Ex-TMZ Employee Says Original Johnny Depp Kitchen Video Was Edited
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 тра 2022
- Morgan Tremaine, a former TMZ employee called by Johnny Depp's team, explained how he received the video of Depp slamming kitchen cabinets. Tremaine stated that the video he received was different than the video played in court.
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard #LawAndCrime
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Written Coverage & Analysis of Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial:
lawandcrime.com/?s=Johnny+Depp
lawandcrime.com/?s=Amber+Heard
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on UA-camTV!
tv.ua-cam.com/users/welcome?...
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK UA-cam CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Channel B: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel C: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel D / @lawandcrimebodycam - Розваги
This dude gained way more than “15 minutes of fame”….he gained the world’s respect and admiration. Well spoken, articulate, and smarter than Heard’s attorneys.
He indirectly called AH a "B list celebrity" at the beginning .... hahaha, love it..
I loved his response “you could say the same about you for representing Amber Heard”😂
He only has the respect and admiration of UA-cam commenters. Nobody important.
@@asimhussain8716 The truth will set you free.
yes! bright young man
"A little argumentative, don't you think?"
"Oh hardly, I find that to be purely logical"
YES, SIR!
LyricalWax...I know judge Penny got a kick out of that 👍🏽
@@stoneymcbutters Are you heaping coals of fire on your own head, Nicholas?! 😁😁😁
That was rich coming from her and what she had just said.
he said it with Jordan Peterson's voice I swear, even if I'm not the biggest fan of the dude it made me laugh so much
nascentKiller I thought Peterson was in the room for a split second
His response was so measured and honest, he gave the lawyer back her own medicine and humiliated her
Elaine totally deserved the humiliation
"Sounded like he was going to engage in hearsay" so unprofessional for a lawyer to be objecting to something someone hasn't even said
She was really scared he would say that the email was from Heard. Or said something that indicates that it was from her. She wanted to preempt it because once it’s out, it’s out. They can strike testimony from the record but the reality is that the jury heard it.
She didn't want him to reveal the source for sending the video, which was Amber herself. Or to reveal the address attached with the video in the dropbox.
@@ShabazzTBL Saw your reply too late. I said the same 😄👍🏽
How could Amber's attorney even think she sounded intelligent...reallly?
Elaine has a Crystal Ball apparently!!
Him putting Elaine in her place was GOLD!!!!!! She just assumed that he was some cheap guy that used to work for some gossipy tabloid, yet he was wayyyy more quick and sharp than her. What a fab job this guy did as a witness, much respect.
People may look down on TMZ for the line of work they're in but they are very good at what they do.
Dude works for twitch
I enjoyed the Depp team's enjoyment at that comeback. Such a cute moment.
@@lxttiedxll959 I'm not saying that he's not clever, but you could tell that Elaine doubted him at first. But yeah he was a great witness!
That’s because their witnesses are like that what she might think about him)
“Your 15 minutes of fame” that was so disgusting, shaming someone for speaking out the truth, that clearly shows Amber has nothing on this case .
How did the judge even let her ask something like that. It has nothing to do with him getting "fame". He is a witness just like others and just speaking behalf on what happend?!?!
I’m so happy that he successfully defended himself in that moment and made the perfect comeback at the lawyer!
U mean how dirty they play and that Cam could have said that to every expert they called in who hasn't seen Depp nor treated him. From doctors to all "experts" they have called to the stand against Depp with insane money just to testify against him
her lawyers are as terrible as her
I had liked this judge so far, but I don't understand her reasoning behind allowing that question to be asked.
Amber Heard's attorney thought she had an easy target with this guy. She was wrong. He is clearly smart, quick thinking, had his information together, and didn't get rattled by her interruptions.
She's too old, losing whatever edge she may have had.
She was shredded and roasted real good.
Heard’s lawyers have misjudged just about everybody in this trial, but the worst may have been their own crackpot doctor who acted like a real nutjob on the stand.
@@MrJamberee That guy really rubbed everyone the wrong way - particularly the jury.
@@elsajones6325 It has nothing to do with age. People don't turn this nasty just because of age. It's imbedded in her personality.
However, Dr Spiegel probably would explain her behaviour as a cognitive decline due to ... whatever 😆
“15 minutes of fame”. He’s not the one who’s currently going on a press tour to tell everyone that the judge and the jury were wrong 🤡🤡
Right 😂😂
😂🙌🏽😂😂🎯Hr gets the last laugh😂 a
And lying that there was all this evidence that we just couldn’t see in the trial lol
The irony is that her mentioning that he was seeking "fame" actually led to him getting his 15 minutes of game.
This man must have felt bad for Johnny being falsely accused of domestic violence. A man standing up for another man. Good job!
Love to see it.
A human being for another. No one deserves to have their name dragged through mud.
Amber is showing the worse qualities in many women.
Hopefully men learn to identify abusive women fast then move in a different direction.
Hopefully this helps equalize the law in family court.
I am a woman and I'm not influenced by this want to be a star A.H. If it wasn't for him she would still be a stripper and a nudes. That's what she was before him. Jealously is a mental health problem and so is pride.
This man is not standing up for "another man." He is standing up for the truth. But I doubt very much you would understand that.
I hope this guy isn't going to be effected negatively by coming forwards. Brave to speak out.
I think TMZ will be blessed for having him that all their sources were verified before they bring publicly like people will watch even more now since they’re very credible on their stories and not just a hearsay!
I hope TMZ gets taken out because of this guy.
No they won't be. They're annoyed at Amber Heard.
TMZ must rather appreciate that they have or had such an honest person working for them. It will be shame if they witch hunt this guy.
No, this guy helps the credibility of TMZ
He actually made TMZ more reputable by stating they don't personally edit any videos. I wouldn't say he's a hero, because he doesn't work for TMZ anymore, but he went above and beyond for the sake of the truth when he had nothing to gain.
And he will make people afraid of TMZ by calling it a “very litigious organization”. Nice press, I’d say,
He basically confirms what most assume. And he didn't say they don't edit, just that when they do they make a clear indication with a whiteout screen, but it's usually just for time and relevance. Don't really check tmz stuff often, or ever so not sure how much they do it.
Also acknowledged they go through a process to obtain copyrights, which again is just confirming what is obvious. I really don't know why they even bothered to try to stop him. Unless Amber actually went into in depth negotiations with tmz to smear Johnny, which would I suppose open them up to a defamation suit by Johnny, but with a far stronger case than he had against The Sun.
It's amazing how you support johnny, yet you support killing Ukrainians.
@@EricLing64 because it shows that AH lief and herself send it to TMZ and edited it beforehand. That shows that she did want to hurt his reputation which then strengthens his case. Without that guy you had 0 proof for that. And the reason TMZ didn’t want that was probably to the connections with her PR team
In fact he did so adding a little dignity for their proffesion which is saying a lot for their historically bad rep. Why would TMZ be mad quite contraire !
Thanks to the judge for overruling the objection for the “15 mins of fame” question. Else we would have missed one of the epic responses of this decade.
The jury doesn’t overrule anything lol the judge decides what information can be presented to the jury and therefore is the one that sustains or overrules objections
@@blazaybla22 smartass ... it was meant the judge obviously
8:37 'You are welcome to speculate. I can see the same thing by taking Amber Heard as a client for you.' Draco Malfoy is savage and leaves Elaine Umbridge speechless!
Draco 😂
Lmfao it was funny
Laughed so hard. Lmaoooo
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💯💯
She did the same thing to that woman at the end. That's all she has for normal people.
This guy is a hero for just coming up and telling the truth.
Johnny should hire this guy. He has integrity
Project Veritas type to be sure 😉
He's a great witness
Yes the subpoenaed hero who didn't have a choice just doing this out of the goodness of his desire to protect himself from legal consequences.
And Kate Moss
He deserves 15 minutes or more of fame. His testimony at the end was priceless!
He can be seeking his 15 minutes and still be telling the truth.
@@MrJamberee irrelevant...he was a valueable witness
@@kimmyfreak200 It’s not irrelevant. He was asked the question. Your reply is irrelevant.
@@MrJamberee Cope
Thank God did. How are you doing ?
Amber deserves jail time . As a REAL DA survivor and someone with PTSD and like many other women who are REAL survivors and who have PTSD want her in prison for faking all this and her PTSD..it's sick to see people say she is a victim. She indeed is not .
agreed !
I completely AGREE 💯
Class action lawsuit!
How do u know? U can’t speak for herself? You don’t know what happened in her life! So stop judging her you have not been in her life only her and Johnny knows the truth 🙄
@@alexabagacina940 so are you one lying byacch too as you feel compelled to defend your lying queen bee?
Camille is a freaking genius…. The way she was able to ask the question so he could say who without saying who…… omg I love her
She is good!!
That was what the whole subpoena was dependent on. They tried to block him from testifying because he would be forced to reveal his source. So Camille immediately knew she had to implicate amber without having him say it outright. Of course everyone already put it together by now anywau
why can't Morgan say it was amber!? i don't understand this
its not like its hearsay or anything.........
its 100% proof.. amber sold tmz the video
@@yianhinsaechao7898 Because of the freedom of the press and their ability to withhold their sources is part of their reporting. TMZ pays for anonymous sources all the time, the only thing that could’ve proven this anymore is if he was able to show receipts that they paid her. Otherwise he is saying that it is her indirectly and that this is all an inference. By saying that the video was edited, proves that she edited it. Not TMZ.
@@yianhinsaechao7898 as a journalist, your sources are everything. If you reveal your sources when the court asks, there's literally no protection for freedom of press, which violates the first amendment. It's kind of a chain reaction
I probably shouldn't love the way he insulted the lawyer back, but MY GOD, do I love the way he insulted her back.
No it’s okay we all loved it too 😂
reiphas..Elaine insulted the owner of the Hicksville Trailers too, who testified for Johnny, telling him he just wanted to come on TV.
Loved it too ...the bloke has more integrity than AH lawyers
@@nellsimpson9307 I second that emotion 👍🏽😄
I clapped. She had it coming
I love how Elaine tells the JUDGE “I can ask that” she behaves like a child lol she’s a terrible lawyer & can barely make a coherent sentence
I loved how often she said that throughout the case and was met with "sustained" 😂
I don't think she's a terrible lawyer, I think her client got her in some deep hole with all her lies and she didn't have any good things to go with. One thing this case taught us is, never lie to your lawyers
@@enrico5740 No, she definitely is. While Elaine claimed everyone against Amber wanted 15 minutes of fame, Elaine has been in more than TWO interviews, repeating the exact same lines over and over again. She is still defending Amber and saying the jury was confused and that the Judge wouldn’t allow for their evidence to be submitted into court. It seems to me she’s enjoying the attention and her 15 minutes of fame.
@@enrico5740 if you check the interview Elaine gave later you'll see that she actually is kind of unprofessional, and intellectually dishonest
@@Kemyo0 She's still Amber's lawyer and she has to do everything to protect her clients integrity. There's nothing wrong with what she's doing
"So this gets you your 15 minutes of fame, doesn't it?"
"No, but this comeback is about to."😎
LOLOLOL!!
GIVE THIS GUY THE "GOLDEN BALLS AWARD" FOR TELLING THE TRUTH.
Or getting a huge bag of money out of Depp deep pockets
Agree
Well, he's definitely got some brass balls...👀
LOL “GOLDEN BALLS AWARD” 😂👍🏻
Haha! Agree! And give Camille a GOLDEN TOUGH TITTIES AWARD 🥇 Anyone who has a better name for the female version award? We need that 😄
LOVE how he totally flipped that "15 minutes of fame" insult from Amber's lawyer and turned it right back on her..... she wasn't expecting that! :-D
I loved that so much
A little argumentative dont you think?
@@Arman-ch5vi haha, HE was being argumentative for asking her her own question back?! Don't you love it?! I HATE her legal team. They even "objected" during JD's closing statements. They're beyond ridiculous 🙄🙄
she keeps yelling, pointing, and accusing people then has the gall to call him argumentative when he pointed out the stupidity in her logic. That man is a legend, and Elaine is the meme that she deserves to be.
@@missmew3499 They are ridiculous but I find that a very fitting match for the client in question and the case as a whole.
Omg the first time I watched this I did not catch the exact point that was being made by Johnnys lawyer BUT this time it smacked me right in the face… it takes about 15 min for TMC to legally copyright something as long as TMC receives it directly from the owner… this guy admitted it only taking about 15 minutes for them to slap their copyrights on the kitchen video….. Meaning Amber directly sent that kitchen video to TMZ and immediately gave them copyright permission.
Scary .... AH is scary
Exactly, AH is a dangerous person
Bingo. She basically showed that the only person that could have sent this video and agreed to a copyright deal would be the person that shot the video. It was subtle the way she got that point out there but yes, if you were paying close attention to it you definitely could’ve figured it out. I thought maybe she was going to reiterate that point because of how damaging it is to AH but she just casually left it out there for the jury to notice. Smart lawyer
@@jasonboisseau409 But of course we all know now that Camille broughf it back to light in her cross examination of Amber and also in her closing statement, well done
Yelp ; you got it correct 💯
He was one of the best witness, he destroyed her with facts. The last nail in her coffin.
He basically confirmed it was a direct source that gave the evidence without actually saying it. Smart questioning and smart responses. Love it. 👏
Her questions were brilliant- leading the jury to that conclusion without saying it.. Amazing 👏
I was wondering why this comment didn't pop up much
so good
she is intelligent I love her
Right? Even though he states in the cross that HE doesn't know who the source was, it is very clear by the earlier questioning that Amber sent the video to them. 15 minutes to verify source and get the exclusive right.
Stand up guy. If he receives backlash from TMZ or in his career he should immediately be picked up by someone else. Integrity goes a long way in this world
Correction he doesn't work there anymore but he still deserves success!
He doesn't work for tmz anymore so any backlash from TMZ isn't gonna jeopardize his career.
TMZ loves all publicity. I think they quite thoroughly enjoy that they are getting press by being mentioned in this trial
TMZ only seemed concerned about the actual name of who provided the video be told. This man did not say WHO provided it.
@@taraevans1108 Exactly. Given the time frames he mentioned however, it is implied that the tips came from Amber/her team.
This TMZ manager just won 15 mins of fame in court smashing AH lawyer. “Take my hat off to his bravery.” Beautiful rebuttal!
Depp's lawyer is absolutely brilliant. She basically asked the exact questions that prove Amber Heard sent the video to TMZ without ever asking where it came from. Then they proved she had edited the video before sending it. Elaine's head was spinning!
Her lawyer is soooo bad. Like it’s ridiculous. Who insults a witness like that? It makes you look desperate like you have nothing else to go to….
From what I hear, Elaine is a very good lawyer. It's just very difficult to represent someone who lies so much so it makes it seem like she's a garbage lawyer. I can't say the same for Rottenborn and that other dude that objects to his own questions he asks. The payday for her is awesome either way.
@@xhandhele Idk how she is in other cases but, it's pretty unorthodox to say the least for her to deliberately argue with a witness over pretty much nothing
@@xhandhele I hear that she’s very good as well she does more civil cases which is why she is representing amber. When your going against such a talented prosecutor with a background in criminal litigation such as Camille it can be very difficult since the case also deals with criminal aspects. Civil lawyers are also not as well versed in the objections I heard which is why Camille is so good at them and Elaine is not. Elaine has gotten better at them through the trial I noticed but when your defending someone as mentally deficient as amber heard I think looking like a good lawyer is impossible.
@@xhandhele objection hearsay
Well, she's definitely disrespectful and unnecessarily combative. Very bad for a lawyer whose already on the loser side.
This gentleman is such a badass! He humiliated Elaine in a smart quick and classy way! 👏👏👏
I hope Johnny puts him in a movie.
He sure did!! Great day for Johnnys team!
Nice come back for him! 🤘
He is very smart!
Loved how he brought it back on her about she wanting fame by taking the case. Touché!
Look how confident and flawlessly he is giving all the answers😯
Why aren't judges calling out lawyers for being so unprofessional? Badgering witnesses? It just feels like lawyers get to say whatever they want and the witnesses just have to take it.
I'm actually surprised that the judge allowed him to clapback like that! lol
Any extra involvement by the judge is ammunition for filing an appeal. So far, AH’s lawyers have only been able to complain about what evidence was permitted prior to the start of the trial, and the 1 week break. They haven’t complained much about the judge’s behavior during trial as the judge gave a lot of leeway to Elaine (with her arguing against Camille’s successful objections in front of the jury instead of approaching the bench, not controlling her own witnesses, arguing that she didn’t have any new evidence to waste everyone’s time, objecting with made up categories, not using the microphone properly, and trying to ram through the same questions to AH despite losing to Camille’s objections).
@Denise Scalco Actually, while the question was not respectful, it was essentially a question aimed to undermine his credibility. He was an ex-TMZ employee and could've easily had personal motivations beneath testifying that could shape his testimony in a certain way. And he avoided the trap well.
I noticed when Mr Tremaine was telling his Testimony Elaine was nodding her head agreeing she never lets him finish his answers,
Draco Malfoy really changed to the good side if he stepped forward to speak out in this trial
haha!
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol
Oh gosh they really do look alike 😂😂
Was looking for THIS comment 😂
Dude OWNED Elaine when she accused him of seeking his 15 minutes of fame. What a legend.
And that's what made him famous, just brilliant 😂
where is that part?
@@bexton8137 from 8:10 onwards.
You simply don’t challenge someone who worked with paparazzi and now with e sports. He know how to behave a own an enemy. Classic noob move from her
@@elmonitorrr2978 Big true. This man is nothing but accustomed to banter. Elaine just learned the hard way and is now on her way to 15 minutes of fame via viral humiliation!
Thank you Morgan Tremaine for going against TMZ and AH lawyers and telling the truth in a pilote and professional way. He didn’t snitch, but confirmed what we all needed to know.
Amber was calling TMZ and selling videos to them and others. She’s so disgusting
I don’t think this man is a fame seeker I think he is a journalist and appreciates integrity
I think he's disgusted and he's trying to do something about it. Most men and woman and digits could learn a thing or two from coming forward to expose lies that corrupt
He is not a journalist though is he?
Journalists don’t work at TMZ 😂
@@beamaria4273 Journalists don't excist anymore.
1000th liked and 5 th comment
Did you notice how he sometimes looks at AH's lawyer, even raises his eyebrows at her? He definitely defies her incompetence and I'M HERE FOR IT.
Yes. Almost like he was bracing for more “hearsay” calls haha.
@@ryangoodrich4148 yeah lol
Ikr? Btw, I understand what "hearsay" is but it felt like Elaine was just saying it sometimes to buy herself a few seconds to think. There were a few times where it felt like:
Depp Lawyer: "Did you receive this video in your email?"
Witness: "Yes."
AH Lawyer: "Objection! Hearsay!"
@@johnplaysgames3120 u handsome
YES!! In the very beginning he did what Johnny did sometimes, where he talks, and then stops and looks at AH's lawyer like "now is time for hearsay right? is that coming? okey no? then I'll continue"
He came across as sincere and truthful. His body language didn’t look suspicious and fidgety. Sorry Amber; that was another nail in the coffin ⚰️.
His subtle smile after Elaine objected made my day 😂 His whole presence and testimony made my day!! Amazing young man!
"Hearsay, I think he's about to reveal hearsay your honour".
What is wrong with Amber's lawyers? You can't object based on what you think is about to happen.
She was trying desperately to stop him from saying that Amber sent the video
Perhaps Nostradamus is on her team 🤷♂️
Her lawyers remind me of Phoenix Wright, Ace Attorney.
@@shutterbird13 that’s absolutely an insult to Phoenix Wight. He may be a bit clumsy sometimes (particularly in the first game) but he’s extremely smart and astute. Unlike these clowns Amber found.
If anything I’d say Elaine is more like Winston Payne from PW.
@@jk844100 Elaine is a good lawyer
Its just hard to defend someone that keeps making up stories every 5 minutes
Elaine accuses everyone of being out for their “15 minutes”, but I’d argue that the only reason they’re all in court right now is because her client made false allegations in order to get her “15 minutes” & it backfired 🤷♀️
Fabulous point!!!
I haven’t watch the whole trial, but if Depp witnesses are interested in 15 mins of fame, why wouldn’t Amber’s be? Seems like an inane argument to me.
that was the argument line of the day
When they cannot defend the point, they try to make the witness itself the target.
@@worldpeace8824So true!!!
He is so calm and knew what he talked out. Brilliant honest guy
This dude's response on the 15 mins of fame was everything, very smart guy
“That part was not present in the version we received” - he was so thoughtful in his testimony. Love this guy.
Saskia...Then you missed the whole wonderful retort. Everything is on UA-cam. He's there, red painted nails and all, in his handsomeness.
@@barbaramccormack5612 lol 😂 but yeah he handsome indeed
@@archieeeee 😁👍🏽
Yes, and it was obvious to the jury why Amber Heard was edited out of the video.
He seems like he is the man of his words! ❤️Magic!
An honest and truthful witness who is willing to testify and tell the truth. He has nothing to gain but incur the wraft of TMZ by coming forward. Very brave and noble of him. 👏👍
He might be protected by whistle blowering
I say we'll done ✔ to this guy its show that not everyone is paid to lie like AH team
@@tofurakhanom2644 It would be great if he joined Project Veritas. HE has presence.
But according to AH’s legal team, all witnesses they do not want to hear from, only want to be there for their 15 mins of fame, and no other reason at all!
Will he be paid by JD after? Can you confirm he isn't bias
What a noble TMZ employee! Seriously have so much respect for this guy
That was one of the most important testimonies. Thank you for being so brave to come out to tell the truth. 👏👏👏👏👏
I think this guy's testimony was one of the key factors for Johnny winning this case
@@maayaaize hvhvhhbhvh
Thanks for supporting me. How are you doing ?
The fact that TMZ lawyers tried to stop this guy from testifying shows he is a very credible witness
Well it also was in ernst to stop him because of the gentleman yesterday testifying that all those photos were manipulated in some way.
Also, they don't want their employees (former or otherwise) giving up sources, revealing inner workings, or reversing the narrative that a source is trying to sell because TMZ will be less likely to receive "tips" from celebs who aren't sure if their photos or video are going to get reverse Uno'd on them later. There's a symbiotic sleaziness between celebs and TMZ and ratting out their sources or contradicting their not-entirely-honest PR attempts jeopardizes that.
@@johnplaysgames3120 reverse Uno'd - brilliant!!
@@johnplaysgames3120 100% correct
@@johnplaysgames3120 He also did it brilliantly by not naming Heard as the source, but by his explanation it could have only come from her or one of her proxies.
TMZ definitely wouldn’t come after this guy as he beat it to the punch telling the public how he’s putting himself at risk by telling the truth. TMZ would get heavily criticized for punishing him for doing the right thing.
I hope so
And he should be. That's how this world works isn't it? You know if some worker inside Facebook destroy their server it will be a right thing. But what will happened if everyone knows who did it?
Sadly I think this mvp may experience some backlash. I watched the live and before hand a rep from TMZ was trying to convince the court he should not be allowed to testify in the case. They were not happy with him nor that their objections got dismissed. It's on record tmz objected to the witness testimony
@@prrithwirajbarman8389 uhm...WHAT?
It's all they have
I dont know about you, but, I could watch his testimony a dozen times! He's so well spoken, charismatic, & knows when a trap is being set. The AH team has been known to disrespect & lead witnesses. I love his honesty about what he knows was really in the full video. & he didnt deny knowing about. Because that doesnt change the process of how tee em zee operates when managing media! It's pretty standard practices! They cant twist anything that man had to say. He is so sweet!
I'm watching it again 11 July 2022
@meowskii. Me too. Thats why I returned!
I watch this video all the time. He's very measured and honest. I loved his reply to that "15 minutes of fame" question. Bravo lad. 👏
the guy was really professional. from his testimony alone, he did not really sided with anyone, merely giving facts of what he know when he worked under tmz at the time.
Thanks. How are you doing ?
Thank God for this man. He literally did the correct thing willingly risking his name for Johnny.
Agreed! Brave man. Johnny is coming off as such a good guy despite his very real personal demons. Amber Herd is really showing herself to be an evil gold digger!
100% stand up guy!
BTW of course she summited video.Shes been tapeing him Thur out.why would she otherwise video him .she may have wanted it for her love diary .
@@fridperon9593 perhaps or maybe she was just using him throughout. Seems she set him up multiple times to try taking his career away. In the video he was mad about 600 mil missing. And she laughing it off.
Thanks for your lovely support. How are you doing ?
This man has integrity. He came out and spoke the truth. We need more people like him.
YES WE DO!!!!!
@@NAConen No he wasn't the judge even said he wasn't subpoenaed and came forward on his own in her ruling on why he could testify.
@@NAConen He contacted Camille himself
He didn’t lie because he’s under oath. God praising someone for not lying is exactly what’s wrong with our society. Lack of morals everywhere.
Amen
Every single witness from JD's team was much more credible, respectful, measured, and well prepared than AH's attorneys and witnesses.
This man is just straight up exposing her plans lmao love how honest he is.
“Objection hearsay” before he even says any hearsay, she just assumes he’s going to but doesn’t even let him talk enough. His face every time she says it is hilarious
and that's why it's called "call for hearsay"
@@neitherami6912 it calls for hearsay so "calls for hearsay" not "call for hearsay"
honestly, I think they were afraid he was going to name the person who sent it...
@@arsena5209 you're right, but it doesn't change a thing - "it calls for hearsay" doesn't mean the guy already presented hearsay. Same point, thanks for correcting, peace.
@@sallyclemmer8517 yep, Heard was 💩 herself! 😄
He literally looked at Amber and raised his eyebrows when he said he got the link. He told us with his facial expressions. I applaud this man.
Absolutely. He did it twice if I am not wrong. He knows that the video came from her but couldn´t say it.
I think he was looking toward her lawyers to see if he was going to get another hearsay objection...
I'm telling you without telling you 🤗👏👉
@@criswebb7470 this probably the more likely conclusion he doesn't want to make an assumption even if its likely true
He was staring at Elaine because she kept calling objections and he was checking to see if she was going to object what he says.
God, Amber Heard's lawyer is just extremely annoying, how can you disrespect a witness like that, so unprofessional and cringy
The pause after the “about fifteen minutes” was satisfying, sheer brilliance. They protected the NDA in its entirety while also legally stating where all the staged propaganda came from. That’s genius! On top of finding a way to include him as a late witness due to other acts that are obliged for them to do so in the state that they’re governed in. Heards attorneys are always badgering witnesses even their own witnesses, it must be difficult to be getting asked something and whilst answering having another one fastballed at you mid sentence, and the next being more elusive, as if they are threatening for you to agree with the shenanigans that they’re asking you
The testimony from the former TMZ actually proves the “Defamation” part of the trial since it is AH’s intention to was ruin JD- and this proves it! I rest my case.
yeah thats true they can only get the copyright from the person who flimed it
Yup it adds to her malicious intention.
Totally right ✅ and I loved how he replied to Elaine that think everyone need to testimonie for the FAME !!!!!but we all in the end understand exactly that A. Did it and this changes everything ........
This literally sounds soo much satisfying
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 Clap her in irons ⛓️
That young man is so bright. He’s beyond articulate and shot her bs accusation to pieces. well done young man. Live long and prosper!
10 points to Slytherin!
🖖
You don't have to worry when you're not lying.
But he worked for a trash company sooooo
AH’s acting as if she were another one of the lawyers is really weird.
Omg, her questioning his legitimacy as a witness was absolute ludicrous! Like wtf, Amber’s witnesses were far less credible
Nothing about Amber or the people around her is credible
JD's witnesses never fail to impress me. They are either intelligent, honest, funny or straight to the point.
You’re absolutely correct. That’s usually how people who are honest and telling the truth act. There’s nothing to twist, hide, or add when telling the straight truth
Like JD!
Some of them are all of the above!
Well said 🙌✨
Lol Ambers witnesses are all bugged out on some drug 😂 Johnnys are the real mvps
“Objection. I think he’s about to commit hearsay”
Seriously? That woman is the dollar store generic equivalent of attorneys.
Objecting ahead of time is a smart move when you fear the witness will say something that might sway the jury. It's better to take that chance than not. I don't see how this makes her a bad attourney - quite the opposite.
😂😂😂😂😂
Highest paid lawyer in the room, for real. I agree, terrible though lol
@@spbalance Elaine don’t you have better things to do with your evening? Like practicing turning on your mic?
@@spbalance He wasn't about to sway the jury, he was literally recollecting an event
This testimony was one of the most important part of the trial! Morgan Tremaine was excellent and a hero!
Hello ma’am,
Trust this message meets you well. In my sadness, I hoped for happiness, in sorrow I bore a smile & that is because of YOU, my ever loyal Depphead. Thank you for standing with me through my trial. I’ll like you to send me a message
-telegram- using my
Endeavor to add your name to the text so I can single your message out.i don't reply unsolicited messages.
Warm Regards
JD
Add me up
Chrsjohndepp
So during the years of assaults she endured the only thing she caught on camera was Johnny slamming the kitchen cupboards and then walking away from her.
Amber's lawyers hated this guy because they didn't like the truth 😅
Well yeah, they're representing Amber so of course lol
Thank God some people come in and tell the truth when it is needed.
@@dianenoga8538 these ppl make me believe there's still some good will in this world xD it's good to see people who are willing to do something good for justice.
And the fact that they were so afraid of his testimony only proves their client is guilty
Believe All Women. Depp is at fault here.
This was such an imperative testimony for this case - it shows that the clip was sent in by the source (Amber/Amber's team) and that her intent was defamation of Johnny. Such an important witness to have for the case. Well done to Johnny’s team!
Yeah I agree ☝️
yes the team is doing well to correct the illusions, but once they do that, Amber has not gotten in trouble for any of the lies she has created prior to or during this trial. Can she be jailed or filed with contempt since she in fact is responsible for many of the coverups and all of the lies both her and her family/friends spew?
They should have asked him if he knew how much TMZ paid for the copyright.
@@eliakimjosephsophia4542 i don't think they would have allowed that, confidential and irrelevant to the case. Would have been objected i guess.
It was Amber all the way. Not anyone else
All I can say is that the Jury should be voting right on this one. It is sooooo obvious who is not telling the truth at this point. Even the blind can see.
Does anyone notice how she’s erratically looking up and down as if she’s actually writing something? I can guarantee there’s a bunch of scribbles on that paper. 😂
Most people make one wrong assumption here: That she knows how to write in the first place :D
I saw a clip of Amber's writing. There was no ink in her pen.
@@lizzyny1613 haha just as I thought lol. Hilarious.
@@lizzyny1613 I just saw the video. The paper was blank. Her lawyer behind her was shaking his head. 😭
@@lizzyny1613 you serious!!?! Omg that’s sooo embarrassing!!! I cannot😩😩😩
This guy represents integrity and awesomeness! He did what was right and handled it with honesty. He earned my respect
So much respect for this guy. He put his own career / employment on the line.
@@ummsumayyah5137 he doesn’t work there anymore and hasn’t for a while nothing to do with this
It's a shame integrity is so unpopular today.
He has integrity, that's why he quit being a papp
@hukt un fonix werx fer me 🤣😂 Who ever sent the video got paid They also had no regard in ruining someones life by sending it to the news agency
His testimony was brilliant. No nonsense and straight to the point. I hope he doesn’t face any penalties from TMZ or anything
I believe, he mentioned he's no longer working for TMZ, please correct me if I'm wrong.
@@aldocardetti2248 no he is nt
He probably wont since he already bought to light the fact that doing this might put him on the target of TMZ, and I think unless TMZ is willing to risk a lot they wont bother him since the whole fact is made a public knowledge at this point.
@@HunterIndia he helped them saying that all sources were verified ... giving them sort of credibility ... they should send him a "thank you" basket
@@kacmed lol yeah 😂
Loved this guy and his testimony! He was not rattled stayed steady and told the truth. Truth always prevails!!!
This man came forward with the truth he deserves a metal
A brave and honest individual. He has nothing to gain from testifying and could be jeopardising his job. All of JD’s witnesses have been credible.
He is an "ex" employee of TMZ. He's taking a real big risk just expose the truth bc TMZ could go after him now and sue him
Yes!!!
@@halligraf9131 I agree. There should be an NDA (Non-disclosure Agreement) before he "resigned"/"fired"/"excused" from TMZ. But kudos to him for telling the truth. TMZ either sue him or TMZ will drop charges due to public support.
@@crimson9714 they can't the emergency hearing threw that out
@@JordanDragonAs Ohh, that's good. Then it would be best if they know/track the one who sent the video to TMZ. It best if its Heard or her henchmen.
This guy is so honest and real, the fact he sacrifice himself to reveal the truth, proves a lot
@@humanbeing8400 He's gonna get fired
@@humanbeing8400on revealing the truth and because he has no job anymore
@@humanbeing8400 read the title better says EX TMZ employee
@@humanbeing8400 are you watching the video with ear muffs? Honestly 🤦♂️
@@humanbeing8400 his testimony proves she's the owner of the video and edited it, so it proves a lot about her intentions
This direct examination was masterful. Camille V made it clear via circumstantial evidence that Amber Heard was the source. This insulated the judge’s ruling on TMZ for appeal purposes.
I just watched Morgan do an interview on DUI Guy and I never would have thought he was terrified to go up there, so nervous…especially from the hilarious, infamous comeback he threw at Elaine!! He’s a stand-up guy that just wanted to do the right thing when he was contacted by his friend and knew the narrative about the video wasn’t right. He absolutely doesn’t deserve to get sued and I truly hope they don’t try to go after him…he was extremely careful about what he said and did what should be happening in journalism…telling the truth!! As he said in the interview and it makes complete sense after hearing how nervous he was and it didn’t come across that way to us at all…when you’re telling the truth, it’s easy to answer questions with ease.
Fake johnny Depp scammers are asking for money..stay safe
Lol AH attorney is like “wow you’re argumentative” - when she herself is being demeaning 😂
Then he responds, “I think it is completely logical.”
Elaine used Camille's reason for objecting ("Objection; argumentative") on Sassy TMZ guy. 😂 I bet Elaine is now wishing that that objection was sustained.
Mr. Spiegel was an Angel
Shes gets argumentative with the judge all the time smh. His response to her was GOLD 😂
@@lecheflan4777 Lol that was the funniest part to me
This doesn't only proves she leaked, but she actually sold it to TMZ since they have exclusive rights, if she just wanted to be out there why would she give them exclusive rights, she wanted to ruin his life + make money out of it .
Also edited the content of the video. The next witness also confirmed manipulation of photos.
That video would have been lucrative, posssibly hundreds of thousands of dollars
1:10 to 1:16. This guy is smooth. He didn’t say it in words, just with his eyes.
Not to mention, all the edited photos
@@DanielPestanaTranslations yes he did
Ty I did not see that before
Also go was the tmz guy
When he spoke about the person who owned the video, something like that he took his hand and waved it at amber
Morgan Tremaine is now my hero! Love it when people are not intimidated by a slimeball attorney.
“I think he’s about to describe hearsay.”
Elaine, Jack of all trades, she’s a psychic now!
Respect. This young man was sharp, truthful, and not rude. Can't tell if he was like that before or after working at TMZ, but you can tell he was good at his role.
That to me is the more impressive part. He wasn't there to play games, or to show off, as some tabloid reporters tend to.
Hes a lawyer I think.....
I happen to know him, actually before he worked for TMZ. He's always been that sharp and smart
@@davidazar1723 what's his name?
I am not familiar with video editing so I appreciated the way he explained the jargon and the SOPs that apply to the industry.
Praying that he will get the best company out there! He’s an asset and honest!
Here in Brasil, we call it "INVERTIDA MONSTRA", when the TMZ employee uses the lawyer's own argument against him back to her. Very satisfying 😌 👌.
Hoisted by her own petard
He was very well spoken and is clearly quite intelligent, not something I would have expected from a TMZ employee tbh.
Truthfully, most of the people who work for tabloids have degrees in journalism, politics, etc. and are well-educated. They typically end up at places like TMZ because they pay better than working for legitimate news sources. 🤷♀️
On the contrary, TMZ only hires people good at the job
Same thoughts! 😂
They lost a real one
They aren't that bad IMO, but their lawyers seem like they are, and that's also what I read/hear. And that usually says a lot about the leadership of an organization.
They had lawyers in the courtroom which this video doesn't show (this clip starts RIGHT when their lawyers stopped talking to the judge, IIRC), and they were trying to intervene in the case (on behalf of the defense/Amber) and one lawyer even asked if he could reserve the right to object (only parties to the case can object, like the lawyers, or even Depp himself -- Johnny could even object, but they wanted this right), that the judge rightly denied.
TMZ's owner (CEO? I mean Harvey 😂) is also a lawyer, however, but I feel he should know better then, perhaps, or maybe he just has good reason for things like this, but it seemed like bullying today.
“i could say the same for taking AH as a client”🤣🤣🤣🤣Elaine was put in her place 😂
Was checked💯
LOVED that part 😍
Wasn't she just!
Too bad it backfired and ruined her career instead of helping her gain good exposure lol
On redirect, the way Camille just asks a single question after that slimy slandering cross, the man just answers straightforwardly in a truthful manner and that's it. Truly masterful. She did a great job on that entire case.
Good man. Holds his responsibilities and integrity close and proud. Every so often someone like this pops up, nothing to claim, no benefit, and says it as it is. Respect.
This guy is smart and very well-spoken. Most importantly, he stands for the truth. If anything, he must be rewarded for doing a good job in the industry he's in.
Yet very charismatic.
He’s so chill I like how he operates in the court room
He’s so cute!!
It seems he knows how to communicate in a courtroom, doesn't give extraneous information. Just answers the question.
wow u think someone being honest deserves an award? it's what ur supposed to do...we expect too little these days
"You got your 15 minutes of fame"
"Argumentative!"
"You could say the same about you become Amber Heards lawyer"
"a little argumentative don't you think?"
"Not at all it's purely logical"
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 legend!
😂😂I loved that scene.
@@carola-lifeinparis Absolutely. highlight of his testimony
Not exactly what he said but close
Yeah,this scene makes me laugh out loud.
Yoooo thats epic on another level
The “about 15 minutes” response after Camille Vasquez laid the copyright verification/timeline foundation was such a dagger. Particularly as it comes minutes after Elaine objected prematurely, out of concern he might answer “Amber Heard” by name. They say it’s her w/o saying it and had to be easy for the jury to pick up on.
Seeing the amount of people that have come forward to influence the truth in this trial has been amazing.
How many times is her team gonna pull the “you’re doing this to get famous” card? Like seriously you can’t accuse everyone who comes forward of doing that just because they say something that proves your client wrong
imagine if they asked Johnny that question
@@richardbottom9843 or Kate Moss
literally, if anything Amber Heard thought she would get more fame but ended up being doubtful of if she would even appear in Aquaman
Anybody who is a expert or witness for Johnny depp is automatically biased and seeking fame according to them
Forgive them, they got nothing to say after all, and they have no way to change their position even they finally realize how terrible their client can be.
I love how this guy from TMZ is ironically so far the most eloquent, authentic and genuine witness on the stand. He answers in full sentences, without hesitation, he’s sharp and observant. Mad respect for this young man!
genuine whiteness?
uh, hummm🤔🤔🤔
Surely you meant Witness or did you?
@@rdwngdblkbrd629 Yes I did! I am battling with the German autocorrect of my phone keyboard and it just does silly things. 🙈🙈🙈
YES! He's so brilliant! Honest, doesn't hesitate at all!
He’s not, though. I’m not against him or JD, and he gave great testimony, but the “most”? No. That’d have been any of JD’s doctors.
@@LadyAstarionAncunin Well I meant the witnesses without a professional background, assisting JD. But now that I think about it Kate James was also very entertaining and I loved her no BS attitude.
Q: How long does it take to get copyright ownership of media that comes directly from the source?
A: 15 minutes
Q: How much time passed passed from TMZ receipt of the video until it was published?
A: 15 minutes
BAM. If TMZ had not had proof that Amber Heard sent the video, they would’ve had to verify who owned the copyright and acquire transfer of ownership.
That’s pretty near iron-clad, yet Amber, uh, denied it all under oath on cross.
Her lawyer as so scared he was about to say that he got the email Heard haha.
One thing to note here is that though the guy didn't mention the source, he mentioned that if the videos come from a direct source it takes only 15 minutes to upload it. When Camille asked him about how much time it took him to upload the video of Johnny banging the cabinets he said it was 15mins. So it implies that it was a direct and verified source which can definitely be Amber or her team! I think the juries would take this into account.
Yes that’s why Camille asked him that because he couldn’t say it out right, but the logical conclusion is that it came from her or her team.
Point to be noted
A true queen
@@lovelylangers Camille is such a legend
@@lovelylangers that just goes to show how good she is with her job