I heard Ann Netrebko sing this at the Kennedy Center in 1999, and here voice was so exquisite that the whole audience was mesmerized. It was the most beautiful sound I ever heard in my life. I have been a fan of hers ever since. This is just a particularly bad quality recording.
regulargonzalez She is depressing her larynx to artificially darken her tone and has thus developed a wobble. She is bowing roles meant for a much heavier voice. She has completely destroyed her voice. She sounds terrible now. Very sad.
Not sure if anyone cares but if you're bored like me atm you can stream all of the latest movies and series on InstaFlixxer. I've been watching with my girlfriend for the last couple of weeks =)
After Anna Bolena, her Adina in the Elixir of Love at the Met last year was a disappointment, although in large part due to the atrocious production. This year, however, she is ROCKING Eugene Onegin. It's a stellar production with an exeptional cast. Netreboko, Marius Kwiecen and Paul Beczala. Fantastic. She absolutely dominates, and her voice is right where it should be.
her Gilda is good, young and fresh voice. especially if you compare this to various rigolettos you can hear now at met and in Europe, where stages are occupied by old "coloratura" chickens who lost their voices (if had any) many years ago
Yes, her voice was much lighter and easier, her technic is way better now, but in spite of that I always get the feeling that she sang more easily with this lighter technic. Sometimes I feel as if she put too much emphasis on the size of her voice. Not always but sometimes. Btw I do like her :)
Think how young she is here. She's still learning, honing her technique, singing with a young instrument. Give her a break! The voice is gorgeous no matter what.
Yes changed, not only with age, but also technical. The middle register is now more, much more darker! Using chest voice to colour the upper register. Must say I love the light soprano here. Lovely!
This is so interesting! Good to see her at a less refined state than she is now, and really appreciate more where she's come. Not saying this isn't beautiful!!
Удивительный голос, покоряющий и заставляющий забыть всё и себя самого, пока он звучит. После такого исполнения хочется кричать "Браво" и крушить всё вокруг )
You are right. She has never described herself as a coloratura; she does sing the lyric repertoire beautifully and her high notes are thrilling, especially as she has aged. Dramatic rep. she has been attempting is too big for her, and is not good for her voice. She is a terrific actress, and I imagine she longs to sing the dramatic roles for that reason. Still, it's too much for her voice, and she loses that lovely brilliance and velvet of her sound when she tries to make her voice 'bigger.'
@Phantess Anna Yuryevna Netrebko (Russian: Анна Юрьевна Нетребко, born 18 September 1971) so in 1999 she was either 27 or 28. BTW Yuryevna is her patronymic - meaning daughter of her father Yury. Love this very much! She is getting even ever better with age!
Its só funny that all the comments here about her 'not good yet' technique and how bad she was come from people that can't even sing a proper amarilli.... Sad people.
I agree I don't think this is as late as 1999. I saw Anna in War & Peace in 2000 and her technique was a great deal more polished than this. Better colouring better phrasing better all round interpretation. I would say it is while she was at the conservatoire or a concert very soon after that. Early 90s or thereabouts. But she has come a very long way since then!!!
ESTA ARIA ES LA QUE MÁS ME GUSTA DE RIGOLETTO. ME GUSTÓ DESDE LA PRIMERA VEZ QUE LA ESCUCHÉ EN UN CD DE COLECCIÓN. ME GUSTA MÁS QUE LA DONNA E MOBILE. ES PARA SENTIRLA CON LOS OJOS CERRADOS Y DEJARSE LLEVAR POR EL PODER DE LA MÚSICA QUE DESPIERTA TANTAS EMOCIONES Y SON CAPACES DE MOVERTE.
It seems to me the the date is wrong. It must be 89 instead. If you look at the il barbiere from 1996 you'll see at that time she already had the look, the smile, the swing, the freedom of scene movements that we saw later, that made her unique and a superstar.
In 1989 Anna was 18 and not yet studying at the conservatory. This video doesn't look like 1999, I think it is the time of her 2 or 3 course of the conservatory, 1992 or 1993.
Gorgeous of course, but amazing to see how far she's come! I'm sure if she watched this again she would cringe, I hate seeing early videos of my performances!
I highly doubt any opera singer would ever get a nose job as it would change the sound of their voice. I think the quality of this video is very poor hence the dark shadows on everyone's face and the hiss in the background. It's a pity as it is a beautiful performance.
I only partly agree with you. I do think that her voice will never be a real dramatic voice, so in my opinion lyric roles are the bests for her. Or maybe a bit more dramatic but definitely not a real dramatic. Anna is a high soprano , not a coloratura, and she knows it and doesnot say that she is a coloratura she actually said that she is a lyrics soprano.
There is no such thing as "high soprano", either coloratura or lyric or spinto or dramatic. She's really a coloratura not a lyric soprano. She just needs to develop her techniques more as a coloratura. There are a lot of great coloraturas in history.
@@dttra566 Yeah she sounds here coloratura. Later in her Career she sounds Lyric but never Dramatic. Many coloraturas develop into full lyric voices. I think it is her case and maybe Lisette Oropesa will also become full lyric with time.
I see they let her shamelessly skip the trills. I'm surprised the audience didn't boo her off the stage, but then again audiences are complicit in the decline of singing the score.
Wow, she was very young here right? She didn't have the coquettish-ness that overtook her later on LOL...and she looks so naive and um...un-tried...but Maria Callas had that sexy depth to her voice BUT Anna has Callas beat in being Sexy...especially what Anna wears at her concerts...
I love how her voice has darkened and become more dramatic. But I came here after listening to Luisa Tetrazinni and wow! I know its bad to compare, but Luisa caught Gilda's girlish innocence and infatuation like a struggling little bird and held it in her hand. Here we have a mature woman in love who knows the meaning of passion. These are very different sentiments.
SOBRE TODO EN LOS BAJOS, PERO CREO QUE ES UN TEMA DE AIRE, DE TODOS MODOS SE VE QUE ESTO ES CUANDO ERA MUY JOVEN. AHORA REALMENTE ME GUSTA Y MUCHO , TODOS MEJORAN CON EL TIEMPO OBVIO SE PREOCUPAN EN ESTUDIAR Y LLEGAR A SU EXCELENCIA.
Sad to see her push her lyric instrument into the dramatic repertoire where it doesn't belong. And she was so pretty. She's still pretty but much more zaftig.
I heard Ann Netrebko sing this at the Kennedy Center in 1999, and here voice was so exquisite that the whole audience was mesmerized. It was the most beautiful sound I ever heard in my life. I have been a fan of hers ever since. This is just a particularly bad quality recording.
Sorry, she already sings false !
Yes! it's !
grandisimo documento de una jovencisima Anna Netrebko de 28 años.
Beautiful voice. Very well suited and well performed. Very nice and heartful interpretation!
What a fascinating artifact. Incredible how her voice has changed.
regulargonzalez she is now playing pretend
regulargonzalez She is depressing her larynx to artificially darken her tone and has thus developed a wobble. She is bowing roles meant for a much heavier voice. She has completely destroyed her voice. She sounds terrible now. Very sad.
Only for the worse. Today she is a parody of an opera singer. And her husbsnd is yet worse.
She was very young then, but very good.
Yes indeed. Lots of potential. Now she is one of my favourites
Anna is as radiant as the Sun!!!!!!!!!!!!
She looks so lovely❤
she had more agility here than now.... beatiful
Fantasztikus érett nagy énekes lett belőle!
Her voice is very beatiful and she too.
Красота! Совершенство! Спасибо за видеозапись!!!
Her sound is much more pleasant here than it is now.
Not sure if anyone cares but if you're bored like me atm you can stream all of the latest movies and series on InstaFlixxer. I've been watching with my girlfriend for the last couple of weeks =)
@Gerald Elisha Definitely, been watching on instaflixxer for years myself :)
@Gerald Elisha definitely, have been watching on instaflixxer for months myself =)
Phenomenal!!!
After Anna Bolena, her Adina in the Elixir of Love at the Met last year was a disappointment, although in large part due to the atrocious production. This year, however, she is ROCKING Eugene Onegin. It's a stellar production with an exeptional cast. Netreboko, Marius Kwiecen and Paul Beczala. Fantastic. She absolutely dominates, and her voice is right where it should be.
Adorable and lovely singing.
La más grande. Muchas gracias
I MUST SAY I AM SURPRISED.
INOLVIDABLE
она в 28 выглядела на 18))))
her Gilda is good, young and fresh voice. especially if you compare this to various rigolettos you can hear now at met and in Europe, where stages are occupied by old "coloratura" chickens who lost their voices (if had any) many years ago
I think if you listened to Tetrazinni you would be happy with what you hear.
BRAVA❗️❤️
Yes, her voice was much lighter and easier, her technic is way better now, but in spite of that I always get the feeling that she sang more easily with this lighter technic. Sometimes I feel as if she put too much emphasis on the size of her voice. Not always but sometimes. Btw I do like her :)
Péter Bécs its because it’s her real voice lol
Think how young she is here. She's still learning, honing her technique, singing with a young instrument. Give her a break! The voice is gorgeous no matter what.
Yes changed, not only with age, but also technical.
The middle register is now more, much more darker!
Using chest voice to colour the upper register.
Must say I love the light soprano here.
Lovely!
I really like this one.
чистый как ручек!!!Браво!!!
why does 99 look like 1856 in color^^
Solarstorm HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA YES
Because that is Russia
This is so interesting! Good to see her at a less refined state than she is now, and really appreciate more where she's come. Not saying this isn't beautiful!!
she was backing vocals demis roussos in 1991
Anna, dalle CAPRE italiane come questa, ogni giudizio è un complimento! :-D
Анна совершенство! Дива.
awesome
Удивительный голос, покоряющий и заставляющий забыть всё и себя самого, пока он звучит. После такого исполнения хочется кричать "Браво" и крушить всё вокруг )
Сергей Баранов здесь она очень "сырая" нет техники, дыхания, тонкости...
You are right. She has never described herself as a coloratura; she does sing the lyric repertoire beautifully and her high notes are thrilling, especially as she has aged. Dramatic rep. she has been attempting is too big for her, and is not good for her voice. She is a terrific actress, and I imagine she longs to sing the dramatic roles for that reason. Still, it's too much for her voice, and she loses that lovely brilliance and velvet of her sound when she tries to make her voice 'bigger.'
I actually like her voice a lot here. It is cleaner than it is now...sounds like Callas almost!
Каллос легко пела, эта натянуто.Голос красивый был, но до Каллос ей, как до луны.
I agree so much with you!
Ахххх..Какая прелесть :)
Совсем юная))
Koshandia )) не совсем. 28 лет - уже не юность)
@@Cantodivino но для начала мирового триумфа нормально.
@Phantess
Anna Yuryevna Netrebko (Russian: Анна Юрьевна Нетребко,
born 18 September 1971)
so in 1999 she was either 27 or 28.
BTW Yuryevna is her patronymic - meaning daughter of her father Yury.
Love this very much! She is getting even ever better with age!
Its só funny that all the comments here about her 'not good yet' technique and how bad she was come from people that can't even sing a proper amarilli.... Sad people.
She sounds beautiful to me! looks beautiful too!!
Как по мне она здесь поет даже лучше чем на многих современных записях.
her technique is much worse now actually, she’s developed a wobble and has a lot of tongue tension
This is a very difficult song.
It's called an aria!
Right!👍
Когда то прекрасно пела!!
Wow you can see why she became such a star!
ESPLENDIDA
Always a little bit off the pitch, very slightly lower than what each note should sound....
Una dolcezza infinita🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Oh my God how was she so slim! And a nice fresh voice! :)
I agree I don't think this is as late as 1999. I saw Anna in War & Peace in 2000 and her technique was a great deal more polished than this. Better colouring better phrasing better all round interpretation. I would say it is while she was at the conservatoire or a concert very soon after that. Early 90s or thereabouts. But she has come a very long way since then!!!
and i think she darkens her voice a little bit now that is why it doesnt sound that light than here
She was younger, it's just a normal evolution
ESTA ARIA ES LA QUE MÁS ME GUSTA DE RIGOLETTO. ME GUSTÓ DESDE LA PRIMERA VEZ QUE LA ESCUCHÉ EN UN CD DE COLECCIÓN. ME GUSTA MÁS QUE LA DONNA E MOBILE. ES PARA SENTIRLA CON LOS OJOS CERRADOS Y DEJARSE LLEVAR POR EL PODER DE LA MÚSICA QUE DESPIERTA TANTAS EMOCIONES Y SON CAPACES DE MOVERTE.
Before she went full blown constricted. What potential ... Wasted.
It seems to me the the date is wrong. It must be 89 instead. If you look at the il barbiere from 1996 you'll see at that time she already had the look, the smile, the swing, the freedom of scene movements that we saw later, that made her unique and a superstar.
Here, Anna does not know yet that she is already great.
I agree, but she is still amazing!
In 1989 Anna was 18 and not yet studying at the conservatory. This video doesn't look like 1999, I think it is the time of her 2 or 3 course of the conservatory, 1992 or 1993.
She is superb...my favourite opera singer.....and at this time she was beggining....
Как же я ее обожаю!))
Ela é Anna Netrebko. ...e vocês críticos destrutivos. ...são o que mesmo ??
Si. si. si, si, si, SIiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!
👏👏👏🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀
Gorgeous of course, but amazing to see how far she's come! I'm sure if she watched this again she would cringe, I hate seeing early videos of my performances!
Dunno. Bet she has every video of herself, for on tap consultations.
stfu
как интересно какая запись ценная,не хватает озороства!
SE QUEDA SIN AIRE EN LOS FINALES¡
Siempre canto bien Anna..
Maravillosa!!!!!
Her noize 's changed...
El que se queda sin aire,casi sin aliento,soy yo de oir a ésta diva del bel-canto.
Voice beautiful but background hiss terrible. Sorry!
I highly doubt any opera singer would ever get a nose job as it would change the sound of their voice. I think the quality of this video is very poor hence the dark shadows on everyone's face and the hiss in the background. It's a pity as it is a beautiful performance.
Volcshebniza, charodeika, oslepitelyno velikolepna...
那时候好瘦啊😁😁😁😘
Звезда первой величины!!! Счастья Вам, Анна Юрьевна!!!!!!!
1aa
Когда то была...
I only partly agree with you. I do think that her voice will never be a real dramatic voice, so in my opinion lyric roles are the bests for her. Or maybe a bit more dramatic but definitely not a real dramatic. Anna is a high soprano , not a coloratura, and she knows it and doesnot say that she is a coloratura she actually said that she is a lyrics soprano.
There is no such thing as "high soprano", either coloratura or lyric or spinto or dramatic. She's really a coloratura not a lyric soprano. She just needs to develop her techniques more as a coloratura. There are a lot of great coloraturas in history.
@@dttra566 Yeah she sounds here coloratura. Later in her Career she sounds Lyric but never Dramatic. Many coloraturas develop into full lyric voices. I think it is her case and maybe Lisette Oropesa will also become full lyric with time.
How old was she in this recording? Love this!
I see they let her shamelessly skip the trills. I'm surprised the audience didn't boo her off the stage, but then again audiences are complicit in the decline of singing the score.
Yes, yes, yes, yes, YES!!
Anna, what happened?
She is only 28!
A MI SI Y SOY TAN PUBLICO COMO LOS DEMAS, DE TODOS MODOS DUERMO BIEN, JEJEJ¡
She is right from the beginning of career a Great Soprano!!!!!!!I love you ear Anna...
en dónde? me da curiosidad saber, ya que yo no tengo muy buen oído
Wow, she was very young here right? She didn't have the coquettish-ness that overtook her later on LOL...and she looks so naive and um...un-tried...but Maria Callas had that sexy depth to her voice BUT Anna has Callas beat in being Sexy...especially what Anna wears at her concerts...
Digamos que Anna Netrebko es muy conocida por tener poco fiato... eso todos lo saben
yes, I agree, that would be more logical.
Magnífica
No parece importarle mucho al público!
Очень богатый голос!!!
but at least to me, not as stable as now. Her support is way stronger now
haha you must be joking
wtf
This can't be 1999... she is a lot younger here!
γεια σου μαιρουλα σχολιαστρια! χαχα
Γεια σου, Ελισαβετακι !!!
why?
ha ha, shes cute funny to se how the woman develop by time
me encanto
I love how her voice has darkened and become more dramatic. But I came here after listening to Luisa Tetrazinni and wow! I know its bad to compare, but Luisa caught Gilda's girlish innocence and infatuation like a struggling little bird and held it in her hand. Here we have a mature woman in love who knows the meaning of passion. These are very different sentiments.
SOBRE TODO EN LOS BAJOS, PERO CREO QUE ES UN TEMA DE AIRE, DE TODOS MODOS SE VE QUE ESTO ES CUANDO ERA MUY JOVEN. AHORA REALMENTE ME GUSTA Y MUCHO , TODOS MEJORAN CON EL TIEMPO OBVIO SE PREOCUPAN EN ESTUDIAR Y LLEGAR A SU EXCELENCIA.
Mejoró?
...
Although technically this was a bad recording, her voice reminds me of Maria Callas.
Beautiful sound.
I was surprised at the amount of movement in the upper chest in those first few phrases. Is that really normal (healthy?)? 1:35
NO HACE LOS STACATTOS SINO LEGATOS QUE SON MAS FACILES ¡
Listen carefully to the top notes at 2'57" and 3.26" - all else is perfection
her staccati are anything but perfection
Sad to see her push her lyric instrument into the dramatic repertoire where it doesn't belong. And she was so pretty. She's still pretty but much more zaftig.
да ладно, ей тут 28 лет?