i love this game so much, no matter what kind of things that the gang did (except for dutch, Micah, Javier, etc) y could tell they were good people inside and the way rockstar portrays that, i love it. This game is a freaking masterpiece!
@Haywood J One of the reasons I like Dutch as a character (and enjoy hating him so much) is that he's complex, he really DID have a lot of redeeming qualities, especially early on- he really did take a lot of destitute people like orphans under his wing, taught them how to read alongside Hosea, taught them to think analytically and philosophically, etc. He had grand ideas about how the world could have been, and raged against what it was. But as the Old West started drawing to a close and his old way of life started to die out; once the Pinkertons and the consequences for his bad actions started to catch up with him... he became increasingly paranoid, narcissistic, and callous. He became a bad man. I think RDR2 is a game in which Arthur careens towards a moral event horizon and (at least in the high honor playthrough which I personally consider canonical) is saved at the last moment.... by his own imminent death. A few characters (most prominently Charles) state that TB is a blessing in a way. It gave Arthur a chance to take a hard look at what he had done in his entire life, and where he was, and what he'd leave.... it gave him a chance to set SOME things right. That's a chance that, for instance, John never got- his death was swift and sudden (though in hindsight he should've known). Tuberculosis destroyed Arthur's body, but it saved his soul. But Dutch didn't step back from that precipice. RDR2 shows that he continued right past Arthur and dove right over it. Anything good left in him was lost to his insanity. It's just one of the many tragedies of this tale. Revenge, paranoia, greed... almost all of the major characters die to them, except those precious few who leave literally all of it behind and escape entirely from the lifestyle. At its heart, RDR is a funeral dirge for the Old West.
Arthur asked John to go and never look back. John asked Jack to go and never look back. Arthur died on top of a mountain in the sunshine while Dutch died on the bottom of a mountain in a snow storm. What a coincidence... these subtle details is one out of many things that makes Rockstar Games games stand out.
RedRiverChannel in my opinion that’s symbolism that Dutch was dishonorable and died in the cold at the bottom of a mountain meanwhile Arthur was honorable and died at the top of a mountain with the warmth of the sunshine comforting him
My favorite one is when Dutch and Arthur get cornered by the US military and he says “you can’t fight change, you can’t fight gravity” and jump into the stream. And funny enough Those are Dutch last words to John before he kills himself.
@@joshuadavis4474 he did, he didn’t have a choice but to help the Pinkertons because they found him and threatened his family, and he died because he was the last loose end
Arthur's death is so emotional not just because he is such a beloved character to all of us, but spending so much time with a protagonist, feeding him, fighting, riding across the world, you can't help but develop a bond to him. Most main characters in a game you are with for an allotted amount of time, but you actually have to take care of Arthur. He will always be, to me at least, the greatest protagonist I ever had the pleasure of playing as.
@@queitn6287 I like thinking that he was a bad person living selfishly until he got diagnosed. Then, with the little time he had left, he decided to change his ways. He finally sees the stag. For all he knows, he lost. John got away, but so did Micah. Dutch left him to die and the rat is still living. In the end, he loses but he doesn’t care because he was able to save John Marston.
@@youraveragemango8671 Arthur never lived selfishly, he always followed Dutch's order and helped the gang wich was his family. He did everything to protect the ones who loved. He was a criminal and did bad things but always with a purpose and not for himself. He sure was a fool to believe in such a plan like the Tahiti's dream, but his heart was in the right place. But he also did many bad things and that's why, in the end, had to redempt himself through death.
Absolutely, I actually felt the same for John on Red Dead 1 and Roman Bellic from GTA 4. When you spend time with/playing someone and all of a sudden they're gone, it just gives me that depressing vibe.
It's one of the most tragic things. To give all you had to someone, and be betrayed in the end. And the saddest part is it happens every day in the real world. How many men have put years and decades into a relationship, only to be cast aside. How many people have broken their backs for a job, only to be cast aside because they're no longer useful or the job destroyed them. That's why this is soo relatable to the average person. People give all they had all the time, every day, all over the world....but in the end they're never made whole. They're just figuratively left on top of a mountain to die alone. Arthur was there for everyone, even his horse, but no one was there for him. Part of that is his fault because of the choices he made, and some people couldn't be there because he was trying to save them, but Arthur was alone in all of it.
People who say that “Arthur didn’t deserve to die” missed the entire point of the game. Arthur was not a good man by any means, he murdered, robbed, and beat innocent people. The whole reason he got TB was because he beat Thomas Downes to death over some debt money. And like Arthur himself said, “you can’t live a bad life and expect good things to happen to you.” Arthur died as a result of his own wrongdoings, and he knew this. So in his final weeks alive, he chose to give others the chance to do the good that he couldn’t.
Well, you can live your life trying to be good and all you get is bad things happen to you. Arthur lived a hell of a life, he was insanely good at what he does, reunion/closure with the woman he loved, loyal friends at the end, beat the shit out of a rat even at the death's door. He won the game of life in my book.
I see it in simpler terms...Arthur needed the gravitas of Death (and knowing he was going to die), to finally see his Life for what it was; a lie. He'd been used his entire life, under pretense of Familial love, with the lives wasted from those who'd died under the same pretense, and that he needed to 'break' from Dutch. "That which is killing you will help you to see, and see clearly Friend...See *and* hear." - Blind Man Cassidy
@@eviafamily7898 My first playthrough, I was max honor all throughout. Every playthrough since I’ve done low honor until the TB diagnosis, then I raise my honor.
I get the feeling that the moment that Dutch was told that the only who won was John, he knew it was the truth. Maybe that’s why he spared John, killed Micah, and left him the gang’s money.
Or it’s because when he shot Micah it’s not because he likes John he hates John still but it’s only because he wanted to fulfill Arthur’s last request to keep John safe
Fã De Games It’s true, to a point. Arthur was an outlaw who robbed and killed his way across half a country. He was not a good person, and he knows this. But, he tries. He tries his hardest (mostly if you have high honor) to change what he can, and right as many wrongs as he can.
Line delivery is great and love how it’s a call back to chapter 3, when they get back from Rhodes and he says “I will ride with you again Mrs.Adler if you will ride with me.”
I didn’t cry but I teared up a lot I’ve played through the game twice but I got more emotional when it came to this part of the game than I did on my first play through
Let’s be honest, if Sadie was sniping then she’d have probably only shot about 2 guys throughout the entire gunfight to Abigail. So truthfully, Arthur is the better shot
Dude yes some appreciation for the music in this mission. It’s 11/10 perfect, that moment you mentioned and the Arthur’s entire final stand on the mountain after John leaves. This video even cuts it off a bit short, the full version is incredible
They're a pain in the you know what at times but at the same time you will go to war or give your life for them. We are all we got as men. Whether related or thru friendship, a true brother will always watch the other brother's back. 😢
I remember I cried when Arthur said thank you to the the horse mainly because I never changed the horse I had once i got the first horse you buy I never got rid of her Rest In Peace Leo
The ending really exemplifies how in the end, we all crawl in pain just to try to experience one moment of peace, like walking through a desert made out of jagged glass for one last cup of water. He didn't just lay there and die, he used the last of what he had to see the sun rise one last time, and all that for just a moment, but as short as it was, it was worth it, because in the end it's the little things that matter, there's nothing bigger than the little things. He took whatever last bit of beauty in the world he could get.
Sadie was Arthur’s Bonnie McFarlane, carried out till the end. Love the role they both play in both our favorite gunslinger’s stories. Nothing like a tough blonde heroine to have our backs until fate catches up with us.
Let's take a minute to remember these great members of the van der linde gang who we lost along the way: Arthur morgan Lenny summers Susan grimshaw Herr Strauss (later revealed by charles he was beaten to death by the pinkertons) Hosea Matthews Molly O'shea (framed for being a rat) Eagle flies (later died from a gunshot wound) Karen (was revealed she drank herself to death in epilogue chapter) Kieran Duffy Sean McGuire
I'm playing for the first time and Arthur Morgan died yesterday, I'm sad, he gave his best for everyone, congratulations Rockstar Games for this great story and for giving us the best game!
Even though Arthur died, he definitely won the fight in emotions. He died knowing he redeemed himself by(depending on the players choice) giving money to Mrs. Londonderry and helping John escape alive with his family. While Micah left on his own, and losing affiliation with Dutch, until he lured him with money.
Closest you can get is the high honor go back option where you slash his eye out. I don't see why Arthur would go back though, especially a high honor Arthur who's literally telling John that money doesn't matter and revenge is a fool's game lol. Although it'd be pretty badass if high honor "go back" Arthur said something like: "Forget the money, John.... Revenge is a fool's game, and I'm feeling mighty foolish right now.... go, get to your family. I'll take care of them."
Joey Loobie For pc gaming for pc gamers. I know a couple of friends who the only video game platform they have is their pc and they have an xbox controller specifically for it
@@Kirokill1 Yea i know some do but he has a xbox He literally did some videos on it when rdr2 came out for consoles you can see the buttons saying RT so the other guy was right.
I've knew something was gonna to happen eventually but not how exactly how he was going to die. The ending broke my heart.. I've was thinking about another playthrough but to be honest, I need too wait. What a game!.. glad I don't see any playthrough before I got it for PC but maybe I'm wrong, would have be easier maybe
The second saddest part about this ending for me is the fact you lose your horse... Now, many swap horses as they find stronger and faster ones, but Stripe I kept all the way from the start of Valentine. He was probably the dumbest horse to ever exist, tripping on random rocks and branches in the woods sending me flying, or barreling straight towards oncoming pedestrians. But he was a good horse... He was a fighter. For how scrawny he was he was resilient. I was expecting Arthur's passing, and I was even preparing for it, but not my horse. I wish I would have groomed him, got him a nice saddle, and a decent bedroll one last time before that mission. Rest in peace Stripe, you were an idiot, but you are probably the most toughest idiot I've ever met.
Had a horse called him legacy because I thought it was a cool name first time playing brought it in valentine with Hosea always kept it clean and I can’t count how many times I reset my progress because I accidentally died with my horse because it slipped of the side of a mountain or died from a train always kept horse reviver on me just in case loved him and in chapter 5 after Hosea died legacy was exactly as his name said he was the legacy of everyone and everyone’s time in the gang and who had passed I remember visiting all the graves with legacy and taking a moment and after he died i could feel tears in my eyes the fact Arthur stayed and thanked him all I could do was reminisce about all the times I had with that horse some people say Beual was their horse but legacy only felt right in the final mission to ride my first horse god I loved you legacy rip for stripe .it’s the second worst death in my opinion
Putting myself self in Arthur’s boots it must of been painfull for the last chapter of the game constantly fighting while having TB most people would be in bed crying but Arthur is just a legend shows how much he cares about others and how he has made the change from a bad man to a good man and I’m result made him so his life more clearly then ever before and he realised the fact Dutch is not who he thinks he was and he had to come to terms with that. And it’s so sad to see him release most of his life has been wasted, on hurting others and that deep down he really does care about others as shown as he helps people all throughout the game, and especially near the end when he was coming to terms that he was gonna die, you could clearly see his main priority was to help others. Also Arthur’s knows he can’t ask for forgiveness for his sins as shown when he gave money to mrs Downes and stopped her son from being bullied and potentially killed, you can see he knows he ruined there lives because he killed mr Downes and he knows he got what he deserved which is the TB he got. So he doesn’t ask for forgiveness because he can not forgive himself, so at the end of his life he try’s spreading good bye letting the Marstons have another chance and letting the innocents of the gang run off and ultimately facing the evil in this world which is represented by Micah. Arthur knows he can not forgive himself so he aims as his last mission to stop Dutch and Micah. As he lays on the ground victorious he leans over to face the sunrise one more time and he remembers all the good times he had and all the friends he lost along the way and at his last breath he knows he has done all he could at his last moments of life. :Rockstar this is Art. RIP Arthur Morgan 1863-1899
It's so poetic...how the Marston family were the ones who killed the antagonists. Abigail killed Milton, John killed Micah, and Jack killed Ross. This mission may not be as grand as RDR1's redemption ending, but Arthur's road to redemption was truly well written as well. I will not forget the first time, went down for the money hoping to help John and family...and I was high honor thankfully. Arthur is completely a bad guy, but his tale of redemption shouldn't be taken for granted. People started benefiting from such redemption, even if the law says he's not worthy of such goodwill. John crying out "you left me" is much more powerful with the first game's context, as well as the fact that Javier never pointed his gun at John and Arthur.
Arthur, John, many of Dutch’s Gang… They went down fighting. They all had their ideals, their differences, flaws, thoughts, and whatnots. In the end… They were all human as you all… And I.
The last interaction ever between Arthur and Sadie, wishing her and Abigail well and saying his final goodbye. And it's even more sad because they both know it's Arthur's final moments. Best Rockstar game ever, and R.I.P to Arthur their best ever character 🥺
@@olgierdvoneverec6216 his actor actually told the devs that he thinks that Javier wouldn’t point a gun at his brothers, they then made it so he pointed it in the air
No Micah Bell you have lost Arthur got what he wanted at the end for John Abigail and Jack to be a family a normal family at is . Arthur won his battle good job Arthur.
If you look closely in the trees near the entrance of the camp, you can see the Pinkertons already. They’re looking at us before the shoot that happens when author just enters the camp you can see them. Pause at 20:15 and look at the trees in the background
"im gonna get you outa this bullshit, if its the last goddamn thing i do" that line absolutely crushed me, it was the last thing he did and im so happy that we got to help john even if we couldn't save Arthur. this game is an absolute masterpiece of art
Arthur and Joel from last of us are going to be remembered as my favorite game protagonists of all time. Arthur Morgan really feels like your big, brave older brother by the end of the campaign.
1:10 The way arthur screams Dutch's name in disbelief is really hearth shattering. Arthur sacrificed everything in his life for this man and his lies. Only to see it crumble and be betrayed in the end.
34:50 I think one of the more underrated devastating moments. In his dying breaths, arthur warns Dutch about Micah. Even til the very end, Arthur was loyal. He has quite literally nothing to lose, and would gain nothing by lying, and Dutch understands this. Arthur is a representation of everything Dutch claimed to value, and he's watching it all die alongside his only friend left in the world. And its his fault. You can see it in his eyes, and for the first time, he's speechless
just finished playing the game for the first time " I'm late for the party I know" but I mean they should warn us to never get attached to the character. wow that was emotional
I know this is old. I just played and beat the game for the first time this week. I fcking cried when Arthur passed his hat to John. And that shootout on the mountain? Arthur went hard to the end. I can never look at Rdr1 John without the reminder of Arthur on his head. Rockstar blessed us with this Red Dead franchise.
2018 since this masterpiece released, but Arthur saying “I’m gonna get you outta this bullshit if it’s that goddamn thing I do” is the most heroically heart breaking thing I’ve ever heard.
If your Honor is low or in the middle (inbetween Low and High, though its High honor by default), there will be someone running in the forest while Arthur ride his way back to the camp. I dunno if its Javier or one of the Pinkertons
I keep coming back to watch this mission. I finally finished the whole game the other day and the end of the main storyline and the end of the epilogue were both very emotional for me and I can't get over it
What makes me so sad about this ending is that John so desperately wanted arthur to keep pushing so he could also leave with his brother even though we know Arthur couldn't have made it with him
![RDR2 PC - John tracks down Micah /American Venom (Full Mission) [4K NO HUD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VIhfB_0AOo8/mqdefault.jpg)
![RDR2 PC - Attacking the Braithwaite Manor (Full Mission) [4K NO HUD]](/img/n.gif)
The pain in Arthurs voice when he says "Dutch"
"Oh Dutch........ He's a rat...." Fucking kills me everytime
Sex?
@@jinnybucko3353 sex
i love this game so much, no matter what kind of things that the gang did (except for dutch, Micah, Javier, etc) y could tell they were good people inside and the way rockstar portrays that, i love it. This game is a freaking masterpiece!
@Haywood J One of the reasons I like Dutch as a character (and enjoy hating him so much) is that he's complex, he really DID have a lot of redeeming qualities, especially early on- he really did take a lot of destitute people like orphans under his wing, taught them how to read alongside Hosea, taught them to think analytically and philosophically, etc. He had grand ideas about how the world could have been, and raged against what it was.
But as the Old West started drawing to a close and his old way of life started to die out; once the Pinkertons and the consequences for his bad actions started to catch up with him... he became increasingly paranoid, narcissistic, and callous. He became a bad man.
I think RDR2 is a game in which Arthur careens towards a moral event horizon and (at least in the high honor playthrough which I personally consider canonical) is saved at the last moment.... by his own imminent death. A few characters (most prominently Charles) state that TB is a blessing in a way. It gave Arthur a chance to take a hard look at what he had done in his entire life, and where he was, and what he'd leave.... it gave him a chance to set SOME things right. That's a chance that, for instance, John never got- his death was swift and sudden (though in hindsight he should've known). Tuberculosis destroyed Arthur's body, but it saved his soul.
But Dutch didn't step back from that precipice. RDR2 shows that he continued right past Arthur and dove right over it. Anything good left in him was lost to his insanity. It's just one of the many tragedies of this tale. Revenge, paranoia, greed... almost all of the major characters die to them, except those precious few who leave literally all of it behind and escape entirely from the lifestyle. At its heart, RDR is a funeral dirge for the Old West.
Arthur asked John to go and never look back. John asked Jack to go and never look back. Arthur died on top of a mountain in the sunshine while Dutch died on the bottom of a mountain in a snow storm. What a coincidence... these subtle details is one out of many things that makes Rockstar Games games stand out.
RedRiverChannel in my opinion that’s symbolism that Dutch was dishonorable and died in the cold at the bottom of a mountain meanwhile Arthur was honorable and died at the top of a mountain with the warmth of the sunshine comforting him
My favorite one is when Dutch and Arthur get cornered by the US military and he says “you can’t fight change, you can’t fight gravity” and jump into the stream. And funny enough Those are Dutch last words to John before he kills himself.
Never thought of this
if John took Arthur’s advice and run he’d be aluve
@@joshuadavis4474 he did, he didn’t have a choice but to help the Pinkertons because they found him and threatened his family, and he died because he was the last loose end
Arthur's death is so emotional not just because he is such a beloved character to all of us, but spending so much time with a protagonist, feeding him, fighting, riding across the world, you can't help but develop a bond to him. Most main characters in a game you are with for an allotted amount of time, but you actually have to take care of Arthur. He will always be, to me at least, the greatest protagonist I ever had the pleasure of playing as.
The bad ending is the best imo he made his bed and had to sleep in it. Arthur wasn’t a good guy he murdered and robbed people great game
@@queitn6287 I like thinking that he was a bad person living selfishly until he got diagnosed. Then, with the little time he had left, he decided to change his ways. He finally sees the stag. For all he knows, he lost. John got away, but so did Micah. Dutch left him to die and the rat is still living. In the end, he loses but he doesn’t care because he was able to save John Marston.
@@youraveragemango8671 Arthur never lived selfishly, he always followed Dutch's order and helped the gang wich was his family. He did everything to protect the ones who loved. He was a criminal and did bad things but always with a purpose and not for himself. He sure was a fool to believe in such a plan like the Tahiti's dream, but his heart was in the right place. But he also did many bad things and that's why, in the end, had to redempt himself through death.
Absolutely, I actually felt the same for John on Red Dead 1 and Roman Bellic from GTA 4. When you spend time with/playing someone and all of a sudden they're gone, it just gives me that depressing vibe.
He's like a Tamagotchi
It’s so sad knowing that Sean, Lenny and Hosea would have been standing with John and I at the end 💔
Only one like
lenny summer I miss you Lenny
It’s so true as well
Why Sean or Lenny? They were pretty loyal to Dutch if I remember correct.
@@emperorducky4951 Yeah but they were not stupid, i think that they would have chose Arthur and John´s side if they were still alive.
A toast to all those who have died along the way may they rest in peace
Abomination demon-feather one final, and one goddam fine toast might I add my friend.
My soul
Jenny, Davey, Mac, Sean, Hosea, Lenny, Arthur.
@@luke8801 kieran, Molly, and grimshaw
@Evan Glickman you’re cringy
You know Arthur's fate is really sealed when he passed on his satchel and hat to John.
Exactly
Big brother passing the torch on to his little brother. 😢
nah his fate was sealed when he got TB
R.I.P.
Arthur “Fenton, Leviticus Cornwall, Orthor, Arthur Callahan, Buffoon, Cowpoke, Pretty Boah, Tacitus Kilgore, Black Lung” Morgan
English too
@Blue green red skull no shit
+ buffoon
@Blue green red skullThey called him that for the Marco Dragic missions
Mr.M
Arthur,Sean,and Lenny drinking and talking
Hosea walks in
“Hello Fellers”
please don't forget kieran
And John later
Callenders brothers, Kieran, Jenny and then John comes last
" Fenton! We got some work to do! "
Issac Morgan too
"I gave you all I had. I did."
2022 and it still rips my heart out.
It's one of the most tragic things. To give all you had to someone, and be betrayed in the end. And the saddest part is it happens every day in the real world. How many men have put years and decades into a relationship, only to be cast aside. How many people have broken their backs for a job, only to be cast aside because they're no longer useful or the job destroyed them. That's why this is soo relatable to the average person. People give all they had all the time, every day, all over the world....but in the end they're never made whole. They're just figuratively left on top of a mountain to die alone. Arthur was there for everyone, even his horse, but no one was there for him. Part of that is his fault because of the choices he made, and some people couldn't be there because he was trying to save them, but Arthur was alone in all of it.
What about now
People who say that “Arthur didn’t deserve to die” missed the entire point of the game. Arthur was not a good man by any means, he murdered, robbed, and beat innocent people. The whole reason he got TB was because he beat Thomas Downes to death over some debt money. And like Arthur himself said, “you can’t live a bad life and expect good things to happen to you.” Arthur died as a result of his own wrongdoings, and he knew this. So in his final weeks alive, he chose to give others the chance to do the good that he couldn’t.
The game is called has Redemption in the name for a reason i mean
Well, you can live your life trying to be good and all you get is bad things happen to you. Arthur lived a hell of a life, he was insanely good at what he does, reunion/closure with the woman he loved, loyal friends at the end, beat the shit out of a rat even at the death's door. He won the game of life in my book.
I see it in simpler terms...Arthur needed the gravitas of Death (and knowing he was going to die), to finally see his Life for what it was; a lie. He'd been used his entire life, under pretense of Familial love, with the lives wasted from those who'd died under the same pretense, and that he needed to 'break' from Dutch.
"That which is killing you will help you to see, and see clearly Friend...See *and* hear."
- Blind Man Cassidy
I think you had low honor.
@@eviafamily7898 My first playthrough, I was max honor all throughout. Every playthrough since I’ve done low honor until the TB diagnosis, then I raise my honor.
Micah *shoots Susan*
Dutch *WhO iS bETraYinG mE*
@Doğu Ali Poyraz jeez chill out, I was making sure..
NOOOOW! Who amongst to, is with me.... And who, is BETRAYING ME?!
@KeyUploadshe’s lying he’s lying
@KeyUploads god dammit move. John your ready. Yeah
Everyone get down!
Nothing can replace the first time I played the mission the emotion behind all of it
1 year later,
It’s still sad
Rest In Peace Arthur Morgan
(11/13/19)
Why did you put a date in 😂
@@Alphae21 😂
I wish he was real
RIP Arthur Morgan
Yeah why did you put a date in?
(11/17/19)
Imagine, how difficult was this scene to film for Micah's actor
Yea he was a really good villian in rdr2 and in la noire when he was the doctor
Micahs actor is able to film this scene cause he’s just like Micah in game
@@JKTMETTASTIC
He's not an asshole in real life...
Yeah, getting his ass handed to him by Arthur.
YourFellowMemester yes he is
I get the feeling that the moment that Dutch was told that the only who won was John, he knew it was the truth. Maybe that’s why he spared John, killed Micah, and left him the gang’s money.
Or it’s because when he shot Micah it’s not because he likes John he hates John still but it’s only because he wanted to fulfill Arthur’s last request to keep John safe
Saddest death ever. Arthur fought til the end for redemption 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢. My favorite hero
He's not a hero
He's a good man
@@rayankamil9451 TRIGGERED
Fã De Games
It’s true, to a point. Arthur was an outlaw who robbed and killed his way across half a country. He was not a good person, and he knows this. But, he tries. He tries his hardest (mostly if you have high honor) to change what he can, and right as many wrongs as he can.
@@jared305 "There's a good man in you. But he is wrestling with a giant..."
"Mrs.Adler, RIDE WIFF MEH"
Such badass delivery from Roger Clark 👍🏼
Line delivery is great and love how it’s a call back to chapter 3, when they get back from Rhodes and he says “I will ride with you again Mrs.Adler if you will ride with me.”
You’re not a human if you didn’t cry for him
After many playthroughs or watches i just get a little tear in my eye
Does it count if i teared up a bit?
I didn’t cry but I teared up a lot I’ve played through the game twice but I got more emotional when it came to this part of the game than I did on my first play through
Ricardo Milos it made me so sad seeing Arthur progressively get weaker and weaker
No game has made me cry, except of course red dead redemption 2
Arthur in the Heaven:
,,HAHA, FOUND YA LENNNAY‘‘
LMAO
Am not so sure Arthur Morgan.
"LENNY MAH BOEH"
MAAAA BOAH
"I'm real sorry for ya son, its a hell of a thing."
* Cries in 4K *
Edit: thanks for likes
vincent vasquez I’m the 69 like
@@mahmoodali2437 who tf cares
1ndex god dammit it’s my time don’t ruin it
vincent vasquez * plays the game 1 year later *
@@Mazhrr bruh
Let’s be honest, if Sadie was sniping then she’d have probably only shot about 2 guys throughout the entire gunfight to Abigail. So truthfully, Arthur is the better shot
Fr nps b shooting nothing
Andy Le and when they do kill someone it’s always the guy that you were just about to shoot, making you miss a shot
Sadie: "Cause you're the better shot I mean."
27:20 Holy fuck this musical note played right then with that line, I wouldn't change a damned thing about this mission.
Dude yes some appreciation for the music in this mission. It’s 11/10 perfect, that moment you mentioned and the Arthur’s entire final stand on the mountain after John leaves. This video even cuts it off a bit short, the full version is incredible
37:39 damn I just realized if you look closely you can see Arthur’s body laying on the rock.
Aw🥺
Oh my, always thought that was a small boulder/rock as the camera gets further away from the original cliff
It’s sad, knowing that Arthur is losing everything really fast, such as losing his horse, his trust with the gang, and his life.
If you've got a brother that you've been through some shit with, I know this hit you hard:
"... You're my brother."
"I know... I know."
They're a pain in the you know what at times but at the same time you will go to war or give your life for them.
We are all we got as men. Whether related or thru friendship, a true brother will always watch the other brother's back. 😢
I remember I cried when Arthur said thank you to the the horse mainly because I never changed the horse I had once i got the first horse you buy I never got rid of her Rest In Peace Leo
Two years later and he still feels more like a person than most real people.
The horse scene was completely unnecessary, but it makes me tear up every single time. I can just feel the sympathy Arthur had.
It was necessary for the emotion, To make you realize you lost everything and you won't get out of this.
Nah, it makes you engage John Wick mode.
It made you realize that escape wasn’t meant for Arthur. He was destined to die, and it’s up for you to decide whether he dies doing good, or bad.
The ending really exemplifies how in the end, we all crawl in pain just to try to experience one moment of peace, like walking through a desert made out of jagged glass for one last cup of water. He didn't just lay there and die, he used the last of what he had to see the sun rise one last time, and all that for just a moment, but as short as it was, it was worth it, because in the end it's the little things that matter, there's nothing bigger than the little things. He took whatever last bit of beauty in the world he could get.
When Skanderbeg died his horse didn’t want anyone to ride him but he would accept to do Arthur’s last ride
Flyareg I appreciate you
Flyareg Skanderbeg ?
weed
He was a Serbian leader fighting the ottoman Turks.
He was Albanian you bitch
I want Arthur back man :(
YO FAM With mods my friend
Start a new game lol
Start the game as John then play the epilogue as Arthur
I read your comment very wrong holy shit I'm not even gonna say what I read
StillBetta80 do it
The 20 last minutes of the game I was crying.
17:11 is where you start to cry
😫😫😫My favourite song...
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
When your girlfriend said she home alone
@@Zachattack1212 ? Its not funny and its make no sense
@@Zachattack1212 you don't even have a gf and probably never will
Doesn’t matter how many times you play through the game, you will always cry at the end
“Your a good man” that line always hits hard
For me is “Thank You Feller” I got that one In my ending
@@kvonn3289 “ya know there ain’t enough kindness in this world that’s for sure.”
Arthur: "I already have beaten you."
Also Arthur: Proceeds to beat the shit out of Micah lol*
That kick at the end of that combo he did on Micah is so satisfying to me, idk why
31:38 those 10-20 seconds of fighting looks so smooth when beating micah
That was the best part of the entire fight for me, my boy Arthur gave Micah the hands
Sadie was Arthur’s Bonnie McFarlane, carried out till the end. Love the role they both play in both our favorite gunslinger’s stories. Nothing like a tough blonde heroine to have our backs until fate catches up with us.
Let's take a minute to remember these great members of the van der linde gang who we lost along the way:
Arthur morgan
Lenny summers
Susan grimshaw
Herr Strauss (later revealed by charles he was beaten to death by the pinkertons)
Hosea Matthews
Molly O'shea (framed for being a rat)
Eagle flies (later died from a gunshot wound)
Karen (was revealed she drank herself to death in epilogue chapter)
Kieran Duffy
Sean McGuire
You forgot the dog lol
I swear high honor Arthur Morgan has the most peaceful death and a legend
The entire gang is dead dude, Jack is the only one left
Its sad
I'm playing for the first time and Arthur Morgan died yesterday, I'm sad, he gave his best for everyone, congratulations Rockstar Games for this great story and for giving us the best game!
Me too, i just finished the game yesterday
I was pissed that i didn’t kill Micah and yes Ik you kill him in the Epilogue but I wanted Arthur to do it and I still miss him 😢😭
Epilogue*
I hated him more when he calls Arthur black lung
Mods activated.
Even though Arthur died, he definitely won the fight in emotions. He died knowing he redeemed himself by(depending on the players choice) giving money to Mrs. Londonderry and helping John escape alive with his family. While Micah left on his own, and losing affiliation with Dutch, until he lured him with money.
Closest you can get is the high honor go back option where you slash his eye out.
I don't see why Arthur would go back though, especially a high honor Arthur who's literally telling John that money doesn't matter and revenge is a fool's game lol. Although it'd be pretty badass if high honor "go back" Arthur said something like:
"Forget the money, John.... Revenge is a fool's game, and I'm feeling mighty foolish right now.... go, get to your family. I'll take care of them."
31:40 Arthur laying a SMACKDOWN on micha
when Arthur said "thank you" to his horse I had to take a break for a few. That was a sucker punch to the gut.
Bro you must have a beast of a computer
Glitch Lazerr what are u smoking no he’s not
@Glitch Lazerr you do know you can use a xbox controller on pc right?
@@codyferrell5075 He has to have a xbox as well why would you get an xbox controller when you dont have one lol
Joey Loobie For pc gaming for pc gamers. I know a couple of friends who the only video game platform they have is their pc and they have an xbox controller specifically for it
@@Kirokill1 Yea i know some do but he has a xbox He literally did some videos on it when rdr2 came out for consoles you can see the buttons saying RT so the other guy was right.
Arthur taught me something and rode off into the sunset. Thank you, Arthur
sunrise
Can we just quickly take a moment to appriciate his aim without the dot
sad thing is, it's so hard to show combat skill on console. either autoaim does all the work or you use manual aim and hit like horseshit.
its autoaim dumbass
@@spinnercylinder6046auto aim can look cool on most games depends on how it looks tho.
36:31 Arthur was laughing a bit cause he knew he won against Micah 🤠
I thought I was the only one who noticed that, I pointed that out before to someone else.
@@ludwigtheholyblade_777 🤠
I love that final decision: you gain true redemption and help John escape; or your greed takes over you and you go for money you never get to spend.
I've knew something was gonna to happen eventually but not how exactly how he was going to die. The ending broke my heart.. I've was thinking about another playthrough but to be honest, I need too wait. What a game!.. glad I don't see any playthrough before I got it for PC but maybe I'm wrong, would have be easier maybe
"He's lying. Heee's LYING."
God, you can hear the snake oil dripping off of Micah's breath in that line.
This will forever be a milestone in entertainment history! 😢
It doesn't get easier, re-watching this has me in tears again
The second saddest part about this ending for me is the fact you lose your horse... Now, many swap horses as they find stronger and faster ones, but Stripe I kept all the way from the start of Valentine. He was probably the dumbest horse to ever exist, tripping on random rocks and branches in the woods sending me flying, or barreling straight towards oncoming pedestrians. But he was a good horse... He was a fighter. For how scrawny he was he was resilient. I was expecting Arthur's passing, and I was even preparing for it, but not my horse. I wish I would have groomed him, got him a nice saddle, and a decent bedroll one last time before that mission. Rest in peace Stripe, you were an idiot, but you are probably the most toughest idiot I've ever met.
Had a horse called him legacy because I thought it was a cool name first time playing brought it in valentine with Hosea always kept it clean and I can’t count how many times I reset my progress because I accidentally died with my horse because it slipped of the side of a mountain or died from a train always kept horse reviver on me just in case loved him and in chapter 5 after Hosea died legacy was exactly as his name said he was the legacy of everyone and everyone’s time in the gang and who had passed I remember visiting all the graves with legacy and taking a moment and after he died i could feel tears in my eyes the fact Arthur stayed and thanked him all I could do was reminisce about all the times I had with that horse some people say Beual was their horse but legacy only felt right in the final mission to ride my first horse god I loved you legacy rip for stripe .it’s the second worst death in my opinion
17:16 coming home after graduation
Damn it’s nostalgic
I can’t wait for the future if gaming. This is the first game I can say is truely photorealistic. Not perfect, but it’s just so beautiful
Putting myself self in Arthur’s boots it must of been painfull for the last chapter of the game constantly fighting while having TB most people would be in bed crying but Arthur is just a legend shows how much he cares about others and how he has made the change from a bad man to a good man and I’m result made him so his life more clearly then ever before and he realised the fact Dutch is not who he thinks he was and he had to come to terms with that. And it’s so sad to see him release most of his life has been wasted, on hurting others and that deep down he really does care about others as shown as he helps people all throughout the game, and especially near the end when he was coming to terms that he was gonna die, you could clearly see his main priority was to help others. Also Arthur’s knows he can’t ask for forgiveness for his sins as shown when he gave money to mrs Downes and stopped her son from being bullied and potentially killed, you can see he knows he ruined there lives because he killed mr Downes and he knows he got what he deserved which is the TB he got. So he doesn’t ask for forgiveness because he can not forgive himself, so at the end of his life he try’s spreading good bye letting the Marstons have another chance and letting the innocents of the gang run off and ultimately facing the evil in this world which is represented by Micah. Arthur knows he can not forgive himself so he aims as his last mission to stop Dutch and Micah. As he lays on the ground victorious he leans over to face the sunrise one more time and he remembers all the good times he had and all the friends he lost along the way and at his last breath he knows he has done all he could at his last moments of life.
:Rockstar this is Art. RIP Arthur Morgan 1863-1899
It's so poetic...how the Marston family were the ones who killed the antagonists.
Abigail killed Milton, John killed Micah, and Jack killed Ross.
This mission may not be as grand as RDR1's redemption ending, but Arthur's road to redemption was truly well written as well. I will not forget the first time, went down for the money hoping to help John and family...and I was high honor thankfully.
Arthur is completely a bad guy, but his tale of redemption shouldn't be taken for granted. People started benefiting from such redemption, even if the law says he's not worthy of such goodwill.
John crying out "you left me" is much more powerful with the first game's context, as well as the fact that Javier never pointed his gun at John and Arthur.
Javier actually does aim at Arthur at 22:35
U kno its gonna be emotional when the name of the mission is the title of the game
Ah yes, now I can watch the saddest ending in video games again... IN 4K!
Arthur, John, many of Dutch’s Gang… They went down fighting. They all had their ideals, their differences, flaws, thoughts, and whatnots. In the end… They were all human as you all… And I.
I will never forget the first time I played this game and a lot of Arthur’s words will stay with me I wish I could go back to when I first played it
The last interaction ever between Arthur and Sadie, wishing her and Abigail well and saying his final goodbye. And it's even more sad because they both know it's Arthur's final moments. Best Rockstar game ever, and R.I.P to Arthur their best ever character 🥺
Even sadder in 4k
you might notice that javier wasn't there to hear that micah was the rat and he was hesitant to point his gun at arthur
The way he said that he's lying
He's LYIIIIIIING!!!!
He’s LYEEEEEEEIIIIIINNNNGGGG
He was.
@@micahbell1435 You're full of shit Micah!
@@micahbell1435 Arthur ain’t lying. You’re a rat...
I just don’t want Arthur to die. I don’t want to start this mission because it breaks my tiny heart to see my favourite character die. Rip
(Game)
Omg, look at Javier. He just pointed his gun up and never chose a side 😂
Maybe we just didn't see
@@olgierdvoneverec6216 his actor actually told the devs that he thinks that Javier wouldn’t point a gun at his brothers, they then made it so he pointed it in the air
@@nunziopuzo9210 Yep I liked that touch, they DID have Javier say some antagonistic things in Ch 6 but it makes sense he might not fully turn on them
That feeling when you accidentally have 380p on for half of the video
Even when Arthur was faced with death he still stayed loyal
Me watching this In 2021 Arthur’s is still a legend
No Micah Bell you have lost Arthur got what he wanted at the end for John Abigail and Jack to be a family a normal family at is . Arthur won his battle good job Arthur.
If you look closely in the trees near the entrance of the camp, you can see the Pinkertons already. They’re looking at us before the shoot that happens when author just enters the camp you can see them. Pause at 20:15 and look at the trees in the background
Damn 😯 Micah looked right at them too. I had a good theory that it wasn't Micah too
PC people finally know the pain now
It really is hard losing a horse. It’s like losing a family member who your close to.
This is the best game ever created thank you rockstar
Maybe not the best game ever created, but it's the best game ever created by Rockstar for sure
"im gonna get you outa this bullshit, if its the last goddamn thing i do" that line absolutely crushed me, it was the last thing he did and im so happy that we got to help john even if we couldn't save Arthur. this game is an absolute masterpiece of art
Arthur and Joel from last of us are going to be remembered as my favorite game protagonists of all time. Arthur Morgan really feels like your big, brave older brother by the end of the campaign.
Even after 5 years, it still stings. Dutch may have been a good man who cared about his people at one time, but i dont think we ever knew that Dutch
and people say this isnt the greatest game of all time
1:10 The way arthur screams Dutch's name in disbelief is really hearth shattering. Arthur sacrificed everything in his life for this man and his lies. Only to see it crumble and be betrayed in the end.
One year later and this still hits me hard.
17:00
Where real men cried
The song gets me everytime
34:50
I think one of the more underrated devastating moments. In his dying breaths, arthur warns Dutch about Micah. Even til the very end, Arthur was loyal. He has quite literally nothing to lose, and would gain nothing by lying, and Dutch understands this. Arthur is a representation of everything Dutch claimed to value, and he's watching it all die alongside his only friend left in the world. And its his fault. You can see it in his eyes, and for the first time, he's speechless
just finished playing the game for the first time " I'm late for the party I know" but I mean they should warn us to never get attached to the character. wow that was emotional
I know this is old. I just played and beat the game for the first time this week. I fcking cried when Arthur passed his hat to John. And that shootout on the mountain? Arthur went hard to the end. I can never look at Rdr1 John without the reminder of Arthur on his head. Rockstar blessed us with this Red Dead franchise.
I don't have the strenght to go throught this....
Not again....
2018 since this masterpiece released, but Arthur saying “I’m gonna get you outta this bullshit if it’s that goddamn thing I do” is the most heroically heart breaking thing I’ve ever heard.
20:34 you can see a person on a horse behind arthur
John?
Was Arthur followed?
@vaping conor "My name is Milton from the shitty Agency and we came to kill you Because Micah Was a good Boah!
Javier on watch.
If your Honor is low or in the middle (inbetween Low and High, though its High honor by default), there will be someone running in the forest while Arthur ride his way back to the camp. I dunno if its Javier or one of the Pinkertons
This needs its own movie
It would be awesome if done right 😊
Only if they don't fuck it up. Hollywood always fucks up video game adaptions.
Map it looks even better than I remember
i cried during this whole mission while shooting them pinkertons. Come on rockstar i can’t kill people while crying
Why am I still crying at this god damn game.
I keep coming back to watch this mission. I finally finished the whole game the other day and the end of the main storyline and the end of the epilogue were both very emotional for me and I can't get over it
Micah when he does the “ahhhhh” he sounds like a gremlin and it makes me laugh
Well he is a gremlin
When Arthur rides his horse and it goes from kinda bright day to cold dark night, takes me every time.
What makes me so sad about this ending is that John so desperately wanted arthur to keep pushing so he could also leave with his brother even though we know Arthur couldn't have made it with him
Arthur's Redemption: Saving a Brother and Reunite a Family
RIP Arthur Morgan
Agreed