Star Wars SC 38 Re Imagined - Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 тра 2019
- Kyle reacts to Star Wars SC 38 Re Imagined by FXitinpost
Vote in content polls and see get access to full length unedited reactions!! / kylekatarn
Twitter : / ky1ekatarn
FaceBook : Ky1eKatarn/?...
Instagram: / ky1ekatarn - Розваги
Hey Kyle, thanks for your kind words!
Outstanding job! Truly setting the bar for future projects of this type. Can’t wait to see what you come up with next!
I really appreciate having Vader using that downward slash to work past that lightsaber blade through lightsaber blade from the original...
Totally awesome...and im an old school star wars fan, and i find this amazing.
Disney should be rocking in thier chairs in shame😆
@@AlbertoRodriguez-zb3iu or if they are smart studying and learning from fans
I was silently hoping you'd edit in "I have failed you Anakin, I have failed you" right before he gets struck down. Those were such profound words. That would be the icing on this very very delicious cake.
Something a lot of people don't seem to notice is that they brought in aspects of Anakin's wildly chaotic fighting style, punches and force pushes included.
@Jesus is God bitch wtf this is star wars not jesus
Xero...I see where Kylo Ren gets the idea to punch while fighting with a saber....he gets it from his Grand-daddy!
Yup..
That twirly twirl Vader does in the first portion of the fight, strait up Anakin from the mustafar duel. Love it.
I love this reimagined scene because you can feel the absolute hatred Vader had for Obi Wan. Every strike felt so heavy and full of just rage and emotion from Vader. Absolutely loved it.
I’ve probably seen 4 reactions of this video haha, it never gets me tired
Jackxu 4444 only 2!!..you need to catch up..I’m kind of 30 already lol 😂
4? pshhh, try 40
ive watched like 20 so far and its still not old and im positive this can NEVER get old man!
You could just feel the hate he had in this moment
didn't even let obi wan finish his sentence at the start LOL
A lot of fans today forget or are not aware that sabers were meant to be space broad swords and to be held with two hands. It later evolved to what we have today. I do enjoy the original but I also enjoy this and honestly would have been happy with both. I do think Alec’s spin in the original just looks goofy and here it’s been “rectified” lol but overall I just love seeing how the fans interpret these scenes and try to make them their own.
Starwars was also largely inspired by samurai sword styles back then.
Although it's likely the biggest reason the original fight scene wasn't more intense was because the props used for the sabers effects back then were actually very fragile and expensive. They couldn't really bash them together without them breaking.
I'd say more of a "Hand and a half" seeing as they are often seen being wielded with both one, and two hands. And maybe a hint of Katana thrown in there too. That being said, it's always cool to remember all the work that went into Star Wars. .
"General Grevious got his ass kicked every time" not to me he did. The 2003 Clone Wars series is my head canon, and there Grevious is an unstoppable badass.
It is cannon
There is logic to how the fight was originally, but it was mostly just that there were limitations, and the idea was new. This update helps A New Hope a lot imo, and helps to connect it to the prequels with the type of light-saber battle and of course those little memory clips. It even is a good connector from Rogue One, starting similar to that corridor scene but then ramping it up both in the type of opponent and in the scale of the confrontation.
I will agree that Anakin’s SABER fighting skills were lessened as a result of losing his limbs, but his absolute rage combined with his ability to enhance his movements with the force, even Kenobi feared Vader. He knew that the next time he faced him, after realizing he’s still alive? He would not survive.
Well his style changed for the better because of it actually. He relied heavily on his agility, endurance, as force abilities as he dueled as a Jedi, but as Vader, his dueling skills are actually better because he can’t rely on these things. As a pure duelist there are few characters in the whole of the series that could take Vader. He’s just so aggressive and his strikes are powerful as fuck.
The biggest issues was that David Prowes lied about his stage combat experience which is why they brought in Bob Anderson for Empire and Jedi. Alec was actually capable of much more than we ever see in ANH.
The other big problem was that the prop department fucked up and didn’t have the reinforced combat lightsabers ready for the fight, so they had to make do with the older versions, which were fragile glass tubes that couldn’t be used with much force.
Kyle - it's Qui-Gon Jinn's Funeral theme, not Padmé. The choral part is somewhat a reprise in her theme but the earlier eery instrumental & humming part is the one by Lucas King (composer with his own YT-channel with same name). A fitting choice considering Obi-Wan going the same route as the old Jedi master final struggle & his padawan witnessing his death, albeit Obi-Wan did it willingly.
Emil Brants obi wan was already dead he is powerful as the emperor had foreseen...just my opinion tho
Love the reaction, but you are wrong about the intensity of the fight. Personally, I think showing that pure rage of Vader is absolutely perfect. I not saying you’re wrong for liking the original better at all, I respect that but this 100% illustrates the emotion behind this fight. Granted it’s debatable Obi-Wan should be able to move like that, whether the force was a big factor (aka how Yoda is able to like he does when he fights) or that he knew he would die. Either way I don’t think the original fight did Vader’s rage justice. Just my thoughts, love the content my man and keep it up!
Its easy to see why a younger Obi could defeat Vader, while rage fuels Vader it opens him to mistakes
So glad to hear from you again!
What I really like about this is it wasn't what most sword fights are in movies - 2 Bobby Boucher's yelling "Slap hands! Slap Hands!" Every swing was a deadly strike going for the kill, not just the clashing of sabers for effect.
I love the fact that Darth Vader sensed Obi-Wan talking to Luke through the force
Your videos always make my day better ☺
I prefer this scene to the original not because its flashier but because it has the proper sense of history between these two. Obi wan literally turned anakin into a torso, and then watched him burn alive. Vader was fighting in this like he really lived those moments, you could feel the violence behind his attacks, plus they added a very anakin feeling to some of his moves. This scene is canon to me for this reason. Just brought it all home and wrapped up obi wans character arc in a way that just wasnt possible in the 70’s.
Just wow! Super impressive...I mean... most impressive. I loved the reimagining. Very respectful and well done. I couldn't bear it if Alec Guiness started doing backflips and whatever. I loved the emotional connections in the saber fight to episode 3. Good stuff.
Been waiting for this!!!
I always look forward to seeing a new vid in my notifications
That robot cut a path through out the Galaxy hunting young fit powerful Jedi Masters Knights and apprentices throughout the Galaxy
Yeah. But that was because Anakin was an incredibly powerfull Jedi. Even at 50% of his original power he was still way stronger than most other jedi, apart from the super masters like Yoda and Mace Windu of course. It was made pretty clear several times in books and stuff that Palpatine intentionally made his suit painfull and cumbersome to make sure that Vader would never be able to overthrow him.
I keep coming back and watching thos video. "You were the Chosen One!", still gives me chills.
That's the thing it was supposed to be flashy and crazy Obi one was at his most powerful during this fight using Force augmentation to keep up with Darth Vader's Superior reflexis
Everyone talks about how brutal Vader is in this reimagining, but I love how plausibly Kenobi is (just barely) holding his own...
3:30 Nice battlefront reference
Works when Yoda does it in duels, Not too Out Of the Question for Kenobi to try Strengthening his Body with the Force, It tots together well because in other Scenes Kenobi is Weary and Tired Same For Yoda, but when it comes time to fight their total badasses
LOVE IT!!!
You have the coolest name, I love the Jedi Knight series.
Hey Kyle. I only recently discovered your channel, and I'm so glad that I did. You clearly, have a deep appreciation for Star Wars. And I am a huge fan of this scene. I especially liked the idea...that Obi Wan wasn't confronting Vader to kill him. But to face his old apprentice one last time. Obi Wan knew he wasn't going to leave the Death Star alive. He just wanted to see Anakin one last time.
Kyle Katarn is off of Jedi knight outcast.
imagine the theater in 1977
I can imagine the theater in 1977 because I was there. Nobody thought the original fight was somehow lacking. On the other hand, when we all got to see the prequels years later there were lots of confused and disappointed people. I'll take the original trilogy (and sequel trilogy) light saber duels over prequel style any fucking day. If you want to know what a light saber duel is supposed to look like (in a more modern style,) then Obi-Wan vs. Maul in "SW:Rebels" is perfect.
I liked how they did the fight choreography, especially for Obi-Wan. He fought here like an old man fighting a younger, stronger, more adept fighter would, barely deflecting blows, but still showing flashes of the years of experience he has. I like to think that if Lucas had today's technology back then, this is the kind of fight he would have put in, not the flippy stuff that came in later movies. An old man's last stand against his protege.
*I've been looking forward to this*
Dang, I haven't watched one of your videos in forever!
8:42 PM
5/10/2019
Fantastic how they managed to show emotion to a figure with a mask.
Finally! Someone with the right sense of mind. This was awesome but the duel in ANH was done the way it was FOR A REASON.
Yeah, because one actor couldn't see and one couldnt hold the heavy lightsaber. This is 30x better.
It’s great as a little standalone scene but if you inserted it into the full cut you’d notice it’s really kinda bloated.
(Good) choreography tells a story without milking the moment. The purpose of the scene wasn’t to show off how cool these dudes are with their sweet moves.
Vader sees someone he previously thought was dead for 19 years and just ... charges in?
I prefer my characters to do things that make sense.
Cool scene, really impressive tech. In no way is it superior to the original.
@@KyleKatarnChannel For better or worse is an argument that will rage for a long, long time, but this does tie in better with the Vader they gave us at the end of ROGUE ONE. For two scenes that take place so close together time-wise (end of R1 and this original scene), Vader is truly a different character.
This is completely the fault of going for the "whiz-bang" factor in ROGUE ONE rather than servicing the story and continuity. The best scene action-wise in that film is the worst scene story-wise. But it's out there now, and I doubt Disney/LFL will be looking to scale it back in a R1:SE any time soon.
@@Bad_Wolf_Media Honestly, i feel like A New Hope was the one who was the one error in continuity. Because Vader has always been portrayed like this in any medium other than the original trilogy. Wether it's Legends or Canon, he has always had this raw, super-powerfull fighting style in books, shows, games, he killed Jedi all over the galaxy and pretty much always won. It was A New Hope that really undersold him because they simply didn't have the technology to do better yet.
@@EskChan19 The problem there is "A New Hope" was originally called "Star Wars," and everything - EVERYTHING! - that's come after it should have been built on that. It was first, it set the rules. It can't be "wrong" when there was nothing else to compare it to.
Every book, every comic, every cartoon, every TV show, every other movie, they all owe their very existence to "A New Hope." So they can't be right and the source material be wrong. They should have made the follow-on material to match what came before.
Absolutely love darths little battle yell right before he swings that saber for the first time at about 2:16. You know he was pissed about how obiwan left him on Mustafar.
I´m glad you acknowledged the Flashback Dialogues. Both in your review and the reaction itself (5:12).
Ohhh, i saw it. Yep, that chin tightening up. I was looking for that kind of reaction.
"That was really Powerful. That was really good" (5:51) Perfect. So many Reaction Videos disregard the "...you were my brother Anakin. I loved you!!" part.
THX
I know you're a purist when it comes to Star Wars, and I appreciate that. But, you have to admit what was awesome about this recreation was how it showed Vader's rage. The way he was striking and how aggressive he was always how I thought Vader would be confronting Obiwan for the first time since Mustafar. Also this would be Vader at a point where he's much more powerful in the Dark side, and canon tells us that he used his Dark side power to augment what he lost with his cybernetics
Whenever I watch EP IV I'll have to stop it and watch this, then proceed after the scene on the video. Aside from Princess Leia's "You came in that?" Line being omitted. This is great. It's not the same thing as George Lucas's Greedo shot first, or the other silly jawas falling off a dinosaur, Palpatine wailing as he falls, or bad Jabba the Hut rendering with Han stepping on the tail sort of additions. This is actually an improvement to a poorly executed lightsaber fight in the original. Which was made even worse by the skill displayed by the Jedi in the prequels. Yoda wasn't a spring chicken in the prequels either. Sure Alec Guinness and whoever donned the Vader suit(possibly) was stage trained Shakespearian, but the standard while certainly great for a stage when the audience has to watch through binoculars wouldn't hold up on film.
Weird question: what dimensions are your book shelves and where you get them? Lol
I HAD THAT FIGHT SCENE DREAMED UP IN MY HEAD 20 YEARS AGO..!
SHAME I NEVER GOT TO LEARN C G I
Im glad to hear you as well think the original was perfect, though I love what they did with this the original is still superior Vader hadnt seen obiwan in twenty years he would be hesitant to rush in like boxers that haven't fought each other. Not knowing if obiwan had a new trick up his sleeve.
Not everything has to be flippy flippy action action
No Vader wouldn't. We know how easily he succumbs to his emotions. And he has always been portrayed as just walking straight into battle. Vader has never been portrayed as carefull, in no source throughout canon or legends. And he hated noone more than Obi-Wan, who he held responsible for all the bad stuff that happened. This is totally in-character for Vader.
You really don't notice the face if you're focusing on the lightsabers contacting that's what most people watch
I saw obi wan pull off an old jedi Palpatine move...😆
You've changed, Katarn. I sense anger in you. Those tatoos, man, they are the path to the dark side.
Don't lecture me, Skywalker...
Can you react to the second part of IMPS Relentless?
2:50 to 3:08 is DIVINE!
They should do a remangin of solo vs boba
Mr.Katarn you're beard is soo crazy looks like Obi Wan Ep 3 Revenge of the Sith like. Very awesome :) :D
this will be a day long remembered it has seen the end of Kenobi soon it will be the end of the rebellion...
Why the fuck do you not have 100k subs at least Jesus you have some really good content
the originals werent "flashy" for one reason only. technology of cinema at the time.
I'm with you on the original duel in Ep 4. two old samurai. it makes a lot more sense if you actually watch a few kendo matches too knowing they were styling the original on kendo, and the slower pace of Kurosawa samurai duels, and not the acrobatics that come in the prequels.
Hadn’t Kenobi just cut off that bar patron’s arm? It hasn’t been that long since he’d used his lightsaber.
Hello Kyle are you going to star wars galaxy's edge when it opens
It makes me think of rouge one vader
*PLOTTWIST* Obi wan pulls out another lightsaber out of his beard and cuts vaders head off
Vader is so in your face !
I wish these guys would remake all three movies. Probably the only way I’d actually like a remake of the originals.
Liked it
Obi-Wan annihilated Maul in 3 moves is that battle he didn't need to move much but against a powerful Sith Lord like Darth Vader
Legatus Lucius too be fair Maul was traveling the desert for a few days, Half a week at most without food or water, So he wasn’t exactly in tip top shape
Not that I’m bashing the Duel itself, Because Ben had it planned out perfectly and knew what Maul would try given their past Encounters
@@Fi_Sci_ but to counter your point a Sith can go on without food or water and use only the dark side of the force to sustain themselves Maul is the greatest example of this being half a man and used the dark side of the force to sustain his body
Legatus Lucius yet he still lost to Kenobi haha
@@Fi_Sci_ good
*mr personality over here* lol
I disagree about Vaders power though. Padme's death is what pushed him to the peak of his power. Even Palpatine gave a prophecy in Episode III "Darth Vader shall become more powerful than either of us".
Wait, are you just using the name kyle katarn? Or are you actually Jason Court
It wasn't intent that made original Episode IV "vanilla", it was all sorts of actual limitations: the original lightsaber props were fragile, Alec Guinness was a frail old man, David Prowse could barely see and like Guinness, wasn't a trained stage fighter, Lucas couldn't afford a fight coreographer, so they kept it WAY simple, and they just didn't have the budget to pay for an extended fight, including the lightsaber visuals. It's fine to be loyal, but this isn't a case of "Han shot first", this reimagining is superior, physically and dramatically.
The prequels are valid, and they showed how the Force enables manuevers beyond pure physicality, Yoda at 800 years old holding his own against Palpatine and Palpatine himself killing three Jedis in less than two seconds. Vader, by IV, has abandoned (for damn good reasons) his wild acrobatics, the corridors don't allow for Jedi leaps, but otherwise, it's two master wizards going balls to the walls...with Obi-wan realizing he'll "win" as long as Luke gets away.
Oh dear.. you got an Subscribe just for your Nickname
You're saying that this wasn't supposed to be a flashy fight, because Vader lost his limbs? He was more powerful than most people he ever met. But i guess you're right when you think about the age. All I'm saying is that Vader was fucking powerful without his limbs as well!
CAN WE HEAR YOUR ALBUM
My issue is I know Obi-wan was old but I feel they didn't really do his fighting style justice he was the master of form 3 soresu which he combines with form 4 Ataru. He scared Dooku to the point that Dooku was scared to see what he was capable of as well as he was the only Jedi to be able to fight grevious because of his trust and tranquil use of the force by letting it literally possess him and he became just a shell for the force. He was also only like 57 so he wouldn't have been a frail old man especially by Jedi standards. They definitely did justice for Vadar thought none stop assault utilizing his robotics and force enhancements to aggressively attack his opponent 10/10 🤷🏻♂️ eh I am just Obi-wan fanboy lol
What do you mean "especially for Jedi Standards"? There's no Jedi standards. Being a jedi doesn't make you live longer. The only supremely old jedi we knew was Yoda and that only because his race lives super long.
@@EskChan19 Randy19 Jedi standards as in a Jedi who is 57 years or even 60 would not be on the same standards of strength and abilities by someone who is not a Jedi or a force user they would be above them.
As for the Yoda what are you talking about?
I said nothing about Yoda this entire video has nothing to do with Yoda do yourself a favor and read my comment in full before jumping the gun.
To help your perspective of things Obi-wan was 57 years old roughly in his rematch with Vadar and his master Qui-gon was just over 60 when they fought maul as you can see Jedi are not so easily weak because they have aged.
Kyle Katarn, when you have time can you react to black crystal by kay ani it deserves more attention than its getting
If there is i want to send you a first order helmet and later a sith trooper one
I know I am 2 years late but whatever
I agree with you that this is not suppouse to be a flashy fights with blackflips but I disagree with your reasons. The Robots cant do shit is really dump. In this movie they need to show the power of Vader and how strong is he (because make no mistake he is Rouge one or the end of Fallen Order). The real reason (It think) that that fight is perfect is that its the start its the start of all the big ass amazing lightsaber fights we all love. We dont need to remake we just need to pay respect (by pushing F :D) for the fight wich was the source for the BEST ACTION SEQUENCES IN CINEMA HOSTORY.
Kyle, what about reacting to a New Hope made by Adywan? It's called "Revisited" If you not like Special Edition in 1997, you gonna like it))
You have to admit Kyle, there was always one little point that was somewhat annoying about the original fight and that was that little pirouette that Kenobi did at some point, it servec absolutely no purpose. At least in this version it looked like he got twisted around by Vader. Much more convincing to me.
Yeah, I’d be lying if I said that little spin move didn’t bug me.
This is fuking cannon to me
I mean Kenobi would have killed Maul like a year before fighting Vader.
Please react to the following videos by DuduFilm:
Revenge Of The Sith - Lost Home / We Are What They Made us / PART 1
It's Time For The Jedi To End / Revenge of The Sith Part 2
Into The Void - Self Destruction (Star Wars)
I'm sorry its no way you liked that original battle. The only reason the first fight wasn't flashy was because of the technology and the story wasn't about the fight it was about obi becoming a force ghost and helping luke. Had nothing about them being old. Did you see yoga fighting at 800 years ago
You're Kyle Katarn?
From a certain point of view...
Great now no1 will watch the original scene the same.
I wasn't a fan of the original fight. There's not enough raw emotion in it. From Anakin especially, this fight has a lot of emotions (particularly hatred, of course) tied up in it. The original fight heavily failed to convey that, mainly as an artifact of that time period. With the way movies were made back then, it wasn't really possible to convey strong emotions very well. But with modern technology, it's possible to finally give scenes the power to convey the underlying emotions, and their sheer strength. This fan work really shows that well. The choreography, the music, the throwback to the lines from episode three, the effects... All of it builds an intense mood, and really conveys the strength of the emotions the characters feel, and how powerful the backstory between them is regarding this particular scene. It does what the original scene absolutely failed to do. Again, it couldn't really be helped, as at the time it was made, the technology just wasn't good enough. So, for the time, it was likely very acceptable. Now, however, we can raise the bar, and do scenes like this the justice they deserve.
You look like walmart burzum, No offense
Yeah? Did someone call and tell you that . . . Euronymously? 😉
@@KyleKatarnChannel Yeah, It caused a bit of..... Mayhem 😎
The original light saber fights were character moments that were meant to express the emotion of the characters and thematic tone. The prequel generation's obsession with highly choreographed light-stick dance fighting just completely misses the point.
RawkMode highly choreographed light-stick dance can express emotion.
The prequels just went a *little* too over the top.
Not flashy? Vader waited 20 years to kill this guy lmao and you like him poking at him? Rogue one changed everything
You say darth vader cant fight? In a way darth vader becomes a better fighter then when he was Anakin... it shows in comics and so on
In many ways he does, yes, but he can’t fight the way Anakin does in the prequels. That’s the point I was trying to make
@@KyleKatarnChannel Yeah it's normal just imagine yourself trying to parry Vader's power strike. He is WAAAY Stronger than when he was Anakin, less techniques but way more brute strength. I mean try to parry a robot when you're in your 60's.
My opinion the way they did it was sooo much better then the original the original was just poking some Dialogue no real emotion this added great fighting more visual pleasure more aggressiveness from Vader and also still showing how even tho old how amazing obi wan Is as a Swordsman and all in all just so much emotion like you felt every angry swing Vader Swang and obi-Wan’s pain of fighting his brother again and the I hate you part with obis u were my brother I loved you was the icing on the cake it just Tied everything in very nicely if they ever remake the original they honestly can keep everything else the same but use this for there fight just graphic it alittle better even tho this is insane already
Sorry but The fact of the matter is the original scene was really bad...everyone says "oh its all about the emotion between the two" I understand that i really do but the prequels weren't even out so i guess i wonder how you felt before the prequels came to be and watched the Vader and obi wan scene cause to be REAL the way they awkwardly swung their sabers was NOT emotional im sorry 😂 George even stated they couldn't make hard contact cause the saber prop was fragile. I bet if they were in the prequel era making A New Hope, the scene would have been more like this reimagined scene.
I felt the same way about the scene before the prequels came out.
There was no frame of reference to compare it to, we were happy to get what we had.
People who never knew a time before the prequels will never fully get it.
Also when I watched this I never expected that classic scene to be EVEN MORE emotional. It really gets you now. ANd not only because of the flashbacks. Because you really catch yourself rooting for the beloved old man, hoping he'll make it somehow, all while finding yourself in AWE at the Black Knight in his full glory or infamy... when the coup de grace comes it really gets you.
Machines can't do shit wow I'm signing off before I say anything I regret
lmao you know what I mean. Droids vs Jedi only goes one way
Am I the only one that thinks the "Now you will die" line is just cheesy?
I disagree, this does seem to give the message that the original is inadequate...and the responses seem to back that up. I feel you want to rip this apart, but are afraid of not jumping on the bandwagon
I just made this comment earlier what they did was fantastic bravo a great achievement. But not necessary. in 1978 Star wars won the academy award for best visual effects because their effects were never seen before it was original.they used the technology of then and did the best they could. When you add special edits you take away the achievement of the men and women from back then. you make it meaningless. Big-time corporations are going to pay to be added to other classic movies. Casablanca will be in the shopping center between the Starbucks and Walmart
Stars Wars is so bad the fan made short scenes put the last couple of movies to shame.
You are entitled to your incorrect opinion.
I HAD THAT FIGHT SCENE DREAMED UP IN MY HEAD 20 YEARS AGO..!
SHAME I NEVER GOT TO LEARN C G I