I was in China in the 1990s and this was going on. I met some expats working for architecture companies and they said builders were selling entire floors of apartments to single buyers and no one was moving into the apartments. They also said builders were using the cheapest materials possible with zero insulation so the heating and cooling costs were enormous
Another reason for such oddity is the over-regulation of the stock market in China. Not everyone can trade stocks freely, authorities step in whenever they like, lots of scams in the market over the decade. All these contribute further to the property investment market, as it has seemed to be the "only legal and safe way" to invest for the masses in China. Just wait for this perfect storm to brew even stronger.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
"Homes are for living in, not for speculating on." - Xi Jinping I agree. The commodification & financialization of housing is an evil scourge on society.
It's just a political slogan to deceive the angry people, because price is too high and most people can't afford housing. Yet their policy is opposite. Fact: China still has ZERO property tax today. This is single most contributing factor that makes housing a perfect speculating investment. No cost to own properties. Keep buying. Rich get richer.
So, I think you just about managed to scratch the surface of the problems. Next time maybe look at who sold the land parcels, why property prices in tier 1 cities are artificially prevented from falling. Who holds the mortgages on the roughly 100 million unfinished apartments bought off plan?
All true. Prices are tumbling in the secong hand market as unseen ever before in China. Some places up to 70% down from purchasing prices just a few years ago (outskirts of Beijing in bordering Hebei province) and Tianjin Binhai New Area 40% down from purchasing prices from 2017. And so on thoughout the country.
@@swingingdaniel The specific locations you pointed out are far away from the city center and are not representative. If readers are interested, you can check the relevant maps by yourself.
Not true. Beijing Wukesong secong hand apartment 2022 asking price 7.5 million, and the offer received was 7.3 million. Sellers did not agree. Now 7.0 Million will not find a buyer. Same for Chaoyang distirict villas. All down by at least 15% and that is about the officially reported number. @@WellSalt-Studio
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Indian developers were doing similar models of business, pre sales, using the money to buy to new land, not completing per sold projects. The Supreme court steps in, created the regulatory framework nationwide. Parliament passed a law to create the independent statutory regulatory authorities in all states. Thats how the Indian real estate industry saved, consumer interest is saved and china like situation is averted.
Smart move from India's Supreme Court to protect the rights of individual consumers, and buyers, or else end up with over a hundred half-finished, skeletal buildings dotting across India. That would later be demolished just like China. A total waste of materials, and resources. At least India has a high-quality demand for building standards, unlike China. Less chance of falling through the floor.
That is because it is still under the British monarchy and basically the Indian framework is the same as the UK's... people tried that with china cos the HK was meant to be the seeding. But it didn't happen that way... the stare council stated that HK remains unchanged but it has changed. Now it has gone beyond repair?....
In the long term, more affordable prices for housing are always better. The bubble was going to pop eventually, and it's better to have it deflate now than let it balloon into an even bigger problem later on. Tough luck for all the investors though.
"In the long term, more affordable prices for housing are always better." Not for China's economy. Without a domestic consumer base, which Xi adamantly refuses to nuture, due to considering domestic credit based consumption as making people "lazy", and 80% of the typical Chinese's wealth being locked up in their home value, you are proposing China falling out of the Middle income trap into the Low-income one. "tough luck for all the investors though." Those investors are literally every single homeowner, which are all Chinese people or companies.
@@freemanol Politely, you are misinterpreting the statistic. It's not talking about % of ownership. It's saying that household wealth at the total is 70% housing. The other 30% is stocks, bonds or cash in banks.
The scary thing is that China's real estate investment cycling has been going on for several years now, and the debt continues to grow every time the debt is paid off with debt. And the sky is the limit. It's not just a limited number of real estate developers. Sixty-four major real estate developers, counting those in China, have such insolvencies. Other bright spots in China are not to be found, such as the high-speed rail system, which continues to swell with regular losses, and the semiconductor companies, more than 5,700 of which have gone out of business.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
@@indiasuperclean6969 its obviously a satire comment but i would still rather live in india than in big brother dictatorship like china especially as a citizen so the joke is on you buddy
Totally underselling the pain that is spread out due to the “debt” structure of developers. Generally speaking, 1/3 of debt is bonds, 1/3 is pre-payments and 1/3 is debt to suppliers. Sure banks are “protected”, but everyone else is totally f’d. Also, the magnitude of debt. Just Evergrande and Country Garden have debt of close to 3% of GDP. When Lehman folded, their debt was about 0.5% of GDP.
@@robbrand922 lol, this dude never heard of mark-to-market. Lehman had $600B in assets on the books. It wasn't an accounting scandal. YOU'VE NEVER TAKEN AN ACCOUNTING CLASS HAVE YOU?
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
There should be more emphasis on the differences between 2008 and this crisis. The huge difference being Chinese banks seem to have much less exposure to the Chinese realestate market compared to the US banks in 2008. US banks made bad investments in derivatives of subprime loans, which led to the first bankruptcies, then panic and bank runs. And these financial instruments were sold to many foreign investors as well, which is what made the recession so global. The current situation in China, while bad, looks nothing like the 2008 crisis. These are defaults of DEVELOPERS, not financial institutions. The major concern would be a panic and bank runs, but even then the effects would probably be mostly domestic, since foreign exposure to Chinese realestate is nowhere near that of international exposure to US realestate in 2008.
@@popcorn6931 Perhaps you could read deeper and tell us how the Americans gave the world the GFC back in 2008? Allow me to drop you a hint, non existent lending controls and CDOs. now get educated.
47 industries are upstream and downstream of the real estate industry. It’s affecting everything and everyone there directly or not . Local governments have been cutting salaries to civil servants from office employees, teachers , bus drivers and on and on . 125 thousands teachers have lost their jobs due to demographic downturn and the dominos haven’t all failed yet … One thing very important not mentioned is that the house buyers have no way out as walking away from their house investments isn’t possible because even if they walk away from their houses they are still liable for the rest of the original loan hence ending up with no house and still a mortgage to pay ! And same with unconstructed houses . The first payment comes when you buy the house NOT when you move in therefore they are stuck paying for a house that might never be built and best case scenario is worth 30 to 50 percent less then they paid for .
1:37 Look at that archival footage from Beijing 1995: New apartment projects selling for 1,600/sqm. 25 years later, those same apartments would likely go for 90,000/sqm; a 5,500% increase. Real estate used to be one of the best, if not the best, investments you could make.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
In China there are very few ways that people are allowed to invest so they bid up house prices. You will actually get more housing through investment than if it is price controlled. In USSR there was never enough housing. Unfortunately China's government directed a lot of malinvestment and it is has been very inefficient.
I feel like speculation has gotten so bad over here that developers and building homes that are more and more inhospitable - they're smaller, uglier, and more poorly built
It's almost impossible to be solved by any policies from the public sectors, because they are stakeholders . This crisis of property in China is correlated with the local governments' budgets. Even though the central government tried to tighten the policies, the local governments are inertia or lack of will to reduce their budgets and have to bid more land to real estate companies. As a resident, you only hope that the invisible hand can adjust the perperty' price. Even though the land supply has been monopolized by the government, the market mechanism still works on the price and the prices most of properties have falled during past several years.
At the time of the global financial crisis, property development and construction was 10% of gdp. In 2020 China, property development and construction was 25% of gdp. China’s potential bubble burst is much bigger than the US.
It wasn't a mortgage product then, do you see? It was a form of credit card company that was being used for investment banking and the offshore locations for commercial properties but then this happened. Cos then they took it internally and domestically transformed it, so now they are In deeper sh!ts than anything.
Even worse, the govt still owns the land the building is built on! The developers bid for 70 year leases for the land. So Chinese homeowners might own their flat, but not the land it sits on.
@@gerardp4759 : Then they are basically not "developers"... and if you project the old Imperial model onto this.. and this is whereby their so called "with Chinese characteristics" comes from... So basically.. it should be such that, the indigenous families or family clans that owns those land, and whatever.. only they should be sitting in the State Council. There used to be around 2 groupings. If I recall. One was the people's committee or other, and then the other one was the state council. So when there was all of this "one country, two systems" thing comes into play... It is like... there are no courts. And yet, there is one group of decision makers by consensus.. and then the other one is group of people with legitimacies.... Where does the courts come into play ? It only deals with foreigners then... the courts are for foreign companies and foreigners then. So then how come.. some people inside the PRC today, see a passport as a form of visa only ??? When it is about legitimacies ?
That is how preconstruction works. Imagine yourself buying a shirt on a lay-away plan. You tell the merchant to hold onto that shirt , and get yourself into a scheduled payment plan. After all, you are Tony Manero, you work at the local hardware store , and you need to upgrade your wardrobe for those Saturday nights . Money is scarce then. This was a very common practice in the US , around the 70’s. Same with pre construction. Builders acquire or lease land , supposedly secure financing , arrange for architectural services , spend money on promotional marketing , get approved by the zoning board to build, put up a show room, and sign up buyers to a pre payment plan that might cover 30% of the purchased unit retail value, parsed through cinstruction. The rest is to be paid upon delivery and a confirmed issued certificate of occupancy. The once ready units now need to be completed by buyers on their own nickel . Flooring , lighting fixtures , in-unit HVAC , cabinetry, closets. Chinese builders operate on other people’s money. They are supposed to secure lines of credit , or get securitized, or have their own cash reserves. Chinese oversight for this stage is done poorly , they are way behind on regulatory and compliance affairs. Other people’s money then become buyers prepayment cash outlays., therefore , builders do not secure for such sources of non buyer originated funds.
Look at the auxillary construction markets linke with China. Cambodia had a ton of Chinese construction contractors there. Also look at Vietnam, it's having a construction meltdown too. I hope you guys continue the investigation, it doesn't stop at China!
@@chinadollfmd there are ways around that, if you are in the mortgage industry you should know that, third party realestate, financing, Chinese contracts with Canadian Estate ect it’s not black and white
@@chinadollfmd: Well... they shouldn't be able to do so to begin with ! Cos some of the "money" is basically OUR money from the British commonwealths which fed into China as well. So then they claimed it as their ow public money. And now, they can't use their so called public money to rebuy back the British land ! Sorry.. but that is ridiculous to begin with ! What do people think they are doing ? Playing mah jong ! Until one gets sick and take them down cos they've not slept for days and days ???
When people are buying homes as an investment rather than as a shelter or to even rent it out. That’s obviously going to lead to a bubble. It’s going to be a long and painful collapse of home prices but that will probably reshuffle the ownership of homes from old to young folks. I suspect the disposable income will be nothing like it was the past decade.
Wow, I can't believe I was feeling nostalgic for those 90's footage of china. And I was only there in '98 as a child and can hardly remember anything too. But in all the times I have been back since, and constantly seeing empty high rises and buildings... yeah I saw this coming years away. The last time I went back and saw that it got even more empty buildings, I advised all of my family members to not buy anything and try to sell it at the next opportunity unless they were actually going to live in the buildings (and not speculate). Too bad they didn't want to believe the words of an American guy who said something negative about their economy. I hope that in those 5 years before the bust, he did something, but I haven't heard from one of my uncles since then.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
China has 400 million middle-income families, and putting their money in banks that pay low-interest rates doesn't make sense. Buy property is the best. Many rent out their properties, and wait it out for their children to take over their parent property. China cannot afford to wait until there is a demand and then start building the houses. This scenario happened in Singapore during the late 70s and early 80s when the government built much public housing but not many applicants. A 4-room flat that cost 24K in 1981 and is now worth more than SDG $500K.
My understanding is Singapore actually sold those properties to working families at the time. They didn't simply exist to be unaffordable uninhabited speculative assets, as is the case in China
@@darthbumblebee7310 Although China has lifted up about 900 million citizens out of the poverty line, those people are not rich, but can live comfortably especially for those living in a third or fourth tier city due to lower inflations. Not a single nation on this planet may not experience higher inflations as they progressed from third to developing, and finally first World nations. As a nation run by a world class government, for the people, by the people of the people, need to distribute the nation's wealth of all its people is no easy task, but the CPC government did it. Of course often there are a small number of "sour grapes" from other nations would like to throw stones at China. China built houses made of bricks and cement, and not glass houses.
1:08 - "There was this fundamental belief that property price's could only go up". Yes, if looking at it in the "long" term (10-30 years). Japan in late 1980s and USA in late 2000s, show that there can be bust. Heck, adjusted for inflation - Japan's property price is still not as high as the bubble back then. Also 2:38 - that's the foundation of a Ponzi Scheme.
American media has been replaying this story since the early 2000s. Long story short is capital and manpower is invested into infrastructure when the timing is right. Concrete does not spoil. All the prior cities that were reported on eventually filled up as demand increased.
The life of concrete is variable depending on quality ingredients and soil/foundation preparation. It certainly can last a very long time when done properly.
South China Post is also playing similar stories. It isn't just American media. And the demand is there for the homes people have already paid for. There shouldn't need to be additional demand for a building that was pre-sold and never completed.
“Concrete Cancer” is a thing. It can most definitely “spoil.” Otherwise we would be refurbishing old buildings indefinitely instead of tearing them down to build replacements on-site.
@@Ryan_Christopher a building is not going to be unusable within a few years or even a decade. these are the timelines. two of the first of these stories were for the cities was in 2011ish and i remember it was about zhengzhou, henan province. Google what Zhengzhou looks like now that it has filled up. China's population was heavily based on the coast. Overcrowded urban areas. The idea, I'm guessing, is to improve infrastructure inland, in suburbs and border areas to promote expansion.
Unfortunately it seems even if your lucky enough to get the condo you paid for completed it will fall apart in five years....money obviously does not buy quality
USA is already an actual extension of China to begin with ! How did NYC saved itself from the first depression ? It was the Taiwanese that came along and invested in them.... and raised the investment games.. and then later on... the West invested into SE Asia as well... and the the tech bubble thing came.. and went... and now morphed... Morphed into a nightmare more like. I am very certain that, a lot of money were stolen during those morphing periods... Really. I accept that it has done so.
I'm an idiot and I could have solved the housing crisis a decade ago. 1- true escrow accounts. None of this double dipping using prepayments as extra leverage 2- RE annual tax. The perverse incentives for local governments to keep selling land at higher prices would be mitigated somewhat. Housing costs soared because...local government were charging higher prices!
Escrow would not work in China. The scoundrels would make those deposits disappear or dip into funds. China is the land of Guanxin. Lots of shady characters doing patronage. The poor investor would’ve gotten swindled. Annual income taxes. Your ever so competent social credit savvy central and provincial governments are riddled with corruption. Let’s face it. China has corruption and graft running from top down throughout the country in every sphere and province. It takes more than sound leadership to reverse China’s fortunes , Singapore style. It takes compromise from the bottom up and the top down. Like the Netherlands.
Always think of the little guy in these things, I truly hope that if NOTHING else, those people who prepaid their housing yet it went unbuilt or uncompleted, I hope they finally see the projects finished. They don't need to be punished when they did everything right.
You should view other channels as well, like China Insights. Then you will get a better picture of what is really going on. The CCP treats the citizens like rubbish. My heart aches for them.
China's property market is facing a deep-seated structural crisis, with deserted shopping malls, half-empty apartment complexes, and abandoned construction sites being just a few signs of the sector's struggles. The privatization of property in the 1990s generated an unprecedented boom in China's real estate, which was further fueled by domestic factors such as a tumultuous stock market. Developers would launch a project for pre-sales, get the money from homebuyers, and immediately invest in new land parcels to keep expanding. However, when sales suddenly tumbled, cash stopped coming in, and developers were unable to finish constructing homes previously pre-sold. The build-up of the bubbles went on unchecked until the Chinese government tightened regulations over developers, culminating in the three red lines policy, which limited firms' ability to obtain financing. Since then, dozens of private developers have collapsed, raising questions about the future of the property market and the health of the entire economy. The latest to struggle is Country Garden, once the country's largest developer by sales and a company many saw as too big to fail. The fallen fortunes of Country Garden signal something fundamentally wrong with China's housing market, pushing even formerly healthy developers to the brink of collapse.
I lived in China for three years. As a foreigner from the U.S. Early 2000’s. In Shenzhen. I saw so much building going on. Cranes everywhere in the air. I would also see many condos for sale but there was no real building yet. Just fancy looking showrooms with detailed models of that future building. So most Chinese would buy from just looking at a fancy looking model in the showroom. As one who has bought in Asia (not China), the most important thing to do is wait until the actual building is built! That you can literally see it. Finished. Running. Then buy into it. But most would not do this because they were tempted with the pre-sales prices. Discounted prices before they built the actual building. But then you took the risk of possibly losing your money down the road. Without getting anything. This is what is happening now to many who did this. Why the protests. The riots. Etc.
Chinese economy is very sick. There's no cure. - Only regime change to something like Taiwan 🇹🇼 can help. It's a win-win solution for both China and the world.
Why don't think to finish those projects with help from govt through debt to equity by govt in china. Than start new one. Cause it's more of a liquidity problem then fundamental problem in economic. Demand is there for new property but lacks of funds is pushing on to builders to shut down operations.
After comparing the prices in several videos, I noticed that China's property prices during its peak is 3 times the prices in Jakarta Indonesia (a similarly developing country), no wonder the bubble burst and the prices are decreasing by about 60% or more, almost back to Jakarta levels.😅
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Empty apartments in China is just housing stock. There remains 500 million who do not yet have their own place. What about US empty office spaces ? Are they getting filed.
If the properties had gone up,the value of the currency decreased. That means, labor is making less. It's a gambling market. I liked when interest rates were above 20 percent, we didnt have these problems. See what negative interest rates and fractional reserve banking does to the workers. It squeezes them, I think that's sick thinking.
Why no one mentioned that the fundamental reasons for this huge property bubble in china is because of one SINGLE thing: the monopolization of land supply by the party !
Things like that happen. Let's remember the unification of East and West Germany. "Blossoming landscapes" were promised. The German state pumped a lot of money into East Germany. Construction took place, renovations were carried out and real estate was sold as investments, with guaranteed subsidies for 10 years. The subsidies were intended to fill the gap between the rent levels in West German metropolises and East German metropolises. Around 2005, state subsidies ran out. The result was private bankruptcies and many apartments at spot prices on the real estate market. At that time, you could buy 10-year-old new-build or completely renovated apartments for half or less of the original purchase price. The rents at the time were so low that many property owners who had bought a property as a retirement plan could not keep it. These are the principles of capitalism. And: In every crisis there are opportunities. Anyone who bought property in Leipzig and Dresden at reasonable prices between 2005 and 2007 is now enjoying high increases in value and increased rents.
If you look at the recent G20 meetings in India western countries have been trying to pivot away from China and conduct trade deals with Southeast Asian countries (Indonesia and Vietnam) + India as the Chinese economy begins to stumble.
China's bad production and consumer habits extend here in Canada. Condos seem to grow like mushrooms and Toronto police say "there's not enough space" on the roads. It's pretty well known that "foreign investers" purchase a floor of condos and rent them or leave them vacant. An uber driver from Brazil told me he went rent a condo and the owner had about 10 units. The owner then told him he only rents to Chinese. Thankfully the building standards should be acceptable, but politicians are only interested in money and "growth". The planet can't sustain insane greed. I don't know what's worse, a communist government with too much top-down planning or uncontained greed in capitalism, which allows billionaires to make us slaves.
They are really all the same. I would love for someone to explain to me how a large corporation functions any differently than what we tend to consider a "communist" country. Authoritarian rule with people at the top far removed from the consequences of the decisions they make? Check inability to speak freely or be critical of higher ups to the wider public? check Those on top get rich off the labour of the working class? Check and double check keep everyone so broke and busy they have no time to question or rebel? check Foster an enviroment of gossip and snitching and a lack of transparent communication so you never know who to trust? yup! No elected representation in higher levels, promotion only comes from impressing those above, not taking care of those below? you betchya. I could go on.
How does the banks loaning money to the developers help? If the builders have already spent that money somewhere else, they have no income coming on the buildings they are now completing, so how will they pay the bank back?
The point is to complete the already sold apartments and hand them over to the buyers, thereby preventing large-scale social unrest. Whether the developers get out of it alive is less concerning for the government. The banks are owned by the state, so you could say it is primarily a 'government social stability program'.
@pjacobsen1000 I came to the same conclusion, but in some ways, this is just shifting the pain and damage from the Chinese people to the banks and indirectly, to the value of the Chinese currency. It also is not addressing the problems that allowed this to happen in the first place. /
People were talking about this for over a decade and people hand waved it away saying the cities were filling. We all saw this but netizens said otherwise
Yeah, it looks like the American shopping Centres. Melting down according to the American media since 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010s 2020s 2024s and keep going on and on and on
Where was Bloomberg in 2019 or 2020? The problems in the Chinese real estate market were painfully obvious then however, if I remember correctly, Bloomberg was touting China as the premier place to invest! The tiger that could not be tamed! Why should anyone listen to Bloomberg?
@@HKim0072 I met Mr. Bloomberg in 1986 and played with his then current terminals at Merrill Lynch that year. The TV stuff is a TV show that report still report on financial matters and to help investors. Make decisions. The point of my comment was that back in 2019 and 2020 they were very bullish on the future of China , even though the ghost cities that they talk about now had already been built by that time. I would contend that the Bloomberg TV show is actually not very knowledgeable or useful.
@@wbwarren57 I would concur, but realistically the journalists aren't top tier analysts. Very few of them are digging into the hard data since they don't have skin in the game. Then, they have people on the shows that are pushing their books.
@@HKim0072 Bloomberg is not alone in NOT having top tier analysts. About a year ago the "Economist" magazine put out a video made by their China "experts" in which the analysts were clearly using the "official" CCP published numbers on the economy without mentioning any caveats whatsoever that viewers might want to take those numbers with a South China Sea sized grain of salt.
One man's loss is another man's gain. Back in 2010 in the US, we bought a bank-owned house for $289,000. In 2022, it was worth $1.2 million. China's population size can withstand a housing crisis. The people who are losing their butts are speculators, not everyday people. Lower housing prices are fantastic for new buyers, just like what happened to us back in 2010.
It's literally ordinary citizens, for whom there were few other "reliable" means to invest their savings, who are most affected. Even the shareholders of the large property developers affected will walk away with billions, and have likely long bought foreign assets with the profits to hedge against such domestic problems. The government will do all it can to save the banks. Which will have to include making sure people don't just withdraw and run with their money (which is one of the more common causes of bank collapse). The "everyday people" are literally the only ones who will suffer.
Why try to put lipstick on a pig? Ordinary people are losing a lot of their wealth. Risk aversion is affecting both A: Consumers, leading to deflation B: Investor confidence, leading to fewer job opportunities. And, Xi's foreign policy is practically encouraging foreign investors to look elsewhere too. Obviously it's not "the end", but there's serious economic difficulties baked into all this for Chinese citizens. And obviously the problems will not last forever, but there's basically no way around substantial short to long term pain for people affected. Many millions of people. Just about the only eventuality up for debate is how the gov will spin it. Not how it will fix it.
6:31 - // "80% of the wealth of the average Chinese household is tied up in their homes. When that home price goes down, they feel poorer...." Hold up there. You JUST said their wealth is literally tied up in their homes. So, when home prices go down, they don't just FEEL poorer. They are *literally* poorer. I do not know why there would be a reframing of this as if it's just irrational emotions. These people are getting burned for real here. It's not just feelings.
The reality isn't realised until the property is sold. All it is is something that's probably true. But the perception has immediate effects on economic behaviour.
There is also a lot China money invested in Thailand,so some people who are getting in trouble in China are forced to sell their assets in Thailand to pay back credits in China
Problems of China is .... many... but the biggest one is the CCP one party system, and as the result, roughly a quarter of their GDP is paid to Government workers. Compared to other developed countries this ratio is way higher. So, the private sectors, including domestic and foreign, have to pay not only taxes, but also other "fees" when demanded. Additionally, they stop construction on the way... so that they can pull more money from who orders to build the buildings. Chinese developers and construction companies simply neglect their contracts and promises. And they create unsafe and even non-working buildings, all of those end up with huthey stop construction on the way... so that they can pull more money from who
how does a developer finish 3000 projects? How do you even start to prioritize which to finish? If the company Country Garden decided this was the way to do business they should go under.
I was in China in the 1990s and this was going on. I met some expats working for architecture companies and they said builders were selling entire floors of apartments to single buyers and no one was moving into the apartments. They also said builders were using the cheapest materials possible with zero insulation so the heating and cooling costs were enormous
Go to Chinese shopping malls. There are too few investment cases. Most shopping malls are operating normally and are designed to deceive you fools.😂😂😂
@@semanadelherrero Your account is two weeks old. More CCP propaganda.
Another reason for such oddity is the over-regulation of the stock market in China. Not everyone can trade stocks freely, authorities step in whenever they like, lots of scams in the market over the decade. All these contribute further to the property investment market, as it has seemed to be the "only legal and safe way" to invest for the masses in China. Just wait for this perfect storm to brew even stronger.
This makes no sense. .your saying jibberish ..
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
A lot of valuable nuance here. Thank you Bloomberg Originals.
"Homes are for living in, not for speculating on." - Xi Jinping
I agree. The commodification & financialization of housing is an evil scourge on society.
Real Estate business is up there of the most evil legal business
Only words from comrade Xi, his government actions speaks contrary.
It's just a political slogan to deceive the angry people, because price is too high and most people can't afford housing. Yet their policy is opposite. Fact: China still has ZERO property tax today. This is single most contributing factor that makes housing a perfect speculating investment. No cost to own properties. Keep buying. Rich get richer.
哎。中国房子不用交税。70年到期后自动续费，交几千块就行了。美国要交房产税。30年就相当于买一套
Funny Trudeau in Canada said the same thing!!!
Get unlimited access to Bloomberg.com for $1.99/month for the first 3 months: www.bloomberg.com/subscriptions?in_source=UA-camOriginals
So, I think you just about managed to scratch the surface of the problems. Next time maybe look at who sold the land parcels, why property prices in tier 1 cities are artificially prevented from falling. Who holds the mortgages on the roughly 100 million unfinished apartments bought off plan?
All true. Prices are tumbling in the secong hand market as unseen ever before in China. Some places up to 70% down from purchasing prices just a few years ago (outskirts of Beijing in bordering Hebei province) and Tianjin Binhai New Area 40% down from purchasing prices from 2017. And so on thoughout the country.
@@swingingdaniel The specific locations you pointed out are far away from the city center and are not representative. If readers are interested, you can check the relevant maps by yourself.
Not true. Beijing Wukesong secong hand apartment 2022 asking price 7.5 million, and the offer received was 7.3 million. Sellers did not agree. Now 7.0 Million will not find a buyer. Same for Chaoyang distirict villas. All down by at least 15% and that is about the officially reported number.
@@WellSalt-Studio
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
@@indiasuperclean6969 Fully agree!
Go to sleep quickly and trying to have more dreams.
Indian developers were doing similar models of business, pre sales, using the money to buy to new land, not completing per sold projects.
The Supreme court steps in, created the regulatory framework nationwide. Parliament passed a law to create the independent statutory regulatory authorities in all states. Thats how the Indian real estate industry saved, consumer interest is saved and china like situation is averted.
Smart move from India's Supreme Court to protect the rights of individual consumers, and buyers, or else end up with over a hundred half-finished, skeletal buildings dotting across India. That would later be demolished just like China. A total waste of materials, and resources. At least India has a high-quality demand for building standards, unlike China. Less chance of falling through the floor.
Yeap, CCP regulations are meant to protect state owned banks and not the consumer.
Yeah that is a democracy. Not in China mate. Chairman knows best
@@AnnaCentauriemperor knows everything
That is because it is still under the British monarchy and basically the Indian framework is the same as the UK's... people tried that with china cos the HK was meant to be the seeding. But it didn't happen that way... the stare council stated that HK remains unchanged but it has changed. Now it has gone beyond repair?....
In the long term, more affordable prices for housing are always better. The bubble was going to pop eventually, and it's better to have it deflate now than let it balloon into an even bigger problem later on. Tough luck for all the investors though.
Haha, 70% of household wealth is housing real estate. Ain’t just about investors.
The percentage of worth is realestate and investors are like 80:20 there is no real investors apart from Chinese companies
"In the long term, more affordable prices for housing are always better." Not for China's economy. Without a domestic consumer base, which Xi adamantly refuses to nuture, due to considering domestic credit based consumption as making people "lazy", and 80% of the typical Chinese's wealth being locked up in their home value, you are proposing China falling out of the Middle income trap into the Low-income one.
"tough luck for all the investors though." Those investors are literally every single homeowner, which are all Chinese people or companies.
@@HKim0072yeah, if you own your house. There's like 30 to 40% of people who are renters. Same in the US or UK
@@freemanol Politely, you are misinterpreting the statistic. It's not talking about % of ownership. It's saying that household wealth at the total is 70% housing. The other 30% is stocks, bonds or cash in banks.
The scary thing is that China's real estate investment cycling has been going on for several years now, and the debt continues to grow every time the debt is paid off with debt. And the sky is the limit. It's not just a limited number of real estate developers. Sixty-four major real estate developers, counting those in China, have such insolvencies. Other bright spots in China are not to be found, such as the high-speed rail system, which continues to swell with regular losses, and the semiconductor companies, more than 5,700 of which have gone out of business.
When push comes to shove, Chinese companies will (and already have) simply default on foreign investors FIRST as a stop gap measure.
They are already doing it. ever grande filed for bankruptcy in US, but are paying the debt to chinese banks. 😃
Foreign investors deserve it.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
@@indiasuperclean6969 I feel sorry for you.
@@indiasuperclean6969
its obviously a satire comment
but i would still rather live in india than in big brother dictatorship like china especially as a citizen
so the joke is on you buddy
Totally underselling the pain that is spread out due to the “debt” structure of developers.
Generally speaking, 1/3 of debt is bonds, 1/3 is pre-payments and 1/3 is debt to suppliers.
Sure banks are “protected”, but everyone else is totally f’d.
Also, the magnitude of debt. Just Evergrande and Country Garden have debt of close to 3% of GDP. When Lehman folded, their debt was about 0.5% of GDP.
@@robbrand922 lol, this dude never heard of mark-to-market.
Lehman had $600B in assets on the books. It wasn't an accounting scandal. YOU'VE NEVER TAKEN AN ACCOUNTING CLASS HAVE YOU?
China has an everything problem right now. One goes down, the rest follows
Investment interest in construction will completely collapse. There will be little to no returns.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
There should be more emphasis on the differences between 2008 and this crisis. The huge difference being Chinese banks seem to have much less exposure to the Chinese realestate market compared to the US banks in 2008. US banks made bad investments in derivatives of subprime loans, which led to the first bankruptcies, then panic and bank runs. And these financial instruments were sold to many foreign investors as well, which is what made the recession so global.
The current situation in China, while bad, looks nothing like the 2008 crisis. These are defaults of DEVELOPERS, not financial institutions. The major concern would be a panic and bank runs, but even then the effects would probably be mostly domestic, since foreign exposure to Chinese realestate is nowhere near that of international exposure to US realestate in 2008.
You haven't read up enough... look deeper
Nice to see this counterargument to all the doomers here on YT
@@popcorn6931 Perhaps you could read deeper and tell us how the Americans gave the world the GFC back in 2008? Allow me to drop you a hint, non existent lending controls and CDOs. now get educated.
@@ML-yu5ij that's cgtn narrative... don't let that be your only source. the writing is on the wall.... and years in the making
@@popcorn6931 Once again, the Chinese did not amplify their exposure with derivatives. Writings on your wall of bigotry?
47 industries are upstream and downstream of the real estate industry. It’s affecting everything and everyone there directly or not . Local governments have been cutting salaries to civil servants from office employees, teachers , bus drivers and on and on . 125 thousands teachers have lost their jobs due to demographic downturn and the dominos haven’t all failed yet …
One thing very important not mentioned is that the house buyers have no way out as walking away from their house investments isn’t possible because even if they walk away from their houses they are still liable for the rest of the original loan hence ending up with no house and still a mortgage to pay ! And same with unconstructed houses . The first payment comes when you buy the house NOT when you move in therefore they are stuck paying for a house that might never be built and best case scenario is worth 30 to 50 percent less then they paid for .
1:37 Look at that archival footage from Beijing 1995: New apartment projects selling for 1,600/sqm. 25 years later, those same apartments would likely go for 90,000/sqm; a 5,500% increase. Real estate used to be one of the best, if not the best, investments you could make.
true, back in the "old" days.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
The trick with the greater fool theory is...don't be the fool.
@@indiasuperclean6969 India is a joke.
I love how this is really slapping the older generation’s idea of buying a house no matter how hard it makes your daily life.
It’s great.
This happens when homes become a speculation when they should be a primary need.
In China there are very few ways that people are allowed to invest so they bid up house prices. You will actually get more housing through investment than if it is price controlled. In USSR there was never enough housing. Unfortunately China's government directed a lot of malinvestment and it is has been very inefficient.
Amen!
Starting to happen in Canada with Toronto and Vancouver leading the way home prices are over priced by at least 40%
Why do you lie? The price of the average home in Vancouver has fallen by more than $100,000 over the last year.
I feel like speculation has gotten so bad over here that developers and building homes that are more and more inhospitable - they're smaller, uglier, and more poorly built
It's almost impossible to be solved by any policies from the public sectors, because they are stakeholders . This crisis of property in China is correlated with the local governments' budgets. Even though the central government tried to tighten the policies, the local governments are inertia or lack of will to reduce their budgets and have to bid more land to real estate companies. As a resident, you only hope that the invisible hand can adjust the perperty' price. Even though the land supply has been monopolized by the government, the market mechanism still works on the price and the prices most of properties have falled during past several years.
At the time of the global financial crisis, property development and construction was 10% of gdp. In 2020 China, property development and construction was 25% of gdp. China’s potential bubble burst is much bigger than the US.
Those empty buildings would make for great dystopian sci-fi brutalist architecture for a TV series or movie.
How can someone obtain a mortgage for a propertly that does not exist? This is also the problem of sick financial rules by speculating Banks.
It wasn't a mortgage product then, do you see? It was a form of credit card company that was being used for investment banking and the offshore locations for commercial properties but then this happened. Cos then they took it internally and domestically transformed it, so now they are In deeper sh!ts than anything.
Even worse, the govt still owns the land the building is built on! The developers bid for 70 year leases for the land. So Chinese homeowners might own their flat, but not the land it sits on.
@@gerardp4759 : Then they are basically not "developers"... and if you project the old Imperial model onto this.. and this is whereby their so called "with Chinese characteristics" comes from... So basically.. it should be such that, the indigenous families or family clans that owns those land, and whatever.. only they should be sitting in the State Council. There used to be around 2 groupings. If I recall. One was the people's committee or other, and then the other one was the state council. So when there was all of this "one country, two systems" thing comes into play... It is like... there are no courts. And yet, there is one group of decision makers by consensus.. and then the other one is group of people with legitimacies.... Where does the courts come into play ? It only deals with foreigners then... the courts are for foreign companies and foreigners then. So then how come.. some people inside the PRC today, see a passport as a form of visa only ??? When it is about legitimacies ?
That is how preconstruction works.
Imagine yourself buying a shirt on a lay-away plan. You tell the merchant to hold onto that shirt , and get yourself into a scheduled payment plan. After all, you are Tony Manero, you work at the local hardware store , and you need to upgrade your wardrobe for those Saturday nights . Money is scarce then. This was a very common practice in the US , around the 70’s.
Same with pre construction. Builders acquire or lease land , supposedly secure financing , arrange for architectural services , spend money on promotional marketing , get approved by the zoning board to build, put up a show room, and sign up buyers to a pre payment plan that might cover 30% of the purchased unit retail value, parsed through cinstruction. The rest is to be paid upon delivery and a confirmed issued certificate of occupancy.
The once ready units now need to be completed by buyers on their own nickel . Flooring , lighting fixtures , in-unit HVAC , cabinetry, closets.
Chinese builders operate on other people’s money. They are supposed to secure lines of credit , or get securitized, or have their own cash reserves. Chinese oversight for this stage is done poorly , they are way behind on regulatory and compliance affairs. Other people’s money then become buyers prepayment cash outlays., therefore , builders do not secure for such sources of non buyer originated funds.
I remember riding from Shanghai airport to downtown and seeing brand new buildings everywhere completely empty. Like a ghost town of new buildings.
And why are the prices still on affordable to me? I want to buy there
Most Chinese buildings are made using reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) which has a 30 year lifespan before it comes crashing down.
Just have a rule that nothing can be sold until its finished.
Look at the auxillary construction markets linke with China. Cambodia had a ton of Chinese construction contractors there. Also look at Vietnam, it's having a construction meltdown too.
I hope you guys continue the investigation, it doesn't stop at China!
I'm glad someone noticed this
What a huge waste of natural resources with all those abandoned half built buildings…
Zhou Xiaochuan was the man who blew the China's housing bubble.
[he was Governor of the People's Bank of China from 28 December 2002 to 19 March 2018]
I wish Canada gets some of this and wish to see some real estate gamblers begging in the streets and taking horse tranquilizers!!
Canada got a lot of Chinese investment into real estate. So the bubble bursting might bring down prices.
@@MrMakabar I am from the mortgage industry and Chinese aren't allowed to buy real estate due to foreign buyer ban In Canada.
@@chinadollfmd there are ways around that, if you are in the mortgage industry you should know that, third party realestate, financing, Chinese contracts with Canadian Estate ect it’s not black and white
Noticing here in Australia that units Chinese like are being sold. Some at lower levels when bought. The Chinese inflate their own market.
@@chinadollfmd: Well... they shouldn't be able to do so to begin with ! Cos some of the "money" is basically OUR money from the British commonwealths which fed into China as well. So then they claimed it as their ow public money. And now, they can't use their so called public money to rebuy back the British land ! Sorry.. but that is ridiculous to begin with !
What do people think they are doing ? Playing mah jong ! Until one gets sick and take them down cos they've not slept for days and days ???
their buildings look a lot like prisons
6:51 everytime this guy shows up😂😂😂
This has been going on for years. They have done these to themselves.
Excelentes documentales, excelentes
Thanks...Great in-depth review!! 👍
When people are buying homes as an investment rather than as a shelter or to even rent it out. That’s obviously going to lead to a bubble. It’s going to be a long and painful collapse of home prices but that will probably reshuffle the ownership of homes from old to young folks. I suspect the disposable income will be nothing like it was the past decade.
So much for the pipe dream of China becoming a superpower, 🤣
Great so very informative
Thank you
Wow, I can't believe I was feeling nostalgic for those 90's footage of china. And I was only there in '98 as a child and can hardly remember anything too. But in all the times I have been back since, and constantly seeing empty high rises and buildings... yeah I saw this coming years away. The last time I went back and saw that it got even more empty buildings, I advised all of my family members to not buy anything and try to sell it at the next opportunity unless they were actually going to live in the buildings (and not speculate).
Too bad they didn't want to believe the words of an American guy who said something negative about their economy.
I hope that in those 5 years before the bust, he did something, but I haven't heard from one of my uncles since then.
As always... they will try to blame everything on the CIA for their mess
It isnt just about the housing market. The US and other countries are looking elswhere for manufacturing. China's in for hard times.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
China will be fine. Just worry about your own country.
So informative..👍
Great video. Just subscribed !
China has 400 million middle-income families, and putting their money in banks that pay low-interest rates doesn't make sense. Buy property is the best. Many rent out their properties, and wait it out for their children to take over their parent property. China cannot afford to wait until there is a demand and then start building the houses. This scenario happened in Singapore during the late 70s and early 80s when the government built much public housing but not many applicants. A 4-room flat that cost 24K in 1981 and is now worth more than SDG $500K.
My understanding is Singapore actually sold those properties to working families at the time. They didn't simply exist to be unaffordable uninhabited speculative assets, as is the case in China
@@darthbumblebee7310 Although China has lifted up about 900 million citizens out of the poverty line, those people are not rich, but can live comfortably especially for those living in a third or fourth tier city due to lower inflations. Not a single nation on this planet may not experience higher inflations as they progressed from third to developing, and finally first World nations. As a nation run by a world class government, for the people, by the people of the people, need to distribute the nation's wealth of all its people is no easy task, but the CPC government did it. Of course often there are a small number of "sour grapes" from other nations would like to throw stones at China. China built houses made of bricks and cement, and not glass houses.
if even 1/3 of the unfinished housing projects are finished I will be amazed.
CCP is so obsessed with USA they forgot to focus on their own leaky ship that is now sinking 😂
ironic coming from the USA
1:08 - "There was this fundamental belief that property price's could only go up". Yes, if looking at it in the "long" term (10-30 years). Japan in late 1980s and USA in late 2000s, show that there can be bust. Heck, adjusted for inflation - Japan's property price is still not as high as the bubble back then. Also 2:38 - that's the foundation of a Ponzi Scheme.
American media has been replaying this story since the early 2000s. Long story short is capital and manpower is invested into infrastructure when the timing is right. Concrete does not spoil. All the prior cities that were reported on eventually filled up as demand increased.
The life of concrete is variable depending on quality ingredients and soil/foundation preparation. It certainly can last a very long time when done properly.
South China Post is also playing similar stories. It isn't just American media. And the demand is there for the homes people have already paid for. There shouldn't need to be additional demand for a building that was pre-sold and never completed.
“Concrete Cancer” is a thing. It can most definitely “spoil.” Otherwise we would be refurbishing old buildings indefinitely instead of tearing them
down to build replacements on-site.
@@Ryan_Christopher a building is not going to be unusable within a few years or even a decade. these are the timelines. two of the first of these stories were for the cities was in 2011ish and i remember it was about zhengzhou, henan province. Google what Zhengzhou looks like now that it has filled up.
China's population was heavily based on the coast. Overcrowded urban areas. The idea, I'm guessing, is to improve infrastructure inland, in suburbs and border areas to promote expansion.
@@kelli_1652We are talking two things. Im talking about "ghost cities", you are talking about developers not fulfilling their contractual obligation
This was a simple explanation, Thanks.
Unfortunately it seems even if your lucky enough to get the condo you paid for completed it will fall apart in five years....money obviously does not buy quality
At this point I’m convinced that if China had a financial crisis the United States would provide a bailout 😂
USA is already an actual extension of China to begin with ! How did NYC saved itself from the first depression ? It was the Taiwanese that came along and invested in them.... and raised the investment games.. and then later on... the West invested into SE Asia as well... and the the tech bubble thing came.. and went... and now morphed... Morphed into a nightmare more like.
I am very certain that, a lot of money were stolen during those morphing periods... Really. I accept that it has done so.
@@MeiinUKTaiwan is not China, its a soverieign country
@@maokuscabe816 US and most of the world does not recognize Taiwan as a country, so you're wrong here. Facts are facts.
@@jukio02what a joke. If the us doesn’t recognize Taiwan as an independent state then why they always be protecting Taiwan from china?
I'm an idiot and I could have solved the housing crisis a decade ago.
1- true escrow accounts. None of this double dipping using prepayments as extra leverage
2- RE annual tax. The perverse incentives for local governments to keep selling land at higher prices would be mitigated somewhat. Housing costs soared because...local government were charging higher prices!
Escrow would not work in China. The scoundrels would make those deposits disappear or dip into funds. China is the land of Guanxin. Lots of shady characters doing patronage. The poor investor would’ve gotten swindled.
Annual income taxes. Your ever so competent social credit savvy central and provincial governments are riddled with corruption.
Let’s face it. China has corruption and graft running from top down throughout the country in every sphere and province. It takes more than sound leadership to reverse China’s fortunes , Singapore style. It takes compromise from the bottom up and the top down. Like the Netherlands.
Chinese real estate has been collapsing for more than 15 years now. Maybe 15 years from now it will be even worse.
ccp wumao!
ccp wumao rat!
Now finally BBG also talks about the OBVIOUS. Other channels have done for at least a year.
Always think of the little guy in these things, I truly hope that if NOTHING else, those people who prepaid their housing yet it went unbuilt or uncompleted, I hope they finally see the projects finished. They don't need to be punished when they did everything right.
Yes about a million people in China stuck with unfinished home.
You should view other channels as well, like China Insights. Then you will get a better picture of what is really going on. The CCP treats the citizens like rubbish. My heart aches for them.
@@dustintacohands1107Many more than a million.
@@marieslabbert6009 that just the number I heard that have unfinished house that won’t be finished now
@@marieslabbert6009you are trapping him to propaganda!
China's property market is facing a deep-seated structural crisis, with deserted shopping malls, half-empty apartment complexes, and abandoned construction sites being just a few signs of the sector's struggles. The privatization of property in the 1990s generated an unprecedented boom in China's real estate, which was further fueled by domestic factors such as a tumultuous stock market. Developers would launch a project for pre-sales, get the money from homebuyers, and immediately invest in new land parcels to keep expanding. However, when sales suddenly tumbled, cash stopped coming in, and developers were unable to finish constructing homes previously pre-sold. The build-up of the bubbles went on unchecked until the Chinese government tightened regulations over developers, culminating in the three red lines policy, which limited firms' ability to obtain financing. Since then, dozens of private developers have collapsed, raising questions about the future of the property market and the health of the entire economy. The latest to struggle is Country Garden, once the country's largest developer by sales and a company many saw as too big to fail. The fallen fortunes of Country Garden signal something fundamentally wrong with China's housing market, pushing even formerly healthy developers to the brink of collapse.
Despite all these signs there are still many china supporters on the waiting for china to overtake the US economy.
Bloomberg originals you're full of it.The information here is unfounded.
Nothing that is not sustainable should be allowed to become an investment object.
2:34 It's always funny seeing people describe ponzi schemes without calling them ponzi schemes.
same thing happens in america
home is for living. the real "meltdown" was in Maui (like the Grenfell Tower fire)
ccp wumao rat!
I lived in China for three years. As a foreigner from the U.S. Early 2000’s. In Shenzhen. I saw so much building going on. Cranes everywhere in the air. I would also see many condos for sale but there was no real building yet. Just fancy looking showrooms with detailed models of that future building. So most Chinese would buy from just looking at a fancy looking model in the showroom. As one who has bought in Asia (not China), the most important thing to do is wait until the actual building is built! That you can literally see it. Finished. Running. Then buy into it. But most would not do this because they were tempted with the pre-sales prices. Discounted prices before they built the actual building. But then you took the risk of possibly losing your money down the road. Without getting anything. This is what is happening now to many who did this. Why the protests. The riots. Etc.
This is a cautionary tale for everyone.
Great video
if property not melted down, GCD will meltdown. Flourishing property market will result more people sleep in car or camping on road side in the city.
In hk.buying apartment for investment . It automatically hit by massive taxation.
There’s no crisis… just use a grey filter and took some unfinished building, fabric some, find some extreme examples and make the story.
据说五毛党员还没失业
Chinese economy is very sick. There's no cure.
- Only regime change to something like Taiwan 🇹🇼 can help.
It's a win-win solution for both China and the world.
Why don't think to finish those projects with help from govt through debt to equity by govt in china.
Than start new one.
Cause it's more of a liquidity problem then fundamental problem in economic.
Demand is there for new property but lacks of funds is pushing on to builders to shut down operations.
When year 2008 USA housing bubble began, Government bail out bank.
Right now, China not bail out bank, but take over share as state company.
After comparing the prices in several videos, I noticed that China's property prices during its peak is 3 times the prices in Jakarta Indonesia (a similarly developing country), no wonder the bubble burst and the prices are decreasing by about 60% or more, almost back to Jakarta levels.😅
Is this another one of those "China Collapse in 30 days" video?
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Empty apartments in China is just housing stock. There remains 500 million who do not yet have their own place.
What about US empty office spaces ? Are they getting filed.
If the properties had gone up,the value of the currency decreased. That means, labor is making less. It's a gambling market. I liked when interest rates were above 20 percent, we didnt have these problems. See what negative interest rates and fractional reserve banking does to the workers. It squeezes them, I think that's sick thinking.
Why no one mentioned that the fundamental reasons for this huge property bubble in china is because of one SINGLE thing: the monopolization of land supply by the party !
Very very evil communism. Everything is state owned, but at the end of day it’s THEY owned
Das ist einfach die Unfähigkeit bestimmte Baulöwen die kommt überall in der vor, ist aber nicht die schuld von KCCP
Great report. India's major cities future.
Well opposite problem here in the US.. makes you understand how there is a balance that is very delicate
Things like that happen. Let's remember the unification of East and West Germany. "Blossoming landscapes" were promised. The German state pumped a lot of money into East Germany. Construction took place, renovations were carried out and real estate was sold as investments, with guaranteed subsidies for 10 years. The subsidies were intended to fill the gap between the rent levels in West German metropolises and East German metropolises.
Around 2005, state subsidies ran out. The result was private bankruptcies and many apartments at spot prices on the real estate market. At that time, you could buy 10-year-old new-build or completely renovated apartments for half or less of the original purchase price. The rents at the time were so low that many property owners who had bought a property as a retirement plan could not keep it.
These are the principles of capitalism. And: In every crisis there are opportunities. Anyone who bought property in Leipzig and Dresden at reasonable prices between 2005 and 2007 is now enjoying high increases in value and increased rents.
Chinese ghost city they should make a post apocalyptic movie in china .
If you look at the recent G20 meetings in India western countries have been trying to pivot away from China and conduct trade deals with Southeast Asian countries (Indonesia and Vietnam) + India as the Chinese economy begins to stumble.
China's bad production and consumer habits extend here in Canada. Condos seem to grow like mushrooms and Toronto police say "there's not enough space" on the roads. It's pretty well known that "foreign investers" purchase a floor of condos and rent them or leave them vacant. An uber driver from Brazil told me he went rent a condo and the owner had about 10 units. The owner then told him he only rents to Chinese. Thankfully the building standards should be acceptable, but politicians are only interested in money and "growth". The planet can't sustain insane greed. I don't know what's worse, a communist government with too much top-down planning or uncontained greed in capitalism, which allows billionaires to make us slaves.
They are really all the same.
I would love for someone to explain to me how a large corporation functions any differently than what we tend to consider a "communist" country.
Authoritarian rule with people at the top far removed from the consequences of the decisions they make? Check
inability to speak freely or be critical of higher ups to the wider public? check
Those on top get rich off the labour of the working class? Check and double check
keep everyone so broke and busy they have no time to question or rebel? check
Foster an enviroment of gossip and snitching and a lack of transparent communication so you never know who to trust? yup!
No elected representation in higher levels, promotion only comes from impressing those above, not taking care of those below? you betchya.
I could go on.
How does the banks loaning money to the developers help? If the builders have already spent that money somewhere else, they have no income coming on the buildings they are now completing, so how will they pay the bank back?
The point is to complete the already sold apartments and hand them over to the buyers, thereby preventing large-scale social unrest. Whether the developers get out of it alive is less concerning for the government. The banks are owned by the state, so you could say it is primarily a 'government social stability program'.
@pjacobsen1000 I came to the same conclusion, but in some ways, this is just shifting the pain and damage from the Chinese people to the banks and indirectly, to the value of the Chinese currency. It also is not addressing the problems that allowed this to happen in the first place. /
@@stephanledford9792 I agree.
People were talking about this for over a decade and people hand waved it away saying the cities were filling. We all saw this but netizens said otherwise
They need to balance competing economic forces as best they can: Take one from column A, one from column B.
Yeah, it looks like the American shopping Centres.
Melting down according to the American media since 1980s 1990s
2000s 2010s 2020s 2024s and keep going on and on and on
the quality of construction, of lack of there in, is absolutely shocking; these building are designed to last 20 years -- max
Where was Bloomberg in 2019 or 2020? The problems in the Chinese real estate market were painfully obvious then however, if I remember correctly, Bloomberg was touting China as the premier place to invest! The tiger that could not be tamed! Why should anyone listen to Bloomberg?
Do you realize that Bloomberg is a computer terminal that provides information?
The TV stuff is just a sideshow.
@@HKim0072
I met Mr. Bloomberg in 1986 and played with his then current terminals at Merrill Lynch that year. The TV stuff is a TV show that report still report on financial matters and to help investors. Make decisions. The point of my comment was that back in 2019 and 2020 they were very bullish on the future of China , even though the ghost cities that they talk about now had already been built by that time. I would contend that the Bloomberg TV show is actually not very knowledgeable or useful.
@@wbwarren57 I would concur, but realistically the journalists aren't top tier analysts. Very few of them are digging into the hard data since they don't have skin in the game.
Then, they have people on the shows that are pushing their books.
@@HKim0072
Bloomberg is not alone in NOT having top tier analysts. About a year ago the "Economist" magazine put out a video made by their China "experts" in which the analysts were clearly using the "official" CCP published numbers on the economy without mentioning any caveats whatsoever that viewers might want to take those numbers with a South China Sea sized grain of salt.
One man's loss is another man's gain. Back in 2010 in the US, we bought a bank-owned house for $289,000. In 2022, it was worth $1.2 million. China's population size can withstand a housing crisis. The people who are losing their butts are speculators, not everyday people. Lower housing prices are fantastic for new buyers, just like what happened to us back in 2010.
Agree. News media tend to exaggerate things as if it were the end of the day.
It's literally ordinary citizens, for whom there were few other "reliable" means to invest their savings, who are most affected. Even the shareholders of the large property developers affected will walk away with billions, and have likely long bought foreign assets with the profits to hedge against such domestic problems. The government will do all it can to save the banks. Which will have to include making sure people don't just withdraw and run with their money (which is one of the more common causes of bank collapse). The "everyday people" are literally the only ones who will suffer.
Why try to put lipstick on a pig? Ordinary people are losing a lot of their wealth. Risk aversion is affecting both A: Consumers, leading to deflation B: Investor confidence, leading to fewer job opportunities. And, Xi's foreign policy is practically encouraging foreign investors to look elsewhere too.
Obviously it's not "the end", but there's serious economic difficulties baked into all this for Chinese citizens. And obviously the problems will not last forever, but there's basically no way around substantial short to long term pain for people affected. Many millions of people. Just about the only eventuality up for debate is how the gov will spin it. Not how it will fix it.
China needs a new leader!
6:31 - // "80% of the wealth of the average Chinese household is tied up in their homes. When that home price goes down, they feel poorer...."
Hold up there.
You JUST said their wealth is literally tied up in their homes.
So, when home prices go down, they don't just FEEL poorer. They are *literally* poorer.
I do not know why there would be a reframing of this as if it's just irrational emotions. These people are getting burned for real here. It's not just feelings.
The reality isn't realised until the property is sold. All it is is something that's probably true.
But the perception has immediate effects on economic behaviour.
So, it was a missive Ponzy Scheme.
I didn’t think I would see this bubble burst in my lifetime but here we are. Another country failed to outrun economics.
thank goodness
so why do i have to worry about my personal carbon footprint again? biggest polluters in the world!
Chinese developers.... yes but what is there to develop? When everything has already been developed
It is like tax cuts, too much government subsidies provide diminishing benefits.
And still their kids are not dying in schools 😂😂😂😂.
There is also a lot China money invested in Thailand,so some people who are getting in trouble in China are forced to sell their assets in Thailand to pay back credits in China
I hope so!, we want them out of NZ as well!
8:50 welding rebar... a recipe for failure
Problems of China is .... many... but the biggest one is the CCP one party system, and as the result, roughly a quarter of their GDP is paid to Government workers. Compared to other developed countries this ratio is way higher. So, the private sectors, including domestic and foreign, have to pay not only taxes, but also other "fees" when demanded. Additionally, they stop construction on the way... so that they can pull more money from who orders to build the buildings. Chinese developers and construction companies simply neglect their contracts and promises. And they create unsafe and even non-working buildings, all of those end up with huthey stop construction on the way... so that they can pull more money from who
what kind of idt is this? 🤣
You should go to China and tell the CPC this, you're a genius!
Buying house has become the biggest meme in China.
I have heard this story many times since the 90s.
how does a developer finish 3000 projects? How do you even start to prioritize which to finish? If the company Country Garden decided this was the way to do business they should go under.