I went on a low-carb diet to lose excess body fat. And, as a side effect, I also lost decades of crippling depression. It's the best side effect I've ever experienced in my life.
Dr Scher, I have kept my depression at bay with running and low carb diets for 20+ years. I was a disaster in university, where it was carbs all day long. The schools now cajole and coerce parents into buying "care baskets" for their students, and it's all processed carbs. No wonder our young people are hurting so much.
Thank you for sharing your journey. You are right, what we have come to accept as "normal" or even "caring" can be counterproductive to our health. We need voices like yours to help push back against that trend.
Thank you so much for this video. Being a layman I didn’t understand everything. I’ll need to watch this again. I really appreciate hearing about this study and having an explain to us. I’ve had mental health issues all my life. I’m just recently learning that much of it could’ve been changed years ago. The studies are so helpful and your channel is a real blessing you. Love from Vermont
Excellent interview. I wish the doctors would catch up! And general population! I am on keto and intermittent fasting since may 2023. I put my husband and four children (including 10 year old keto-resistant 😅😂) on Keto (not all the time but 3 days or more) abd wow, the level of ability to handle stress and the reduction in anxiety is amazing. I cannot say that loud enough. I believe all mental and physical illness begins in the gut!!! ❤❤
I am 78 years old. I have had dysthymia since childhood. My grandfather was paranoid and my schizophrenic brother recently committed suicide. I have been eating keto + IF for 4 years, carnivorous for a few months = no improvement in mood and fatigue. When the mental problem is anchored in the family over 2 generations or more ..... hum not easy to get out of it without certainly the support of a multidisciplinary team. Google translate french. (one of my grandsons 30 years old is hospitalized with schizophrenia)
There may also be underlying nutritional deficiencies, as I have found, as well as a serious wheat/gluten genetic sensitivity as well as MSG and a link to neurological issues.
One of my twin sons died by suicide when he was 24; 10 days after I took him to the hospital with suicidal ideation. They said he had anxiety and released him without further testing or treatment. His brother was in the hospital for a month a couple of years ago. The hospital did no blood work testing, just observed and prescribed medication for schizophrenia. The next week, he was diagnosed with severe B12 and D deficiency, to start with.
Oh Anita! I am so sorry for all you have been through. Mental illness has been in my family for generations as well. Please stick with it and consider working with one of the metabolic nutritionists that are found on the metabolic Mind website. I am 4 months in to a ketogenic diet + IF. It has helped tremendously but have had to work with macros. It has taken time and assistance to work things out and be able to keep my ketones at an optimal level for metabolic and brain health. I wasn’t overweight but horribly insulin resistant. It has taken my body months to start to heal but it is healing and my brain/moods are so much better. I look forward to what I will feel like in another 2 months and at a year. Hoping you feel better soon and that one of the brilliant practitioners that are recommended on the website can help. Lifting you up today and your sweet nephew.
Respect for you for trying so hard. You may want to look into individual food items that maybe causing issues. I know some people are combining ketogenic + AIP for better results.
Thank you, Metabolic Mind, for your bold, yet balanced, proclamation of the truth. Just to relate a quick personal story: I recently took my Mom to a very kind, brilliant neurologist. My Mom has significant stenosis of her left, carotid artery, and I am concerned (obviously) about the potential for stroke. The doctor was terrific, but I was stunned, frankly, when he admitted to not knowing what a CAC score is! He also seemed almost flippant when I voiced my concern regarding how insulin resistance might be impacting her carotid artery disease. I stayed humble and thanked him for his expertise, but I find myself a bit baffled! How is it that brilliant people do not know this stuff? Is it a lack of interest in the literature? Or, are they, perhaps, fearful of not operating within the current standard of care framework? It just puzzles me, and sort of saddens me, too.
It's the "silos" of care in the current medical system. This neurologist immerses himself in cultivating expertise in neurology, rather than taking a more holistic approach. Unfortunately it can mean missing the forest for the trees.
This is the kind of situation that makes me and many other experienced well informed allied health clinicians so disappointed with our medical system colleagues.
The can of worms not touched by this dialogue is that the antipsychotics commonly prescribed for severe mood disorders tend to make insulin resistance WORSE. Nevermind the "freshman fifty," here comes the "olanzapine one hundred."
There is a psychiatrist called Chris Palmer who has done a lot of research on the ketogenic diet being used to reduce the need for antipsychotics as well help patients lose antipsychotic induced weight gain.
Please Dr Scher bring in Professor Thomas Seyfried from College Boston. He is in the for front of Metabolic therapy to help cancer patients in particular. 🙏
I suggest that those who hesitate to embrace these connections bristle at the word "lifestyle" as "the object of needed change". Americans in particular cling to their "lifestyle" as their "right", and thus resist anyone who suggests they "give up" that "right". "Empowerment" wording might shift this hesitance. Look at the "empowerment" language model of the Paleo/Crossfit community, for instance. [I am not judging any "lifestyle" as "good" or "bad"]
Hi, I’m new to keto and tracking macros and I was just wondering how do I find the macros in food if the nutritional label isn’t trustworthy . For example we have two bags of frozen broccoli with the same serving size and grams but one says 1 net carb a serving and the other says 2. Where can I find accurate information? Thank you
Hi Megan. You are likely to find small discrepancies like this wherever you look. But the "good news" is that they are small and unlikely to significantly affect the ultimate outcomes. That being said, if you are looking for a site that tends to be accurate, the USDA is a good place to start fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/1103170/nutrients
You can have perfect metabolic health and get psychosis or depression. I do think if your metabolic health is poor it can lead to things like yo yo dieting, low gaba, etc which leads to mental disfunction. It's hard enough getting sane people to rectify metabolic issues, good luck getting not so sane people on medication that probably cause metabolic disfunction, to rectify this
That is why it would be so much more helpful to be diagnosed and have corrected, as children, or early in the health issues, so their illness doesn't become them.
Stress and trauma can cause mental health problems while messing with hunger hormones, fat gain, etc. Toxins also can cause serious psychiatric disorders. But even if diet isn't the cause, it's probably often a key contributing factor. One can deal with other problems to a greater degree if one follows a diet that gives a lot of nutrition, metabolic health, low inflammation, etc. It's usually not only one factor but the cumulative effects, some of them epigenetically cumulative over multiple generations.
@@MarmaladeINFP yeah. You can have perfect diet, but if there is some form of chronic stress, it will get to you. Combined factors make things worse. I think trauma leads to poorer choices, and lots before the trauma got to them their choices weren't that poor
I went on a low-carb diet to lose excess body fat. And, as a side effect, I also lost decades of crippling depression. It's the best side effect I've ever experienced in my life.
same here
I can't wait when I lose that too during that diet❤
Dr Scher, I have kept my depression at bay with running and low carb diets for 20+ years. I was a disaster in university, where it was carbs all day long. The schools now cajole and coerce parents into buying "care baskets" for their students, and it's all processed carbs. No wonder our young people are hurting so much.
Thank you for sharing your journey. You are right, what we have come to accept as "normal" or even "caring" can be counterproductive to our health. We need voices like yours to help push back against that trend.
Thank you so much for this video. Being a layman I didn’t understand everything. I’ll need to watch this again. I really appreciate hearing about this study and having an explain to us. I’ve had mental health issues all my life. I’m just recently learning that much of it could’ve been changed years ago. The studies are so helpful and your channel is a real blessing you. Love from Vermont
Excellent interview. I wish the doctors would catch up! And general population! I am on keto and intermittent fasting since may 2023. I put my husband and four children (including 10 year old keto-resistant 😅😂) on Keto (not all the time but 3 days or more) abd wow, the level of ability to handle stress and the reduction in anxiety is amazing. I cannot say that loud enough. I believe all mental and physical illness begins in the gut!!! ❤❤
I am 78 years old. I have had dysthymia since childhood. My grandfather was paranoid and my schizophrenic brother recently committed suicide. I have been eating keto + IF for 4 years, carnivorous for a few months = no improvement in mood and fatigue. When the mental problem is anchored in the family over 2 generations or more ..... hum not easy to get out of it without certainly the support of a multidisciplinary team. Google translate french. (one of my grandsons 30 years old is hospitalized with schizophrenia)
There may also be underlying nutritional deficiencies, as I have found, as well as a serious wheat/gluten genetic sensitivity as well as MSG and a link to neurological issues.
One of my twin sons died by suicide when he was 24; 10 days after I took him to the hospital with suicidal ideation. They said he had anxiety and released him without further testing or treatment. His brother was in the hospital for a month a couple of years ago. The hospital did no blood work testing, just observed and prescribed medication for schizophrenia. The next week, he was diagnosed with severe B12 and D deficiency, to start with.
Oh Anita! I am so sorry for all you have been through. Mental illness has been in my family for generations as well. Please stick with it and consider working with one of the metabolic nutritionists that are found on the metabolic Mind website. I am 4 months in to a ketogenic diet + IF. It has helped tremendously but have had to work with macros. It has taken time and assistance to work things out and be able to keep my ketones at an optimal level for metabolic and brain health. I wasn’t overweight but horribly insulin resistant. It has taken my body months to start to heal but it is healing and my brain/moods are so much better. I look forward to what I will feel like in another 2 months and at a year.
Hoping you feel better soon and that one of the brilliant practitioners that are recommended on the website can help. Lifting you up today and your sweet nephew.
Wearing a continuous glucose monitor and really dialing in your sleep hygiene can potentially help you move the needle more. 🤲🏽
Respect for you for trying so hard. You may want to look into individual food items that maybe causing issues. I know some people are combining ketogenic + AIP for better results.
Thank you, Metabolic Mind, for your bold, yet balanced, proclamation of the truth. Just to relate a quick personal story: I recently took my Mom to a very kind, brilliant neurologist. My Mom has significant stenosis of her left, carotid artery, and I am concerned (obviously) about the potential for stroke. The doctor was terrific, but I was stunned, frankly, when he admitted to not knowing what a CAC score is! He also seemed almost flippant when I voiced my concern regarding how insulin resistance might be impacting her carotid artery disease. I stayed humble and thanked him for his expertise, but I find myself a bit baffled! How is it that brilliant people do not know this stuff? Is it a lack of interest in the literature? Or, are they, perhaps, fearful of not operating within the current standard of care framework? It just puzzles me, and sort of saddens me, too.
so frustrating!!!!
It's the "silos" of care in the current medical system. This neurologist immerses himself in cultivating expertise in neurology, rather than taking a more holistic approach. Unfortunately it can mean missing the forest for the trees.
This is the kind of situation that makes me and many other experienced well informed allied health clinicians so disappointed with our medical system colleagues.
I have never been diagnosed with any kind of mental illness but I can say that I am so much calmer and happy since I started the carnivore woe.
Hi, I am interested in keto for folks without mental illness - so, please let me know what is your diet like.
I only eat real food from the animal kingdom, no plant matter at all. I also do not use any type of vegetable oil.@@jayanthirangan-uc9oo
Loved this video! Thank you!
The can of worms not touched by this dialogue is that the antipsychotics commonly prescribed for severe mood disorders tend to make insulin resistance WORSE. Nevermind the "freshman fifty," here comes the "olanzapine one hundred."
There is a psychiatrist called Chris Palmer who has done a lot of research on the ketogenic diet being used to reduce the need for antipsychotics as well help patients lose antipsychotic induced weight gain.
Totally.
Great video! Thank you!
Awesome interview. Great info
Please Dr Scher bring in Professor Thomas Seyfried from College Boston. He is in the for front of Metabolic therapy to help cancer patients in particular. 🙏
I suggest that those who hesitate to embrace these connections bristle at the word "lifestyle" as "the object of needed change". Americans in particular cling to their "lifestyle" as their "right", and thus resist anyone who suggests they "give up" that "right". "Empowerment" wording might shift this hesitance. Look at the "empowerment" language model of the Paleo/Crossfit community, for instance. [I am not judging any "lifestyle" as "good" or "bad"]
Eating less and especially eating smaller meals and less carbs cured my depression.
Hi, I’m new to keto and tracking macros and I was just wondering how do I find the macros in food if the nutritional label isn’t trustworthy . For example we have two bags of frozen broccoli with the same serving size and grams but one says 1 net carb a serving and the other says 2. Where can I find accurate information? Thank you
Hi Megan. You are likely to find small discrepancies like this wherever you look. But the "good news" is that they are small and unlikely to significantly affect the ultimate outcomes. That being said, if you are looking for a site that tends to be accurate, the USDA is a good place to start fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/1103170/nutrients
❤
Someone get this to the family of the one that tromped dr oz in politics John feterman
good idea.
👌
You can have perfect metabolic health and get psychosis or depression. I do think if your metabolic health is poor it can lead to things like yo yo dieting, low gaba, etc which leads to mental disfunction. It's hard enough getting sane people to rectify metabolic issues, good luck getting not so sane people on medication that probably cause metabolic disfunction, to rectify this
Like most medications for bipolar, that seem to work, cause obesity in lots of people
I think your points are really valid! This can explain why this might not work for everyone!
That is why it would be so much more helpful to be diagnosed and have corrected, as children, or early in the health issues, so their illness doesn't become them.
Stress and trauma can cause mental health problems while messing with hunger hormones, fat gain, etc. Toxins also can cause serious psychiatric disorders. But even if diet isn't the cause, it's probably often a key contributing factor. One can deal with other problems to a greater degree if one follows a diet that gives a lot of nutrition, metabolic health, low inflammation, etc. It's usually not only one factor but the cumulative effects, some of them epigenetically cumulative over multiple generations.
@@MarmaladeINFP yeah. You can have perfect diet, but if there is some form of chronic stress, it will get to you. Combined factors make things worse. I think trauma leads to poorer choices, and lots before the trauma got to them their choices weren't that poor