. I loved the reverse motion clips, and the panoramic compositions.
No video is a plus for me. Not to mention a super simplified menu. So ... I have the Hasselblad 907X CVF100C. The image quality is crazy good. 40 years of image making and I'm astounded by how advanced it has all become. Amazing.
Another great vlog Gavin! And what an epic location for the battle of the big guys! Hasselblad or GFX - I'd love to have either one. Of course I did see a sneak preview of a couple of shots while I was out with Chris while you were in New York - and new you'd love it there. Unfortunate about all the tourists! 😂 Hopefully your gimpy leg heels quickly and you can continue to frolick around Cape Breton! Cheers to you both. Keep up the good work!
What’s ailing your leg? I hope you recover quickly. Thanks for the video, I’ll never buy either one, but I love your videos.
I know that park very well. I used to be a Naturalist for NYS Parks, and though that park was not in my region, I went to it many times.That whole area of NYS is very beautiful. I assume you wish to not name the park.
Thank You for this comparison video. It has helped me with a decision for my next camera
It shouldn’t have…
For this expenditure - a major question. How many years will DJI support the camera? Fuji? Spare parts & labour, eg a new screen 10 years from now...
The opening drone scene I thought was stunning (or since it's in USA = it's 'awsum'). The colours were stunning and yep of rocks had been wetter it'd improved the scene. 1st image > bril. Yep ~ a majestical area indeed. Very much enjoyed watching.
Humour I like😅 and with your 'poorly' leg and all I'm just glad you put your silth like young wife through the toil of carrying the heavier camera. What a man (joking 😂😂😂). Cheers
What a location! That handheld X2D shot was pretty darn impressive at those settings for sure.
From personal experience, the Hasselblad's images are much more filmic. However, one thing not mentioned in the review is that the Fujifilm's autofocus is vastly superior. Also, the price gap between the two systems increases massively if you need multiple focal lengths. But the Hassy is just such a beautiful thing to use the one that gets used the most.
I live in NYC and had no idea that such fantastic photo making opportunity was upstate. Thanks for the inspiration!
Hey! You're finally in my home state! A good spot to check out next time you go through Maine is Baxter State Park. All kinds of scenic places.
I liked the GFX colours, it looked like they got a better white balance, which is hard to do in a forest. In my edit I would have the shadows have less green, and allow a bit more green in the midtones. Anyway it's hard to judge, but maybe it's time to poll your viewers, and offer a few edits on screen?
I terns of camera choice, I think the without tripod X2d would allow you to explore new angles, which would result in different and new images. I'm sure you can find a way to make an interesting video without the internal video recording the GFX offers.
❤ your choice for location on that shoot. I was just there on June 24th and did have rain. Glad it's only a 3.5 hour drive for me.
Whats the name of this exact location. Would love to visit
Some gorgeous scenery in that park. I'm quite jealous.
Informative & entertaining..... Thank you from a new fan in Rio de Janeiro, BR
I am looking at both cameras for boudoir “style” photos. Lots of lower and natural light moody but all handheld. Probably with Hassy would use the 80/1.9 a lot. Already have a Lumix S5 that I can use for video and would be ok with just straight photo camera. Any thoughts on which direction to go?
I like how you got the bear spray past the Walmart greeter!
J'adore ce que vous faites... Et surtout vôtre humour.
I am glad YT suggest your video. Did you have a chance to play around with the film simulations on the GFX? I am curious because I shoot in Velvia on my XT4 most of the time for the vibrant colors sooc. Subscribed 🤙🏼
What a location Gavin, love the images,
I shoot black and white primarily so color is not too important to me. I bought the FujiFilm GFX 100 II. Much of my landscape work is shot at a lower angle and the tilt adapter is priceless to me! I also shoot portraits and eye/face detection is very nice to have. Finally when I do shoot color FujiFilm’s film simulations remind me of choosing different film stocks. They’re great starting points in post.
Great review. Thank you. ❤
Nice comparison and beautiful setting sir! One question please…Would you say that the Hasselblad lenses are generally sharper than the Fujinon lenses? I saw more detail in your X2D handheld long exposure, but obviously that could be due to factors other than pure lens sharpness/resolution. Thanks again!
Hi good comparison, the color are very different, which better for you?
I've been on the brink of cancelling my too-many months long order for the super, sphincter tightening-ly expensive new Nikon 600mm and put the budget toward the super, sphincter tightening-ly expensive Hasselblad X2D (and a portrait lens of a length not yet decided). This video of yours is not helping LOL Hasselblad renders human flesh as exquisitely as you experienced it does with landscape colours and detail. Always wanted one and it'll look better on me than a sports car in my old age :) Cheers!
The color comparison looked to be skewed. What FIlm Simulation did you use for the GFX100S? You are doing landscape, so you should have used the Velvia Simulation.
The colors and handheld clarity with the Hasselblad are amazing I think that’s the “sexy” you felt. Almost had a meltdown when I saw where the test shoot was it’s my former back yard 🥰
Fairly new to the channel, generally hate gear comparisons but your narrative style is enjoyable and entertaining, good job sir. As it happens I just bought the Fuji 100s as I enjoy landscape photography in the pursuit of mindfulness. I got it on sale for ~7000au, a quick search shows the XD2 at ~15000au and building as for aquiring a lens set, with my current budget, I dont have any spare organs to sell. If I had oodles of $$$ then I’d have reconsidered, but as it is, no one’s paying me for my photographic interest, and brand loyalty or colour science seems worth less than it was pre LR-PShop.
yes I think higher iso effects image stabilization by giving more info to the sensor for tracking.
Hey! Great Video - thank you so much for it! May I ask which camera you used for the Video footage? Thanks a lot in advance for your answer! All the best from Ausria, G Huemer
Thanks for a great comparison video. I went through the agony of deciding between the Hasselblad H2D and the Fuji 100S for about 6 months. Finally, I settled on the 100S, but for a reason you did not really explore in your video. I have been a Hasselblad shooter for about 50 years, from the old 500C and CW film cameras, the H1D and up through the H5D-50 cameras, and finally to the H1D-50C. And for my favorite type of shooting, landscapes, the H2D is a perfect camera. The well documented shortcomings in focusing speed and lack of video do not effect me at all. I really loved the H2D; however, in a test at a local camera shop the Fuji produced beautiful images with breathtaking detail. I think the magnificent Hassy color and sharpness can be matched by the Fuji with post processing in Photoshop/Lightroom. What really convinced me was the fact that Fuji has a superb line of lenses for its GFX cameras. (And remember, the Hassy H series lenses were made by Fuji.) Hassy has only one zoom for its X cameras, 35 to 75 mm. If they had also had, say a 60-120mm, or a 70-140mm zoom, I would have bought the X2D with the two zoom lenses. I now have the Fuji 100s, three Fuji zoom lenses, 32-64mm, 45-100mm and the 100-200mm, plus the 1.4 extender for the long zoom. This gives me a 100 megapixel camera and lenses with a focal lengths from 32mm to 280mm, in a backpack that weighs only 16 lbs., including other paraphernalia.
And of course the GFX100 is more affordable. A few years ago, a local Fuji product specialist told me that Fuji's vision is to bring medium format to bigger audience. Yep, I can definitely see that.
You surprised me, I never thought that Fuji records such blurry photos. Well done.
I live a little bit away and would have loved to have meet you both. It took me about 40 minutes to get the shot without any people. Just so many places do get stunning pictures. In the Fall on a beautiful day, the Glen is mind blowing. Great video!
Enjoyed the show
Absolutely incredible location & well worth the long drive. As for the cameras, my initial thought was the colours looked a little unreal (almost over-saturated?) with the Hasselblad, but I can only judge from the UA-cam video & not what you see. One thing which really stood out for me was the image stabilisation of the Hasselblad - totally unreal. Thanks for the comparison Gavin 👍👏
Oh wow that Hasselblad really looks lovely!
I landed in Boston and onwards to Bangor Maine. The bus departed and I was alone in USA! Like North by Northwest. My pals soon picked me up! Passport control! Looked at my Canadian passport. Officer said wait here and went to another room! He came back with a whole lot of folks to Welcome me back to Canada! Wow! I was many months near boundary. I crossed from St Stephen to States, to use library! Your test was/is perfect. Hasselblad always had great colours! I could never focus the 500v series!
Wild to see you pick up a camera from that FedEx location, that's where I always drop off my rentals!
Glad you and Amanda are enjoying your business holiday in NY State. Also glad that I don't have to make your decision on which camera to buy. Pretty sure that you will choose the Fuji because of the video capability. Also sure that if you could find a workaround you would choose the Hassy. Take a sheet of paper and draw a line down the middle of the page. List all the pros on one side and the negatives on the other. Then wrack your brain between the two until you decide. 😁 Forgot to say that Amanda looked great again, as usual.
That image stabilization is insane.
Hasselblad has always ruled on top for image quality over the years. Its truly a professional photography system. You proofed that it is in this video. I loved that waterfall scene , you need to go back when no one is there.
Hasselblad colours were much more beautiful. Also the contrast and sharpness were nicer. It’s the camera I would choose between those two all day long (saying that as a Fuji fan and previous owner of X-Pro 2). The GFX100S might cost less, but it’s still a lot of money and doesn’t feel any different from the cheaper Fujis to me. The Hasselblad on the other hand feels like a million dollars. I’ve never held a camera that feels so premium. Leica is the only comparison really in terms of build quality.
Also as a lover of flash photography nothing beats leaf shutter lenses.
Same here. Agreed on all counts.
"Beautiful" color is in the eye of the beholder.
There is also something called color accuracy.
Sometimes extreme accuracy is required, and sometimes less than accurate can actually be an artistic choice, just as choosing between Kodachrome, Fujichrome, and Ektachrome. I love Kodachrome and Fujichrome, but for different reasons. But I was NEVER a fan of any sort of Ektachrome. The only time I found Ektachrome more or less acceptable was virtually at sea level, and in more or less semi bright light.
I even liked the ISO 200 Kodachrome better than I liked the ISO 100 Ektachrome. Or was Ektachrome only 64 ISO? I can't remember.
Yes, I'm sure your Hassy feels like a million dollars, because it costs almost a million dollars, and is FAR far far out of reach for the average person, even for countless professional photographers. This is why Fuji outsells a Hassy 10 to 1. People who buy a Hassy only want to make a statement, and that statement is ... "I have shitloads of cash to spend."
Fuji most assuredly knows color science, because Fuji is also a film manufacturer.
It's not necessary to manufacture film in order to comprehend color science for digital.
But then again, Hasselblad has never manufactured a single role of film.
Wow, seriously? - -
You told me that you can't tell a lot of difference between the Fuji GFS100S and the smaller format Fuji cameras? Are you BLIND?
@@scotthullinger4684 When I had my Fuji's, I thought the skinstones were great. However, the colors weren't what I'd call accurate. Both the greens and the reds were off. It was not a big deal since I shoot raw, but some products I shot I've noticed reds shifted to oranges more. In addition, this was a weird worm artifact even in raw files. Both of these cameras are expensive, and both have plus and minuses. I'd be happy to own either.
2:30 Taking bear spray into Walmart with you? Good idea, I'm going to do that from now on.
I hope you made it to Taughannock, Buttermilk and Letchworth while you were in the area, beutiful shots btw especially the drone in watkins!
Here for the comedy while using my old canon 6D today. 😆😆. Nice shots buddy.
what a stunning location well worth the drive !! I just checked my lotto number ☹☹☹Il be sticking to this side of the pond with my Pentax 😭😭Thank god for folks Like you that can bring me to these fabulous locations Ps you did a unboxing video Id love to see Mr Heaton do a reaction video to this especially during the image stabilisation test where the chap was just short of holding the camera for you ! Id say Mr Heaton was physically sick at this point 😷🤯
to be honest the colours of the fujifilm is subjective to which colour simulation is set. Provia, Astia, Velvia all produce drastically different base look in terms of colour. I wouldnt say one is superior to one or another-- it's just different. The biggest issue of the Hassleblad system is it's lens selection.
Thanks, I love your vids
Thank you too!
Nice to see a location I recognize (used to visit there often).
Very enjoyable comparison video. Most of these types of video’s are endlessly boring with incredibly redundant details. This shows what you need to know I a real life setting. I am amazed at the handheld performance of the Hasselblad.