Here’s the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you! Redback: amzn.to/3Z7pYEC Steel Blue: amzn.to/3GErs1Z Carolina: amzn.to/3X5aori Rockport: amzn.to/3jNay8f Reebok: amzn.to/3Qdi0pi Dunlop: amzn.to/3ifEzNB (no longer available) Black Hammer: amzn.to/3ZcEATh Ad Tec: amzn.to/3jSdbWf Brahma: amzn.to/3GgDRHM Red Wing: Available at the Red Wing Online Store Herman Survivors: Available at Walmart Larnmern: Available at Walmart
please could you do a test on snake proof boots. many claim to be but i'm not thinking there are any industry standards they must adhere to. it's very important to me and probably to many others who live in rattler country. thank you
I agree about wishing you could rate longevity, but also important I think is specifically tread longevity and effectiveness. I fear that the traction tests that you do might not be very effective after a small or a significant amount of wear on the sole material. for example, some of the more expensive rubberized soles seemed to perform worse initially but I would venture to guess that may change over time as initial wear and more significant wear patterns set in. Do you think you would be able to simulate some sole wear?
You mentioned you wanted to test longevity, it's been about 2 years. Hopefully its something that's been worked on as a surprise, if not its a suggestion for another video. As if the cheap pair don't last as long, would they still be the best/cheaper option compared to the pricier boots. For example, I'm on my 4th pair of Walmart cargo pants so thats already around 80+ Would be nice for more boot episodes
Especially if you have planter faceitis, which then can irritate sciatica if you have it. Also, you develop aches and pains in your joints, knees, low and mid back. It's all related to your shoes/boots and whether your arch' are off. Once this happens you start to develop callous pressure points where the skin will callous. Be sure and use a golf ball preferably (if you can tolerate it), or tennis ball and roll them under each foot to break up the fascia tissues. I would also invest in a electric foot file. You will be amazed at the difference in your feet.
Thanks for adding the Redwings. The pair you tested are the same ones I wear welding. I usually get from 4 to 6 years out of them on concrete and sharp objects. I only had 1 pair fail when I punctured a hole through the sole. Redwing gave me a new pair, no questions asked. 10 hrs a day on my feet and still the best boots.
I suggest trying the 2414, puncture resistant and goretex for dryer interior along with waterproof. The plate in the bottom helps with standing on ladders as it adds rigidity to the shank of the boot keeping your foot straighter and not allowing it to fold as much.
Red Wings have a super sole on some models witch is about nail proof those are the ones I always got and I never got the ones with the big pad in back as it don`t really add any comfort
I wore the Redwing Style 2406 that you feature in this video while I worked at an aluminum extrusion plant in Corona, Ca. They saved my foot when it got caught in a hydraulic lift. The steel toe kept my toes from being crushed and helped hold the steel plate from breaking all my metatarsal’s. Overall damage was one broken metatarsal, damaged tendons, and severe bruising. Great quality boots, I’d recommend them to anyone.
Garhettgross - thank you for not sharing the gristly photo. Crushing toes is an important test which Todd amazingly missed but which anyone working in heavy industry should seriously consider. Most of us go with a price/comfort ratio thing. The shock is that the Redwings tested #1 (by PF) for comfort as well. I've never owned a pair due to the cost, but would consider that if I needed my toes not crushed:-) The info is much appreciated!
I’d enjoy seeing you test military boots. Not only the different manufacturers, but also the variances between what each branch authorizes. Even a comparison of tanker boots would be awesome (but understandably niche to most viewers). I joined the Marine Corps in 2006 when they just changed from black boots to Coyote brown with the embossed EGA’s. The quality of some manufacturers was quite inferior to others, but improved over time. After a few years I got my first set of Danner RAT steel toes and loved the comfort despite the heaviness. Another set of Danner RAT boots were the gortex/waterproof version and they didn’t last a year. My third set was RAT but non steel toe and I still wear them now; 10 years later. Belleville was quite a good brand as well when I got out in 2015 and that pair still wears well but not very often. Love all your videos; keep up the excellent work!
The other day I restored my headlight housing based off your video, went with the sylvania restore kit and I know for a 100 percent fact that your test are as legit as they get. Thank you for all your hard work and dedication to us viewers
@@joshuadavidson4103 I tend to buy tools only after checking for a project farm video on the subject and without fail the people I work with have positive things to say when borrowing them.
Not true when it comes to boots..the reason you spend money on better boots is because your trying to stay as comfortable as possible for as long as possible..the only way to find out if boots are quality is to WEAR THEM for at least 24 hrs of work..after 20 plus years,i've worn just all of them. cheap to expensive..get boots that are comfortable,you can resole and that have a good shank in them
Longevity is really important when considering the cost. I used to buy ~$50 Brahma boots every 4 months or so. My first pair of redwings was around $250, and they lasted around 18 months of hard wearing in a junkyard, and still looked better than 3-4 month old Brahma boots. When you add up the price for all the cheap boots to last as long, suddenly the price of good boots looks a lot better. That plus the extra comfort of the nicer boots makes it a no brainer option for me these days. Fantastic work as always! I'd really love to see you get your hands on some nice handmade boots like Nick's
Curious if you have had your RW's re-soled/etc? A resole and basic care can run 130-160 and might really extend the life. Check out Trenton and Heath's latest video.
I'm going on 10 years with my Redwing boots. Granted, I don't daily them but they still get used. I learned years ago not to buy cheap boots. Dry and comfortable feet go a long way when you get older.
I learned about Redwing boots when I worked on the fire line for the forest service back in the mid '60s. Now I am just on my second pair. Quite economical. The Redwing store resoled my first pair several times, and I replaced the insole, but they were still good for 40 years. The only time I wear cheap boots is when welding. Next time I need to replace those boots, I'm definitely going to look at the Black Hammer. Thank you for all your work and creativity.
I work in oil and gas in a fairly chemical ridden environment. Everyone here uses red wings. They are the only boot you can get 1-3 years of service out of here. Nothing else lasts. I am amazed to see people getting double digits worth of use out of their redwings. While that is certainly not the case up here, the redwings still outperform everything else. Redwings all the way.
@@curtisbender1945 , made to order boots from companies that have been making boots for decades (or, in some cases, over 100 years) offer better toughness/ longevity than Red Wings (I really like Red Wings, but I’m a boot person). Look up White’s Boots Smokejumpers, Nick’s BuilderPros, or Wesco Jobmasters. Or Franks, etc. Red Wings are maybe the best mass produced work boots, but not the best overall in terms of toughness/ longevity.
My father has worn the Redwings for 50 years. He was an electrician at a Phosphate and Acid production mine for 40 years and that was the only boot he wore there. He's still wearing his last pair he bought and he's been retired for nearly 15 years. Always appreciate the effort you put into trying out and comparing the items in your projects.
I grew up less than a 40 minute drive from Redwing , Minnesota. If ya worked da range, felled trees and bucked em, built houses with the lumber, put down concrete, brick and mortar, put up and shingled roofs, dug a ditch, built a bridge....ya wore Redwings. Period. 👍🏻💪🤷♂️😏
I imagine Red Wings were the only boot a lot of people wore at that mine. I don't put my boots in that sort of environment but Red Wings are the only shoes that have been able to keep up with my abuse. I can see why he wore those.
I built Red Wing boots for 9 years. I was a floating operator so I did all processes in 2 departments. They are Very good boots made with care in my home Town of Red Wing MN. The cost more but if you take care of them they will far outlast other brands. 😉👍 Great video as always.
All you really need to do with Redwings is clean them and condition them so they don't dry out. Plus most Redwings are able to be resoled. After the break in period my 606's are easily the most comfortable thing I've ever put on my feet. Can't wait for my Iron Rangers to be broken in. I think they hit that sweet spot of quality, durability, and cost for most people.
@@craig3536 my Iron rangers lasted 7 year 3 resoles. They still look pretty good but are now hurting my left heal. Time for a new pair. But they change the designed the midsole is no longer use cork! Very disapointed not sure if I'll buy a pair.
I'm not sure what I'm more impressed by: The fact that you make these objective comparison videos, or how you manage to make these and still read/respond to nearly every comment on every video you make. You sir deserve a commitment award
Great test! I have been an industrial electrical contractor for over 30 years. Redwing by far have been my favorite as well as Keen. The EH (Electrical Hazard Rating) that you refer to is an ASTM standard of 600 volts or less in dry conditions. You far exceeded this test.
I worked in a factory over a decade and Red Wings became my go to after having to replace cheaper boots frequently. More expensive but this is one of those "You get what you pay for" situations.
From years of fieldwork I agree that Red Wings and Danners are awesome for holding up for ages. Red Wings also have such a wild array of sizes if you have very big or very wide feet.
As someone who has been in the trades for around 20yrs, and wears safety boots everyday for work, this is an area I don't cheap out on. I have bought cheap boots before, and I am usually lucky if they last a year. But if I spend more, the invest pays off, and they last a lot longer. I usually spend about $250-$300 CAD on my boots, and they will last me at least 5 years of hard use. To me, they are in investment. Thanks for the informative video once again, Todd 👍
Agreed. I take care of my feet ! I worked as a UBC carpenter for almost 30 years in industrial environments. I only wore American made Red Wings, they served me well.
I think I paid $380 for my nicks boots. They are 11 years old and have been rebuilt twice. Each rebuilt was $109 with shipping. I will need new ones by December. Daily worn. Working in the woods and timber industries outdoors. All made by hand in the USA 🇺🇸
Also, another big benefit is comfort and healthy feet. BUT you should wear a second pair every other day to allow boots to air out in between so foot fungus don't happen.
Excellent review as always. I'm retired now, but, I was an auto mechanic straight outta high school. I walked on average 9 miles a day according to a pedometer I hooked onto my belt for a while, and all of it was on concrete. And my feet hurt the entire time. I sure wish all of this information was available when I was just getting started. I hope you younglings understand what an invaluable guide you are receiving here. Living in pain, day in and day out for decades really sucks. Thank you, Todd.
I’ve got a 30 yr old pair of Redwings. Still in good shape. Just have to keep them oiled. Quality always trumps cheap when you figure the mileage. Thanks for the review, well done.
Over the past 25 years of wearing work boots every work day, I have tried well over a dozen different brands. I stopped trying different ones when I found my redwings. For me they offer the best combination of comfort, durability and longevity. They were the only brand I found that I wear for much more than a year without them blowing out, breaking down or just flat becoming miserably uncomfortable.
I agree. Being on a concrete floor all day, climbing ladders, working on machines while in awkward positions makes the redwings the best and I still have a pair that I bought in 2013 and they have held up just fine. It is good to oil them down with redwing oil occasionally for added longevity. I still wear them to work everyday.
Same here. Haven't tried as many but have been wearing Redwings since the '70s- on pair maybe #6 or #7. I'm in & out of peoples houses a lot, so a relatively smooth sole that doesn't track dirt is important to me.
Todd, I worked 30 years in a power plant. I wore nothing but Red Wings and only had to buy 2 pairs my whole career. I did have to replace the soles a few times in both pairs but the rest of boot held up great. If you buy good boots, they'll take care of your feet. Great content and channel!
I wore nothing but Red Wings for years like you said put new soles on now and then witch I had to make sure the shoemaker used genuine Red Wing soles each time and they were good to go ,I liked the leather on the Wings because I needed water proof so with a regular treatment of wing oil my feet stayed dry all the time ,And the best part is all those years I still used the same size every time try that with another brand.
I've had Redwing for years. Several pairs as I walk about 20,000 steps a day. I will continue to buy them. They stay pretty comfortable for years but of course changing the insoles regularly.
@@Hallowsaw They will clean and condition them for free in store. There are several tiers from Red Wing, stick to the higher tiers and they will last years if not 10+ years after a few resoles. If you get a $200 boot it will last a year, at that price point you are competing with Wolverine or Timberland, if you get a $280+ boot and a custom insole, you are in a completely different world for durability and comfort.
As retired USAF...I have found military issue boots comfortable and safe in the workplace. Redwing boots in the civian workplace are also good. Great tests...loved the carrots!
As an Ironworker I put a lot of wear and tear on my boots. If you did another showdown with Wedge sole boots including brands like Danner, red wings, thorogood, and Irish setter I would love to see how they stand up to each other. From my previous experience danners don't last as long, but I'm not certain how you could test longevity in a controlled way. Thanks for all the amazing content!
The lengths you go through testing is epic. You are a superstar on UA-cam and should have a minimum of 10 million subscribers. The best channel on UA-cam hands down.
I am a truck driver at Neo industries. We handle steel Mill rolling pins. The job is hectic on boots. The timberland gravel pit was my main boot. I love the way the boot looks, but they don’t last. I went through 4 pair. They last about 6 months and the seem fails where the boot bends when you walk. All 4 had the same failure. I decided to try redwing. The Brnr Xp to be exact. They are flawless. I’ve had them for over 2 years now of rugged wear and they have maintained perfectly. Excellent boot.
I used to get those same Brahma boots about every 4 months. They are actually pretty comfortable with a Dr. Scholls insert. I recently switched to Wolverine boots, they are much more comfortable without any insert and have already lasted longer than any pair of Brahmas I ever owned. Thanks for you content!
I used to buy carolina/corcorans, but I got cheap one time and bought some used german-made military boots. With only a few exceptions, I've been wearing them every day for about 10 years now. Best $20 boots you can buy.
Sad Wolverine wasn't in the video! First pair I had lasted me almost 5 years of heavy duty use and a few changes of insoles. My second pair (same product) are still in great shape after 2 years of light-medium use. Definately my favorite boots I have ever had. Excellent insulation, really good slip proof, quality leather, the Durashock soles are amazing. Just an all over perfect boot.
Get yourself some thorogood if you want a very nice boot that last a long time I absolutely hated spending so much on a pair of boots but every pair of wolverine Redwing and anything I tried in between wore out in less than 1.5 years my thorogood I paid like 300 for BUT I've had them going on 3 years now and they still have at least another year on them I wear them 14 or more hours everyday
I have the shorter version of the Redwing you have here. I have been working in boots for over 20 years, and the $200+ boots are worth it! Redwing will have to go out of business before I stop buying them. Most comfortable, last forever, almost zero break in time, and the local store customer service is top notch! Great video. Your results prove my experience!
I think I have the same boot as you. It took me about 4 years to wear out the boots, and then a cheap resole got me another 1.5 years. The upper is still in fine shape so I keep them around for yardwork. Then I bought the exact same boot again.
After you realize you can have them resoled over and over and over again why would you bother buying a brand new pair? Plus they sell the nose guard that nobody else sells
The problem with sending boots back to Redwing for resoling.. it costs about 75% of new Redwings based on several attempts I made to get mine repaired. I finding myself buying used replacements on Ebay for less than 50 bucks.
Bought a pair of Redwings a couple years ago, I'm 55 and these will be the last boots I will ever need. They are as comfortable as my tennis shoes, and worth every penny. They keep my toes warm in the winter. Wish you could have tested that feature. Thanks for the review.
I spent many years in a construction oriented position. I went through alot of boots over the years. 1 thing I concluded is that a quality boot is 1 of the most important tools I used. Of all the boots over 25 years I had, I can say the Chippewa 25220 boots were the most comfortable and were equally durable to any other boot I found. I would not hesitate to purchase another pair. I still have the last pair I bought even though I've retired, they still get worn around the acreage on occasion.
I was first introduced to Steel Blue boots when I worked for a mining company and went on a business trip to visit with mining sites in Australia. All the mining supply stores carried walls of Steel Blue boots, I bought a pair & wore them every day for over 5 years before they wore out. (Office guy, but lots of time in the field). I absolutely love steel blue, they are the most comfortable, toughest boots on the market! I recommend them to everyone
They used to be made in Australia (in WA where most of the mines are) but like Blundstone have now moved most of their production overseas. Redback and Mongrel are the only two that I know of still made in Australia but there may be others. Interesting to see the US price of Redback, here they can be picked up for ~US$100 so less than half that.
I have the same experience with Steel Blues. Five year life span with some pretty tough work and are the most comfortable steel cap boots I have ever owned. I've had some pretty bad brands in the past.
Red wing is my go to. I've had boots in the $50-$125 range and they all lasted 6-9 months. My first pair of redwings (~$225) lasted 2 years before the toes wore out so they were no longer water resistant. I've had a different brand that was about $200 and they lasted almost 2 years but were never as comfortable as the redwings.
I buy the 2414, the ones in the video are 2408. I coat mine with toe coat before ever wearing them. They will last so much longer if you do a toe cover.
@@Rad_Triumph_765_RS I get the 2240 (my feet are fucking wide at the toes so I need the extra space). After that first set I started putting tuff toe on them
I was a 35 year redwing user, but no longer because of repeated quality issues in recent years and I’m far from being alone. Many people have had very similar issues; stitching, soles. And redwing doesn’t care. I’m done.
You are the best reviewer in You Tube. Direct to the point of what consumers need to know. No clowning around, very knowledgeable always the precise equipment to test the product. Thank you so much.
My dad wore Redwings throughout his career as a mechanic/manager. He rarely has back pain now at 70, but he did have a knee replacement about 15 years ago. I only remember him buying a new pair about 3 times from 1986 to 2019. So I'd say for longevity, the Redwings will give you up to 10 years. He chose them because he has narrow feet, and they were the only brand that was comfortable and had that option.
Love to see more boot tests. Anvil Rose makes some great videos on boots and their construction if people want more boot videos. Been a Red Wings fan for the last 15 years, and glad to see they're performing well. Be kind to your feet, and your joints will thank you as you get older.
I wish Rose would do a serious review of real safety toe boots... I think he performs the most thorough and useful reviews of footwear on the planet...
I've been wearing the Reebok in an 8" boot for several years. After 3 pair, I can say that they are the most comfortable boot, out of the box, that I have ever owned. Several coworkers are now wearing them also. One has a bone spur on his heel that really had him in a bad way. The comfort of the Reeboks have helped him out a bunch. I have had the Tan and the Coyote Brown and like the darker one because it looks cleaner longer. They are all still servicable, just dirty and because of the suede outer surface are near impossible to keep new looking. The grip and comfort are all I need to know about these boots! Great video, as usual!
The Redwing boots you tested I've been buying for 20 years. As a heavy machinist they are the only boots that will last 2+ years walking in coolent, deep oil, and hot razer sharp metal chips. Redwing referrers to the sole as 2.0 and is amazing. Don't cheap out and buy lesser boots. Buy the best and buy Redwing.
Great to see some new boots tested! I'd like to see you test some more of those "work sneakers" that look like regular ones but have toe protection and claim slip resistance. They look like they would be super comfortable to work in, but I've never given them a chance.
Longevity is one of those difficult tests to perform. Here's my own personal take on Red Wing at least. I served as a missionary from 1982-1984 and I bought 2 pairs of Red Wing shoes, not the boots but they have the same build quality in my opinion. I was walking every day and they withstood all that in great comfort, some very wet conditions too (I was in Colombia). I continued to wear them after getting home. Because I liked them so well I bought another pair. I am still wearing them today, 39 years later. I wear them once a week so they don't get as much wear and tear but they still look like new. Very good quality even though they are quite pricey.
Same here with the RedWings . Take them in to the store and get new laces and leather treated and they look good. At no cost . Hard to wear them out working in a factory but outdoors is definitely not the same. We got a shoe allowance so if you bought cheap ones you couldn’t keep the unused balance. Buy the best and your feet will thank you.expensive doesn’t mean that they are the best.
I've been wearing the Reebok zip ups for over 10 years ..they were originally made by converse. They are the most comfortable boots I've ever worn, nice ball of gell sewn into the inside under the heel..so much cushion. Grip well and easy on off. Love them
@@ProjectFarm No problem, Work on railroad and do a lot of walking on rough ballast. The insoles could use a bit more cushion but that gel cushion sewn directly into the heel of the boot makes them extremely comfortable.
How is the toe holding up? I tend to go through mine quickly. Was thinking of getting these and put a replacement cover right away to make them strong from the start
@@oscarinacan I never had the toe wear out as far as holes/cuts, the body of the boot has never torn or separated from the sole. They are the best boots for every day hold.up to whatever and feels like it wearing gym shoes.. you won't regret them
This video basically sums up why I love Red Wing. I went from $50-$150 work boots every few months to a pair of Red Wings that have lasted several years. The comfort difference is just an added bonus.
Especially if you go to a redwing store to get the best fit! My experience: Service - 10. Comfort - 10. Durability - 10. Put these things through a deployment, multiple years of use around a shipyard, motorcycle riding, and 6 years past they're still on the original soles and looking great!
Great info! One thing you didn’t test was water resistances. I got my redwings because they were the only ones to keep my feet dry in standing water. Thank you again for the great content!!!!!!!
I've had the same 2 pairs of Redwings for over 15 years now. I maintain them every year and they have outlasted every boot and shoe I've ever owned. You might pay more upfront, but for that kind of quality, you actually save money in the long run.
i bought the cheapest walmart brand boots i could and some other cheap brands when i started working on a farm at 14years old. they last about 6months at most before coming apart in one way or the other. eventually i spent the money on some redwings which the farmer that owns the farm wore for many years and i havent bought a different brand since. ive been using redwings now for years as im 30yrs old and ive bought 3 pairs over that time. if used reasonably they last and they keep your feet comfortable and safe. my first pair are still usable to this day but the inside wore out and became annoying to feel. so maybe take care of them and replace the inside after a bit to prevent serious wear and tear haha. another experience to was when a hydraulic line on our skid steer broke which dropped the bucket full of gravel on my foot, the steel toe saved my toes and the top of my foot was bruised but it could have been a lot worse.
I just bought my second pair. First pair was bought in 2014 made it through 9 years of on and off use. they went through hell and were not maintained well at all. This second pair will be taken care of now that I know better. Hopefully get 10-15 years out of this pair.
I own a lawn service in Florida and during the Summer it doesn't matter if I buy expensive Redwings or the Brahmas from Walmart. Couple months of going through puddles and getting covered in grass and mud. They're no longer waterproof pretty worn out and end up in the trash so I just buy the cheap Walmart boots. I feel better throwing away $25-$30 every couple months rather than $250-$300 can't deny Redwing makes some amazingly comfy and nice looking boots though.
I've been wearing Red Wings for years and just swapped to Reeboks a few months ago and found the Reeboks to be more comfortable because of my extremely wide feet. It's nice to know that they are at the top in most of the objective categories too.
@@alexhamon9261 I've got H width Red Wings. I thought they were comfortable until I swapped back to them temporarily from my Reeboks and realized how comfortable the Reeboks actually are.
Redwing also sells insole for wide feet as well. When i bought my boots, i thought they're were comfortable but missing something. I explained to the sell person, and they took the insole out of the boot and opened the "wide sole."( I can't remember what it was called), but it made a total difference, and I've been rocking Redwing for 3 to 4 years now! There are no issues! here!
This is just what i needed to hear not someone that never tryed any other boot ive wore red wings im not that impressed unless your climbing trees or poles im fixing to give these reeboks a try they look like something i could wear 10 hr days
I've been wearing RedWing boots the past 2 or 3 years, they're wonderful boots, except the break in period can be quite long depending on the boot style. I've done maybe 6-10 million steps in one pair so far. One benefit of the redwing boots is that they offer a resole and refresh program for the non waterproof/insulated versions of them for less than half the cost of a new boot, with the same sole you get when you buy them new. Great testing! Glad to see there are some good value options out there as well!
I have a pair of Red Wings I'm about to send in to be resoled. I'm not looking forward to being without them while they're being repaired. As far as the break in period I always tell people that once the Red Wings are done breaking in your feet they're the most comfortable boots you'll ever wear.
You should mink oil the Red Wings and not only does it waterproof them it apparently extends their life. I agree with the break-in period not being ideal but they are better than most.
A durometer test of the rubber, thickness measurement of the leather, and cross section of the construction would be very interesting data. Much love Todd, thanks for putting in so much effort to make the most amazing product testing videos in the world
@@tobiass1184 Cold boots tested on ice would be a great test. As for wear resistance would a certain amount of downward pressure on the boots over a belt sander be adequate? I'd like to get a pair of boots that last me more than 1 - 1.5 years.
I just bought Reebok RB4131 composite toe high tops and I gotta say they are the most comfortable work boot/shoe I've ever worn. These are my first "work shoe" I used to always wear boots but with back and knee injuries I've always had problems with pain by end of day, now I have no issues and they are waterproof and corrosive resistant and anti slip, anti shock, ASTM- F2413. Only $93 too.
Thanks for testing these boots! Makes me feel good about my past purchases of Reebok and Red Wing. My job requires a non conductive toe, like the composites, so it's good to see that the boots are up to safety standards.
Great review of the boots, but there is one additional factor that could be considered: long term durability. Many of the cheap boots fall apart after a few months with the sides bursting out from insufficient sewing and the soles falling off because of poor gluing. I'm currently using some Carolina moccasin toed steel safety, ankle high boots made in USA and after over two years of heavy use I expect to get several more years out of them, though I did just replace the laces because one got partly cut somehow.
I’ve been wearing Red Wings every day for 3 years now. They are the best boots I’ve ever owned. I’ve been through so many cheap brands including the Walmart Brahama’s before investing in a good pair of red wings. Highly recommend. Buy nice or buy it twice. My dad always said, don’t cheap out on shoes, mattresses, underwear.
I bought my first pair or Red Wings in 2002. I still own that pair and wear them occasionally. The sole is worn almost smooth (these ones can't be replaced) but they have held on longer than anything else I've ever bought. When I went to buy hiking boots, it was right back to Red Wings again. My youngest has finally stopped growing so now he too can have a pair of Red Wings to match his older brother. Yes you pay dearly for these but they pay you back.
As a former machinist I can't tell you how much o love your videos man !!! You do an amazing job. As far as boots go I've worn Redwing as far as I can remember I've tried others but you cannot beat the quality of Redwing and also it's a Made in America company which i support! To this day i still buy redwing every other year great boot! Cheers from your biggest fan in Colombia amigo!
As an Aussie raised on a farm, I quickly learned to appreciate a good work boot. The pair I remember most fondly was a Redback pair, so it’s nice to see them show up here.
Redbacks are top notch. I wore a pair almost every day for 4 years before I retired them. They took me to bush festivals, my entire mechanic apprenticeship, dirt bike riding, to the snow, metal shows, lots of farm work. The ol bastards did not give up.
Great review, as always. We get a significant discount on work boots (45% for the red wings). I always choose the same model red wing you tested. The oil test after a few 8-hour shifts would be significantly improved. These red wing boots are incredibly comfortable. I get an annual boot allowance, but these last me around 5 years. I walk about 8k-11k steps per day on concrete floors. The work environment is very oily. They hold up amazingly when treated with snow seal. The biggest flaw with the red wing is the break-in period. The first two weeks wearing these boots is miserable. After that, they're perfect. I wear these boots every day, even on weekends. I'll gladly pay $150 out of pocket for these every 5 years. Wear them until the soles fall off or split.
I'm in the same situation as you and agree with everything you said. I've been at my job for 16 years and get a brand new pair every year that they pay for. Needless to say, I've only worn out 4 pairs and have 10 or so brand new pairs in my attic.
This weekend I realized the bottom-outsole of one of my RedWings has split and is tearing off. I was a bit upset at the thought of the cost to replace them until I remembered I bought them in the early ‘10s, maybe late ‘00s, and have worn them for every outdoor project, off path hike, and snow day since. Amortized that way, they cost me about $20 per year.
One way to improve cheaper boots or shoes is to buy a quality insole for $20. You'd be surprised how much of a difference it makes in comfort and fit. Great video, as always. 💪
AND changing out insoles can re-fit the boots fit. It can snug up a " too large of size " with a thicker pad, or loosen a "too tight" of a boots fit with a thinner pad.
I always GREATLY appreciate your overall subjective assessments at the end of product tests. All of us know that you can't test for everything and sometimes, you have to get to the end to know what what you wish you'd measured. (E.g., maybe you can just feel that some products are truly made to last and others aren't.) So I really like when you get to the end and say something like, "Overall, if price weren't a factor, I'd go with A, but if I only had $X, I'd go with B." That's gold, pure gold.
I know it would cost a lot, but there's no better channel than this one to test out the effectiveness of certain washers, as in clothes washers. I'd love to see a comparison of similar priced washers in the three main styles, agitator, impellor, and front load. And of course you could test different brands, but I think a lot of people would love to see just how well each style cleans clothes.
I can attest to the comfort of red backs. I have a steel toe version and a standard pair. Wear both pretty much everywhere and are incredibly comfortable. Even after long days at work or long walks/hikes
Agreed as well. I’m an automotive fleet tech that walks an average of 2 miles per day in the shop. I’m on my 5th pair of Redbacks that have lasted an average of 3 years per pair and can say they are by far the best of all worlds in terms of comfort, durability, slip resistance and quality. I prefer them to the Red Wings and Wolverines I’ve had in the past. The numerous pairs of various brands all made in China I used earlier in my career aren’t even in the same universe as Redbacks.
@@chipyeahoo I like how they are slip on too. I have to take my shoes on and off alot with work when visiting people's homes. So it's much better than laces and they haven't stretched out either.
As for longevity, my Redwings go back to the early 1990's! They probably should be re-soled, but they are still in great shape. Best wear and comfort for the money I've ever spent.
redwings are still good, but they aren't what they used to be. most redwings now made overseas, only a handfull still made here, and those don't see to be as good as they were 10 years ago and prior. sad, but it is what it is. redwing used to be so much better than everything else that they were worth the higher price, now that value proposition just isn't there.
I personally just picked up a pair of Red backs after having a pair of Blundstone work boots and have to say they are amazing, One thing to note is the lack of time it takes to put on the red backs compared to the other boots being a slip on in my work environment is essential as in certain situations I have to put my work boots on and run as in as fast as possible. Another point of the slip ons is in environment where your working with combustible liquids and hot surfaces a major plus of being a slip on is that in the event they caught fire you can easily get them off and not suffer burns to your feet and legs. I know from experience. Great video!
Im gkad to see my red wing 2406s tested on here and happy to see they came out on top. I can tell you from personal experience iver the last 10 years they hold up very well and are extremely comfortable. Ive stood on red hot bolts, nuts, and random metals that i had just cut with a torch and never noticed, had multiple large impacts with no issues or damage and most importantly no injuries, and are extremely comfortable. Over the last 10 years I have bought 3 pairs, and my original pair i stull use for work every day.
I'd destroy them in a year. Not even red wings hold up in actual hard use, like my water plant. Constant water and pure chlorine gas exposure kills $500 boots in a year or so. So my employer buys me new boots every year. KEENS are the best I've ever tried, after all these.
@@RobertMorgan My red wings have held up 5 years in highly caustic and acidic conditions in one industrial plant, extreme fires and hot ass hydraulic fluid for 2 years at a metallurgy plant, and the last 3 years working as a diesel tech. Just oil the lether ebery few months and they hold up forever
I like my Red Wing boots, very comfortable. If you go to one of their retail stores they can 3D scan your feet, and have you walk back and forth on a pressure pad to measure your feet. It will tell the size you need, and they will even email the results to you.
When I was cruising Timber out west I almost bought a pair of Red Wings. Very comfortable but I tried out a set of Buffalo's (Whites semi custom brand) and handed over almost twice as much for them. On lava rocks all day nothing bothered my feet over many miles of walking once broken in
Thank you for your videos. My mother bought me the most expensive boots Red Wing offered with steel metatarsal guard and steel sole plate when I started my first construction job. That was over ten years ago and those boots are still kicking, no pun intended. It's nice to see that those boots were worth the cost she paid. I've cherished those boots and seeing this makes me love them even more.
One thing you should have tested was abrasion resistance of the sole, sides, and toe. Some boots will cut straight through if you accidentally scrape the corner of concrete steps and such, and some boots lose all of their tread very rapidly just by walking on concrete. You could probably test it pretty quickly and release a short addendum, I'm sure it would be appreciated greatly, as all of your videos are. Aside from normal wear and tear, I know some people tend to hit their heels together when they walk(I used to until I taught myself not to) and that can rapidly damage many shoes/boots, so that's a thing to consider for some people(although plastic heel and toe caps trivialize this). If you decide to do another boot video, you should try to test out the boots with kevlar midsoles, plus it'd be cool to see a comparison of the differences in durability/protection from leather, synthetic "leather", fabric mesh, and mixed material boots. I know, for example, my dad has a pair of Brunt brand boots that uses the fabric mesh body(with hard toe and heel caps), which are waterproof and *extremely* abrasion resistant despite being a very flexible material. I personally have some cheap soft faux leather boots which are shockingly cut resistant. Material science is hard.
I end up bought blackhammer shoe 2 years ago but not this model. I wear it almost everyday since then. It holds up for two years now. You got it right about the padding not so thick. I bought new padding after around 6 months wearing it. Thanks for the video. You really have been helpful.
If you wanted a follow-up video, you may be able to test longevity in some ways. You could measure how much of the sole is worn away by sliding the boot around on an abrasive surface with an added weight, or flex the soles/uppers a number of times or directions until the materials fail. I suppose that wouldn't account for variations in environment, but it would be a start. Thanks for this video, Project Farm!
I used to buy a new pair of boots every 6 - 8 months. A coworker suggested that I spend a bit more money and buy some Red Wings. They last me 3 - 4 years, I would have been excited if they lasted 1 - 2 years. Thanks for another great video!
REDWING PERIOD!! And before I forget absolutely awesome review as usual. For longevity it's Redwing hands-down. I've got a pair that I've worn for thousands of hours of hard physical labor and they just gave out this year they're about 18 years old. I have worn many brands up until about 15 years ago. I wear nothing but Redwing now. I don't mean to sound like a fanboy I'm just simply saying they're the best for a reason. Spend the $300 today and don't even think about needing to buy another pair for over a decade easy. You'll have to get new insoles and you'll have to replace the shoelaces once or twice a year if you wear them like I did. Also use mink oil to keep them highly water resistant if not waterproof. I am very very hard on boots. Most don't make it six months. Like I said these made it 18 years.
I wore the Reeboks in Afghanistan as a contractor for almost two years and they held up tremendously well. They are desert tan because the were authorized for use by solders. Bad part is they were not well ventilated and my feet would get pretty hot in them, but they saved my ankles from twisting over all the rocks on base.
Same for me. They held up well and quite comfy besides the heat. Good thing is the zipper was good so you could pop them off for a few minutes without much fuss.
In the early 1970’s I bought the exact same Redwings you tested. I was a locomotive electrician so I wanted the electrical insulation, they looked good and were comfortable with good ankle shin protection and quick lacing.
My last pair of Redback lace-up boots finally wore out after 5 years in the auto collision industry with lots of different chemicals. And definitely very comfortable. And thanks for your awesome videos!
I’ve been wearing Red Wings for years. Hands down worth the money. Made in the USA! My favourite feature is you can custom order different widths so you get a more custom fit for your foot width. That’s a game changer.
Working in wet ditches and excavations all day the redwings are great for being in a few inches of water and mud all day and keeping dry feet! I used to buy caterpillar boots but the exact make they discontinued and I switched the the redwing2412s and never looked back. Wear them right down to -20 in the winter and i am still comfortable!
This is the most informative and detailed REVIEWS you could hope for, now everyone can make a fact base decision on which pair of Boots will best serve their needs. BEST CHANNEL ON UA-cam 👍👍👍👏👏👏👏
While I was working as a paramedic I had a pair of Redwing boots that lasted well over 10 years ( I did have to have them resoled several times ). During that time they were exposed to just about every harsh condition you can imagine and never let me down. The only reason that they didn't last longer is that they got contaminated in hazmat incident and I was unable to decontaminate them so they were given to the hazmat cleanup team (they did buy me a new pair of Redwings, that that was OK with me).The only downside I ever found with the boots is that needed to treat them with snowseal to keep then water repellant during the winter. They are by far the best work boots that I ever used, yes they are expensive but you get what you pay for.
I got nearly 3 years out of a pair of Rockport Works RK6640 boots. The only things wrong with them are worn out insoles, and the soles peeled at the front.
As a video idea, I'm actually interested in something a lil bit different. Would love to see strength tests of wood joints, like how mortise and tenon would fare against pocket hole joints. Would love to see objectively how strong they truly are! Anyway, thank you so much of all of the great tests you're doing Todd!
There are some good ones already in the mix out there, 45 miters with splines seem to be winning most of the showdowns. Bourbon Moth Woodworking is a good place to start, good sense of humor
Matthias Wendel and other woodworkers have done testing on this to the nth degree. Don't think Todd would find anything different, and it would simply duplicate some excellent work thats already well respected.
That's been done on other channels. Dowels are pretty strong. If appearance doesn't matter a glued and screwed butt joint is hard to beat. Modern PVA glue is stronger than wood is. So joints usually fail by the wood pulling apart. Then it comes down to what wood is the strongest. But some wood doesn't glue good.
I bought a pair of the Steel Blue women's a few years ago. I worked as a remote-control locomotive operator in a steel mill. I don't think they even made it 6 months. Both boots split where the heel comes into the sole. Because I purchased them on Amazon there was no way to return them even though the company says to just return them to where you bought them for a full refund. For reference I was walking between 15,000-20,000 steps per shift, 60 hours a week average. For $200 I expected a better outcome.
I wore Danner Acadia's for many, many years. Learned early on that the odds of a cheap boot being a good boot were slim. This is a great topic, if you do it again and can get a pair of Acadia's please test them. I spend a lot of time in the desert these days, and the Reeboks you tested look very interesting to me.
It would be cool to see a "hiking" boot tested through the same tests. ESP against ice etc, I would love to see Crispi's boots compared to others. Those are my fave right now, but I am curious how others perform.
I have been wearing 5.11 8" boots for six years now. They are the best I have found for the money and comfort. I would like to see your tests with these. The other thing you don't test with boots is the waterproofness of them. That is a big thing for a lot of us out here. Great channel!
Unless the boots are rubber no boot is really waterproof for very long. So you just have to prepare for having wet feet. To that end you wear silk liner socks and woolen outer socks. Even soaking wet your feet stay comfortable then. Least for how long you're going to be out in the weather. 10-12 hours or so is about max. You can reasonably expect boots to resist being soaked for some time. A couple hours maybe? In real weather conditions rubber boots are the way to go.
When I did line clearance tree trimming I bought 2 pair of Carolina lineman boots. 1 for the winter & 1 for the summer. They are both the best feeling and quality boots I've ever owned. Love them. I need to find them again though bc I left that line of work about 7 years ago.
by the way, I want to express my gratitude for your great videos! walking half a mile in each of those boots to prepare them for testing... I have never been so impressed by such dedication! 😍😍😍😍😍
Having owned work boots across the cost spectrum, I do adore my Red Wing boots. Wouldn't trade them for anything. I actually have two pairs, currently saving to get the first pair re-soled since there's a small break about where the toecap starts (I walk around a lot and have to move heavy stuff in small spaces)
Excellent comparison. My dad wore Red Wing throughout his career in construction, and he swore by them. They weren't cheap, but you get what you pay for. They saved his feet on many occasions. I would love to see more tests, as a home DIY I would like to have a safety shoe for my projects but don't need the level of Red Wing as I'm not on a construction site.
ive not seen the results yet, but used to buy redwing, and found boots that only cost 70 bucks and lasted 2 to 3 times as long. Ive not bought any other brand after that. They are the Bates military boots from Canada, with either steel toe or thermal liners.
I'm a gasoline hauler and have worn Red Wing boots, exclusively, for over 25 years, in both work and play and always keep a pair or two in rotation while having worn boots resoled. I think the anti-slip soles are more aggressive than other brands, so I think that is why the soles wear quicker. But to have that quality and comfort, resoled at a third of the cost of new, is a no-brainer. When I get them back from Missouri, they always look like new, other than normal wear and tear. When I saw you were testing Red Wing boots, I was confident they were gonna impress. Thank you for all your hard work on the channel.
Here’s the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you!
Redback: amzn.to/3Z7pYEC
Steel Blue: amzn.to/3GErs1Z
Carolina: amzn.to/3X5aori
Rockport: amzn.to/3jNay8f
Reebok: amzn.to/3Qdi0pi
Dunlop: amzn.to/3ifEzNB (no longer available)
Black Hammer: amzn.to/3ZcEATh
Ad Tec: amzn.to/3jSdbWf
Brahma: amzn.to/3GgDRHM
Red Wing: Available at the Red Wing Online Store
Herman Survivors: Available at Walmart
Larnmern: Available at Walmart
Can you please make another of these work boot test with a new lineup. Thank you
please could you do a test on snake proof boots. many claim to be but i'm not thinking there are any industry standards they must adhere to. it's very important to me and probably to many others who live in rattler country. thank you
I agree about wishing you could rate longevity, but also important I think is specifically tread longevity and effectiveness. I fear that the traction tests that you do might not be very effective after a small or a significant amount of wear on the sole material. for example, some of the more expensive rubberized soles seemed to perform worse initially but I would venture to guess that may change over time as initial wear and more significant wear patterns set in. Do you think you would be able to simulate some sole wear?
You mentioned you wanted to test longevity, it's been about 2 years. Hopefully its something that's been worked on as a surprise, if not its a suggestion for another video. As if the cheap pair don't last as long, would they still be the best/cheaper option compared to the pricier boots. For example, I'm on my 4th pair of Walmart cargo pants so thats already around 80+
Would be nice for more boot episodes
Quick tip; If you'll be spending a lot of time on ladders, get boots with a steel shank. They'll keep your arches from aching. Great review !
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Especially if you have planter faceitis, which then can irritate sciatica if you have it. Also, you develop aches and pains in your joints, knees, low and mid back. It's all related to your shoes/boots and whether your arch' are off. Once this happens you start to develop callous pressure points where the skin will callous.
Be sure and use a golf ball preferably (if you can tolerate it), or tennis ball and roll them under each foot to break up the fascia tissues. I would also invest in a electric foot file. You will be amazed at the difference in your feet.
very true!
Jeez I wish I knew this earlier
It can also prevent nerve damage if you have to stand on really thin metal like tower climbers.
Thanks for adding the Redwings. The pair you tested are the same ones I wear welding. I usually get from 4 to 6 years out of them on concrete and sharp objects. I only had 1 pair fail when I punctured a hole through the sole. Redwing gave me a new pair, no questions asked. 10 hrs a day on my feet and still the best boots.
You're welcome!
I suggest trying the 2414, puncture resistant and goretex for dryer interior along with waterproof. The plate in the bottom helps with standing on ladders as it adds rigidity to the shank of the boot keeping your foot straighter and not allowing it to fold as much.
Red Wings have a super sole on some models witch is about nail proof those are the ones I always got and I never got the ones with the big pad in back as it don`t really add any comfort
I wore the Redwing Style 2406 that you feature in this video while I worked at an aluminum extrusion plant in Corona, Ca. They saved my foot when it got caught in a hydraulic lift. The steel toe kept my toes from being crushed and helped hold the steel plate from breaking all my metatarsal’s. Overall damage was one broken metatarsal, damaged tendons, and severe bruising. Great quality boots, I’d recommend them to anyone.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Garhettgross - thank you for not sharing the gristly photo. Crushing toes is an important test which Todd amazingly missed but which anyone working in heavy industry should seriously consider. Most of us go with a price/comfort ratio thing. The shock is that the Redwings tested #1 (by PF) for comfort as well. I've never owned a pair due to the cost, but would consider that if I needed my toes not crushed:-) The info is much appreciated!
Been wearing them myself for many, many year's. Very comfortable (for me), grip well and wear like iron. The 2406 really is a very high quality boot.
Did Todd not do two tests that demonstrated the boots’ ability to prevent toe crushing?
whats your opinion on the 3507, if any?
I’d enjoy seeing you test military boots. Not only the different manufacturers, but also the variances between what each branch authorizes. Even a comparison of tanker boots would be awesome (but understandably niche to most viewers).
I joined the Marine Corps in 2006 when they just changed from black boots to Coyote brown with the embossed EGA’s. The quality of some manufacturers was quite inferior to others, but improved over time. After a few years I got my first set of Danner RAT steel toes and loved the comfort despite the heaviness. Another set of Danner RAT boots were the gortex/waterproof version and they didn’t last a year. My third set was RAT but non steel toe and I still wear them now; 10 years later. Belleville was quite a good brand as well when I got out in 2015 and that pair still wears well but not very often.
Love all your videos; keep up the excellent work!
The other day I restored my headlight housing based off your video, went with the sylvania restore kit and I know for a 100 percent fact that your test are as legit as they get. Thank you for all your hard work and dedication to us viewers
You are welcome!
I used that same one after seeing that video and it works great.
This man consistently helps me decide what to buy. There’s no better proof of quality than these tests
Thanks!
@Project Farm absolute legend~
So happy I found this channel for true unbiased reviews I need to do my projects
@@joshuadavidson4103 I tend to buy tools only after checking for a project farm video on the subject and without fail the people I work with have positive things to say when borrowing them.
Not true when it comes to boots..the reason you spend money on better boots is because your trying to stay as comfortable as possible for as long as possible..the only way to find out if boots are quality is to WEAR THEM for at least 24 hrs of work..after 20 plus years,i've worn just all of them. cheap to expensive..get boots that are comfortable,you can resole and that have a good shank in them
Longevity is really important when considering the cost. I used to buy ~$50 Brahma boots every 4 months or so. My first pair of redwings was around $250, and they lasted around 18 months of hard wearing in a junkyard, and still looked better than 3-4 month old Brahma boots. When you add up the price for all the cheap boots to last as long, suddenly the price of good boots looks a lot better. That plus the extra comfort of the nicer boots makes it a no brainer option for me these days.
Fantastic work as always! I'd really love to see you get your hands on some nice handmade boots like Nick's
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
I grabbed 4 pairs of these exact same Brahma boots for $5/pair so I have boots for a while lol.
Curious if you have had your RW's re-soled/etc? A resole and basic care can run 130-160 and might really extend the life. Check out Trenton and Heath's latest video.
I'm going on 10 years with my Redwing boots. Granted, I don't daily them but they still get used. I learned years ago not to buy cheap boots. Dry and comfortable feet go a long way when you get older.
Try redback boots. So much lighter and incredibly comfortable.
I learned about Redwing boots when I worked on the fire line for the forest service back in the mid '60s. Now I am just on my second pair. Quite economical. The Redwing store resoled my first pair several times, and I replaced the insole, but they were still good for 40 years.
The only time I wear cheap boots is when welding. Next time I need to replace those boots, I'm definitely going to look at the Black Hammer.
Thank you for all your work and creativity.
Thanks for sharing.
I work in oil and gas in a fairly chemical ridden environment. Everyone here uses red wings. They are the only boot you can get 1-3 years of service out of here. Nothing else lasts. I am amazed to see people getting double digits worth of use out of their redwings. While that is certainly not the case up here, the redwings still outperform everything else. Redwings all the way.
rocky outback
@@curtisbender1945 , made to order boots from companies that have been making boots for decades (or, in some cases, over 100 years) offer better toughness/ longevity than Red Wings (I really like Red Wings, but I’m a boot person). Look up White’s Boots Smokejumpers, Nick’s BuilderPros, or Wesco Jobmasters. Or Franks, etc. Red Wings are maybe the best mass produced work boots, but not the best overall in terms of toughness/ longevity.
Careful welding with cheap boots the plastic they use on cheap boots are very flammable
My father has worn the Redwings for 50 years. He was an electrician at a Phosphate and Acid production mine for 40 years and that was the only boot he wore there. He's still wearing his last pair he bought and he's been retired for nearly 15 years. Always appreciate the effort you put into trying out and comparing the items in your projects.
Thank you for sharing!
I grew up less than a 40 minute drive from Redwing
, Minnesota. If ya worked da range, felled trees and bucked em, built houses with the lumber, put down concrete, brick and mortar, put up and shingled roofs, dug a ditch, built a bridge....ya wore Redwings. Period. 👍🏻💪🤷♂️😏
I still have my Red Wing boots that are over 40 years old and still very serviceable.
This mine wouldn't happen to be in Aurora NC would it?
I imagine Red Wings were the only boot a lot of people wore at that mine. I don't put my boots in that sort of environment but Red Wings are the only shoes that have been able to keep up with my abuse. I can see why he wore those.
I built Red Wing boots for 9 years. I was a floating operator so I did all processes in 2 departments.
They are Very good boots made with care in my home Town of Red Wing MN.
The cost more but if you take care of them they will far outlast other brands. 😉👍
Great video as always.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Lifetime warranty too
All you really need to do with Redwings is clean them and condition them so they don't dry out. Plus most Redwings are able to be resoled. After the break in period my 606's are easily the most comfortable thing I've ever put on my feet. Can't wait for my Iron Rangers to be broken in. I think they hit that sweet spot of quality, durability, and cost for most people.
I wore red wing for a long time 👍
@@craig3536 my Iron rangers lasted 7 year 3 resoles. They still look pretty good but are now hurting my left heal. Time for a new pair. But they change the designed the midsole is no longer use cork! Very disapointed not sure if I'll buy a pair.
I'm not sure what I'm more impressed by:
The fact that you make these objective comparison videos, or how you manage to make these and still read/respond to nearly every comment on every video you make.
You sir deserve a commitment award
Thanks!
I agree 100%
Yes. Truly impressive! You're someone whose educated opinion I trust.
?.."thanks" takes about 3 sec to type out..try it 😂
@@Jeremya74 Thanks but such an economy of words would not have expressed my gratitude for the effort to product this valuable content. Get it?
Great test! I have been an industrial electrical contractor for over 30 years. Redwing by far have been my favorite as well as Keen. The EH (Electrical Hazard Rating) that you refer to is an ASTM standard of 600 volts or less in dry conditions. You far exceeded this test.
I worked in a factory over a decade and Red Wings became my go to after having to replace cheaper boots frequently. More expensive but this is one of those "You get what you pay for" situations.
Very true if you buy the American made "heritage" line.
Thanks for sharing.
Agreed!
From years of fieldwork I agree that Red Wings and Danners are awesome for holding up for ages. Red Wings also have such a wild array of sizes if you have very big or very wide feet.
Same for me. Redwings are so comfortable
As someone who has been in the trades for around 20yrs, and wears safety boots everyday for work, this is an area I don't cheap out on. I have bought cheap boots before, and I am usually lucky if they last a year. But if I spend more, the invest pays off, and they last a lot longer. I usually spend about $250-$300 CAD on my boots, and they will last me at least 5 years of hard use. To me, they are in investment. Thanks for the informative video once again, Todd 👍
Agreed.
I take care of my feet !
I worked as a UBC carpenter for almost 30 years in industrial environments.
I only wore American made Red Wings, they served me well.
I got a $300 pair of 8 month old Ariat Catalyst boots that would like to have a word with your statement. They are RUINED lol
@@thefrogking481 I like Danner
I think I paid $380 for my nicks boots. They are 11 years old and have been rebuilt twice. Each rebuilt was $109 with shipping. I will need new ones by December. Daily worn. Working in the woods and timber industries outdoors.
All made by hand in the USA 🇺🇸
Also, another big benefit is comfort and healthy feet. BUT you should wear a second pair every other day to allow boots to air out in between so foot fungus don't happen.
Excellent review as always. I'm retired now, but, I was an auto mechanic straight outta high school. I walked on average 9 miles a day according to a pedometer I hooked onto my belt for a while, and all of it was on concrete. And my feet hurt the entire time. I sure wish all of this information was available when I was just getting started. I hope you younglings understand what an invaluable guide you are receiving here. Living in pain, day in and day out for decades really sucks. Thank you, Todd.
And people wonder why we're grouchy at the end of the day.
Thanks and you are welcome!
damn I always thought it was just me who's feet hurt at the end of every day
Thanks!
Thanks for supporting the channel! I really appreciate it!
I’ve got a 30 yr old pair of Redwings. Still in good shape. Just have to keep them oiled. Quality always trumps cheap when you figure the mileage. Thanks for the review, well done.
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
Over the past 25 years of wearing work boots every work day, I have tried well over a dozen different brands. I stopped trying different ones when I found my redwings. For me they offer the best combination of comfort, durability and longevity. They were the only brand I found that I wear for much more than a year without them blowing out, breaking down or just flat becoming miserably uncomfortable.
Thanks for sharing.
I agree. Being on a concrete floor all day, climbing ladders, working on machines while in awkward positions makes the redwings the best and I still have a pair that I bought in 2013 and they have held up just fine. It is good to oil them down with redwing oil occasionally for added longevity. I still wear them to work everyday.
Same here. Haven't tried as many but have been wearing Redwings since the '70s- on pair maybe #6 or #7. I'm in & out of peoples houses a lot, so a relatively smooth sole that doesn't track dirt is important to me.
My RW 608 were going on 4 years before I replaced them.
Just cleaned and oiled them and they look so good in thinking a resole just for an extra pair.
I only wear red wings started wearing them because they were made in the USA
Todd, I worked 30 years in a power plant. I wore nothing but Red Wings and only had to buy 2 pairs my whole career. I did have to replace the soles a few times in both pairs but the rest of boot held up great. If you buy good boots, they'll take care of your feet. Great content and channel!
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I wore nothing but Red Wings for years like you said put new soles on now and then witch I had to make sure the shoemaker used genuine Red Wing soles each time and they were good to go ,I liked the leather on the Wings because I needed water proof so with a regular treatment of wing oil my feet stayed dry all the time ,And the best part is all those years I still used the same size every time try that with another brand.
That is a the difference with a boot that can be repaired rather then replaced.
2 pairs in 30 years?! I’ve had red wings, Ariats, etc. and I have to get new ones every 1-2 years. I work in agriculture.
true if you bought them 30 years ago not so much today.
4:52 Dry Traction (lbs)
6:24 Wet Traction (lbs)
9:13 Bottom of Boot Strength (lbs)
10:22 16-Penny Nail Pressure to Puncture Sole (lbs)
11:21 16-Penny Nail Pressure to Puncture Top of Boot (lbs)
12:21 Subjective Outer Sole Heat Exposure Rating
15:26 Maximum Weight While Maintaining 1/2 Inch Gap (lbs)
17:04 Electrical Protection (volts)
18:50 Subjective "Pointed Object" Protection
19:01 Subjective "Natural Walking Motion"
19:13 Subjective "Sole Padding"
19:19 Subjective "Overall Padding"
19:28 Overall Comfort Rating
19:35 Overall Rating
Thank you for that....
I've had Redwing for years. Several pairs as I walk about 20,000 steps a day. I will continue to buy them. They stay pretty comfortable for years but of course changing the insoles regularly.
How do you get them to last years? Mine wear out in 6 months
@@Hallowsaw clean them everyday lol
@@Hallowsaw They will clean and condition them for free in store. There are several tiers from Red Wing, stick to the higher tiers and they will last years if not 10+ years after a few resoles. If you get a $200 boot it will last a year, at that price point you are competing with Wolverine or Timberland, if you get a $280+ boot and a custom insole, you are in a completely different world for durability and comfort.
@@Hallowsaw
Buy the American made boots.
I agree.
I buy the American made Redwings and they will last for years if you keep them oiled.
Been wearing USA made Thorogoods or USA made Redwings for years. Love them. Nice to have a local boot shop to re sole them
American made thorogood boots have been the best I've ever had!
@@johneubanks5951 same. They have Replaced all my redwings except one pair over the years
Thanks for sharing.
As retired USAF...I have found military issue boots comfortable and safe in the workplace. Redwing boots in the civian workplace are also good. Great tests...loved the carrots!
Thanks! Thanks for your service!
As an Ironworker I put a lot of wear and tear on my boots. If you did another showdown with Wedge sole boots including brands like Danner, red wings, thorogood, and Irish setter I would love to see how they stand up to each other. From my previous experience danners don't last as long, but I'm not certain how you could test longevity in a controlled way. Thanks for all the amazing content!
My pleasure!
Yes Danner! Test danner!
I've been loyal to Thorogood for years. Would love to see PF do just "American Made" Boot showdown
@@TriStarWorkshop Nick's and similar boots would be an interesting one that I'd be really curious about in that set
Testing combat boots would be great to see. Belleville, Rocky, Danner, Bates, Thorogood, Lowa, Reebok.
The lengths you go through testing is epic. You are a superstar on UA-cam and should have a minimum of 10 million subscribers. The best channel on UA-cam hands down.
Thanks so much!
This channel offers a true value and confidence in how each item and test were performed. No sponsorship keeps it honest.
Thank you!
I am a truck driver at Neo industries. We handle steel Mill rolling pins. The job is hectic on boots. The timberland gravel pit was my main boot. I love the way the boot looks, but they don’t last. I went through 4 pair. They last about 6 months and the seem fails where the boot bends when you walk. All 4 had the same failure.
I decided to try redwing. The Brnr Xp to be exact. They are flawless. I’ve had them for over 2 years now of rugged wear and they have maintained perfectly. Excellent boot.
Thanks or shariing.
I used to get those same Brahma boots about every 4 months. They are actually pretty comfortable with a Dr. Scholls insert. I recently switched to Wolverine boots, they are much more comfortable without any insert and have already lasted longer than any pair of Brahmas I ever owned. Thanks for you content!
You are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
I used to buy carolina/corcorans, but I got cheap one time and bought some used german-made military boots. With only a few exceptions, I've been wearing them every day for about 10 years now. Best $20 boots you can buy.
Sad Wolverine wasn't in the video! First pair I had lasted me almost 5 years of heavy duty use and a few changes of insoles. My second pair (same product) are still in great shape after 2 years of light-medium use. Definately my favorite boots I have ever had. Excellent insulation, really good slip proof, quality leather, the Durashock soles are amazing. Just an all over perfect boot.
Get yourself some thorogood if you want a very nice boot that last a long time I absolutely hated spending so much on a pair of boots but every pair of wolverine Redwing and anything I tried in between wore out in less than 1.5 years my thorogood I paid like 300 for BUT I've had them going on 3 years now and they still have at least another year on them I wear them 14 or more hours everyday
@@tcp8946my current wolverines have outlasted every high priced boot I've ever owned.
I have the shorter version of the Redwing you have here. I have been working in boots for over 20 years, and the $200+ boots are worth it! Redwing will have to go out of business before I stop buying them. Most comfortable, last forever, almost zero break in time, and the local store customer service is top notch! Great video. Your results prove my experience!
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
I think I have the same boot as you. It took me about 4 years to wear out the boots, and then a cheap resole got me another 1.5 years. The upper is still in fine shape so I keep them around for yardwork. Then I bought the exact same boot again.
For me it’s always been Red Wing.
Great customer service too if you can find an outlet.
Thanks for the feedback.
After you realize you can have them resoled over and over and over again why would you bother buying a brand new pair?
Plus they sell the nose guard that nobody else sells
And don't get me started on the nose guard that nobody else sells that will make your boots last twice as long
The Red Wings are the only ones made in the United States. After they have broken in I like them.
The problem with sending boots back to Redwing for resoling.. it costs about 75% of new Redwings based on several attempts I made to get mine repaired. I finding myself buying used replacements on Ebay for less than 50 bucks.
Bought a pair of Redwings a couple years ago, I'm 55 and these will be the last boots I will ever need.
They are as comfortable as my tennis shoes, and worth every penny.
They keep my toes warm in the winter.
Wish you could have tested that feature.
Thanks for the review.
I spent many years in a construction oriented position. I went through alot of boots over the years. 1 thing I concluded is that a quality boot is 1 of the most important tools I used.
Of all the boots over 25 years I had, I can say the Chippewa 25220 boots were the most comfortable and were equally durable to any other boot I found. I would not hesitate to purchase another pair. I still have the last pair I bought even though I've retired, they still get worn around the acreage on occasion.
Thanks for sharing.
I was first introduced to Steel Blue boots when I worked for a mining company and went on a business trip to visit with mining sites in Australia. All the mining supply stores carried walls of Steel Blue boots, I bought a pair & wore them every day for over 5 years before they wore out. (Office guy, but lots of time in the field). I absolutely love steel blue, they are the most comfortable, toughest boots on the market! I recommend them to everyone
Thanks for the feedback.
If you can't have them resoled to me they're not worth buying
They used to be made in Australia (in WA where most of the mines are) but like Blundstone have now moved most of their production overseas. Redback and Mongrel are the only two that I know of still made in Australia but there may be others. Interesting to see the US price of Redback, here they can be picked up for ~US$100 so less than half that.
I have the same experience with Steel Blues. Five year life span with some pretty tough work and are the most comfortable steel cap boots I have ever owned. I've had some pretty bad brands in the past.
@@lukespread funny how only Red Wing makes the nose guard that everyone else uses on all the other boots
Red wing is my go to. I've had boots in the $50-$125 range and they all lasted 6-9 months. My first pair of redwings (~$225) lasted 2 years before the toes wore out so they were no longer water resistant. I've had a different brand that was about $200 and they lasted almost 2 years but were never as comfortable as the redwings.
Thanks for sharing!
High test are the best you can buy dont waste your money on redwings
I love Red Wing boots and wore them for many years in manufacturing! The biggest drawback to them is they’re heavy and expensive.
I buy the 2414, the ones in the video are 2408. I coat mine with toe coat before ever wearing them. They will last so much longer if you do a toe cover.
@@Rad_Triumph_765_RS I get the 2240 (my feet are fucking wide at the toes so I need the extra space). After that first set I started putting tuff toe on them
i’m from minnesota!! i hav always worn Redwings!! i will never buy a cheap pair of boots!! your videos are amazing!! thank you
Thanks and you are welcome!
I was a 35 year redwing user, but no longer because of repeated quality issues in recent years and I’m far from being alone. Many people have had very similar issues; stitching, soles. And redwing doesn’t care. I’m done.
You are the best reviewer in You Tube. Direct to the point of what consumers need to know. No clowning around, very knowledgeable always the precise equipment to test the product. Thank you so much.
You are welcome!
My dad wore Redwings throughout his career as a mechanic/manager. He rarely has back pain now at 70, but he did have a knee replacement about 15 years ago. I only remember him buying a new pair about 3 times from 1986 to 2019. So I'd say for longevity, the Redwings will give you up to 10 years. He chose them because he has narrow feet, and they were the only brand that was comfortable and had that option.
Thanks for sharing.
They are also one of the only brands with wide boot sizes, very nice for me as I have wide feet
Love to see more boot tests. Anvil Rose makes some great videos on boots and their construction if people want more boot videos.
Been a Red Wings fan for the last 15 years, and glad to see they're performing well. Be kind to your feet, and your joints will thank you as you get older.
I wish Rose would do a serious review of real safety toe boots... I think he performs the most thorough and useful reviews of footwear on the planet...
Truth
Good reviewer but I hate when he reviews a product that is a good value. Jim Green jacked their prices up $40 after his review.
Rose plays that annoying music.
I've been wearing the Reebok in an 8" boot for several years. After 3 pair, I can say that they are the most comfortable boot, out of the box, that I have ever owned. Several coworkers are now wearing them also. One has a bone spur on his heel that really had him in a bad way. The comfort of the Reeboks have helped him out a bunch. I have had the Tan and the Coyote Brown and like the darker one because it looks cleaner longer. They are all still servicable, just dirty and because of the suede outer surface are near impossible to keep new looking. The grip and comfort are all I need to know about these boots! Great video, as usual!
Thanks for the feedback.
The Redwing boots you tested I've been buying for 20 years. As a heavy machinist they are the only boots that will last 2+ years walking in coolent, deep oil, and hot razer sharp metal chips. Redwing referrers to the sole as 2.0 and is amazing. Don't cheap out and buy lesser boots. Buy the best and buy Redwing.
Thanks for sharing.
What’s the name of the boots ?
@@fawkimhigkhgk6523Redwing. You often have to buy in store. Some of the boots are not available online.
@@fawkimhigkhgk6523 redwing 2406
What model was it
Great to see some new boots tested! I'd like to see you test some more of those "work sneakers" that look like regular ones but have toe protection and claim slip resistance. They look like they would be super comfortable to work in, but I've never given them a chance.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Longevity is one of those difficult tests to perform. Here's my own personal take on Red Wing at least. I served as a missionary from 1982-1984 and I bought 2 pairs of Red Wing shoes, not the boots but they have the same build quality in my opinion. I was walking every day and they withstood all that in great comfort, some very wet conditions too (I was in Colombia). I continued to wear them after getting home. Because I liked them so well I bought another pair. I am still wearing them today, 39 years later. I wear them once a week so they don't get as much wear and tear but they still look like new. Very good quality even though they are quite pricey.
Thanks for sharing!
What type of missionary
Same here with the RedWings . Take them in to the store and get new laces and leather treated and they look good. At no cost . Hard to wear them out working in a factory but outdoors is definitely not the same. We got a shoe allowance so if you bought cheap ones you couldn’t keep the unused balance. Buy the best and your feet will thank you.expensive doesn’t mean that they are the best.
I've had my Red Wing's for a little over 3 years now and they're holding up great. If you can get over the sticker shock, they are really great boots.
Thanks for the feedback.
Got two pairs of redwings love them both
I agree been using them for 30 years, each pair last 4 years or more.
I've been wearing the Reebok zip ups for over 10 years ..they were originally made by converse. They are the most comfortable boots I've ever worn, nice ball of gell sewn into the inside under the heel..so much cushion. Grip well and easy on off. Love them
Thanks for sharing.
@@ProjectFarm No problem, Work on railroad and do a lot of walking on rough ballast. The insoles could use a bit more cushion but that gel cushion sewn directly into the heel of the boot makes them extremely comfortable.
How is the toe holding up? I tend to go through mine quickly. Was thinking of getting these and put a replacement cover right away to make them strong from the start
@@oscarinacan I never had the toe wear out as far as holes/cuts, the body of the boot has never torn or separated from the sole. They are the best boots for every day hold.up to whatever and feels like it wearing gym shoes.. you won't regret them
@@Carguy0882 cool. Thanks
This video basically sums up why I love Red Wing. I went from $50-$150 work boots every few months to a pair of Red Wings that have lasted several years. The comfort difference is just an added bonus.
Thanks for sharing.
red wings are the only boot ive worn the are so comfortable they dont need to be broken in.
Especially if you go to a redwing store to get the best fit!
My experience:
Service - 10. Comfort - 10. Durability - 10. Put these things through a deployment, multiple years of use around a shipyard, motorcycle riding, and 6 years past they're still on the original soles and looking great!
Yea I got a pair of boots I paid &150 for around 9 months ago! Tips are coming apart, and one side seam has busted open
Still own the Irish settlers from ‘84 - just mink oil and ready to hunt
Great info! One thing you didn’t test was water resistances. I got my redwings because they were the only ones to keep my feet dry in standing water. Thank you again for the great content!!!!!!!
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
I've had the same 2 pairs of Redwings for over 15 years now. I maintain them every year and they have outlasted every boot and shoe I've ever owned. You might pay more upfront, but for that kind of quality, you actually save money in the long run.
Unless you do metal working, my brother gashed a hole in his on his second day in the shop lmao
@@JacobyStevens That's just bad luck lol
i bought the cheapest walmart brand boots i could and some other cheap brands when i started working on a farm at 14years old. they last about 6months at most before coming apart in one way or the other. eventually i spent the money on some redwings which the farmer that owns the farm wore for many years and i havent bought a different brand since. ive been using redwings now for years as im 30yrs old and ive bought 3 pairs over that time. if used reasonably they last and they keep your feet comfortable and safe. my first pair are still usable to this day but the inside wore out and became annoying to feel. so maybe take care of them and replace the inside after a bit to prevent serious wear and tear haha. another experience to was when a hydraulic line on our skid steer broke which dropped the bucket full of gravel on my foot, the steel toe saved my toes and the top of my foot was bruised but it could have been a lot worse.
I just bought my second pair. First pair was bought in 2014 made it through 9 years of on and off use. they went through hell and were not maintained well at all. This second pair will be taken care of now that I know better. Hopefully get 10-15 years out of this pair.
Or me who goes through them every 2 years cause work gives them out for free
I own a lawn service in Florida and during the Summer it doesn't matter if I buy expensive Redwings or the Brahmas from Walmart. Couple months of going through puddles and getting covered in grass and mud. They're no longer waterproof pretty worn out and end up in the trash so I just buy the cheap Walmart boots. I feel better throwing away $25-$30 every couple months rather than $250-$300 can't deny Redwing makes some amazingly comfy and nice looking boots though.
Thanks for the feedback.
I've been wearing Red Wings for years and just swapped to Reeboks a few months ago and found the Reeboks to be more comfortable because of my extremely wide feet. It's nice to know that they are at the top in most of the objective categories too.
Thanks for sharing!
Kinda surprised you didn't find boots wide enough from Red Wing, these are available in H width.
@@alexhamon9261 I've got H width Red Wings. I thought they were comfortable until I swapped back to them temporarily from my Reeboks and realized how comfortable the Reeboks actually are.
Redwing also sells insole for wide feet as well. When i bought my boots, i thought they're were comfortable but missing something. I explained to the sell person, and they took the insole out of the boot and opened the "wide sole."( I can't remember what it was called), but it made a total difference, and I've been rocking Redwing for 3 to 4 years now! There are no issues! here!
This is just what i needed to hear not someone that never tryed any other boot ive wore red wings im not that impressed unless your climbing trees or poles im fixing to give these reeboks a try they look like something i could wear 10 hr days
I've been wearing RedWing boots the past 2 or 3 years, they're wonderful boots, except the break in period can be quite long depending on the boot style. I've done maybe 6-10 million steps in one pair so far. One benefit of the redwing boots is that they offer a resole and refresh program for the non waterproof/insulated versions of them for less than half the cost of a new boot, with the same sole you get when you buy them new.
Great testing! Glad to see there are some good value options out there as well!
Thank you for sharing!
I have a pair of Red Wings I'm about to send in to be resoled. I'm not looking forward to being without them while they're being repaired. As far as the break in period I always tell people that once the Red Wings are done breaking in your feet they're the most comfortable boots you'll ever wear.
You should mink oil the Red Wings and not only does it waterproof them it apparently extends their life. I agree with the break-in period not being ideal but they are better than most.
A durometer test of the rubber, thickness measurement of the leather, and cross section of the construction would be very interesting data. Much love Todd, thanks for putting in so much effort to make the most amazing product testing videos in the world
Heh, I love the cross pollination between this channel and Wes' Rose Anvil channel. Friendly competition is great!
@@TheJohn8765 Rose Anvil is great, but he made me spent a lot of money on the toughest boots on the planet. 😅
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm can you also look at cold traction? Ive found boots that turn hard as a rock and slip at cold temps
@@tobiass1184 Cold boots tested on ice would be a great test. As for wear resistance would a certain amount of downward pressure on the boots over a belt sander be adequate? I'd like to get a pair of boots that last me more than 1 - 1.5 years.
I just bought Reebok RB4131 composite toe high tops and I gotta say they are the most comfortable work boot/shoe I've ever worn. These are my first "work shoe" I used to always wear boots but with back and knee injuries I've always had problems with pain by end of day, now I have no issues and they are waterproof and corrosive resistant and anti slip, anti shock, ASTM- F2413. Only $93 too.
Thanks for testing these boots! Makes me feel good about my past purchases of Reebok and Red Wing. My job requires a non conductive toe, like the composites, so it's good to see that the boots are up to safety standards.
You are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
Great review of the boots, but there is one additional factor that could be considered: long term durability. Many of the cheap boots fall apart after a few months with the sides bursting out from insufficient sewing and the soles falling off because of poor gluing. I'm currently using some Carolina moccasin toed steel safety, ankle high boots made in USA and after over two years of heavy use I expect to get several more years out of them, though I did just replace the laces because one got partly cut somehow.
I’ve been wearing Red Wings every day for 3 years now. They are the best boots I’ve ever owned. I’ve been through so many cheap brands including the Walmart Brahama’s before investing in a good pair of red wings. Highly recommend. Buy nice or buy it twice. My dad always said, don’t cheap out on shoes, mattresses, underwear.
Thanks for the feedback.
Add socks!
I bought my first pair or Red Wings in 2002. I still own that pair and wear them occasionally. The sole is worn almost smooth (these ones can't be replaced) but they have held on longer than anything else I've ever bought. When I went to buy hiking boots, it was right back to Red Wings again. My youngest has finally stopped growing so now he too can have a pair of Red Wings to match his older brother. Yes you pay dearly for these but they pay you back.
Right. Spend the money on things your gonna be in for a long time.
Socks bro, foe sure. And pocket knifes.
I used to work in the red wing shoes boot factory in Red Wing, MN
Used to? Did you .... get the boot? Kidding!
@@john091077did you use the John John😂😂😂😂
As a former machinist I can't tell you how much o love your videos man !!! You do an amazing job. As far as boots go I've worn Redwing as far as I can remember I've tried others but you cannot beat the quality of Redwing and also it's a Made in America company which i support! To this day i still buy redwing every other year great boot! Cheers from your biggest fan in Colombia amigo!
Thanks so much!
As an Aussie raised on a farm, I quickly learned to appreciate a good work boot. The pair I remember most fondly was a Redback pair, so it’s nice to see them show up here.
Thanks for sharing.
Redbacks are awesome. I'll never buy another brand
Redbacks are top notch. I wore a pair almost every day for 4 years before I retired them. They took me to bush festivals, my entire mechanic apprenticeship, dirt bike riding, to the snow, metal shows, lots of farm work. The ol bastards did not give up.
Great review, as always. We get a significant discount on work boots (45% for the red wings). I always choose the same model red wing you tested. The oil test after a few 8-hour shifts would be significantly improved. These red wing boots are incredibly comfortable. I get an annual boot allowance, but these last me around 5 years. I walk about 8k-11k steps per day on concrete floors. The work environment is very oily. They hold up amazingly when treated with snow seal. The biggest flaw with the red wing is the break-in period. The first two weeks wearing these boots is miserable. After that, they're perfect. I wear these boots every day, even on weekends. I'll gladly pay $150 out of pocket for these every 5 years. Wear them until the soles fall off or split.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I'm in the same situation as you and agree with everything you said. I've been at my job for 16 years and get a brand new pair every year that they pay for. Needless to say, I've only worn out 4 pairs and have 10 or so brand new pairs in my attic.
@@Big-Wonka You should sell 80% of them on Marketplace....that's about $2K...
This weekend I realized the bottom-outsole of one of my RedWings has split and is tearing off. I was a bit upset at the thought of the cost to replace them until I remembered I bought them in the early ‘10s, maybe late ‘00s, and have worn them for every outdoor project, off path hike, and snow day since.
Amortized that way, they cost me about $20 per year.
Thank you so much for a part two to this project 🙌🏽
You are welcome!
One way to improve cheaper boots or shoes is to buy a quality insole for $20. You'd be surprised how much of a difference it makes in comfort and fit. Great video, as always. 💪
That's exactly what I do! 20$ Dr Scholls insoles have lasted me more than 3 years!
@@trm4life same here
AND changing out insoles can re-fit the boots fit. It can snug up a " too large of size " with a thicker pad, or loosen a "too tight" of a boots fit with a thinner pad.
Most insoles are garbage marketing gimmicks, if it ain’t the Good Feet Store soles, you’re buying garbage
@@saltytart4891 I stopped there. Bought the $269 insoles.
I later found the exact same thing for $50 online. That place is a SCAM
I always GREATLY appreciate your overall subjective assessments at the end of product tests. All of us know that you can't test for everything and sometimes, you have to get to the end to know what what you wish you'd measured. (E.g., maybe you can just feel that some products are truly made to last and others aren't.)
So I really like when you get to the end and say something like, "Overall, if price weren't a factor, I'd go with A, but if I only had $X, I'd go with B."
That's gold, pure gold.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
I know it would cost a lot, but there's no better channel than this one to test out the effectiveness of certain washers, as in clothes washers. I'd love to see a comparison of similar priced washers in the three main styles, agitator, impellor, and front load. And of course you could test different brands, but I think a lot of people would love to see just how well each style cleans clothes.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I can attest to the comfort of red backs. I have a steel toe version and a standard pair. Wear both pretty much everywhere and are incredibly comfortable. Even after long days at work or long walks/hikes
Agreed. I’m an automotive diagnostician & programmer and wear non-steel toe Redbacks daily for five years now.
Agreed as well. I’m an automotive fleet tech that walks an average of 2 miles per day in the shop. I’m on my 5th pair of Redbacks that have lasted an average of 3 years per pair and can say they are by far the best of all worlds in terms of comfort, durability, slip resistance and quality. I prefer them to the Red Wings and Wolverines I’ve had in the past. The numerous pairs of various brands all made in China I used earlier in my career aren’t even in the same universe as Redbacks.
Thanks for sharing.
@@ProjectFarm thanks for your hard work 👍
@@chipyeahoo I like how they are slip on too. I have to take my shoes on and off alot with work when visiting people's homes. So it's much better than laces and they haven't stretched out either.
As for longevity, my Redwings go back to the early 1990's! They probably should be re-soled, but they are still in great shape. Best wear and comfort for the money I've ever spent.
Nice!
redwings are still good, but they aren't what they used to be. most redwings now made overseas, only a handfull still made here, and those don't see to be as good as they were 10 years ago and prior. sad, but it is what it is. redwing used to be so much better than everything else that they were worth the higher price, now that value proposition just isn't there.
What kinda job sites do you wear those Redwings on?
@@workingdad Best off with a Nick's, Frank's or JK's anymore.
@@willieearles3151 probably wears them around the house 😂
I personally just picked up a pair of Red backs after having a pair of Blundstone work boots and have to say they are amazing, One thing to note is the lack of time it takes to put on the red backs compared to the other boots being a slip on in my work environment is essential as in certain situations I have to put my work boots on and run as in as fast as possible. Another point of the slip ons is in environment where your working with combustible liquids and hot surfaces a major plus of being a slip on is that in the event they caught fire you can easily get them off and not suffer burns to your feet and legs. I know from experience. Great video!
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
Im gkad to see my red wing 2406s tested on here and happy to see they came out on top. I can tell you from personal experience iver the last 10 years they hold up very well and are extremely comfortable. Ive stood on red hot bolts, nuts, and random metals that i had just cut with a torch and never noticed, had multiple large impacts with no issues or damage and most importantly no injuries, and are extremely comfortable. Over the last 10 years I have bought 3 pairs, and my original pair i stull use for work every day.
Thanks for the feedback.
I'd destroy them in a year. Not even red wings hold up in actual hard use, like my water plant. Constant water and pure chlorine gas exposure kills $500 boots in a year or so.
So my employer buys me new boots every year. KEENS are the best I've ever tried, after all these.
@@RobertMorgan My red wings have held up 5 years in highly caustic and acidic conditions in one industrial plant, extreme fires and hot ass hydraulic fluid for 2 years at a metallurgy plant, and the last 3 years working as a diesel tech. Just oil the lether ebery few months and they hold up forever
I like my Red Wing boots, very comfortable. If you go to one of their retail stores they can 3D scan your feet, and have you walk back and forth on a pressure pad to measure your feet. It will tell the size you need, and they will even email the results to you.
Thanks for the feedback.
When I was cruising Timber out west I almost bought a pair of Red Wings. Very comfortable but I tried out a set of Buffalo's (Whites semi custom brand) and handed over almost twice as much for them. On lava rocks all day nothing bothered my feet over many miles of walking once broken in
Loving this new content on work wear / jeans / boots etc.
Thank you!
Thank you for your videos. My mother bought me the most expensive boots Red Wing offered with steel metatarsal guard and steel sole plate when I started my first construction job. That was over ten years ago and those boots are still kicking, no pun intended. It's nice to see that those boots were worth the cost she paid. I've cherished those boots and seeing this makes me love them even more.
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Great tests and love the channel.
From everything I could find, the EH rating on boots is only good for
Thank you for the video idea!
One thing you should have tested was abrasion resistance of the sole, sides, and toe. Some boots will cut straight through if you accidentally scrape the corner of concrete steps and such, and some boots lose all of their tread very rapidly just by walking on concrete. You could probably test it pretty quickly and release a short addendum, I'm sure it would be appreciated greatly, as all of your videos are.
Aside from normal wear and tear, I know some people tend to hit their heels together when they walk(I used to until I taught myself not to) and that can rapidly damage many shoes/boots, so that's a thing to consider for some people(although plastic heel and toe caps trivialize this).
If you decide to do another boot video, you should try to test out the boots with kevlar midsoles, plus it'd be cool to see a comparison of the differences in durability/protection from leather, synthetic "leather", fabric mesh, and mixed material boots. I know, for example, my dad has a pair of Brunt brand boots that uses the fabric mesh body(with hard toe and heel caps), which are waterproof and *extremely* abrasion resistant despite being a very flexible material. I personally have some cheap soft faux leather boots which are shockingly cut resistant. Material science is hard.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I've had a pair of redback boots for over 6 years now. Never missed a beat! Super comfy and extremely durable!
Thanks for sharing.
I end up bought blackhammer shoe 2 years ago but not this model. I wear it almost everyday since then. It holds up for two years now. You got it right about the padding not so thick. I bought new padding after around 6 months wearing it. Thanks for the video. You really have been helpful.
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
The carrot analogy is great. I don't know why, but "the carrots are getting nervous" totally cracked me up! 🤣
Lol, Thanks for sharing!
If you wanted a follow-up video, you may be able to test longevity in some ways. You could measure how much of the sole is worn away by sliding the boot around on an abrasive surface with an added weight, or flex the soles/uppers a number of times or directions until the materials fail. I suppose that wouldn't account for variations in environment, but it would be a start. Thanks for this video, Project Farm!
Yeah, and maybe run them through temperature cycles as well as dry / wet cycles and bend them all up.
I used to buy a new pair of boots every 6 - 8 months. A coworker suggested that I spend a bit more money and buy some Red Wings. They last me 3 - 4 years, I would have been excited if they lasted 1 - 2 years. Thanks for another great video!
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Same, went from buying Doc Martens work boots to Redwing Iron Rangers, and now I upgraded to the Builder Pro from Nick's Boots.
REDWING PERIOD!! And before I forget absolutely awesome review as usual.
For longevity it's Redwing hands-down. I've got a pair that I've worn for thousands of hours of hard physical labor and they just gave out this year they're about 18 years old. I have worn many brands up until about 15 years ago. I wear nothing but Redwing now.
I don't mean to sound like a fanboy I'm just simply saying they're the best for a reason. Spend the $300 today and don't even think about needing to buy another pair for over a decade easy. You'll have to get new insoles and you'll have to replace the shoelaces once or twice a year if you wear them like I did.
Also use mink oil to keep them highly water resistant if not waterproof. I am very very hard on boots. Most don't make it six months. Like I said these made it 18 years.
PFarm always hits a home run w me. These tests were well thought out and executed well. I owe Project Farm a big thank you. Eggsellent job sir!
Thank you!
I wore the Reeboks in Afghanistan as a contractor for almost two years and they held up tremendously well. They are desert tan because the were authorized for use by solders. Bad part is they were not well ventilated and my feet would get pretty hot in them, but they saved my ankles from twisting over all the rocks on base.
Thanks for sharing.
Yea I was about to say those Reebok boots looked familiar to me lol
Same for me. They held up well and quite comfy besides the heat. Good thing is the zipper was good so you could pop them off for a few minutes without much fuss.
I'm from Red Wing. I've been wearing Red Wing Boots most of my life. Nice vid.
Thank you
In the early 1970’s I bought the exact same Redwings you tested. I was a locomotive electrician so I wanted the electrical insulation, they looked good and were comfortable with good ankle shin protection and quick lacing.
Thanks for sharing.
Love this channel, it’s like Mr.Rodgers for adults. Keep the videos coming!
Thanks, will do!
My last pair of Redback lace-up boots finally wore out after 5 years in the auto collision industry with lots of different chemicals. And definitely very comfortable. And thanks for your awesome videos!
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
I’ve been wearing Red Wings for years. Hands down worth the money. Made in the USA! My favourite feature is you can custom order different widths so you get a more custom fit for your foot width. That’s a game changer.
Thanks for the feedback.
But many of the Red Wings are, in fact, Chinesium
Working in wet ditches and excavations all day the redwings are great for being in a few inches of water and mud all day and keeping dry feet! I used to buy caterpillar boots but the exact make they discontinued and I switched the the redwing2412s and never looked back. Wear them right down to -20 in the winter and i am still comfortable!
Thanks for sharing!
This is the most informative and detailed REVIEWS you could hope for, now everyone can make a fact base decision on which pair of Boots will best serve their needs. BEST CHANNEL ON UA-cam 👍👍👍👏👏👏👏
Thanks!
While I was working as a paramedic I had a pair of Redwing boots that lasted well over 10 years ( I did have to have them resoled several times ). During that time they were exposed to just about every harsh condition you can imagine and never let me down. The only reason that they didn't last longer is that they got contaminated in hazmat incident and I was unable to decontaminate them so they were given to the hazmat cleanup team (they did buy me a new pair of Redwings, that that was OK with me).The only downside I ever found with the boots is that needed to treat them with snowseal to keep then water repellant during the winter. They are by far the best work boots that I ever used, yes they are expensive but you get what you pay for.
I got nearly 3 years out of a pair of Rockport Works RK6640 boots. The only things wrong with them are worn out insoles, and the soles peeled at the front.
As a video idea, I'm actually interested in something a lil bit different. Would love to see strength tests of wood joints, like how mortise and tenon would fare against pocket hole joints. Would love to see objectively how strong they truly are! Anyway, thank you so much of all of the great tests you're doing Todd!
There are some good ones already in the mix out there, 45 miters with splines seem to be winning most of the showdowns. Bourbon Moth Woodworking is a good place to start, good sense of humor
Thank you for the video idea!
Matthias Wendel and other woodworkers have done testing on this to the nth degree. Don't think Todd would find anything different, and it would simply duplicate some excellent work thats already well respected.
No disrespect to any of those guys you mentioned. Nobody tests like Todd though, plus he's not sponsored.
That's been done on other channels. Dowels are pretty strong. If appearance doesn't matter a glued and screwed butt joint is hard to beat. Modern PVA glue is stronger than wood is. So joints usually fail by the wood pulling apart. Then it comes down to what wood is the strongest. But some wood doesn't glue good.
I bought a pair of the Steel Blue women's a few years ago. I worked as a remote-control locomotive operator in a steel mill. I don't think they even made it 6 months. Both boots split where the heel comes into the sole. Because I purchased them on Amazon there was no way to return them even though the company says to just return them to where you bought them for a full refund. For reference I was walking between 15,000-20,000 steps per shift, 60 hours a week average. For $200 I expected a better outcome.
Thanks for the feedback.
I wore Danner Acadia's for many, many years. Learned early on that the odds of a cheap boot being a good boot were slim. This is a great topic, if you do it again and can get a pair of Acadia's please test them. I spend a lot of time in the desert these days, and the Reeboks you tested look very interesting to me.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Def get what you pay for
It would be cool to see a "hiking" boot tested through the same tests. ESP against ice etc, I would love to see Crispi's boots compared to others. Those are my fave right now, but I am curious how others perform.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
I have been wearing 5.11 8" boots for six years now. They are the best I have found for the money and comfort. I would like to see your tests with these. The other thing you don't test with boots is the waterproofness of them. That is a big thing for a lot of us out here. Great channel!
Mink oil solves the waterproof concern and also seems to extend the life of the boots.
But dissolves the stitching
Unless the boots are rubber no boot is really waterproof for very long. So you just have to prepare for having wet feet. To that end you wear silk liner socks and woolen outer socks. Even soaking wet your feet stay comfortable then. Least for how long you're going to be out in the weather. 10-12 hours or so is about max. You can reasonably expect boots to resist being soaked for some time. A couple hours maybe? In real weather conditions rubber boots are the way to go.
When I did line clearance tree trimming I bought 2 pair of Carolina lineman boots. 1 for the winter & 1 for the summer. They are both the best feeling and quality boots I've ever owned. Love them. I need to find them again though bc I left that line of work about 7 years ago.
Thanks for sharing.
by the way, I want to express my gratitude for your great videos! walking half a mile in each of those boots to prepare them for testing... I have never been so impressed by such dedication! 😍😍😍😍😍
Thank you!
Having owned work boots across the cost spectrum, I do adore my Red Wing boots. Wouldn't trade them for anything.
I actually have two pairs, currently saving to get the first pair re-soled since there's a small break about where the toecap starts (I walk around a lot and have to move heavy stuff in small spaces)
Thanks for the feedback.
Excellent comparison. My dad wore Red Wing throughout his career in construction, and he swore by them. They weren't cheap, but you get what you pay for. They saved his feet on many occasions. I would love to see more tests, as a home DIY I would like to have a safety shoe for my projects but don't need the level of Red Wing as I'm not on a construction site.
Thanks!
ive not seen the results yet, but used to buy redwing, and found boots that only cost 70 bucks and lasted 2 to 3 times as long. Ive not bought any other brand after that. They are the Bates military boots from Canada, with either steel toe or thermal liners.
I have been wearing to Red Wings for many years. Hold up very well for me working as a railroader.
I'm a gasoline hauler and have worn Red Wing boots, exclusively, for over 25 years, in both work and play and always keep a pair or two in rotation while having worn boots resoled. I think the anti-slip soles are more aggressive than other brands, so I think that is why the soles wear quicker. But to have that quality and comfort, resoled at a third of the cost of new, is a no-brainer. When I get them back from Missouri, they always look like new, other than normal wear and tear.
When I saw you were testing Red Wing boots, I was confident they were gonna impress. Thank you for all your hard work on the channel.
Thanks and you are welcome!