The Unresolved Mystery of Murtaza Bhutto’s Murder
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 лис 2021
- On 20th September 1996, Mir Murtaza Bhutto, the brother of then Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, was killed as a result of a shootout between the police and his gunmen. Dr Shoaib Suddle, who was the DIG Karachi at that time, shares details of the event and controversies that followed.
Watch the full episode: • Police Officer Fightin...
TCM’s five-year journey has been about telling stories that people want to hear which mainstream media has been neglecting for decades. We want to disrupt the status quo by delivering engaging content which empowers impassioned voices and impacts social change. We are defined by integrity, grit and ingenuity and this is what makes us do what we do.
Support independent journalism in Pakistan and get exclusive access to the full-length version of our videos: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Subscribe to TCM Original: bit.ly/2A3pOXz
Subscribe to TCM: bit.ly/2Tu6AkW
-------------------
Follow us on
Facebook: / tcmoriginalsofficial
Facebook: / thecentrummedia
Facebook: / centrumenter. .
Tiktok: / tcmoriginals
Twitter: / thecentrummedia
Instagram: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Join our Facebook community: bit.ly/35oeLVs
-------------------
Website: thecentrummedia.com
-------------------
About The Centrum Media
The Centrum Media (TCM) has the credit of Pakistan’s first digital news operation specializing in visual storytelling. Being a premier online platform, TCM strives to enhance the online experience of the new generation, ranging from hard news to feature stories. TCM creates original content and curates simultaneously from multiple sources.
We will take you where the real stories happen but often go untold and unseen in the shortest possible time having more information. Unlike the traditional media, TCM aims at sharing diverse stories across multi-platforms aimed at the people who consume news through mobile and social stream. We take up the challenge in the digital arena to present the news in the most imaginative and innovative ways.
Your on-the-go lifestyle forces us to bring the news directly to your pocket devices.
TCM should have a response video from the victim's perspective. Invite Fatima Bhutto or survivors from this incident.
Kabhi bhi nahi.... TCM is not showing neutral account
100% agreed
This is a sitting IG talking, whose team killed Mir Murtaza Bhutto. He is making a total idiot of himself. Its impossible to digest that he had either had no idea or he is lying.
He is telling lie.
You are absolutely right
Jhoot bol raha hey sala, chutiya samajhta hey sab ko
Benazir ny khud marwaya apny bhai ko
Ager sial suicide ki thi to aap ne us k pillow se gun kaise nikal li jab goli lag ne k bad to wo khatam ho
Gia
Tha
It would be a huge diservice to the people if TCM doesn't cover Fatima Bhuttos take on this.
They will never, because they are part of it. Deep pockets
He thinks people are nuts to believe in his concocted story that the only eyewitness committed suicide. The SHO involved was killed with his own pistol while he was being guarded by four security personnel. Murtaza was alive for two hours after being hit but they did not take him to a well equipped hospital. I mean there are hospitals in every corner of the city, how long does it take to shift a fatally injured person to another hospital specially when there is almost no traffic?
Moreover, there are thousands of people who have their guards armed with state of the art weapons, nobody goes after them. Plus he admitted that they were carrying licensed weapons but still police specifically target them. Where in the world does that happen? Why was police after him when it was proved that he owned those weapons. I have become sceptical of Bibi’s role in this. Why does the whole investigation give this impression that she was complicit in this fiasco and that she hid the truth to protect herself and her children.
This whole story sounds more like a underworld Bollywood saga than a real life even. The police officers were certainly killed by their colleagues who were on payroll of their masters. And expecting the culprits to investigate themselves is probably the biggest joke of the century. In west, even in our country, when a police officer is accused of anything they are suspended until the enquiry in completed and they come out clean. The culprit are still at large and reaping the rewards of their crimes by being promoted to highest position and granted ministerial positions in the governments.
Murtaza was involved in suspicious activities. It is very likely that his gunman fired shot at police party. He was arrogant brother of sitting PM. Guards were aware of impunity they had.
BTW This gun culture came after 9/11.
One tererist die like a dog why you ppl thinking about him he kill to many Pakistanis in bumb blasts he was son of bitch
Dr Shoaib Suddle was the Commanding Officer of the police Party. He was instrumental in this assassination. Asif Zardari is afraid of this person
bhai agli dafa urdu main commt kia kar, takey humme saamajh aye tere sir main kia chal raha hain,,tere kon sa ye commt BBC main dekhya jaiyega jo english main
Well, the distance between Jinnah Hospital, which is not only one of the largest and but also one of the most advanced hospital in Pakistan is hardly 7 to 9 Minutes away from 70 Clifton - Maximum 10 minutes from Mid-east.
This person knows everything but trying to hide reality.lying.
jhoot bol raha hai.yeh. zardari ki taraf se is ko paisa mila tha murtaza attack kerwanay mein help kernay per
NS was behind
@@FaridKhan-su9zh zardari did it!we all know
@@kb319
TRUE ... a.a.z. was also behind the assassination of his own wife (and a handsome amount of life insurance 💰 he claimed on b.b.).
@@FaridKhan-su9zhha ha har cheez mein nawaz sharif ko ghusa do koi tumhara ristadaar bhi maray to kehna nawaz sharif ne marwaya
Sial shot himself and after shotting placed pistol under pillow. Wow thiis physicist seems genious
Hahaha exactly same thing I noticed...
Mera bhi exactly yeh hi sawal hey. But again, this is Pakistan where anything that defy laws of nature & physics is possible
Javeria good
Same thing I noticed
Bingo! Case solved. Place the pistol nicely after committing suicide.
He totally insane and extremely clever
He can't tell the truth but he knows .
If he tells the truth....he is sure to be killed
He says sial murder is a suicide case, then how he found his svs pistol under sial pillow? Never heard or seen anyone committing suicide and tuck the weapon under pillow after pulling trigger. Dude has completely lost his credibility even if he really has an MSc in physics
Very logical point
suchhh nikal ata hai
Looks he is lying
His security guards must have helped the culprit to finish the job.
His msc physics should be reassessed 😂
He has left many things unclear in his dipiction of the event. He also portrayed himself as very calm when bullets were shot on his house and were passing over his head. Anyone would have run for his life at that moment, how he remained unmoved is suspicious. His laughs are very strange here when he is narrating killing and suicide.
there's a reason to why they are DIG
Hain na? I was surprised at the way he was narrating a murder story. He showed as if he was unnerved. The witness was probably killed. How can he laugh at the alleged suicide case?
These rascals had joined hands with Zardari to kill Murtaza Bhutto & to sieze his wife's political power & huge money.
He’s one of the key players, but trying to make it like an innocent observer. He may be a goof in a higher position
Inho nay, unho nay aur aesay phir wesay...story ends.
It's quite clear from this interview that this guy is lying
Ooh dakh k ..
U know who is he..
@@irshadhussainshadbaltistan1046 han tou bhai whoever he is kia murtaza bhutto nay khud ko goli maar ke pistol wapis takiye ke neeche rakh dia jab woh khud khatam ho gaya tha?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He's a sitting IG and his team killed murtaza bhutto. Uski body language bhi wazeh hy.
He is surly liying
@@awaishanif8240 sir ap to Sherlock Holmes hain..
There is definitely something amiss here, why did Dr sab not try to gather more information from the SHO when he came to him asking for more security. The way Dr Suddle is dilly dallying and beating about the bush indicates that he knows something which he is hiding, this I am afraid puts a big stain on his much hyped about legendary reputation. Honestly I am disappointed with this guy after watching this interview.
Exactly.
Very interesting he was persuasive to follow about arms but I think there is more to it. And Post mortem doctors didn't get it right. Hahahaha 🤣. And police constable who was eye witness killed himself. Wow injury to jugular vein is common matter can be easily solved.. wah .. bravo.
He himself had a rift with Murtaza Bhutto as well…he was directly involved in his murder…
He is telling lie.
He entrenched all Police officers behind the bar but he escaped himself in this case. I know a few police officers which were alleged in this case.
Sir, they have tried to cover up his assassination since years. They wont miraculously admit to it now. They just make it seem like BB got him killed because people have a general distrust of politicians.
He was a famous personality he could have arms gunmen yeh kya bata thi check him 🤷.
If I am not wrong but a person committed suicide because he was afraid of being killed?
And after shooting himself, he placed the pistol under the pillow, this officer things everybody is stupid.
To save his family bro
Judging by the numerous contradictions in his 'simple' explanation its evident that he really has gotten old and cannot be trusted as a reliable narrator. Though the whole story does indicate presence of layers within layers in the whole plot.
1st time meny saddle ki statment suni
Aur feel huwa k ye mujrim hy
Keo Mara Murtaza ko.?
@@kamlipaul8498 Zardari ke kehne pe
There is a reason Shoaib Saddal was always in good book of State cz he has done dirty job for them for so many times. Come on, even story dots are not connecting with each other.
Asif Ali Zardari smiling after watching his interview🤣🤣
He is enjoying telling this such a sad and big tragic of the country...... Thats a shame
The great Musharraf said once " Always look for the beneficiary in these incidents* and he was referring to BB's case. Surely we all know that in this case it was the same culprit. None other than Asif Ali Ghadari..
Musharraf named him openly
Zor zor se chilla kar sab ko Bata do
according to your logic every child his his parents killer because he inherits property/wealth... so is every wife/husband
@ Aniket Shyam. If the child is a greedy f*** then yes the same rule applies. There is a difference between inheritance vs getting something by evil means..
@Cosmic Goat Maybe in muslim contries where people idolize aurangzeb
Check "Songs of blood and swords" by Fatima Bhutto, where she dictated the story from the survivors available with her father. And especially one more thing, he didn't mention about the lights being turned off at the place of event.
@ I saw that narrative years ago (again a.a.z. was behind it, irrespective of whether b.b. knew it or not - a.a.z. is a notorious 'Rákshâsh' amongst many others in the Politics of🇵🇰).
Sial wanted 4 police personnel to protect himself but he himself killed himself???
Thank u TCM for such great informative videos great a big thumbs up for you keep posted/uploded videoa like you did ..
I came across your channel today and really liked it. Subscribed as well. Just want to say that keep up the good and quality work because we have rare channels like this as a Nation. I like the quality content, editing, efforts, precision and diversity. Well Done to whole team!
Thank God All people commenting here cursing him and loving mir murtaza bhutto
Dr. Shoaib Suddle, Former DG IB is lying.
Why unresolved? wasn't Zardari involved in it?, surely he's not an angel
G aur story tellr mr.saddle also involve
I thing that I noticed was that he never mentioned anything significant regarding politics or Zardari and this was a Deja vu for me. Context: I have seen something similar (if not identical) in the Benazir's death case by Uncle Majeed. Well for me he's Uncle Majeed, for the world he's Additional IG investigation (retired) Chaudhary Abdul Majeed who was the head of Benazir case JIT. When he showed me the JIT report (actual printed hardcopy) it was a massive eye opener but nowhere there was any mention of any political person i.e Musharaf or Zardari. Every time me or my mother asked about the political aspect Uncle Majeed just twisted the conversation to something else or out rightly denied any knowledge or such sorts (it was obvious he knew but he never told). He did mention something about the initial days of the investigation and Zardari which indicated some ill intent but nothing that shows a motive to kill. Somethings are just never meant to known to the world out there.
Benazir also
Put the interview of Fatima Bhutto the daughter of Mir murtaza Bhutto
7:48 Dr. Shoaib Suddle, Former DG IB is calling the autopsy finding of Murtaza as incorrect. Then at 14:23 he's accepting autopsy finding of suicide of SHO Sial that suits his narrative.
8:43 SHO Sial "eliminated" along with the things he knew. Just like "Shehanshah" was. Sial asked for more security & 4 men were guarding his residence, and surprise surprise; he allegedly committed suicide. What a pathetic liar Shaib Suddle is. Shoaib Suddle went there himself just to smell Sial's firearm and it smelled of gunpowder (any previously used gun would have).
12:38 camera had "rust" hence it falsely pictured a hole in the roof of the car. Do they teach in the M.Sc. physics classes about effects of rust on cameras?
He never talked about questioning Sial in detail about the incident. just sort of talked nothing about it. Sial came to him.
This man was appointed IG Sindh in 2008 by Asif Ali Zardari... Benazir & Zardari killed their biggest rival; Murtaza could potentially have taken back PPP especially if he worked with the establishment.
that's the difference, Benazir worked with the establishment while Murtaza was principled and anti-establishment. this is why the Libyan Jamahiriya was drawn to support a figure like him.
He should be behind the bars, he is the culprit.
But why.?
@@kamlipaul8498 all the strings going towards him.
He knows everything but he did not do it
Zardari killed murtaza Bhutto. Benszir knew every thing. Fatima Bhutto also said that there were police on the roofs and 🌲 trees. Rao Anwar and Shahid hayat were near murtaza Bhutto in hospital and they made sure that he died. Murtaza was also taken lately in hospital. A photographer journalist captured the pic at hospital and ran away as police tried to catch him. Rao Anwar is the same man who did killing of naqeeb ullah
TCM , you guys make gr8 documentaries... well done 👍
Surely he was involved in that murder..
Ok. But why he killed him.?
@@kamlipaul8498
Asif Ali Zardári's orders ...
It is so obvious with the eye movements and body language and words use he is master mind of all.
from his face expressions & the way he is telling this story shows that he is lying
TCM is a good channel, but too many holes in this narration. Why would DIG Karachi ask the Federal Interior Minister (in Islamabad) to send doctors. As Head of Police he should have ordered injured body to be taken to Jinnah Hospital, Civil Hospital, Aga Khan Hospital or Liaquat Hospital where there are doctors round the clock. Why would sole eyewitness commit suicide, when he asked for security. Why did DIG Suddle remain sitting in his residence when he heard the firing outside?
یہ خبیث اتنا جھوٹا انسان کە آنکھ اٹھا کر بات نہیں کرسکتا اور ھمیں الو سمجھ کر دفعہ دور والہ انداز
اوٹ پٹانگ ھانک رھا ھے جیسے اسکا کوئی کیا کر سکتا ھے . بے نظیر بارے بات میں ایسی ھوا ایسی سانس دے رھا ھے جیسے وە اس کے ساتھ قتل کے معاملے میں شامل ھوں .
Need more clarity bring the victims and their interview too
Very unprofessional presentation. It shows how non-competent people run the show at the top level. This guy appears to be unqualified for his job.
Murderers. Cook up any stories you like.
اگر انسپکٹر نے خودکشی ہی کرنی تھی تو سیکورٹی مانگنے کی وجہ؟؟؟
اسلامی جمہوریہ پاکستان
Kitna masoom ig hai... Jo btata gya isay sab pae yaqeen krta bhi gaya, krwata bhi gya......
Murtaza to shaheed ho gya.... Jana to us nae tha he...... Ab yeh bhai MSc Physics apna hisab Allah ko kaisay daingar?
میر مرتضیٰ بھٹو آخری کیل تھا
جس سے بھٹو فیملی کے دروازے
کا پردہ بندھا ہوا تھا۔ وہ
کیل کیا نکلا
اللہ ہواکبر ۔۔۔دنیا نے کیا کیا نہیں دیکھا
Why r u giving ur forum to.these criminals
Asif Zardari in his presidential tenure awarded shoaib with Hilal-e-Imtiaz the fact is only the dead fish follow the stream and how insane is to interview a Culprit!
Abb soch lo sitting pm k Bhai ko aesay mara jata hai ,tu aam admi ka Kya hota hoga Pakistan mei
Why he was trying to unarmed the body gaurds of Mir Murtaza
Sara game us 10% ka hai.....he took auth to finish bhutto family and he did it. Only one lives and he is unwillingly living a life of gay.
What 10% please explain
@@satvirsingh9152 Singh sahib ap Pakistan se ho to samjhane ki zaroorat nahin aur Pakistan se nahin ho to yeh sawal puchne ki zaroorat nahin.
@@durrani1983 how you know exactly that he is gay?
@@rafaynadeem4696 watch videos carefully and pay attention
@@durrani1983 yes many peoples say this that he is gay I also noticed it but don't judge a book by its cover btw iam the supporter of Imran Khan
His entire body and tone is against his words.
Please bring in the case of then DSP Aziz ur Rahman’s sons who were gunned down with their guards near Shamsi Masjid Malir halt near their house
The way he is nerrating this incident is very ruthless as if he himself was involved.
Sial must had ultimate degree of OCD... he put the svc pistol back even after shooting himself.... Wow.
It was the most hyped case of his career, he couldn't prepare a tale, cover, back story till date.
Murders...
He was the mastermind
PPP la waris hogie is k Jane k bad
Khud ko Goli mar k pistol pillow k nechy rkh diya... Msc physics...
He's throughly hiding facts and making stories as he must did on that time ...
The best channel i have ever found...
Fatima bhutta has a different story as an evidence on site..
And the funny thing is that, Benazir did not take much interest in the investigation for her brother's murder case. It looks like, she was also part of the murder conspiracy.
Because of her husband
Why would Sial kill himself when a day earlier he had asked for extra security and clearly mentioned a threat to his life. This statement doesn't make any sense
You are doing a good journalism
Respect from India
He is lying thinking ppl are stupid
He can't share info....or he will be gone
He has bloods in his hand
He's as unconvincing as you can get.
What a joke , since it was Friday there was no doctor present. It seems Allah personally attends all patients on Friday in Pak
That’s was not a Hospital.. just a nursing home.. plz listen carefully then give comment.
Shoaib Suddle was the main architect of Murtaza Bhutto and later on he was rewarded by military establishment
Yh professional attitude 🤔😵 kisi angle se nhi 😏
Nice smile at the end.
Main sach nahi janta per ALLAH sab janta hai or Saza zaroor milay gi Dunya mein bhi or Akhirat mein bhi. Or barri bhayanak saza milay gi. Ye besharam aadmi kisi ke murder per baat ker raha hai or baat kertay hue has raha hai. Aafreen hai iski besharmi per.
Puppet of Zardari
Zardari and Benazir both were involved.
Good job
One of the main culprit amongst the killing conspiracy of Murtaza Bhutto
He's a liar 🙁😐.
He can not tell the truth....if he does ...he will be gone
his laughs in between the narration are scary
Watch history of pakistan series by DSJ..faisal warriach...he cover's this whole case in some episodes with very brief and interesting details..
He died on the road and police didn’t respond dont lie
Here After Imran Khan statement about his murder plan same like murtaza bhutto
Itne important bande ke guards se guns lena ..jab ke waise hi khatra tha unko ... something looks fishy
Sial ne tu esy sham press conference mai bataya ta ke agar aaj raat muje bachaya jaee tu kal mai adalat mai sabkuch bata vonga _
Shame on this devil , and may he rot in the deepest depth of hell .
Nice cover up.. shameful
Mideast hospital tha operation theater be tha or har tarha ka docktor mojod hota tha waha,
In a very clever manner, he tried to endorse his biased perspective. But the other side of coin need to be scratched to bring real truth before nation.
He knows everything but he don't want to show the reality..
Last 2-3 generation failed us all completely
They brought us where we are as a country
Some of them still clinging to the system
And generations after them have no opportunites because of failed planning of these people
They had very easy going lives
It's wrong statement that every time has its own challenges.
Previous generations had easy shot at life.
And they are still clinging to the system extensions after extensions
They have eaten up all the resources and enjoyed very good financial lives
They left nothing for coming generations and neither planned any good for coming times
Previous generations are responsible for the chaos we are facing as a country
And we see them all telling there stories proudly without realizing they are completely failures as the top positions they hold for long time.
We are ashamed of watching them telling there stories in most of this channel videos
Curse them all the previous beorocrates and politicians
@5th Gen
surely Quáidê-Millat was a different kettle of fish from these politicians and bureaucrats ...
i am not interested in case but this person is mostly lying or telling stories which are not reliable
It is generally considered that asif ali zardari got murtaza bhutto murdered by using his own men and later zardari was arrested but was released without any charge because he had already covered it up as his wife was then a prime minister benazir bhutto who was also assasinated in december 2007 most likely by her husband zardari.
I am trying to focus on the story but that background music is keep diverting my focus to "kurhi kendi baby pehla jaguar le lawo, fer jinna marzi pyar le lawooooo oo oo oo oooo" -_-
Munafiq....iske chehrey sey munafiqat tapak rahi hey
He is the murderer of mir Murtaza Bhutto
No he is not....but he knows everything
@@baba747baba2 Mastermind and planner is murderer
The one side story.every coin has two different sides
Gotcha
He is the team leader of raid team. And lying .. just tell the Pakistan.. how many promotion he get from establishment for rest of his life. And still sitting on top seats.😡 If he tell the truth Soo many unknowns history and myth get clear..
Botched up to the core an eyeopener
M.Sc Physics, name included Dr.
Specialist in investigations.
A man with GOD gifted talents.
Ye baba mulawis hoga
Not mulawis ....but he knows