Nuclear Engineer DEBUNKS HORRIBLY WRONG Nuclear Themed TikToks
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
- Original Videos (in order of appearance):
Silly Chernobyl AI: www.tiktok.com/@legend_of_lor...
Nuclear Greenhouse Gas Emissions (really?): www.tiktok.com/@climatecrisis...
Nuclear Winter: www.tiktok.com/@humanreaction...
Elephant's Foot: www.tiktok.com/@thehappydead/...
Tsar Bomba: www.tiktok.com/@quirkyquest5/...
NUKEMAP by Alex Wellerstein: nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ - Наука та технологія
Thanks so much for watching! For more details on nuclear winter, please check out: ua-cam.com/video/QBeSNsyLuw8/v-deo.htmlsi=7l5Afqx11oavfzYF
You really need to pull down that totally flawed video about that 100 micro Watt battery claiming it can charge a phone. It's super idiotic cause a modern phone uses 1000 times more power just in standby and even if you turned off the phone completely, it would still take more than 10 years to charge it. Rather, you can earn a ton of credits by making a debunking video concerning the applications for nuclear battery technology considering isotopic power density and beta (or alpha or gamma) voltaic energy transfer efficiency. Even the most radioactive (most isotopic power) isotopes wont ever get close to the power density of Li-Ion besides being extremely dangerous and expensive. Tons of stupid videos are made of it and sadly you joined the crowd of stupidity. Go fix it, and you will be a hero of science 🙂
Should look at Rojothern's videos on nuclear stuff. There are two, but they're pretty good.
You know Tyler's already fed up when he doesn't bother doing his intro.
I'm sad you didn't start the video with "Hi I'm a nuclear engineer with over 10 years of experience" part of your intro :( , still very good video, also I suggest not looking at videos with creators who have ai voices or ai art as many of them can be very misinformative.
He got emotionally damaged by AI videos, that is why he didn't say the line.
I like the new Intro. It seems more to the point and like personal
@@sir_no_name1478it's less personal and so worse
I think something quick and snappy like this works for reacting to the equally fast-paced TikToks, but I'd be sad to see the old one go.
Yeah I rewinded the video thinking I missed the intro 😂 I think debunking is the point of the video.
You know Tyler is annoyed when he doesn’t say “I’m a nuclear engineer with 10 years of experience in the commercial nuclear industry. From engineering to operations to emergency response. I don’t claim to know everything but I can certainly share some knowledge.”
Inspiration from skube587 for the original comment, I just wanted to add a bit more.
I'm starting to wonder if rebranding nuclear power plants as "quantum energy generation centres" would finally get the public to support them. I really suspect the majority of opposition to nuclear power generation is the result of people remapping their fears about nuclear war onto anything nuclear.
Who could forget that iconic Call of Duty level, where you go to Pripyat and snipe the terrorist in the Disney Castle? Ah, memories...
Hi , greating from France , keep your good work going . You were able to change my mind on the nuclear energy , i just needed someone to argue with scientific facts . Thanks for "all" your works.
Thanks so much!!
@@tfolsenuclear No no, thanks to you . There's a lçt of engineers talking and reacting about nuclear stuff,but you are the only-one who's able to challenge "myself"(sorry but i'm french ).
@@guillaumeberger3598 It's very impressive of you to realize that you NEEDED to be challenged like that, and excellent that once you learned from this amazing nuclear engineer that you said to yourself (and now even to us!) that "Hey, I was wrong about this stuff!", so 'kudos to you'. And yes, this man seems to be quite sensible about what he knows, which is very helpful of him. I'm glad to hear that you have changed your own mind. That's not easy for (too) many of us!
"50,000 people used to live here. Now it's a ghost town." - CoD Modern Warfare (OG)
I think there was a literal Chernobyl map in MW
The Elephant's Foot was lethal in about 3 minutes of exposure when it was first discovered about 6 months after the accident. It may have been as hot as about 1800 Celsius when it formed, but its surface cooled to near room temperature by the time it was discovered; it has not moved a centimeter since that time. The picture showing it as appearing to be hot was actually lit by Kornyev's flashlight with long camera exposure; the room is and always has been black dark. By the time Kornyev photographed himself in the room (ten years after the accident) the time to lethality was more like 30 minutes; today it is more than an hour (38 years after). Kornyev was interviewed in 2015 in retirement, 20 years after his photo session with the Foot.
I fully agree with the nuke engineer. No one wants nuclear bombs ever used again; hell, I don't want any bombs used again, but both of these videos are fear-mongering for shock value. That is simply stupid and has no place in serious discussions about nuclear physics and technology. Stick to the facts, and leave the opinions at home.
i lost braincells and earned them back at the sametime
Yeah, this was a 'break-even video' overall. :D So painful...
the tsar bomba one gave me brain damage I think.
That AI art while nothing like reality, is pretty cool for a sci-fi post apocalyptic setting
So AI is moron. It's a machine garbage in garbage out. The Google AI puts me in Illinois when I live in Indiana
@@GrantWaller.-hf6jnPlease type properly bro, I can't take you seriously when you sounding like that 😭🙏
@@ILikeMen823oh I sound like that when I am ranting. Thus G rant. Thanks for wanting to take me seriously. Some times the hype of AI technology makes point out it is a tool. It puts my home cell tower 50 miles away from me and I get ads that basically say commit vote fraud. And FYI you are not the first person to say that to me. My friends say. Yes I know how to speak Grant.
The really frightening thing about these Tik Toks is, people out there actually believe this nonsense!
Most TikTok users should start their intro with "Hi I am a 12 year old adolescent and have made up some BS story with some copy/paste from YT videos to impress my even dumber friends"
That should be required.
why did i read that like tyler's own full intro
@@varahunter68 because I wrote it w/o seeing the intro hahaha
why the heck does that one image place a WW2 British barrage balloon over the Chernobyl reactor?
I identified the reactor facility you reference working at from various clues, and obviously will not name here, but given the age of that plant, I was amazed looking at the site view how few waste storage casks there were stored on site. It really brings home just how low the volume of waste generated is from nuclear facilities.
HOW. HOW.
Rainbolt
Is it a BWR PWR ?
That tsar bomba tiktok at the end reminds me of when you have that one friend that insists just one atom splitting has enough energy to be as strong as a nuclear nomb.
0:52 possibly centrifuges for uranium enrichment?
I love when people go on about how unsafe they are and the hazardous health effects. When more people die from second-hand smoke exposure every year than the entire history of nuclear accidents. Or the idea that the HLW will be weaponised and used to spread radiation over a great mass of land. If we had that much HLW, maybe we'd have solved the energy crisis by now.
First I like the new intro.
Second I thought about the decay heat and tought that you could use heat pumps to distribute it into different homes. Therefore you would have a lot more usage out of the fule.
Even after it is spent.
Thanks tyler, I love learning from you everyday!
I see so many people worry about nuclear winter, but I've never seen a good take on what's going to happen when a full nuclear exchange destroys every logistical center and oil refinery in the country. Yeah, you can grow food, but good luck shipping all of it where you need it, and good luck keeping a fraction of your industrial base running. I have a hard time seeing how you avoid a complete systems collapse like the Bronze Age Collapse.
Just so happened to stumbled upon your channel very interesting, funny and informative thank you
This is the real reason we need to ban TikToff 😂
@erheheh Aren't crappy misinformation videos the majority of TikTok content though? (I've never used it, so this is just an assumption based on what little content I've seen elsewhere)
The people ruin TikTok, blame the people not the platform
@erheheh Except no one in Congress is seriously trying to ban cars for me to make fun of.
@erhehehYes. It does. You should try it for a change. This is two posts in a row where you clearly didn't, and your second one you managed to imagine I'm the one who didn't understand. 😒
Imma start spreading that name thx
guy is flying in the air , he doesn't need shelter
have you ever seen a fire in a cooling tower before?
TikToks raise MY risk of cancer. Primarily brain cancer.
the first TikTok here is very obviously fully-automated AI generation farming content
When I set off a '100MT Tsar Bomba' I noticed that my blast effect radius went exactly as far as your map, so that wasn't the 50MTons that the Tsar was as detonated. They set it to "only" 50 megatons because it was going to have NASTY-gross fallout otherwise, and it wouldn't be worth them doing that even to show off, so the Tsar COULD have had another 50MTon stage for a full 100 megatons of blast equivalence, but they set it off as only 50...which gives me an outer blast radius just short of Fredricksburg. :) Setting to 100 gives me your result, but the '50 MTon As-Tested Tsar Bomba' preset comes out to an air-burst blast reaching only to Stafford/Baltimore.
Also, the 50/100Mton Tsar Bomba presets are much more exciting for fallout maps, with hot-green (500 Rem) in the center, then Orange out to a bit past Arlington so the 'green area' would be INSIDE the fireball anyway so who cares about 500 Rem of fallout/exposure. Red (20PSI blast wave/Heavy damage) extends to Takoma in the north and Alexandria in the south. 5psi (moderate) blast damage goes to Fort Washington in the south, and Aspen Hill/Almost to Rockville in the north. Wild. Thermal Burn limit is 60km, which is all the way to the outskirts of Dahlgren or Stafford in the south, and Eldersburg/the city-center of Baltimore in the north. Those 'Thermal Burn' victims are third-degree burned anywhere they are exposed to the blast's light. Also maybe blinded, of course, even just from reflections.
Turning on "Fallout modeling" gives me an 'Up to 100 rads' fallout channel leading halfway to College Hill from the detonation site...so anyone in something strong enough to survive the nuclear fireball will not be coming out any time soon. 'up to 10 rads' fallout goes most of the way to Newark, and 'up to 1 rad/hr fallout' extends to some area a bit past a line drawn between Philadelphia and Reading. It doesn't have a convenient end-city-marker in the map result I got. 220km estimated '1 rem/hr' fallout plume, for whatever that's worth.
End America? Nooot nearly. Cause a TON of special elections? Definitely. Plus side; the gridlock on the Hill would surely end after that!
Edit/reply to add, "The fireball and stuff is way different for the 50Mt Bomba because it was a MESSY weapon, but we DO know exactly what it would do...we saw it on film, even, so the '50Mt Bomba preset' option is way more fun than just entering '50000ktons' and hitting Detonate." More fun than the 100, even.
In 1818 a volcano in Indonesia blew up and put enough ash in the air to cause there to be no summer that year. Humanity survived that winter. In 1888 there was the Krakatoa volcano went off in Indonesia. There was still a summer that year, but the winter was brutal.
Sunsets were very beautiful for several years after the volcanos.
The nuclear exchanges wouldn’t be as devastating as those two volcanoes
9:27 fun fact there are actually 2 more dangerous corium masses in Chernobyl. The Heap is only a bit bigger and more dangerous than the elephant's foot but The China Syndrome (yes that's it's actual name) is roughly 3x more radioactive and is a hell-of-a-lot bigger.
Where are these wonders? I've never heard of them in the literature I've read. By far the worst concentrations of radiation outside the inside of a running reactor are the masses of fresh spent fuel rods moved out of the reactor and into the cooling pools. Yet they are handled readily (underwater, for sure) without harm to the technicians.
The China Syndrome is a fictional disaster thriller movie from 1979.
@@firstletterofthealphabet7308 Yup, it was. But people have been (erringly) referring to the possibility ever since.
Some of those videos probably got generated using Fujiwarachoki money printer app
My heart goes to v the family in Brazil! Especially the little girl setting on the floor playing with cesium 137 ! That family infected 1,000's and in 2017 66 had died from radiation! It's a captivating sad story! The amazing blue powder fascinated them to their death!
i mean hiroshima is a bustling metropolis nowadays. no one was walking around with extra limbs or eyes.
Hey there Tyler, I am a high school student working on research paper for a class. I was wondering if I could interview you and ask some questions. I am not educated on nuclear, but I have been using your videos and as reliable sources as I could find. My questions might not be very difficult, but I thought it might make a nice video to condense some of the more commonly asked questions along some that you might not have encountered. Love what you do and keep up the great work.
These videos that he is reacting to, are the reasons why people have a hard time accepting nuclear power. There is so much misinformation out there that i even laugh at it
utterly insane
It's hard to even conceive how far things would need to scale to match those giga tsar bombas
Could a power plant that big power the UK?
I found this by encountering in recomended 24s ago
Nice video.
Frankly if someone is getting their information from TikTok and genuinely thinks it's a reliable source, they're probably a stinky bum bum.
Could you maybe do a video about how we currently deal with nuclear waste products, how long they have to be kept safe and what plans there are to keep them safe for that amount of time?
at 12:16 the picture looks bad because the light conditions were bad. If you take a photo in a dark place you got all this grain
The last tiktok also said, that the TSAR-Bombe is the largest bomb ever created by humanity - which isn't even remotely true. It may be the largest nuklear bomb, but there are much bigger hydrogen bombs in the US arsenal.
I remeber reading that there is no point to going higher then 100 megatons because more then that and the effects are wasted into space instead of spreading out more.
It’s interesting how bad AI is. It’s decades away from making convincing videos.
Id say longer.
sad reality is there are some people who do find it convincing.
Fear equals clicks
How much electricity does 1 of these 3:50 containers produce?
Going to make a couple of quick comments as i came here from the short, then watch the full video so apologies if either of them were raised in this full video.
Whilst a Tzar Bomb wouldn't normally be able to contaminate the entire US with ust 3 bombs, if converted to a cobalt bomb it might actually be able to do it, (and probably more). Those things are kind of freaky with the potentiol they have for rendering huge area's uninhabitable for a very, very, very long time.
The US, and presumably Russia did run concept studies on detonating very large, (Multi-Gigaton), bombs in very low orbit as a way to hit continent sized areas with extreme thermal pulse. The low orbit location would mean for a very large radius the atmospheric attenuation would be greatly reduced, and the high yield would keep the thermal pulse effect intense enough to be dangerous over that kind of effective radius.
hold up the waste heat from the waste, why aren't we making the caskets with peltier, effectively making the waste heat into an RTG of sorts?
Deadliest room in the world lmao. How about an inside of a tokamak?
sometimes AI art hits a very specific spot in the uncanny vally that gibs all the good existential liminal feels :3
To anyone who wants to see him react to the full thing, the linked video in the description doesn't contain it. It's a pity, because the video he's reacting to actually contains most of the things he's commenting about. 😁
that first one with the weird AI art, the words being spoken sound an awful lot like @KyleHill's words... makes me think they plagiarised some of his work
elephant's foot tiktok also.
The second tiktok pissed me off so much
Could we just spam report it for misinformation?
TikTok is a cancer to our society, great work by the way.
Oh. Oh no. I left a comment saying something along the lines of "this is surprisingly un-shit, considering it's TikTok" on the previous TikTok reaction video. This one made it up 100x. What even AAAAAHH! Make it stop 😓 By the way, if someone claims that three of the lowest quality TikToks are enough to make the USA uninhabitable, I'd believe it. Doesn't even require a bomber.
It’s nice of you to credit the original creators of the TikToks even though most of them except one is spreading misinformation
Theese people on tik tok usually just use AI generated pictures and voice to make videos (some even go far enought to let AI write the script)
If you would like to review a video based on something related to nuclear energy, I would suggest the following video on nuclear weapons. It's been a while since I took AP Physics, but the science is pretty well presented. There aren't too many places where they talk about lithium 7 being the key for hydrogen bombs.
ua-cam.com/video/QHL2nTFPdpg/v-deo.htmlsi=QFiavKWxk11SZsXh
PS. Did he catch the news on or read the actual study on ion beam bombardment of Lithium creating safer nuclear fission?
Keep going
Pretty sure that first TikTok was 100% AI generated. Everything is off in so many ways.
Have you heard of the super powered nematode worms of chernobyl. Maybe radiation can give super powers☻
One of my new favourite channels! I’ve literally been binge watching all your videos whilst preparing for my exams 😂❤ hello from England 🏴
Thanks so Much! Welcome Aboard!
It's great that everyone can have a platform to reach others, but it's also really really bad 🤷♂
If that was the most deadly room in the world we should be over the moon from happiness.. there are places that will make you braindead because you wanted to steal a poster..
make video about CANDU please
i’m curious how the way the war in Ukraine has affected Chernobyl
i don’t think the russians have touched and would touch chernobyl
@@ThatWeirdBarrel they did though right? i remember reading about how at once point at least it was under russian control
@@NithinJune probably sorry i thought you were talking about bombing
Nile red made a new video
This is another reason why Tik Tok needs to not exist.
We have things much larger than any nuclear bomb, they are call volcanos. Krakatoa exploded at around 200 megatons, 4 times the size of the size of Tsar Bomba, yet Indonesia is still there. Tsar Bomba was a weapon of propaganda, not war, it produced almost no fallout, being mostly an air detonated hydrogen bomb. Nuclear weapons generally have this funny place, any war the goal is to ether take land, or force a change of administration in the government you are fighting, without creating a flood of refugees. Nuclear weapons aren't really a good idea for ether, beyond ether shock value, like WW2 or threat value, like the cold war, outside of those two things, they are pretty useless.
And this is why I don't like tiktok 90% of the stuff I have seen on there is off the wall and or stupid.
Tiktok - the greatest source of reliable information :)
wait i just realized, you're a nuclear reactor
haha good joke
Despite the fact we have Mr Folse to give us the correct information, I feel like those tiktoks made me dumber anyway.
I'd bet good money that first video was also written by "AI", probably that second video as well. If that second video was sincere, the person does not even know what a nuclear power plant looks like, they think coal power plants are nuclear, but in all likely hood it is probably written by chatgdp as the imaged are clearly generated.
Some people only get their information from shows and movies, that bald guy is one of them. That must be the kind of guy who thinks "life as we know it" means all life because he can't imagine anything outside what he thinks he knows.
The last one is another guy who gets his information from fiction. If the Czar Bomba was that powerful Russia wouldn't be a country anymore. I wander is this written by chatdgp too or is this guy that thick.
Hi Tyler! I saw a video earlier and figured you'd probably get a good video out of it lol (They talk a bit about mass extinction events, including a possible nuclear war)
ua-cam.com/video/2I5oEZECX_g/v-deo.html
Also, props to you for making so many informative videos, and helping educate the public on our best way to get energy! (At least, until fusion becomes viable in like 20 years lmao)
The AI stuff at the beginning is part of a horrible trend that has been increasing a lot lately, it was shown by Kyle before which at times even uses stolen content for example parts of his video on the Chernobyl dogs and it's mass spammed by people to farm views.
This stuff is infuriating.
I understand the calculated, estimated number of human deaths per wattage caused by nuclear energy is a tiny, tiny fraction of the same figure for coal or oil energy. Really, if it hadn't been for the Democrats' own scaremongering against nuclear energy preventing us from adopting it on a larger scale, their electric car switchover would be a few steps closer to being practical now. Not quite there yet, but decades closer than it is as it stands.
y
Doooeeeessss anyone wonder WHY today's youth is soooo stew pid ???
Tiktok.....tiktok is a big contributor !
Hate the fake creators pushing this AI garbage, not the platform. Sure, they could do better with moderation, but currently it's an awful game of whack a mole. 🙄
@jlp1528 no, tiktok is garbage. It pushes the most degenerate behaviors to the front, and suppresses any content that isn't trash
@@John-ir2zfsomething tells me you aren't much smarter than your average tiktok user.
@paulisfat8077 what would make you assume that ??
Let me guess, the misspelling, right ??
Or the fact that I grade between 139-141 on the intelligence quotient scale ?
I guess even with your comprehensive knowledge of things, you hadn't figured out how to get around youcensortubes flagging and removing comments that they consider demeaning to the lesser minds ?
How about you run back to tiktok and ingest some more 30 second idi0t programming, it seems to do you well.....
@paulisfat8077 oh.... and what would make you assume that ?
Is it the PURPOSEFUL misspelling ?
Or me being in the 139-141 intelligence quotient range ?
Perhaps with your vast intellect, you hadn't figured out how to get around youtubes flagging and removing comments that it believes are demeaning to lesser minds ?
Please do nit lie about coal power plant. They are safe and clear
Am wondering if there's any model that explains precisely why some isotopes are radioactive and others not?
What are the limits of how big an atom can without having instant fission of the atom?