The fact that this feels more like a goodbye to me than a "we'll see you later" makes me tear. I've loved them for a long time, and I wish I could thank them for everything.
@@MINSISFor Tbh I'm glad for her, I think she made the right decision. I've always perceived her wanting to change paths, maybe even careers, so I'm actually very happy that she bargained to remain with them until 2023, so it's not an immediate leave. I'm with her on this
I disagree. She such a valuable asset, and has so much more to give. Very skilled singer. She needs a challenge, a change in direction , a change in direction of MaMaMoo to cover more different and interesting songs and styles and projects. And to do songs in English, and travel the World and achieve World Recognition. The more creative and skilled a person is, the more of challenge and varied activities and projects they need. They need to wake up every morning excited about what they're gonna do. The lack of foresight of the management company is maybe partially to blame. However, it could be a personal decision by Weein. Whatever...we wish her the Best and in making the right Decision for her. God Bless.
I can peacefully die. I cried so much listening to this and now seeing the lyrics, the song just became my safe place. I seriously want to thank my mother for I AM BORN AND AM ALIVE IN THE SAME TIME AS MAMAMOO. The way they harmonized with each other Moonbyul's part EVERY LINE KILLED MY HEART.
The beauty of the lyrics is that although they are portraying their complicated feelings atm but at the same time they are saying they are thankful for how far they've come together The fact that they are looking forward to a future unknown, they're excited to unleash it together like they always have been doing it Stan Mamamoo for good future
🇬🇧 Where are we now, MaMaMoo ✨ NeW FAN ✨ 0:01 Hwasa Soft and Gentle, and can be Powerful ✨ 0:33 Wheein's broad voice range, Beautiful Confident tone, Beautiful Emotions, lovely control of riffs. Powerful. ✨ 0:44 Solar's Powerful Voice, and the voice tone I love the most of the girls. ✨ 1:17 Moonbyul sound like she could Rap this to bits if she wanted.! Very good stepping through the Lyrics telling the story. ✨ These girls *all have POWER in their vocals* , and Vocals ARE *CONFIDENT* and *in CONTROL* , and have Talent Skill Quality setting them apart from other KPoP artists, as MaMaMoo are *TRUE VOCAL ARTISTS* . ✨ The _reasons_ why they are not as busy as BP, IU , etc on the World Stage are many, but these reasons are mostly not truly related directly nor personally to the Vocal Artists but the other Demands generally of Artists, such as their Dance Routines and fitness, MVs, their promotional activities, and sadly even how they MUST look in physique and Style because of the public interest and demand of what sells and is popular...Nothing related to the True Pure Skill and Talent of 🎶 Singing...which MamaMoo Excel Admirably. ✝️ God Bless them. 💖 *4thIMPACT* _are sisters of Harmony singing since Kids, _*_the Pride of the Philippines_*_ , and in my Heart. They are KPoP fans of MaMaMoo, BP, IU, Ailee, BTS, AKMU,... MY PROFILE LINKS - Please listen in their FREE LiVe SHoWs SUB BELL YT 4thimpactMusic , (Fr) Sa Su 830pm-11pm_ 🇵🇭 _Philippines, 930pm Seoul Tokyo, 130pm UK, 230pm Paris Berlin Rome, 830am NY, 530am LA, 430pm Dubai, 930am Brazil, 1030pm Sydney,..._ *SOON TO RELEASE COVER OF MAMAMOO's Where Are We Now* . 🎶 *SUB BELL YT 4THIMPACTMUSIC* ✝️ *SEE MY PROFILE LINKS* .
A beautiful and moving piece of art. Hwasa's voice is unique Solar's voice is powerful Whee-in's voice is gentle Moonbyul's voice is a beautiful baritone of a rapper They are all so unique and that's why MAMAMOO is so good. QUEENS INDEED
I'm not a mamamoo stan, but yesterday I saw this video and the bgm at the first took my interest, I checked the credit that it is mamamoo where are we now. So now I'm here
Although moonbyul's part is so short and i wished it is longer but she killed it.. I wish they gave her a vocal line cause she has honey vocals.. Anyways mamamoo's vocals are no joke.. They did a great job✨
That is sung by Wheein and Hwasa. They both are best friends from their childhood and they shared the same dream as eachother. Now they made it. Their dream came true
mamamoo' s songs helps me a lot nowadays. Lately, i feel tired and helpless. I don't know what to do. My anxiety and depression keep coming, but i am so grateful to have mamamoo in my life. Just please don't disband.
3:25 Wheein and Hwasa sing together here and talk about "The two of us who had the same dream as each other." Reminds me of how they've known each other for so long, and how they had always aspired to become what they are now.
There is something about mmm's vocal line, they are just so good and can sing with so much emotion, I can't explain it. For me definitely the best vocal line in the female k-pop industry
This is the question i asked myself every night .... where are we now Omg this song is the perfect crying song The lyrics ... the vocals .. the feelings This is a good music💛
🇬🇧 Where are we now, MaMaMoo ✨ NeW FAN ✨ 0:01 Hwasa Soft and Gentle, and can be Powerful ✨ 0:33 Wheein's broad voice range, Beautiful Confident tone, Beautiful Emotions, lovely control of riffs. Powerful. ✨ 0:44 Solar's Powerful Voice, and the voice tone I love the most of the girls. ✨ 1:17 Moonbyul sound like she could Rap this to bits if she wanted.! Very good stepping through the Lyrics telling the story. ✨ These girls *all have POWER in their vocals* , and Vocals ARE *CONFIDENT* and *in CONTROL* , and have Talent Skill Quality setting them apart from other KPoP artists, as MaMaMoo are *TRUE VOCAL ARTISTS* . ✨ The _reasons_ why they are not as busy as BP, IU , etc on the World Stage are many, but these reasons are mostly not truly related directly nor personally to the Vocal Artists but the other Demands generally of Artists, such as their Dance Routines and fitness, MVs, their promotional activities, and sadly even how they MUST look in physique and Style because of the public interest and demand of what sells and is popular...Nothing related to the True Pure Skill and Talent of 🎶 Singing...which MamaMoo Excel Admirably. ✝️ God Bless them. 💖 *4thIMPACT* _are sisters of Harmony singing since Kids, _*_the Pride of the Philippines_*_ , and in my Heart. They are KPoP fans of MaMaMoo, BP, IU, Ailee, BTS, AKMU,... MY PROFILE LINKS - Please listen in their FREE LiVe SHoWs SUB BELL YT 4thimpactMusic , (Fr) Sa Su 830pm-11pm_ 🇵🇭 _Philippines, 930pm Seoul Tokyo, 130pm UK, 230pm Paris Berlin Rome, 830am NY, 530am LA, 430pm Dubai, 930am Brazil, 1030pm Sydney,..._ *SOON TO RELEASE COVER OF MAMAMOO's Where Are We Now* . 🎶 *SUB BELL YT 4THIMPACTMUSIC* ✝️ *SEE MY PROFILE LINKS* .
The first time I heard this I replayed it all day. I'm talking about today. I'm so sad this is their last comeback with Wheein. This song is so beautiful.
Technically it isn't. It's a bit complicated but Wheein is still part of the group and she is going to take part in their songs. She just won't do idol work anymore. I am not entirely sure what that's supposed to look like since I don't know any similar situation in kpop but I believe that she won't do any stages anymore, she won't be at award shows and maybe she isn't even in the MVs. I believe that she still wants to make music with the girls but the idol life is too much for her, which is why she has this special contract.
@@sugasinfireration5863 a bit late, but what you said isn't really true. Wheein is still part of the group, but just not under Rbw entertainment anymore. She will be on MVs, she will be at award shows and she will continue her work with the group until December 2023 (which is what the contract says). 2PM is a group, that also has members from now different agencies
Mamamoo Where are we now is such a beautiful song that everyday it's in mind and sing this song everyday because the lyrics and the genre sound is so perfect.
I'm sorry but moonbyul singing "everything we did together was like a great drama" with all that emotion though. Like sis. I'm already gay. I just- I can't-
I want to apologize to hwasa because i always hated her for the things she has done and i didnt even realize she was human.All i did was hate her and i regret it , i should have forgiven her for the things she has done.I hope the girls will forever be happy
![[4K] 마마무(MAMAMOO)의 “Where Are We Now” Band LIVE Ver.│콘서트에서만 들을 수 있는 맘무 밴드 라이브 [it’s KPOP LIVE 잇츠라이브]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rIr3Y4zEOoU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Bad Bye | MAMAMOO Lyrics (Color Coded) [ENG+ROM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/98if7lkoHqs/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact that this feels more like a goodbye to me than a "we'll see you later" makes me tear. I've loved them for a long time, and I wish I could thank them for everything.
After Wheein's news ,this hits different😭😭
@@MINSISFor Tbh I'm glad for her, I think she made the right decision. I've always perceived her wanting to change paths, maybe even careers, so I'm actually very happy that she bargained to remain with them until 2023, so it's not an immediate leave. I'm with her on this
@@alexhell224 I support her too!She is still a part of Mamamoo so moomoos should support her.
I disagree. She such a valuable asset, and has so much more to give. Very skilled singer. She needs a challenge, a change in direction , a change in direction of MaMaMoo to cover more different and interesting songs and styles and projects. And to do songs in English, and travel the World and achieve World Recognition. The more creative and skilled a person is, the more of challenge and varied activities and projects they need. They need to wake up every morning excited about what they're gonna do. The lack of foresight of the management company is maybe partially to blame. However, it could be a personal decision by Weein. Whatever...we wish her the Best and in making the right Decision for her. God Bless.
@@MINSISFor what news?
I can peacefully die. I cried so much listening to this and now seeing the lyrics, the song just became my safe place.
I seriously want to thank my mother for I AM BORN AND AM ALIVE IN THE SAME TIME AS MAMAMOO.
The way they harmonized with each other
Moonbyul's part
EVERY LINE KILLED MY HEART.
The beauty of the lyrics is that although they are portraying their complicated feelings atm but at the same time they are saying they are thankful for how far they've come together
The fact that they are looking forward to a future unknown, they're excited to unleash it together like they always have been doing it
Stan Mamamoo for good future
This is sooooo powerful yet emotional
ya
🇬🇧 Where are we now, MaMaMoo ✨ NeW FAN ✨ 0:01 Hwasa Soft and Gentle, and can be Powerful
✨ 0:33 Wheein's broad voice range, Beautiful Confident tone, Beautiful Emotions, lovely control of riffs. Powerful.
✨ 0:44 Solar's Powerful Voice, and the voice tone I love the most of the girls.
✨ 1:17 Moonbyul sound like she could Rap this to bits if she wanted.! Very good stepping through the Lyrics telling the story.
✨ These girls *all have POWER in their vocals* , and Vocals ARE *CONFIDENT* and *in CONTROL* , and have Talent Skill Quality setting them apart from other KPoP artists, as MaMaMoo are *TRUE VOCAL ARTISTS* . ✨ The _reasons_ why they are not as busy as BP, IU , etc on the World Stage are many, but these reasons are mostly not truly related directly nor personally to the Vocal Artists but the other Demands generally of Artists, such as their Dance Routines and fitness, MVs, their promotional activities, and sadly even how they MUST look in physique and Style because of the public interest and demand of what sells and is popular...Nothing related to the True Pure Skill and Talent of 🎶 Singing...which MamaMoo Excel Admirably. ✝️ God Bless them. 💖 *4thIMPACT* _are sisters of Harmony singing since Kids, _*_the Pride of the Philippines_*_ , and in my Heart. They are KPoP fans of MaMaMoo, BP, IU, Ailee, BTS, AKMU,... MY PROFILE LINKS - Please listen in their FREE LiVe SHoWs SUB BELL YT 4thimpactMusic , (Fr) Sa Su 830pm-11pm_ 🇵🇭 _Philippines, 930pm Seoul Tokyo, 130pm UK, 230pm Paris Berlin Rome, 830am NY, 530am LA, 430pm Dubai, 930am Brazil, 1030pm Sydney,..._ *SOON TO RELEASE COVER OF MAMAMOO's Where Are We Now* . 🎶 *SUB BELL YT 4THIMPACTMUSIC* ✝️ *SEE MY PROFILE LINKS* .
the ending moment between two young girls "the two of us who had the same dream as each other" stop ;-;
oof lmao this song is a masterpiecee
😭
A beautiful and moving piece of art.
Hwasa's voice is unique
Solar's voice is powerful
Whee-in's voice is gentle
Moonbyul's voice is a beautiful baritone of a rapper
They are all so unique and that's why MAMAMOO is so good. QUEENS INDEED
I dont stan Mamamoo but all of their songs are just amazing and this one is proof of it
Yep
Stan them, you'll never regret it
I'm not a mamamoo stan, but yesterday I saw this video and the bgm at the first took my interest, I checked the credit that it is mamamoo where are we now. So now I'm here
Although moonbyul's part is so short and i wished it is longer but she killed it.. I wish they gave her a vocal line cause she has honey vocals..
Anyways mamamoo's vocals are no joke.. They did a great job✨
Yasss if only their chorus for this song was like “I miss you”, where they all sing in harmony
This is so relaxing, this is like a lullaby for me.
This is heartbreaking omg if you know lyrics+personal experience like farewell to someone you loved
"Goodnight" is the real lullaby btw haha
This is not a song. it's pure art, a masterpiece
It's not a masterpiece or pure art. *ITS A GODDESS LEVEL MASTERPEICE*
"this beautiful star, the two of us had the same dream as each other. Where are we now?"
That's deep, that actually meant something & it's kinda sad😥
That is sung by Wheein and Hwasa. They both are best friends from their childhood and they shared the same dream as eachother. Now they made it. Their dream came true
I am not even a fan, but this song touches me very much and Solar's vocals hit different
mamamoo' s songs helps me a lot nowadays. Lately, i feel tired and helpless. I don't know what to do. My anxiety and depression keep coming, but i am so grateful to have mamamoo in my life. Just please don't disband.
@Cloudoof auww thank you ☺️.and to tell you, I am already passed that phase. I hope you're doing great too in your life 🤗.
3:25 Wheein and Hwasa sing together here and talk about "The two of us who had the same dream as each other." Reminds me of how they've known each other for so long, and how they had always aspired to become what they are now.
Feeling this...
It hurts so much.. Beautiful song.
I'm not a fan but their vocal is on another level sorry for my bad english
Your english is not bad
Yeah their vocals are amazing oh and your english is not bad at all it perfectly fine
They are on another level, for me they are underrated... Listen also hip, recipe, Nada sou sou and you're the best 😊🙃
VOCAL QUEEN: MAMAMOO
TRUEEEE
Why this song is so nostalgic! Their vocals could make u cry like a river
i just imagine solar, hwasa, and wheein high note in the same time like- 🤧
Vocalist queen's of whole kpop industry
There is something about mmm's vocal line, they are just so good and can sing with so much emotion, I can't explain it. For me definitely the best vocal line in the female k-pop industry
my favorite "neol manna~"
solar : 0:46
hwasa : 2:03
and from 0:00 until 3:46 i got a goosebump!!!
I never thought need Moonbyul voice singing more than ever 😭❤️
They are cutting my heart into peaces with their vocal.
I don't understand why people said this song wasn't good enough, this is a masterpiece 💕
No one said tho. This is highly underrated
This song makes more sense with Wheein’s departure. It was what I was afraid of 😭
The lyrics omg vocals ahhhh
Jaeguchi is faster than my internet
Lmao yassss
Nah. They didn't do Save by NCT 127 yet
Why and how is this so accurate?! 😭
But they make lot of mistakes
Vocal queens ! Stan Mamamoo
Hwasa and Solar sound beautiful on the choruses, but I wish Wheein had one! Would have been beautiful and so powerful!!
Who love wheei.
👇🥺❤️
*wheein
Soorryyy hehehe
To all the proud moomoos who are crying while listening 💛💛
The fact that this song is so underrated kills me dude
I haven’t become a big fan of Mamamoo yet, but Hwasa’s voice is stunning. All of their voices are, but Hwasa really stands out to me.
I listened to this song so many times this morning! This song is simply gorgeous. I am so glad I pre-ordered this mini-album.
Wheein harmonizing with z members is just so beautiful
This is the question i asked myself every night .... where are we now
Omg this song is the perfect crying song
The lyrics ... the vocals .. the feelings
This is a good music💛
This was soo beautiful that I almost cried, and jaeguchi u are really something else
THIS IS A MASTERPIECE....
*The vocals are not a joke*
You got me crying over words I don’t even know 😭
Wheein owned this era 😭
Momoo, this could be their last song. Let's take a good look at this song. 💚
It's not. They will be a group till 2023
Discovered this song because some boy imitate mamamoo singing this song in tiktok.
Best discovery ever 😭
This song is amazing I got chills just listen to this 😭
Can someone recommend me more songs like this from mamamoo
I miss you
And the whole WAW album
Sting , I miss you , my everything,…
Yes, try to listen Hip, Nada sou sou, recipe, you're the best, taller than you, ahh oop 😊😊😊
Paint me , miss you
Love you mamamoo!
(Listening to this all day)
mamamoo never detoriates in quality
THIS IS SO TOUCHING.
OT4 FANS 👇😭😭
MAMAMOO
MAMAMOO
MAMAMOO
MAMAMOO
MAMAMOO
I swear this song makes me cry everytime
Mamamoo has evolved into DIVA🔥🔥🔥🔥
🇬🇧 Where are we now, MaMaMoo ✨ NeW FAN ✨ 0:01 Hwasa Soft and Gentle, and can be Powerful
✨ 0:33 Wheein's broad voice range, Beautiful Confident tone, Beautiful Emotions, lovely control of riffs. Powerful.
✨ 0:44 Solar's Powerful Voice, and the voice tone I love the most of the girls.
✨ 1:17 Moonbyul sound like she could Rap this to bits if she wanted.! Very good stepping through the Lyrics telling the story.
✨ These girls *all have POWER in their vocals* , and Vocals ARE *CONFIDENT* and *in CONTROL* , and have Talent Skill Quality setting them apart from other KPoP artists, as MaMaMoo are *TRUE VOCAL ARTISTS* . ✨ The _reasons_ why they are not as busy as BP, IU , etc on the World Stage are many, but these reasons are mostly not truly related directly nor personally to the Vocal Artists but the other Demands generally of Artists, such as their Dance Routines and fitness, MVs, their promotional activities, and sadly even how they MUST look in physique and Style because of the public interest and demand of what sells and is popular...Nothing related to the True Pure Skill and Talent of 🎶 Singing...which MamaMoo Excel Admirably. ✝️ God Bless them. 💖 *4thIMPACT* _are sisters of Harmony singing since Kids, _*_the Pride of the Philippines_*_ , and in my Heart. They are KPoP fans of MaMaMoo, BP, IU, Ailee, BTS, AKMU,... MY PROFILE LINKS - Please listen in their FREE LiVe SHoWs SUB BELL YT 4thimpactMusic , (Fr) Sa Su 830pm-11pm_ 🇵🇭 _Philippines, 930pm Seoul Tokyo, 130pm UK, 230pm Paris Berlin Rome, 830am NY, 530am LA, 430pm Dubai, 930am Brazil, 1030pm Sydney,..._ *SOON TO RELEASE COVER OF MAMAMOO's Where Are We Now* . 🎶 *SUB BELL YT 4THIMPACTMUSIC* ✝️ *SEE MY PROFILE LINKS* .
The first time I heard this I replayed it all day. I'm talking about today. I'm so sad this is their last comeback with Wheein. This song is so beautiful.
Technically it isn't. It's a bit complicated but Wheein is still part of the group and she is going to take part in their songs. She just won't do idol work anymore. I am not entirely sure what that's supposed to look like since I don't know any similar situation in kpop but I believe that she won't do any stages anymore, she won't be at award shows and maybe she isn't even in the MVs. I believe that she still wants to make music with the girls but the idol life is too much for her, which is why she has this special contract.
@@sugasinfireration5863 a bit late, but what you said isn't really true. Wheein is still part of the group, but just not under Rbw entertainment anymore. She will be on MVs, she will be at award shows and she will continue her work with the group until December 2023 (which is what the contract says). 2PM is a group, that also has members from now different agencies
I can fell this song,it just soo relax 💖
اصواتهم 😭😭.
마마무 신곡
Thanks so much for quick translation!!
So touching
This song is so comforting.I was in a tough situation today and this song made me feel so empowered,
This beautiful song feels so much like a OST
This song came outta nowhere. It's INSANELY beautiful. Like, I just can't -
Mamamoo Where are we now is such a beautiful song that everyday it's in mind and sing this song everyday because the lyrics and the genre sound is so perfect.
صوتهم يهبل 😭
The vocals. Amazing
The melodies, the rhythm made me cried without a reason..
IM GONNA CRY- WHEEIN IS LEAVING MAMAMOO AND IT SO SAD
She's not leaving mmm
Not until the end of this December 😭
So beautiful😭👑
1:09 - It's Solar
2:23 - Also Solar
I'm sorry but moonbyul singing "everything we did together was like a great drama" with all that emotion though. Like sis. I'm already gay.
I just- I can't-
3.24 Wheesa "The beautiful star The two of us who had sama dream as each other Where Are We Now" makes me so emotional tho ToT
They make me cry...this is emotional 😢and obviously sometimes helpful when I feel lonely😊😊thanks to them
My New Safe Place
Thank you mamamoo :
I always cry listening to this song it's more like a goodbye song and I will always love and adore mamamoo
I love you 😭🥺💙💙💙
I want to apologize to hwasa because i always hated her for the things she has done and i didnt even realize she was human.All i did was hate her and i regret it , i should have forgiven her for the things she has done.I hope the girls will forever be happy
What things did hwasa do?
@@xuelan7004 lots of CA and said the n word
@@ms1748 CA?
@@xuelan7004
cultural appropriation. they also did blackface for a bruno mars cover.
@@user-qb9ft9ro9d ohh I see. Thanks for informing.
This song make me feeling 🤧💜
wow that was quick
This song is so smooth
Everytime I hear those highnotes,I get goosebumps!!!
Thank you for translation
i just realized in the description of this it says the album is the chaos chapter freeze-
Hwasaaa voice is deep💜💜💜
I don’t stan but this right here lord have mercy
At 2:03 it kinda makes me feel she was actually emotional like, it sounded a bit like a cry. Hwasa’s vocals are no joke istg.
Mamamo love you 💋
this song is gorgeous
oh my gosh the vocals-
2:39 listen carefully...
Listen 👂 something?
Does that have some meaning👉👈?
OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH 💕💕💕💕💕
I'm not crying my eyes are sweating😭
Queens of vocals💓
Finalmente a Hwasa tá cantando mais nas músicas
Actually I wonder where are you now...
♡♡
i got goosebumps, why are they always surprise moo moo?
their vocal!!!
Those 70 people who disliked this masterpiece... I hate you with you all my heart, loves
Byul oh you are perfect
yall are so fast it’s been just some minutes??