@@somsuvramukherjee502 And how did you get the perception that I didn't understand the gravity of the situation. I am a judicial officer myself. So I don't think I exceeded the limits of my words in any manner.
@@somsuvramukherjee502 What does my experience have to do with the point I am trying to make? And are you on this side of the bench for more than 10 years? Well, I don't think I need to reply to someone who just comments something for the sake of commenting in order to garner attention or otherwise. What I commented was a genuine reply and it made sense, since the Hon'ble judge here was not at fault here. So I had to take his side. How can you drag contempt into this? Does protecting the bench when the bar was wrong, constitute contempt?
The Hon. Justice showed him his place and also moved on to the next matter inspite of the emotional tactics by a senior counsel carrying on and on. Hats off to the judge..... Hail Indian Judiciary
i have seen multiple cases of this judge. He is fair from a legal perspective and friendly, as far as I can see... It would take a special type of advoicate to agitate him.
This Honourable Judge is very hard working, with clear understanding of the law, apt in dispensation of justice⚖, great orator from his persona he seems to be. Stay blessed Honourable judge.
I will share one bitter experience of my first encounter with judiciary where in the Munsif Judge was unable to understand my petition for 8 years where as In Honourable High Court of jammu and Kashmir, I had challenged the forged Will Deed in which Honorable HC of jammu and Kashmir gave Three verdicts in my favour, in which Single Bench, Division Bench disposed of case in my Favour within two years time while as Musif judge was such a dumb person that he couldn't understand the Litigation.
Oh no, the munsif judge would have understood the petition but you didn't grease his palms. They are also in cahoots with the lawyers to squeeze both the parties. That is the prevailing system from Kashmir to Kanyakumari. -from Tamil Nadu.
It's the experience my man it's the experience. Experience comes with time and maybe it's possible that the lawyer has saw more cases than the judge as per their respective age. Not fighting nor I'm arguing just placing my view
This judge was purely in Sadhguru mode up until the Senior advocate turned him into Sunny Deol. Great to see these live sessions, gives a glimpse of the reality of our law establishment. Unlike what is shown in the mainstream cinemas.
Senior advocate is right though I respect honorable justice Ashutosh Sir, he is very good person but still on legal grounds senior Advocate is right at his place despite he has pushed his stand
Everybody here is taking the side of judge but let's watch the part of the lawyer too. He's explaining what has gone wrong with the committee from past 2 years he's not doing anything wrong maybe i guess and please guys never forget experience comes with time and he's a more aged than the judge maybe he's saw more cases. I believe experience comes with time and there's a good gap in lawyer's and judge's age here
Judges are made on the basis of there hardwork,knowledge and intelligence.. Every advocate cannot be judge.. So whether he is senior in age he should respect someone senior in knowledge..
He was insisting to proceed to contempt even though the order was carried out by forming a comitee. If he wanted to challenge the way committee was formed or the way it took the decision warranted a fresh case. For a layman to insist in this manner may have been understandable but for a senior lawyer like him was deeply irritating
Sir, India needs judges like you Sir. Honestly admitting you are no doubt one of the Best judge in India. My best wishes to you to be in Supreme court.
Judge clearly understood Advocate argument and told to challenge the committee findings by saying that only formality is done. But Advocate was not in mood to listen.
Ye judge sahab naram haintoh vakil sahab ne itna bol diya. Kisi gusse wale judge ke samne inn vakiloan ki bolti band ho jati hai. Justice Ashutosh Kumar is one of the only few judges worthy of being respected and look at this irony.
For a senior counsel like him as having seen lots of seasons, it is very difficult to accept the moral authority and judicial acuman of a judge less experienced than him.
Being a judge; he must not show any attitude. Senior advocate was telling right only that committee had made did some circus n rejected job seekers on the basis of they are not eligible. Same candidate they only recommended then rejected 🤣🤣🤣 Just because of anger he didn't did proper justice with the case
Judge sahab ko gussa aa raha toh adjourn krke proper hear krte; actually gussa isliye aaya kyunki opposition ka kuch ni kar paye or ni kr sakte; Opposition ne judge sir diplomatic way me disobey Kiya hai toh koi case bhi ni banta
@@samraddhisoni7149 learn the basics of contempt jurisdiction. Justice Kumar is absolutely correct when he says that the counsel must challenge the order. Contempt occurs when certain directions are not followed, here the authorities have passed some orders pursuant to the directions, which the applicant disputes. This dispute cannot be raised in contempt jurisdiction at all, and the applicant knows it very well, hence the reaction.
@@shreyangvayeda sir me bhi wahi keh rahi hu ki gussa ki wajah hai diplomatic action taken by state; jahan par unhone judge sahab ko disobey na krte hue bhi kiya hai
@@shreyangvayeda aise me apko lagta hai ki higher court Jane se koi madad milegi? Jo high court k judgement ko diplomatically bypass kar sakte hain will it not be possible for them bypass respected other court .
@@samraddhisoni7149 the High Court has asked them to consider in accordance with law, it hasn't gone into whether they should be absorbed in services or not. They might not be qualified to do so, an officer of court cannot dictate the court to pass certain orders in their favour, that too in contempt jurisdiction. If he is right, he can challenge the order on all grounds available to him under the law and get it quashed by filing appropriate proceedings. His prayer in contempt will certainly not be that of consequent relief, but of punishing the alleged wrongdoers, hence the court even otherwise by any stretch of imagination cannot interfere with the orders passed by the state.
This counsel spoiled the case for his client by his high handed attitude and arrogance. He apoears senile and after certain age counsels shall not be allowed to practice, lest they affect the case adversly for poor clients.
Law student hawi na nawhawi aadhar card votercardlink huwar bill jetiya lawt pawrinat hol tar pisawt kaenaekae 1951 etc vittibarkha hawbaw parae neighbour asae na nai
Banwari Sharma ji court me judge la sammn kijiye...gundai mt kijiye...sab samjh me aa raha hai.. Ap jartiwad se grasit hai...adat sudhariye...waqlt khtm ho jiyega...ap senior hai eska judge lehaj kr rahe hai....warna ab tak ap par contempt of court ho jiyega
In your comments there should be a clear disclaimer about the source of the video mentioning that you do not hold any copyright of the video whatsoever
You can write your channel name down and don't move up and down constantly. This is very bad practice. If you move it for few seconds once twice it's acceptable but this is irritating. Aur lagatar aap Subscribe ki appeal karre ho neeche. Itna obsession?? Please think about viewers also
Court Language is English for convience of judges and advocates from different parts of the country..... Mr. In our constitution English, Tamil, Odia, etc have been given the same status as that of Hindi and judges are transferred from one part of the country to another therefore the language of the courts is English. Hope this helps.
Hon’ble judge tried to be so calm throughout. The senior counsel just kept pushing the wrong buttons.
Correct. The lawyer was testing judge patience.
Just stop commenting before you understand the gravity of the matter.... Don't forget this is a contempt jurisdiction...
@@somsuvramukherjee502 And how did you get the perception that I didn't understand the gravity of the situation. I am a judicial officer myself. So I don't think I exceeded the limits of my words in any manner.
@@blackcoatdiaries6592 then with deepest respect, have you ever been on this side of the bench for atleast 10 years ?
@@somsuvramukherjee502 What does my experience have to do with the point I am trying to make? And are you on this side of the bench for more than 10 years? Well, I don't think I need to reply to someone who just comments something for the sake of commenting in order to garner attention or otherwise. What I commented was a genuine reply and it made sense, since the Hon'ble judge here was not at fault here. So I had to take his side. How can you drag contempt into this? Does protecting the bench when the bar was wrong, constitute contempt?
The Hon. Justice showed him his place and also moved on to the next matter inspite of the emotional tactics by a senior counsel carrying on and on. Hats off to the judge..... Hail Indian Judiciary
i have seen multiple cases of this judge. He is fair from a legal perspective and friendly, as far as I can see...
It would take a special type of advoicate to agitate him.
This Honourable Judge is very hard working, with clear understanding of the law, apt in dispensation of justice⚖, great orator from his persona he seems to be. Stay blessed Honourable judge.
These type of arrogant advocates should argue in front of pagal judge of Gujarat high court, Niral.
Ashutosh kumar is very calm and responsive judge.
Agreed
sach me
Mind your language you illiterate fool. What the hell is "pagal judge of Gujarat high court, Niral." ?
Mind ur language before using pagal for honble justices... Uh can be pulled down in contempt
@@yashdixit215 Don't cry now Dixit bhaiya, dil pe mat lo 😁
Asitosh sir.first time we see you get angry for a valid reason.reg sir.
Great judge
Watching from Pakistan
Student of law
Pakistan m law😂😂😂
Best wishes from Bharat, brother
Our next CJI is here 🙏🇮🇳
honourable justice Ashutosh Kumar Singh sir a gem 💎
Lol the judge completely ignore the senior council at the last moment 😂😂🤣🤣
I will share one bitter experience of my first encounter with judiciary where in the Munsif Judge was unable to understand my petition for 8 years where as In Honourable High Court of jammu and Kashmir, I had challenged the forged Will Deed in which Honorable HC of jammu and Kashmir gave Three verdicts in my favour, in which Single Bench, Division Bench disposed of case in my Favour within two years time while as Musif judge was such a dumb person that he couldn't understand the Litigation.
Oh no, the munsif judge would have understood the petition but you didn't grease his palms.
They are also in cahoots with the lawyers to squeeze both the parties. That is the prevailing system from Kashmir to Kanyakumari.
-from Tamil Nadu.
Munsiff kus ous , naaw kya chus
Funny to see how people in the comments section have started being the judge of a judicial judge. 😂
🤣🤣
Sometimes senior lawyers consider themselves above the constitution itself but never even have been chosen to be elevated from the bar to bench.
Uh idiot.. Many of 90% of them withdraw from elevation... Go get some knowledge idiot
It's the experience my man it's the experience. Experience comes with time and maybe it's possible that the lawyer has saw more cases than the judge as per their respective age. Not fighting nor I'm arguing just placing my view
@@shubhamjangid4843 That doesn't give him right to disrespect the bench.
@@sauravs293 he didn't do it bro he didn't he had got a point. You never know the real circumstances. Truth is bitter always.
@@shubhamjangid4843 Whatever truth one is possessing, there are certain code of conduct which shall be adhered to when standing infront of the bench.
Honorable Ashutosh sir is super judge
The judge looks like Mathur Ji from Jolly LLB 2 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Honble Judge is very excellent in holding court and briliant too
This judge was purely in Sadhguru mode up until the Senior advocate turned him into Sunny Deol. Great to see these live sessions, gives a glimpse of the reality of our law establishment. Unlike what is shown in the mainstream cinemas.
Senior advocate is right though I respect honorable justice Ashutosh Sir, he is very good person but still on legal grounds senior Advocate is right at his place despite he has pushed his stand
Judiciary in general is the institution where maximum amount of injustice can be seen
Everybody here is taking the side of judge but let's watch the part of the lawyer too. He's explaining what has gone wrong with the committee from past 2 years he's not doing anything wrong maybe i guess and please guys never forget experience comes with time and he's a more aged than the judge maybe he's saw more cases. I believe experience comes with time and there's a good gap in lawyer's and judge's age here
Experience comes with time if given proper direction..
Judges are made on the basis of there hardwork,knowledge and intelligence..
Every advocate cannot be judge..
So whether he is senior in age he should respect someone senior in knowledge..
He was insisting to proceed to contempt even though the order was carried out by forming a comitee. If he wanted to challenge the way committee was formed or the way it took the decision warranted a fresh case. For a layman to insist in this manner may have been understandable but for a senior lawyer like him was deeply irritating
He is best judge I have even seen❤️
He is the best judge..
Sir,
India needs judges like you Sir.
Honestly admitting you are no doubt one of the Best judge in India.
My best wishes to you to be in Supreme court.
If you have the ability to piss of justice ashutosh who is one of the coolest justices , there is an inherit problem with u ,
Inko gujarat hc Niral k saamne bhejo. Wakeel k kapde utar lete h wo 😂😂😂
Lordship’s angry for a valid reason!!!
Best judge ashutosh sir ,🙏
He is the best judge
Sr counsel has nothing to lose and that is why he was testing the patience of Hon'ble judge but there is a limit.
This judge is a true professional!
Judge nature is very Good but senior advocate did not behave like senior.... judge ne umar ka lihaaz krte huve bohot baad me gussa kiya
Correct
इस बुड्ढे ने कैसे इतने साल वकालत कर ली भगवान जाने। Court etiquettes मालूम ही नहीं है।
Judge clearly understood Advocate argument and told to challenge the committee findings by saying that only formality is done. But Advocate was not in mood to listen.
Skip at 6:50 angry judge moment
Great sir
1st time sir get angry
But jaruri tha. THe lawyer behaving very badly.
Powerful वकील
And when it comes to junior's salary they become the world's biggest miser
Ye judge sahab naram haintoh vakil sahab ne itna bol diya. Kisi gusse wale judge ke samne inn vakiloan ki bolti band ho jati hai. Justice Ashutosh Kumar is one of the only few judges worthy of being respected and look at this irony.
Where we can see full videos please??
THis was he full length for the proceeding.
For a senior counsel like him as having seen lots of seasons, it is very difficult to accept the moral authority and judicial acuman of a judge less experienced than him.
The old man resorted to tantrums and grunting. Horrible behaviour in a court.
Being a judge; he must not show any attitude. Senior advocate was telling right only that committee had made did some circus n rejected job seekers on the basis of they are not eligible.
Same candidate they only recommended then rejected 🤣🤣🤣
Just because of anger he didn't did proper justice with the case
Judge sahab ko gussa aa raha toh adjourn krke proper hear krte; actually gussa isliye aaya kyunki opposition ka kuch ni kar paye or ni kr sakte;
Opposition ne judge sir diplomatic way me disobey Kiya hai toh koi case bhi ni banta
@@samraddhisoni7149 learn the basics of contempt jurisdiction. Justice Kumar is absolutely correct when he says that the counsel must challenge the order. Contempt occurs when certain directions are not followed, here the authorities have passed some orders pursuant to the directions, which the applicant disputes. This dispute cannot be raised in contempt jurisdiction at all, and the applicant knows it very well, hence the reaction.
@@shreyangvayeda sir me bhi wahi keh rahi hu ki gussa ki wajah hai diplomatic action taken by state; jahan par unhone judge sahab ko disobey na krte hue bhi kiya hai
@@shreyangvayeda aise me apko lagta hai ki higher court Jane se koi madad milegi?
Jo high court k judgement ko diplomatically bypass kar sakte hain will it not be possible for them bypass respected other court .
@@samraddhisoni7149 the High Court has asked them to consider in accordance with law, it hasn't gone into whether they should be absorbed in services or not. They might not be qualified to do so, an officer of court cannot dictate the court to pass certain orders in their favour, that too in contempt jurisdiction. If he is right, he can challenge the order on all grounds available to him under the law and get it quashed by filing appropriate proceedings. His prayer in contempt will certainly not be that of consequent relief, but of punishing the alleged wrongdoers, hence the court even otherwise by any stretch of imagination cannot interfere with the orders passed by the state.
Ye gussa bhi decent tha
Judges are sent by God to deliver justice to us believe it or not
Lawyer is very old better to retire and take rest.
Woh lawyer chacha ko tho jail bhejna chahiye tha contempt ke liye 😠😠😠
After watching I understand that this is court language no matter how hard you try we don't know which one is supporting the crime who isn't 🤣🤣🤣
The senior counsel behaviour was so intolerable..
Age factor of Sr. Advocates causes temper bp
The senior advocate murmured something bad at the end of video. 11:09.. I hope I was wrong
He said this is not done or this is not fair as I'm able to hear that
I still wonder why they use hard copies instead of scan or soft copies
This counsel spoiled the case for his client by his high handed attitude and arrogance. He apoears senile and after certain age counsels shall not be allowed to practice, lest they affect the case adversly for poor clients.
l like this judge
The advocate is not wrong
Sach to kadhwa hota ha ,jo Sacha hota ha wo to Jor Jor se cahlyege 😡
Judge sb.is so cool person,but senior lawyer is not well behave .
arguments aise hi hote h senior counsel h vo power uske pass h boycott krws dega to sab case pending rah jayenge
Konsa exam hota hai, im in class 7 and i want to be supreme court lawyer
Judge hai woh, Zubaan se pocha lagwayega....
Digitalise the Courts.
Law student hawi na nawhawi aadhar card votercardlink huwar bill jetiya lawt pawrinat hol tar pisawt kaenaekae 1951 etc vittibarkha hawbaw parae neighbour asae na nai
gusa hona to jahir tha kyuki vo judge hai nto your friend 😂 same like you are student and you teaching your teacher
The judge of the high court listens to some pandit and wears multiple rings. Pathetic irony
Ho sakta h Sahi ho pr judge se bat karne ka tarika Sahi nhi thaaa
Your.. Subscription tag.. Again and again.... Is so... irritating
... Please try to keep it.... At max 2-3 times.. But.. Not so frequent. frequent.
Banwari Sharma ji court me judge la sammn kijiye...gundai mt kijiye...sab samjh me aa raha hai..
Ap jartiwad se grasit hai...adat sudhariye...waqlt khtm ho jiyega...ap senior hai eska judge lehaj kr rahe hai....warna ab tak ap par contempt of court ho jiyega
Jatiwad ?
Ye india ki cort h ya iglend ki
❤️❤️💐🌹🌺🌹🌺💐🔥🙏
Lgta h
Advocate ne jyda paise kama liye h
Esilye
Judge ke respect ni krta
Do we need to take permission to cut and post the videos from the site of high court to avoid copyright..?
This is public video coming from public institution and we are using just for educational purposes
In your comments there should be a clear disclaimer about the source of the video mentioning that you do not hold any copyright of the video whatsoever
@@LawChakra watermarking videos as your own like you are the court master. Pathetic
Also mostly all judicial paperwork in still English language.
430
Why not using Hindi language if everyone simply knows that. Why still following the rules of ancient international robbers.
High court hei
Hindi mein vocabulary limited hai loggo ki, English sb smjte
Judge saheb ki shakal Ankit awasthi sir se milti h
Same talking style
Law chakra ka shadow image screen pe aana band kr de please
Ok Noted
@@LawChakra thanks
302
Budha satak Gaya
You can write your channel name down and don't move up and down constantly. This is very bad practice. If you move it for few seconds once twice it's acceptable but this is irritating. Aur lagatar aap Subscribe ki appeal karre ho neeche. Itna obsession?? Please think about viewers also
bane "muslim rashtara" ya "hindu rashtara" ghareeb ko do waqt kee roti chahiye !!
Why in English use your mother tongue such a shame
Court Language is English for convience of judges and advocates from different parts of the country..... Mr. In our constitution English, Tamil, Odia, etc have been given the same status as that of Hindi and judges are transferred from one part of the country to another therefore the language of the courts is English. Hope this helps.
Hindi nahi aati kya
Lawyers client : "maaro mujhe maaro 🥲🥲"