Barry: How Barry Berkman Evolves and Devolves

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лип 2024
  • This video essay analyzes HBO's Barry, played by Bill Hader. The character suffers from an inability to take control of his own life, so this video is dedicated to examining Barry's fatalism, psychology and morality.
    PATREON: / justanobservation
    FAIR USE NOTICE:
    This video may contain copyright material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This material is made available under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made "fair use" for the purposes such as criticism, comment, review, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that otherwise might be infringing. All rights belong to its owners.
    Music used:
    C Major Prelude by Bach
    'Moonlight' by Scott Buckley - released under CC-BY 4.0. www.scottbuckley.com.au
    'In Search of Solitude' by Scott Buckley - released under CC-BY 4.0. www.scottbuckley.com.au
    Eureka by Huma-huma
    'Midvinter' by Scott Buckley - released under CC-BY 4.0. www.scottbuckley.com.au
    Beethoven's 7th Symphony (Public Domain)
    Bach Cello Suite No 1, G Minor, Prelude by Cooper Cannell
    Space Walk by Silent Partner
    Timestamps:
    0:00 Intro/Prologue
    3:29 Season 1
    13:17 Season 2
    18:33 Season 3
    24:36 Conclusion
    #barry #billhader #morality
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 411

  • @TheChuckers123
    @TheChuckers123 Рік тому +2224

    BARRY is a rare show that can effortlessly shuffle between being a satirical black comedy one minute and a brutal, bleak character study the next.

    • @andrewstephens5885
      @andrewstephens5885 Рік тому +51

      “There’s no forgiving Jeff!” Was a perfect example. What a brutal but perfect intro to the third season.

    • @toongamer2810
      @toongamer2810 Рік тому +5

      For an anime example of a show that can do this, you may want to try Gintama

    • @toongamer2810
      @toongamer2810 Рік тому +4

      @@Research0digo Most people who heavily enjoy gintama are older than the targeted demographic of shonen jump :)

    • @greentaigo2552
      @greentaigo2552 Рік тому +5

      Bojack Horseman

    • @dudewhy6953
      @dudewhy6953 Рік тому +3

      @@andrewstephens5885 both funny, and truly dark. I love how dark it really gets after season 2. At first I was laughing, then the claws sank in and I just can’t turn it off. Can’t wait for season 4!

  • @Chadmlad
    @Chadmlad Рік тому +1919

    I couldn't believe how heartbreaking this last season was. It went from a sometimes shaky comedy to, honestly, something deeply terrifying.

    • @Tyleradams1301
      @Tyleradams1301 Рік тому +61

      Season 4 is confirmed so not the final season yet

    • @Chadmlad
      @Chadmlad Рік тому +58

      @@Tyleradams1301 No fucking way. I have no clue what route they could take the show at this point

    • @lundylow
      @lundylow Рік тому +72

      @@Chadmlad Have faith in Bill Hader, dude. He brought us this far. Not knowing where things are going is part of what hooked me in the first place.

    • @ThrobbertJomes
      @ThrobbertJomes Рік тому +19

      @@Chadmlad apparently they wrote season four before three was filmed

    • @Chadmlad
      @Chadmlad Рік тому +13

      @@ThrobbertJomes Thats good to hear. Looks like we're going to be starting off right from where we left off

  • @jahcode6132
    @jahcode6132 Рік тому +261

    Dude that scene where he narrates his first kill, and transitions between the acting student's interpretation of the event, assuming he must have been emotionally shaken and broken by taking a life, to what actually happened, with everyone chanting his name and no remorse shown whatsoever, my jaw actually dropped.

  • @emilystrauser
    @emilystrauser Рік тому +1245

    Nobody, including Mr Cousineau, has shown Barry affection without ulterior motives.

    • @MaxPowersUK
      @MaxPowersUK Рік тому +270

      I feel like Albert letting him go in the desert counts?

    • @walkingonsunshine1571
      @walkingonsunshine1571 Рік тому +153

      @@MaxPowersUK I kinda agree, but their relationship is still weighed down by the fact that seeking Albert's approval is one of the things that led him down the path towards violence imo

    • @LAGator-qu7tc
      @LAGator-qu7tc Рік тому +52

      No… not everyone… “dip that toe..”
      Good vibes right there

    • @emilystrauser
      @emilystrauser Рік тому +6

      @@MaxPowersUK I agree with you on that. I posted this before I saw that episode.

    • @JojoTheRed
      @JojoTheRed Рік тому +31

      @@MaxPowersUK He let him go because he owned him his life and his daughter’s existence by association.

  • @billepperson2662
    @billepperson2662 Рік тому +272

    I think the biggest lesson to be learned from Barry (especially the Chris saga) is: don't reconnect with people over Facebook... Just don't

    • @UNUSUALUSERNAME220
      @UNUSUALUSERNAME220 Рік тому +9

      That's the main selling point of Facebook. I never understood it. If there are people in your life that are important to you, they remain in your life. If those people are not still a part of your life, it's because people move on. It may sound detached, but it truly is the way life is. I feel the same way about reunions. Why in the hell would I want to see those people again!? I didn't have a bad time in HS, but I don't care to reexamine those relationships, they do not matter to me anymore. Plus, Facebook has devolved into a sinister entity over the years. That was inevitable. They don't make anything, they do not provide a service (which some would debate) and they are (incidentally) responsible for people turning into phone junkies. Sorry. I guess I took your joke and just went overboard with it.

    • @billepperson2662
      @billepperson2662 Рік тому +2

      @@UNUSUALUSERNAME220 well put!

  • @peerrii17
    @peerrii17 Рік тому +1063

    Barry is one of the best shows out there, it's an uncomfortable watch sometimes, as all the main characters are flawed and have their own selfish motivation, much like real people. It just feels so real. Thank you for the analysis.

    • @Barren_Harem808
      @Barren_Harem808 Рік тому +3

      Sally is very close to not being a good person

    • @recoveringintrovert717
      @recoveringintrovert717 Рік тому +14

      @@Barren_Harem808 Sally isn't a good person. The only reason she wasn't 100% like Barry was because she was sheltered. She was abused, yes, but she was sheltered. She was a "child" like the other actors, as Gene says. She has moved closer to Barry by the end of season 4, giving into her darker and more selfish impulses.

    • @AkaironoUnko
      @AkaironoUnko Рік тому +3

      @@Barren_Harem808 Sally uses other people like Fuches just different methods and circumstances. I haven't seen her make any honest gesture out of kindness to anyone, though, I've only seen 2 season. Idk if she changed in season 3.

    • @nobodyspecial9513
      @nobodyspecial9513 Рік тому +1

      It is based off a real person.

    • @SW-zb6bf
      @SW-zb6bf Рік тому

      horrible take

  • @daschwah
    @daschwah Рік тому +102

    This show is achieving everything Dexter didn’t have the balls to do, and making it feel effortless.

    • @HMSTR1995
      @HMSTR1995 11 місяців тому +7

      I couldn’t quite put my finger on what show this was scratching the itch of, and you’re right, it’s Dexter. Man that show sucked in the end

  • @ididntmeantoshootthatvietn5012
    @ididntmeantoshootthatvietn5012 Рік тому +495

    i love how Barry didnt kill anyone in season 2 until the murderous rampage in the season finale

    • @shrimpmanwhit3621
      @shrimpmanwhit3621 Рік тому +35

      Holy shit you're right!

    • @BroZilla-vh3tu
      @BroZilla-vh3tu Рік тому +61

      also the bullet he loads to kill Esther early in season 2 is used to kill her in the finale

  • @seanlaffey3633
    @seanlaffey3633 Рік тому +471

    That scene where Barry is in Cousenaeu’s house threatening him is so good. That’s the creepiest look I’ve seen on Bill Hader’s face.

    • @iwantgoals1566
      @iwantgoals1566 Рік тому +10

      Just love the way they used show don’t tell to really let you understand the seriousness of that moment. Other shows will spit on your intelligence so much that they’ll actually spell it out for you.

  • @graysonwhite5441
    @graysonwhite5441 Рік тому +87

    Barry in the first season: Starts off bad, tries to become better, ends off even worse
    Barry in the second season: Doesn't kill anyone the entire season, morally becomes better, but the last 10 minutes and he kills 1029312903 people
    Barry in the third season: Doesn't care anymore

  • @SweatyOracle
    @SweatyOracle Рік тому +29

    It’s amazing how universal this show is. I doubt many of us are hitmen. But many of us are trying to escape who they were in order to start a new life/be a new person. And many of us fall and stumble because it sometimes feels impossible, no matter how much we want to be better… often failing due to trying so hard to be better.

  • @wenfin7048
    @wenfin7048 Рік тому +32

    Just my observation but I think that the point of Sara going back and brutally killing her attacker and then shedding one tear shows not how different she is from Barry, but how much given the right ( or in this case, wrong) circumstances, many of us would become like Barry.

    • @bell6dandy564
      @bell6dandy564 Рік тому

      Right! I think it's inevitable that they'll be drawn and stuck together by their trauma and so much else.

  • @carsonclay2965
    @carsonclay2965 Рік тому +289

    This is a great video, you make some great points. Personally, I think Barry is definitely a bad person. He has a million opportunities to turn himself in but refuses to because he feels he doesn't deserve to face the consequences of his actions. Barry is under the delusion that he is the hero of his story, a delusion projected onto the audience because he's the title character. Season 3 is really when the facade breaks apart. Killing Jeff, threatening Gene's grandson, verbally abusing Sally. It becomes harder and harder to root for him until you realize this is who he's been the whole time.

    • @odst2247
      @odst2247 Рік тому

      Would you turn yourself in

    • @joannelee5574
      @joannelee5574 Рік тому +10

      Definitely agree!! Someone mentioned how he’s an unreliable narrator, and I feel like that’s a great way to describe his character

    • @mrnukes797
      @mrnukes797 Рік тому +4

      I also recommend legion a show about Charles Xavier son and trust me you'll love it

    • @balloonfiesta15
      @balloonfiesta15 Рік тому +16

      ​@@joannelee5574 eh, that doesnt really add up. an unreliable narrator is someone who blurs the line between their perception of the story's reality and the actual story's reality. the show has never had a moment where its events are ambiguous in that way.
      i would say he's more of an anti-hero, since he doesn't really tweak the story to his favor the way an unreliable narrator would, its more that we are made to sympathize with him as a protagonist despite him doing awful things.
      like with a lot of anti-hero stories, its very easy for the audience to get confused about the moral alignment of the protagonist. and i would argue this is very much a part of anti-hero stories, its just that sometimes audiences don't always put in the thought work to figure out why the writers are using this storytelling device and the philosophical implications behind that decision.
      in the case of Barry, its easy to sympathize with him because we can see that his profession is slowly tearing him apart and he wants to change. but the end of season 1 pretty firmly establishes that Barry is a bad person. he kills Detective Moss and ruins the life of his mentor for no reason other than he wants to protect his new life.
      its extremely complex but basically, he and the audience want to believe that he can change and grow from the past and we do genuinely start to believe he is capable of that. but by using murder to escape the consequences of his past, he isn't really protecting the positive changes in his life, he's reinforcing the change through the violence of his past. its establishing the paradox inherent to his character that causes him to slowly deteriorate over the course of the show.
      none of that is unreliable narration, its all literally happening in the show's reality.

    • @joannelee5574
      @joannelee5574 Рік тому +2

      @@balloonfiesta15 Just gonna preface that the comment I read was much more well explained, so this isn’t doing their interpretation enough justice lol. He’s definitely an antihero tho!! (Edit: Ig it would’ve been more fitting to say he has traits of an unreliable narrator since I get how it doesn’t completely work with the show’s pov tho)
      Imo it made sense on the objective evil of his actions (especially starting s3) and how he justifies them in a way that’s increasingly based on his specific worldview (which is not good to say the least). It’s almost telltale heart-ish but he’s trying to prove his actual “good”ness vs. sanity. We see everything he’s doing play out directly so his unreliability isn’t particularly deceptive or anything, but it’s visible more in how he defends his actions to himself and why he “had to do it” (like killing moss), like a third person unreliable narrator of sorts. He waters down his actions, and contradicts general moral code to justify why he’s killing with an almost naïveté that everything will be normal if he does this again, but this plays out in third person. He disregards that some of his actions are objectively evil and caused by his own issues (ex. the murderfest at season 2 finale when he kills everyone due to his rage issues), and it pushes the audience to sympathize even when the actions aren’t sympathetic, because we’d like him to have a normal life. It’s just near impossible now.
      Ofc the other person also wrote their comment very well, so there were a lot of things said more eloquently lol. You’re definitely right about him being an antihero too, he’s a super interesting character to discuss 👍👍

  • @tonybippitykaye
    @tonybippitykaye Рік тому +182

    Season 3 was extremely depressing to watch: we had 2 seasons of Barry trying to be a better person only to have him fall straight back into that hole and snap mentally and for the worse. The fact that he’d go as far as to threaten to kill Gene’s family if he didn’t comply and even casually mention to Sally that he could traumatize her boss at BanShe in a pretty sick way made me go from rooting for him to despising him. And then you have the scene with Albert where he viscerally breaks down with all his sins catching up to him, actually being given a second chance, and even THAT not being enough to save him.
    Hader really puts the freaking dark in dark comedy.
    Edit: For the record, I did love this season, it was just sad to see the characters go through such awful circumstances, even if someone like Barry rightfully deserves it.

    • @greentaigo2552
      @greentaigo2552 Рік тому +6

      Honestly seems pretty clear to me that it is at least partially an addiction for him, or at least allegorically used to portray addiction. He hates doing it and hates himself when he does it, but every effort to stop seems useless and season 3 really showed him giving up on trying to be better and completely giving in to that addiction. The fact that he even puts effort into making sure Sally doesn't blame herself for what went down at his house by placing the blame on himself shows that he still is aware and filled with guilt about his situation, but has accepted it as a part of his life he can't escape.

    • @jamaalsmith5626
      @jamaalsmith5626 Рік тому +1

      Okay namby pamby that's enough critter noises out of you!

    • @GiselleKlara
      @GiselleKlara Рік тому +2

      I think there was an element of comedy in his ideas on Sally's boss or whatever. "Like switch her dog with a slightly different dog" ....imagine some guy turning up at the pound saying "I'd like a dog that's LIKE this one, but not this one"

  • @ellicel
    @ellicel Рік тому +281

    I avoided this for the longest time because I hate casual violence on tv and I’d heard the show was a comedy. So I thought the violence would be gratuitous. Once I did give it a chance I realized that it really was quite a deep character study that surfaced many uncomfortable questions for the audience to chew on. Barry’s ethical quandaries in light of the question of whether people can really change are really very relatable. We all hurt people around us with some of our choices; we’ve all used excuses to justify our behavior. And I think there are many times when we feel “forced” by circumstances to act against our better judgment. In the end, I even appreciated the use of extreme violence as Barry’s chosen “profession” definitively answered the ethics of the actual killings so that the viewer can examine the individual decisions and circumstances that caused such destruction. It’s easy to like Barry, to want to find a way out for him. But his extreme actions make it impossible to look away from the reality of what he is.

    • @yoinksp8972
      @yoinksp8972 Рік тому +7

      Nice

    • @mossbased
      @mossbased Рік тому +3

      I think that’s a major point of the show though to show this casual violence and these awful men who never get caught or have any consequences and are glorified

    • @iwantgoals1566
      @iwantgoals1566 Рік тому +3

      The show doesn’t make violence “casual” or glorify it. It makes you really appreciate how serious and destructive it is by going out of its way to point out the intimate gruesome details.

  • @crimsonking440
    @crimsonking440 Рік тому +637

    All the acting in this show is top notch, but Sarah Goldberg really stole the show with that final episode.

    • @andrewstephens5885
      @andrewstephens5885 Рік тому +39

      For this show, That was pretty horrific! Reminded me of when the cartel and law timelines cross in better call saul.

    • @deadchanneldontwatch7347
      @deadchanneldontwatch7347 Рік тому +17

      @@andrewstephens5885 looks like Sally was in the middle of something...

    • @ulicesvilla6995
      @ulicesvilla6995 Рік тому +11

      @@andrewstephens5885 the show reminds me of better call Saul quite often

    • @saierwe
      @saierwe Рік тому +1

      ​@@ulicesvilla6995 ohh then is crap! thanks for saving my time! watched 1 and a half season of better call saul and it was the most boring thing I've seen, 99% of the time was an old man preparing té in a dark house with depression and no talking or sounds, as a fan of breaking bad I gave it a chance but it was too bad, I see this show is boring too, nope thanks!

    • @solen5529
      @solen5529 Рік тому +1

      @@saierwe I got to season 4/6 of bcs and it is one of the most boring shows i have ever watched don’t pick it back up and people try to make up for it by saying it’s a good show because seasons 5 and 6 are good, but that doesn’t make any sense because if a majority of a shows seasons are bad it is a bad show no matter how good the other seasons are

  • @Kanashimimo
    @Kanashimimo Рік тому +110

    Barry is such a layered character to follow. At a time where a lot of fandoms are grasping with nuances when it comes to characters, Barry feels like a breath of fresh air. What I find fascinating with his character is how much he refuses to own up to what he did. Only once does he think about turning himself in, not because he feels guilty about what he did, but because someone else could take the fall from him.
    The guilt he ever feels is a "surface guilt", something he can definitely live with, unlike the other characters who find themselves taking a life to protect themselves. He's almost always finding a way to justify what he did, why he did it, and why he should be forgiven for it.
    I honestly think the only way Barry could get the redemption he's longing for would be by turning himself "willingly" to the police and facing what he did. But doing so wouldn't allow him to get the second chance he feels he deserves, so he can't just do that. His journey is fascinating to follow, as well as the others characters' own journey.

    • @iwantgoals1566
      @iwantgoals1566 Рік тому +2

      Very well said man. I often find it confusing when people are so black and white about Barry and just hate him cause he’s not the most morally upright character. But the whole point of the story and why he’s such a fascinating character is because he’s struggling with being a human being in search for redemption. The show goes out of its way to tease you with the life Barry could have if he changed but he always throws it away by his own hands. Or was he forced into those actions? Honestly this show is a breath of fresh air and reminds me of books like Dr. Jekel and Mr. Heid. It’s so layered and complex.

  • @ethandew1768
    @ethandew1768 Рік тому +14

    Barry is the craziest story of circumstance, he literally had the worst luck known to man, he’s been so traumatized by war that his broken mind simply could not comply with normal society

  • @SenseiSeagal420
    @SenseiSeagal420 Рік тому +84

    I don't know which scene broke my heart for Barry more that hair raising scream he let out after his friend caught him or the look of hurt and betrayal in his eyes when those cops yelled from the dark after Gene set him up ugh.

  • @vicdaman
    @vicdaman Рік тому +94

    Glad to see after this past season so many more people are seeing how brilliant this show is. Barry is one of the greatest shows on right now.

  • @IAN0351
    @IAN0351 Рік тому +58

    When Barry first premiered I related to him so hard. A Marine Corps infantry vet with no purpose. Fuck what a great show.

    • @lifeisa.smalllesson4607
      @lifeisa.smalllesson4607 Рік тому +3

      They rlly nailed the complexities of the struggle, trauma, desire, and blood lust!
      OIF Army vet.
      Purple heart recipient
      Bronze star nominee

    • @Rodrasroom
      @Rodrasroom Рік тому +4

      All of this! I love that this show actually considers the mindset of a veteran who comes back home. How can an efficiently trained killer just go back to “normal?”

  • @frazfrazfrazfraz
    @frazfrazfrazfraz Рік тому +22

    I was under the impression that he wasn't trying to kill Ronnie, but just defend himself. He's constantly asking Ronnie to stop, and once Ronnie relaxes, Barry tries to stand down, but then Ronnie always starts back up again. Aside from the arguably very risky throat punch, I don't remember Barry doing anything particularly aggressive or dangerous.
    Although, the fact that Barry was still trying to fool Loach by sending Ronnie away could be entirely self-serving, and you could say that maybe he should have just left or warned him about Loach or something.

  • @pascalculate
    @pascalculate Рік тому +109

    Sally's killing wasn't mainly for self defense. She did stabbed the guy in the neck with a knife, but her own rage pushes her beyond the edge so she killed him entirely. That's why at the end she chosed to leave, since she can't be the new person that she just became

    • @GiselleKlara
      @GiselleKlara Рік тому +15

      i think though the show is partially about how much of each person is their deeds and how much is something else. She'll still be the person who did that back home. And on some level, she wanted to do it because she'd wanted so much to have stood up to him but didn't....until she DID. i think she''ll be another layer

    • @fuchsia203
      @fuchsia203 Рік тому +2

      yall thinking to deep. she was bouta die and killed him cus shes experienced violence from other men (her ex). she left because barry told her too, thats why in the new episode she is confused about who barry killed. she left so they couldnt put the blame on her killing the guy, she doent know barry is a serial killer yet.

    • @taniajimenez8863
      @taniajimenez8863 Рік тому

      @@fuchsia203 Nah, pay attention to the scene, the dude stopped attacking her and she had the means to escape. But she chose a blunt weapon. She got cancelled that day, and was distraught already and was planning to psychologically abuse Natalie anyway, she projected that rage onto the biker.

  • @allanjim3
    @allanjim3 Рік тому +8

    This show really is a banger. At the conclusion of Season 3, the show must be the result of a highly capable team focusied on a very clear purpose. I’d guess the levels of skill and energy required to produce each episode must be immense.

    • @rudeboyspodcast
      @rudeboyspodcast 10 місяців тому

      It's funny you say that because a lot of seasons 1-2 were never all that structured. Events were fluid, writing was off the cuff, they admitted they never planned out the structure of an entire season before 3, and it took the COVID pandemic to give them time to sit down and plan out the last two seasons for them to really focus their efforts. You can definitely tell in season 4 especially just how uniquely singular it is in terms of being Bill and Alec's vision for the finale.
      With all that said tho, I think it was an amazing show from start-to-finish. Every episode is great!

  • @angryman4305
    @angryman4305 Рік тому +24

    The ending of season 3 closes up everything so good that it might be the ending as well, needless to say that the whole season felt like an extended version of ozymandias, tragedy after tragedy

  • @jackrosevear
    @jackrosevear Рік тому +149

    As always, outstanding smart, acute observations. And great taste in shows. Keep them coming mate, please!

  • @francesengland79
    @francesengland79 Рік тому +10

    I love this show. Every character is truly a representation of how good and bad humans are. Even Sally, when she has her flip out on her assistant, you see how narcissistic and entitled she is. I love how this show can go from dark drama to comedy in an instant.

  • @filmreviewer117
    @filmreviewer117 Рік тому +15

    What I love about the show is that from the first episode, you know it can't have a happy ending for Barry. But I had no idea how painful and depressing it would be for Barry as he tries to get out of this life.

  • @AshleySmithh
    @AshleySmithh Рік тому +9

    I'm halfway through and I can't help but notice how everything you say and talk about can be related to ADDICTION. Like replace the whole murdering part with someone who's addicted to ANYTHING, and it's eerily a similar description of someone trying to escape the cycle of addiction. Excellent video though mate, I just found you recently and have been binge watching all your videos! Keep making quality content!

    • @GiselleKlara
      @GiselleKlara Рік тому

      i don't really see any addiction in here; i think this is exploring other issues. but maybe there are elements i'm missing. i don't think barry is addicted to killing. he'd stop if given a real chance, but he doesn't know how to make a life and no one will help him make one

  • @nont18411
    @nont18411 Рік тому +4

    15:45 This. This is the crux of the story.

  • @madelinedelarche4543
    @madelinedelarche4543 Рік тому +30

    The really cool thing about Bill Hader as a person and an actor is that he makes it so easy to genuinely like and care about his characters. Even here, where he's not a good person and his shitty behaviors aren't praised by the narrative like they would be in other shows/movies. When you first start Barry, you want to root for him because Bill is such a sincere and lovely person that it comes through constantly. When Barry starts getting worse, it really hurts to have to reassess and have to acknowledge that you've probably spent a little too much time convincing yourself of Barry being "not as bad" as his actions would indicate. I honestly can't think of any actors that would have had the same effect. I probably would have given up on Barry quicker
    .... Though I may be biased because of how much I fucking love Bill Hader

    • @Hideyoriisdaman
      @Hideyoriisdaman Рік тому

      Barry is just a product and a victim of manipulative human garbage ambushing him perpetually, I'd fucking snap with that pressure too and the point of the story is to point out that everyone is just as bad as Barry, but more pussyfooting and verminous in their approach through manipulations. Hope Barry finally breaks out of the cycle, either through dying in prison or literally nuking all of humanity.

    • @paedarbrown9609
      @paedarbrown9609 Рік тому

      Nah man, you hit the nail on the head 👌

  • @yvsh
    @yvsh Рік тому +48

    Such a great analysis of the show. This video made me see Barry's arc in a whole new light. Great work dude!

  • @picaweltschmerz6357
    @picaweltschmerz6357 Рік тому +9

    Bill Hader's performance, ESPECIALLY in season 3, was heartbreaking. The man deserves all the cookies.

  • @hpyoung9646
    @hpyoung9646 Рік тому +12

    Best comedy, Crime drama I ever saw

  • @Seisoks
    @Seisoks Рік тому +4

    Barry is the simplest,craziest and one of the greatest show ever.
    All the cast pulled their weights by tons.
    Great casting and great acting.

  • @abstractist
    @abstractist Рік тому +20

    Absolutely brilliant. Thank you for highlighting how poetic the writing for this show is. I always knew it was but damn. Awesome analysis.

  • @damianstarks3338
    @damianstarks3338 Рік тому +13

    This breakdown is beyond perfect and so is this show.

  • @xhale_YT
    @xhale_YT Рік тому +5

    I really love this breakdown and deep explanation into Barry. Himself being a complex character is sometimes hard to understand. I appreciate this video. I love you work. Keep it up

  • @BlancoSuave
    @BlancoSuave Рік тому +9

    Lovely synopsis! Barry is unlike any show I've seen before and people like yourself do justice with your breakdowns and questions.

  • @gregwillett2710
    @gregwillett2710 Рік тому +1

    What an INCREDIBLE narrative and thematic breakdown. Nice work sir. This show is endlessly fascinating - even after multiple viewings - what a Masterpiece

  • @jenhasken
    @jenhasken Рік тому +1

    This is the best summary and analysis I’ve seen, good job.

  • @realworldcodingapplications
    @realworldcodingapplications Рік тому +2

    This was beautiful! nice analysis

  • @dbayles3677
    @dbayles3677 Рік тому +17

    Only just found your channel and started binge watching. Love your work my dude, as someone that’s ex military Barry is a great show. I can definitely see a few people I’ve served with pulling a Barry, it’s pretty easy to do as your told and go through the motions.

    • @residentelect
      @residentelect Рік тому +2

      I'm the same mate.
      I came out on a medical discharge, beaten up pretty badly both physically and mentally.
      Thankfully I have an incredibly supportive family and then met my fiancee who continues to be my rock, both sides nursed me back into a society I felt incredibly out of touch with, and even very bitter towards.
      It's because of this I tend not to attend many reunions, or go drinking with lads I served with. Don't get me wrong, they are my brothers for life, as you know yourself the bond formed by combat is virtually unbreakable. However, some of them haven't been nearly as fortunate as I have, and there is a very dark rabbit hole of alcohol, drug abuse, domestic abuse and casual violence I don't want to be near. Some of the lads actually frighten me a little (I know, I'm a pussy lol)
      It sounds incredibly selfish, but I want to keep that rabbit hole at arms length, as I know given the wrong set of circumstances I could very easily tumble back into it.
      All the best mate, hope you're living your best life now you're on the other side.

  • @geniosityfilms
    @geniosityfilms Рік тому

    One of your BEST observations yet! Keep up the great work!!!

  • @coleh3499
    @coleh3499 Рік тому +7

    Amazing how you so eloquently capture the essence of what the show is portraying. So many constant conflicting viewpoints, and Barry can never decide which way to go. I have no clue where they go in season 4, and I can’t decide if I want Barry to break free or not

    • @coleh3499
      @coleh3499 Рік тому +1

      @zetta _ but if he confesses to everything, he’s away for life. How would he get a chance at redemption?

    • @joannelee5574
      @joannelee5574 Рік тому +1

      Realistically, I think the only redemption he can get now is more moral/conceptual (small chance if any) than a chance at a normal life. Obviously fuches is a huge part of his actions, but this is about the second/third chance he’s gotten. He was kind of forced back, but usually it was him making the final decision in each season finale to go further, out of rage or his own selfishness, and his choices catch up with him eventually
      People can evolve, but Barry made some progress then backspaced so hard that he’s hit the point where he would have to confess if he wants to redeem himself, very somewhat, to the people he’s affected. But by now, it’s been made pretty visible that he’s not willing to make the responsible choices left, and he’s dug himself his own grave
      Just my take at least!! Super excited to see what they do, I honestly don’t know how it’ll end

  • @Bugalugs
    @Bugalugs Рік тому +1

    At 1:01 you nailed the piano timing of the Prelude to fit what you were saying

  • @tedtawk2783
    @tedtawk2783 Рік тому +15

    Incredible show and this video only makes it better!

  • @jayquoproductions
    @jayquoproductions Рік тому +1

    Barry is an absolutely incredible show that should be on everyones' list who hasn't seen it. Completely redefines Bill Hader as more than just a comedian to me. He really shows his dramatic acting chops in this one, this show deserves some serious awards for its efforts and achievements

  • @thegiftedone
    @thegiftedone Рік тому +6

    My goodness……I’m binge watching your excellent channel…..this is my 4th one in a row…….as a writer, you have opened a part of my brain that didn’t exist through your unique but perfectly precision observations…sure I seen other channels but you my friend, are next level eye opening, mind blowing, expert…… you must have a background in human behavior or clinical psychology………5 stars!………..across the board! Greetings from the malfunctioning corporation called Hollywood,CA…………keep preaching! Cheers!

  • @toongamer2810
    @toongamer2810 Рік тому +22

    Barry now fits into my top 5 shows of all time, along with breaking bad, better call saul, the boys and death note

    • @Lgbtfortnite
      @Lgbtfortnite Рік тому +2

      Sopranos clears that list 😈

    • @toongamer2810
      @toongamer2810 Рік тому +1

      @@Lgbtfortnite can't find a way to watch it, Should I get HBO max?

    • @Lgbtfortnite
      @Lgbtfortnite Рік тому +2

      @@toongamer2810 Yeah HBOmax or if you live outside the US Binge/Foxtel

    • @toongamer2810
      @toongamer2810 Рік тому +1

      @@Lgbtfortnite oh alr thanks

  • @thisiszohair
    @thisiszohair Рік тому +1

    Beautiful video essay, really enjoyed this! Awesome job 👏

  • @howardron543
    @howardron543 Рік тому +8

    Yes finally Barry... Loved it and everything you do

  • @rebeccagibbs4128
    @rebeccagibbs4128 Рік тому

    wow, this was a great watch- you touched on all the things that make BARRY so much more than the dark comedy it's been shown as. Love ur channel, you deserve all the likes and more

  • @colinsteadland
    @colinsteadland Рік тому

    i liked this video simply because you used two of my favorite compositions ever, prelude #1 in C and Allegretto. but i wouldnt have stayed around long enought to hear allegretto if your video essay wasnt so well put together. bravo my dude

  • @lkf8799
    @lkf8799 Рік тому

    Amazing analysis. Such a great video. Well done 😃

  • @TheGeekyAmreeki
    @TheGeekyAmreeki Рік тому +5

    Really good stuff bro. Keep it up.

  • @jvnsfunny
    @jvnsfunny Рік тому +2

    you are incredibly skilled at video essays

  • @dysfunctional_deviant6681
    @dysfunctional_deviant6681 Рік тому +1

    Awesome video. I've been praising this show from season 1 for it's character depth and brilliance. Season 3 was chilling and tragic in a perfect, human way. I can't wait for season 4.

  • @funturtle23
    @funturtle23 Рік тому +1

    Great video and analysis, subscribed

  • @osrspac420
    @osrspac420 Рік тому +1

    Barry is a show that makes me laugh harder than any other, but also makes me cry like a baby, it's a very special show. I'm really sad that were on the final season but I'm also glad they aren't milking it. Damn man this show fucks me up, in a good way tho.

  • @chrisacton4200
    @chrisacton4200 Рік тому

    Thank you this was great, you really did the show justice. Subbed

  • @593Andrea
    @593Andrea Рік тому +1

    Thank you. Wonderful video!

  • @rogerallen4320
    @rogerallen4320 Рік тому

    Well done! Fantastic
    job!

  • @PhilMiCoochie
    @PhilMiCoochie Рік тому

    I've never seen this show before but you brilliantly told the story to perfection. Over the course of 26 minutes you got me to connect with Barry as if I just watched all 3 seasons

  • @jarlysonbarros5733
    @jarlysonbarros5733 Рік тому +1

    Excellent observation, bro!!!

  • @joannelee5574
    @joannelee5574 Рік тому +1

    Love your analysis!! I absolutely adore this show, and I think all the characters in this show are so fascinatingly written (sally is another fantastic arc)
    One of the things I noticed (at least my interpretation) was that even though Barry got dragged back into things, usually it was his choice that ultimately takes him further in each season finale. He’s a sympathetically written character, but there’s definitely more going on than he convinces himself, especially since he usually blames fuches or some other outside force. Definitely feel like a normal life is out of the cards now though...
    I’m really not sure how his story will end, now that everyone around him has also been so deeply traumatized, but I’m super excited for season 4!!

  • @deborahthomas3475
    @deborahthomas3475 Рік тому +1

    Superb observations

  • @I_Heart_Hader
    @I_Heart_Hader Рік тому

    This was absolutely brilliant.

  • @Benjy1
    @Benjy1 Рік тому

    Great video essay

  • @OrchardcottagefarmCo
    @OrchardcottagefarmCo Рік тому +1

    Brilliant summary of this brilliant show!

  • @rocker8912
    @rocker8912 Рік тому +8

    Incredible analysis, makes me really consider what I pulled from this show, keep it up

  • @sanuspg
    @sanuspg Рік тому

    Interesting video. Thanks for making it.

  • @SaucyTUX
    @SaucyTUX Рік тому +1

    Yes!!! I've been wanting to watch this!

  • @DocM.
    @DocM. Рік тому

    You're awesome, love your videos! ❤

  • @StrangerX9
    @StrangerX9 Рік тому +1

    This show is a masterpiece! Not enough people are talking about it’s brilliance.

  • @deadchanneldontwatch7347
    @deadchanneldontwatch7347 Рік тому +9

    Barry in season 3 reminded me of the veteran Chechen hitman Goran and Noho Hank hired to kill him "my wife left me...said I´m broken"

    • @Kanashimimo
      @Kanashimimo Рік тому +3

      I think Bill Hader or Alec Berg specifically said that the "old" hitman was a glimpse into what Barry would ultimately become, staying on the path he was on. Makes me wonder if the show will ultimately end with Barry killing himself like the guy did, maybe with Fuches by his side as well.

  • @blackbatman3152
    @blackbatman3152 Рік тому +7

    Also Feuches actually said that being able to kill a person that person has no soul. I find that interesting that the main father figure/manipulator even says how soulless you could be to actually commit the murders he ordered

    • @Delta_Aves
      @Delta_Aves Рік тому +1

      It’s like that old saying “who’s more foolish, the fool or the fool that follows him/her?”
      Just replace “fool” with soulless/ evil/ wicked etc.

  • @dontsubcribedontlike673
    @dontsubcribedontlike673 Рік тому

    Thank you for this analysis. I have a feeling it will age very will as season 4 comes out.

  • @ajl1000
    @ajl1000 Рік тому +1

    Very insightful thanks

  • @sknoy7792
    @sknoy7792 Рік тому

    Absolutely amazing

  • @kenthefele113
    @kenthefele113 Рік тому

    Excellent job. Subscribed.

  • @mikeisrael737
    @mikeisrael737 Рік тому +1

    You really broke that down and left me wondering 💯

  • @dylanwittrock7985
    @dylanwittrock7985 Рік тому +1

    This is just a summary of Barry. The best tv show ever made will always be breaking bad but this will always be my favorite, I love this show so much

  • @nyceplayz8051
    @nyceplayz8051 Рік тому

    LOVELY video

  • @bojanglesfries
    @bojanglesfries Рік тому +6

    I finished this show recently and it's still on my mind. I hope s4 is good, because this show really left an impact on me

  • @ronaldburse7610
    @ronaldburse7610 Рік тому +2

    A masterpiece kid for real 👏🙌

  • @littlebair3482
    @littlebair3482 Рік тому +1

    Great video, I’ll be excited to see what you think about season 4 when it’s out

  • @AndersonTheAgent
    @AndersonTheAgent 5 місяців тому +1

    Very impressed by your analysis, it's some of the best available anywhere. Any chance we might take a dive into your writing process? Curious about how many times you'll watch a series in preparation for a video. Where does passive enjoyment end and critical analysis begin? Your essay on Sally showcases an uncommon level of insight into the acting process, while other videos provide expert level examination of camera movement. Where do these insights come from? Are you a filmmaker yourself? Trained actor? Whatever the case, you've certainly earned my sub.

  • @pdub88372
    @pdub88372 Рік тому +1

    Props to Hader for this. Barry is a completely different character than anything he’s ever done. Who’d have thunk that the Superbad/Anchorman types could have so much range.

  • @gabrielpetersen8528
    @gabrielpetersen8528 Рік тому +1

    This show was written very well. It challenges the feelings that us, the western audience, has come to expect and desire from our tv shows and movies. It hit deep and maintained a bit of comedy all the way through until the very end. Chefs kiss! Bill Hader has always been amazing but he really did it this time.

  • @topcat59
    @topcat59 Рік тому

    Great vid bro.😺

  • @lordturtle8735
    @lordturtle8735 Рік тому +1

    I didn't understand what this show eas before seeing it. I only wish i could experience it for the first time again. It is genuinely the greatest show I've ever seen.

  • @rafaelpestke7868
    @rafaelpestke7868 Рік тому

    Great content👍

  • @BrianFarstvedt
    @BrianFarstvedt Рік тому +2

    I was hoping this channel would make a Barry episode!!

  • @sanddollar55
    @sanddollar55 Рік тому +5

    This is a really good explanation. 👍 I never considered Barry not trusting his instincts as being a core obstacle to his growth (duh!). I get this character more, now.

    • @sanddollar55
      @sanddollar55 Рік тому

      Thank you. Now that I've finished watching this, I appreciate Season 3, which I honestly didn't get before listening to your explanation. I hope someone sends this to BH. You seem to get this show better than anyone else!

  • @samnunhossain3553
    @samnunhossain3553 Рік тому +5

    Ngl, the dynamic between the one who shoots and the one who orders to shoot is the same as Macbeth and Lady Macbeth , because Lady Macbeth orders him to kill the king doesn't mean that the guilt isn't there .
    But more like people either ignore it or perish from it . The examples of Lady Macbeth seeing Spots means that the conscience guilt is taking over her , had she ignored t his like the other group , she would probably been alive.

  • @bencera6067
    @bencera6067 Рік тому

    Great video, smart!

  • @hotfudgecake
    @hotfudgecake Рік тому

    love this

  • @antialeks5013
    @antialeks5013 Рік тому +2

    I honestly had no clue where they could go from season 3 but if anyone of you have caught up with Season 4 yet holy fucking jesus

  • @detroitmcpro
    @detroitmcpro Рік тому +1

    Great breakdown of one of the best shows on TV right now! Can you do a video on another HBO classic, The Wire?