This is so funny to me cause in class I would yawn and never understand these worksheets in class and I've been on a journey to learn more as a 28 year old and now I watch it for fun. How things change lol
Isn't #2 a trick question? If it said "The Wren is the oldest building...." I would agree that building is the predicate nominative but "The Wren Building" already declares the Wren as a "building" so the second use of the word building is superfluous and the key modifier is "oldest", making it the PA. Couldn't this sentence be written this way? The Wren Building is the oldest on campus? Is there any doubt we are talking abut buildings? If it was written this way, wouldn't the word "oldest" be a predicate adjective? Also, how does "The building is a building" tell us more about the subject that we didn't already know? #4, I guess the same argument can be used in favor of identifying "largest" as PA rather than "State" as PN I'm guessing the rule is: When a noun (building) and an adjective (tall) are present, the noun takes precedence. I'm dyslexic so pardon me if I don't see this right.
Sir I hope this is part of subject complements chapter. Please comment if it is not. i have an exam coming up on subject complements. your class is perfectly lucid and easy to understand.
I know I'm like, 10 years late, but is there a document where you can send the link to (or maybe a PDF) in which we can print the assignment that you showed in the video?
Common mistake. The word oldest is a noun unless it modifies a noun right after it. “I am the oldest” is a noun and a predicate nominative. “I am the oldest son” is an adjective, but not a predicate adjective.
There is neither a PA nor a PN in your sentence example. "...from his video career" is an adverb phrase. "Retire" is not a linking verb. It is usually an intransitive verb and only rarely does it take an object. I discuss linking verbs and how to find them at about :50.
i have a doubt regarding this sentence- Jack is a great musician. so is the "great musician' predicate nominative or adjective cuz it seems to be both. and also if the word 'great' will be counted in the first place. please do reply fast. its urgent.
Is that the same case with predicative adjective as in the e.g . John is extremely angry, only angry would be the predictive adjective, right? Thank you so much for the prompt reply. Nobody usually do that.
Helena “angry” would be the PA “extremely” would be an adverb modifying the PA. Remember, adverbs modify more that just verbs. They can also modify adjectives and other adverbs.
Thank you my English teacher can't teach Grammar for his life.... you saved me for my final
Sameeee
Just a tip, crossing out/bracketing the prepositonal phrase will make it much EASIER!
THANK YOU FOR MAKING THIS VIDEO :D
Nice tip!
This really helped me, my English teacher always confuses me lol you made it so easier to understand
Our so-called Dr is more confused than us that he doesn't explain anything that simple. I am looking forward to more grammar videos from you!
you taught it so much better than my teacher
It's sad how you are better than my college professor who is a "Dr"
I'm in middle school and learning this. Why are you here?
For real
@@EnderSlayer-mz1xw he is probably an English major idk though
just want to say thank you, your video was the only one out of 5 to help me understand - kash freeman
This is so funny to me cause in class I would yawn and never understand these worksheets in class and I've been on a journey to learn more as a 28 year old and now I watch it for fun. How things change lol
Isn't #2 a trick question?
If it said "The Wren is the oldest building...." I would agree that building is the predicate nominative but "The Wren Building" already declares the Wren as a "building" so the second use of the word building is superfluous and the key modifier is "oldest", making it the PA.
Couldn't this sentence be written this way?
The Wren Building is the oldest on campus?
Is there any doubt we are talking abut buildings?
If it was written this way, wouldn't the word "oldest" be a predicate adjective?
Also, how does "The building is a building" tell us more about the subject that we didn't already know?
#4, I guess the same argument can be used in favor of identifying "largest" as PA rather than "State" as PN
I'm guessing the rule is: When a noun (building) and an adjective (tall) are present, the noun takes precedence.
I'm dyslexic so pardon me if I don't see this right.
Don't worry, I totally agree with you. When I saw #2 I was so confused, but now I realized I was right! THANKS for your help!!
Yeah. You got it right. I made the same observation also. Grammarians will look at it the right way instead.
“The oldest” is still a predicate nominative.
@@robertprichard1171 How is oldest the predicate nominative? Isn't it describing the building?
Anirudh Sukhija The word “oldest” can take the place of an implicit predicate nominative as in the sentence “The Wren building is the oldest.”
Thank you Robert for this lesson. You clearly explained the lesson. New subscriber here.
Sir,kindly bring complete grammar .
Love you
So Helpful! I struggled so hard in this stuff until you helped me. 😀
Got a English test over this tomorrow thank u
Really helpful, Thanks!
thx a lot Robert
❤ well done
You said there could only be a PN or PA after an LV but then #4 you have PP and you just cross it out, I don't get it. Please explain.
Thank u so much!!
Very helpful, ty
Thanks so much this vid was really helpful
Sir I hope this is part of subject complements chapter. Please comment if it is not. i have an exam coming up on subject complements. your class is perfectly lucid and easy to understand.
Yes these are subject complements
Thanks! Very helpful.
Tysm!
Hello,
Plz just I wanna ask you what is the name of the book that you are using for explain the lessons . Plz I need the name of the book . And thanks
MOHAMED LAKSIR The Holt Handbook: Grammar, Usage, Mechanics, Sentences. Introductory course
Book by John Warriner
very well explained
sir this class is about subject complements, right? predicative nominatives and adjectives are part of subject complements, right?
I know I'm like, 10 years late, but is there a document where you can send the link to (or maybe a PDF) in which we can print the assignment that you showed in the video?
Thank you for this video.
In 2 example, why are you ignoring the oldest. It is an adjective after a linking verb.
Common mistake. The word oldest is a noun unless it modifies a noun right after it. “I am the oldest” is a noun and a predicate nominative. “I am the oldest son” is an adjective, but not a predicate adjective.
@@robertprichard1171 if it modifies a noun , it will be a pre modifier
Laraib nida Ehsaan An adjective in the predicate is only a predicate adjective if it modifies the subject of the sentence.
@@robertprichard1171 🌹
Why no mention of predicatives in transitive clauses?
Hi robet ! Could you please share the name of the book with me, please.
It's the holt handbook. fourth course... I use it for school
i have a question, would "he retired from his video career" be a predicate nominative or predicate adjective?
There is neither a PA nor a PN in your sentence example. "...from his video career" is an adverb phrase. "Retire" is not a linking verb. It is usually an intransitive verb and only rarely does it take an object. I discuss linking verbs and how to find them at about :50.
@@robertprichard1171 thanks
Thanks bro u saved my final today lol
hey, that is the SAME book I use at the school
😶😶😶
Thank you so much...🤍
Thanks man
thanks
i have a doubt regarding this sentence- Jack is a great musician. so is the "great musician' predicate nominative or adjective cuz it seems to be both. and also if the word 'great' will be counted in the first place. please do reply fast. its urgent.
“Great” is an adjective modifying the predicate nominative “musician”. Adjectives modifying PNs are not predicate adjectives.
Is that the same case with predicative adjective as in the e.g . John is extremely angry, only angry would be the predictive adjective, right? Thank you so much for the prompt reply. Nobody usually do that.
Helena “angry” would be the PA “extremely” would be an adverb modifying the PA. Remember, adverbs modify more that just verbs. They can also modify adjectives and other adverbs.
Thank you so much sir. You are truly a blessing.
Jajajajj I have that book 😂
Dang
Who is watching this in 2020
Me lmao
Online school lmaooooooo
Me
@@themadladprince430damn
thank you for making this video
May I get the name of this book?
UNKNOWN
@@themadladprince430 I found it. Thank you.
Description: description
I have that book lol
Book name please
@@indrad1698 elements of language