Detroit's Short-Lived Kimball .30 Carbine Pistol

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 бер 2018
  • The J. Kimball Arms Company of Detroit introduced a semiauto pistol in 1955, chambered for the .30 Carbine cartridge - what better companion for the tactical uber weapon of the day, the M1 Carbine? Kimball’s pistol was styled heavily after the High Standard, and it looks good and handles well. The .30 Carbine cartridge is too powerful for a blowback pistol, however, and so Kimball needed some type of locked breech or delaying mechanism. He chose to cut an annular ring in the front of the chamber - the mouth of the brass would expand into this ring upon firing, and the force required to press it back down to the diameter of the chamber body would force the slide to remain closed long enough for pressure to drop to a safe level.
    However, the system was not adequate for the cartridge. The slide velocity was high enough that the guns very quickly battered the slide stop block. The would peen and deform at first, then crack, and eventually either bend to the point that the gun would not cycle, or break off and allow the slide to come right off the back of the frame. I can’t find any documentation of anyone actually injured in this way, but that was obviously the concern. Only between 250 and 300 of the pistols were made before the company went bankrupt and closed. There had been plans to expand the line to include gun in .38 Special, .357 Magnum, and .22 Hornet, but none of those went any farther than prototypes.
    / forgottenweapons
    Cool Forgotten Weapons merch! shop.bbtv.com/collections/forg...
    If you enjoy Forgotten Weapons, check out its sister channel, InRangeTV! / inrangetvshow
    Contact:
    Forgotten Weapons
    6281 N Oracle #36270
    Tucson, AZ 85704

КОМЕНТАРІ • 504

  • @MrFreddyFartface
    @MrFreddyFartface 3 роки тому +138

    "Who's the guy with the knight's helmet at the range?" - "That's Dan, he's trying out his new Kimball and doesn't know how many shots it has left until the slide slams into his face"

  • @malusignatius
    @malusignatius 6 років тому +354

    'Magazine looks flimsy, but hey, it's not like the gun's going to last...'
    Sassy Gunjesus is sassy.

    • @lycossurfer8851
      @lycossurfer8851 6 років тому +21

      The magazine will outlive the gun (or possibly the shooter)

    • @ScottKenny1978
      @ScottKenny1978 5 років тому +8

      Not like .30 Carbine mags were exactly long-lived, apparently.

    • @john-paulsilke893
      @john-paulsilke893 4 роки тому +5

      So sad because it’s a pretty sweet caliber. Probably too slow a burn for pistols however but there are many powders, so short barrel options are available. Timing matters more then engineering sometimes. Clearly this was a dead end and deserves to be so.

    • @paullytle1904
      @paullytle1904 4 роки тому +2

      THE PISTOL BROKE BEFORE THE MAGAZINE DID

  • @scoutrifle6827
    @scoutrifle6827 3 роки тому +151

    Ian: "The only gun where the physical position of the gun affects reassembly." Ruger Mk I/II/III .22 pistol: "Here, hold my beer."

    • @Qingeaton
      @Qingeaton 3 роки тому +10

      That is what my brain said too.

    • @quiettime6871
      @quiettime6871 3 роки тому +10

      If you know, you know

    • @AM-hf9kk
      @AM-hf9kk 3 роки тому +15

      Yep. Got my wife a Mk III 22/45. Sweet little gun, but damned if it isn't the worst thing to reassemble. You have to pump the trigger like a Holy Hand Grenade and hold your tongue just so with your pinky out to get that blasted hammer dingus in the right place for everything to snap back together. The only truly useful video I've found for the thing features a young girl... which is both emasculating and offers hope when you're struggling for fifteen minutes.
      There's also the Beretta / Stoeger Cougar, where you have to hold it upside down and offer a short prayer to the gun gods that the barrel doesn't rotate the wrong way and the cam block stays in the right position and hold your finger on the end of the barrel. Which brings to mind the three seashells of an S&W CS9, where the ejector and couple other random gizmos will never let the slide back on if you hold it upside down.

    • @longiusaescius2537
      @longiusaescius2537 Рік тому

      @A M huh

    • @davidharing6475
      @davidharing6475 8 місяців тому +1

      I made the mistake of dissembling a Ruger Mk I....it took a lot of UA-cam videos to figure how to put it back together....mistakes were made....

  • @langanjoseph
    @langanjoseph 6 років тому +69

    Looks like they could have used a "dream killer" on the design team
    That dude that does the math and has to give everyone the bad news

    • @DonMeaker
      @DonMeaker 3 роки тому +5

      Reliability Engineer: Job is to call other people's baby "Ugly" in quantitative way.

    • @fablesguykol3025
      @fablesguykol3025 3 роки тому

      @@DonMeaker wait....I could be getting paid to do this shit?!

    • @johndallman2692
      @johndallman2692 3 роки тому +1

      @@fablesguykol3025 Yes, if you can show convincingly how a design is bad. I've done this a few times, and good engineering companies do not get cross with employees about it.

    • @fablesguykol3025
      @fablesguykol3025 3 роки тому

      @@johndallman2692 I meant this as a joke of "I can be an asshole to people and get paid for it" but that actually seems kinda cool.

  • @jballew2239
    @jballew2239 6 років тому +152

    I have had the chance to fire one of these.
    It was "snappy". To be kind.
    All in all the piece felt very much like someone scaled up a Colt Huntsman, but left out the "quality". Yes, the magazine felt like they said "Oh, right, we need to have a mag fit in here." after the chips had been made.
    Of note, the one disassembled in the vid is a later production version, with the shallow "fluting" in the chamber behind the "ring", an attempt to further delay the opening of the breech, added after problems were noted with the earlier versions.
    If one ever needed a good example of "Afterthought Engineering", the Kimball would suffice.

    • @RandomGuy9
      @RandomGuy9 8 місяців тому +2

      How did the cases look like after shooting? Did they show signs of overpressure or was the "locking mechanism" enough?

    • @jballew2239
      @jballew2239 8 місяців тому +1

      @@RandomGuy9 Never saw signs of overpressure, but it was not kind to the cases (it's ejection could be termed "energetic") As .30 Carbine is a very stout case, this may have helped the design somewhat. Occasionally a split near the case mouth, but this could be attributed to the handloads it was being fed.

  • @MrStrangelymade
    @MrStrangelymade 6 років тому +126

    I had annular ring once, but some suppositories soon sorted it.

  • @gonshocks
    @gonshocks 6 років тому +181

    That must be a real flame thrower. I have a Ruger revolver in .30 carbine with a long barrel but because of the slower burning rifle powder used in the cartridge there's a lot of unburnt powder
    coming out of the muzzle forming a fireball.

    • @gonshocks
      @gonshocks 6 років тому +14

      You're right about how loud it is. Louder than my S&W 44mag.

    • @georgekeith9928
      @georgekeith9928 6 років тому +17

      The .30 carbine black hawk is my favourite single action to shoot. Not really all that useful but damn fun.

    • @gonshocks
      @gonshocks 6 років тому +6

      I agree, I had a bolo Broomhandle. Flashbang!!

    • @mikearmstrong7830
      @mikearmstrong7830 6 років тому +27

      I have had the repeated experience of setting up at a pistol range with the Blackhawk 30carbine. I would be asked what I was shooting and after responding, watch people remove their hearing protection and kick back. After firing a round, I would witness a mad scramble to grab the protection while being called a liar. I have never thought it prudent to call someone names while that someone was holding a pistol. I did understand their inability to think clearly while that damn ringing was lingering. Out of a carbine, the sound is manageable. But from the pistol, oh my. I witnessed an individual, obviously suicidal, carrying a Blackhawk 30carbine cut down to 3 inches. He asked if I wished to try it. I started to answer him but realized he would never hear me.

    • @Borsia
      @Borsia 6 років тому +5

      I had that same Ruger and it was one of my favorite shooters loved it. Very accurate with that long barrel and cheap to shoot. Quite a light show shooting at night

  • @AlaskanQueenInExile
    @AlaskanQueenInExile 6 років тому +300

    So, in theory, it'd flare out the case and then reform it. This sounds like a reloaders nightmare.

    • @Easy-Eight
      @Easy-Eight 6 років тому +88

      There was so much cheap .30 cal ammo during the 50s & 60s that would have not been an issue. It would have been like reloading 7.62 x 39 AK ammo during the glory days of the mid-90s. As a kid I can remember going into gun shops and they had wooden barrels of odd surplus ammo, thirty ought six for example, and you could get a bag of ammo like peanuts. This is from over 50 years past. Those days are long gone.

    • @tz8785
      @tz8785 6 років тому +42

      OTOH as a reloader you can probably shoot these guns and make them last a lot longer by using a smaller powder charge.

    • @whyjay9959
      @whyjay9959 6 років тому +17

      Smaller charges would be more suitable for these short barrels too...

    • @PostalPatriot556
      @PostalPatriot556 6 років тому +17

      Bill H oh man that sounds amazing.. like the mosin, and 7.62x54r. I remember mid 2000s when you could get them for under 100 bucks. I wasn't old enough at the time though. I wish prices would drop again. My dad got a whole case of 7.62x54r for dirt cheap back then.. But nothing's cheap in the fire arms world now a days.

    • @derblip4608
      @derblip4608 6 років тому +17

      Saibot Saibot a smaller powder charge could lead to less pressure and the case mouth would not bend enough into the ring to delay the action safely 😲

  • @AlfaPegasii
    @AlfaPegasii 6 років тому +53

    I wonder what would have happened if Kimball was around long enough to succumb to the .50 Cal craze? That action on .50 BMG would be awesome.

    • @john-paulsilke893
      @john-paulsilke893 4 роки тому +5

      Maybe. Much like politics many people get into it to change the world but unfortunately fall short. Timing is everything and if the Hudson H9 came out 5 years from now we’d all be singing it’s phrases. Iteration is nearly as important as engineering.

  • @sethshacklettShacksGunsmithing
    @sethshacklettShacksGunsmithing 6 років тому +112

    It looks like a giant Colt Woodsman/Huntsman.
    Even the disassembly is similar.
    So lesson learned : don't take a simple .22LR pistol and upscale it to accommodate a Rifle cartridge.

    • @CiastoToKlamstwo
      @CiastoToKlamstwo 4 роки тому

      *25ACP

    • @fontaineking5158
      @fontaineking5158 4 роки тому

      @BW MadDog [retired] The Woodsman/Huntsman are my favorite .22 There was one in the Lincolin Lawyer with Matthew Mconahey

    • @austinm.9832
      @austinm.9832 3 роки тому +3

      @@CiastoToKlamstwo .22 LR, they were designed for target shooting, not self defense.

    • @greycatturtle7132
      @greycatturtle7132 Рік тому

      True

  • @JohnLeePedimore
    @JohnLeePedimore 6 років тому +40

    It's been a while since I took apart a Ruger Mk I but I seem to recall that re-assembly required a unique orientation and a very specific set of swears.
    The .30 carbine has the same case length as the .357 mag(1.290'') but a slightly higher max pressure. The .30 carbine is most often compared to the .357 in muzzle energy which is true but most .30 carbine data is collected from rifle length barrels and most .357 data is from a 4''-6'' barrel. When you compare apples to apples the .30 carbine is closer to the .327 Federal magnum.
    Back when those guns were made there was TONS of surplus ball ammo but today that has all dried up forcing it's users to pay a premium or reload their own. Hornady now makes the .30 carbine in their Critical Defense line.

    • @merlemorrison482
      @merlemorrison482 6 років тому +2

      I too was remembering the Ruger MK 1 pistols......

    • @mazkact
      @mazkact 6 років тому +4

      Until the introduction of Ruger's MK IV series some found it difficult to reassemble them, the hammer strut must be in the right place. It's really not all that hard if you read the manual , gravity is your friend.

    • @davidlamppert9093
      @davidlamppert9093 6 років тому +2

      Yes, I got a used Ruger without paperwork, and it took me forever to get it back together!

    • @ASAPLocksmith
      @ASAPLocksmith 6 років тому +4

      lol Ian forgets disassembly procedure of the most popular .22lr in the united states ever.

    • @williambell7763
      @williambell7763 6 років тому +1

      FORMAN ASAP Locksmith .Los Angeles Well it's not forgotten by the masses, so Ian kinda forgot about it...

  • @werewally3156
    @werewally3156 6 років тому +5

    my pops and I reloaded .30 carbine and one of the problems he warned me about was the tendency for the brass to sometimes not resize properly, not allowing it to fully go into battery, and the m1 carbine would still fire regardless. that happening in the Kimball would be a disaster. gives me shivers.

  • @jonathonschram3429
    @jonathonschram3429 6 років тому +6

    I actually have quite a bit of experience with one of these. I believe it must be a later example than the one because it seems to have a different magazine release and and a beefier "toggle lock thingy" that retains the slide. My friends dad owned a gun shop and it sat unsold for years before he just decided "buy" it himself.
    We loaded some mild 113gr Lee and 110gr Lyman cast loads and played with it for a while. Cool idea, but I can see why it didn't work out commercially. Even mild loads are fairly snappy if you load them powerful enough to cycle the pistol. The Lee boolits hang up pretty regularly out of the mag.
    It was fun to shoot, but certainly not the most accurate autoloader in the world. I don't remember brass being too beat up, but a decent number of the reloads will split cases.
    I could have sworn it was called a King...but there is no mistaking it was the same pistol as the example above. Had I known how few were made I might have tried to weasel it into my collection and preserve it.
    I'll let my friend know about this video next time I see him. Thanks for this interesting upload!

  • @WinterCedar
    @WinterCedar 6 років тому +10

    As a michigander, it's too bad this never took off! I'd love to own one of these.

  • @urbanwikstrom9246
    @urbanwikstrom9246 6 років тому +49

    Thanks Forgotten Weapons.
    I, sincerely hope that Forgotten Weapons will have a place on You tube.
    Thanks Ian.
    You`re doing a fantastic job.
    Cheers!

    •  6 років тому +1

      Urban Wikström they are going after all the weapons channels, liberals are dominant in the Tech Industry.

  • @Easy-Eight
    @Easy-Eight 6 років тому +58

    This pistol caused me not to buy a Universal M1 Carbine from Kmart back in the 70s. Why? In my state you had to be 18 to buy pistol ammo during the 1970s and I could buy the rifle and not the ammo. Why? The stores at the time had to keep track of the .30 caliber ammo sales. The clerk at the Kmart counter could not sell me the ammo for the rifle because it could be used in a pistol. Kmart would sell a 17 year old a rifle in 1976. 70s' logic.

    • @otm646
      @otm646 6 років тому +9

      Either the law has changed since then or the clerk was incorrect.

    • @Easy-Eight
      @Easy-Eight 6 років тому +7

      OTM, as a 16 year old kid I'd buy ammo for my 12 gauge. Nobody cared. I'd go into town to the local hardware store & they had a book full of all the .22, .38, and the rest of the pistol ammo sales. My state changed the laws for non-registration of pistol ammo sales in the early '80s.

    • @michaelmoorrees3585
      @michaelmoorrees3585 6 років тому +5

      You could get the Ruger Blackhawk revolver, in 30 carbine, since the late 60's, so don't blame this gun.
      These Kimballs will probably be "shelf queens", and never fired. Display them next to any "Kyber Pass", specials.

    • @tedkier3264
      @tedkier3264 6 років тому +2

      easy eight youre still harboring a grudge because if you had purchased an m1 carbine 50 years back it would have been slightly harder for you to procure ammo ? but just until '71?

    • @achillebelanger9866
      @achillebelanger9866 4 роки тому +1

      Universal carbines kinda sucked...universilly.

  • @Dsdcain
    @Dsdcain 6 років тому +142

    Nice looking gun though. So what if you potentially take a slide to the face as long as your gun looks cool.

    • @Rudofaux
      @Rudofaux 6 років тому +5

      Axel Pingol woosh

    • @TheRogueWolf
      @TheRogueWolf 6 років тому +16

      "I may have a cracked skull, but I still also have most of a sweet-lookin' gun!"

    • @amigi968
      @amigi968 6 років тому +1

      It's called humor. There are some how-to videos here on youtube you can use.

    • @RRVCrinale
      @RRVCrinale 6 років тому

      Dsdcain So THIS is where Ubisoft got the idea for Far Cry 2...

    • @joshglover2370
      @joshglover2370 5 років тому

      You know it's bad when you have to bring a helmet when you go shooting! 😅

  • @andrewshirley2485
    @andrewshirley2485 6 років тому +1

    Just gotta say I love this guy he is soooo awsome and I love watching him show how older guns work

  • @gvente87
    @gvente87 6 років тому

    It's videos like this that I like the most. I had never heard of an annular ring delayed blow back until now. Interesting designs like this are the best. Reminds me of the Pancor Jackhammer video- another unique and interesting design.

  • @hoodyk7342
    @hoodyk7342 6 років тому

    Awesome and informative as always glad i watch early

  • @M1911Guy
    @M1911Guy 6 років тому

    I shutter slightly, looks a lot like my Conn. High Standard Sport King. Almost got out the pistol to check and make sure it was still a HS, they look so much alike overall. Great vids, awesome work.

  • @falloutlover5443
    @falloutlover5443 6 років тому

    That's one of the coolest extractors I've seen.

  • @gavin3488
    @gavin3488 6 років тому +1

    It is a beauty, I love that shape and design.

  • @gunner678
    @gunner678 6 років тому +1

    Perfect description of the M1 carbine. This pistol looks like the Nambu.

  • @TheGearhead222
    @TheGearhead222 3 роки тому +2

    Another great video, Ian! This gun SO reminds me of the original Ruger Standard Mk. 1 pistol. As you probably know, it requires one to hold the gun at a unique angle so that the hammer stirrup (what I call it) nests correctly in the scallop of the grip retaining clip (another made up word;). A real bugger with a long learning curve IMHO, as it allows the gun to be reassembled but not working if done incorrectly. My dollars worth-John in Texas

  • @dominob2343
    @dominob2343 6 років тому

    Ian !!!! You ROCK THE GUNS!!!! Good job

  • @tedkier3264
    @tedkier3264 5 років тому

    thank you for this posting,ian. someone tried to sell me one of these before. i showed him my own annular ring in response.

  • @thaddeuscarpenter1580
    @thaddeuscarpenter1580 5 років тому

    It looks like a simplified high standard, sans the lever actuated block. It also eliminates the primary malfunction issue with the high standard.

  • @thegoldencaulk2742
    @thegoldencaulk2742 6 років тому +278

    This is off topic, but you should update the Forgotten Weapons logo to a higher res version when you get the chance. It's lookin' a little pixel-y.

    • @RebSike
      @RebSike 6 років тому +121

      "do I look like I know what a jpeg is?"

    • @wierdalien1
      @wierdalien1 6 років тому +3

      RebSike you need a TIFF

    • @mrb692
      @mrb692 6 років тому +22

      Alistair Shaw, but all he wants is a picture of a gosh danged hot dog

    • @wierdalien1
      @wierdalien1 6 років тому +3

      mrb692 ahahaha. Then he will get a high res uncompressed hot dog

    • @jantekina5238
      @jantekina5238 6 років тому +12

      to be fair, your comments are almost always off topic

  • @SNOUPS4
    @SNOUPS4 6 років тому +4

    The view of the barrel with the flashlight is really nice; maybe try to do it more often, if if here it was useful to point out the (theoretically-)delaying ring, it's also cool to just be able to see the rifling so nicely... but the lighting strategy only works out nicely with short barreled firearms I presume...

  • @Taistelukalkkuna
    @Taistelukalkkuna 6 років тому +31

    Words "Slide to forehead" come to mind.

    • @frankatchison1617
      @frankatchison1617 6 років тому +1

      Taistelukalkkuna at arm's length i think you'd be o.k.

  • @submitandresist3399
    @submitandresist3399 6 років тому +1

    Thanks for this lm from Detroit (Dtown) never knew about this weapon.

  • @toolthoughts
    @toolthoughts 6 років тому +2

    Cheers, I've been wondering about these!

  • @RyTrapp0
    @RyTrapp0 6 років тому

    Wow! I've never heard Ian be so complimentary of the .30 carbine!
    Unique little pistol, too bad they just didn't really work, I would love to have one to go with my carbine.

  • @estudiom142
    @estudiom142 2 роки тому

    Slick lines... love them!! Cheers!

  • @lanedexter6303
    @lanedexter6303 5 років тому +3

    Wow. Long ago, I made the mistake of beginning reloading with 9mm instead of a .38 revolver. I learned a lot. I recall the differences in factory brass, both in hardness and in thickness. This gun scares me just a bit.

  • @MauldtheMan
    @MauldtheMan 6 років тому +1

    The Seecamp has a similar delaying mechanism in its operation, too; it's ring, however, is near the back of the chamber.

  • @xioix5758
    @xioix5758 6 років тому

    Disassembly gives me flashbacks of learning how to disassemble/ reassemble the Ruger Mk series rimfire pistols.

  • @Dakktyrel
    @Dakktyrel 6 років тому +10

    This is literally a High Standard B in .30 cal. I'm surprised Kimball got away with this without raising their attention.

    • @bstrachan8527
      @bstrachan8527 3 роки тому +1

      At least High Standard provided an external lever to raise/lower that slide stop. Mucho better.

    • @VMEMotor5
      @VMEMotor5 3 роки тому +1

      It was so poorly made and disappeared from the market so quick, HS, probably figured why bother. It will implode on it's own.

    • @deaconblue949
      @deaconblue949 3 роки тому +4

      And the High Standard B was just a copy of the first series Colt Woodsman after the patents expired

    • @floydvaughn836
      @floydvaughn836 3 роки тому

      High Standard lawyers: let's sue. High Standard gunsmith: I've looked at it. Don't bother....

  • @BLECHHAUS
    @BLECHHAUS 6 років тому +5

    The .30 Carbine cartridge in a handgun, may it Pistol or Revolver, is - cool.

  • @kenhelmers2603
    @kenhelmers2603 6 років тому

    Perfect example of 'bad designs go away..." Thanks Ian :)

  • @prjndigo
    @prjndigo 6 років тому +21

    Cool disassembly mechanic, it looks like he was headed towards a further design and tried to produce an incomplete development. If the rear slide hooks were on a pivot against a very strong spring to accept the impact the gun would probably have been workable. If it had a gas blowback delay it would likely have lasted several decades.

  • @therealinak
    @therealinak 6 років тому

    Angle matters on the Ruger Mk.1-3 for sure. The hammer has to be manually pushed up into the fired position and the hammer spur has to be forward (done by putting the pistol barrel down) but not resting above the pin running through the grip frame for the hammer spring assembly/backstrap/takedown pin and lever piece to go in properly. You also may have trouble removing the bolt if the barrel isn't up, as the hammer spur will catch behind said pin and not allow the hammer to fall backwards.
    Takes a properly set jaw and and holding the pistol at the right angle.

  • @warped8425
    @warped8425 6 років тому +1

    Ian, two things. 1st, please do an AMT Automag III. I have one, love it and it throws an awesome fireball. 2nd, AMT Automag II uses dimpleing in the chamber to delay blowback of the .22 WMR to make it cycle right. Similar to the annular ring in this gun except the Automag functions flawlessly every time.

  • @22tanmay
    @22tanmay 5 років тому

    Thanks for another nice find Ian. The slide on this one, especially the button on top locking the recoil sporing in its compressed position, is a copy of the 22LR High Standard Model B. In the model B however the rotating slide stop is controlled by a small rotating lever on the right of the frame. The firing pin, recoil spring (the Model B has only one) hammer and trigger are all copied from the Model B. The slide stop is indeed the weakest part of the design, the reason why high velocity 22 ammo cannot be fired in the Hi Standard model B without damaging the gun. No wonder the 30 cal Kimball failed.

  • @swagner58
    @swagner58 6 років тому

    I'm thinking that muzzle blast and flash with that would be borderline awesome

  • @Digitalmindseye
    @Digitalmindseye 3 роки тому

    Not really a military firearm but another interesting Detroit firearm was the Mauser-Bauer over under shotgun. Made in Italy for Mauser, imported by Bauer...pretty guns. Would love to see a video on this!

  • @joshdude2137
    @joshdude2137 5 років тому

    paused at 6:27... the ruger 22/45 mark 3 i know for sure has to be tilted to reassemble it, just putin that out there, love your videos man.

  • @vguyver2
    @vguyver2 6 років тому +6

    This is one of those firearms that actually would have benefited in it's design with use of a weaker cartridge, but that destroys the purpose of this model.

  • @psjasker
    @psjasker 4 місяці тому

    “…a lot more conducive to questionable delaying mechanisms …”. Hahah - Ian has a way with words

  • @MikeDCWeld
    @MikeDCWeld 6 років тому +1

    I bet someone could design a replacement recoil spring set that would slow the slide down sufficiently to alleviate the issue of it battering the back end to destruction. Widening and/or deepening the annular ring might help too.

  • @ZGryphon
    @ZGryphon 4 роки тому

    Upon rewatching, I empathize with the Kimball pistol. I, too, have some interesting engineering features that don't work quite the way they're supposed to.

  • @esrvdb88
    @esrvdb88 6 років тому +3

    The Ruger Standard series (until the new mkiv I think.) require you to use gravity on reassembly, but not on disassembly for that you just need cussing and threatening looks.

  • @skorpius752
    @skorpius752 4 роки тому

    Something people who design guns like these never get is that you need a much faster powder for a .30 carbine going out of a 6" barrel than for going out of a 16" barrel. So even if they can delay the recoil enough, the cartridge is still woefully inefficient in the shorter barrel.

  • @Beanpapac15
    @Beanpapac15 6 років тому

    It’s like one of those puzzle boxes, you gotta hold it just right and shake it to get it open

  • @andrewjacobson243
    @andrewjacobson243 6 років тому +11

    Do an amt!!! They had a 30 carbine auto pistol

  • @BigElCat
    @BigElCat 3 роки тому

    That is sooo cool ! They should have cut multiple annular rings, a trial and error engineering, until it worked. I'm thinking three of them would have done it. Rumpled case spitting out.

  • @stanleystrycharz2572
    @stanleystrycharz2572 3 роки тому +1

    AMT made a .30 semi-auto pistol too. Built like a 1911. Worked fine, was very loud and had a lot of flame. Just fun at the range! :D not so good for anything else.

  • @stacybrown3714
    @stacybrown3714 6 років тому

    I think that the AMT auto mag II 22 MAG used a row of holes in the chamber in a similar Manor to this expansion ring. They also made a 30 carbine that I think worked.

    • @christopherconard2831
      @christopherconard2831 3 роки тому +1

      I've had both in 22Mag and 30 Carbine. They worked fine, but the Automag III (30 Carbine) worked longer. The 22 version was very dirt/fouling sensitive. 5-8 magazines was the maximum I could do before disassembly and cleaning.

  • @agentmango
    @agentmango 6 років тому

    Haha, another example of a pistol that involves geometric position for disassembly and/or reassembly is the Ruger 22/45 Mk II. I always need to reread the manual when I'm working on that one!

  • @JohnDoe-pv2iu
    @JohnDoe-pv2iu 5 років тому

    How could any designer look at this and say that's a Good idea??? Great video.

  • @witmoreluke
    @witmoreluke 3 роки тому

    Y'know, for a less powerful cartridge that disassembly mechanism is actually pretty slick to be an original design.

  • @millwaterpublishing1387
    @millwaterpublishing1387 6 років тому +1

    Assembly / disassembly reminds me a little of my Ruger 22/45 (m2)... Some telekinesis required.
    I suppose if someone really wanted to shoot one of those, they could experiment with lighter powder loads, get it down to something a light blowback pistol could handle.

  • @J.DeLaPoer
    @J.DeLaPoer 5 років тому +2

    Looks like an overgrown Hi-Standard .22... and to go by my HD Military at least, disassembly is done exactly the same way via button system.

    • @deniscurran7288
      @deniscurran7288 4 роки тому

      Looks like the same internal design too, with just a token regard for much higher forces. Predictable result.

  • @danirizary6926
    @danirizary6926 6 років тому

    I'd like to see a fired case. I remember one of these floating around the gun shows, "back in the day". IIRC steel case ammo was problematic in them.

  • @lptomtom
    @lptomtom 6 років тому +21

    I guess shooting .30 Carbine from that small Combat variant wasn't the most pleasant experience...

    • @ostiariusalpha
      @ostiariusalpha 6 років тому +4

      Anyone masochistic enough to own a S&W Model 629 snubbie, probably wouldn't be put off by the Kimball Combat.

    • @amigi968
      @amigi968 6 років тому +1

      That cartridge is just a little more powerful than a .357 pistol load. ATM makes The Automag chambered in .30 carbine. Not a terrible round to shoot. It might not be fun from this pistol in this video, however.

    • @ostiariusalpha
      @ostiariusalpha 6 років тому

      +keith moore AMT is still very much defunct, but Excell Arms has started a company called Auto Mag Ltd. Corp. to produce a high quality model of the AutoMag chambered in .44 AMP. There doesn't seem to be any plans to bring back the .30 Carbine AutoMag III version.

  • @ghettoxprepper3138
    @ghettoxprepper3138 6 років тому

    Very very cool!

  • @kenibnanak5554
    @kenibnanak5554 6 років тому

    It needed a 2nd annular ring behind the first, also a stiffer recoil spring set. :)

  • @ruskgaming6019
    @ruskgaming6019 6 років тому +26

    It looks like a 1911 with the slide locked back

    • @d4ngru5h83
      @d4ngru5h83 6 років тому +1

      Rusk Gaming yeah, that's why they seemed familiar looking

    • @odinvik7821
      @odinvik7821 6 років тому

      yeah kinda

    • @joejoelesh1197
      @joejoelesh1197 6 років тому +1

      Rusk Gaming are you a member of the media?

    • @ruskgaming6019
      @ruskgaming6019 6 років тому

      what?

    • @joejoelesh1197
      @joejoelesh1197 6 років тому +1

      Rusk Gaming, this gun and the 1911 share the same passing resemblance that all long guns used in a shooting share with the murderous Ar15. Well, to members of the media, they are all the same.

  • @GinSoakedBoy
    @GinSoakedBoy 6 років тому

    Speaking of 30. cal, hoping a Knight's Armament Revolver Rifle, if indeed one still exists out there, pops up on one of these auctions one day so Ian can do a video on it.

  • @russbilzing5348
    @russbilzing5348 Рік тому

    There was, if I recall correctly, a .22 Magnum auto-pistol that used a variation on the annular chamber ring. It was in the form of hemispherical pits in the chamber, designed for the very same purpose. Between the small area and the typical ,22's ability to foul things, they required scrupulous cleaning and rapidly achieved an unfavorable sort of reputation. I just wish I could remember it's name or that of it's maker.

  • @Destructoglitch
    @Destructoglitch 6 років тому

    Am I the only one that thinks the disassembly is pretty slick?

  • @hassenfepher
    @hassenfepher 6 років тому

    So. Physical position affecting dissasembly of the gun. I propose gen 1 ruger lc9. There is a dissasembly pin retained by a dropping gate. you drop the gate. Hold the pistol, left side down. Then giggle the slide to loosen the dissasembly pin and it drops out.

  • @GIR9595
    @GIR9595 6 років тому

    That slide disassembly button works a bit like the Colt Woodsman in that it disables the spring

  • @stevebrown8745
    @stevebrown8745 5 років тому

    Design the frame around the right spring set up and that cal. would take off. I so love that round and to have in reliable pistol form would be the coolest thing. I don't see why every company tried and failed to make this. There is no documented cases of slide slap. Probably the competition giving a company a bad rep.

  • @Qingeaton
    @Qingeaton 4 роки тому +1

    Looks very much to me like my high standard .22 HD Military, which I love.
    Too bad they didn't rework it into something useable.
    I wonder if we will ever get to the point where opposing magnet force will be used as dampening?

  • @EDSKaR
    @EDSKaR 6 років тому +8

    What happens if, during assembly, you loose the recoil springs when the block at the back is in the downward position? I assume it would not function in this condition, but can you dissasemble it to fix the problem?
    Also, what happens if mud/dust gets inside and the block gets stuck in the upwards position?
    Even in a sensible calibre, I see too many ways to make this gun permanently inoperable...

    • @PatienceDepleted
      @PatienceDepleted 6 років тому +5

      It looks like that pivoting piece against the springs is the only thing holding it together. If it was down, and somehow the springs got knocked loose, the slide should still just come back off. It would probably be a pain to compress the springs again outside of the gun though.

    • @EDSKaR
      @EDSKaR 6 років тому +3

      I think you might be right actually. So it would only be 'unassemblable' if the piece got stuck.

  • @TJGUNSBESTCHANNEL
    @TJGUNSBESTCHANNEL 6 років тому

    REVELLI grooves..first thing what comes to mind

  • @finnmcool2
    @finnmcool2 3 роки тому

    Jiggle the parts into place is a phrase I doubt you hear in engineering school very often.

  • @geometro9512
    @geometro9512 5 років тому

    Seecamps use a similar delayed blowback action. Still in production.

  • @RaymondPeter
    @RaymondPeter 6 років тому

    I was literally reading about these last night before bed.

  • @USSEnterpriseA1701
    @USSEnterpriseA1701 6 років тому

    Seems to me the older versions of the Ruger .22 pistols need to be held certain ways to be disassembled and reassembled to get the hammer into the correct position once the mainspring has been removed. Considering the Ruger was from 1949 originally and this is from the 50's, it stands to reason that at one time, this was a perfectly acceptable step in pistol disassembly.

  • @nc_classics_9610
    @nc_classics_9610 6 років тому

    Kimball must have been a fan on the FG-42 to come up with that delayed blowback system.

  • @rickdsr
    @rickdsr 6 років тому

    A buddy of mine had a couple of those , said that if you fired into the ground near yourself , the fireball would light the grass on fire .

  • @me3333
    @me3333 6 років тому

    That looks like a nightmare if the spring lock button gets released while the slide is off the frame

  • @ozdavemcgee2079
    @ozdavemcgee2079 3 роки тому +1

    Nice looking l8nes and looks friendly to us of huge hands. Would have been cool if (a) it worked (b) it took M1 mags

  • @whyjay9959
    @whyjay9959 6 років тому +2

    At 41.91mm, that's the longest cartridge I know of that fits into a pistol grip.

  • @laughingdaffodils5450
    @laughingdaffodils5450 6 років тому +1

    Thanks for the video! I always thought it was a shame there are no good pistols made for the round. At least if there are I haven't seen one. The Kimball clearly wasn't sufficient. There's the Blackhawk which is a fine revolver but I'd just as soon have .357 in a revolver. Did anyone else attempt this? Why have I never seen a Desert Eagle in this round?

  • @tangero3462
    @tangero3462 6 років тому

    That grip angle looks like a feed angle nightmare for 30 carbine

  • @4991Ares
    @4991Ares 6 років тому

    I wonder if a design like this would work with 9mm or .45 instead of the much more powerful .30 Carbine. It looks really simple to make, it has a stationary barrel for good accuracy, it might come in lighter than a Hi-Point, and less powerful cartridges would certainly make it less explodey than it's current configuration.

  • @keithallardice6139
    @keithallardice6139 3 роки тому +2

    Cool idea and a fantastic cartridge BUT ...... but .... but .... no.
    The '21 Mann pistol video brought me here - blessed are the followers of GJ

  • @CurmudgeonExtraordinaire
    @CurmudgeonExtraordinaire 3 роки тому

    And since the .30 carbine is a rifle cartridge, it's using a slower burning powder than you would normally load in a handgun cartridge. As such, if you were reloading for a .30 carbine handgun like this with a relatively short barrel, you might want to choose a faster pistol powder and develop your load from there while not exceeding the maximum allowed chamber pressure... I reload for quite a few different calibers, but unfortunately, I never bought an M1, so I don't reload for it...

  • @davidgrover5996
    @davidgrover5996 6 років тому

    Every thing that annoys me about the Hi Standard with added danger, a unique disassembly, and a operating system I do not own. I may have to get one!
    Edit: I bet it works great with Wolf .30 carbine ammo!

  • @richardanderson2742
    @richardanderson2742 3 роки тому

    Highlighting why some firearms are really, really, really, best forgotten.

  • @stevenbaker8184
    @stevenbaker8184 3 роки тому

    It looks like a gun that would have been used in the "Death Wish" movie series. As a bad guy with a death wish taking the slide to the face. On a serious note, it is an early Thompson contender type idea.Firing rifle cartridges via sidearm.Also keeping in the same relative general idea of the 10ga. Revolver shotgun pistol, the old .45-70 Cavalry pistols made by Remington, and the Modern day BFR. No practical purpose except hunting accident waiting to happen, shooting things that would require a really big gun before it makes lunch of you.

  • @maxman1602
    @maxman1602 6 років тому

    Not sure why anyone would see the need to delay .25 ACP. It's a very low pressure round, so direct blowback works fine.

  • @CannaCJ
    @CannaCJ 3 роки тому

    Over-obturation delayed? Fascinating stuff.

  • @ethanarias2911
    @ethanarias2911 3 роки тому

    Huh, cut that barrel flush with the slide and chop the grip down a bit and that looks like a pretty crazy pocket gun

  • @StenCheesemonger
    @StenCheesemonger 6 років тому

    Delayed blowback is one those things that while simple end up being more complicated than a complex solution... mainly because instead of answering the question "how we wait enough for the pressure drop and then unlock?" it answers "how in God's name we keep this from either not working or blowing up?" it has some very interesting advantages but also a narrow operating envelope.

  • @Sube-Tube
    @Sube-Tube 4 роки тому

    It seems like it would be good for a smaller cartridge. Seems well enough designed to handle like. 32 or something