My book The Saad Truth about Happiness: 8 Secrets for Leading the Good Life is available for order: www.amazon.com/Saad-Truth-about-Happiness-Secrets/dp/1684512603 _______________________________________ To subscribe to my exclusive content on Twitter, please visit my bio at twitter.com/GadSaad _______________________________________ If you appreciate my work and would like to support it: subscribestar.com/the-saad-truth patreon.com/GadSaad paypal.me/GadSaad You can also click on the "Heart Thanks" icon immediately below the clip. _______________________________________
Dear sir wanted to let you know the ads they are running on your video are donations to Gaza fund...Parasites gonna parasite! (Empty Pots by Najam Institute !!!)
Always brilliant. ... indeed thousands of interesting🌟 questions deserve Elon, but not the "sour" of the lemon. Although he 😶 gets into dialogues with people like that. 🤢
@@MartimSmith No, I was referring to Doctor Saad. 🌟🌟🌟🌟 But Elon is a relevant character. I don't know how they keep that comment with shit,👅 they disappear for me, I guess because they have more content. 😸
I think meant "lapse". in any case it was a clear strategy to attract sponsors from across the political spectrum which seems like a fine strategy. Lemon will still host his content on X, just without receiving payment from them.
It's good to hear you, Professor Saad, weigh in on this subject. You, along with Jordan Peterson, are among the few Canadian intellectuals in whom I have real confidence. Aside: Musk seems to understand the old maxim, "When the world gives you a lemon, make lemonade."
The active Islamists around the world could not do what they do without the implicit support of the passive ones. When the call comes from the Imans and others, the presently passive ones will do what the Koran instructs and behoves them to do. Going to sleep for a time does not alter your system of beliefs.
One is supposed to be a journalist the other is the most successful entrepreneur. They are not supposed to be in the same league. However Lemon was kicked out because his interview didn't look like an advertisement for Elon's brand. For example Elon Musk always gets upset when asked about the hate speech on his platform. He could have argued that all the other platforms have so many restrictions for access to information that he thinks that there is a price worth paying. Addressing the people problems would go a long way to improve Elon's image. Instead he is petty while being one of the most influential people in the world. Of course that a large part of population will be concerned.
As an American, I fear for Our and Canadian Western Culture. I have lost all faith in the Muslim New Comers, Their demonstrations tell me that they are not here to Assimilate and move away from the Ignorance that generated the Circumstance and Quality of life of their home country. I believe that very few would turn against a Fellow Muslim to keep our Country, Cities and Quality of Life intact.
It's hard to understand why Musk would give Don Lemon, of all people, the time of day. Don Lemon's career had leveled off at ground level. So why throw him a bone?
It's less about Lemon and more about Elon himself trying to show a willingness to sit down with even the worst of the worst if they'll lay off the constant propagandizing and activism. Lemon, on the other hand, showed a complete inability to break free of his NPC programming. I think Musk accomplished exactly what he intended. He showed graciousness in accepting the interview and restraint in at least _trying_ to a have a civil conversation, then made Lemon look like a clown when he didn't apologize or back down from his stance in the face of loaded questions.
Us regular red pilled people saw it as Musk allowing Lemon a chance to self implode. However: Lemon is such an ideologue that he's incapable of reflection. And his fellow travellers (on The View, on CNNn etc.) rushed to his side, assuring him of his bravery in speaking truth to power, making sure to reinforce Lemon's world view. All we can hope for is that a few more people on the "other side" saw through this and started questioning the narrative.
He actually told lemon during the interview, “the only reason I agreed to do this was because your show is on X as a platform. Otherwise I wouldn’t have done it.”
I can't believe that people who claim to care about people in Gaza, ignore the oppression that the people of Gaza are suffering under and because of Hamas.😮
that's because you learned about Palestine a few months ago when your media told you to pay attention. Hamas is a thing for little over a decade while Israel is exterminating the Palestinians since 1948. Hamas is a direct result of Israel's crimes and ethnic cleansing actions.
I admire the Jewish people for the fact that in spite of being constantly persecuted, they have the iron willpower, the strong faith in their country and the bravery NEVER to give in to savage calls for their extinction. They are the true survivors of genocide!
There has to be something warped in the leftie/Communist/Marxist mindset if they are not able to appreciate that for feminists, people who practise non-Islamic religion, homosexual people, and Jews, the Israeli model of government promotes human flourishing to a vastly greater extent than the Islamic Republic of Gaza.
By your own argument you've set a very low bar. Why, if you believe Islamic countries are so barbaric, do you praise Israel for being better. Better than barbarians? Woopdy doo! Try actually being good , not just less shit.
Absolutely. It is a religion that is centered around hate and intolerance as a primary driving force and it has shaped their society. More importantly though, Palestine lacks all the objective requirements of an actual civilization, as defined most famously by Ayn Rand. This includes things like art, literature and scientific discovery. This is truly a barbaric society, and that’s not a slur it’s an objective fact.
I'm only at 2:52 into your video, but I had thought that Don Lemon might have grown as a person, done some introspection, had some counseling etc etc. But I DIDN'T SEE OR HEAR THAT. The owner of a business who has a customer or a client that he doesn't like or finds offensive HAS EVERY RIGHT TO TOSS SAID PERSON OUT OF HIS ESTABLISHMENT! THAT'S WHAT ELON DID, AND GOOD FOR HIM!
Way back when Chris Cuomo had his show before D Lemon, I even commented to CC that CC was firing on ALL cylinders whilst DL was stuck in neutral. CC came back ATTACKING ME!
Alexander the Great named Palestine in his final speech of the Satrapies he conquered during the mutiny of Opis. Palestine is an ancient name, you must learn history before you write foolish comments like that!
@@stavz777 Alexander the Great was alive at a time around 1,000 years after the "ancient Greek" Philistines settled in Canaan, so that wasn't what I was referring to.... But either way you're right. We mistake Palestinians as "Arabs", yet despite speaking Arabic today and being predominantly Muslim these people lived in the area just as long as the Jews did (actually technically longer if you consider the Hebrew exile into Babylon as a brief stint, plus all the time they were exiled from Palestine after the fact as well) and were a distinct group completely separate from the Arabs.
The modern day Palestinians are a collection of tribes and can't be put in one box. Some may be descendants of the the ancient Csnaanites but the vast majority are Arabs who came to the region with the muslim conquest of the 7th century. A lot also were brought during the rule of the Ottoman Empire (Like the blond Bosnian family Thamimi in Hebron). The rest came during the British mandate to work and can tell you exactly where their family came from (There's an old famous interview with a Hamas official that claimed Egypt should help the Gazans because "half the Gazans have family ties in Egypt and the other half in Saudi..") All and all, there is no Palestinian people. There are people that inhabited the region known as Palestine but they never grouped together for any cause other than to kill Jews. The first Zionist poet came before the first poet who ever identified as a Palestinian. @@Anonymous07192
Is really that simple! When you look at both societies and their choices from a Universal principle, and you have principles and objectivity, you can't help but support Israel.
Nobel Prize awarded for Chemistry. J - 29 M - 3 Awarded for Physiology or Medicine J- 47 M - 0 Awarded for Physics J - 45 M - 1 Awarded for Economics J - 35 M - 0 Awarded for Peace J - 9 M - 8
Aren’t the Js you mention here converted Js? Slaws really from eastern Europe? Just asking. Of course believe and social structure are important too so you are right but a lot of the science nowadays really is utter bs and completely going to waste. 😂
It still blows my mind how Gad is Ariel Helwani's uncle. How can two people be so different? Mind you, I used to love Ariel as well, until he went all woke in 2016. He never has been the same since. Meanwhile Gad gets better each year like a fine wine.
The Palestinian people only began to identify themselves as such from 1964 forward, 1948 and before the Israelis living in the historical land of Israel identified themselves as Palestinians.
Elon should have paid BIG for Lemon and Carlson to co-host an odd-couple show of cancelled TV hosts together... Just imagine the chaos... Who wouldn't want to watch that?
Your right about the history of palestine. Now, Quebec is here, en français depuis plus de 400 ans. Il faut être reconnaissant que le quebec décide de défendre sa culture et son histoire avec des référendums et non par la violence; au risque d'effectivement disparaitre. C'est une sorte de noblesse.
Quebec defends its culture by oppressing other cultures. "Je me souviens...que j'étais né sous le lys (France), mais j'ai fleuri sous la rose (England)." Québec separatists are salty language fascists who are mad because they got their asses handed to them at the Plains of Abraham by the English.
"" Let those who fight in the way (violent way) of Allah who sell the life of this world for the other. Who so fighteth in the way of Allah, be he slain or be he victorious, on him We shall bestow a vast reward... "(Surah 4:74,77)
I stand for those who cherish and wish to preserve an individual life, not sacrifice them as martyrs. I loved Douglas Murray's quote from the other day, I'm paraphrasing but he asked how many people would support the Palestinian cause if Israel had never created the Iron Dome. Keep up the good work Dr. I appreciate your viewpoints.
@@julesbrunton1728 It’s funny when I can read someone’s comment, and they exude a miserable existence. You should try working out and lifting weights; it’ll do you good👍
Here is what I do not understand. Why did Israel push the Palestinians off their land and into a 4 by 25 mile strip of land? And how long does it take to overthrow that tiny piece of land? All this happened between 1946 to now. Was it because Palestinians did not have a library?
And why haven’t they built any libraries on that strip of land since 1946? Why don’t they have some nice museums and art galleries? It’s disgraceful to complain about starving children when you can’t even produce any art!
- Remember , whatever you do , do NOT insult the King ! You want that job at the round table after all , don't you ?! Donna Leon : goes ahead and insults the King up front ! Faceplam .
That's not quite the point -- On the eve of a major event for Elon & SpaceX, Lemon only wanted to talk about gossip. And now that Lemon had Elon on camera, he's going to ask the questions he's afraid to ask him in private. Anyone would squash that "cockroach", too!
For me it was watching interviews of children from the UNRWA schools. They have been taught nothing but hate. It is a society where the most you could possibly aspire to achieve in life is martyrdom. Martyrs are the only heroes and role models, they collect pictures of them like baseball cards. There is no hope for these people. They would/will have to start over completely from scratch. The sad reality is that most Muslims are hateful intolerant people, even secular ones who are funny or seem nice. I have even had friends like this, as a secular atheist myself. If you scratch the surface, there is an underlying almost unconscious sentiment of Islamic supremacy, entitlement, and hate.
Why are so many people espousing the erroneous and irrelevant argument that Palestine is not a nation/country/state? The issue that statehood is trying to solve is the indiscriminate mass murder campaign. What the people should be called or whether or not they have the right to self-determination is not important or even in question.
Simple RATIONAL thinking, thank you Gad, I support you, not because I am Jewish 😂😂but because you are clearly a voice of sanity in a very confused world
I hope you can find time to make more videos! I saw you on Pierce Morgan and immediately saw your intelligence and wisdom. And no yelling 🙂 (Not as a certain rabbi) Greetings from Norway!
It is practically impossible for a shared sense of a unitary culture with unique linguistic features to develop in any area in which the population density is as low as it was in Palestine in the early 20th century. In other words, there is no Palestinian cultural or national identity other than the fact that they live together.
6:43 And on your complicity Gad, always remember that those accusing you of that are the same people who swear that slavery is a western invention started in 1619 and never before practiced anywhere in the world.
The Quran says JIHAD is, in fact, NOT JUST A RELIGIOUS DUTY but a commerce, a business! (Surah 61:10-13). The Quran only promises spiritual rewards, but in the Hadith (Islamic tradition), Jihad is said to be THE BEST METHOD OF EARNING BLESSINGS BOTH SPIRITUAL AND TEMPORAL. If victory is won, there is enormous booty of a country, which cannot be equalled to any other source of income. If there is defeat or death, there is everlasting paradise where "there are rivers of wine and wide-eyed, virgin girls to marry as many as Muslims WANT". JIHAD (nor VIOLENCE) IS NOT EXTREMISM, BUT NORMAL IN ISLAM... Much of the incitement to violence and war in the whole of the Quran is directed against the Jews and Christians who rejected what they felt to be a strange god Mohammed was trying to preach...
Ney Gad, I'm curious what your thoughts are in regards to the recent interview Yasmine Mohamed had with Jay Shapiro. I was surprised at how anti-Israel Shapiro was, and he seemed to have the makings of what you call a parasatized mind.
Glad to know you have family getaways. I don't as my sons have now "woked" with their father, who claims to be me, their mother. I live a free flow gardening life now, channel in the handle here.
According to an article by Victoria Taft, Dork Lemon wanted editorial control over news on X, plus 8 million dollars a year for his show, among other outrageous perks for someone in his little league. Those are more significant reasons behind his deserved firing.
A) name ANY Arab that has done something noteworthy. B) the argument that the Arabs in Palestine have no right to their land because they did not have a state is highly disingenious.
Team Israel & team Arabs are like team Democrat & team Republican. These people for the most part will always support their team. Rest of us are somewhere in between and too often speaking out get verbally attacked by both sides.
I’m an anti war libertarian so I guess that makes me far right. I disagree with the operations in Gaza so I guess I’m a college liberal, I am a firearm enthusiast and enjoy learning about military operations so I guess I’m a republican? I want all drugs legal so I guess I’m a libtard, What is it people? Protect the constitution should be #1 priority not sending billions in weapons and aide to a country where the average citizen has a vastly better life in every measurable way than the average us citizen. Same goes for NATO. As soon as I see a European city or tel aviv look like la, sf, ny, or any other metro in the broken USA I might change my tune but my tax dollars should not be padding the pockets of foreign billionaires I don’t care what geopolitical excuse you come up with.
Dr Saad, is trying to point to the historic record of the Palestinian state. When you ask where are the great accomplishments from Palestine, you are pointing to the lack of a historical Palestinian state.
But where is the Free Speech test for Musk? By asking Don Lemon to come to X, he obviously invited a liberal point of view. I think that even if you don’t like Don Lemon, he should be able to speak his mind in this “Free Speech” X town square of the world. This is intellectually dishonest. The point of bringing Don Lemon was to bring more liberal POV to X, probably as a balancing act to Carlson, and probably to bring advertising back, but hopefully, not to stand there and salute E. Musk
Yes, asking Elon about how to best regulate hate speech is „woke“. There are so many interesting questions that could lead to real insights, like what do you have for breakfast, or tell me why you are such a great entrepreneur. This surely has to be satire.
it's a false choice to ask - should we model ourselves after a "free, democratic" society such as Israel or a "backwards, terrorist" society such as Gaza. thats like looking at the past apartheid situation in South Africa and asking should we model ourselves after the rich ruling white society or the poor barbaric black society? they arent equivalent in either case because one of the choices is the oppressor of the other and prevents the oppressed society from thriving and growing in a normal healthy way. being kept in a cage both literally and figuratively will cause the oppressed societies to become toxic and violent... this is normal human nature and has no link to any race or culture in particular. what we need to answer is... what would I/we do if I/we lived in an oppressed society over the period of 5 generations+ ??? things get worse over the passage of more time as things appear to be hopeless and any human society would resort to extreme violence in response. the solution is not to uphold one side as superior and more desirable, but to put an end to the division and the oppressor / oppressed relationship.
Have you seen SA lately? Its become a nation on the border of collapse and anarchy. The leaders are corrupt as hell and there is growing civil unrest. The choice one takes between Israel and Gaza depend on your values and intelligent choices. I woudl bet if they could most Gazans would gladly become Israeli citizens if they could. They can't because they have been hostile to Jews from the beginning and still are. The 20% of Israelis that are muslims are much better of in every way than Palestinians. I severy country that is strong or "white" (shows your racism) an "oppressor"? Should not a people be judged on their actions and the morals behind those actions? The way I see it is Israel got attacked and invaded savagely on Oct 7th and deemed it a declaration of war. Now Gaza is at war. Who decided to attack Israel? Who decided to perform those barbaric medieval acts of torture, rape and murder in the most heinous inhumane way? It CERTAINLY WAS NOT ISRAEL WAS IT? Israel is fighting a war in an urban theatre that has no precedent. But people like you want to virtue signal about a war you have no clue about. Where were you and your friends when Syria slaughtered almost 500,000 of their own musims? Nowhere ! Where were you when SA killed over 240,000 Yemeni muslims? Nowhere. Now that Hamas (so known for its integrity and honesty) tells you 30,000 Palestinians are dead you auto believe it? Why because they are the "oppressed"? Your lack of critical reasoning as well as history and ethics leads to only one conclusion. The difference is Jews are involved. Otherwise you would be 100 times more outraged at Syria and SA. Sometimes the powerful IS THE RIGHT SIDE. Where do you get your moral compass from? Disney? Go learn how to think for yourself instead of repeating the same echo chamber diatribe you are getting form your leftist friends.
My book The Saad Truth about Happiness: 8 Secrets for Leading the Good Life is available for order:
www.amazon.com/Saad-Truth-about-Happiness-Secrets/dp/1684512603
_______________________________________
To subscribe to my exclusive content on Twitter, please visit my bio at twitter.com/GadSaad
_______________________________________
If you appreciate my work and would like to support it:
subscribestar.com/the-saad-truth
patreon.com/GadSaad
paypal.me/GadSaad
You can also click on the "Heart Thanks" icon immediately below the clip.
_______________________________________
When are you coming back to Regina to give a lecture again?
Dear sir wanted to let you know the ads they are running on your video are donations to Gaza fund...Parasites gonna parasite! (Empty Pots by Najam Institute !!!)
Lemon is such a clown.
Just a lemon.
World Association of Clowns: "Hey, stop comparing us with Don Lemon!"
Always brilliant. ... indeed thousands of interesting🌟 questions deserve Elon, but not the "sour" of the lemon. Although he 😶 gets into dialogues with people like that. 🤢
You mean Elon? With his starshit exploding third time, lol)
@@MartimSmith No, I was referring to Doctor Saad. 🌟🌟🌟🌟 But Elon is a relevant character. I don't know how they keep that comment with shit,👅 they disappear for me, I guess because they have more content. 😸
Musk knew a Lemon when he saw it.
Yep - a vrot one too..
You could say Lemon-aided Elon in promoting his brand of management ,lol.
If it looks like a Lemon .....
The Gad Father is a purveyor of truth 👏
I can't imagine what Musk was thinking in hiring Lemon or allowing himself to be interviewed by that bottom feeder. Seems like a lapse in judgment.
I think meant "lapse". in any case it was a clear strategy to attract sponsors from across the political spectrum which seems like a fine strategy. Lemon will still host his content on X, just without receiving payment from them.
Musk is not smart in everything. Advocates carbon taxes and genocide of Ukraine.
Just to prove a point, I think
Musk was thinking free advertisment and he didn't get it. What Saad is saying here is that he would be happy to oblige.
E.M. really liked obama too..
It's good to hear you, Professor Saad, weigh in on this subject. You, along with Jordan Peterson, are among the few Canadian intellectuals in whom I have real confidence.
Aside: Musk seems to understand the old maxim, "When the world gives you a lemon, make lemonade."
The active Islamists around the world could not do what they do without the implicit support of the passive ones.
When the call comes from the Imans and others, the presently passive ones will do what the Koran instructs and behoves them to do.
Going to sleep for a time does not alter your system of beliefs.
🎯
You have this on authority or on drugs?
The word "Islamist" is a made up newspeak word. They are called MOSLEMS.
Don Lemon is a sophist. He isn't even in the same league with a guy of Elon Musk's caliber.
You give him too much credit to be a sophist.
One is supposed to be a journalist the other is the most successful entrepreneur. They are not supposed to be in the same league. However Lemon was kicked out because his interview didn't look like an advertisement for Elon's brand. For example Elon Musk always gets upset when asked about the hate speech on his platform. He could have argued that all the other platforms have so many restrictions for access to information that he thinks that there is a price worth paying. Addressing the people problems would go a long way to improve Elon's image. Instead he is petty while being one of the most influential people in the world. Of course that a large part of population will be concerned.
@BartdeBoisblanc exactly, more like a sophist wannabe
Sophist indeed.
"Palestinian" is a cipher, a stand-in for the grievances of all sorts of Middle Eastern malcontents.
Yeah, not euro-h!cks. 🤡
You mean Islam .
As an American, I fear for Our and Canadian Western Culture. I have lost all faith in the Muslim New Comers, Their demonstrations tell me that they are not here to Assimilate and move away from the Ignorance that generated the Circumstance and Quality of life of their home country. I believe that very few would turn against a Fellow Muslim to keep our Country, Cities and Quality of Life intact.
It's hard to understand why Musk would give Don Lemon, of all people, the time of day.
Don Lemon's career had leveled off at ground level. So why throw him a bone?
It's less about Lemon and more about Elon himself trying to show a willingness to sit down with even the worst of the worst if they'll lay off the constant propagandizing and activism. Lemon, on the other hand, showed a complete inability to break free of his NPC programming. I think Musk accomplished exactly what he intended. He showed graciousness in accepting the interview and restraint in at least _trying_ to a have a civil conversation, then made Lemon look like a clown when he didn't apologize or back down from his stance in the face of loaded questions.
Us regular red pilled people saw it as Musk allowing Lemon a chance to self implode.
However: Lemon is such an ideologue that he's incapable of reflection. And his fellow travellers (on The View, on CNNn etc.) rushed to his side, assuring him of his bravery in speaking truth to power, making sure to reinforce Lemon's world view.
All we can hope for is that a few more people on the "other side" saw through this and started questioning the narrative.
He actually told lemon during the interview, “the only reason I agreed to do this was because your show is on X as a platform. Otherwise I wouldn’t have done it.”
Wow! Knocked my socks off. What a wonderfully constructed argument!
I look forward to reading your book.
I can't believe that people who claim to care about people in Gaza, ignore the oppression that the people of Gaza are suffering under and because of Hamas.😮
Hmmm - of course Hamas exists because of Israel - kinda matters.
Stop acting like the two are mutually excusive. It's just a way to ignore warcrimes.
that's because you learned about Palestine a few months ago when your media told you to pay attention. Hamas is a thing for little over a decade while Israel is exterminating the Palestinians since 1948. Hamas is a direct result of Israel's crimes and ethnic cleansing actions.
I admire the Jewish people for the fact that in spite of being constantly persecuted, they have the iron willpower, the strong faith in their country and the bravery NEVER to give in to savage calls for their extinction. They are the true survivors of genocide!
And just like survivors of domestic abuse they continue the cycle
@@julesbrunton1728 look at which society commits and promotes gang graping women and children. All you need to know, silly billy
Elon had the patience of a saint putting up with Don lemon. I'm looking forward to you conversations with him. Thanks.
Well said Professor! Thanks.
There has to be something warped in the leftie/Communist/Marxist mindset if they are not able to appreciate that for feminists, people who practise non-Islamic religion, homosexual people, and Jews, the Israeli model of government promotes human flourishing to a vastly greater extent than the Islamic Republic of Gaza.
Sadly, these are concepts that go way over their heads. Navel gazing IS a thing.
By your own argument you've set a very low bar. Why, if you believe Islamic countries are so barbaric, do you praise Israel for being better. Better than barbarians? Woopdy doo! Try actually being good , not just less shit.
Absolutely. It is a religion that is centered around hate and intolerance as a primary driving force and it has shaped their society. More importantly though, Palestine lacks all the objective requirements of an actual civilization, as defined most famously by Ayn Rand. This includes things like art, literature and scientific discovery. This is truly a barbaric society, and that’s not a slur it’s an objective fact.
A poetic lecture on the term of a "straw man argument." Love this guy.
I'm only at 2:52 into your video, but I had thought that Don Lemon might have grown as a person, done some introspection, had some counseling etc etc. But I DIDN'T SEE OR HEAR THAT.
The owner of a business who has a customer or a client that he doesn't like or finds offensive HAS EVERY RIGHT TO TOSS SAID PERSON OUT OF HIS ESTABLISHMENT!
THAT'S WHAT ELON DID, AND GOOD FOR HIM!
Really? You thought he’d ‘grown as a person’? Oooookay….
@prague7706 no, apparently Lemon HAS NOT grown as a person. Read my comment again.
He did his best for a guy with 80 IQ
Way back when Chris Cuomo had his show before D Lemon, I even commented to CC that CC was firing on ALL cylinders whilst DL was stuck in neutral. CC came back ATTACKING ME!
Grow as a person seems to mean do advertisement for the person who hired you and realize that otherwise you get sacked.
Palestine isn’t a country. It’s a place. Like the Alps is a place.
Alexander the Great named Palestine in his final speech of the Satrapies he conquered during the mutiny of Opis. Palestine is an ancient name, you must learn history before you write foolish comments like that!
@@Anonymous07192😂 you mean ancient Greek philistines by ancient right? At least be accurate 😂
@@stavz777 Alexander the Great was alive at a time around 1,000 years after the "ancient Greek" Philistines settled in Canaan, so that wasn't what I was referring to.... But either way you're right. We mistake Palestinians as "Arabs", yet despite speaking Arabic today and being predominantly Muslim these people lived in the area just as long as the Jews did (actually technically longer if you consider the Hebrew exile into Babylon as a brief stint, plus all the time they were exiled from Palestine after the fact as well) and were a distinct group completely separate from the Arabs.
@@Anonymous07192 the ancient philistines predominantly came from area of ancient Gaza...not necessarily Canaan? Look at ancient maps of the time?
The modern day Palestinians are a collection of tribes and can't be put in one box.
Some may be descendants of the the ancient Csnaanites but the vast majority are Arabs who came to the region with the muslim conquest of the 7th century. A lot also were brought during the rule of the Ottoman Empire (Like the blond Bosnian family Thamimi in Hebron). The rest came during the British mandate to work and can tell you exactly where their family came from (There's an old famous interview with a Hamas official that claimed Egypt should help the Gazans because "half the Gazans have family ties in Egypt and the other half in Saudi..")
All and all, there is no Palestinian people. There are people that inhabited the region known as Palestine but they never grouped together for any cause other than to kill Jews.
The first Zionist poet came before the first poet who ever identified as a Palestinian.
@@Anonymous07192
Yesssss
It's a pleasure to see you back Gad, this is one of those evenings where I need some of your anti-parasitic wisdom.
Is really that simple! When you look at both societies and their choices from a Universal principle, and you have principles and objectivity, you can't help but support Israel.
You mean white-colonization.. yeah support that. In that sense, you would’ve supported the oppressing Germans in the 1930-40s too. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Nobel Prize awarded for Chemistry.
J - 29
M - 3
Awarded for Physiology or Medicine
J- 47
M - 0
Awarded for Physics
J - 45
M - 1
Awarded for Economics
J - 35
M - 0
Awarded for Peace
J - 9
M - 8
Aren’t the Js you mention here converted Js? Slaws really from eastern Europe? Just asking. Of course believe and social structure are important too so you are right but a lot of the science nowadays really is utter bs and completely going to waste. 😂
Peace Prize is bobo
People have become so insane. Please keep speaking the truth Sir.
My favourite professor by far!
Thank you so much for your voice ❤
Gad you are awesome ❤
Love professor Gaad honest, reasonable, open communicator and humanist💯
Love the Gad Father!!!
Thank you for your insights and continuing education of us Canadians, Gad!
Gad, PLEASE REHASH FOR US CANADIANS WHAT A PALESTINIAN PERSONHOOD IS SUPPOSED TO BE!
I'M TOTALLY CONFUSED ABOUT THIS!
GOOD POINTS
Lemon never answers difficult questions, certainly never rude ones. He's a knob. And a hypocrite.
I support Israel because I am civilized!
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡😂😂
I think the words youre looking for are murderous and ignorant.
You mean murderous and ignorant.
@@dave9547 You give "ignorant" a new level in the vernacular of english language.
@@dave9547
Tell Hamas to free the slaves.
An excellent view on the ‘conflict’. Thanks.
It still blows my mind how Gad is Ariel Helwani's uncle.
How can two people be so different?
Mind you, I used to love Ariel as well, until he went all woke in 2016. He never has been the same since.
Meanwhile Gad gets better each year like a fine wine.
Thank you for this video and thanks to David Deutsch for sharing
Well said sir... 👏
You look thoroughly refreshed.
As always, 100% correct. Well, you told them, it's up to them to understand and succeed in life or not and fail with all the rest of the liberals.
Welcome back, Professor Gad, and may we live to see peace in the Middle East
The Palestinian people only began to identify themselves as such from 1964 forward, 1948 and before the Israelis living in the historical land of Israel identified themselves as Palestinians.
Thanks Bibi
@@julesbrunton1728 Uncomfortable facts, but facts nonetheless.
Elon should have paid BIG for Lemon and Carlson to co-host an odd-couple show of cancelled TV hosts together... Just imagine the chaos... Who wouldn't want to watch that?
Most sane people
Very compelling and impacting on my viewpoint. Nice job.
Araphat did the scarf thing and that is now a big big fashion thing now.
Your right about the history of palestine. Now, Quebec is here, en français depuis plus de 400 ans. Il faut être reconnaissant que le quebec décide de défendre sa culture et son histoire avec des référendums et non par la violence; au risque d'effectivement disparaitre. C'est une sorte de noblesse.
Quebec defends its culture by oppressing other cultures.
"Je me souviens...que j'étais né sous le lys (France), mais j'ai fleuri sous la rose (England)."
Québec separatists are salty language fascists who are mad because they got their asses handed to them at the Plains of Abraham by the English.
Don actually thought he would get away with using MSM tactics without MSM institution to back him
Keep up the good work Gad.
Glad this showed up in my feed, could have sworn I was subscribed.
"" Let those who fight in the way (violent way) of Allah who sell the life of this world for the other. Who so fighteth in the way of Allah, be he slain or be he victorious, on him We shall bestow a vast reward... "(Surah 4:74,77)
I stand for those who cherish and wish to preserve an individual life, not sacrifice them as martyrs. I loved Douglas Murray's quote from the other day, I'm paraphrasing but he asked how many people would support the Palestinian cause if Israel had never created the Iron Dome. Keep up the good work Dr. I appreciate your viewpoints.
The simple answer is billions. Murray is such an eloquent simpleton, no wonder you love his rhetoric
@@julesbrunton1728 It’s funny when I can read someone’s comment, and they exude a miserable existence. You should try working out and lifting weights; it’ll do you good👍
Spot on Prof.
Here is what I do not understand. Why did Israel push the Palestinians off their land and into a 4 by 25 mile strip of land? And how long does it take to overthrow that tiny piece of land? All this happened between 1946 to now. Was it because Palestinians did not have a library?
And why haven’t they built any libraries on that strip of land since 1946? Why don’t they have some nice museums and art galleries? It’s disgraceful to complain about starving children when you can’t even produce any art!
@@deepestvermillion
Save the babies.
- Remember , whatever you do , do NOT insult the King ! You want that job at the round table after all , don't you ?!
Donna Leon : goes ahead and insults the King up front !
Faceplam .
That's not quite the point -- On the eve of a major event for Elon & SpaceX, Lemon only wanted to talk about gossip. And now that Lemon had Elon on camera, he's going to ask the questions he's afraid to ask him in private. Anyone would squash that "cockroach", too!
When I heard that 85% of terrorstinians support Hamas I lost all sympathy. I don't care one iota for them. I stand with Israel 100% all the way.
For me it was watching interviews of children from the UNRWA schools. They have been taught nothing but hate. It is a society where the most you could possibly aspire to achieve in life is martyrdom. Martyrs are the only heroes and role models, they collect pictures of them like baseball cards. There is no hope for these people. They would/will have to start over completely from scratch.
The sad reality is that most Muslims are hateful intolerant people, even secular ones who are funny or seem nice. I have even had friends like this, as a secular atheist myself. If you scratch the surface, there is an underlying almost unconscious sentiment of Islamic supremacy, entitlement, and hate.
Why are so many people espousing the erroneous and irrelevant argument that Palestine is not a nation/country/state? The issue that statehood is trying to solve is the indiscriminate mass murder campaign. What the people should be called or whether or not they have the right to self-determination is not important or even in question.
Hm, by those criteria - that of needing to boast of a history of merit - perhaps a lot of other countries would not make the grade.
Welcome back!
Simple RATIONAL thinking, thank you Gad, I support you, not because I am Jewish 😂😂but because you are clearly a voice of sanity in a very confused world
I'd love to watch an interview between Saad and Musk.
Don Lemon is the definition of woke.
Exactly. Wasted experience Don Lemon furnishing Don Lemon’s ego. I thought it was an appalling interview.
I hope you can find time to make more videos! I saw you on Pierce Morgan and immediately saw your intelligence and wisdom. And no yelling 🙂 (Not as a certain rabbi) Greetings from Norway!
If it makes you better, apparently I am complicit too all the way from South Africa.
It is practically impossible for a shared sense of a unitary culture with unique linguistic features to develop in any area in which the population density is as low as it was in Palestine in the early 20th century. In other words, there is no Palestinian cultural or national identity other than the fact that they live together.
Looking good professor! I guess you needed a vacation (some time off)?! Very good argument b.t.w. 😉
Schmuck is a great word
Great Palestinians of the last 200 years. LMAO!
7:50 Not all Muslims are to blame, but Islam itself _damn_ sure is.
Love your commentary. Don't stop.
Gandalf? Is that you....
Why are we talking about a province of Rome in 2024?
6:43 And on your complicity Gad, always remember that those accusing you of that are the same people who swear that slavery is a western invention started in 1619 and never before practiced anywhere in the world.
The Quran says JIHAD is, in fact, NOT JUST A RELIGIOUS DUTY but a commerce, a business! (Surah 61:10-13). The Quran only promises spiritual rewards, but in the Hadith (Islamic tradition), Jihad is said to be THE BEST METHOD OF EARNING BLESSINGS BOTH SPIRITUAL AND TEMPORAL. If victory is won, there is enormous booty of a country, which cannot be equalled to any other source of income. If there is defeat or death, there is everlasting paradise where "there are rivers of wine and wide-eyed, virgin girls to marry as many as Muslims WANT".
JIHAD (nor VIOLENCE) IS NOT EXTREMISM, BUT NORMAL IN ISLAM... Much of the incitement to violence and war in the whole of the Quran is directed against the Jews and Christians who rejected what they felt to be a strange god Mohammed was trying to preach...
Ney Gad, I'm curious what your thoughts are in regards to the recent interview Yasmine Mohamed had with Jay Shapiro. I was surprised at how anti-Israel Shapiro was, and he seemed to have the makings of what you call a parasatized mind.
We are all Jewish now, great work Gad
Dr. Saad - Within the public domain, has the refuting of compelled speech now become the denial of free speech?
hi gad saad
Glad to know you have family getaways. I don't as my sons have now "woked" with their father, who claims to be me, their mother. I live a free flow gardening life now,
channel in the handle here.
What was he even thinking getting lemon in the 1st place
i think i'd be tougher on Musk: why did you toss billions down the toilet with twitter? why in the hell are you flirting with putin? and so forth
According to an article by Victoria Taft, Dork Lemon wanted editorial control over news on X, plus 8 million dollars a year for his show, among other outrageous perks for someone in his little league. Those are more significant reasons behind his deserved firing.
A) name ANY Arab that has done something noteworthy.
B) the argument that the Arabs in Palestine have no right to their land because they did not have a state is highly disingenious.
Dr.Saad it is impossible to reason with Zombies.
Nice tan, Gad!
Team Israel & team Arabs are like team Democrat & team Republican. These people for the most part will always support their team.
Rest of us are somewhere in between and too often speaking out get verbally attacked by both sides.
Exactly.
I’m an anti war libertarian so I guess that makes me far right. I disagree with the operations in Gaza so I guess I’m a college liberal, I am a firearm enthusiast and enjoy learning about military operations so I guess I’m a republican? I want all drugs legal so I guess I’m a libtard, What is it people?
Protect the constitution should be #1 priority not sending billions in weapons and aide to a country where the average citizen has a vastly better life in every measurable way than the average us citizen. Same goes for NATO. As soon as I see a European city or tel aviv look like la, sf, ny, or any other metro in the broken USA I might change my tune but my tax dollars should not be padding the pockets of foreign billionaires I don’t care what geopolitical excuse you come up with.
@@sumkidincalilol US is the Roman Empire. That comes with a cost. Where do you think your taxed prosperity comes from?
The "Constitution" is literally a ruling class document that legitimised taxation & the federal state @@sumkidincali
Dr Saad, is trying to point to the historic record of the Palestinian state. When you ask where are the great accomplishments from Palestine, you are pointing to the lack of a historical Palestinian state.
The entire soccer team was Jewish in Palestine 🇮🇱
But where is the Free Speech test for Musk? By asking Don Lemon to come to X, he obviously invited a liberal point of view. I think that even if you don’t like Don Lemon, he should be able to speak his mind in this “Free Speech” X town square of the world. This is intellectually dishonest. The point of bringing Don Lemon was to bring more liberal POV to X, probably as a balancing act to Carlson, and probably to bring advertising back, but hopefully, not to stand there and salute E. Musk
This isn't funny.
You are complicit.
As is Lemon.
Your the same.
Mr. Lemon is detesticle, I mean detestable.👀
Gad, exit Canada while you can.
Question... What do Israeli muslim parliamentarians say about the situation?
don't worry gad, the universe will give you the opportunity to experience israhell from the other side.
Yes, asking Elon about how to best regulate hate speech is „woke“. There are so many interesting questions that could lead to real insights, like what do you have for breakfast, or tell me why you are such a great entrepreneur.
This surely has to be satire.
Its time for the 47 minute video to be made public.
Dear Dr. Saad, desperately waiting for your comments about Lex Fridman's latest Israel "debate" 🙈
Thoughtful. Thanks Mr. Saad. I still marvel at the idea that grown adults follow islam. It doesn't take much thought to see it is a pack of lies.
Provocation doesn’t require much thought either. '
Doesn't suffer fools and why should he
it's a false choice to ask - should we model ourselves after a "free, democratic" society such as Israel or a "backwards, terrorist" society such as Gaza. thats like looking at the past apartheid situation in South Africa and asking should we model ourselves after the rich ruling white society or the poor barbaric black society? they arent equivalent in either case because one of the choices is the oppressor of the other and prevents the oppressed society from thriving and growing in a normal healthy way. being kept in a cage both literally and figuratively will cause the oppressed societies to become toxic and violent... this is normal human nature and has no link to any race or culture in particular. what we need to answer is... what would I/we do if I/we lived in an oppressed society over the period of 5 generations+ ??? things get worse over the passage of more time as things appear to be hopeless and any human society would resort to extreme violence in response. the solution is not to uphold one side as superior and more desirable, but to put an end to the division and the oppressor / oppressed relationship.
Have you seen SA lately? Its become a nation on the border of collapse and anarchy. The leaders are corrupt as hell and there is growing civil unrest.
The choice one takes between Israel and Gaza depend on your values and intelligent choices. I woudl bet if they could most Gazans would gladly become Israeli citizens if they could. They can't because they have been hostile to Jews from the beginning and still are. The 20% of Israelis that are muslims are much better of in every way than Palestinians.
I severy country that is strong or "white" (shows your racism) an "oppressor"? Should not a people be judged on their actions and the morals behind those actions? The way I see it is Israel got attacked and invaded savagely on Oct 7th and deemed it a declaration of war. Now Gaza is at war. Who decided to attack Israel? Who decided to perform those barbaric medieval acts of torture, rape and murder in the most heinous inhumane way? It CERTAINLY WAS NOT ISRAEL WAS IT?
Israel is fighting a war in an urban theatre that has no precedent. But people like you want to virtue signal about a war you have no clue about. Where were you and your friends when Syria slaughtered almost 500,000 of their own musims? Nowhere ! Where were you when SA killed over 240,000 Yemeni muslims? Nowhere. Now that Hamas (so known for its integrity and honesty) tells you 30,000 Palestinians are dead you auto believe it? Why because they are the "oppressed"? Your lack of critical reasoning as well as history and ethics leads to only one conclusion. The difference is Jews are involved. Otherwise you would be 100 times more outraged at Syria and SA. Sometimes the powerful IS THE RIGHT SIDE. Where do you get your moral compass from? Disney?
Go learn how to think for yourself instead of repeating the same echo chamber diatribe you are getting form your leftist friends.
Israel isn't South Africa. US is closer to apartheid than Israel.
Look at where we are in South Africa and rethink. We are collapsing as a country. No water, no electricity and no services.
@@wannenburgg You were taken over by Communists, and they are the people behind the WEF.
Russia is fighting the WEF, the worlds mortal enemy.