I've seen a lot of people trying to figure out what the message for this MV was and the controversies that have come from certain interpretations. After listening to Simon's IG posts, explanations, and XGALX docu-series this is what I was able to figure out: the girls are singing about how the industry treats girl groups, particularly overseas. If you pay attention to the lyrics you can catch some of the more heavy implications on how many companies view their artists: "It's time I get what I deserve. Act like you don't know what I'm worth. We spend a lot of time talking, but it feels like I'm never heard." Obviously, the artists aren't being taken seriously, no matter how hard they work, how much attention they garner, or money they're earning the company. They still are being mistreated and disregarded, used as products/brands. A great example of that is when Harvey's part comes up early on. "Listen to what comes out my mouth, before you try to take me out." Now you can take that at face value or look deeper into what she's saying. Paired with the fact that she's speaking out, Harvey points to her mouth while singing. Upon closer examination, her teeth appear to be dark and bloody as if someone hit her in retaliation. The MV transitions as Harvey then points to Jurin. The first thing that everyone notices with her are her sharp shark teeth and quick elbow jabs into the air (as if she's fighting, you see the group punching and using the same elbow move again later on). The differences in Harvey and Jurin's appearances leave lasting impressions despite how beautiful they are. They're still being puppeteered by outside forces as the girls fight to be treated fairly. " We'll make them do what WE enjoy" "They'll do anything, anything, when you got them hanging by a string" "We play them like they're plastic dolls" Unsurprisingly, many industry contracts are unfair. It isn't uncommon to have the artist do things that they personally do not agree with or want to do - they become the product to be dressed up and showcased how the company sees fit. Take for instance how Juria is trying to run, eventually jumping up towards the balloon (her ambitions) to float away. Before she can escape, she's grabbed by the ankle as one of the white giants holds her back. The same giant holds onto Hinata, keeping the 3 of them grounded as Hinata helplessly looks up to Juria. Likewise you see Chisa, Jurin, Hinata, and Maya look for escape routes. Many of the "artists" also try to escape, but they blow up in the white beams of lights. It isn't until the artist, the one in blue and white, takes a deep look at Hinata and disappears that things change. The one in white and blue that explodes, that is symbolic of their producer Simon. Simon was also in the music industry before XGALX. He was actually a member of the boy group DMTN. He faced many of the same hardships as XG and saw the ins and outs of how the industry worked with their artists, how poorly many of them were treated, and the sort of environments that they were made to grow in. He wanted to break away from it all, find his own company, and do things in a manner where young artists could grow in a healthier environment. This is how XG was founded. When the explosion bursts into blue smoke, the ground shakes and all the people except XG fall. This is because XG is elite, being nourished and trained by producers and a company that genuinely cares for them and their opinions. No one else can hold a candle to them as they make waves across the board.
Wow your explanation is very detailed and extraordinary, I got goosebumps when I read your explanation, now I just know the meaning of all the lyrics of this song, thank you very much bro, I'm falling in love with XG even more, maybe XG is the only girl group currently who dares to open their voice through the lyrics of their songs and express all the complaints experienced by trainees, especially trainee from overseas.
Thats what I´ve been telling people, I feel like the line "We spent a lot of time talking, but it feels like Im never heard" fits really well here (since a lot of people didnt understand the lyrics at all) , people usually just take the lyrics too literally and make conclusions without thinking about it for a second. Some people even thought that they were saying that women should control men, I guess that nowadays attention span is really short, even if you take the lyrics literally its more of a hypotethical vengeance to their past boyfriend.
Puppet Show is being based as the idol life makes more sense now. The other day when they first performed live for Puppet Show their white uniforms reminded me when the girls used to perform on secret shows(back when they were 10 girls) as shown in Xtra Xtra.
@@naivet When I listened to this song for the first time I thought the lyrics were about XG itself because they are still not considered and underestimated by some people, especially haters because their identity is still being debated until now, but it turns out it goes deeper than that. XG is special, I am lucky to be able to witness the journey of a great group like XG.
Can you mark us on the clues you got from Simon? I think I saw 1983->2023 kind of post on IG but it’s not indicative of the message. Thanks in advance!
I said the same of course they should be serious because xg is definitely going to be their most biggest and successful idol group in their company that other upcoming artists are going to look up to them
Well deserved, they are technically one of the best groups right now considering they are all amazing singers, dancers and visuals, not to metion that the rapline actualy knows how to rap on a really high level. Ace group
@@nickylove4304well thats huge to say, bcs they have TRF or speed, they have like more than 20 million sales hdjd, but they are more artists than idols I think
Judging from AVEX’s annual report it’s reflecting successful growth of fandom (SNS views, followers and monthly listeners) right after SS, LR and Gals Xypher but they need to keep growing if we expect the same level of investment in the next comeback (so please spread XG in your social circle and buy their album if you haven’t)
@@Lycaonightley Well put as long as they have millions of views in albums and increasing followers and monthly listeners the couch company would see their growth and and success and would start having faith in them
There is a lot of theories going on what it is about. Here are some answers that might be helpful. Harvey has dark teeth, it is an old Japanese tradition that every married woman must do to show obedience to their husbands. Bali has a similar tradition where women would sharpen their teeth to show obedience like Jurin has. Hinata also has a hairstyle resembling a traditional wedding hair set of Mongolian women. Others also have a veil on or some wedding hair pieces. Theory could mean they were expected to be obedient but they are fighting back, like grabbing destiny in their own hands and taking control. Quite literally taking leap of faith. Some people say it could be talking about K-pop industry or music industry in general on how controlling it is. Often musicians are i contracts where they have strong concept to the point where they have to lie about things they like to do and fake personality. Girls are here then turning tables and tsking control instead, so they can do what they actually enjoy.
and just when the rapping ends, Cocona start singing! pay atenttion in how she is a superb rapper and a talented singer too, she starts singing with "automatic when i want for it to please me". i support these Xtraordinary Girls since their debut, i just didn't knew'em on their pre debut, but they have great content from that great XG "era" haha (in the end of the video, that you talk about references, i just couldn't help to point that Jurin's hair really looks similar to what she uses in XG GALZ XYPHER TAPE #2)
As you can see they are dressed like puppets/plastic dolls meaning they have been played by or on a string to people who does whatever they want with them, all they're saying what if it were reversed.
nice reaction and very good observation with the lyrics, pretty much no reactors were able to catch that the song was talking about the idol / kpop industry with their first react...
Just wanted to share the story and lore behind the music video., credit to @exScythed. - The XG girls are lowered individually into Buddhist Hell by the thread of a spider (the scene with Chisa represents this). The figures you see in the very beginning are wearing traditional Buddhist headdresses. They are surrounded by spirits who are caught in a cycle of reincarnation that never ends. (In Buddhism the “spider’s thread” is a reference to how Buddha took the thread of a spider in Heaven and lowered it down to Hell so that a criminal can climb up from Hell to Paradise. Therefore the thread of a spider is a symbol of slight hope aka a silver lining and of fragility. In the story it’s stated that the thread descended through “many layers of sky and clouds.”) - The XG girls look on sadly as many spirits attempt to reach Paradise and fail, exploding into nothingness (Chisa looking down from her perch represents this.) - Even though the XG girls are hailed as goddesses by the other spirits (represented by the way the other spirits bow to them) they realize they still can’t reach Paradise alone aka achieve enlightenment. - This changes when the XG girls find each other in death, realizing that their meeting was fate in order for them to reach Paradise together (they are tied together by the “red string of fate” and “hesonoo” is Japanese for umbilical chord.) This is represented four times in the video and twice in the chorus of the song; When Juria is running to help a spirit and meets Hinata there’s a close up of her eye where we see her having a vision of an explosion, when Harvey (who has black teeth which in Japan is a common practice amongst women because it represents a “woman with virtues”) meets Jurin, when the XG girls rap/dance together as a group with the drums, and when a wayward spirit’s failure to achieve enlightenment causes an explosion which knocks everyone down leaving only XG standing strong. There’s also a ton of fourth wall breaks showing that they’ve broken away from the circle the spirits are stuck walking in. They know the Truth aka achieved enlightenment and know you’re watching basically. Also, it is only in the later two choruses the girls adlib together. The first chorus, when they haven’t met in the video yet, has none. - Before XG goes, they bless one of the spirits who is heavily implied to be pregnant with a girl (the moon is associated with womanhood, XG fans are ALPHAZ aka wolves) and has earned the right to be reincarnated. - The XG girls take a literal leap of faith together and successfully reach Paradise! The music video is tied to XG’s themes of female empowerment-women have two “x” chromosomes, the girls are “extraordinary,” they have the “x-factor,”they represent a better future for women which is connected to the idea that the next generation of children (children birthed by women who have “new DNA”) are the future hence the futurism stuff. I hope this helps anyone!
it can also be interpreted as stepping into adulthood, cause as a child you are more free but when you become an adult you are far more controlled, whether it be in your work or in your play, you can't just do what you want as an adult (bills need to be paid and jobs need to be kept) plus your actions have real lasting if not permanent consequences
5:22 "Bye Felicia" is urban slang meaning roughly I don't have time for your games so you can exit now. Yes, the term gained popularity from a scene in the movie Friday.
Anthony, I know this is off topic, however, I do miss the reactions you did for all of Upchurch's tracks. I sincerely would enjoy seeing you react to his Blue Gene's album. 🤘 Your energy in addition to Upchurch's is CONTAGIOUS and comical. On instance comes to mind where you got so hyped that you decided to work out AGAIN doing pull ups IIRC 😆
Every song has a meaning from raw emotions to refined reactions. Some song are frowned upon. This song is a big middle finger to the censorship of the Korean government. Go back and read the lyrics. It can mean about bf gf drama but it's not. Read the lyrics and you'll know exactly what Simon's intent is with this song. Just so everyone knows the singer Billy Joel is forever banned from S Korea and is labeled dangerous for promoting rebellious behavior among the youth of the time. I wanna say mid '90s it happened but yeah I do believe this is that middle finger to the SK censorship. But this song is good. What is there that XG cannot do?
XG コンテンツを継続してください。常に素晴らしいです。エイミーの赤い歯、マヤとジュリアスのビジュアルが今回の作品では際立っています。そしてもちろん、千紗ちゃんの声とアイコンタクトも重要です。Keep up the XG content, always awesome....Amy's red teeth, Maya and Jurias visuals standout in this one and of course Chisa-chans voice and eye contact....
Hi AR, I follow OG ALPHAS Channel with Nate, it's cool watching the girls from there earlier days, to now. Definitely new school as you put it. I'm glad you introduced me to OGAL Nate and Chris. XGs videos are amazing to watch...🔥☝️🤓
![[UA] Eternal Fire проти NAVI | EPL Season 20 Malta](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/chvlsDygrZM/mqdefault.jpg)
I've seen a lot of people trying to figure out what the message for this MV was and the controversies that have come from certain interpretations. After listening to Simon's IG posts, explanations, and XGALX docu-series this is what I was able to figure out: the girls are singing about how the industry treats girl groups, particularly overseas. If you pay attention to the lyrics you can catch some of the more heavy implications on how many companies view their artists:
"It's time I get what I deserve. Act like you don't know what I'm worth. We spend a lot of time talking, but it feels like I'm never heard."
Obviously, the artists aren't being taken seriously, no matter how hard they work, how much attention they garner, or money they're earning the company. They still are being mistreated and disregarded, used as products/brands. A great example of that is when Harvey's part comes up early on.
"Listen to what comes out my mouth, before you try to take me out."
Now you can take that at face value or look deeper into what she's saying. Paired with the fact that she's speaking out, Harvey points to her mouth while singing. Upon closer examination, her teeth appear to be dark and bloody as if someone hit her in retaliation. The MV transitions as Harvey then points to Jurin. The first thing that everyone notices with her are her sharp shark teeth and quick elbow jabs into the air (as if she's fighting, you see the group punching and using the same elbow move again later on). The differences in Harvey and Jurin's appearances leave lasting impressions despite how beautiful they are. They're still being puppeteered by outside forces as the girls fight to be treated fairly.
" We'll make them do what WE enjoy"
"They'll do anything, anything, when you got them hanging by a string"
"We play them like they're plastic dolls"
Unsurprisingly, many industry contracts are unfair. It isn't uncommon to have the artist do things that they personally do not agree with or want to do - they become the product to be dressed up and showcased how the company sees fit. Take for instance how Juria is trying to run, eventually jumping up towards the balloon (her ambitions) to float away. Before she can escape, she's grabbed by the ankle as one of the white giants holds her back. The same giant holds onto Hinata, keeping the 3 of them grounded as Hinata helplessly looks up to Juria. Likewise you see Chisa, Jurin, Hinata, and Maya look for escape routes. Many of the "artists" also try to escape, but they blow up in the white beams of lights. It isn't until the artist, the one in blue and white, takes a deep look at Hinata and disappears that things change.
The one in white and blue that explodes, that is symbolic of their producer Simon. Simon was also in the music industry before XGALX. He was actually a member of the boy group DMTN. He faced many of the same hardships as XG and saw the ins and outs of how the industry worked with their artists, how poorly many of them were treated, and the sort of environments that they were made to grow in. He wanted to break away from it all, find his own company, and do things in a manner where young artists could grow in a healthier environment. This is how XG was founded. When the explosion bursts into blue smoke, the ground shakes and all the people except XG fall. This is because XG is elite, being nourished and trained by producers and a company that genuinely cares for them and their opinions. No one else can hold a candle to them as they make waves across the board.
Wow your explanation is very detailed and extraordinary, I got goosebumps when I read your explanation, now I just know the meaning of all the lyrics of this song, thank you very much bro, I'm falling in love with XG even more, maybe XG is the only girl group currently who dares to open their voice through the lyrics of their songs and express all the complaints experienced by trainees, especially trainee from overseas.
Thats what I´ve been telling people, I feel like the line "We spent a lot of time talking, but it feels like Im never heard" fits really well here (since a lot of people didnt understand the lyrics at all) , people usually just take the lyrics too literally and make conclusions without thinking about it for a second. Some people even thought that they were saying that women should control men, I guess that nowadays attention span is really short, even if you take the lyrics literally its more of a hypotethical vengeance to their past boyfriend.
Puppet Show is being based as the idol life makes more sense now. The other day when they first performed live for Puppet Show their white uniforms reminded me when the girls used to perform on secret shows(back when they were 10 girls) as shown in Xtra Xtra.
@@naivet When I listened to this song for the first time I thought the lyrics were about XG itself because they are still not considered and underestimated by some people, especially haters because their identity is still being debated until now, but it turns out it goes deeper than that. XG is special, I am lucky to be able to witness the journey of a great group like XG.
Can you mark us on the clues you got from Simon? I think I saw 1983->2023 kind of post on IG but it’s not indicative of the message. Thanks in advance!
It looks like Avex has been getting more serious with XG ( more production budget)…girls deserve it they are doing good
I said the same of course they should be serious because xg is definitely going to be their most biggest and successful idol group in their company that other upcoming artists are going to look up to them
Well deserved, they are technically one of the best groups right now considering they are all amazing singers, dancers and visuals, not to metion that the rapline actualy knows how to rap on a really high level. Ace group
@@nickylove4304well thats huge to say, bcs they have TRF or speed, they have like more than 20 million sales hdjd, but they are more artists than idols I think
Judging from AVEX’s annual report it’s reflecting successful growth of fandom (SNS views, followers and monthly listeners) right after SS, LR and Gals Xypher but they need to keep growing if we expect the same level of investment in the next comeback (so please spread XG in your social circle and buy their album if you haven’t)
@@Lycaonightley Well put as long as they have millions of views in albums and increasing followers and monthly listeners the couch company would see their growth and and success and would start having faith in them
I’m going to Tokyo for their show case🫡✨
Jealous. I’ll be on Live with all album purchasers. Support / Stan XG!
Im going to sydney for their concert ❤❤
あなたのXGリアクションがないと寂しいのです。待ってました！ありがとう🎉
歌詞の事ですが、自分の人生を他人に委ねるのではなく自分でコントロールしよう、本質的に自立をしよう。というメッセージ性だと思う。
Now we need that Hesono+X-gene.
There is a lot of theories going on what it is about. Here are some answers that might be helpful.
Harvey has dark teeth, it is an old Japanese tradition that every married woman must do to show obedience to their husbands.
Bali has a similar tradition where women would sharpen their teeth to show obedience like Jurin has.
Hinata also has a hairstyle resembling a traditional wedding hair set of Mongolian women.
Others also have a veil on or some wedding hair pieces.
Theory could mean they were expected to be obedient but they are fighting back, like grabbing destiny in their own hands and taking control. Quite literally taking leap of faith. Some people say it could be talking about K-pop industry or music industry in general on how controlling it is. Often musicians are i contracts where they have strong concept to the point where they have to lie about things they like to do and fake personality. Girls are here then turning tables and tsking control instead, so they can do what they actually enjoy.
Bye Felicia is a line from the movie Friday (Ice Cube and Chris Tucker)
and just when the rapping ends, Cocona start singing! pay atenttion in how she is a superb rapper and a talented singer too, she starts singing with "automatic when i want for it to please me".
i support these Xtraordinary Girls since their debut, i just didn't knew'em on their pre debut, but they have great content from that great XG "era" haha
(in the end of the video, that you talk about references, i just couldn't help to point that Jurin's hair really looks similar to what she uses in XG GALZ XYPHER TAPE #2)
I think so. I think Puppet Show is about the Kpop industry.
Indeed💯
Jp industry isn’t any better so can be both
You need to do the reaction to the song on Side B " X-gene ".
It's ❤ ....fire!
up
I also agree with you on this group. So refreshing to watch XG.
待ってました😌😌
“Bye Felicia” is a reference to the movie Friday with Ice Cube and Chris Tucker from the 90s
As you can see they are dressed like puppets/plastic dolls meaning they have been played by or on a string to people who does whatever they want with them, all they're saying what if it were reversed.
Puppet Show as a song about the industry makes more sense. They’re also wearing white which was a nod to when they were trainees with 10 members.
nice reaction and very good observation with the lyrics, pretty much no reactors were able to catch that the song was talking about the idol / kpop industry with their first react...
You gotta watch X-Gene by XG. No video. Do Lyrics video
あなたの反応が大好きです🎉
お願いです、MVはありませんがX-GENEにも反応してください🥹🙏
Bro do X-Gene
XG💗
I hope X-gene is next 🤞🏽
Just wanted to share the story and lore behind the music video., credit to @exScythed.
- The XG girls are lowered individually into Buddhist Hell by the thread of a spider (the scene with Chisa represents this). The figures you see in the very beginning are wearing traditional Buddhist headdresses. They are surrounded by spirits who are caught in a cycle of reincarnation that never ends. (In Buddhism the “spider’s thread” is a reference to how Buddha took the thread of a spider in Heaven and lowered it down to Hell so that a criminal can climb up from Hell to Paradise. Therefore the thread of a spider is a symbol of slight hope aka a silver lining and of fragility. In the story it’s stated that the thread descended through “many layers of sky and clouds.”)
- The XG girls look on sadly as many spirits attempt to reach Paradise and fail, exploding into nothingness (Chisa looking down from her perch represents this.)
- Even though the XG girls are hailed as goddesses by the other spirits (represented by the way the other spirits bow to them) they realize they still can’t reach Paradise alone aka achieve enlightenment.
- This changes when the XG girls find each other in death, realizing that their meeting was fate in order for them to reach Paradise together (they are tied together by the “red string of fate” and “hesonoo” is Japanese for umbilical chord.) This is represented four times in the video and twice in the chorus of the song; When Juria is running to help a spirit and meets Hinata there’s a close up of her eye where we see her having a vision of an explosion, when Harvey (who has black teeth which in Japan is a common practice amongst women because it represents a “woman with virtues”) meets Jurin, when the XG girls rap/dance together as a group with the drums, and when a wayward spirit’s failure to achieve enlightenment causes an explosion which knocks everyone down leaving only XG standing strong. There’s also a ton of fourth wall breaks showing that they’ve broken away from the circle the spirits are stuck walking in. They know the Truth aka achieved enlightenment and know you’re watching basically. Also, it is only in the later two choruses the girls adlib together. The first chorus, when they haven’t met in the video yet, has none.
- Before XG goes, they bless one of the spirits who is heavily implied to be pregnant with a girl (the moon is associated with womanhood, XG fans are ALPHAZ aka wolves) and has earned the right to be reincarnated.
- The XG girls take a literal leap of faith together and successfully reach Paradise!
The music video is tied to XG’s themes of female empowerment-women have two “x” chromosomes, the girls are “extraordinary,” they have the “x-factor,”they represent a better future for women which is connected to the idea that the next generation of children (children birthed by women who have “new DNA”) are the future hence the futurism stuff. I hope this helps anyone!
🔥XG!!!🔥
I've been waiting👍😆
This time is also a great work🔥 they are always crazy👽🛸🤭💖
Definitely gotta hear “X-Gene”. The drill beat is solid
Thank you for your reaction 😊
100%!!! Just like you said I do believe that they are talking about the industry.
it can also be interpreted as stepping into adulthood, cause as a child you are more free but when you become an adult you are far more controlled, whether it be in your work or in your play, you can't just do what you want as an adult (bills need to be paid and jobs need to be kept) plus your actions have real lasting if not permanent consequences
5:22 "Bye Felicia" is urban slang meaning roughly I don't have time for your games so you can exit now.
Yes, the term gained popularity from a scene in the movie Friday.
Bye Felicia from the movie Friday.
Bye Felicia is another old school reference. It's from Friday the movie that Ice Cube And Chris Tucker were in.
Btw, Maya is also on the rap verse with Coco and Harvey 😊
Anthony, I know this is off topic, however, I do miss the reactions you did for all of Upchurch's tracks. I sincerely would enjoy seeing you react to his Blue Gene's album. 🤘 Your energy in addition to Upchurch's is CONTAGIOUS and comical. On instance comes to mind where you got so hyped that you decided to work out AGAIN doing pull ups IIRC 😆
Please listen to x gene!! You will definitely love it
ALPHAZ ON DECK❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Hell yeah❤❤❤❤❤
Puppet Show is about taking control from the type of person they talk about in the intro and the 1st verse, at least that is my take.
the whole concept is giving peregrines peculiar children 🤩
Bruh, X-Gene is THE ONE. Infuriating that it is so short
It's industry and men/women relationship. Double meaning. I got that in the beginning...it's everyone following the lead...now, they are at the top.
New jeans God you HAVE to see it
あなたのチャンネルはとても音がいい。あなたの声もリアクション元の音楽も素晴らしい音質です。聴いていて気持ちがいい！
👍🔥🔥🔥🔥
Every song has a meaning from raw emotions to refined reactions. Some song are frowned upon. This song is a big middle finger to the censorship of the Korean government. Go back and read the lyrics. It can mean about bf gf drama but it's not. Read the lyrics and you'll know exactly what Simon's intent is with this song. Just so everyone knows the singer Billy Joel is forever banned from S Korea and is labeled dangerous for promoting rebellious behavior among the youth of the time. I wanna say mid '90s it happened but yeah I do believe this is that middle finger to the SK censorship. But this song is good. What is there that XG cannot do?
I'm really glad you were respectful to XG ❤unlike that youtuber Teddy who was upset about the song and called XG vaginas and wh0res
The on-screen steam comments always bother me so bad 😭
please check BE:first "Mainstream"
this is a boy group from japan that belongs to the same avex family as XG
Please listen Ado’s songs!!!
can't you do reacting for straykids:
Lil durk,straykids- all my life🎶 /straykids remix lyr.. (color lyric...)
How come you didn’t react to NEW DANCE 🥲
I did. One month ago. Do some research before you comment, please.
@@AnthonyRay I honestly did. Thanks for responding though.
XG members are inspired by destiny's child ,TLC, 2NE1,Spicy girl.The energy is back.
Also , looking forward to your reaction of X-GENE by XG.😍
Really?😮😮😮
Ohaguro: The Beauty of Blackened Teeth in Old Japan
Seems to me like you upped your game Anthony.
XG コンテンツを継続してください。常に素晴らしいです。エイミーの赤い歯、マヤとジュリアスのビジュアルが今回の作品では際立っています。そしてもちろん、千紗ちゃんの声とアイコンタクトも重要です。Keep up the XG content, always awesome....Amy's red teeth, Maya and Jurias visuals standout in this one and of course Chisa-chans voice and eye contact....
Hi AR, I follow OG ALPHAS Channel with Nate, it's cool watching the girls from there earlier days, to now. Definitely new school as you put it. I'm glad you introduced me to OGAL Nate and Chris. XGs videos are amazing to watch...🔥☝️🤓
you gotta give us Hesonoo + X-Gene as a pair now..
Maya slayed so hard, I cannot!!