this is my fave song on the album, the intense progression of the song and the hints of dark sadness and the heartbreak the vocal line express, and moonbyul's intense and even a bit angry rap just make it the absolute best for me
@@Katerima1 Uh no. I love Byul, but lets not discredit anyone else by giving her all credit.. She wrote her rap, like she usually does. B.O wrote most of the song.
God, I never cry because of break up songs since I can't relate and most have very predictible/repetitive lyrics, but this one hits hard - the beat, strong vocals and lyrics combined make it really heartbreaking. Great job, producers and mamamoo!
I noticed that Mamamoo has such good break up songs. Destiny, Windflower, Better than I thought, Bad Bye. I never experienced a break up but if I ever do I’ll go to Mamamoo’s song for sure😂
Love that the message in their lyrics can give us some comforts..." that's why I don't see MMM as idols than an ARTIST. there's more to this gg than we'll ever know including their wacky personalities is a major plus! 🤣💚❤
This song has the best bridge I’ve ever heard. Moonbyuls dreamy sing-rapping overlaid by vocals building up into this beautiful harmony by wheein and hwasa at the end and finishing with a perfect power vocal from solar. It made the final bass drop into the chorus THAT much more satisfying. Just... *chefs kiss*
*SUCH* a good song. In fact White Wind is a really good EP! I find myself coming back to it again and again (and again). I accept your chef's kiss and raise you a *humble bow* of appreciation.
Wow, it was pretty clear what the song was about even without knowing the translation but these lyrics hit me right in the feels. It's something that is way too relatable for me right now. Moonbyul's rap (the first one in particular) was so intense it took my breath away as I was reading what she was saying. Also this feels like it could be a prequel to Wind Flower!
People who did not know Mamamoo have missed out a lot. They might give views to other groups with not so good song and vocal but missed such a beautiful song with heavenly vocal like this.
This song doesn't deserve a dislike, Mamamoo, a group containing members who could do any genre, may be pop or dramatic romance. You know who gave this song a twist and killed it for the song to be balanced, ---BYUL🔥🔥🔥
Actually my favorite song off the album!! Seldom I find tracks on k-pop albums that I love more than the songs that headline albums. Love MAMAMOO and Moonbyul.....KEEP DOIN YOU BABE!!!!!!!!
I love the word play of Bad bye and Goodbye. Tbh at first I thought Byul’s rap part was a bit jarring of a transition but now I loveee it. It hits hard! Also their vocals and the piano instrument!! Overall best song in this album imo!
I'm glad Mamamoo is only 4 members so we got to hear all members voice fully❤. Not like some group with 9 members that some member only got 1/2 sentence😂
@@d0wntownki2k not really, but also kinda. I mean not that it's the group's fault but of course if u have 9 members it ain't gonna be a vocal group or dance group, but rather people mastering in different roles will be selected. And so depending on their concept, not really easy to give everyone lines everywhere. Happens in any big group
Yes, well said. Mamamoo have soooo many incredible songs tucked away as B-sides in their albums. Their title tracks get most of the attention, but the real joy is that every song in every album has been made with love and care, and among those are many gems and treasures to discover, in many different styles. Bad Bye always makes me cry, even from the first time I heard it without knowing Korean.
guess we're at the generation of KPOP where we ignore songs that give us motivational strength, confidence and more meaningful lyrics to a simple and plain lazy songs with upbeat and catchy instruments to the extend we have forgotten that ballad tracks can't have a chance in music anymore which is quite unbelievable in my opinion.
god i can definitely hear this song in a drama (like the beat). I imagine a a scene with a man in a suit, in his apartment, watching the seoul night city view with a drink in his hand regretting something
She is the main vocal and lots of people appreciate her vocals..😅 Even a señior singer goes out of hiding when she learns that Solar will sing her song..
You probably don't see it often cause everyone been knowing Solar slays😂. Wheein and Moonbyul were kinda looked over the first 3-4 years after their debut, so I think Moomoos are tryna make up for that, and it helps that they've been kinda showing off recently.
The fact that we rarely see solar's comments trending in youtube everywhere. Solar's stan is more calm. But then, its annoying that we can see other 3 members trending comments but not her, right?
I wish just like the song I Miss You, moomoo would make this song popular as a ''hidden gems", and choose this song to be performed live if mamamoo ever ask which..
I got goosebum after 1 second..ahh..its hurt me,i have a bad bye to my dad that passed away last Christmas 2017..while i have chance say nicely to my mom because suffering from lung cancer stages 4.i have regretting forever in my life until i die because my dad
Ethan J I'm sorry for your lost. I hope your mom fights with all she has. Your dad is looking over you and I'm sure he loves you and wouldn't want you to live with regrets!! Fighting ❤️❤️❤️ moomoos supports you
The way the narrative shifted from wishing the loved one would suffer too, to wishing them well in the future. ;-; It reminds me of "FOMO" by Hwasa: "even if we say goodbye, let's love again". This song is just so freaking amazing, from lyrics, to the melody, i love it so much 🥺🥺💖💖
![Mamamoo - I Miss You [Eng/Rom/Han] Picture + Color Coded HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Dzog19gc_Aw/mqdefault.jpg)
this is my fave song on the album, the intense progression of the song and the hints of dark sadness and the heartbreak the vocal line express, and moonbyul's intense and even a bit angry rap just make it the absolute best for me
The perfect summary for this song 😭
3:19
Every time Hwasa and Wheein harmonize 3 years are added to my life
Also when Wheein and Byul harmonize, everytime I'm dead
=)))
am very willing to listen to it for a week
Same !
Same
Is it just me or did moonbyul just KILL it with the rap!
Sml
moonbyul is a goddess she will kill anything and still look beautiful
Always
i just click the like button cause i want it to be 666 xD
anyway i like moonbyul's rap
i thought the same
Me too
i wish this will be used as an OST for a drama., IT WILL BE LITERALLY LIT!
I was thinking the same thing 😆😆
I can imagine it and it's PERFECT
We the same thoughts 💕
at first i really thought that this is some ost from the new kdrama or what😂
Omg righhttt i can feel the kdrama vibe in the song lmaoo
Byul sing and rapping is so freaking amazing.
Moonbyul be getting these royalties with all the songs she participated writing
I think she actually wrote whole song herself. It hurts me she only got like 15% of lines
@@Katerima1 Uh no. I love Byul, but lets not discredit anyone else by giving her all credit.. She wrote her rap, like she usually does. B.O wrote most of the song.
@@exessen1684 who's b.o ?
@@langsz I'm not sure, but he's worked with Mamamoo before. Guess he's just a producer.
Okay everyone slayed in this song but BYUL AND WHEEIN JUST STRAIGHT OUT MURDERED ME
This is such an underrated Bop and omg Moonbyul really came for our necks with that smooth ass rap.
Moonbyul's rap in this is THE THING
Byuls lyrics hit me hard. Its just so real and you will really feel it. 😭❤️
God, I never cry because of break up songs since I can't relate and most have very predictible/repetitive lyrics, but this one hits hard - the beat, strong vocals and lyrics combined make it really heartbreaking. Great job, producers and mamamoo!
So very true, preach sister! Also with the powerful rap to top it off this is absolutely amazing
I have good relationship with my husband and I'm happy right now but I'm crying like I can relate to this song hahahahaha
I noticed that Mamamoo has such good break up songs. Destiny, Windflower, Better than I thought, Bad Bye. I never experienced a break up but if I ever do I’ll go to Mamamoo’s song for sure😂
Also Decalcomania makes me go wild 🤣 "You and I kiss, I feel good"
Love that the message in their lyrics can give us some comforts..." that's why I don't see MMM as idols than an ARTIST. there's more to this gg than we'll ever know including their wacky personalities is a major plus! 🤣💚❤
This song has the best bridge I’ve ever heard. Moonbyuls dreamy sing-rapping overlaid by vocals building up into this beautiful harmony by wheein and hwasa at the end and finishing with a perfect power vocal from solar. It made the final bass drop into the chorus THAT much more satisfying. Just... *chefs kiss*
*SUCH* a good song. In fact White Wind is a really good EP! I find myself coming back to it again and again (and again).
I accept your chef's kiss and raise you a *humble bow* of appreciation.
this song got me crying about an ex that i don’t have
I can relate I just lie on my bed and look at he ceiling and catch feelings whilst listening to this song
Same lmao
Relatable!🤙
literally-
@@kitschh99 that’s sad 😭
Omg!! Wheein voice is just so out of this world!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Wow, it was pretty clear what the song was about even without knowing the translation but these lyrics hit me right in the feels. It's something that is way too relatable for me right now. Moonbyul's rap (the first one in particular) was so intense it took my breath away as I was reading what she was saying. Also this feels like it could be a prequel to Wind Flower!
3:15 the two soulmates trading lines and then harmonizing is something I need in more Mamamoo songs please. My ears are blessed.
People who did not know Mamamoo have missed out a lot. They might give views to other groups with not so good song and vocal but missed such a beautiful song with heavenly vocal like this.
Wheein's voice oh my God. I cried 😭
First line: Don’t try to push me away saying sorry
Last line: Don’t be sorry because I loved you.
I’m not crying. You are. 😭
Omg Byul finally having some lines...this song is also amazing!!!
Still it isn't that many :
She is one of the raper with the most lines in the industry
@@S_T_fania raPPer 😂
actually, every single song in this album deserve a live stage..
Truth
True
Which album is this??
@@btsmamamoo2754 White Wind
Berdasar 👍
The way solar singing "wae iri naman appa" line is so heartbreaking 😭
It's amazing how you can feel the raw emotion even without the lyrics
Byul's rap really killed it!
Whoever wrote the bridge is a PURE GENIUS
This song doesn't deserve a dislike, Mamamoo, a group containing members who could do any genre, may be pop or dramatic romance. You know who gave this song a twist and killed it for the song to be balanced,
---BYUL🔥🔥🔥
Mamamoo has the best bsides in kpop
the mossttt fav part is this 2 bff harmonies 3:19 soo good
The taste 😭😭😭👌
Moonbyul omg I’m crying 😭❤️❤️ And their voices are so perfect damn !!!!
Actually my favorite song off the album!! Seldom I find tracks on k-pop albums that I love more than the songs that headline albums. Love MAMAMOO and Moonbyul.....KEEP DOIN YOU BABE!!!!!!!!
This song always makes me cry.. especially byuls rap and the last words hwasa says at the end
byul's rap completes the song 😭
Yea! Screw those ppl who says rap don't belong in songs
But my life not complete without you. Cia ~~ 😣
@@maf1083 lol u malay?
@@foziahmatzain5703 im japan
Best song in the album, 100 percent. Listen to those vocals, jesus.. I'm having chills.
The taste 👍👍💯
One of my favorite song of the album! The vocals and rap slayed 😍
Moonbyul is such a flow Goddess
Need a K-Drama make this song their ost
I love the word play of Bad bye and Goodbye. Tbh at first I thought Byul’s rap part was a bit jarring of a transition but now I loveee it. It hits hard! Also their vocals and the piano instrument!! Overall best song in this album imo!
Wow, this is such a great song
damn moonbyul didn’t have to go that hard 🥺😪🤧
"Don't be sorry because I loved you"
wowowowoahwoah that hurt
At first I thought Moonsun broke up cuz Byul's rap made me cry
love the tone of her rap
WHEEIN VOICE always surrender my heart 💔❤
This is Moonbyul's best rap aside from decalcomanie and sleep in the car
This deserved to be an OST! MAMAMOO SONG ARE ALL GOOD!! DAMN
As I said earlier....Mamamoo deliver the song beautifully...in 💜 with the song...
idk why but when byul's part came on i felt so attacked and tears just start flowing from eyes perhaps i felt every words
I'm glad Mamamoo is only 4 members so we got to hear all members voice fully❤.
Not like some group with 9 members that some member only got 1/2 sentence😂
The fact that Sistar have only 4 member but Bora and Dasom seems like have only one-three sentences😂
Twice shade??? 🤔🤔🤔
I'm just joking
@@d0wntownki2k not really, but also kinda. I mean not that it's the group's fault but of course if u have 9 members it ain't gonna be a vocal group or dance group, but rather people mastering in different roles will be selected. And so depending on their concept, not really easy to give everyone lines everywhere. Happens in any big group
3:27 that line is hitting me 😢🤧
Definitely my favourite song in this album
I just love every song that Mamamoo sings.
Wheein’s voice is just HONEY so sweet ❤️
this song took me on a rollercoaster of beat switches, highnotes, and byul rapping and singing as if she wants me dead
Every lyric in this song ... is very relevant to my life ...
Sadly this song didn't see the light of day. TBH, this is one of their most powerful song vocal and message wise, it deserves a live performance. 😢
Man this song! It’s a like a “normal breakup”.. until it happens to you.
Everyone’s talking about Byul, but I’m sitting here blown away by Hwasa’s husky voice🥰🥰😍😍
When Scarlet Heart came back for season 2 ill definitely recommened this song to be their OST 😍😭 im sure it will be totally lit
put this in the top comment for everyone to see and then let's start a petition! Gosh you're brilliant! ❤️❤️❤️
this song hit so many feels. i would love to see them sing this live. my fav song on the album!
A song that wheein started... 👌
the lyrics is a masterpiece, if you experience break up you can really relate
This song should have to be more popular❤️❤️❤️❤️
I swear this song will make me burst into tears every time
People say mamamoo doesn't have that many good songs and that they don't stan because if the songs but actually they're sleeping on songs like this
Yes, well said. Mamamoo have soooo many incredible songs tucked away as B-sides in their albums. Their title tracks get most of the attention, but the real joy is that every song in every album has been made with love and care, and among those are many gems and treasures to discover, in many different styles. Bad Bye always makes me cry, even from the first time I heard it without knowing Korean.
guess we're at the generation of KPOP where we ignore songs that give us motivational strength, confidence and more meaningful lyrics to a simple and plain lazy songs with upbeat and catchy instruments to the extend we have forgotten that ballad tracks can't have a chance in music anymore which is quite unbelievable in my opinion.
This song deserves a drama. The mood is there already.
It's like a kdrama ost. Love it!
urgh i love the rap verse and vocals. perfect
MMM's Bad Bye and NCT's No Longer are my ultimate favorite when I'd like to cry at night awu
Byul's rap hits right to the home. IT'S HURTING ME 😭
진짜 휘인이 도입부부터 목소리로 사람 홀려버리네
Moonbyul with that rap!!!! OoO
god i can definitely hear this song in a drama (like the beat). I imagine a a scene with a man in a suit, in his apartment, watching the seoul night city view with a drink in his hand regretting something
I'm here again everytime I'm in the mood to just cry while watching the rain pouring outside my window :')
This song has 90s r&b vibe like SWV, Allure! They need to have these kind of songs often
Queens of heartbreaking songs!
Just discovered this song after my breakup . Omg their emotion hits on me hard . But for sure im gonna be their fan after this
Don't listen to "Sting" by them. That song fucking hurts.
Exessen cannot unseen anymore . Prepare my eyes to be swollen again ~
@@nurajeerah231 Hope you'll be okay friend. I've been there before. Time heals all wounds, even when it doesn't feel like it will.
@@exessen1684 yeah i hope so ,, to be strong as you is all i need :') thanks btw ❤️
I wish solar can be more apreciated by her vocals like the others
She is the main vocal and lots of people appreciate her vocals..😅 Even a señior singer goes out of hiding when she learns that Solar will sing her song..
You probably don't see it often cause everyone been knowing Solar slays😂. Wheein and Moonbyul were kinda looked over the first 3-4 years after their debut, so I think Moomoos are tryna make up for that, and it helps that they've been kinda showing off recently.
All Moomoos love Solar’s vocals. She is one of the strongest vocals in k-pop.
The fact that we rarely see solar's comments trending in youtube everywhere. Solar's stan is more calm. But then, its annoying that we can see other 3 members trending comments but not her, right?
i feel like if you love mamamoo you automatically love Solar.
I wish just like the song I Miss You, moomoo would make this song popular as a ''hidden gems", and choose this song to be performed live if mamamoo ever ask which..
I would have liked that they promoted this song :(
ok but im in love with the "babe you~"
This has been one of my favourites in the album ever since I first listened to it 💗💗💗
Byul snapped!!!
😔 thank you for giving a good music it goes straight to my heart
hands down for the best song of the ep.
So in love with Solar ❤️
why only now i discovered this AWESOME song huwaaaaaaaaaaa
I got goosebum after 1 second..ahh..its hurt me,i have a bad bye to my dad that passed away last Christmas 2017..while i have chance say nicely to my mom because suffering from lung cancer stages 4.i have regretting forever in my life until i die because my dad
Ethan J I'm sorry for your lost. I hope your mom fights with all she has. Your dad is looking over you and I'm sure he loves you and wouldn't want you to live with regrets!! Fighting ❤️❤️❤️ moomoos supports you
This song is so good...
one can't simply listen to mamamoo's song without end up liking the song
I love this one too !! So much soul in it !!
Wheein do have a big soul 🙈
I wish mamamoo can sing all their white wind, rib, travel bside live 😭😭😭😭
The songs sound good bcs their voices complete the song tbh
everytime i hear mamamoo's songs i can't stop saying wow..
Wow this such a great song 😢very well composed
Mamamoo always the BEST 💖
My sweet star and wind
Wahhh.. Goosebumps.. Beaitiful song with beautiful voice
mamamoo QUEENS OF KPOP THESE GENERATION!!! *periods
The way the narrative shifted from wishing the loved one would suffer too, to wishing them well in the future. ;-;
It reminds me of "FOMO" by Hwasa: "even if we say goodbye, let's love again".
This song is just so freaking amazing, from lyrics, to the melody, i love it so much 🥺🥺💖💖
I liked this more than gogobebe- wish we could have a cheoro or an mv for it its so pretty
I think this is the best song in the album; the feel alone breaks the language barrier. Sorry to say, I'll gotta put Gogobebe last in the list.
Why am i crying to hear this song ????? I am not in a relationship and i am not broken. Buuuuttttt, whyyyyyy am i cryiiiiingggggggggg ?????
너무 좋누~! 이게 ❤️마마무❤️지! 오직 ❤️마마무❤️니까 가능한 노래!