@@kincaidwolf5184 Get your facts right mate the version the corries are singing is the 1791 Robert Burns version, the version you are talking about predates that.
@@alastair6356 Ahh Yes Robert Burns the famous anti Jacobite. Listen to his lyrics "Your fautes I will proclaim, Your doctrines I maun blame - you shall hear, you shall hear! Your doctrines I maun blame - you shall hear" i guess you don't understand Scots.
@@kincaidwolf5184 I think you suffer from the right man syndrome, It is an anti war song however you can make of it whatever you want but dont turn in into Rule Britannia.
@@alastair6356 It's explicitly an anti-Jacobite song, insulting the rebellion and the ideology behind Catholic restoration and the culture of the Highland clans. It's nothing to do with Rule Britannia but absolutely everything to do with Scots (lowlanders) crushing the Highland clans. Robert Burns was absolutely a Rule Britannia character. It was of course the famous Scot James Thomson who wrote Rule Britannia.
@@hiddenknowledge2012 If you want to be pedantic, the 'real' languages of Scotland were Pictish and a dialect of Old Welsh. But, yeah, I wish Gaidhlig was properly taught and made to be the only language of, along with Scots, maybe.
Love all Scottish songs. Bought a book of Roberts Burns songs and poems. In my time, 70s, sang a few folk songs with friends at a folk club. We wernee that bad... Happy Christmas to all my friends and dear family in Scotland. X
Stuff the polotics i'll be 60 this year and and have every type or gig from Pink Floyd to the Royal Philharmonic and have o say the nihjt I saw thr Corries was one of the best gigs i've eer seen Eddie
The worlds first anti-war song...written 200 years before vietnam..." what haunts a parents life is bloody war!".....As the father of 2 sons how true is that verse....... the immortal legend that is Rabbie Burns.
This song reminds me of being in the US Marines. My friend was shot from a living room in Iraq by a man with a 5 foot high mounted anti aircraft gun he had mounted in his living room. Thru the air came a huge quick rush of air as I heard the explosion. My heart flipped over it felt like. The the rounds came in fast repetition to my ears. He was gone, they had to identify him by his dental records.
This song harbours religious tension and separatist sentiments being from Scotland myself. Whether I believe in the movement or not, this is our historical legacy and a reminder of that time. It comes in handy when you need to ground yourself within the political world and it helps you understand why things remain so bitter - we can hold a grudge - must be in our DNA from the time we were living in clans. Scotland and Northern Ireland is the only place we have on-going religious bigotry and violence on an organised level in the western world, its kind of embarrassing, if you remember the origins of America was based on religious tolerance, unfortunately, 400 years later we still see the effects of the Reformation and the times that followed with King Billy. Much of our Catholic population lives in poverty to this day, both sides are living in poverty of course but its more prevalent among the former. Anyway, you are very courageous, Americans protect the free world and that means me too. Thanks for your input on the song. Its really interesting you said that. Gives a neutral glimpse at how this song impacts people. Take care buddy.
@@RenaissanceMan29 Americans protect the free world by invading countries that happen to have oil and don't do what the US says. If the US gov't really wanted to put an end to dictatorship, then they wouldn't have allied themselves with Saudi Arabia, a country with a government which only recently was so generous as to allow women to drive cars. In 1956 MI6 and the CIA overthrew the democratic Iranian gov't to replace it with a monarchy. The PM Muhammad Mosaddegh was a champion of liberal democracy but he wanted to nationalise BP Oil in Iran, so democracy in Iran ended for good. (The US gov't literally admitted to doing this in 2013 by the way). This is only one of a slew of coups and armed invasions of sovereign democratic countries that the US participated in. If the US really supported freedom then why does it topple democracies and support dictatorships?
@@huxleyleodwalding5751 I get your concerns, but I hope you understand, this is America we are talking about, and it includes a vast array of people with different objectives. The people who operate with Anthony Blinken and the Neo-Liberal or Neo-Conservaties, those are the people to watch out for and they are voted into power with lies. If America does something that's bad, then the whole world is watching but remember, they toppled Russian backed Corrupt Democracies.
Mate I hope you are alright and dealing with this tragedy in the right way. I disagree with the fact that we as a civilisation fought this war but absolutely respect everyone (you especially) who fought in it. Good luck to you!
"and leave the man undone to his fate" - refers to Bonnie Prince Charlie - who was undone by the loss of the Stuart Crown. Burns says the Highland Clans should leave him to his own fate and not go to war to save him
Burns was a lowlander and had no sense of loyalty. The Stewarts were the rightful kings of Scotland and the English establish had no business removing them from the throne, certainly not from the Scots throne.
@@andyallan2909 are you high or just ignorant of Burns and lowlands in general? Im from Inverness before ye talk pish . Blind loyalty is not a good virtue .Burns was proStewart if you had half a clue
Thanks for sharing your music I just joined your community of friends looking forward to your uploads, I look forward to hearing from you thank you Ken
i am from east berlin. ye jacobites, yes that was also us. this could have been a wonderful rebel song in november 1989. - we did not know it at the time. but this year is 25 years fall of the berlin wall and this song still expresses of what we felt when the wall came down. what is right and what is wrong by the law. ye jacobites my name - your doctrines i'm unblame ! so magnetic. so strong. so wonderful. thank you corries.
This is not a Rebel song in fact the poem could easily have been titled " The Rant Against The Cause !" Robert Burns is telling the Jacobites to listen to him .Their FAULTS he will proclaim and their doctrines he felt to BLAME . Burns also thought the Jacobites should have made the changes by the LAW . He goes on to say he thought the Jacobites should have left the State alone with their schemes and plots ..He also wonders why the Jacobites cause is seen as HEROIC. He didn't see it this way. He seems to be writing about his total disgust with the Jacobian cause and every thing they stood for. Above is a small amount of what all he did say .So please read the poem first then listen to the song . I think you will agree ,
@rossmcl177 The Jacobite uprising was a British Civil War, the Jacobites were Catholics who wanted the Stewarts as the rulers of a cathloc Britain but the Government were the Supporters of the Protestant Britian
My Mother was born in Perth, Scotland. She emigrated to Canada and eventually Detroit. I have heard from my youth that according to the Scottish folk the Stuarts held the crown. Well history proves that a fraction group of individuals as were the Scots under the Jacobite Revolution cannot control anything, and unfortunately they lost. If you want to see it happening again look at the USA, we are fractioned beyond repair. And while we were noble in the wars of the 1940's those folks are gone. and just like the Jacobites I fear we will succumb to individual pride and personal vindication. God help me that I am wrong
Canada is fracturing too, and it’s because of one person. The most prideful and arrogant man in the country. Trudeau I call by name, Lend and ear, lend and ear! Trudeau I call by name, lend an ear! Trudeau I call by name, Your faults I will proclaim, Your Actions I defame, You will hear, you will hear, Your actions I defame, You will hear! “Leave the man undone to his fate.” 🇨🇦🍁❤️✌️🙏
That's Celtic obscurantism at its its finest. The term "Celtic" applies to genetic markers that half of Europe share. Just say that highland Scots, and the Irish are both descended from the same group of Gaels/Scotti. Just leave the silly Celtic pish out. Lowland Scots are also decened from the Gaels/Scotti by the way. How do you think Scotland came to be? The Gaels/Scotti, and the Picts conquered the Angles, Saxons, Friesian's, and the Brythonic settlers. All these groups came together to create lowland Scots. South-Western Lowlander's, and folk from Fife even spoke Gaelic for centuries.
Okay, just stop for a second. The Kingdom of Scotland was founded by Cinaed Mac Ailpin, former King of Dal Riada and King of the Picts. he united the two into the Kingdom of Alba and over the centuries the two cultures merged into Scots' Gaelic "Brythonic Settlers" First off, the Brythonics had settled in the land they would call "Alt Cluit" and "Gododdin" before the Gaels had settled Dal Riada. The Picts at that point were just doing their own thing and infighting. The Brythonic kingdoms were destroyed in the region by the Kingdom of Northumbria, which in turn was destroyed by a man who I can't remember the name of whilst one of his relatives, Ivar the Boneless, fell upon the Kingdom of Alt Cluit that revolted from Northumbria (Basically the region that was Carrick, Strathclyde and Galloway), Ivar also conquered the Kingdom of Dal Riada and set up shop there. Eventually, Scottish culture came to those regions over time and FINALLY the norse conquered regions were absorbed into Scotland however by that point we'd lost Carlisle and England had conquered over half of Ireland and Wales. I skipped out a hell of a lot of history but you get the gist. The Gaelic language was predominant in the Lowlands until 1400 I believe, where the language lost a lot of it's following and was eventually phased out in law and administration by 1450.
***** What? Alba (Gaels and Picts) conquered Strathclyde (Brythonic settlers) and Northumbria ( Angle, Saxon, and Fresian settlers). All three became Scotland. It was Lowland Scots who were responsible for repelling England, and they were just as Saxon as the English were. Keep your Celtic obscurantism to yourself, Scots want none of it.
+Patrick J III McGuigan Celtic obscurantism at it's finest. You're either an ignorant yank, or an Irishman with with an inferiority complex. If you're Welsh don't even bother commenting, you're irrelevant.
The song is telling a story! Most traditional Irish and Scottish songs are recounting historical events that the English don't wish to be reminded of. Its in the past you say so move on! So was WW1 and 2 and yet your happy to relive those historical events. You don't like hearing songs that recount your black deeds..
Confusing comments on this video. The lyrics quite clearly are about maintaining the status quo because the cost of rebelling is too great and ít falls on everyone, not just those culpable. On the other hand, lots of people here are calling for independence. I want independence too, but let's not misunderstand the song!
Not to mention the fact that Jacobites are, by definition, absolute monarchists. I'd rather live in a republican Britain than a absolutist Scotland, though right now we obviously have neither.
There's nothing like coming upon a wonderful historical song and seeing it offer a home for bigotry. I'm English and I'm ashamed of much of what was done by the English in the past; similarly, it's not all innocence and romantic ideals amongst those the English 'suppressed'. One thing is most definitely in common - all these issues are those of the past and are only brought to the surface by those who are unhappy with peace. Live and let live and let religious and nationalist bigotry die.
Now that's weird - I was just thinking of this song, didn't write anything on my computer, and now it is on my recommended. Does YT have the capability to read my thoughts?
Great song and nobody does it better than the Corries, but I'd just like to correct the frequently held erroneous belief that the Jacobites were all Scots, because the truth is that there were many English Catholics who wanted to see a return of the Catholic Stuarts to the British throne, while the greater majority of lowland Scots were in favour of maintaining the Protestant Hanoverian succession.
viciouswolf1111 The lowlands were never dedicated to Scotland. They had their "wee bit grund" and the fear of losing that made them take the part of the London government.
@ogreoh I kind of agree with you there. As I said pox on both their houses. Just because someone points out 17thC Stuart flaws it doesn't mean they don't recognise 18thC Hanovarian flaws.
@USAsoldier1955 It is because the actual genetical input from these later invasions is surprisingly very low......but this depends on the area. Some parts of Western Wales and Western Ireland can have 95-98% of population being majority iberian 'pre celtic' settlers (celtic being an evolved european culture) with several later celtic invasions bringing their own genetic tint to the proceedings :D, and this can very between person to person, the actual difference is small however just potent
The Jacobites probably would not recognise the modern United Kingdom (neither would the 'Hanoverians') but they would surely never recognise the multicultural republican "independent" Scotland the SNP pushes for.
@@zoomer_zveno i thought the Hanoverians came to the throne by dint of a scottish line of succession, so they were closer to being scottish than english?
Whereabouts in the Highlands? I'm fae Dunbar in East Lothian myself. Sorry if I was a bit condescending, but the Welsh have never given up. Look at Owain Glyndwr for example.
@3tangle3 There is. "Erin Go Brach - the Scottish version." "Johnny Cope, Ar ye wakin' yet", and many more, check Battlefield Band, Tannhill Weavers and Brian McNeill (my favorite)
@akropiss well we are all closer to the original settler who were pre celtic,,,,,but as a welsh geneticist I agree with your sentiments....dont forget the welsh includes the cornish and strathclyde britons/cumbrians. Whereever you are from its not important its the CULTURE!! and its been totally pushed back to these islands fringes ignored during the empire days..and still is to an extent
@ogreoh "James II strived for a kingdom with the peace to allow religions to develop" Actually James oppressed the Presbyterians in Scotland whilst his brother was on the throne and continued to do so whilst in office. He was eventually persuaded to moderate slightly but the idea that he wanted complete toleration for everyone is bunkum!
Scots killing Scots over whether a Catholic of Protestant should rule the British (English, Scottish and Irish) Kingdom. This song mocks the Catholics.
To the best of my knowledge they fought on the Jacobite's side, I have not researched or heard otherwise. Also, there is an ancestry connection with John O'Sullivan who was also on the Jacobite side. But in truth, the way I choose to view the fight as one for freedom. Though, as complicated as the politics were then; others may view it very differently.
A couple of my ancestors were transported to the American colonies for being Jacobites. One of my 2nd great grandmothers was a Stewart, and I have autosomal dna matches to the royal House of Stewart. Not that that makes me anything great, but it's cool anyway.
I'm not sure... I think Burns' version of this song is highly critical of "Jacobites by name", by which he means people who enjoyed calling themselves Jacobites but in fact did nothing to support that cause, in other words "Jacobites in name only".
I actually randomly turned on my turntable on the Thursday of the Referendum and I had Live At The Lyceum on from a few weeks before, and it was at this very song. Everyone thought it was very apropos. I'm in America for reference, and argued with the other local ancestrally scots-irish folk about how we'd all vote if we were there.
I'd think of all the good reasons to vote no, then I'd think that I have seen Culloden with my own eyes, and the feeling of death that hangs over the place, and I'd maybe flip a coin.
Edward also demanded not to be buried until Scotland was conquered, and he is yet to be buried. Your hero failed his ultimate goal a united Britain in his lifetime.
Iam a true nationalisy, ans=d agree Charlie wanted the English throne for himself, and used the brave highlanders to gt it, remember he lived in France all of his life, and had not a lot of alegience to SCOTLAND.
I was thinking of Soutie or Sout Piel, which refers to the idea that British South Africans are associated with both Britain & South Africa & are therefore affected by the ocean in the middle (I won't translate it because it's a wee bit rude, but it's actually very similar to the English anyway). I don't really know if it's in common currency these days.
oil is a minor asset and dont you know it ran out in the ninties or so we were led to believe but gues what we are still discovering new fields but apart from that the only question is would you rather be shafted by an english politition or scottish one
@ashbannor Quite so. The original source song Burns based this on is vehemently anti-Jacobite. Burns tones it down making it more anti-war than anti-Jacobite. Though he still blames them for the conflict in it. "You Jacobites by name....your faults I will proclaim....your doctrines I will blame...you shall hear"
@TheComradeRoss not exactly tbh, they weren't all cathlics many of them wanted the stuart family bck on the throne, or were forced to fight by clan chiefs
Billy Bragg does a good Thatcherite version. Love the history of this song... relevant for generation after generation. Yea Patriots ya name Yea Patriots ya name
@ColdMattyCross Rabbie Burns wrote this poem. He was jacobite. The 'Your fautes I will proclaim/Your doctrines I maun blame' are reference to the failures of the rebellion (Culloden) and not condemnation of the jacobites. It may not be a song that praises the jacobites but it definitely isn't an anti-jacobite song.
@USAsoldier1955 King Billy fought against the (mostly Catholic and re enforced by Scots Highlanders) Jacobites. Read up on the siege of Derry 1689 I think that was mostly Scots Jacobites against King Billy's orangemen backed by the dutch navy.
i get your point, but just because the English were willing to massacre, starve and displace any number of people necessary, doesn't mean submission is the right course to take. Look what happened to the Gaels after they gave up their armies.
@danonutube1 I don't know why the other poster brought the law into it. There is nothing unlawful or unconstitutional about the Nats holding an independence referendum - or people debating it. The UK govt has conceded that!
Burns’ believed his own grandfather and possibly his father to be Jacobites. The air of the song was a Jacobite tune, by changing the words preserved the melody. There’s also an interpretation of the song as coming from the perspective of an old Jacobite who seen the horror of the first two rebellions and didn’t want to see the next generation go through the same thing
Really miss these guys. So musical.
As far as I know Ronnie Browne still performs on his own since Roy Williamson has passed away a few years ago .
I love this kind of music. It is real, not digitized, folk style, no electric instruments. Real music.
I would have loved to have seen this live.Shivers down the back of my spine👊👊👍👍
Many years ago, whilst at secondary school (early 1970s, before 1973) I saw them in London. Still remember it with great pleasure.
Great to hear the old songs my dad use to listen to on a Sunday afternoon, dreaming of freedom. Soar Alba our time will come.
You realise this song is about Loyalty to the British monarchy? Amd about crushing the Highlanders? I guess you aren't Scottish
@@kincaidwolf5184 Get your facts right mate the version the corries are singing is the 1791 Robert Burns version, the version you are talking about predates that.
@@alastair6356 Ahh Yes Robert Burns the famous anti Jacobite. Listen to his lyrics "Your fautes I will proclaim,
Your doctrines I maun blame - you shall hear, you shall hear!
Your doctrines I maun blame - you shall hear" i guess you don't understand Scots.
@@kincaidwolf5184 I think you suffer from the right man syndrome, It is an anti war song however you can make of it whatever you want but dont turn in into Rule Britannia.
@@alastair6356 It's explicitly an anti-Jacobite song, insulting the rebellion and the ideology behind Catholic restoration and the culture of the Highland clans. It's nothing to do with Rule Britannia but absolutely everything to do with Scots (lowlanders) crushing the Highland clans. Robert Burns was absolutely a Rule Britannia character. It was of course the famous Scot James Thomson who wrote Rule Britannia.
Scots dialect is bloody awesome. It's a cultural treasure in the English speaking world. preserve it with care, ye laddies of Scotland!
English is a German dialect. If English is a language then so is Scots
Too bad we dont speak Gaelic, the real language or Scotland before the English came and forced theirs upon us. Just like the rest of the UK.
@@hiddenknowledge2012 If you want to be pedantic, the 'real' languages of Scotland were Pictish and a dialect of Old Welsh. But, yeah, I wish Gaidhlig was properly taught and made to be the only language of, along with Scots, maybe.
the lowlanders spoke Lallans
I think you mean "Scottish", "Scots" is a different language
These guys bring Scottish folk music to life!
The very best
This is folk magic , Very powerful version of this song with the crowd singing along .,pure electricity, True bards were these men.
Corries brilliant music love to hear them stirring songs from a scouser English man 👨
Love all Scottish songs. Bought a book of Roberts Burns songs and poems. In my time, 70s, sang a few folk songs with friends at a folk club. We wernee that bad... Happy Christmas to all my friends and dear family in Scotland. X
My father side of the family half came from Ireland and the other half came from Scotland so i love both the Irish and Scottish songs
Try Runrig and Capercaillie
Being lucky enough to be part of an audience in a Corries concert.Brilliant Song and great Scots! :)
Lucky you,indeed ! :)
I AM GREEN with envy in TN.......
love it
Likewise.... And a privilege too.
Me too, many times. Such a great show, every time.
My hearts beats along with this song...
Poor Rabbie Burns, A great poet. He was only 37 when he died.
Great song, brilliant singers. 👍
An amazing song two amazing singers and musicians and one more thing mone the jacobites
it just gets better every time i hear it. brilliant
superb rosswatt1979. we are rising once more. people should remember this song for what it was.
Stuff the polotics i'll be 60 this year and and have every type or gig from Pink Floyd to the Royal Philharmonic and have o say the nihjt I saw thr Corries was one of the best gigs i've eer seen Eddie
The worlds first anti-war song...written 200 years before vietnam..." what haunts a parents life is bloody war!".....As the father of 2 sons how true is that verse....... the immortal legend that is Rabbie Burns.
Voyez la grande offense comes from the Middle Ages. Anti-war songs are as old as war
You think there had never been an anti war song before 200 years ago..?
Vietnam ?? Strange reference. 🙄
@@iandavidson7799 American lol
This isn’t even the oldest Scottish anti war song 😂😂
This song reminds me of being in the US Marines. My friend was shot from a living room in Iraq by a man with a 5 foot high mounted anti aircraft gun he had mounted in his living room. Thru the air came a huge quick rush of air as I heard the explosion. My heart flipped over it felt like. The the rounds came in fast repetition to my ears. He was gone, they had to identify him by his dental records.
This song harbours religious tension and separatist sentiments being from Scotland myself. Whether I believe in the movement or not, this is our historical legacy and a reminder of that time. It comes in handy when you need to ground yourself within the political world and it helps you understand why things remain so bitter - we can hold a grudge - must be in our DNA from the time we were living in clans. Scotland and Northern Ireland is the only place we have on-going religious bigotry and violence on an organised level in the western world, its kind of embarrassing, if you remember the origins of America was based on religious tolerance, unfortunately, 400 years later we still see the effects of the Reformation and the times that followed with King Billy. Much of our Catholic population lives in poverty to this day, both sides are living in poverty of course but its more prevalent among the former. Anyway, you are very courageous, Americans protect the free world and that means me too. Thanks for your input on the song. Its really interesting you said that. Gives a neutral glimpse at how this song impacts people.
Take care buddy.
@@RenaissanceMan29 Americans protect the free world by invading countries that happen to have oil and don't do what the US says. If the US gov't really wanted to put an end to dictatorship, then they wouldn't have allied themselves with Saudi Arabia, a country with a government which only recently was so generous as to allow women to drive cars. In 1956 MI6 and the CIA overthrew the democratic Iranian gov't to replace it with a monarchy. The PM Muhammad Mosaddegh was a champion of liberal democracy but he wanted to nationalise BP Oil in Iran, so democracy in Iran ended for good. (The US gov't literally admitted to doing this in 2013 by the way). This is only one of a slew of coups and armed invasions of sovereign democratic countries that the US participated in.
If the US really supported freedom then why does it topple democracies and support dictatorships?
@@huxleyleodwalding5751 I get your concerns, but I hope you understand, this is America we are talking about, and it includes a vast array of people with different objectives. The people who operate with Anthony Blinken and the Neo-Liberal or Neo-Conservaties, those are the people to watch out for and they are voted into power with lies. If America does something that's bad, then the whole world is watching but remember, they toppled Russian backed Corrupt Democracies.
Mate I hope you are alright and dealing with this tragedy in the right way. I disagree with the fact that we as a civilisation fought this war but absolutely respect everyone (you especially) who fought in it. Good luck to you!
@@RenaissanceMan29 You do know there were Jacobites in Ireland also? Not just Scotland.
Love the corries
I bought this album when visiting Newtonmore 1980. Also a Jean Redpath album.
Let your schemes alone and leave a man to his fate 💕. Thank you corries. Our fate isn't this UK chaos.
Well said.
long live the king over the water
Often referred to as Heiland Harry (you're wise not to mention his name).
"and leave the man undone to his fate" - refers to Bonnie Prince Charlie - who was undone by the loss of the Stuart Crown. Burns says the Highland Clans should leave him to his own fate and not go to war to save him
Burns was a lowlander and had no sense of loyalty. The Stewarts were the rightful kings of Scotland and the English establish had no business removing them from the throne, certainly not from the Scots throne.
@@andyallan2909 are you high or just ignorant of Burns and lowlands in general? Im from Inverness before ye talk pish . Blind loyalty is not a good virtue .Burns was proStewart if you had half a clue
@@andyallan2909 You think Charlie wanted to free Scotland and sit on the throne of Scotland?
He was a Stuart not a Stewart
Thanks for sharing your music I just joined your community of friends looking forward to your uploads,
I look forward to hearing from you thank you Ken
i am from east berlin. ye jacobites, yes that was also us. this could have been a wonderful rebel song in november 1989. - we did not know it at the time. but this year is 25 years fall of the berlin wall and this song still expresses of what we felt when the wall came down. what is right and what is wrong by the law. ye jacobites my name - your doctrines i'm unblame ! so magnetic. so strong. so wonderful. thank you corries.
***** Amazing what we learn from these old folk songs
This is not a Rebel song in fact the poem could easily have been titled " The Rant Against The Cause !" Robert Burns is telling the Jacobites to listen to him .Their FAULTS he will proclaim and their doctrines he felt to BLAME . Burns also thought the Jacobites should have made the changes by the LAW . He goes on to say he thought the Jacobites should have left the State alone with their schemes and plots ..He also wonders why the Jacobites cause is seen as HEROIC. He didn't see it this way. He seems to be writing about his total disgust with the Jacobian cause and every thing they stood for. Above is a small amount of what all he did say .So please read the poem first then listen to the song . I think you will agree ,
Cynthia Senn ye dontt half talk some pish, ye know fuck all about scotts history.
robert turner And you apparently know sod-all about Rabbie Burns.
Cynthia Senn Still, it sort of fits the spirit of the '89 protests, don't you think? Just that the tables have turned, of sorts.
Lovee you guys since i was 10 #yesscotlad !
Fabulous..... my fav Corries song..
@rossmcl177
The Jacobite uprising was a British Civil War, the Jacobites were Catholics who wanted the Stewarts as the rulers of a cathloc Britain but the Government were the Supporters of the Protestant Britian
I have been to both Newcastle and Liverpool and they feel like Glasgow
scottish and PROUD!!!!!!!!!!!!
Excellent!! Love the quaint idiom.
My Mother was born in Perth, Scotland. She emigrated to Canada and eventually Detroit. I have heard from my youth that according to the Scottish folk the Stuarts held the crown.
Well history proves that a fraction group of individuals as were the Scots under the Jacobite Revolution cannot control anything, and unfortunately they lost.
If you want to see it happening again look at the USA, we are fractioned beyond repair. And while we were noble in the wars of the 1940's those folks are gone. and just like the Jacobites I fear we will succumb to individual pride and personal vindication. God help me that I am wrong
Canada is fracturing too, and it’s because of one person. The most prideful and arrogant man in the country.
Trudeau I call by name,
Lend and ear, lend and ear!
Trudeau I call by name, lend an ear!
Trudeau I call by name,
Your faults I will proclaim,
Your Actions I defame,
You will hear, you will hear,
Your actions I defame,
You will hear!
“Leave the man undone to his fate.”
🇨🇦🍁❤️✌️🙏
Yes the Stuarts owned the crown of England....The wrong family is at Buckingham Palace..
Protestant or Catholic, Scotsman or Irish, we're all Celts by spiritual descent or actual if you're a highlander.
That's Celtic obscurantism at its its finest.
The term "Celtic" applies to genetic markers that half of Europe share.
Just say that highland Scots, and the Irish are both descended from the same group of Gaels/Scotti.
Just leave the silly Celtic pish out.
Lowland Scots are also decened from the Gaels/Scotti by the way.
How do you think Scotland came to be?
The Gaels/Scotti, and the Picts conquered the Angles, Saxons, Friesian's, and the Brythonic settlers.
All these groups came together to create lowland Scots. South-Western Lowlander's, and folk from Fife even spoke Gaelic for centuries.
Okay, just stop for a second.
The Kingdom of Scotland was founded by Cinaed Mac Ailpin, former King of Dal Riada and King of the Picts. he united the two into the Kingdom of Alba and over the centuries the two cultures merged into Scots' Gaelic
"Brythonic Settlers" First off, the Brythonics had settled in the land they would call "Alt Cluit" and "Gododdin" before the Gaels had settled Dal Riada. The Picts at that point were just doing their own thing and infighting. The Brythonic kingdoms were destroyed in the region by the Kingdom of Northumbria, which in turn was destroyed by a man who I can't remember the name of whilst one of his relatives, Ivar the Boneless, fell upon the Kingdom of Alt Cluit that revolted from Northumbria (Basically the region that was Carrick, Strathclyde and Galloway), Ivar also conquered the Kingdom of Dal Riada and set up shop there. Eventually, Scottish culture came to those regions over time and FINALLY the norse conquered regions were absorbed into Scotland however by that point we'd lost Carlisle and England had conquered over half of Ireland and Wales. I skipped out a hell of a lot of history but you get the gist.
The Gaelic language was predominant in the Lowlands until 1400 I believe, where the language lost a lot of it's following and was eventually phased out in law and administration by 1450.
+Robbie Lobster
All true, but irrelevant to my comment.
*****
What? Alba (Gaels and Picts) conquered Strathclyde (Brythonic settlers) and Northumbria ( Angle, Saxon, and Fresian settlers). All three became Scotland.
It was Lowland Scots who were responsible for repelling England, and they were just as Saxon as the English were.
Keep your Celtic obscurantism to yourself, Scots want none of it.
+Patrick J III McGuigan
Celtic obscurantism at it's finest.
You're either an ignorant yank, or an Irishman with with an inferiority complex.
If you're Welsh don't even bother commenting, you're irrelevant.
Could I please vote for this to be added to Spotify? Cracking piece!
Very eloquent! Strong finish too!
Truly magnificent
Me and my sis love this
Beautiful
Preach on brother! Lets all take heed and push on!
Up wi' the bonnets! Ya bass
We arer aye ready just gie the word !
This song is about the misery that violence and war inflict. So, again, "Are we no more wise than then?"
The song is telling a story! Most traditional Irish and Scottish songs are recounting historical events that the English don't wish to be reminded of. Its in the past you say so move on! So was WW1 and 2 and yet your happy to relive those historical events. You don't like hearing songs that recount your black deeds..
@@markkavanagh4457 This song is literally anti-Jacobite Mark
I wish! If they were to do that, I'd move to Scotland.
graet song i like it
Thur twa proper scoats god bless Roy.
Brilliant version!
Classic Corries once again. Linda, when will you be canonised?!? I;m about to search the thatch for my claymore!
Always vote for your own country bud,your family friends and neighbours are your country,YES!!! for all of them scotland forever!!
well said comrade
Confusing comments on this video. The lyrics quite clearly are about maintaining the status quo because the cost of rebelling is too great and ít falls on everyone, not just those culpable. On the other hand, lots of people here are calling for independence. I want independence too, but let's not misunderstand the song!
Independence; from Londonistan, and the Scottish _Kalergi_ Party.
@@deadsouls72 Aye Brother, Amen.
Not to mention the fact that Jacobites are, by definition, absolute monarchists. I'd rather live in a republican Britain than a absolutist Scotland, though right now we obviously have neither.
The Corries were/are Socialist/Republican...what a song this is.....
@9th Legion Listening again and here ye are big yin lol😉
There's nothing like coming upon a wonderful historical song and seeing it offer a home for bigotry. I'm English and I'm ashamed of much of what was done by the English in the past; similarly, it's not all innocence and romantic ideals amongst those the English 'suppressed'. One thing is most definitely in common - all these issues are those of the past and are only brought to the surface by those who are unhappy with peace. Live and let live and let religious and nationalist bigotry die.
wars are more and more about money but the religious and nationalist stuff are useful getting it going
great tune from the bard down with Tory tyrrany.
Now that's weird - I was just thinking of this song, didn't write anything on my computer, and now it is on my recommended. Does YT have the capability to read my thoughts?
Hey i'm also half scot half french!! you're right long live the auld alliance!!
:) Love this! SO few remember the Auld Alliance. Vive La France, Vive the Auld Alliance and Saor Alba Gu Brath !
Alba gu BRATH et vive la france! From a scottish-french descent canadian
Great song and nobody does it better than the Corries, but I'd just like to correct the frequently held erroneous belief that the Jacobites were all Scots, because the truth is that there were many English Catholics who wanted to see a return of the Catholic Stuarts to the British throne, while the greater majority of lowland Scots were in favour of maintaining the Protestant Hanoverian succession.
You're right,,the truth hurts a lot
What truth? Scots made up 99% of those who actually fought. We're not going to mention the people too cowardly to actually fight for their cause.
The lowlands were heavily split. But Yorkshire had heavier Jacobite support than Dumfries. Still it was most certainly a north/south divide.
viciouswolf1111 The lowlands were never dedicated to Scotland. They had their "wee bit grund" and the fear of losing that made them take the part of the London government.
I call them "Border Gardners" ;-)
@ogreoh I kind of agree with you there. As I said pox on both their houses. Just because someone points out 17thC Stuart flaws it doesn't mean they don't recognise 18thC Hanovarian flaws.
Oh my gosh! Wow!
@USAsoldier1955 It is because the actual genetical input from these later invasions is surprisingly very low......but this depends on the area. Some parts of Western Wales and Western Ireland can have 95-98% of population being majority iberian 'pre celtic' settlers (celtic being an evolved european culture) with several later celtic invasions bringing their own genetic tint to the proceedings :D, and this can very between person to person, the actual difference is small however just potent
Corries on youtubes home page, amazing! Serch for Braes o Killiekrankie, best song ;)
see the pentland folk version of this..its brutal..this is brilliant though no doubt!
Freedom for Scotland
The Jacobites probably would not recognise the modern United Kingdom (neither would the 'Hanoverians') but they would surely never recognise the multicultural republican "independent" Scotland the SNP pushes for.
@@zoomer_zveno i thought the Hanoverians came to the throne by dint of a scottish line of succession, so they were closer to being scottish than english?
@@philipwilliams5808 not sure bout that
Freedom for us English too who don't want to be ruled by Old Etonian Tories!!
@@kc8923 this i agree with , i symathise at the loss of english culture at the hand of project GB
Whereabouts in the Highlands? I'm fae Dunbar in East Lothian myself. Sorry if I was a bit condescending, but the Welsh have never given up. Look at Owain Glyndwr for example.
@rabnuds I don't think any of us should debate whether scotland will become independent - that's presumably what the referendum would decide
@3tangle3
There is. "Erin Go Brach - the Scottish version." "Johnny Cope, Ar ye wakin' yet", and many more, check Battlefield Band, Tannhill Weavers and Brian McNeill (my favorite)
i generally agree although its ,ore complicated than that......british history is so rich and has a long legacy and you well know
@akropiss well we are all closer to the original settler who were pre celtic,,,,,but as a welsh geneticist I agree with your sentiments....dont forget the welsh includes the cornish and strathclyde britons/cumbrians.
Whereever you are from its not important its the CULTURE!! and its been totally pushed back to these islands fringes ignored during the empire days..and still is to an extent
@ogreoh "James II strived for a kingdom with the peace to allow religions to develop" Actually James oppressed the Presbyterians in Scotland whilst his brother was on the throne and continued to do so whilst in office. He was eventually persuaded to moderate slightly but the idea that he wanted complete toleration for everyone is bunkum!
What doctrines? I am American.
Restoring the Stuart dynasty to power in Britain.
Scots killing Scots over whether a Catholic of Protestant should rule the British (English, Scottish and Irish) Kingdom. This song mocks the Catholics.
The Clan MacLean was there and served bravely at Culloden.
On which side ? Many clans had members on both sides
To the best of my knowledge they fought on the Jacobite's side, I have not researched or heard otherwise. Also, there is an ancestry connection with John O'Sullivan who was also on the Jacobite side. But in truth, the way I choose to view the fight as one for freedom. Though, as complicated as the politics were then; others may view it very differently.
@muzzawelsh I'm referring to the Scots in the sense of 'people who live in Scotland'
Fell guid ! Thank ye :)
Fancy seeing this legend in the comments section
A couple of my ancestors were transported to the American colonies for being Jacobites. One of my 2nd great grandmothers was a Stewart, and I have autosomal dna matches to the royal House of Stewart. Not that that makes me anything great, but it's cool anyway.
I'm not sure... I think Burns' version of this song is highly critical of "Jacobites by name", by which he means people who enjoyed calling themselves Jacobites but in fact did nothing to support that cause, in other words "Jacobites in name only".
I actually randomly turned on my turntable on the Thursday of the Referendum and I had Live At The Lyceum on from a few weeks before, and it was at this very song. Everyone thought it was very apropos. I'm in America for reference, and argued with the other local ancestrally scots-irish folk about how we'd all vote if we were there.
I'd think of all the good reasons to vote no, then I'd think that I have seen Culloden with my own eyes, and the feeling of death that hangs over the place, and I'd maybe flip a coin.
Alba gu brath
Daniel Olszewski Stick yer Gaelic pish up yer kilt
Will do.
Daniel Olszewski Ha ha :)
Oh I nearly forgot to ask are you any relation to John Watt from Milnathort? He wrote the Kelty Clippie song? Just askin'
I see a lot about Scottish independence here. Well, If you get it please take Newcastle. Closer to the scots than the Londoners...
The frontier should be Hadrian's Wall. England pinched a bit of Scotland at some stage.
Please no, I'd rather be part of the UK thank you very much.
@@samh3074 Part of the terrible parliament, government and crown. How lovely..
@@samh3074 fick
sam h you can fuck off to englandville
Edward also demanded not to be buried until Scotland was conquered, and he is yet to be buried. Your hero failed his ultimate goal a united Britain in his lifetime.
It's not religion, it's Scotland , 🦄 Soar Alba !
saor Alba gu brath.
Iam a true nationalisy, ans=d agree Charlie wanted the English throne for himself, and used the brave highlanders to gt it, remember he lived in France all of his life, and had not a lot of alegience to SCOTLAND.
Albannach there's no cure!
@@susanlittlejohn8054 He paid for it by a slow and sad lonely death by drink...in poverty at his aquaintences and friends' charity.
@USAsoldier1955 Tres bien.
Crikey can't we just enjoy the song!
I was thinking of Soutie or Sout Piel, which refers to the idea that British South Africans are associated with both Britain & South Africa & are therefore affected by the ocean in the middle (I won't translate it because it's a wee bit rude, but it's actually very similar to the English anyway). I don't really know if it's in common currency these days.
Amen!
oil is a minor asset and dont you know it ran out in the ninties or so we were led to believe but gues what we are still discovering new fields but apart from that the only question is would you rather be shafted by an english politition or scottish one
@ashbannor Quite so. The original source song Burns based this on is vehemently anti-Jacobite. Burns tones it down making it more anti-war than anti-Jacobite. Though he still blames them for the conflict in it. "You Jacobites by name....your faults I will proclaim....your doctrines I will blame...you shall hear"
@TheComradeRoss not exactly tbh, they weren't all cathlics many of them wanted the stuart family bck on the throne, or were forced to fight by clan chiefs
This is a cracking version. I prefer the song at a slower pace such as here. It always sounds rushed when it's played faster.
Billy Bragg does a good Thatcherite version.
Love the history of this song... relevant for generation after generation.
Yea Patriots ya name
Yea Patriots ya name
A comment on the Thatcherites song actually led me to this song.
@ColdMattyCross Rabbie Burns wrote this poem. He was jacobite. The 'Your fautes I will proclaim/Your doctrines I maun blame' are reference to the failures of the rebellion (Culloden) and not condemnation of the jacobites. It may not be a song that praises the jacobites but it definitely isn't an anti-jacobite song.
Quite agree. Michael Moore says the SNP will say anything to win the referendum but I think myself he'll say anything for a job in the UK cabinet
absolutely!
@USAsoldier1955 King Billy fought against the (mostly Catholic and re enforced by Scots Highlanders) Jacobites. Read up on the siege of Derry 1689 I think that was mostly Scots Jacobites against King Billy's orangemen backed by the dutch navy.
The King
if you want to hear some viciously anti-monarchical sentiments, try " Cam ye ower frae France", which is literate, bitter and satirical.
yes, yes, yes! Steeleye Span.....
Such a great song
i get your point, but just because the English were willing to massacre, starve and displace any number of people necessary, doesn't mean submission is the right course to take. Look what happened to the Gaels after they gave up their armies.
Anyone have the words to this song? When was this song written?
I dont but i know a man who does...hes called Google ...www.lyricsfreak.com/c/corries/ye+jacobites+by+name_21008654.html
Thanks!:)
@remeclerk surely it's quite difficult to get mixed up between the SDP abd the SNP?
Soz just found that difficult to believe
@danonutube1 I don't know why the other poster brought the law into it. There is nothing unlawful or unconstitutional about the Nats holding an independence referendum - or people debating it. The UK govt has conceded that!
and you could dance to this
Stop it i am a highlander and this is tame compared to what we talk about southerners
The Jacobean uprisings (3 of them) weren't as simple as a Protestant/ Roman Catholic issue. It ran so much deeper than that, alot deeper.
Burns’ believed his own grandfather and possibly his father to be Jacobites. The air of the song was a Jacobite tune, by changing the words preserved the melody. There’s also an interpretation of the song as coming from the perspective of an old Jacobite who seen the horror of the first two rebellions and didn’t want to see the next generation go through the same thing
Yes
Scottish /French alliance daftys, have a old film that tells you de bruce singed it in dundee lasted for hundreds of years