I'm also a student from the University of Dhaka and have actively participated in the movement and revolution. But sorry to say this guy you brought is either spreading misinformation intentionally or he has very little knowledge about our history. For example, he doesn't know about the ruling period of Gen. Ziaur Rahman and Gen. Hussain Md. Ershad. While Zia got very little time. Ershad ruled for almost 9 years as a military ruler. Like this in the whole podcast, there are several misinformation. So be aware!!!
yep i actually commented fixing few mistakes, i can not believe he is a du student, he also did not mention coordinators in compromising role, army officer meeting role, how on 1/2/3 July we bravely came out on street. He also failed to portray political mess and timings completely
I think this podcast was amazing. Especially because it came first hand from someone who could narrate the raw emotions of Bangladeshi youth. Everyone bashing on the comments didn't understand the actual meaning of inviting a guest like this.
I am 25 years old, and I am ashamed of myself seeing this 22 year old being so sensible and emotional for his countrymen. There are 5 key differences Pakistan has with Bangladesh that will put Pakistan in more and more vulnerable position in the future. 1. Youth in Pakistan is not well integrated and organized as I find in Bangladesh. 2. Army is not playing the role Bangladeshi army had played on 5 August. 3. The junior ranks of of Pak Army are not brave enough, and did not turn down orders to shoot civilians. 4. The movement in Pakistan is not leaderless. Army has deduced ways to manipulate and control the leadership thus controlling the movement. 5. Pakistan is not home to one large ethnicity, rather a number of ethnicities live here. There is very little organization among these ethnicities thus reducing the momentum of the movement by turning it a movement of only the pushtuns but this is very dangerous. I hope and pray for a miracle....
Ow, really! Pakistan was so naive 1971? 😂😂 Recently, Awami League has done wrong deed, that doesn’t justifies the killing of 2 to 3 Million Bengali by Pakistan army.
The total death toll on Bangladesh in 71 as per international and neutral sources is around 3 Lacs (not 3 million) and this also includes over 1 lac non bengalis killed by mukti bahini and have been proven. No doubt atrocities were committed by the army but it was not a one way rhing
We as pakistani respect him but he has very limited knowledge of history and other issues... It would be better to invite a professor or expert to discuss these sensitive issues
he didn't express it properly ... pls. contact some private university student who can explain nicely in English ... he miss lot of thing.. love & respect from Bangladesh
His English was okay. I don't think there is any issues in his English. He lacks in knowledge . To make it public vs private is such a cheap stunt. Bro grow up.
I'm not a very emotional or patriotic guy. But seeing Mamunur brother shed tears remembering our independence made me respect him. May Allah reward him for his good deeds ❤️
Obviously Pakistan was the villain during 1947 to 1971. There is no question about that. They did genocide, discriminations in all aspects, killings, dictatorship, no democracy etc. That was a failed state overall. They forgot to recognize the power of Bangali people.
Why many people are talking bad about him. I am a 19 year's old girl from Bangladesh. When he was crying i also got emotional, the general students are really angry and frustrated during protest, and he is a student of Dhaka University so he saw the revolution closely.
Many people will say our 🇧🇩 army general waqar zaman helped our protesters to kicked hasina's ass, yes he helped but there is twist...... Large number of army general/Major/senior Officer was pro hasina and they wanted to keep hasina but there was Threat from junior officers and soldiers, they said they will go Against their officer and risk their life for the country! So waqar zaman didn’t want internal conflict within army and he know how brutal it would be! So dont help hasina! But my question is where is the this level of Pakistani army officials who can help Pakistan to free from these army Mafia! How it is possible that entire army organisation is destroying Pakistan! Why not someone came from Pakistan army and save this country!
Pakistan can not have a revolution like Bangladesh due to many factors, one big is the army junior personal unquestioned loyalty to their officer, our army never had 2 factions who play for power like Bangladesh our army has been one selfish unit.
@@SyedArfatMahi hey bangali bro ... Paki non sense log samjhty hein k hmara mulk bhi bangladesh bun jaye ga ...in logon ko btao k bangladesh mein students revolt tha na k elections ....
He actually made many mistakes here, saying as Bangladeshi. Aim this should be showing proof, facts not making Hasina villain only. So let me start: Mujib made a one-party state, avoiding the multiparty democracy sentiment of 1971. He was killed (external international powers played a role). By luck, Zia came to power. He handled everything okay but killed and jailed many. He was a patriot and made effective steps that directly improved the economy. Then he understood that without democracy, he would lose power, so he created BNP. The 1979 election happened, which was a yes/no vote (odd election), and he won. After it, controversy started, so to create a mess in Awami League (main opposition), he let Hasina enter Bangladesh from India and take Awami leadership around 1980/81. After Hasina came, she, India, and a few greedy generals planned to kill Zia. He was killed in Circuit House, Chittagong. But as he was very popular, the killers could not hold power. Zia's close ally and secretly India's backed Ershad came to power. Ershad also made economic improvements more than Zia, but he was a controversial character. As BNP led by Khaleda Zia (wife of Zia) and Awami League led by Hasina (daughter of Mujib) protested, after 9 years, Ershad lost power. (Actually, students removed Ershad, but these students were led by political party student wings.) Fair elections happened, and BNP won. Then again, election time came. Awami League understood fair elections might not happen under BNP (they demanded an interim government). Jamaat helped and supported Awami League in this (ironically). In 1996, Awami League won. After that, another election happened, and BNP won.
This time, Khaleda's son Tarique (now the main candidate for PM) did huge corruption and made a big mess. BNP failed to bring control in anything (Awami League is a hard political opposition to deal with, always protesting). So again, after a lot of protests, as Khaleda denied giving power to an interim government, a few brave army officers came forward and arrested both political party leaders, did a few reforms, and in 2009 elections were held. People were very unhappy with BNP, and Awami League gave a lot of blood (there were grenade attacks, killing of Awami leaders, etc., also Hasina portrayed herself as a better leader). She won with a huge majority, and alas, the mess started again. First, Hasina, backed by India, targeted the army and made a coup by BDR (border guard soldiers) and killed them. People saw it as a coup by junior soldiers. Then the steamroller started on BNP; many leaders were arrested. They protested a lot, but nothing happened. During this time, the economy started improving for the first time in history; there was no food shortage in Bangladesh, so civil society supported Hasina. Hasina now targeted Jamaat leaders, blaming many of them for supporting Pakistan and directly participating in genocide (it was true, but many of them were innocent or forgiven by Mujib, or the court failed to prove it, but the court still gave hanging orders due to so-called public pressure (Gonojagoron Moncho, a protest). To counter it, Jamaat called for protests under the Hefazat banner, claiming Islam was being targeted. Clashes between party workers happened in Dhaka. Then the Hefazat killing happened, the first mass killing by the government. In one night, many were killed as they were Islamists. The army supported Hasina, and she got away with it. Then elections happened. BNP demanded an interim government, Awami League did not agree. India intervened and made Ershad agree to participate. Awami League won. After that, Awami League became the most powerful entity; all political parties failed in front of them.
After this the monster hasian and her big brothere regime came where people wer abducted, killed, court ruling changed over night , made mujib god like figure country filled with statues of him . Anyone speaking against any wrong became against 1971 war and anti national
Many people from Bihar (India) who migrated to east Pakistan in 1947 are stranded in Bangladesh since 1971. They were no accepted by Pakistan nor Bangaldeshi have them any rights!! You need to do a complete program on this topic to enlighten all about the reality and let people know the amount of sacrifice Biharis have done for independence in 1947.
This is not true Two days ago I visited the bihari residents in Mirpur and i asked many of them if they consider themselves Bangladeshi. They were like we live in Bangladesh for many so long but we are Biharis, they were not admitting to be Bangladeshi but surprisingly most of them have National identity card of Bangladesh but still they themselves do not consider to be Bangladeshi but would call themselves Pakistani Biharis. In this situation the Government of Bangladesh can't help.
@@rodelaa9196 It's a big injustice that happened with them, they should be brought back to their own country asap.if the still willing to accept Pakistani citizenship.
Finally some one is smart enough to think about bringing people from Bangladesh too. Great initiative. This will eventually help bring both countries on better terms. I will take a lot of time but i can work
Very Insightful Episode. Huge respect for the guest and Bangladeshi students ❤ Would love to hear more from guest and how we can improve relationships between Pakistan and Bangladesh.
All respect to Bangladesh. They put foundation of PAK. NAWAB SALEEM ULLAH OF DACCA did it. There had been no Bangladesh had there no Pak. Bangladeshi ae more devoted and sensible and smart. May they progress and acheive all glory.
Though he misses a lot of major events of this protest but still can't stop my tears from remembering those hard days. We were so happy not only individually but also as a nation, by our freedom from fascist dictator killer Hasina.
what a waste of time. You are asking a 22 year old about bengaly history which he cant really describe correctly (No blame to him) but this basic knowledge is publicly available and Muzamil did the interview doing absolutely no homwork of any history at all.
Very intelligent young boy of Bangladesh. Well done keep it up. It started from Agartala and ended up in Agartala. BD is a Muslim country with more than ninety six percent Muslims and not secular.
Do you mean that the oppression by Pakistan was wrong? We believe that whatever the Pakistan Army did, we can't blame the mass people for it. But whatever they did, it's true.Though india played a major role to divide us. You can't deny that a genocide happened by them and Pakistan should apologize for it.
Muzammil Bhai , I request you to create a video on India's obsession with Pakistan. Please watch their recent on Jaipur dialogues (it is an Indian nationalist channel) , they say that Pakistan will soon disintegrate and the people will migrate to India instead of Afghanistan or Iran etc. They've been talking a lot of bs that we would have to put refugee camps and then they'll have to enter Pak etc etc. Also in pasg few months we saw how every Bharati UA-camr is obsessing with Pakistan. Like for God's sake can't they concentrate on their own country, people and leave us alone!!!!
Dear it's not obsession. Actually Pak Army is controlling everything in Pakistan, rest of the people became there entity. Pakistan is moving towards civil. If civil war happens definitely people will migrate to India because they understand each other language and culture rather than Iran or Afghanistan.
@@HaidarAli-n4z the refugee crisis will only happen if there is a power struggle between two powerful people and the public is collateral damage. In Pakistan, it is the army vs 250M+ people. Even if there was a refugee crisis, there is a thick border which is guarded by BSF. Who will let the refugees in? Also, if you know anything about the realities on ground in Sindh and Punjab, you would assume people are already trying to become refugees. Each people have their own battle to fight.
The guest was around 80% correct on the history side. Also the Army chief IS NOT HASINA RELATIVE....His father in law was. General Waqar is a hero of the nation and thought about his responsibilities ie to serve the people first and then the politicians afterwards. Without him the Awami scum would still be here now.
Hussain Muhammad Ershad February 1930 - 14 July 2019) was a Bangladeshi military officer and politician who served as the president of Bangladesh from 1982 to 1990
Great Initiative but Bangladesh young student was not able explain well the history and political system in Bangladesh. I guess you should invite someone academic or political analyst.
Another video comparing Moon with Sun .😂 Bangladesh student movement was not about vote or politics or for any leader. It was about food and employment which Hasina imposed by selecting her cronies in Govt . Around a Million of graduates in Bangladesh are facing unemployment. Govt jobs were the only options because the private sector was also corrupted through legals. No legals no jobs. But then Hasina imposed 46% quota which benefits less than 1% of population. And they were Awami league supporter families . To add on these there was huge scum on selection of freedom fighters. Awami local goons who was not even born after 1971 was made freedom fighters.This FF guy's grandsons were also getting quotes . Plz stop this nonsense. In Bangladesh 14 jamat leaders were hung in fake trials and Main Opposition party leader Khaleda(ex-Pm) was in jail for 6 years . People didn't even spit on those issues . 😀
Mamunur Rashid, the guest, was fascinating and he addressed many of the queries during the discussion, and I found his conversational style engaging and promising as an emerging one. However, while his enthusiasm was evident, his responses sometimes came across as overly cursory and lacked depth. Although his presence in the protest provided valuable firsthand experiences, there was some lack of insight. Specifically, the timeline and key events of the protest were not articulated properly. Also, at Chittagong University, Students did not throw chatra league cadres from the roof. Being employed by the fallen ruling government, they entered the multi-storey student dormitory to assault general students. However, the students outnumbered the cadres and retaliated them. As a result, some of the cadres retreated to the rooftop. Trapped with no clear way to escape, being anxious, some of them attempted to climb down the building, which was nearly impossible to do. Unfortunately, in the chaos, several slipped and fell due to the lack of proper means to descend.
Ok But why hindu targeted..... Why hindu teacher forcefully expelled in school and college.. Why raped hindu women ..... Why hindu property fired..... Hypocrisy
Speaking moderate English doesn't necessarily justify this lad to be the right person to critically narrate the history of Bangladesh. This lad merely has a political prudency, starting with the statement, "Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib tried his best to develop the country", which is a sheer misinformation. On a side note, he is calling the dictator Sheikh Mujib as "Banga bondhu (Friend of Bengal), which has always been controversial. Request to the anchor, please bring someone more prudent, politically enlightened person if you do a podcast on Bangladesh in future.
This was great. Can you also get someone from India - even a BJP supporter. Just to understand their point of view. More important to have dialogue - especially amongst younger gen - between South Asian nations
Let me tell you that Bangladesh invested in education and women empowerment unlike Pakistan, which is still not a stable country and failed to invest in human development.
How can the BD young lot forget Pakistani Muslims our elders have fought for independence from British and Hindus together Bangales of India leading. Those responsible for the separation and break up of two wings of Pakistan were 1. Bhotoo 2. Mujib 3.Gen Yahya khan and Indra Ghandi as India was looking for a chance to weeken the Muslims in sub continent and we give them the opportunity to do so. Now the BD people should build up their fighting forces which India along with Hasenna never allowed. Secondly they should quickly get hold of some sort of nuclear technically for hard times to come from India.BD Zindabad.God bless them.
I don't like the way mamun talk about the history. Generally he served the Indian way, Pakistan was the first country that gave us independence from the British. The British period is most cruel. The way he is respecting sheikh mujib, is suspicious. In 50 years what Bd is achieved is very small. Not in economics, not in military power, not in education. Not in infrastructure. For the betterment of Bangladesh, we need a leader of great vision, we have gotten that kind of leadership many times in past years. But the cause is whenever our country gets the right path India stands in the way. If Bd developed much more than India in south Asia their colonial states desire for independence will increase. And hard possibly they can join us. Mamun talks is rubbish. I think he feared his life. Talking about India's aggression is still fearful in Bangladesh. The better example of this is Abrar Fahad. He gave his life, for a Facebook post that serves Bangladesh interest in river and fish and port and so on. We want a great friendship with Pakistan. Pakistani Muslims are our only true brothers in south Asia. Indians are uncivilized. Love you guys from Bangladesh 🇧🇩 Pakistan Bangladesh zindabad 🇧🇩 🥇 🇵🇰
@@HalJordan661 He is at the lower tier for an "Average" Bangladeshi student. He missed 70 percent of the details and couldn't explain the whole thing properly. He might be great in other topics but yeah, I don't think he is a good guest to represent this issue as an "Average" citizen.
Muzmil I have watched full video my suggestion is to share the revolution part only on your social channels its very important and interesting part. I believe, it is very motivational part as well. First part is not that much important which is the history and its very much boring I guess! Share the discussion part of election 2018 and onward. Thanks
Not the same it was not a political movement. Or for any leader . It was for quotas . Where fake freedom fighters were getting govt jobs and their grandsons but after studying hard for 20 years you were discriminated .In 2012 Hasina killed 14 jamat leaders for 1971 which was a fake trial . Took their business and lands but no one spit on those issues.
Most people didn't even believe Bangladesh revolution is inspired from pakistan Pakistan is first who crushed israeli product imramdu and then Bangladesh crushed Indian product haseena sheikh😂
Army directly shot at people multiple times just like Syria during the first phase of the protest. There are many videos. Army just stopped supporting Hasina during the final phase when they saw the protest is unstoppable. Sane like Egyptian army during the protest against Hosni Mobarak. And the BGB is also commanded by army officers same like Rangers & FC. They also killed so many people.
I'm also a student from the University of Dhaka and have actively participated in the movement and revolution. But sorry to say this guy you brought is either spreading misinformation intentionally or he has very little knowledge about our history.
For example, he doesn't know about the ruling period of Gen. Ziaur Rahman and Gen. Hussain Md. Ershad. While Zia got very little time. Ershad ruled for almost 9 years as a military ruler.
Like this in the whole podcast, there are several misinformation. So be aware!!!
yep i actually commented fixing few mistakes, i can not believe he is a du student, he also did not mention coordinators in compromising role, army officer meeting role, how on 1/2/3 July we bravely came out on street. He also failed to portray political mess and timings completely
Lack of knowledge
Thanks for letting us know
I think this podcast was amazing. Especially because it came first hand from someone who could narrate the raw emotions of Bangladeshi youth. Everyone bashing on the comments didn't understand the actual meaning of inviting a guest like this.
I am 25 years old, and I am ashamed of myself seeing this 22 year old being so sensible and emotional for his countrymen.
There are 5 key differences Pakistan has with Bangladesh that will put Pakistan in more and more vulnerable position in the future.
1. Youth in Pakistan is not well integrated and organized as I find in Bangladesh.
2. Army is not playing the role Bangladeshi army had played on 5 August.
3. The junior ranks of of Pak Army are not brave enough, and did not turn down orders to shoot civilians.
4. The movement in Pakistan is not leaderless. Army has deduced ways to manipulate and control the leadership thus controlling the movement.
5. Pakistan is not home to one large ethnicity, rather a number of ethnicities live here. There is very little organization among these ethnicities thus reducing the momentum of the movement by turning it a movement of only the pushtuns but this is very dangerous.
I hope and pray for a miracle....
As you sow, so shall you reap'.
Ow, really! Pakistan was so naive 1971? 😂😂 Recently, Awami League has done wrong deed, that doesn’t justifies the killing of 2 to 3 Million Bengali by Pakistan army.
The total death toll on Bangladesh in 71 as per international and neutral sources is around 3 Lacs (not 3 million) and this also includes over 1 lac non bengalis killed by mukti bahini and have been proven. No doubt atrocities were committed by the army but it was not a one way rhing
@@msr7373 yeah
Wrong deed? That's a massacre
You seem to he naive too to BAL. Calling a massacre just a wrong deed
Congestion. You proved yourself a modern Genocide supporter!
We as pakistani respect him but he has very limited knowledge of history and other issues... It would be better to invite a professor or expert to discuss these sensitive issues
Invite professor Shahid uzz zaman
True
He represents the average Bangladeshi student. I think thats the point lf it
Professors didn’t lead the Movement. These limited knowledgeable students did it.
He is the right person...he represent average students
Awami league massacre in 2024 is same a Pakistan one in 1971. I don't know why this Student is being a Pro Pakistani
he didn't express it properly ... pls. contact some private university student who can explain nicely in English ... he miss lot of thing..
love & respect from Bangladesh
English is not an issue bro....Any publican can narrate better than that one of private
His English was okay. I don't think there is any issues in his English. He lacks in knowledge . To make it public vs private is such a cheap stunt. Bro grow up.
I'm not a very emotional or patriotic guy. But seeing Mamunur brother shed tears remembering our independence made me respect him.
May Allah reward him for his good deeds ❤️
Obviously Pakistan was the villain during 1947 to 1971. There is no question about that. They did genocide, discriminations in all aspects, killings, dictatorship, no democracy etc. That was a failed state overall. They forgot to recognize the power of Bangali people.
one thing u have missed
What was the reaction of India during these protests, etc
Why many people are talking bad about him. I am a 19 year's old girl from Bangladesh. When he was crying i also got emotional, the general students are really angry and frustrated during protest, and he is a student of Dhaka University so he saw the revolution closely.
Love for mamun fom Pakistani, I haven't missed single second of this podcast. Hats off to you bangla students.
Ziaur Rahman was killed in a Military Coup in May 1981 (1977-1981).
So many historians are here in Bangladesh.... Next time invite a Professor
Hasina Was indian Agent.. It's Shame For Us.., Good Job Pakistani Brothers... Love Frm Bangladesh... 🇧🇩🇧🇩❤️
Now you got an American agent Yunus.😂❤😅
@@Jayz-oq9ubbetter then being under India
@@Jayz-oq9ubbetter then Being under India
@@Jayz-oq9ubbetter then India
Many people will say our 🇧🇩 army general waqar zaman helped our protesters to kicked hasina's ass, yes he helped but there is twist......
Large number of army general/Major/senior Officer was pro hasina and they wanted to keep hasina but there was Threat from junior officers and soldiers, they said they will go Against their officer and risk their life for the country! So waqar zaman didn’t want internal conflict within army and he know how brutal it would be! So dont help hasina!
But my question is where is the this level of Pakistani army officials who can help Pakistan to free from these army Mafia!
How it is possible that entire army organisation is destroying Pakistan!
Why not someone came from Pakistan army and save this country!
Pakistan can not have a revolution like Bangladesh due to many factors, one big is the army junior personal unquestioned loyalty to their officer, our army never had 2 factions who play for power like Bangladesh our army has been one selfish unit.
Love From Bangladesh ❤🇧🇩
Love from Pakistan ❤🇵🇰
@@SyedArfatMahi hey bangali bro ... Paki non sense log samjhty hein k hmara mulk bhi bangladesh bun jaye ga ...in logon ko btao k bangladesh mein students revolt tha na k elections ....
He actually made many mistakes here, saying as Bangladeshi. Aim this should be showing proof, facts not making Hasina villain only.
So let me start: Mujib made a one-party state, avoiding the multiparty democracy sentiment of 1971. He was killed (external international powers played a role). By luck, Zia came to power. He handled everything okay but killed and jailed many. He was a patriot and made effective steps that directly improved the economy. Then he understood that without democracy, he would lose power, so he created BNP. The 1979 election happened, which was a yes/no vote (odd election), and he won. After it, controversy started, so to create a mess in Awami League (main opposition), he let Hasina enter Bangladesh from India and take Awami leadership around 1980/81. After Hasina came, she, India, and a few greedy generals planned to kill Zia. He was killed in Circuit House, Chittagong. But as he was very popular, the killers could not hold power. Zia's close ally and secretly India's backed Ershad came to power.
Ershad also made economic improvements more than Zia, but he was a controversial character. As BNP led by Khaleda Zia (wife of Zia) and Awami League led by Hasina (daughter of Mujib) protested, after 9 years, Ershad lost power. (Actually, students removed Ershad, but these students were led by political party student wings.) Fair elections happened, and BNP won. Then again, election time came. Awami League understood fair elections might not happen under BNP (they demanded an interim government). Jamaat helped and supported Awami League in this (ironically). In 1996, Awami League won. After that, another election happened, and BNP won.
This time, Khaleda's son Tarique (now the main candidate for PM) did huge corruption and made a big mess. BNP failed to bring control in anything (Awami League is a hard political opposition to deal with, always protesting). So again, after a lot of protests, as Khaleda denied giving power to an interim government, a few brave army officers came forward and arrested both political party leaders, did a few reforms, and in 2009 elections were held. People were very unhappy with BNP, and Awami League gave a lot of blood (there were grenade attacks, killing of Awami leaders, etc., also Hasina portrayed herself as a better leader). She won with a huge majority, and alas, the mess started again. First, Hasina, backed by India, targeted the army and made a coup by BDR (border guard soldiers) and killed them. People saw it as a coup by junior soldiers. Then the steamroller started on BNP; many leaders were arrested. They protested a lot, but nothing happened. During this time, the economy started improving for the first time in history; there was no food shortage in Bangladesh, so civil society supported Hasina. Hasina now targeted Jamaat leaders, blaming many of them for supporting Pakistan and directly participating in genocide (it was true, but many of them were innocent or forgiven by Mujib, or the court failed to prove it, but the court still gave hanging orders due to so-called public pressure (Gonojagoron Moncho, a protest). To counter it, Jamaat called for protests under the Hefazat banner, claiming Islam was being targeted. Clashes between party workers happened in Dhaka. Then the Hefazat killing happened, the first mass killing by the government. In one night, many were killed as they were Islamists. The army supported Hasina, and she got away with it. Then elections happened. BNP demanded an interim government, Awami League did not agree. India intervened and made Ershad agree to participate. Awami League won. After that, Awami League became the most powerful entity; all political parties failed in front of them.
After this the monster hasian and her big brothere regime came where people wer abducted, killed, court ruling changed over night , made mujib god like figure country filled with statues of him . Anyone speaking against any wrong became against 1971 war and anti national
He is just a Razakar trying to explain our history to a Pakistani.
on point
Many people from Bihar (India) who migrated to east Pakistan in 1947 are stranded in Bangladesh since 1971. They were no accepted by Pakistan nor Bangaldeshi have them any rights!!
You need to do a complete program on this topic to enlighten all about the reality and let people know the amount of sacrifice Biharis have done for independence in 1947.
Biharis were offered Bangladeshi citizenship which they did not embraced and Pakistan doesn't want to take them. This is the fact.
@@fakrulislam1655 Oh "the poor immigrant is wrong" we have similar situation with Afghan immigrants
This is not true
Two days ago I visited the bihari residents in Mirpur and i asked many of them if they consider themselves Bangladeshi. They were like we live in Bangladesh for many so long but we are Biharis, they were not admitting to be Bangladeshi but surprisingly most of them have National identity card of Bangladesh but still they themselves do not consider to be Bangladeshi but would call themselves Pakistani Biharis. In this situation the Government of Bangladesh can't help.
@@rodelaa9196
It's a big injustice that happened with them, they should be brought back to their own country asap.if the still willing to accept Pakistani citizenship.
Bihari didn’t recognise Bangladesh even pak After pak military surrender but Behari kept fighting Against freedom-fighters, They are devoted to pak...
Finally some one is smart enough to think about bringing people from Bangladesh too. Great initiative. This will eventually help bring both countries on better terms. I will take a lot of time but i can work
Very Insightful Episode.
Huge respect for the guest and Bangladeshi students ❤
Would love to hear more from guest and how we can improve relationships between Pakistan and Bangladesh.
Brilliant discussion. Thank you for narrating Bangladesh’s history so well.
Well i think As a young Man and students he did a great job
All respect to Bangladesh. They put foundation of PAK. NAWAB SALEEM ULLAH OF DACCA did it. There had been no Bangladesh had there no Pak. Bangladeshi ae more devoted and sensible and smart. May they progress and acheive all glory.
Though he misses a lot of major events of this protest but still can't stop my tears from remembering those hard days. We were so happy not only individually but also as a nation, by our freedom from fascist dictator killer Hasina.
what a waste of time. You are asking a 22 year old about bengaly history which he cant really describe correctly (No blame to him) but this basic knowledge is publicly available and Muzamil did the interview doing absolutely no homwork of any history at all.
Razakar trying to explain our history to a Pakistani.
22 years old knows more about Bangladesh than some Awami dalal
@@HalJordan661 who's awami dalal? sorry im old and not in touch with new words.
@@HalJordan661 Oh right!
Very intelligent young boy of Bangladesh. Well done keep it up. It started from Agartala and ended up in Agartala. BD is a Muslim country with more than ninety six percent Muslims and not secular.
Bangladesh is a secular country and i have many hindu and Buddist friend. We respect them they are also our brothers.
The chicken 🐔 is defending KFC 🍗
Hope it goes viral. We need such quality content 🎉
Thanks muzammil bhai.
Do you mean that the oppression by Pakistan was wrong? We believe that whatever the Pakistan Army did, we can't blame the mass people for it. But whatever they did, it's true.Though india played a major role to divide us. You can't deny that a genocide happened by them and Pakistan should apologize for it.
He is so naive. Get someone with more maturity who knows their history better and has better understanding of how dictatorships work in the world.
Pathetic to go with the word of a mediocre student of just twenty two years to learn the story of Bangladesh and its turbulent times.
That's a brilliant podcast. Very enlightening .. very relatable to the current situation in our country.
Great episode, what a inspiring story. Respect
Great Podcast. Next should be from Srilanka.
Muzammil Bhai , I request you to create a video on India's obsession with Pakistan. Please watch their recent on Jaipur dialogues (it is an Indian nationalist channel) , they say that Pakistan will soon disintegrate and the people will migrate to India instead of Afghanistan or Iran etc. They've been talking a lot of bs that we would have to put refugee camps and then they'll have to enter Pak etc etc. Also in pasg few months we saw how every Bharati UA-camr is obsessing with Pakistan. Like for God's sake can't they concentrate on their own country, people and leave us alone!!!!
Dear it's not obsession. Actually Pak Army is controlling everything in Pakistan, rest of the people became there entity. Pakistan is moving towards civil. If civil war happens definitely people will migrate to India because they understand each other language and culture rather than Iran or Afghanistan.
@@HaidarAli-n4z the refugee crisis will only happen if there is a power struggle between two powerful people and the public is collateral damage. In Pakistan, it is the army vs 250M+ people. Even if there was a refugee crisis, there is a thick border which is guarded by BSF. Who will let the refugees in?
Also, if you know anything about the realities on ground in Sindh and Punjab, you would assume people are already trying to become refugees. Each people have their own battle to fight.
Why Bangladehi run towards India?
@@HaidarAli-n4zlol it won't happen and on ground reality Pakistan is not going towards civil war
Love our Bangladeshi brothers ❤
Our bangladeshi brother is meetha ❤
🤣
dont say that he is our brother
Mamun you talk rubbish 😅
56:44 answer is Pakistan
❤️❤️
Dubai bhag kar Pakistan main revolution chahtay ho.
Kya yeh khula tazad nhi
He is not bhaga huwa, he visits Pakistan regularly.
@omsh505 did he tòok part in 9th may or recent protests .
The ones he is inciting or giving hope 2
App ya Podcast dykh rhy ho qk wo Dubai ha pakistan main Podcast upload hoty 2 din lagty 3-4gb ki
The guest was around 80% correct on the history side. Also the Army chief IS NOT HASINA RELATIVE....His father in law was. General Waqar is a hero of the nation and thought about his responsibilities ie to serve the people first and then the politicians afterwards. Without him the Awami scum would still be here now.
I am from Mumbai India. I appreciate yr channel.
Hussain Muhammad Ershad
February 1930 - 14 July 2019) was a Bangladeshi military officer and politician who served as the president of Bangladesh from 1982 to 1990
Timestamps are not properly marked for this video.
Great Initiative but Bangladesh young student was not able explain well the history and political system in Bangladesh. I guess you should invite someone academic or political analyst.
"we still don't have a survey of how many people died in the protest"
This is so true for Pakistan too.
Maybe you need to listen to your PTI leadership
@@taribkhan5468 they are not my leadership. Everyone's a tout at this point.
The brother os very sweet, but he is not an expert in this field. May he does great in future podcasts.
We love Bangladesh n love people of Bangladesh people aur brother ❤❤
he didn't explain it probably because of excitement 😭and i can't blame him.i am excited too
V love n respect Bangladesh n ppl of Bangladesh 🇧🇩, all good wishes for our brother country 🎉❤🙏
You ate doing a wonderful work bro🔥
This bangladeshi boy expkained very elegant way in detail setep by step ,he should write a book about suddnt led revolution in bangladesh
nah i don't think he did a good job to explain it..i am so disappointed:(
The discussion is not concluded. Please make another discussion session 🙏
Explained badly.
Another video comparing Moon with Sun .😂 Bangladesh student movement was not about vote or politics or for any leader. It was about food and employment which Hasina imposed by selecting her cronies in Govt . Around a Million of graduates in Bangladesh are facing unemployment. Govt jobs were the only options because the private sector was also corrupted through legals. No legals no jobs. But then Hasina imposed 46% quota which benefits less than 1% of population. And they were Awami league supporter families . To add on these there was huge scum on selection of freedom fighters. Awami local goons who was not even born after 1971 was made freedom fighters.This FF guy's grandsons were also getting quotes . Plz stop this nonsense. In Bangladesh 14 jamat leaders were hung in fake trials and Main Opposition party leader Khaleda(ex-Pm) was in jail for 6 years . People didn't even spit on those issues . 😀
@@GoodboyJawad exactly ...agreed bro
Mamunur Rashid, the guest, was fascinating and he addressed many of the queries during the discussion, and I found his conversational style engaging and promising as an emerging one. However, while his enthusiasm was evident, his responses sometimes came across as overly cursory and lacked depth.
Although his presence in the protest provided valuable firsthand experiences, there was some lack of insight. Specifically, the timeline and key events of the protest were not articulated properly. Also, at Chittagong University, Students did not throw chatra league cadres from the roof. Being employed by the fallen ruling government, they entered the multi-storey student dormitory to assault general students. However, the students outnumbered the cadres and retaliated them. As a result, some of the cadres retreated to the rooftop. Trapped with no clear way to escape, being anxious, some of them attempted to climb down the building, which was nearly impossible to do. Unfortunately, in the chaos, several slipped and fell due to the lack of proper means to descend.
Invite Prof Shahid Uz Zaman. May be you won't, it won't suit your narrative.
Average students know more about Bangladesh than so called expert
Muzamil Hasan SIR U ARE MY HERO,
Oh my Allah... He is so cringe in some extent... Couldn't you find anyone better from Bangladesh?
Bangladesh 🇧🇩 ❤ 🇵🇰 Pakistan...
Great nation Bangladesh
Dear Muzamal
This is one of the best episode.
Damn muzammil good job💯
What a surprise muzzamil....great...thanks JazakALLAH
Ok
But why hindu targeted.....
Why hindu teacher forcefully expelled in school and college..
Why raped hindu women .....
Why hindu property fired.....
Hypocrisy
Phir hum iok may atrocities Ka bolay tau roya mat Karo
please do video with Dhaka University Professor Shahiduz Zaman he is a famous personality and intellectual person
Looking forward for a followup.
Thank you
Speaking moderate English doesn't necessarily justify this lad to be the right person to critically narrate the history of Bangladesh. This lad merely has a political prudency, starting with the statement, "Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib tried his best to develop the country", which is a sheer misinformation. On a side note, he is calling the dictator Sheikh Mujib as "Banga bondhu (Friend of Bengal), which has always been controversial.
Request to the anchor, please bring someone more prudent, politically enlightened person if you do a podcast on Bangladesh in future.
This Bangladeshi boy is basically spitting stereotypes. But still good to know what the masses think.
This was great. Can you also get someone from India - even a BJP supporter. Just to understand their point of view. More important to have dialogue - especially amongst younger gen - between South Asian nations
Happy to see bengladehi brother
Loved it.
🇧🇩❤️🇵🇰 Say No To 🇮🇳❌.
Let me tell you that Bangladesh invested in education and women empowerment unlike Pakistan, which is still not a stable country and failed to invest in human development.
How can the BD young lot forget Pakistani Muslims our elders have fought for independence from British and Hindus together Bangales of India leading. Those responsible for the separation and break up of two wings of Pakistan were 1. Bhotoo 2. Mujib 3.Gen Yahya khan and Indra Ghandi as India was looking for a chance to weeken the Muslims in sub continent and we give them the opportunity to do so. Now the BD people should build up their fighting forces which India along with Hasenna never allowed. Secondly they should quickly get hold of some sort of nuclear technically for hard times to come from India.BD Zindabad.God bless them.
Alhamdulillah i am a part of this Movement
Razakar
@@User-4fbs-g6jme too but only for last 5 days
Overall pretty well, but missed sort of significant transitional period and moment. Also he was getting out of the exact question and point.
I don't like the way mamun talk about the history. Generally he served the Indian way, Pakistan was the first country that gave us independence from the British. The British period is most cruel. The way he is respecting sheikh mujib, is suspicious. In 50 years what Bd is achieved is very small. Not in economics, not in military power, not in education. Not in infrastructure. For the betterment of Bangladesh, we need a leader of great vision, we have gotten that kind of leadership many times in past years. But the cause is whenever our country gets the right path India stands in the way. If Bd developed much more than India in south Asia their colonial states desire for independence will increase. And hard possibly they can join us. Mamun talks is rubbish.
I think he feared his life. Talking about India's aggression is still fearful in Bangladesh. The better example of this is Abrar Fahad.
He gave his life, for a Facebook post that serves Bangladesh interest in river and fish and port and so on.
We want a great friendship with Pakistan. Pakistani Muslims are our only true brothers in south Asia. Indians are uncivilized. Love you guys from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Pakistan Bangladesh zindabad 🇧🇩 🥇 🇵🇰
He isn’t respecting Mujib...I think you missed the video
Not the perfect guest to learn about bangladesh, there are better people to learn from.
He represent average Bangladesh students...he knows more about Bangladesh than so called expert
@@HalJordan661 He is at the lower tier for an "Average" Bangladeshi student. He missed 70 percent of the details and couldn't explain the whole thing properly. He might be great in other topics but yeah, I don't think he is a good guest to represent this issue as an "Average" citizen.
@@tarek_khan He missed some major details I agree but overall his explanation was good
Good discussion
he is naive. Has no idea what will be implications in coming years.
Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️🇧🇩
🇧🇩💕🇵🇰
Well explained mamun
Part 2 will be more interesting. This one will also go long way.
It is funny how similar the situation is in Paksitan only difference students are not on the road.
Another clickbait banger from muzammil
You haven't asked how they will tackle Indian propaganda against the new government & 'endangered' Hindu minority?
Muzmil I have watched full video
my suggestion is to share the revolution part only on your social channels its very important and interesting part. I believe, it is very motivational part as well. First part is not that much important which is the history and its very much boring I guess!
Share the discussion part of election 2018 and onward.
Thanks
Same story in both Countries.
Not the same it was not a political movement. Or for any leader . It was for quotas . Where fake freedom fighters were getting govt jobs and their grandsons but after studying hard for 20 years you were discriminated .In 2012 Hasina killed 14 jamat leaders for 1971 which was a fake trial . Took their business and lands but no one spit on those issues.
56:44 Yes brother there is which is our country Pakistan 😢
Most people didn't even believe Bangladesh revolution is inspired from pakistan
Pakistan is first who crushed israeli product imramdu and then Bangladesh crushed Indian product haseena sheikh😂
*everything is true*
Army directly shot at people multiple times just like Syria during the first phase of the protest. There are many videos. Army just stopped supporting Hasina during the final phase when they saw the protest is unstoppable. Sane like Egyptian army during the protest against Hosni Mobarak. And the BGB is also commanded by army officers same like Rangers & FC. They also killed so many people.
LOVE..
We are Muslim Brother 🇧🇩❤🇵🇰
listening to the discussion it give me the impression of orchestrated revolution by the Bangladesh military.
Thanks mamun we Love you