She's always in the background dancing behind someone else and it's so frustrating because in most of her fancams you can't even see her properly throughout the performance. And she gets the least lines in every song, so she may as well be just a background dancer
N.Dz3 i honestly don’t care about lines I just want to see her dance but even in her fancams I can’t see her properly, Believe me shuhua Stans are having it rough
In Haan comeback. She was get bashed from those knets about her accent in korean and she lost her confidence so she ask Soyeon for a few lines. But now she’s improved so much about speaking korean so she got one long line in Uh Oh. And I think she will get more lines in future
@@gone7200 yes,when I saw the stage from Latata my first thought was: she is the lead dancer. With Hann this makes it more clear. But then I founded that Yuqi is the lead dancer ;-;
Nicole Anne Hernandez Honestly same i don’t want to make her feel uncomfortable but I want to see her dance so bad, I can’t see well on fancams of shushu🙁
This is just my opinion. Tbh, I prefer this song than Senorita. This song is so beautiful and well made. It's really deep and their theatrical dance is really great! ♥♥♥
@@nanasnanamin3164 coolness well good luck! Dont think its hard! For me its easy because chinese and japanese is alot harder but gooe job keep learning!
In my opinion: She would be more nervous if she got more lines. Especially when they sing purely acapella. She is not yet confident in her Korean. Please understand that she doesn't get many lines for a reason. She asked to receive less lines because she was being criticised. Pushing her past her limits wouldn't necessarily work
Guys I don’t wanna be shady but a group has to highlight the members strengths. Shuhua slayed with visuals and acting skills because that’s her forte. She even struggles to sing Latata line and y’all keep asking for more lines. She’s improving but she still has a strong accent.
I wish you'd also do the studio version from their I Made album. I've seen some but none of them are correct (mainly because most are confused on who sang which). Now that we got a live performance, the line distribution is now clear for everyone of us.
Although Miyeon sang all her lines, I’m sad because they didn’t focus on her in parts of Apa aya… Just why? upd : Please stop answering me. That's my opinion and you can't change it
Azure Mason To be honest, they should have done it in the Minnie part. In the end, it was she and Yuqi who sang. Miyeon just looked like a backing vocalist
Azure Mason Yes, I agree. This is incredibly frustrating for me. Miyeon deserves more than just being a backing vocalist. I do not want to blame Idle for everything that happens with Miyeon (lack of advancement, lack of lines and center). But I don’t know how to explain it differently. And that upsets me even more.
@@КсенияКлишевич-т5ж I know it's somewhat frustrating, especially for Shuhua's case. But that's how a group works, everybody will have "a" part, some will be highlighted more than others. But have faith notably for this group! With Soyeon and her unique conceptualization, tt's just a matter of time before Miyeon becomes the center.
shuhua ask soyeon for less lines because she's not confident with her korean and soyeon as a good leader respect her desition. shuhua told soyeon how thankful she is to have a good leader like her cause she make her a better person..
Weeell in fire sang 14sc and this track was when she wasnt cofident enough so... Lets hope for her to have more línes... Soyeon said onces that she is starting to be more cofident
Don't ever bash Soyeon, She's the mad genius that's keeping the group together. if it was up to keep to Cube, who knows what would of happen to Shuhua. respect Soyeon for giving the group and us great music comeback after comeback.
Unlocked Shuhua deserves all the praise she’s getting you’re acting as if she didn’t work hard as well and of course Soyeon deserves all the praise she gets and more because she’s one of the most talented kpop idols but Shuhua shouldn’t just be ignored and left in the dust
chicken noodle soup First of all. I’m trying to sound less as rude as possible. But saying that she is not confident with her Korean is not longer a good excuse for her lack of lines. You can see that she has improved a lot with her Korean, and that she is confident and fluent with it. It’s not longer that she isn’t confident. It’s just that CUBE and whoever distributed the lines really hate Shuhua.
So, about Shuhua,,,she's said she isn't very confident in Korean and many, many people bashed her for her accent when Hann came out. Even if she may not have asked Soyeon to give her fewer lines, it seems reasonable Soyeon would anyways. And it probably has a lot to do with Cube, they put her in the back most likely because she was a trainee for the least amount of time and wasn't very confident. She's improving a lot though, so I really hope she gets more lines in the next cbs! i honestly love her
It's not soyeon's fault that Shuhua doesn't have lines. Shuhua has specifically asked for less lines because she doesn't want to get bashed because of her accent. It's rough for her and people need to respect that.
so everyone knows this is a bside from the seniorita era which is right after Hann where shu got a lot of backlash for her pronunciation explaining her limited lines
Not hating soyeon but her last part aka the last part of the song could have went to shuhua... i know shuhua said shes isnt confident in singing korean but i mean you need to sing it to pick it up isnt it? At least 10s of line is better than 3s..
@@ksou972 actually haters who says that "jennie is lazy bitch, jisoo and irene are taletless pretty face who even not that pretty and soyeon is ugly" are also real but that doesn't mean they are right haters always gonna hate, if she sings they would say she is terrible at singing and her korean is bad when she is dancing they would say she is a tree and you know other hater stuff so btw she never said she wants less lines
@@emilykie2301 Maybe she has said that to Soyeon, we don't know what happens behind the stages. I'm pretty sure that if Shuhua was confident enough, and Soyeon would recognize that she's ready to have more lines without getting hate for her accent and pronunciation, Shuhua would get more lines. And actually these haters weren't hating without any basis. They shouldn't have hated her at all, hating her for something like accent is bullshit imo, but Hann era has given them a chance to hate, you could easily hear her accent and different pronunciation.
@@umiku9407 then i guess chaeyeon said to jyp that she is NoT CoNfIdEnT and also felix as you said we don`t know what happens bts so it could be thousands reasons so don`t be like "may be she said im not sure but probably" we didn`t hear her saying this but IF it like this than what about dancing? she is always in the back but she had danced at least 2 times at cube uc and she did REALLY GOOD and she has her style she is great at dancing so why?
@@emilykie2301 Your comparison is actually stupid you know. Afaik Chaeyoung and Felix are Korean, they're also from JYP so they've trained much more compared to Shuhua(she's trained for less than a year right?). I don't know about Felix because I'm not into Stray Kids, but Chaeyoung is a rapper and TWICE's songs are not-that-fierce/badass to put a lot of raps. Their discography is much more focused on vocals, so it's already quite a miracle that she gets her fierce raps in their songs. Meanwhile Shuhua is from Taiwan, she wanted to be an actress at first(so she didn't get proper training before training in CUBE), she's trained for less than a year and we can see that she's still not that communicative live compared to other members of IDLE. Much wiser comparison would be Handong from Dreamcatcher, who is Chinese. She's debuted in 2017 and she still publicly says that she's not that confident in her Korean, because she tends to forget words, thus she wanted less lines. I'd really think that Shuhua's situation is much more closer to Handong's situation than Chaeyoung's or Felix'. From what we know, the safest way to assume why Shuhua doesn't get as much lines is because she's just not confident in her Korean or her singing techniques are lacking compared to other members'. That's why when singing an encore stage she always gets nervous and members often try to help her. When it comes to dancing, she got much better in Uh-Oh era, so I'd be expecting her to be less in the back in the future. The main reason she was put in the back a lot is probably that she looked emotionless when dancing in the past, so Soyeon and Soojin, the most charismatic members got a lot of center time. And actually she's not always in the back, people just want to justify their words by saying something like that lol.
@@КристинаДостоевская-ш6д Well, i guess we can rejoice now because G-idle is going to perform "lion" and Shuhua will finally ge the lines she deserves.😁
@@lemortedbrian6070 Sure she'll never get the amount of focus as Soyeon does, but sounds stupid to me if you've reduced her to a sub-vocal for the rest of her career. Little change once in a while doesn't hurt anyone. To me it looks like she got bullied for her accent and already being shy and in a foreign country so she got even more insecure. If you want a long lasting group you don't throw someone to the side for the rest of eternity. That's why you have all these idols not resigning their contracts. They wanted more and instead got paid dust. I'm happy for her 10 seconds in Uh-oh and her dance solos, the only way is up.
are you stupid?? shuhua ask soyeon for less lines because she's not confident with her korean and soyeon as a good leader respect her desition. shuhua told soyeon how thankful she is to have a good leader like her cause she make her a better person, why tf yall always shitting on soyeon for shuhua having less lines..
@@renee387 shuhua has been more confident lately! but not enough, she said it was difficult to record her verse in lion (and in omg) so soyeon was with her when she did it, shuhua trust soyeon and soyeon respect shuhua, she's not gonna force her to do long lines if shuhua doesnt feel comfortable with her korean yet.
Gdile: So now the lines are fairly distributed. *Shuhua: wait what about me?* **Soyeon: oh yeah! I forgot! um... just randomly give you some ad-libs.**
@@megyogur9619 that "shuahua cant speak korean well" reason is so old . Shuahua has been in korea for years she could atleast sing it properly with no to minimal foreign accent. So try harder cause that excuse is overuse.
In the original version there was no rap, so without the rap Miyeon and Minnie, who are both main vocalists,would top the line distribution. So stop saying that Soyeon did not distribute lines to the main vocalists. This track was released back in February, where Shuhua was not that confident yet. Hopefully she has an increase in lines for their next album
Well, I don't mind if u guys said that to me. Because maybe i didn't express it well. But I do have to say: 1. I am a fan of gidle(not a big fan but still a fan) 2. *i do not hate soyeon* 3. *it's just a joke dun be that serious or over-sensitive* 4. Why I said it's soyeon because it's queendom. I think soyeon led the group to prepare the stage so... 5. *The main purpose of mine is too emphasize that shuhua doesn't have lines* but not blaming soyeon(I didn't even blame her.) 6 *once again, don't be that serious*
@@megyogur9619 I have to say. I am not hating soyeon. And my main purpose is to say shuahua deserves more lines. ******If u think this is hating soyeon then maybe I could also say that you're hating shuhua cuz u think it's normal that she can only sing 3 secs. Will u still be good if I say that to u?**********
People really complaining too much.. They are in a group.. They cover eachother weakness and support (highlight) other as well. Like miyeon did in the last part.. She became backsinger and didnt get the spotlight.. But thats okay bcs maybe its her time to give the spotlight to other member.. Maybe in other chance miyeon will get spotlight. Its a pretty fair line distribution. I liketheir dynamic.. And for shuhua i know she can improve better in the future and get more lines, for now 3 sec line and her beauty is a nice addition to the group.
this song is a side track of Señorita, which explains why Shuhua has less lines, bc at that time she wasn't confident enough. Shuhua asked Soyeon to give her lesser lines.
I ask myself if Shuhua did and audition to enter in CUBE? Because she has a good voice, why she doesn't have lines, this is like the first person I saw singing less than 5sec in a song
Shuhua is improving with her stage presence in dancing but seriously she sucks in singing live. She even lipsynchs some of her little lines here LOL. So to here fans complaining and complaining should see how Shuhua sings before you make her some lead vocals or something LOL. She has little lines and yet her lines are given exposure so be contented with that.
shuhua ask soyeon for less lines because she's not confident with her korean and soyeon as a good leader respect her desition. shuhua told soyeon how thankful she is to have a good leader like her cause she make her a better person..
This is just my opinion, so please keep calm and chill. I prefer this song (as Bside with Senorita) than Senorita. This song is well made. This concept is really deep and all members looks shining and stunning with this concept ♥♥♥ (I'm sorry for bad english, because english isn't my first languange)
Its a competition so she probably wants not to fuck up because of her pronunciation and more with a song they dont sing live at all that's it. Remember prep time is a week.
![[INA SUB] [퀸' Story] (여자)아이들 '싫다고 말해(Nightmare Ver.)' @퀸덤 3차 R2 경연 (INA SUB)](/img/n.gif)
shuhua is my favorite background dancer 😔
EYE-
#shuhuaneedmorelines
She's always in the background dancing behind someone else and it's so frustrating because in most of her fancams you can't even see her properly throughout the performance. And she gets the least lines in every song, so she may as well be just a background dancer
Yea.. she is learning korean but still her korean (especially pronunciation) is terrible so she doesn't get many lines to sing :(
N.Dz3 i honestly don’t care about lines I just want to see her dance but even in her fancams I can’t see her properly,
Believe me shuhua Stans are having it rough
shuhua: i-
cube: you did great sweetie, next
Shuhua doesn't want lines....
@Alenka Chan she is afraid that knetzs will bash her for her korean pronounciation... It's not easy for her to feel confident ofc
@Tahsin Akhlaq she literally said she wanted less lines on naver
@Alenka Chan because she get bashed of her accent in hann
In Haan comeback. She was get bashed from those knets about her accent in korean and she lost her confidence so she ask Soyeon for a few lines. But now she’s improved so much about speaking korean so she got one long line in Uh Oh. And I think she will get more lines in future
at least shuhua got the killing part, like hann's dance solo
kanan is love it was 5second dance break in hann
Unlocked I think Shuhua is actually the lead dancer-
Soojin’s ponytail In Senorita she isn’t. soojin is main, with soyeon and yuqi as leads.
@@gone7200 yes,when I saw the stage from Latata my first thought was: she is the lead dancer. With Hann this makes it more clear. But then I founded that Yuqi is the lead dancer ;-;
That's true
Shuhua : *breath*
Cube ent : ok that's enough
Her visuals overflowed
*shuhua has the most beautiful breathing* 😍❤️
@@shinobuss2620 i don't even care about the lines but her visuals slay... And still loud af even tho her pronunciation is not good.
Nicole Anne Hernandez
Honestly same i don’t want to make her feel uncomfortable but I want to see her dance so bad, I can’t see well on fancams of shushu🙁
*soyeon*
omg I was so hyped when I found out they performed put it straight/say no. This is one of my favourite bsides
ME TOOOOOOOOO OMG
This is just my opinion. Tbh, I prefer this song than Senorita. This song is so beautiful and well made. It's really deep and their theatrical dance is really great! ♥♥♥
Same!
Minnie: I'm the first!
Miyeon: no lol
Soyeon: hold my beer
Hadwin Ying *ahaha also the fact that soyeon want to do a beer cf*
Shuheart2 lol
Miyeon and minnie: flip table
Miyeon's vocals are so alluring I'd love to hear more... praying they don't shun her away next cb as well😞
@@lemortedbrian6070 she's the most underrated member rn
True.
Spoiler alert, they did 😭
@@emoore2313 I was about to say the same thing, she literally isn't a main vocsl anymore
Harrison Hawker she might as well downgrade to sub.
When Minnie hurt part is can feel really hurt
Note 아파 mean hurt
But 음파음파 mean bop
Pedro orbit yes.
Pedro orbit yeah I’m not too but I tries as much as I can to use it in my daily life so I can remember it faster.Note it’s very hard
@@nanasnanamin3164 coolness well good luck! Dont think its hard! For me its easy because chinese and japanese is alot harder but gooe job keep learning!
@Pedro orbit bct y kmu
I don't understand...
My opinion:
If Shuhua got more lines, she would be more confident by now.
Agreeddddd
In my opinion:
She would be more nervous if she got more lines. Especially when they sing purely acapella. She is not yet confident in her Korean. Please understand that she doesn't get many lines for a reason. She asked to receive less lines because she was being criticised. Pushing her past her limits wouldn't necessarily work
Well, good news then. They're going to perform "Lion" at their next queendom performance and the line distribution is quite fair 😊
Mika Kate Lisa from Blackpink had the same problem when she trained, she learned korean because her teammates helped her. They should help Shuhua.
@@derpio658
How would you know that they're not currently helping Shuhua?
I love Minnie's dreamy voice
SHUAHUA S 3 SEC LINE IS ICONIC, YUQI GETTING MORE LINES, AND THEY ARE THE MOST POPULAR MEMBERS I THINK,
shuhua is one of the most underrated member but yes yuqi is the most popular
Miracles In Mao
Shuhua is underrated but she gets lots of views on he fancams
@@shinobuss2620 I think Shuhua has the most number of fancafe in Korea if I'm not mistaken
SACCHAN *thats amazing I’m so happy for her*
@@shinobuss2620 yes me too. Her visual is no joke that's why k-nevies really like her
Can’t explain it, but Minnie put absolute creepy into this and I love it 😍
Main vocalist is back!!!!she so stunning and her visual is wow
Andira 1963 Miyeon?
What the hell? MiYeon and Minnie are both main vocals.
@@pinwuzzie5283 no miyeon main vocal and minnie just lead vokal
@@myprivatelifechannel225 no, Minnie and MiYeon are Main Vocalist the two
@@pinwuzzie5283 just searching it, idle main vokal only miyeon
슈화가 부르는 파트가 저렇게 적었어요? 시각적 임팩트가 커서 존재감 장난 아니었는데... 와....
내 말이...
다들 미쳐가고 무너져 가는 와중에도 이성의 끈을 놓지 않으려 노력하는 가련함의 느낌이 너무 임팩트가 컸던 듯...
너무 킬링파트라 파트 적게 준듯하네요..머리 뒤집을때 진짜 킬링..
아파아이야부분을 원래 슈화가 하는데 라이브가 약해서 민니가 한듯해용
파트가 거의 세줄뿐인데 임팩트는 엄청 컸던거 가틈..
김수한무거북이와두루미 죄송한데 제가 알기로는 원래 이 노래에서 슈화파트 엄청 적어요... 날 멀어질까가 끝입니당 아파아이야는 원래 미연, 민니 파트에요 유튜브에 파트별 가사가 잘못되어잇는게 많더라구요ㅠㅠ
Shuhua sounds so beautiful even when she breaths❤️
Guys I don’t wanna be shady but a group has to highlight the members strengths. Shuhua slayed with visuals and acting skills because that’s her forte. She even struggles to sing Latata line and y’all keep asking for more lines. She’s improving but she still has a strong accent.
shuhua: (exist)
cube: ok, your lines end here
Unlocked they didn’t mention Soyeon tho
lol
SHUHUA still slayed with that 3 seconds of line
This really is a *NIGHTMARE* for shuhua.......
Bro, it sounds true though
It's good that we know now that Shuhua wasn't really bothered by having few lines during that time.
I wish you'd also do the studio version from their I Made album. I've seen some but none of them are correct (mainly because most are confused on who sang which). Now that we got a live performance, the line distribution is now clear for everyone of us.
미연 비주얼 보컬 다 되네...ㄹㅇ 사기...
Miyeon♥♥
Are you gonna do the line distribution of Empire when it comes out?
I am planning to do so ^^
Is that the name of what their song on the 24tj will be called?
Meon tysm
Super Lame no, it’s the collaboration between Wengie and Minnie from Gidle, it’s dropping on 18th 10pm KST.
Miyeon Main Vocalist Comeback!🥺❤️
Soyeon is main vocalist main rapper leader main dancer visual center jaja soyeon ft (G)idle
Fernan Garcia sure? But Miyeon Vocal Is better than Soyeon!
@@erickhui5769 yes I know that miyeon is the main vocalist but I said it as a joke since soyeon is always dull
Fernan Garcia Please don’t spread hate
@@fernangarcia6245 agree, they give everything to Soyeon :/
2:28 I can't with this Queen. Her rap is AMAZING 🌹💎💫
Miyeon ❤️
Although Miyeon sang all her lines, I’m sad because they didn’t focus on her in parts of Apa aya…
Just why?
upd : Please stop answering me. That's my opinion and you can't change it
They did... well, with Minnie 😂
Azure Mason To be honest, they should have done it in the Minnie part. In the end, it was she and Yuqi who sang. Miyeon just looked like a backing vocalist
@@КсенияКлишевич-т5ж Not to be rude, but in that part, Miyeon was just a back vocalist to harmonize with Minnie.
But it was very well done!
Azure Mason Yes, I agree. This is incredibly frustrating for me. Miyeon deserves more than just being a backing vocalist. I do not want to blame Idle for everything that happens with Miyeon (lack of advancement, lack of lines and center). But I don’t know how to explain it differently. And that upsets me even more.
@@КсенияКлишевич-т5ж I know it's somewhat frustrating, especially for Shuhua's case. But that's how a group works, everybody will have "a" part, some will be highlighted more than others.
But have faith notably for this group! With Soyeon and her unique conceptualization, tt's just a matter of time before Miyeon becomes the center.
Minnie was amazing in this💕
I was just looking for this
MIYEONNNN I LOVE YOU
3.7 seconds is way too short for a song over 4 minutes for Shuhua.
shuhua ask soyeon for less lines because she's not confident with her korean and soyeon as a good leader respect her desition. shuhua told soyeon how thankful she is to have a good leader like her cause she make her a better person..
In the original version, I believe Shuhua has the chorus to herself
@@6IDLE she has more than 3.7 seconds I believe. She's more confident in Korean now so that's no longer true.
@@quillettt it's still true, the members are the one who pick their lines...
슈화파트가 확실히 적긴하지만 아무래도 라이브로 부르다보니까 발음이나 라이브에 약한 슈화한테 파트 조금 준듯.. 그래도 우리 슈화 이쁘다ㅠㅠ 많이 늘었다!!
Y’all remember Shuhua has said she don’t want to many lines
Yall acting surprised with shuhua getting little lines even though yall done knew how many lines she gets in these lines since it's an old song
Weeell in fire sang 14sc and this track was when she wasnt cofident enough so... Lets hope for her to have more línes... Soyeon said onces that she is starting to be more cofident
In the original version she did the apa ah yah bits
@@furei88 im sorry but where is the proof how do you still think its shuhua when its clearly miyeon and minnie 😱
@@aizen3347 I literally said in the original version, as in the side track for 'I Made'
@@furei88 that's why why would you think that that's im sorry but that's dum......
Don't ever bash Soyeon, She's the mad genius that's keeping the group together. if it was up to keep to Cube, who knows what would of happen to Shuhua.
respect Soyeon for giving the group and us great music comeback after comeback.
SuperNovah
Those are just idiots solo stans or ot5
Unlocked Shuhua deserves all the praise she’s getting you’re acting as if she didn’t work hard as well and of course Soyeon deserves all the praise she gets and more because she’s one of the most talented kpop idols but Shuhua shouldn’t just be ignored and left in the dust
Minnie deserved!
3:34 miyeon vocal..omg..i love this
said the same in Minnie why do you always praise the same people
basically shuhua's lines are the end of yuqi ones.
Miyeon 😍😍😍
Miyeon and Minnie suit this song so much, and Soojin’s part gave me goosebump
Hey cube did you know that Shuhua *_IS A VOCALIST?_*
did you know that shuhua is not confident with her korean so she ask for less lines???
did you know that shuhua is not confident with her korean so she ask for less lines???
Cube:Who is Shuhua??
@@ubb5111 yeah... not funny.
chicken noodle soup First of all. I’m trying to sound less as rude as possible.
But saying that she is not confident with her Korean is not longer a good excuse for her lack of lines.
You can see that she has improved a lot with her Korean, and that she is confident and fluent with it.
It’s not longer that she isn’t confident. It’s just that CUBE and whoever distributed the lines really hate Shuhua.
I feel so sorry for Shuhua, my baby only has 3 seconds
Guys don’t get mad shuhua literally wanted to become a actor plus her korean is not good yet.
Minnie’s emotions are just 🔥
miyeon in the thumbnail 😩🤒❤️
Atleast Shuhua’s getting the hyped, Miyeon has the most of the line but no one is talking abt her
So, about Shuhua,,,she's said she isn't very confident in Korean and many, many people bashed her for her accent when Hann came out. Even if she may not have asked Soyeon to give her fewer lines, it seems reasonable Soyeon would anyways. And it probably has a lot to do with Cube, they put her in the back most likely because she was a trainee for the least amount of time and wasn't very confident. She's improving a lot though, so I really hope she gets more lines in the next cbs! i honestly love her
Miyeeeooon ✨❤️💜
Miyeon still our main vocaaaaaal
Minnie main vocalist before miyeon join cube entertainment lol
ME: OMG SHUHUA LINES PLEASE...
CUBE: NO BICHT JAJA
all songs making by soyeon
It's not soyeon's fault that Shuhua doesn't have lines. Shuhua has specifically asked for less lines because she doesn't want to get bashed because of her accent. It's rough for her and people need to respect that.
Santiago Perez stop making Soyeon seem like a villain. Shuhua has said that’s she’s not confident in her Korean and she has asked for less lines.
Santiago Perez this is an old song made when Shuhua was not confident about her korean
Wtf delete this shit😑
At least the camera was focusing on our favourite background dancer Shuhua on her parts.
so everyone knows this is a bside from the seniorita era which is right after Hann where shu got a lot of backlash for her pronunciation explaining her limited lines
Not hating soyeon but her last part aka the last part of the song could have went to shuhua... i know shuhua said shes isnt confident in singing korean but i mean you need to sing it to pick it up isnt it? At least 10s of line is better than 3s..
Yh
When Shuhua doesn't want to sing let it be plz. She knows what's good for herself
@@iwillhityouwithblackpinksl9879 true
chisoo is jicken I like it when it starts with soyeon and ends with soyeon ❤️
That was Soyeons part in the original song anyways. And shuhua is not confidant in korean yet. Give her time please
IF ANY OF YOU HEARD THAT SHUHUA "SIAD SHE WANTS LESS LINES" IT ISNT TRUE THAT WAS A WRONG TRANSLATION SHE NEVER SAID THAT
But haters who said that she doesn't know how to speak Korean are real. With sulli everybody know how haters have power even to kill someone
@@ksou972 actually haters who says that "jennie is lazy bitch, jisoo and irene are taletless pretty face who even not that pretty and soyeon is ugly" are also real but that doesn't mean they are right
haters always gonna hate, if she sings they would say she is terrible at singing and her korean is bad when she is dancing they would say she is a tree and you know other hater stuff so
btw she never said she wants less lines
@@emilykie2301 Maybe she has said that to Soyeon, we don't know what happens behind the stages. I'm pretty sure that if Shuhua was confident enough, and Soyeon would recognize that she's ready to have more lines without getting hate for her accent and pronunciation, Shuhua would get more lines.
And actually these haters weren't hating without any basis. They shouldn't have hated her at all, hating her for something like accent is bullshit imo, but Hann era has given them a chance to hate, you could easily hear her accent and different pronunciation.
@@umiku9407 then i guess chaeyeon said to jyp that she is NoT CoNfIdEnT and also felix
as you said we don`t know what happens bts so it could be thousands reasons so don`t be like "may be she said im not sure but probably"
we didn`t hear her saying this
but IF it like this than what about dancing? she is always in the back but she had danced at least 2 times at cube uc and she did REALLY GOOD and she has her style she is great at dancing so why?
@@emilykie2301 Your comparison is actually stupid you know.
Afaik Chaeyoung and Felix are Korean, they're also from JYP so they've trained much more compared to Shuhua(she's trained for less than a year right?).
I don't know about Felix because I'm not into Stray Kids, but Chaeyoung is a rapper and TWICE's songs are not-that-fierce/badass to put a lot of raps. Their discography is much more focused on vocals, so it's already quite a miracle that she gets her fierce raps in their songs.
Meanwhile Shuhua is from Taiwan, she wanted to be an actress at first(so she didn't get proper training before training in CUBE), she's trained for less than a year and we can see that she's still not that communicative live compared to other members of IDLE.
Much wiser comparison would be Handong from Dreamcatcher, who is Chinese. She's debuted in 2017 and she still publicly says that she's not that confident in her Korean, because she tends to forget words, thus she wanted less lines. I'd really think that Shuhua's situation is much more closer to Handong's situation than Chaeyoung's or Felix'.
From what we know, the safest way to assume why Shuhua doesn't get as much lines is because she's just not confident in her Korean or her singing techniques are lacking compared to other members'.
That's why when singing an encore stage she always gets nervous and members often try to help her.
When it comes to dancing, she got much better in Uh-Oh era, so I'd be expecting her to be less in the back in the future. The main reason she was put in the back a lot is probably that she looked emotionless when dancing in the past, so Soyeon and Soojin, the most charismatic members got a lot of center time. And actually she's not always in the back, people just want to justify their words by saying something like that lol.
I'm so sad about Shuhua..
Why?
Skrrrtt like only 3 sec.
@@КристинаДостоевская-ш6д
Well, i guess we can rejoice now because G-idle is going to perform "lion" and Shuhua will finally ge the lines she deserves.😁
Honestly, at award shows, they made up with her lack of lines sometimes with having her dance solo.
miyeon stable vocal as always❤
main vocal indeed!
I last longer in the bathroom than Shuhua in the studio
슈화 파트가 3초뿐인게 맘에 걸릴수도있는데 무대에서의 슈화의 파트는 3초인게 생각 안날정도로 임팩트가 컸던..게다가 아무리 킬링파트를 줘도 못살리면 의미가 없는데 슈화파트는 그냥 슈화 그자체..
Cube should defo give Shushua more lines. Like I absolutely love her voice and she doesn't even show it. Happy she finally got lines in Lion tho
Shuhua has not been here long, so he put the part in the special memorable part
Poor Shuhua, she needs some serious love in the next comeback.
@@lemortedbrian6070 I am awake and i know this song is old. In Uh-Oh Shuhua got the least amount of lines once again so nothing has changed.
@@lemortedbrian6070 Sure she'll never get the amount of focus as Soyeon does, but sounds stupid to me if you've reduced her to a sub-vocal for the rest of her career. Little change once in a while doesn't hurt anyone. To me it looks like she got bullied for her accent and already being shy and in a foreign country so she got even more insecure.
If you want a long lasting group you don't throw someone to the side for the rest of eternity. That's why you have all these idols not resigning their contracts. They wanted more and instead got paid dust.
I'm happy for her 10 seconds in Uh-oh and her dance solos, the only way is up.
Shuhua: Only today can you give me good lines?
Miyeon,Soyeon and Minnie: *NO*
are you stupid?? shuhua ask soyeon for less lines because she's not confident with her korean and soyeon as a good leader respect her desition. shuhua told soyeon how thankful she is to have a good leader like her cause she make her a better person, why tf yall always shitting on soyeon for shuhua having less lines..
@@6IDLE i am sorry it was just meant to be a joke .....
chicken noodle then what about lion?!?!
@@renee387 shuhua has been more confident lately! but not enough, she said it was difficult to record her verse in lion (and in omg) so soyeon was with her when she did it, shuhua trust soyeon and soyeon respect shuhua, she's not gonna force her to do long lines if shuhua doesnt feel comfortable with her korean yet.
I honestly didn’t focus on the lines when I first saw the performance cause the performance got me so wrapped up in it
Gdile: So now the lines are fairly distributed.
*Shuhua: wait what about me?*
**Soyeon: oh yeah! I forgot! um... just randomly give you some ad-libs.**
*Cube
Not Soyeon
@@megyogur9619 that "shuahua cant speak korean well" reason is so old . Shuahua has been in korea for years she could atleast sing it properly with no to minimal foreign accent. So try harder cause that excuse is overuse.
In the original version there was no rap, so without the rap Miyeon and Minnie, who are both main vocalists,would top the line distribution. So stop saying that Soyeon did not distribute lines to the main vocalists. This track was released back in February, where Shuhua was not that confident yet. Hopefully she has an increase in lines for their next album
Well, I don't mind if u guys said that to me. Because maybe i didn't express it well. But I do have to say:
1. I am a fan of gidle(not a big fan but still a fan)
2. *i do not hate soyeon*
3. *it's just a joke dun be that serious or over-sensitive*
4. Why I said it's soyeon because it's queendom. I think soyeon led the group to prepare the stage so...
5. *The main purpose of mine is too emphasize that shuhua doesn't have lines* but not blaming soyeon(I didn't even blame her.)
6 *once again, don't be that serious*
@@megyogur9619 I have to say. I am not hating soyeon. And my main purpose is to say shuahua deserves more lines.
******If u think this is hating soyeon then maybe I could also say that you're hating shuhua cuz u think it's normal that she can only sing 3 secs. Will u still be good if I say that to u?**********
I really hope they release this version of the song recorded!! 😍😍😍😍😍
I think at first the first line is minnie hehe but soeyeon slaying it
BAGUSAJI SETIAWAN no it’s Soyeon you can read lyrics and see which member sang the part in the original video
No it's soyeon
Soyeon has good vocals too
The Minnie vocals was everything!!!....
That hair and contacts on Yuqi look beautiful.
ชอบเสียงพี่มินนี่❤️
This is Gidle ft. Shuhua
People really complaining too much.. They are in a group.. They cover eachother weakness and support (highlight) other as well. Like miyeon did in the last part.. She became backsinger and didnt get the spotlight.. But thats okay bcs maybe its her time to give the spotlight to other member.. Maybe in other chance miyeon will get spotlight. Its a pretty fair line distribution. I liketheir dynamic.. And for shuhua i know she can improve better in the future and get more lines, for now 3 sec line and her beauty is a nice addition to the group.
Unlocked Shuhua barely had lines, and Miyeon that is the official Main vocalist since debut haven't the chance of show Hera VoiceOver
Oh no it’s f(x)’s song Dracula!! It drives me back to f(5) era😭😭😭
Miyeon is the prettiest MAIN vocalist. PEROID💕💕💕
When ur bias only gets 3.7 seconds of an amazing song
Again.... R.I.P shuhua's lines☹️
Oh, Soyeon is first. Soooo unexpected.
this song is a side track of Señorita, which explains why Shuhua has less lines, bc at that time she wasn't confident enough. Shuhua asked Soyeon to give her lesser lines.
Minnie❣️
Nossa shuhua sempre cantando menos e a soyeon e minnie, sempre cantam mais que as outras ,e olha a diferentes lines
슈화 3초가 뭐야 3초가.. 소연아 슈화한테 파트좀만 줘라 ㅠㅠ 원래 슈화파트 많았는데 민니랑 미연파트로 바뀌었네,, 아쉽
혹시 슈화파트 아파아이야 말씀하시는거면 그거 원래 미연 민니 맞아요ㅠㅠ 유튜브에 파트별 가사 다 다르게 나와있는데 슈화 파트는 날 멀어질까 다섯글자가 다구요 아파아이야는 1,2절 나눠서 메보 둘이 합니당...
@@오리-m6p 이게 맞아요ㅜㅜ
MaiN DanCer CHo MiYeoN!!! 예? 제 말이 맞다는거죠?? 예전에 달앗던 댓글이라 놀랏네요ㅋㅋㅋ
Shuha: Apa-
Cube: No, let minnie say it over there.
Shuha: :(
CUBE didn't distribute their lines actually
More lines for my bby shuhua❤️😊💛
I ask myself if Shuhua did and audition to enter in CUBE? Because she has a good voice, why she doesn't have lines, this is like the first person I saw singing less than 5sec in a song
Seeing Shuhua like this makes me feel like I can become a kpop idol even I don’t even know hơ to sing
Shuhua is improving with her stage presence in dancing but seriously she sucks in singing live. She even lipsynchs some of her little lines here LOL. So to here fans complaining and complaining should see how Shuhua sings before you make her some lead vocals or something LOL. She has little lines and yet her lines are given exposure so be contented with that.
Crazy how shuhua actually ask for less lines. But go ahead, assume 😹😹.
shuhua ask soyeon for less lines because she's not confident with her korean and soyeon as a good leader respect her desition. shuhua told soyeon how thankful she is to have a good leader like her cause she make her a better person..
@@6IDLE Girl I know... that's why i said- nvm.
@@namjoonsblackwifeuwu8916 that sound like you werent sure about it
Minnie queen
This is just my opinion, so please keep calm and chill.
I prefer this song (as Bside with Senorita) than Senorita. This song is well made. This concept is really deep and all members looks shining and stunning with this concept ♥♥♥
(I'm sorry for bad english, because english isn't my first languange)
아이들 음색 담당은 민니인듯
민니 입니당 !
뚀밍 수정했어용 감사합니다
Miyeon 38.9
Minnie 38.5
Soojin 16.0
Soyeon 41.9
Yuqi 25.1
Shuhua 03.7
Minnie owned this concept y'all 👏👏👏
why does Minnie still have those bangs
tbh this is her best look to date
She looks good with them that’s why.
I prefer her and Soojin without bangs
Jaden Collins Sorry, but Idle is Idle. If you think they better be ot4, then please leave
@@КсенияКлишевич-т5ж he never said something about ot4
I feel like the last part should have been given to Shuhua instead of Soyeon, cause Soyeon got enough lines as a VOCALIST.
Until now I didnt know who is my bias. Before its yuqi, but now.. I don't knoowww
Miyeon shows her vocals in this one ahh
minnie♥️me ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
maybe shuhua needs more practice before going to be an idol, i mean she's ready but her korean is not that good yet and she's a great visual though
I cried in Minnie's part..... I feel so much pain..
Its a competition so she probably wants not to fuck up because of her pronunciation and more with a song they dont sing live at all that's it. Remember prep time is a week.
우기야 슬픈연기 대박 💝💝💝💝💝💝