Roger Waters probably wasn't thinking of Sinead O Connor when he wrote this song, but it hit the spot with her. They apparently didn't hit it off during the show, and Waters said a few things which he probably now regrets, but he will never get a more honest heartfelt interpretation of his song. RIP SINEAD O CONNOR.
Ela deu um show, foi incrível, brilhante, extremamente emocionante . O seu sorriso como resposta quando a platéia se manifestou foi de arrepiar!🌟🌟🌟👏👏👏👏🌹🌹🌹🌹💯♥️baby!
@@curragh2840 Ela sempre arrasou, lembra da interpretação da canção do Prince, nada se compara a você , ela encantou o mundo. Ainda continua encantando Genialmente, uma Diva, uma lenda,🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
I grew up with this live and this song always excited me. Seeing Sinead singing in front of this huge audience with his fragility, emotions, humility, her smile and her perfect voice, made in my mind the example of the real artist.....rest in peace Sinead, the most beautiful voice in the universe!
Man , it's so SO bittersweet finding all of these clips of her performing , now that she's gone, and seeing all this love for her now that she's gone, and wondering if she had any idea of how her voice, her words, her bravery, touched so many.. heartbreaking ❣️❣️❣️ You were a teacher of strength , courage, and yet , humanity, vulnerability.. I hope your beautiful soul is at peace, Sinead..
Mother do you think they'll drop the bomb Mother do you think they'll like the song Mother do you think they'll try to break my balls Ooooh aah, Mother should I build a wall Mother should I run for president Mother should I trust the government Mother will they put me in the firing line Ooooh aah, is it just a waste of time Hush now baby don't you cry Mama's gonna make all of your Nightmares come true Mama's gonna put all of her fears into you Mama's gonna keep you right here Under her wing She won't let you fly but she might let you sing Mama will keep baby cosy and warm Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe Of course Mama's gonna help build the wall Mother do think she's good enough for me Mother do think she's dangerous to me Mother will she tear your little boy apart Oooh aah, mother will she break my heart Hush now baby, baby don't you cry Mama's gonna check out all your girl friends for you Mama won't let anyone dirty get through Mama's gonna wait up till you come in Mama will always find out where You've been Mamma's gonna keep baby healthy and clean Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe You'll always be a baby to me Mother, did it need to be so high
Her innocence is disarming...and she had to go through heart wrenching experiences because of her vulnerability and transparency of being human and angelic at the same time in a world hostage to the juggernaut of power and greed. A heart full of love and reverence for you, and your awareness that you really were a living 'Witness to Truthfulness'.❤
RIP Sinead - I am born in Berlin - living with the Wall between East and West Berlin over 30 Years - and I was at this Concert at Potsdamer Platz . And hope for a new world - we are One. And now - War in Europe - and Sinead is dead. I am shocked - just another sad day in these times .... now one perfect voice singing for God !
...be happy that God has blessed you with such emotions... this song is my Psalm, by text but also melodic line.... do you realize how happy we are to be contemporaries with Pink Floyd?
The way Roger smiles at her as she does his brilliant work such justice! Just a beautiful thing to see. The whole performance and the players involved is a truly epic tribute to the power of music and collaboration.
Never heard this version before...just Beautiful...Beautiful Sinead ❤ & this version! Fan of Pink Floyd 44 years and saw them live in my 20s...just awesome💝🌠🌈🌠
makes no sense to have a woman sing this song though. It's about pink's personal experience growing up and about him singing it. No hate towards her I just think it was kinda pointless for them to do this.
I don't care who's in the room, nor matter the point in time, I cannot keep a dry eye listening to this music. There's just no way. Even though my mother is still alive, it's still a very emotional impact song for me. I think of my dad a lot who has passed on now for almost 9 years. Thank God for the song. And no! I absolutely do not trust my government. Not anymore
i never saw this before now. Ya RIP Sinead what a beautiful voice . Then i noticed Garth Hudson then Rick and Levon. Big fan of the band. Sorry we are losing all these talents. i wonder how they came together here
I was there, 300.000 people at Potsdamer Platz. After the helicopter flew over the area, everyone was covered in dust. So many artists all singing the Pink Floyd songs. Best concert ever.
Sinead losing her mother when she was young made this even more poiniant for her to sing this masterpiece of a song with her voice from the heavens RIP Sinead gone but will never be forgotten 💥💫
I listened to this song obsessively as a 12 year old. Hearing Sinead sing it was like nothing I’ve ever heard in this world. I’m sorry, my precious Angel, I’m sorry that you couldn’t stay. I’m sorry the world was cruel beyond imagining. Be free now. Forever loved.
J ai vu le concert à la télé en 2002 the wall à Berlin RIP sinead o connor j ai regardé une de tes vidéos quelques heures avant ton décès quelle perte énorme ! 😢❤
This was a rehearsal unfortunately there was a power cut during the live performance so they added this into the performance overwise we wouldnt have got this great version
Привет из России. Великая песня. Это творчество великих исполнителей. Слушал их,будучи юношей. И слушаю их сейчас,когда у меня седая голова. Пивица так же великолепна. Знаю её много много лет. Браво.
Big Thanks to Roger Waters to pull this of...one of the few musicians nowadays standing his ground in regards to everything that is going wrong on this planet...some might not like him, but he really is a true hero! Keep going Roger!
This compilation sounds and looks perfect at the original live concert many things went very wrong. F.i. Sinead forgot the lyrics of the song (Roger had to whisper them into her ear) furthermore there was a powerdrop which made parts of the PA system fail..... So for all sake's they had to redo this song from scratch during the gig. This footage is mainly shot during the full dress rehearsal from the night before the actual concert.... I know because i was there back then on the 'real' night ;)
The only Floyd that was there was Roger Waters. It was a bit of a controversy at the time. They put a big pair of balls on the giant pig to differentiate it from the Floyd pig
I am gone see Roger Waters together with my son in Antwerp on the 14.5..23. The Wall. I was 25 in 1990. Just married. Now i am 58. Roger is almost 80. Unbelievable. Greetings Dirk Belgium.
Tous les jours je regarde et j'écoute ma Sinéad tant aimée ❤❤❤, elle est tellement exceptionnelle, je la découvre sans cesse, et je ne me lasse pas , sa voix me fait vibrer et pleurer souvent. Sinéad je t'aime❤❤❤ jusqu'à ma propre fin.
Sublime. Surely the pinnacle of what music is about. Poignant, lyrical and majestically sung by Sinead and played by the others. The squeeze box guy adds another dmension to something already full of wonder. What brilliance. I can't stop listening to this and only discovered it this summer of 2023. Where have I been all my life?
I was there after I and two friends caught the ferry to Ostend and drove all the way to Berlin, we were allowed to camp in the Tiergarten, a fantastic concert and a look around the city the next day.
That, sweet, shy, almost embarrassed smile @ 0:44 is how I will remember Sinead. People have commented on how brave she was and they're right. She called out the abuse by the Catholic Church a long time before the scandals started coming to light. Inside, I think she was still that abused little girl at heart.
incredibly moving moment. this is perhaps Sinead at her finest. RIP. Maybe Roger's also. Such a beautiful song. No doubt the best version of it I've heard. Being able to listen to songs like these, to witness performances like these is the only thing that has made my life worth living. Art......, it is everything to me.
Who is here for Sinead? Such a brave soul. May your voice and heart live on forever. Great song....Sinead you were right! I hope you had some comfort in knowing you were always right...
Удивительно, каким необыкновенным талантом обладала Шинейд О'Коннор, что все самые известные песни любых исполнителей, даже из "Стены" Пинк Флойд она каким то чудом исполняла более чувственно и эмоционально. Любим и скорбим. Аллах Велик !
From the first few words, this song became hers. I can think of no other performer so powerful and yet so fragile. I’m almost offended when the chorus comes and others sing along with her.
immensa, fragile, tenera, vulnerabile, ma voce divina ...lontana dai clisce dello star sistem , per questo semplicemente umana...vola e canta tra gli angeli dolce Sinead....
Amazing work of art beautifully done by legends. Rest in peace our beloved Sinead. You have gone to a better place. You will never be forgotten, you will live in our hearts forever.
She sure as hell did. Her intense vocal delivery, facial expressions, it's obvious she was totally emotionally into the music. Roger Waters had good reason to smile at her.
R.I.P. Danke für deine musikalische Unterstützung in der Vergangenheit! Die mich als kleines Ost Berliner Mädchen im Jahr 1990, ich war 5 oder 6 Jahre alt, bis heute in meinem Emotionen daran erinnert, was war. Nur mit deinem goldenen Klang & Stimme für immer und ewig prägt.
one of the greatest song writers of all times got one of the greatest voices to do one of his masterpieces! Respect! So happy i was part of it back then!
There are so many awesome vocalists. Each with her or his own style, muse, source, motivation, etc. Sinead O’Connor goes to a place that is so raw and painful … the result is a voice that penetrates my soul. It hurts so much in what is equal parts pain and beauty. I watch this clip many times a year. It is special
Fantástica apresentação ao vivo !!! Sinead linda !com a coz de um anjo ....Descanse em paz... Sua obra ecoará nas paredes da eternidade ...todo som emitido pra sempre se propaga!!!!
There's a LOT of talent on that stage. Some aren't with us anymore but the gifts they left me with I'm forever grateful. Godspeed Garth, Levon, Sinead. Forgive my ignorance if I left someone out.
Love you ever..sinead, you are always in my heart ❤...thank you for All your amazing and greatfull Songs ....its a great Song with pink floyd ..thank you ❤❤❤..and 🎉sleep well sweet😢😢😢
She had a set of lungs and her voice was as impactful on this song. As a Pink Floyd fan overall, when Roger really wanted to bring in acts to recreate his songs he was solid. But as a Gilmour fan it’s hard for me to say. But I give Roger his props when they are due. R.I.P. Sinead thanks for the memories
I’ve always loved this song, I was blown away the first time seeing the wall video. This version with the stunningly talented and beautiful Sinead O’Connor was something special at a special moment in history.
What a line-up 🫶🏻 No one will ever touch the lyric/song writing talents of Mr. Waters imo. Always brings me out in goosebumps and often to tears. Legendary.
This song is so hauntingly beautiful it brings me to tears. Sinead so brave, talented & beautiful. Also I do believe that's Rick Danko & Levon Helm of THE BAND singing backup with Garth Hudson on accordion. RIP Sinead O'Connor ❤
@@jeanlucpicard5794 ok gotcha & at times in some of the video's I had difficulty telling if it was Rick or Robbie. Considering stories of issues with Robbie, it makes sense it was Danko with Helm. Garth Hudson was featured on accordion. Just days after my posting that Robbie passed away.
She absolutely CRUSHED it. I remember watching this on MTV live while it happened and was blown away by all of it. But, she absolutely CRUSHED that song. I have this one in a few Spotify playlists. She was decades ahead of time.
My mum was there and brought me back rocks from the wall. I wish the past in every country could be forgotten now and we put our every moment into our kids now.
Wow, I was at that concert. Huge production, massive crowd, mostly remember being on top of a shed or garage of some sort to see the stage. Saw the Stones the same week, it was a much smaller crowd and way more fun cause I had room to dance.
Con certeza, esta es la mejor interpretación de Mother. El momento histórico, la reunión de los intérpretes y claro, el acierto de que Sinéad O'Connor haya sido la primera voz en esta canción; su personalidad, completamente en armonía con el tema.
RIP Sinéad O'Connor. I'll never forget this performance
Okay
This is a rehearsal. The actual performance was probably better.
Roger Waters probably wasn't thinking of Sinead O Connor when he wrote this song, but it hit the spot with her. They apparently didn't hit it off during the show, and Waters said a few things which he probably now regrets, but he will never get a more honest heartfelt interpretation of his song. RIP SINEAD O CONNOR.
Ela deu um show, foi incrível, brilhante, extremamente emocionante . O seu sorriso como resposta quando a platéia se manifestou foi de arrepiar!🌟🌟🌟👏👏👏👏🌹🌹🌹🌹💯♥️baby!
@@curragh2840 Ela sempre arrasou, lembra da interpretação da canção do Prince, nada se compara a você , ela encantou o mundo. Ainda continua encantando Genialmente, uma Diva, uma lenda,🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Sinead is so beautiful. No makeup. No hair. Just that perfect face and perfect voice, so full of emotion.
I am with you she is pretty all around !! I love her and cannot stop listening to her !! That beautiful voice !!
RIP
Nothing compares to Sinead RIP ❤❤❤❤❤
This is a rehearsal. It’s not the actual performance. The audience is dubbed. Look up the real story of this ‘performance’.
🌌
I grew up with this live and this song always excited me. Seeing Sinead singing in front of this huge audience with his fragility, emotions, humility, her smile and her perfect voice, made in my mind the example of the real artist.....rest in peace Sinead, the most beautiful voice in the universe!
Una artista increíble ahora su música e interpretaciones vivirán por siempre ...
Nothing compares to her RIP Sinead
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽🙁😥😥😥😥😥😥😥💔✌🏽
💙 buon ritorno a casa anima meravigliosa
As far a I heard, Waters said they had to record this one without the audience in a special take out of programme.
Man , it's so SO bittersweet finding all of these clips of her performing , now that she's gone, and seeing all this love for her now that she's gone, and wondering if she had any idea of how her voice, her words, her bravery, touched so many.. heartbreaking ❣️❣️❣️ You were a teacher of strength , courage, and yet , humanity, vulnerability.. I hope your beautiful soul is at peace, Sinead..
Mother do you think they'll drop the bomb
Mother do you think they'll like the song
Mother do you think they'll try to break my balls
Ooooh aah, Mother should I build a wall
Mother should I run for president
Mother should I trust the government
Mother will they put me in the firing line
Ooooh aah, is it just a waste of time
Hush now baby don't you cry
Mama's gonna make all of your
Nightmares come true
Mama's gonna put all of her fears into you
Mama's gonna keep you right here
Under her wing
She won't let you fly but she might let you sing
Mama will keep baby cosy and warm
Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe
Of course Mama's gonna help build the wall
Mother do think she's good enough for me
Mother do think she's dangerous to me
Mother will she tear your little boy apart
Oooh aah, mother will she break my heart
Hush now baby, baby don't you cry
Mama's gonna check out all your girl friends for you
Mama won't let anyone dirty get through
Mama's gonna wait up till you come in
Mama will always find out where
You've been
Mamma's gonna keep baby healthy and clean
Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe Ooooh Babe
You'll always be a baby to me
Mother, did it need to be so high
Her innocence is disarming...and she had to go through heart wrenching experiences because of her vulnerability and transparency of being human and angelic at the same time in a world hostage to the juggernaut of power and greed. A heart full of love and reverence for you, and your awareness that you really were a living 'Witness to Truthfulness'.❤
I thought the same
thought i knew something of her work but there is more and then more and them more MAGIC but now Why not before
RIP
Nothing compares to you Sinead ,❤ RIP
RIP Sinead - I am born in Berlin - living with the Wall between East and West Berlin over 30 Years - and I was at this Concert at Potsdamer Platz . And hope for a new world - we are One. And now - War in Europe - and Sinead is dead. I am shocked - just another sad day in these times .... now one perfect voice singing for God !
...be happy that God has blessed you with such emotions... this song is my Psalm, by text but also melodic line.... do you realize how happy we are to be contemporaries with Pink Floyd?
The way Roger smiles at her as she does his brilliant work such justice! Just a beautiful thing to see. The whole performance and the players involved is a truly epic tribute to the power of music and collaboration.
Penso la stessa cosa ❤
Grandi THE BAND ❤
This is exactly what I noticed too 🍀
Yes so beautiful that admirative look upon her. 💕
Q INCRIVEL!!!TALENTO NATO,E GRANDE SER!!!❤
Beautiful rendition. So full of soul, power, and gentle yet raw emotion.
RIP Sinéad.
For real.
I think you’ll find her name was Sinéad.
@@martinbanks7686 I think you still understood my sentiment without snarky semantic quips.
If I could like this a million times
Waters actually sharing the stage and it’s not all about him…astounding and amazing.
RIP Sinead
This couldn't have been an easy song for Sinead to sing with what she went through but I'm glad she did. RIP.
This was the rehearsal, in the end she didn’t perform at the concert… Which is a huge shame.
I didnt know that....
@@haraldsydness4902
🎉🎉🎉2 de 🎉2🎉🎉2🎉2🎉🎉🎉🎉😂🎉ńnmmbnnnmnnnn 6:42
RIP Sinead O'Connor. She sang so beautifully in this song
I was at that concert with my friend Michael. I will never forget standing among 300.000 people with chills all over. I was 18 years in 1990.
Wow…just wow
Great man!! Was there too!!
I was there too, 19yo at the time - all my heroes were there, only missed Clapton
I was there too! I am there totally and immediately when I hear this song.
Ты не представляешь что бы в 2000 в Олимпийском!!!!!🤒👍👍😅
Sinead adds a delicacy to the vocals that makes it absolutely haunting. It touches my soul.
She's the best voice of my generation in my opinion
@@stephenberry7876❤
@@stephenberry7876,She is the big heart
Best vocal for me
Never heard this version before...just Beautiful...Beautiful Sinead ❤ & this version! Fan of Pink Floyd 44 years and saw them live in my 20s...just awesome💝🌠🌈🌠
Totally underrated. When Danko, Helm, Waters, and Hudson are your backup and you blow the song away, you know that is real talent.
Such a Legends!!!
Damn this is so POWERFUL. Sinead has an insanely powerful voice. I love this song
makes no sense to have a woman sing this song though. It's about pink's personal experience growing up and about him singing it. No hate towards her I just think it was kinda pointless for them to do this.
Por algo la habrán elegido pero yo también me pregunto lo mismo, no por Sinead porque lo hace maravilloso
me too
One. Love thank You
Yes l do
I don't care who's in the room, nor matter the point in time, I cannot keep a dry eye listening to this music. There's just no way. Even though my mother is still alive, it's still a very emotional impact song for me. I think of my dad a lot who has passed on now for almost 9 years. Thank God for the song. And no! I absolutely do not trust my government. Not anymore
Pink Floyd and Neil Young both punch me straight in the heart, and I love it.
Easily the highlight of this concert. Beautifully performed. RIP Sinead.
The accordion adds a special feel to the song, it is indescribably beautiful.
Garth!
i never saw this before now. Ya RIP Sinead what a beautiful voice . Then i noticed Garth Hudson then Rick and Levon. Big fan of the band. Sorry we are losing all these talents. i wonder how they came together here
What a legend she is ❤
The world needs still this words.
Was für eine Ballade!!
Besser gibt es nicht!! 🤗
I was there, 300.000 people at Potsdamer Platz. After the helicopter flew over the area, everyone was covered in dust. So many artists all singing the Pink Floyd songs. Best concert ever.
One of the greatest rehearsals ever recorded.
Sinead losing her mother when she was young made this even more poiniant for her to sing this masterpiece of a song with her voice from the heavens RIP Sinead gone but will never be forgotten 💥💫
RIP. One of the best pieces of music ever written by the best band on Earth sung beautifully by an irreplaceable tragic talent. Tears. Xx
Those vocals at 4:30 thru 4:50. ..gets me everytime..that stare she gives..sends chills down my godamn spine
I listened to this song obsessively as a 12 year old. Hearing Sinead sing it was like nothing I’ve ever heard in this world.
I’m sorry, my precious Angel, I’m sorry that you couldn’t stay. I’m sorry the world was cruel beyond imagining. Be free now. Forever loved.
J ai vu le concert à la télé en 2002 the wall à Berlin RIP sinead o connor j ai regardé une de tes vidéos quelques heures avant ton décès quelle perte énorme ! 😢❤
Wow. One of the best versions I've ever heard of this.
RIP Sinead O'Connor - this a beautiful rendition of this song.
That look of joy and apreciation from roger to sinead 😍
:-)
This was a rehearsal unfortunately there was a power cut during the live performance so they added this into the performance overwise we wouldnt have got this great version
@@mairyhuff7102 it’s lip syncing, see at 1:50
@@jeepmap1 😂😂😂
RIP bald beauty
Wow never heard this version before. How come we don’t have artists like this anymore? Sinade O’Connor is so under rated
Привет из России. Великая песня. Это творчество великих исполнителей. Слушал их,будучи юношей. И слушаю их сейчас,когда у меня седая голова.
Пивица так же великолепна. Знаю её много много лет. Браво.
I agree. Now that she became a muslim, they'll do anything to burry her.
Mango Tango - I know artist today have no soul. It’s all about being a boss and living in Callabassas like a Kardasian. I fear for my children.
Dejen de hablar pavadas, Sinead está bien a pesar de todo lo que pasó, vive en un lugar apartado y tranquila, no la pudieron destruir
Waters and O'Connor are still out there and doing strong. Where you been?
❤❤❤ mit dem Konzert haben sich alle teilnehmenden Künstler ein Denkmal gesetzt! ❤❤❤Danke, Roger! ❤❤❤
Big Thanks to Roger Waters to pull this of...one of the few musicians nowadays standing his ground in regards to everything that is going wrong on this planet...some might not like him, but he really is a true hero! Keep going Roger!
Phenominal. Sinead and Floyd are incredible together. Sineads voice was perfect.
Oui ! En fusion d'énergie positive !!!
Sinnead is huge, ❤
This compilation sounds and looks perfect at the original live concert many things went very wrong. F.i. Sinead forgot the lyrics of the song (Roger had to whisper them into her ear) furthermore there was a powerdrop which made parts of the PA system fail..... So for all sake's they had to redo this song from scratch during the gig. This footage is mainly shot during the full dress rehearsal from the night before the actual concert.... I know because i was there back then on the 'real' night ;)
The only Floyd that was there was Roger Waters. It was a bit of a controversy at the time.
They put a big pair of balls on the giant pig to differentiate it from the Floyd pig
Sinéad estaba enojada con Roger, no recuerdo porque, pero algo andaba mal
Ein unglaublich tiefes und gutes Lied. Vielen Dank an die Frau die es mir geschickt hat.
What a great perfomance!!!! Sinéad O'Connor👍👍👍👍
Today, Monday 1st January 2024 and Im Still Listening To Sinead O'Connor . ❤.
*Never Forgotten Beautiful Soul *
Was hatten wir damals für Träume bei diesem Konzert und was haben sie draus gemacht, aus diesem schönen Land? Man könnte heulen!
I am gone see Roger Waters together with my son in Antwerp on the 14.5..23. The Wall. I was 25 in 1990. Just married. Now i am 58. Roger is almost 80. Unbelievable. Greetings Dirk Belgium.
Oh God to have been there! im 76 yrs old and this is the most amaysing event of my long lifetime. Oh to have been there!
Tous les jours je regarde et j'écoute ma Sinéad tant aimée ❤❤❤, elle est tellement exceptionnelle, je la découvre sans cesse, et je ne me lasse pas , sa voix me fait vibrer et pleurer souvent. Sinéad je t'aime❤❤❤ jusqu'à ma propre fin.
Sublime. Surely the pinnacle of what music is about. Poignant, lyrical and majestically sung by Sinead and played by the others. The squeeze box guy adds another dmension to something already full of wonder. What brilliance. I can't stop listening to this and only discovered it this summer of 2023. Where have I been all my life?
I was there after I and two friends caught the ferry to Ostend and drove all the way to Berlin, we were allowed to camp in the Tiergarten, a fantastic concert and a look around the city the next day.
That, sweet, shy, almost embarrassed smile @ 0:44 is how I will remember Sinead. People have commented on how brave she was and they're right. She called out the abuse by the Catholic Church a long time before the scandals started coming to light. Inside, I think she was still that abused little girl at heart.
incredibly moving moment. this is perhaps Sinead at her finest. RIP. Maybe Roger's also. Such a beautiful song. No doubt the best version of it I've heard. Being able to listen to songs like these, to witness performances like these is the only thing that has made my life worth living. Art......, it is everything to me.
The Band! Sinead ! Who would have thought. This is incredible. I love her voice on this! Plus the late great Levon Helm !
And Rick Danko.
Rest in Peace Sinead!! 🙏
One of the most beautiful voices in the world that I have had the pleasure to hear!!
Not only a fantastic soulful voice and an open activist but, the most beautiful lady in the world. RIP Sinead.
RIP Sinead. Be at peace.
Who is here for Sinead? Such a brave soul. May your voice and heart live on forever. Great song....Sinead you were right! I hope you had some comfort in knowing you were always right...
Удивительно, каким необыкновенным талантом обладала Шинейд О'Коннор, что все самые известные песни любых исполнителей, даже из "Стены" Пинк Флойд она каким то чудом исполняла более чувственно и эмоционально. Любим и скорбим. Аллах Велик !
Brilliant performance. Few people misunderstood you but the super majority of us understood you well. RIP
She has one of most beautiful female voices of all time !
She really does, and phenomenal control.
you should listen to more music, lol. she's not even average.
Who do you like better?
Disagree...THE most incredible voice of all time!
Das beste Konzert der Welt
Ich war dabei
Schöne Grüße aus Salzburg
Sinead O'Connor is a legend! One of the greatest singers!!!
From the first few words, this song became hers. I can think of no other performer so powerful and yet so fragile. I’m almost offended when the chorus comes and others sing along with her.
immensa, fragile, tenera, vulnerabile, ma voce divina ...lontana dai clisce dello star sistem , per questo semplicemente umana...vola e canta tra gli angeli dolce Sinead....
Ma che vuoi dire?! Non leggo della sua morte…😮
@@MariastellaArgentiTia .... infatti è solo una metafora...un saluto!
RIP dear Sinead. You were a true phenomena ❤
STOR SAKNAD vi kommer alltid minns dig evigtid❤ from Sweden ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I saw them with my late husband in 1990. Absolutely the best concert I’ve ever been to. No one can beat Pink Floyd.
Maybe you were just early
Nah sorry stones beat Floyd
man Sinead puts a good spin on this song i love it
Überragend ................. mehr kann man zu diesem Traum nicht sagen. Erich Jeske
Amazing work of art beautifully done by legends. Rest in peace our beloved Sinead. You have gone to a better place. You will never be forgotten, you will live in our hearts forever.
So sad to hear of Sinead's passing - a great talent!
Such a beautiful voice you can feel the vibes from it through your body
Musicians and singers at their best and for anyone who knows anything about music must acknowledge this as one of the most iconic performances ever
Roger's just smiling at her
She did a good job. Bravo bravo
She sure as hell did. Her intense vocal delivery, facial expressions, it's obvious she was totally emotionally into the music. Roger Waters had good reason to smile at her.
Timeless masterpiece.. and the unique voice of Sinead, just mesmerizing. May you Rest in Peace, Sinéad
R.I.P. Danke für deine musikalische Unterstützung in der Vergangenheit! Die mich als kleines Ost Berliner Mädchen im Jahr 1990, ich war 5 oder 6 Jahre alt, bis heute in meinem Emotionen daran erinnert, was war. Nur mit deinem goldenen Klang & Stimme für immer und ewig prägt.
one of the greatest song writers of all times got one of the greatest voices to do one of his masterpieces! Respect! So happy i was part of it back then!
There are so many awesome vocalists. Each with her or his own style, muse, source, motivation, etc. Sinead O’Connor goes to a place that is so raw and painful … the result is a voice that penetrates my soul. It hurts so much in what is equal parts pain and beauty. I watch this clip many times a year. It is special
Mantana !!!!!!;;
So sad she left us today. She will be remembered eternally for her gift to us. May she find peace everlasting!
Fantástica apresentação ao vivo !!! Sinead linda !com a coz de um anjo ....Descanse em paz... Sua obra ecoará nas paredes da eternidade ...todo som emitido pra sempre se propaga!!!!
big floyd fan, and I love this version, thank you sinead, for this and so much more
Jesus when you watch this you can see how much she respects this mob great job girl. You are the Queen.
There's a LOT of talent on that stage. Some aren't with us anymore but the gifts they left me with I'm forever grateful.
Godspeed Garth, Levon, Sinead. Forgive my ignorance if I left someone out.
Great you also recognized Robbie & Levon. They provided great backup on the song plus just being with her was supportive.
It's Rick Danko!@@shaykatz5648
Love you ever..sinead, you are always in my heart ❤...thank you for All your amazing and greatfull Songs ....its a great Song with pink floyd ..thank you ❤❤❤..and 🎉sleep well sweet😢😢😢
Such a beautiful performance one I wish I would have seen live. Thanks Sinead and Rogers. Such a beautiful voice and soul. RIP.
She had a set of lungs and her voice was as impactful on this song. As a Pink Floyd fan overall, when Roger really wanted to bring in acts to recreate his songs he was solid. But as a Gilmour fan it’s hard for me to say. But I give Roger his props when they are due. R.I.P. Sinead thanks for the memories
Why do you have to be a Gilmour OR Waters fan? Why can’t you appreciate both. I’ve seen both on many occasions and like what they do individually.
@@keithgrahammusicbecause Rogers is the reason PF broke up.
@@danielkaminske5048 Pink Floyd didn’t break up. Roger left. They made a few albums after he left.
Just doesn't get any better than this 🤩🤩
I was there, 19 years old, thrilled
I’ve always loved this song, I was blown away the first time seeing the wall video.
This version with the stunningly talented and beautiful Sinead O’Connor was something special at a special moment in history.
It’s really so cool and weird to see Garth Hudson and Sinead sharing the stage
What a line-up 🫶🏻 No one will ever touch the lyric/song writing talents of Mr. Waters imo. Always brings me out in goosebumps and often to tears. Legendary.
Was there, what a great show and many talents, gone to soon Sinead
Its amazing that 4 guys made this music. Sinead is awesome.
Mr. Waters. You made my life better
THIS IS THE VERY BEST RENDITION OF THIS SONG - THE OTHERS ARE GOOD MAKE NO MISTAKE BUT THIS IS THE VERY BEST!!!
R.I.P. Rick and Levon - filled my youth with many delights - Still do.
Sinned o Connor is such a beautiful soul !
That smile! That voice! R.i.Peace sweetheart.
OMG! The best Version ever!! 👍🏻 Just love ❤ it!!
I hope people will be listening to this 150 years from now. Please.
This song is so hauntingly beautiful it brings me to tears. Sinead so brave, talented & beautiful. Also I do believe that's Rick Danko & Levon Helm of THE BAND singing backup with Garth Hudson on accordion. RIP Sinead O'Connor ❤
Rick Danko. not Robbie
@@jeanlucpicard5794 ok gotcha & at times in some of the video's I had difficulty telling if it was Rick or Robbie. Considering stories of issues with Robbie, it makes sense it was Danko with Helm. Garth Hudson was featured on accordion. Just days after my posting that Robbie passed away.
@@jeanlucpicard5794 I edited my comment to show Rick.
Do not forget Sinead o Connor she is a legend ❤
We forget never Sinead RIP❤❤❤❤
this is the song # 1 in ml heart; especially this one !; because of Shuhadâ Sadaka...rest in peace Shuhadâ, may Allah (CC) have mercy on you !
She absolutely CRUSHED it. I remember watching this on MTV live while it happened and was blown away by all of it. But, she absolutely CRUSHED that song. I have this one in a few Spotify playlists. She was decades ahead of time.
Wo siehst oder fühlst du da Zerstörung ????? 😱
- Blessed memory, Sunny!...
Sinéad O'Connor nos deixou, mas nos trouxe muita alegria com suas músicas e composições. Vá em paz!
My mum was there and brought me back rocks from the wall. I wish the past in every country could be forgotten now and we put our every moment into our kids now.
Wow, I was at that concert. Huge production, massive crowd, mostly remember being on top of a shed or garage of some sort to see the stage. Saw the Stones the same week, it was a much smaller crowd and way more fun cause I had room to dance.
Con certeza, esta es la mejor interpretación de Mother.
El momento histórico, la reunión de los intérpretes y claro, el acierto de que Sinéad O'Connor haya sido la primera voz en esta canción; su personalidad, completamente en armonía con el tema.