Are Sony KIT Lenses That BAD? [ZV-E1 & 16-50mm!]

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 96

  • @worldoftony469
    @worldoftony469 Рік тому +1

    Thank you for doing this video. I love seeing different types of lenses on zve1. I have tried APSC lenses on mine. It works perfectly fine, but I hated having to zoom in every time I turn the camera off. The 20 mm 1.8 is king for me

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      I really appreciate that, and I completely get that... The 20 is still probably the best lens that I own; it's hard to beat! However, if I could design a prime lens, maybe a full frame 18mm f1.4 would be the dream... And if I could design a zoom, it would be a full frame version of the 16-50 maybe a constant f/4 (to be realistic). Imagine a compact, power zoom 16-50 like that!?
      Thanks again!

    • @worldoftony469
      @worldoftony469 Рік тому +1

      @@BrianCatalano that would be the dream. I’m still trying to look for a full frame lens that would be compact enough but as you know, they are quite large. Plus if Sony came out with one, it would cost quite a bit. Keep up the good work. Just subscribed to your channel.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      @@worldoftony469 yes, you're right, they are either big, expensive, or both! Thank you so much, I really do appreciate the sub!!

    • @lb_projekt
      @lb_projekt Рік тому

      @@BrianCatalano tampon release soon 17-50 f4 with internal zoom if you're interested

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      @@lb_projekt yes, that's an exciting release... I'm looking forward to it!!

  • @OliverWiehe
    @OliverWiehe Рік тому

    You got a sponsor - awesome!!! Great breakdown of the lens, you make a great "case" for the kit lens! your content this summer is on FIRE!!!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Thank you so much... I'm always on the lookout for budget options!
      Yes, I try not to do sponsored videos because most of them don't fit my niche, don't pay well, or they want me to promote a bad product, but using Buyee to buy Japanese products seemed interesting to me since most camera manufacturers are in Japan...and this lens was a steal!
      Thanks again!!

  • @CharlieVN
    @CharlieVN 9 місяців тому +2

    FYI, i found the lens, and if you remove the baffle, you will have 20-50 completely free and clear, no hard vignetting at all with dynamic stabilization.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  9 місяців тому

      I had heard you could do that but was too scared to attempt (and I don't think I had the right tools). Have you done that with any other of your APSC lenses? It seems more difficult with newer lenses...

    • @CharlieVN
      @CharlieVN 9 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano I stripped the sigma screws 😂, only the two sony’s both gone through the baffle removal. Look up Moody Tools 58-0257, one of those bits fits the lens screws. Has to be the exact one, i stripped the sigma because i got lazy and didn’t look for my set of proper tools. Basically any lens, it will be 4 mount screws followed by three baffle screws on the underside.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  9 місяців тому

      @@CharlieVN ha ha, sounds like something I'd do! And awesome... looking it up now. Thank you!

  • @jaquedebates
    @jaquedebates Рік тому +1

    Hey Brian, have you tried the 18-105? Amazing video! thanks for sharing!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Hello Harvey! I really appreciate that... Thank you, and no I haven't yet! It's one of the lenses that I'm really hoping to try soon, as my dream would be to be able to take one camera and one lens with me as I travel. Do you own it or use it often...and if so, on a full frame camera or APSC?

  • @simoz78
    @simoz78 11 місяців тому +2

    Is the Dynamic stabilization any worse with the apsc kit lens compared to the FF kit lens? I kinda remember seeing some videos complaining about an apsc lens producing some jitter compared to the FF lens. But I am not even sure it was a Sony apsc lens or 3rd party. (btw, is Dynamic stabilization influenced by Sony vs 3rd party lens?)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  11 місяців тому

      I think you may be hearing right, as from what most people report that native Sony full frame lenses work best... However, in my experience after Sony released their first firmware update to the camera, I didn't notice any major jittering issues with any lenses, third party or APSC. For me, dynamic stabilization in the zve1 is the best stabilization in any full frame camera without question... Yet, it isn't perfect but it's way better than everything else that I've experienced. Obviously the hope is to get it to action cam smoothness and it seems to be going in that direction.

    • @simoz78
      @simoz78 11 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano Thanks for the reply! Anyway I have a spare 16-50 kit lens so I will try it first before looking at full frame lenses (after I get a zv-e1 next weeks)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  11 місяців тому

      I use my 16-50 a lot as a travel lens... Then maybe consider what focal range you find yourself using most and then either get a fast prime or a full frame zoom like a 24-70!

    • @simoz78
      @simoz78 11 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano I need something light and small if possible... I was now even considering another apsc zoom lens with more reach (16-70 f4 OSS) as I don't need the 16-24 range anyway and f4 would be nice enough

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  11 місяців тому

      @@simoz78 I fully support the idea of using APSC zooms on the zve1 as some have surprising amount of minimal vignetting on full frame, especially with stabilization on. I have also been considering the 18-50 f2.8... I don't understand why Sony hasn't made a more compact full frame zoom or even updated this kit lens!

  • @francoismarc3
    @francoismarc3 Рік тому

    The opening is fire!!! A new camera body was purchased by me yesterday, so I'll do some tests with my kit lens to see how it is! And thanks for recommending the site!!!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      Thank you so much!!
      Oooooooh, I'm so excited for you and to hear/see your findings!! Your first vlog will be nuts!
      Also, you're welcome, was just thinking about you in Japan... So jealous. BUYEE is the closest I'll get for now!

    • @francoismarc3
      @francoismarc3 Рік тому

      @BrianCatalano Hahahaha you'll be there one day!! And can't wait to start playing with it!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      @@francoismarc3 I'm guessing you're going to be pairing it with your 14mm GM!?

  • @soholingo
    @soholingo Рік тому +1

    Another solid production Brian. I haven't tried the 1650 lens but only because I favor primes and the 20/2.8 is a bit faster and smaller.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Thank you so much! Yeah, that makes sense, the 20 is a pretty perfect lens! Thanks for reminding me, I need to see if I can find some deals on it... I feel like I may need to pick that one up and sell some of my others! Thanks again

    • @JoshuaBelanger
      @JoshuaBelanger Рік тому +1

      Thanks for the idea on the 20/2.8 aspc. I received it last night and tested, perfect for vlog/slim setup.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      @@JoshuaBelanger that's brilliant... I need to get one now, too!

  • @VoicedTV2
    @VoicedTV2 Рік тому

    The production and quality of your videos are 🔥🔥. Salute bro 🫡

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      I really appreciate that... Thank you! Been trying to get a little better on each video...
      But wait, first thing I noticed, some new branding!? I dig your new logo! It's sleek!!

  • @CLVlogs05
    @CLVlogs05 Рік тому +1

    I can't tell about the kit lens on FF but the one on APS-C sucks. you don't get to notice until you start using some quality glass.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Yes, you are right and in no way are these kit lenses replacements for high quality glass as if you have the budget, I do recommend getting the best you can. However, many people do have tight budgets or are just beginning their entry into learning photography or videographers, and in those instances, these kit lenses are a great value for how versatile and compact they are. I would also say the full frame 28-60 is actually really sharp, and surprisingly quite good... It's just not very bright and the focal range is odd.

  • @jannarkiewicz633
    @jannarkiewicz633 2 місяці тому

    Good video. You convinced me to to buy WHICH IS A GOOD THING. It does not meet my needs so great content.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  2 місяці тому

      @@jannarkiewicz633 I really appreciate that... That's my aim with each video, to show people if a product is worth picking up and buying or skipping... So thanks for that feedback. Helps more than you know!!

  • @PhotoGearFun
    @PhotoGearFun Рік тому

    I didn't get the 28-60 but I have used that 16-50 lens on my APS-C Sony cameras for years and it's solid for a kit lens. Thanks for the video!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      Thank you so much, and I'm constantly surprised by how much I use that APSC kit lens on my zve1 as my travel lens... Thanks again!

  • @geneb2967
    @geneb2967 Рік тому

    im on the same boat having just bought an a7c ii with the 28-60mm. trying to shave as much weight as possible and am considering the 16-50mm crop lens to save 50g and also get a wider view for handheld selfie and group selfie shots (i don't vlog). your video helped me understand the vignetting issue and drawbacks. i'll still get it second-hand though if i can see a great deal.. so thank you!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      I have actually been using the 16-50 on the A7Cii and am loving it. Its so small and versatile...and because of the higher resolution and more MP, I don't mind being in crop mode!
      (And there's no vignetting!)

  • @AprilClayton
    @AprilClayton 8 місяців тому

    Sweet idea! I thought I was crazy for considering that combo.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  8 місяців тому

      I know... Same! Still many think it's crazy, but it's so cheap, compact, and versatile that it seems crazy not to at least try it!

  • @stevearita3267
    @stevearita3267 Рік тому

    Excellent video Brian! Your review(s) of various kit lenses, their quality and focal ranges is something a lot of folks overlook and/or don't bother with...interesting to see what one can find out there. Am sure you've heard the rumors about 2 different A7c's being released...if the A7cR is what it is...I'm going to be real tempted to pick one up (of course depends on how much it costs!), having a high megapixel for as my "backcountry hiking" camera for landscapes would be perfect. Can't wait to see what actually drops. Thanks again for the informative video!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Thank you so much, and you're right... a lot of people overlook these lenses for obvious reasons, but they definitely deserve a second chance not just because of their price but their versatility.
      Yes, if there is an A7CR, I too would be tempted... However, my presumption is that it will be at minimum $1000 more than the A7Cii at $3298 (purely speculation), but would be worth every penny. I personally think that's too many MP for my needs, but I know if I had my hands on it, also with 8k, I'd be convinced otherwise!
      I could imagine though for somebody like yourself that while hiking with a super lightweight compact body, where every ounce of added weight matters, it's a dream camera!
      I'm really intrigued to see if this rumor turns out to be true... Here's hoping!
      Thanks again!!

  • @paulmitchellphoto
    @paulmitchellphoto Рік тому

    Thanks man. Kind of firms up my decision to start out with the 16-50, that I have left over from an ancient a6000, on an a6700 for vlogging . May try an 11mm or a 15mm later on.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      You're so welcome... Happy I was able to help! Also, I hear great things about both the 11 and 15, but I particularly am drawn to the 11. That would be a great second lens to pair with the kit!

  • @CharlieVN
    @CharlieVN 9 місяців тому

    thanks for this video, been working on a project to figure all the aps-c lenses + dynamic stabilization, I happen to have this lens, although I cant figure where I put it 😆. The sony 10-18 works through the whole range (without hood), the sigma 10-18 f2.8 is the gold standard, works through the whole range (without hood), @ 8:23, that looks like it can use some surgery, square vignette is not natural, there is an obstruction.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  9 місяців тому

      Really appreciate you checking out this video and now looking forward to your breakdown! It sounds like you've experimented as much as I have with APSC plus dynamic stab., if not more, so can't wait to hear your findings... except for I'm sure you're probably going to convince me to buy more lenses that I don't need! The 10-18 f2.8 does sound perfect!
      Also, I completely agree with you on 8:23. I included that segment to show how the vignetting looks in higher frame rates, and I ended up liking the frame--had that 3:2ish open gate feel. That being said, you could crop it that way if needed, but I typically only shoot 4k 120fps with a full frame lens on it for that reason.
      Thanks again for stopping by and commenting!!

  • @850Tech
    @850Tech 7 місяців тому

    Can you suggest any high quality wide angle lens to use with OSS? Doesn't have to be sony but should fit my A6400

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому +1

      Hello! I highly recommend Sonys 10-18 f4 OSS APSC lens... Here's a quick Short of me using it:ua-cam.com/users/shorts5DTUI2xEcfk?feature=share

    • @850Tech
      @850Tech 7 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano is it sharper than the Kit lens

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      @@850Tech yes, it's sharper than the 16-50 APSC kit lens...but less sharp than the 28-60 full frame kit lens!

  • @frankiemorris5866
    @frankiemorris5866 Місяць тому

    Would the video quality be a lot worse 16/50 on a zve1. Rather that on a6400.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Місяць тому

      @@frankiemorris5866 that's a good question and I'm not sure there's a definitive answer as the zve1 has a far superior image overall, but cropping in on the 12 megapixel sensor is something to try to avoid--usually. Yet, the a6400 would look sharper and in good lighting might be better especially with that apsc lens. It's hard to say though

  • @TSCameraGear
    @TSCameraGear Рік тому

    Great video Brian. you definitely put some food for though there regarding these kit lenses. I personally use the sony 24-240 when I'm on the go. It looks ridiculous outside. Indoors, Samyangs 35mm f1.4 is my go-to lens.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Thank you so much! How is the 24-240 for video? I'm always curious about that lens, but I feel like I don't hear about it often enough... I am a big Samyang/Rokinon fan. I keep meaning to try out their 35 or 50 f1.4, do you have version 1 or 2?

    • @TSCameraGear
      @TSCameraGear Рік тому

      @@BrianCatalano The sony 24-240 is a great all round lens. its wide, and the tele is good. and the built in IS helps. Its kind of big though. I wish they could make a 16-300 F1.4 wouldn't that be something?
      I have version 1 of samyang 35. Its in most of my "talking head videos".

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      @@TSCameraGear ha ha! A 12-2000mm f1.2 would be nice, too!!
      Or even, seriously a 18-85mm f2-2.8 would work and may even be possible!
      You got me thinking, I used to be at 30mm (cropped 20) for my talking head, and now I'm on my Samyang 24mm f1.8... but I sort of wish it was at 35. I may see if there's any deals on that version 1 then, as your A roll looks great!

  • @bagpuss998
    @bagpuss998 Місяць тому

    Great show

  • @cholulized
    @cholulized Рік тому

    Have you bought a Sony camera on buyee? Is there any risk that the menu can't be changed to English language?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      That's a really good question, and I have not bought a Sony camera and would have previously not thought this would be a concern, but a friend of mine just bought a Sony ZV-E1 in a camera shop in Korea and it was region locked and there was no option for an English menu. I didn't realize that they even did that, so I probably would be careful about buying a camera from Buyee unless it's clear that you can change the language. I also don't know if a Korean camera might be different from one manufactured for a Japanese market or if this is a new issue... Regardless, I have only bought lenses via Buyee without issue, but it is something to think about. Thanks for bringing that up!

  • @夏侯彪
    @夏侯彪 8 місяців тому

    for videography,it is 16-50 F8 Gmaster

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  8 місяців тому

      A 16-50 f8 GMaster? Do you mean the 16-35 f2.8 GM or the old 16-50 A mount? Sorry for my confusion!

  • @nightdonutstudio
    @nightdonutstudio 6 місяців тому

    Sony 16-35 pz f4 could be an great option for you.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому

      Yes, that's a fantastic option as well. However I'm curious if that focal range is enough!? I wonder if a 24-50 would be better...

  • @JayfkProductions876
    @JayfkProductions876 Рік тому

    Stuck in a situation where the 16-50mm is my only option for my Zv E10, stuff is so hard to get here in 🇯🇲

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      I'm sorry to hear that, I can imagine that's frustrating... it's still not a bad lens to be stuck with for the ZV-E10, but I'd rather have the option to choose it and not be forced to have it. What lens would you get?

    • @JayfkProductions876
      @JayfkProductions876 Рік тому

      @@BrianCatalano Rokinon 12mm F2.0
      or Better
      Sony E 11mm F1.8
      Tbh if I'm not comfortable after testing the 16-50mm my financial advisor gonna see a sudden shipping bill 😂 😂 i'ma bite the bullet for that Sony 11mm

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      @@JayfkProductions876 that's funny!! I debated the same thing too with the Rokinon 12 as it seemed like a cheap option, but what I really wanted was the 11mm f1.8. I think you made a good choice!!

  • @stkuj
    @stkuj Рік тому

    I just picked up the 28-60 on eBay for 209.00. I needed it for travel.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      That's a good deal for that lens, but generally a fantastic deal for any autofocus, native Sony zoom lens that's as sharp as it is compact. I really do love it and hope you do too. Again, my only thing I don't like about it is that it is only 28mm at its widest and you can zoom in or out smoothly... But for $200, amazing!

    • @Channel-xx8qt
      @Channel-xx8qt Рік тому

      For travel best lens 18-105 f4 😁

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      @@Channel-xx8qt yeah, that's a brilliant focal range!

  • @jan-jans143
    @jan-jans143 Рік тому +1

    i bought 2 primes just to forget about this lens. it sucks.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +2

      I get that, 90% of my lenses are primes and faster than f/2.8, but for $65 as a compact, versatile zoom for traveling, it's been good for me in a pinch. If I'm shooting for a client though, I usually reach for a prime!

  • @binarytech8457
    @binarytech8457 Рік тому

    Helpful video. Btw Leica is a German brand and not Japanese :)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      Thank you! And you are so right about Leica... I realized that right after I finished my edit. I'm not even sure how I completely missed that before then though... as I even learned about Leica in art history! Ugh, there's always at least one dumb error in my videos! Yet, I really appreciate you gently correcting me! Thanks again

  • @HouseOwl
    @HouseOwl 7 місяців тому

    4:33 great Use Of A Wide Lens 😉Who Needs 'BOKEH"🤡

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      Agreed! This lens is not great if you're looking for bokeh...

  • @Jm3rv
    @Jm3rv Рік тому

    I regret selling my 28-60mm kit lens :/

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому +1

      I'm sorry to hear that, and I completely get it... I almost sold it too but changed my mind at the last minute! Hope you come across a cheap, used one!

  • @bathygao
    @bathygao Рік тому +1

    Leica is German, Ricoh is Japanese

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      You are right! I noticed that I stupidly included that name on the list, late night in the edit, after I published it. I made a note in the description somewhere, but I wish I could have caught it... Thank you!

  • @Samiam-mu5ln
    @Samiam-mu5ln Рік тому

    0:57, wow, did this man just straight up steal the quality chart from Christopher Frost youtube video 😮 like yeah, you wrote in the credit but a verbal shout out would have been waaaay more acceptable. Thats not cool ☠️

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  Рік тому

      I love Christopher Frost, he's definitely one of my favorite lens reviewers, and for that reason and due to the fact that he's so recognizable that if ever I don't have b-roll of a lens because I don't own it, I will use his and of course credit him.
      I'm not sure if you noticed but my videos are scripted and recorded prior to editing and adding b-roll, so of course I would not even conceive of retroactively recording myself to verbally credit b-roll (for redundancy?) when it's written in a graphic unless it's part of the narrative.
      I don't think it's a bad idea at all, but completely unnecessary for my personal work flow--nor is there any ethical standard to do so... Yet, it's a good idea, and I fully support you if that's the type of video you want to make. I could see that working for someone else... Cheers!

  • @pathosderdistanz9341
    @pathosderdistanz9341 8 місяців тому

    WORST kit lens ever.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  8 місяців тому

      That might be true, there's been a lot of bad kit lenses throughout the years, but even so, for $60 it's nice to have on hand since it's so small!

  • @夏侯彪
    @夏侯彪 8 місяців тому

    for videography,it is 16-50 F8 Gmaster

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  8 місяців тому

      A 16-50 f8 GMaster? Do you mean the 16-35 f2.8 GM or the old 16-50 A mount? Sorry for my confusion!

    • @夏侯彪
      @夏侯彪 8 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalanosorry,its the 16-50 kit lense for apsc,the image quality is actually not bad at F8 especially for videos. So 16-50 F8 GM,half joke half true

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  8 місяців тому

      @@夏侯彪 ha ha... I get that and you're right!