little did that guy realise that would be the most famous thing he'd ever do in his life. that 3 second moment will be preserved for centuries when everyone else who long forgot his name have died
My grandmother was born in Beijing in 1929. It's really great to be able to see what she may have seen as a child. If she wasn't blind now with cataracts, I'd show her this to see if it jogs her memories of old Beijing.
This commentary was humane, unlike arrogant commentaries that showed the contempt they were held in by some. Much more objective about his subject, their is empathy there too.
However, he is completely wrong about how Chinese see death. I am an American economist who taught and researched for 12 years. I also saw of Chinese cry wen her loved ones or friends died. They also have plenty of sympathy for foreigners who are grieving In other words, Chinese are ordinary humans. Births deaths, anniversaries, etc. are all important to Chinese and other humans. Also the announcer is completely wrong about Chinese not liking their pics taken for fear of losing their soul. This has always been absolutely fails Chinese quickly embraced photography when it started in the 1800s.
@@avecmoi9429 : I think he's talking about Confucianism.... i.e. Meaning that... chinese people, see death as a motivation to be good, in this lifetime. Even today.. people often see death.. or to imagine death.. in order to do good... as a living human being.
America today is pretty damn obvious as is most countries other than those countries where like half of your earnings is taxed and you’re given shit healthcare in return... oh wait those countries have extremely rich and extremely poor too!
It was not long ago that the last of old China was destroyed to make way for today's modern structures. Thousands of years of culture and tradition were lost forever. This was only about ten to eleven yrs. ago. It is so sad to see such beauty lost.
Notice the Chinese-men are not wearing pig tails, for the most part, anymore. They wore them in the Qing dynasty 1200 till 1912. By the 1920's pig tails were no more ! Thanks for the upload!
I think it's more accurate to call it "queue" rather than "pigtails." The Qing Dynasty didn't start in 1200. It ruled China for almost 300 years from 1644 to 1912. In 1922, the last emperor Puyi cut his queue (pigtails) too.
I have a Chinese Great grandmother who was born in Foochow. She married an American who was working for the Chinese Maritime Customs Service. Two of their sons lived in the same area as my Grandmother and much about her relationship with one of them remains clouded with the perceived shame of out of wedlock pregnancy with a biracial young man.
You can tell her， in today's China, no one cares about such things anymore. Almost half of the young people have the experience of unmarried pregnancies. Those with biracial blood are more fashionable.
It's funny when he called it "piping", but I suppose back then, people didn't have a standard pronounciation as well. He was kind of wrong when he stated that was "the temple"... I think that was a section of the Imperial Palace.... Maybe dated as far back as the Qin dynasty... I presume. He said "the chartered city", what did he mean by that ?? So the "Forbidden City" was allowed to be filmed ? Somehow I do not think that he was a priest. I am guessing that he was an enuch.. or one of the old Imperial's servants... and he looked after the building. If the other "palaces" for Ming or whatever "dynasties" were created outside of this. It meant that, once the old Dynasty had fallen, and someone created a new dynasty, the old ones, were not lived in. There is a myth that, most chinese do not like old things. This is why... but... It isn't one do not like old things, rather than to respect that it belonged to someone else, and it should not be owned or something. The Emperor prayed ?? I think the Emperor kowtowed to the sky to "hope" his subjects were loyal or something...
He mentioned that the women's feet were bound and that Empress Dowager Cixi was in the other palace ? I am assuming that, she made women bound their feet to keep their circulation or other. Cos it occurred to me only in recent years that chinese were anaemic... So I can now understand how bound feets were really a way to keep circulation going. She was known as one of the matriarchy to keep the lineage of the empire going.... I now get why TCM was always so important to us Chinese.... It was to keep the population going. I know that ginseng was really a Korean thing, which prolonged circulation or other. Or rather, maybe in hindsight, more like Mongols... Or Manchu race by that time I think. And those haircuts... I think those guys were probably villagers who still followed the Qing dynasty's dress code etc. Maybe Hans Chinese.. This is actually a really sad video... In my mind, a lot of things finally clicked... I cannot really believe that this was from the 1930s...
It's not "Piping", but "BeiPing"(北平)，another name of Peking（北京）city. it should sounds like “bay-ping”....western foreigners often pronounce wrong Mandarin.
the Temple of Heaven（天坛） is another palace outside Forbidden city（紫禁城故宫），used for offering sacrifices to heaven god and praying for the New Year，it's not a section of the Imperial Palace. the first time Peking city became a Imperial capital is Liao Dynasty at 1125 AD，not Qin dynasty.
Most of the monuments here are ruined，Like the old city walls, all torn down by Mao....Even if something exists today, the surrounding environment and the decoration of the exterior have been wrongly refurbished, and turn to the Tourism Profitable Project
En la toma del minuto 5,40 se pueden ver a las mujeres de la época luciendo su tradicional "pie de loto" (una deformación producida de manera forzada de los pies para que no crecieran). Ojo ese era un lujo. Hoy ya son muy pocas las mujeres que se aprecian con esa deformación, sólo ancianas de edad muy avanzada o artistas de la "Opera de Beijing"
I wish China kept building traditional buildings rather than modern boring buildings! Us tourists are really fascinated by these architectures and pagodas
Actually, the narrator wanted to say " Beiping" ,the Chinese pronunciation? Instead he said 'Pipe ping'. He could have just said Peking .That will do.That's why a lot of Chinese used Christian name for eg Tom Chan or Simon Li etc.For the convenience of most foreigners who doesn't know how to pronounce in Mandarin.
actually he was saying it was hot, piping hot is an english expression. so he said its piping. also he may have been commenting on the pipes that were everywhere at the time.
Peiping was the old Postal Romanisation spelling of Beiping. Postal Romanisation and Wade Giles was based on the dialect of old Luoyang which up till 1850 was the official Sociolect of the upper classes.
This map showed Mongolia and Tibet were very much part of China. Only Mongolia got independent later. This claim Tibet was a independent nation can be said to be totally false.
Now Peking is a great metropolis. On the basis of such poor, undeveloped and constant wars, great changes have taken place in less than one hundred years
Well they did, just a bit late. U forgot that China was actually the #1 Gpd with India at #2 at the start in 18th century. If Europeans weren’t so greedy...
@M T Don't forget history, but don't be confused by history. Why did the Kuomintang fail, is evil over justice? If the Kuomintang had treated the people well, history would have been very different.Now Taiwan is just a frontier for the U.S. to attack China. So the U.S. supportfors Taiwan's development. Also divide the river and rule is the wisest decision.
It's not "Piping", but "BeiPing"(北平)，another name of Peking（北京）city. it should be pronounced like “bay-ping”....westerners often pronounce wrong Mandarin.
Highlight for me was seeing those women with the bound feet hobbling along. While more difficult to visit, I guess China was more easy to visit in the 1930s before it was closed off in 1949 by the Communist takeover.
Is anyone else surprised that the percentage of Chinese within the total of humans on the planet has not changed? Still about one fifth. I thought today a higher percentage of humans would be Chinese. Perhaps the Indian subcontinent's rise in population accounts for that?
"Pi Ping" makes my skin crawl. The correct pronunciation in Mandarin is "Bay Jeeng" (phonetic), written as "Beijing" in Pinyin, the official Romanization system of the Peoples Republic of China.
Yes but the correct pronunciation in English is "Pi Ping". The Mandarin pronunciaton doesn´t matter as the commentator was speaking English. So in this case the English pronuciation has to be choosen.
@@billanderson4619 : Everything in Chinese is more or less poetic, so when translated into English, it should be more descriptively done, "Peace of the North".
@@davec1615 : By "Tartar City", does he mean the Muslim-Chinese ? The ones that helped Empress Cixi to fight the Hans ? (Sorry, my chinese history, of the entire prc region is not so clear...)
@askjiir because in the 1930's europeans thought of themselves of the best, the creme de la creme :P the second world war took away any of that thought what the first world war did't
Well to simplify and not go back too long, 北平(Peking) was the old name of 北京(Beijing) before the PRC made it it's capital in 1949(I think that's the year, don't remember)
@WuBingWay How about you learn your own history, it's only called Beijing because of Mandarin Chinese which is only about 700 years old. The major spoken languages in the past were all Cantonese related and in these languages it sounds more like Puck King which was commonly written as Peking. You complain about others not knowing Chinese history but you don't know it either.
This is the most subversive and xenophobic documentary regardless of the fact its from the 30's. The narrator's pedantic voice has undertones of positivity, at best.
I am totally amazed by Christian ignorance. After being robbed by Christians from the west for decades the Chinese started to stand up against Christian brutal colonization.
![[UA] NAVI vs MOUZ | BO5 | IEM Rio 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CMBYk0cbGoA/mqdefault.jpg)
1:40 that guy was waving to us. Hello from 2020!!
little did that guy realise that would be the most famous thing he'd ever do in his life. that 3 second moment will be preserved for centuries when everyone else who long forgot his name have died
ディズニー
He was a nice guy which you would like to meet and have a cup of tea and talk😃
Nice people wave
My grandmother was born in Beijing in 1929. It's really great to be able to see what she may have seen as a child. If she wasn't blind now with cataracts, I'd show her this to see if it jogs her memories of old Beijing.
My grandmother was born in Peking in 1931. She just passed away two months ago. It would have been nice if I could show her this ...
This commentary was humane, unlike arrogant commentaries that showed the contempt they were held in by some. Much more objective about his subject, their is empathy there too.
However, he is completely wrong about how Chinese see death. I am an American economist who taught and researched for 12 years. I also saw of Chinese cry wen her loved ones or friends died. They also have plenty of sympathy for foreigners who are grieving In other words, Chinese are ordinary humans. Births deaths, anniversaries, etc. are all important to Chinese and other humans. Also the announcer is completely wrong about Chinese not liking their pics taken for fear of losing their soul. This has always been absolutely fails Chinese quickly embraced photography when it started in the 1800s.
Very inaccurate commentary but i like the video if muted
@@avecmoi9429 : I think he's talking about Confucianism.... i.e. Meaning that... chinese people, see death as a motivation to be good, in this lifetime. Even today.. people often see death.. or to imagine death.. in order to do good... as a living human being.
Thank you for posting all these films on the net. They are all very important documentaries.
thanks for sharing this footage...I've visited Beijing twice before...amazed by the architectures from this footage even after 80+ years.
For a 1930 documentry, this is an exceptionally positive comment on China.
America had a more positive feeling, albeit paternalistic, toward China than other powers. That is, until now.
Weren't they allies at that time?
@@geogsf179 because China at that time had a different government than current one
@@MrLarossi China had a government that was a slave that obeyed everything
Because back that time China is a poor and weak country, cannot be the quote “strategic competitor” of USA, so its OK for positive. but now.... haha
The contrast between the rich Chinese and poor Chinese is very clearly shown.
The gap is even wider today!
same thing today
@@sheldonfish5161 food back then was better
Antediluvian Clockwork lol what? There is, of course, a wage gap but it is obviously smaller for the general population
America today is pretty damn obvious as is most countries other than those countries where like half of your earnings is taxed and you’re given shit healthcare in return... oh wait those countries have extremely rich and extremely poor too!
this really a great movie, shows bejing a long time ago.....
It was not long ago that the last of old China was destroyed to make way for today's modern structures. Thousands of years of culture and tradition were lost forever. This was only about ten to eleven yrs. ago. It is so sad to see such beauty lost.
no...it was 1966-1976
Notice the Chinese-men are not wearing pig tails, for the most part, anymore. They wore them in the Qing dynasty 1200 till 1912. By the 1920's pig tails were no more ! Thanks for the upload!
I think it's more accurate to call it "queue" rather than "pigtails." The Qing Dynasty didn't start in 1200. It ruled China for almost 300 years from 1644 to 1912. In 1922, the last emperor Puyi cut his queue (pigtails) too.
@@perfectstudents8361 Thanks for sharing.
You are beautiful. Are you Chinese?
I have a Chinese Great grandmother who was born in Foochow. She married an American who was working for the Chinese Maritime Customs Service. Two of their sons lived in the same area as my Grandmother and much about her relationship with one of them remains clouded with the perceived shame of out of wedlock pregnancy with a biracial young man.
You can tell her， in today's China, no one cares about such things anymore. Almost half of the young people have the experience of unmarried pregnancies. Those with biracial blood are more fashionable.
@@slavish_superiority I wish I could've met My grandfather and his family. But either they weren't allowed to know my father or they didn't want to.
Thanks anti China propaganda for 73 years!
@@weizhang2834 Sensitive and suspicious, narrow -minded
I jonesing for some cake. He kept calling Peking “Piping” so often I couldn’t help think about piping on frosting onto a cake. So now I’m craving cake
I always think of a plumber when he says "piping" .. good documentary though
2:37 That's the Tiananmen Square !! Look carefully it still doesn't have the Mao portrait hung up there yet.
Haha, a good one. He was hanging on to his life in 1930. He eventually won. That's what has mattered for China.
@@geogsf179 And Mao fucked china up.
wow your comment is from 10 years ago already ! internet is getting oldl Look even more carefully, Someone else's portrait is hung there. Who is it?
@@mtlicq see u next 10 years
@Qianlima exactly like it or not Mao united China.
I was just there two weeks ago!!it is magnificent!
Wow! What history and I am not living too far from where this was taken! Incidently, I'm American!
thx for uploading!
Wonderful documentary! The narrator could have done a wonderful W.C. Fields impression with just a little adjustment.
This was one of James A. FitzPatrick’s earliest “Traveltalks”.
Love that guy at 1:41, he's all like NI HAO!!!!!
这就是祥子时候的北京阿，太感动了！thanks for posting
Thank you for this video 📷, I always enjoy the company of Chinese people, and the food!!
I have a feeling the guy at 1:40 figured out time travel and wormholed his way from our times to 1930 to wave at us.
Getting a 13 year old video about history recommended cause of youtube algorithm?
"You know me too well..."
0:29 1910년대 지어진 한국의 부산역하고 너무 비슷.
그리고 인디애나주 인디애나폴리스에 모자의 챙처럼 나와 있는 구조와 유사한 구조의 건물도 있음.
2:35 天安門に掲げてある文字は「 要废除不平等条约 」 (Abolish the unequal treaties) ?
今は「世界人民大団結万歳」だよね
You are a wicked Godless race -- we America will crush you by any means necessary
@@kennyholeater2494 America cannot do anything.
@@kennyholeater2494 how are you supposed to crush them if all your hammer are made in china ?
It's funny when he called it "piping", but I suppose back then, people didn't have a standard pronounciation as well. He was kind of wrong when he stated that was "the temple"... I think that was a section of the Imperial Palace.... Maybe dated as far back as the Qin dynasty... I presume. He said "the chartered city", what did he mean by that ?? So the "Forbidden City" was allowed to be filmed ? Somehow I do not think that he was a priest. I am guessing that he was an enuch.. or one of the old Imperial's servants... and he looked after the building. If the other "palaces" for Ming or whatever "dynasties" were created outside of this. It meant that, once the old Dynasty had fallen, and someone created a new dynasty, the old ones, were not lived in. There is a myth that, most chinese do not like old things. This is why... but... It isn't one do not like old things, rather than to respect that it belonged to someone else, and it should not be owned or something. The Emperor prayed ?? I think the Emperor kowtowed to the sky to "hope" his subjects were loyal or something...
He mentioned that the women's feet were bound and that Empress Dowager Cixi was in the other palace ? I am assuming that, she made women bound their feet to keep their circulation or other. Cos it occurred to me only in recent years that chinese were anaemic... So I can now understand how bound feets were really a way to keep circulation going. She was known as one of the matriarchy to keep the lineage of the empire going.... I now get why TCM was always so important to us Chinese.... It was to keep the population going. I know that ginseng was really a Korean thing, which prolonged circulation or other. Or rather, maybe in hindsight, more like Mongols... Or Manchu race by that time I think. And those haircuts... I think those guys were probably villagers who still followed the Qing dynasty's dress code etc. Maybe Hans Chinese.. This is actually a really sad video... In my mind, a lot of things finally clicked...
I cannot really believe that this was from the 1930s...
he said the "Tartar city" (likely referring to the Manchu section) , not "chartered city"
您说的特对，特正确
It's not "Piping", but "BeiPing"(北平)，another name of Peking（北京）city. it should sounds like “bay-ping”....western foreigners often pronounce wrong Mandarin.
the Temple of Heaven（天坛） is another palace outside Forbidden city（紫禁城故宫），used for offering sacrifices to heaven god and praying for the New Year，it's not a section of the Imperial Palace. the first time Peking city became a Imperial capital is Liao Dynasty at 1125 AD，not Qin dynasty.
China is so fascinating.
see u in beijing
Not so much anymore.
Shameful that the beutiful culture that China had were erased by the CCP. I hope they find their way back.
Most of the monuments here are ruined，Like the old city walls, all torn down by Mao....Even if something exists today, the surrounding environment and the decoration of the exterior have been wrongly refurbished, and turn to the Tourism Profitable Project
@@ZoltanDeluxeMe too 😊😊
3:27 who was this guy, like a boss ?...
Lol!
You should go pay him a visit.
@@liliencalvel6151 hes a dead meat
He's a priest of the temple, as narrated by the narrator. just a positive fella
En la toma del minuto 5,40 se pueden ver a las mujeres de la época luciendo su tradicional "pie de loto" (una deformación producida de manera forzada de los pies para que no crecieran). Ojo ese era un lujo. Hoy ya son muy pocas las mujeres que se aprecian con esa deformación, sólo ancianas de edad muy avanzada o artistas de la "Opera de Beijing"
Sim uma tradição cruel para certas mulheres de algumas etnias.
i think the video taker was very excited when getting on the great wall
At 2:38, the caption should say "Tartar City," not "charter city."
This video amazed me.!
You tried to give me coronavirus with this comment (joke) 🤣
I wish China kept building traditional buildings rather than modern boring buildings! Us tourists are really fascinated by these architectures and pagodas
I heard the narrator said "Piping"?
Mispronunciation of Peiping
It's Beiping, one of the many names of Beijing
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Names_of_Beijing
@Morel Lefèvre : Thanks ! I never knew that....
Beijing(北京) was called Piping（北平）too.
Actually, the narrator wanted to say " Beiping" ,the Chinese pronunciation? Instead he said 'Pipe ping'. He could have just said Peking .That will do.That's why a lot of Chinese used Christian name for eg Tom Chan or Simon Li etc.For the convenience of most foreigners who doesn't know how to pronounce in Mandarin.
actually he was saying it was hot, piping hot is an english expression. so he said its piping. also he may have been commenting on the pipes that were everywhere at the time.
What a typical dumbass from HK
Peiping was the old Postal Romanisation spelling of Beiping. Postal Romanisation and Wade Giles was based on the dialect of old Luoyang which up till 1850 was the official Sociolect of the upper classes.
@eddielung31
Why should it be negative? China wasn't communist before 1949 . . .
Because the Roller are not (han) chinese
@@mr.cebuano2843 Roller?
@@DrJones20 ruler
Thank God, No people say free Tibet, free Xinjiang in this video.
Or free Hong Kong and Taiwan is the official China.
Tibet was functionally independent at this time
@@DeclinedMercy aka functionally a scam lip service
0:12 Notice the Republic of China map...
This map showed Mongolia and Tibet were very much part of China. Only Mongolia got independent later. This claim Tibet was a independent nation can be said to be totally false.
Mingpo Yang It includes Tannu Tuwa too, I believe. Now it’s in Russia.
Tibet was functionally independent from 1912 until the PLA invasion.
Idk if this is sarcasm, can't really tell through the screen but that is the Qing dynasty's or I think it is because Mongolia is inside
Awesome!
Now Peking is a great metropolis.
On the basis of such poor, undeveloped and constant wars, great changes have taken place in less than one hundred years
I like the smiling face of the barbar.
Yes ! I love KMT !!
This is fascinating!
Just noticed how old the video and reply were
那时候的视频影像
刚出狼穴又入虎口，真可谓是多灾多难啊
If only China had decided to industrialize like Japan, there was so much squandered potential
Well China did industrialize, 100 years later than japan in the 1990s.
Well they did, just a bit late. U forgot that China was actually the #1 Gpd with India at #2 at the start in 18th century. If Europeans weren’t so greedy...
@M T Don't forget history, but don't be confused by history. Why did the Kuomintang fail, is evil over justice?
If the Kuomintang had treated the people well, history would have been very different.Now Taiwan is just a frontier for the U.S. to attack China.
So the U.S. supportfors Taiwan's development.
Also divide the river and rule is the wisest decision.
Wasn't really that possible because of the corruption and superstition and a little later also got invaded by the West and Japan
It's not "Piping", but "BeiPing"(北平)，another name of Peking（北京）city. it should be pronounced like “bay-ping”....westerners often pronounce wrong Mandarin.
Highlight for me was seeing those women with the bound feet hobbling along. While more difficult to visit, I guess China was more easy to visit in the 1930s before it was closed off in 1949 by the Communist takeover.
I support your comment to the 1000th degree.
Shame that most of these monuments were destroyed during the Cultural Revolution
4:33小时候 记得都是这么剪头的
I REALLY WANT KMT CAN COME BACK !!!
@cuteameri no, much earlier, in the 1890s
Is anyone else surprised that the percentage of Chinese within the total of humans on the planet has not changed? Still about one fifth. I thought today a higher percentage of humans would be Chinese. Perhaps the Indian subcontinent's rise in population accounts for that?
Sorry, going from 700 million to 1.4 BILLION under 200 years is a GOOD thing ? I do not think so.
5:03 Fck I wanted to see the final haircut
"Pi Ping" makes my skin crawl. The correct pronunciation in Mandarin is "Bay Jeeng" (phonetic), written as "Beijing" in Pinyin, the official Romanization system of the Peoples Republic of China.
Yes but the correct pronunciation in English is "Pi Ping". The Mandarin pronunciaton doesn´t matter as the commentator was speaking English. So in this case the English pronuciation has to be choosen.
Beijing was known as Beiping at the time of the video
@@rickyzhang995 You are correct. That occurred to me after I posted my comment. "Northern Peace,"
@@billanderson4619 : Everything in Chinese is more or less poetic, so when translated into English, it should be more descriptively done, "Peace of the North".
Piping : Before Downfall TGO
China's territory was so vast back then.
やば
あっという間に近代化してるやん
しかとデカい建物
2019 anyone?
me
2020 anyone
开场白的中国地图版图还是很大的
可惜都被蚕食侵略了，周边国家都或多或少侵占了一部分中国领土
日本人なら、警察官が出て交通処理するこの時代は警察官がいない
China is one of the most interesting nation in the world.
峰峦如聚，
波涛如怒，
山河表里潼关路。
望西都，意踌躇。
伤心秦汉经行处，
宫阙万间都做了土。
兴，百姓苦；亡，百姓苦。
--------张养浩《山坡羊·潼关怀古》
You discovered an ancient Chinese secret
Lol the guy at 1:42! Stealing spotling was already existant in China 1930 xD
They don't know that they're about to die many years later, do they?
nguyenkhan202 3 months ago
--Nor does anyone else!
すごすぎる
The Hui Chinese were the Citizen China
Four walled cities,
... “The North are Tartar cities”
I think he said "unchartered cities".. whatever it meant.
the "tartar city" is where the manchu ("tartar") elite of the qing regime lived.
@@davec1615 : By "Tartar City", does he mean the Muslim-Chinese ? The ones that helped Empress Cixi to fight the Hans ? (Sorry, my chinese history, of the entire prc region is not so clear...)
เป็นประเทศที่ประชาชนต้องประสบกับชะตากรรมและมากด้วยเรื่องราวที่สุด...
việt nam có ai xem như tui hem nhỉ 😍
and beijing now ？ i think battle more new york
The barber looked only 14 or 15.
哎哟
@askjiir
because in the 1930's europeans thought of themselves of the best, the creme de la creme :P
the second world war took away any of that thought what the first world war did't
@rushius Oh , everything you've said is true despite the fact that Chinese lack self-esteem, over.
Very inaccurate commentary but i like the video if muted
哎哟😄
Peping, Peking, Beijing. Lol. Which is it? The north is a tartar city? That isn’t correct. They would have been Manchu, not tartar.
Well to simplify and not go back too long, 北平(Peking) was the old name of 北京(Beijing) before the PRC made it it's capital in 1949(I think that's the year, don't remember)
How they would soon suffer with horrible genocide and war, then rise dramatically from the ashes.
Shaniwada surang
Kuldhara
Balaquila
@WuBingWay How about you learn your own history, it's only called Beijing because of Mandarin Chinese which is only about 700 years old. The major spoken languages in the past were all Cantonese related and in these languages it sounds more like Puck King which was commonly written as Peking. You complain about others not knowing Chinese history but you don't know it either.
Unfortunately, some still do.
Padmini fort
I would Love to be surrounded by more Chinese people 💌
那时候天安门还没挂毛泽东。
You're a Wicked Godless race of people and America will crush you by any means
@@kennyholeater2494 America is not a model nation itself.
when china was clean...中国干净的时代。。。
James Johnson 你想要去那个时代？呵呵，真干净！
@@ithinilben4672 奴隶时代
Yet to be destroyed and depopulated by Mao.
How the narrator deliver his script feels a bit racist
@tibet4504 do you stand for the majority of tibetans? prove it if you can
This is the most subversive and xenophobic documentary regardless of the fact its from the 30's. The narrator's pedantic voice has undertones of positivity, at best.
1000000000000000000000 Times better of today chinese, they wear their clothes
I am totally amazed by Christian ignorance. After being robbed by Christians from the west for decades the Chinese started to stand up against Christian brutal colonization.
Jauhar kin$a[illa rajasthan knal
北平
I would like Chinese children 🆒❤️🤗🤗🤗😁🌹🌹🌹
Amerfortsurang