This kind of shopping has a humanizing effect. You get to know the owners, and they get to know you. It becomes a relationship, not just a transaction. A feeling of community. I miss that.
When I was a child, I often went to the shotengai. Unlike chain stores, the interaction between people was very warm. They often gave me free sweets on my way home from school. I am sad to say that the number of such shops has been decreasing recently. If you ever come to Japan, please visit a shotengai ! Thanks for making this video. From Japan.
My heart melts when I see human scaled streets like the one at 9:10. There's something so calming about a street where people can walk and shop with leisure without the stress of fast moving automobiles.
Yes, good point about 'human scaled' environments, a movement which has been gaining recognition in international urban planning. Though we in the US are spoiled regarding 'living space', and the sorta density that is common in Japan might take a bit of 'cultural' adjustment.
@@jac1011 I love that channel. A really underrated channel is Dean Bog. He does these short films on neighborhoods in Pittsburg that are excellently done
I live in Europe where we have pedestrianised town centres. When I visited the US for the first time I was shocked how huge everything was, wide roads and urban environment designed for motorists.
This reminds me of the English High St. By the 80's the locally owned high street shops were being replaced with large chain stores and the owners who used to live above them no longer did so but to this day the layout of every high street in England has a lot of similarities to their Japanese equivalent. Back in 1980 the UK did not yet have out of town malls or supermarkets and local people who lived in walking distance of their local high street did pretty much all their shopping there.
That's untrue. We did have "out of town malls" but we refer to them as shopping centres, along with the inner city shopping centres, and they were pretty rare. Not far from me, there are 2 major "out of town malls". One is the Metrocentre located in the outskirts of the teams, Gateshead. There's also Dalton Park located in Durham. There's also 3 major inner city shopping centres and like 10 smaller inner city shopping centres near me. the big 3 include The Galleries (Washington, sunderland, though this could also be cast as an "out of town malls" cause of the lower living density of washington itself), Eldon Square, Newcastle City Centre and Grainger Street Market ( A permanent indoor market that usually has the same independent* shops inside) The only issue, unlike over the pond, these were never cheap, so the only places that could afford it were the national and international chains (Like McDonalds, greggs, Next, Curry's, JD Sports etc.) and thus were usually limited in number. Metrocentre opened it's doors in 1986. What you probably meant, though, was that until the '80's the UK have very few "out of town malls" and the ones that existed were usually located in the south-west of england. * Most of the stores inside are independant with 1 single exception. Marks and Spencers (Known globally as M&S) was founded there as Marks and Spencers Penny Arcade** and still retains that store to this day. **a Penny Arcade used to refer to a small independant budget orientated store, much like a modern day poundland/home bargains/poundstretcher/herons/b&m, 100 yen store or dollar store but more independant (as these are national chains as far as I'm aware). PS Metrocentre (or officially The Metrocentre before INTU's acquisition and then later liquidation of the shopping centre) is indeed one word, I had to double check, as spell checker doesn't identify it as a word.
I was thinking that it's more like a shopping arcade. There still around in a lot of UK cities. Lots of them have small clothing shop, craft stores and fabric markets. 🙂
Walking around shotengai was one of the best parts of visiting Japan. I wish we could have more of a walking-city culture in the US, having to drive everywhere gets so boring and you miss out on the chance to happen upon something you've never seen before
I have to say, I’ve been with your channel since WAY early on and watching your videos now is like watching a professional documentary. Production value has gone way up and it’s just incredible to see how far you’ve come. Thanks for always uploading such high quality videos on my favorite place on earth :)
The quality of Greg's videos on this channel went from good to great. These aren't "like watching a professional documentary". These are professional documentaries. The only real problem Greg stumbles over is choosing what to focus on. He needs a marketing consultant/researcher to help him find interesting subjects and stories. I suppose this channel would be averaging 1 million views per video... if Greg presented more interesting subjects and stories. It's not a trivial problem to solve, but it's not difficult. Greg simply needs to find the right person to do the job.
@@yekutielbenheshel354 If he were to focus on catering to masses, then we wouldn't have extremely interesting niche and rarely spoken about topics like these. As far as I'm concerned, he should do just what he likes to study about.
@@recyclebinladen5903 If he's content with his current view count then this niche seems reasonable. But there's huge potential to increase viewership. The topics he chooses are generally too boring for many people. His ramen shop video was great and probably appealed to a wide audience, yet I would guess probably appealed to you too.
@@yekutielbenheshel354 Ah, I see. I wouldn't call them boring though. I really like his videos on zoning, town planning, homelessness and other stuff outside of normal food videos. I absolutely loved his video on Muslims in Japan - and I hope he can do more of such niche topics. There are so many food oriented content creators out there, I doubt we need any more.
@@recyclebinladen5903 Did you watch the Ramen shop video? It wasn't about food; it was about the struggles of a small businessman trying to earn a living. It was great and extremely popular. I thought the zoning and homeless videos were great too... but those aren't going to appeal to large numbers of viewers. The best videos for a channel like this are, "Here's what life is like for person A, or person B, or person C" where person A, or person B, or person C live a life that is different and interesting compared to life in, say, the West.
i'll say, these are just the kind of things that international tourists LOVE to visit. Tourists don't wanna go to the mall, they want something they can't get back home and Shotengai are exactly that. I think if the owners want to counteract the big malls, they need to cater to tourists as something special and unique about Japan. I'm sure many shotengai already cater primarily to tourists anyway.
These businesses need local repeat customers. Tourists only stop once or not at all. Most tourists have a been there done that, so many places to explore, no need going back to the same place and if they do come back to a particular store it will be a year or 3 years gap. They can't depend on tourists traffic.
Really enjoyed this video. While I love the shotengai's atmosphere, I agree that having places to eat and a toilet nearby is key to keeping the crowds coming back. It was an unusual experience having to hunt for a McD for some bladder relief.
The convenience of living next to so many useful shops and restaurants is exactly what I'd wish for. I love the idea of having my favorite eateries and snack shops just outside my door.
These walks for me are fascinating, seeing how communities from foreign shores live and where they do their daily shopping 🛍 in Japan. I'm so glad your able to enjoy showing us these amazing places thanks, I just love these walks.
When I lived in Auckland, New Zealand, there was a Queen's arcade at the end of Queen St. in downtown Auckland that had a lot of locally owned shops and only a few brands. I loved walking there and browsing and it had an old records shop as well as a Tabletop game store (located quite appropriately in the basement). If you're ever in Auckland, spend a bit of time there.
I find a unique charm in all of the smaller independent shops that have a story to tell and have unique things that not many chain stores can replicate!
Thank you for this fascinating in-depth look at the issues surrounding shotengai. I lived for several years in Okachimachi, near Ueno, just steps from Satake Shotengai (said to be the second-oldest in Tokyo) and everything you discussed could be found there--including shuttered shops, new arrivals, big apartment buildings, and issues with a lack of foot traffic (it's about a 10-minute walk from JR Okachimachi Station). The older shopkeepers say the area used to be much more bustling. Where I live now in Toyama, the situation is even more dire, and I'd say at least 50% of the shops in our neighborhood shotengai are now permanently shuttered. An Aeon Mall located a 20-minute drive away hasn't helped the situation.
I got the idea to make the video after you all watched the videos about a typical Tokyo neighbourhood ua-cam.com/video/TheOkz8oF_I/v-deo.html and zoning ua-cam.com/video/wfm2xCKOCNk/v-deo.html It was fun to explore all the different shops in the local shotengai.
High quality as usual, Greg. I’ve always enjoyed wandering around ‘shotengais’, especially the ones in Nagoya and Osaka (the nearest big cities from me). Here in Mie, they’ve been steadily dying since the 90s. BUT, have actually been getting a bit popular again since the pandemic started. My favorite local one (in Yokkaichi) has a craft beer bar that kind of expands out into the street, like a covered biergarten. Well-ventilated, social drinking for the pandemic era! 🍻
I think shotengai provide something we’ve keenly felt the loss of and need for during the pandemic: community. When the shop owners live where they work, they are part of the community. There is much more exchanged than merchandise and money. I don’t think we realised how much we, as humans, need that until a couple of years ago.
The business hours of locally owned shops are so real. I still remember the fried chicken place that was on our way from the airbnb to Dotonbori. We walked by it the first time and it was opened but every subsequent day whenever we walked by it was closed. We left Osaka after a week without knowing how that fried chicken shop taste lol
In my country (Singapore) it's a similar phenomenon with food hawkers (many of whom are selling in purpose-built buildings, while those operating on the streets only do so temporarily e.g. for night market bazaars). On the flip side for shops in shopping malls, their tenancy contract may stipulate when they need to be open
I used to live in Kawasaki while I was studying in Japan, and would often enjoy walking around the local shotengai near the station after classes. About 80% of the stores are local mom-and-pop stores, I think. And some of the best ramen I had can usually be found in these independent stores.
Your videos are absolutely out of this world, they make me feel tocuhed, relaxed and willing to overcome my fears, thank you for this hardwork you put into everything you do! ❤
I wanna go to Japan and visit all these places so badly. They put so much care and love into what they do. It’s so nice to see. We should support them all we can!
I love shotengai but they do need to have places to sit, talk, and eat. In that sense, they will need to evolve. People want something that is the street equivalent of a friendly neighborhood coffee shop.
Now that I think about it, Tokyo doesn't have much in the way of public spaces, does it? Is that more of a Tokyo, or a Japan thing? I can't recall seeing many public benches, and certainly no parks or squares with a bunch of seating. I also don't remember seeing any outdoor dining. For some reason I'd never thought about it till now.
@@SnakebitSTI I think it is only the super busy places. Even in America and Europe, the busy places to this: Move people in and out fast. There are other locations to hang around though. Japan actually has amazing public spaces. This includes Tokyo. There are giant parks to sit around and various other squares and plazas to hang out at. It is just that busy businesses might not have the space to just let people hang out. I think this means that just as in any city, just be aware where the public spaces are and take your food and friends there. Or find a less busy coffee shop, though businesses might not always want people just loitering around.
10:00 This seems a good suggestion. Imagine a place where instead of a shop it was a resting area with tables where people can eat what they bought. This would decrease the problem of "not knowing what the shops have to offer", customers could see what other customers are buying and share recommendations. edit: oh, by the way, what are shopping streets like were I'm from? Hum... I think here in Brazil we have two types. One is called "Calçadão", that it's bunch of streets close to the traffic with shops only. It's not as organized was these shotengai looks but it works. On Calçadão there may be big chain stores but most are small stores with all it's attractions, and because the streets are narrower and cozier and there aren't nearly as many as like shotengai those places tend to be very, very crowded. Maybe because of this the inverse is happening, the Calçadão that I know and frequent is becoming to crowded to the point you could call it hellish, hard to shop there. The other type is "Marcadão". It's usually a covered area with stores, usually more traditional and handmade stores. It's common for these Mercadão to concentrate shops selling products from other regions of the country, most of them from the North and Northeast.
My wife and I was fortunate to visit Japan before the pandemic. Grew up in NYC, visited Europe, and now living in the Midwest of the U.S. Japan is still my favorite.
I really do like shotengai and arcades. They have such a unique feeling to them and sometimes a little magical. In my area, we do have a couple of streets that have a mix of chain stores and smaller local stores, but nowhere near the same feeling.
the type of shops that will be able to survive was that izakaya you showed because of their dynamic nature of dishes with respect to the season plus they feel comfartable. As time is changing shotengai need to adapt to their audience/consumers. I hope they keep existing as they are a part of history
Here in the uk, we have a similar concept called High Streets, which are streets dominated by or exclusively shops. In the UK, unless it is located in a speed zone (which is an area of a town or city that is set to 1 specific speed limit. In most cases this is 20 or 30 MPH (AKA 32 or 48 km/h). Examples of large High Streets near (but not close to) me would be Birtley Highstreet (Located along Durham Road in Birtley Town Centre) Chester-le-street Market Place (in County Durham) and Newcastle Northumberland Street/Grey Street/Market Street (In newcastle city centre) Usually the biggest high streets are in cities, with exception of super large towns like birtley or civil parishes that cover a largely populated area like chester-le-street. Most towns with have a smaller High Street with say like 5 businesses and a Aldi and/or Lidl. Wrekenton Highstreet is an example of a smaller high street. Gateshead High Street & Trinity Square is another.
A fascinating story, because I live in a small city in the western US, near a shopping street like this, although very American in its operation. When I was young, this street had many small businesses patronized by locals, mostly white-owned. Since I have grown up, most of the businesses have been taken over by Southeast Asian immigrants, usually operating their own style of business. They have brought their own cultures, including New Years celebrations, and they are responsible and progressive business owners. There is a large mall and chain stores nearby, but they persist, and have dealt with the growing community successfully.
I live in Osaka and shoutengai are probably my favorite part of living in here. I've been known to walk a few kilometers out of the way to visit a new-to-me one. Sometimes I'm pleasantly surprised like the Komagawa Nakano shoutengai, which became our main produce shopping spot, and sometimes I'm sad and disappointed like the Hirano shoutengai, where most stores have been closed for around 20 years. Some are great people watching places like the longest in Japan, Tenjinbashisuji and others are modern malls like Shinsaibashisuji. If you want to get the pulse of every day life in Japan, visit and shop the shoutengai. The owners are always willing to help and Osakans being much friendlier than Tokyoites, will go out of their way to chat you up and try to make you laugh.
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. If you're going to have your shutters closed, it'd be nice to have something on them that'll help brighten up the place.
Shotengai would definitely take off here in the states as many of our malls are being converted into being less shopping mall and more shopping street (my local mall has a tech fix place, cafes, and even a dentist office and another had one of it’s anchor spaces converted into a school). In fact the only difference between American shopping streets and Japanese shopping streets is that American shopping streets include places to eat/rest and public toilets.
Places like these are the flames keeping the sense of community warm and alive. We have similar streets where I'm from but more about hustle and bustle.
A thoroughly enjoyable look at old and traditional Japan. Good interviews and excellent content, not to mention the contributions of Ako who seemed to be enjoying herself 🎉. Good work, Greg!
Amazing video as usual. I think these shotengais offer a unique experience where every shop has its own signature. I hope that all of these shotengais will continue on in the future.
Another thing I want to go to Japan for! I love the atmosphere of Shotengai whenever they're shown in videos, movies, anime, etc. Thank you so much for this video!
This exactly why I try to shop at independently owned shops! We call them Mom and Pop stores here in Hawai’i ! They have character and take the time chat with Customers when time permits. It gives a Human Touch compared to chain businesses which is all about the bottom line! Our world is becoming robotic with the addition of self checkout and I refuse to use it! SHOP MOM AND POP!
Funnily, I've seen a couple of other vids on Jujo in the last couple of weeks--probably a result of observation bias--but yours, Greg, is the deepest and most informative. Thanks again for your great work!
My wife and sister-in-law contacted a few shotengai and we were able to get an interview with them, which is a big reason why we went there. It was a great experience. But there are so many shotengai that it is surprising that you saw a couple other vids in the past couple of weeks.
This is kind of how bazareks look like in Poland, on a much smaller scale and with less variety of shops but it's pretty close. They are often combinad with farmer's markets. It's usually fruit and veg stores (either run by farmers themselves or imported), small grocery stores (sometimes with imported foods, usually from Germany or Ukraine), butchers, clothes stores (often cheap clothes but it CAN be niche chain shops as well), cafes, bakeries, patisseries, toy stores, healthy food stores, medicine shops etc. Pretty much anything can be bought there.
we have a lot of shops that have closed on our shopping street, but I love the atmosphere these places have. We still have a traditional 雁木通り, maybe the oldest or longest in Japan. That could be an interesting video, too 😊
Hey, you must have been in my neighborhood, Greg! I recognized the 東十条銀座商店街 which I pass through every weekday, in the video. And as always: great work, great video!
Wow. Shotengai sound (and look) fabulous. I wish we had them in the Midwest. Shopping Streets don't exist here. Today I got up at 7:45AM to catch the bus downtown. I got off the bus at the last stop and walked 5 blocks for coffee and breakfast. Then I walked 8 blocks back the other direction past where I got off the 1st bus and caught bus #2 to go to the 2nd biggest chain store in town, which is 30 minutes away on that bus. Done there, I caught bus #3 to cheap chain store and cheaper chain store, then caught the return trip of bus #3 back to where I got off bus #1. I then walked 5 blocks to catch bus #4 to the 2nd outlet of the cheapest chain store and went for lunch at the fried chicken place across the busy highway from that store. Shopping done for the day, I caught bus #4 again so I could make the connection to bus #5 and head home. I could have caught the return trip of bus #4, but that route is really bumpy and winding and it makes me sick. I wish I did not go on that bus before lunch, but after lunch would have been worse. At the last stop back downtown for the #5 bus, I exited bus #5 expecting to catch the return trip of bus #1 home, as it's supposed to go 5 minutes after the time bus #5 dropped me off. But it didn't go, so I waited 30 minutes in the 95 degrees Fahrenheit blazing sun, sweating, getting hotter by the minute, and blinded because it was so bright. I felt half dead by the time bus #1 showed up to go home at 5:41PM. So, in all, I went to 5 stores and 2 eating places, and it took me 10 hours, about half of which was actually on the buses. And there was a bus between bus #2 and bus #3 which I didn't count because it's just a route to connect between bus #2 and bus #3 because there's more than 3 miles between the transfer points and it's too far to walk.
If those shuttered shotengai spots can be converted to rest stop areas with seats n vending machines, this could be an income stream without active participation, especially when it’s a busy shotengai without areas to sit and rest.
I really enjoyed seeing and listening to the owners of these street level independent stores. It will be testing for those associations to find ways to attract customers. I hope there will be positive outcome for the owner-occupiers. I wonder if you could find an owner that would be willing to show how one would build a new home inside the Shotengai itself. Also your sister-in-law was thoroughly enjoying herself, well done.
VERY enjoyable, and informative video! I’ve been a subscriber for about three years. This is one of my favorite videos of yours. Keep up the great work. Thank you.
This is probably your best video yet. I love everything about this. The topic, the picture it paints, the experience, the shots, the interviews and the relevant information and history sprinkled along the vid. Masterful work. Thanks for the wonderful vid
Wandering around shotengais has always been my favorite activity whenever I visit Japan. There are so many delicious foods and random stuffs that I can find when I visit these mom-and-pop shops. While the shop owners might not be able to speak English, I find them very friendly and proud of their products. The experience is very wholesome, unlike visiting large shopping malls or chain stores. Sad to know that these shotengais might not exist in the future :(
Shame to see so many shotengai going under in favor of generic, chain stores. As someone living in Canada where everything looks the same in the suburb (in Ontario), I prefer these types of streets much more the separated houses and malls we have due to zoning. They build a local community and these types of stores always have products you can't get elsewhere.
I would be stopping to check out everything 😍! The culture, the people, the language (the collective history!) just all create such a unique experience. Great video! I enjoyed it thoroughly 😌
Here in Australia shopping streets seem to co exist with malls OK. The road tends to be wider then in Japan and more cars mean less closed streets but not everything happens at a mall.
The demographic angle and land planning aspects added to this I found very interesting. I almost didn't watch it. ALL of Greg's vids are interesting, I will keep this in mind. 😁
This kind of shopping has a humanizing effect. You get to know the owners, and they get to know you. It becomes a relationship, not just a transaction. A feeling of community. I miss that.
I totally agree🥂🥗👍
I prefer a cold, impersonal corporate environment personally. Nah i’m playin. I love the flea market.
Was only intended to play this video as ''background video', but the video got so interesting it became the main activity instead.
"we would get more customers if only he was normal" Damn, this mum ain't messing around😭😭😭
why are mums always like this TT ___ TT poor guy hahaha
@@_GunpowdertheGabite they have no filter at all Istg😭
When I was a child, I often went to the shotengai.
Unlike chain stores, the interaction between people was very warm.
They often gave me free sweets on my way home from school.
I am sad to say that the number of such shops has been decreasing recently.
If you ever come to Japan, please visit a shotengai !
Thanks for making this video. From Japan.
I lived right next to one in the Ikebukuro area, such a vibrant place!
My heart melts when I see human scaled streets like the one at 9:10. There's something so calming about a street where people can walk and shop with leisure without the stress of fast moving automobiles.
Agreed! And I would probably not be scared at night.
Yes, good point about 'human scaled' environments, a movement which has been gaining recognition in international urban planning. Though we in the US are spoiled regarding 'living space', and the sorta density that is common in Japan might take a bit of 'cultural' adjustment.
check out the channel not just bikes
@@jac1011 I love that channel. A really underrated channel is Dean Bog. He does these short films on neighborhoods in Pittsburg that are excellently done
I live in Europe where we have pedestrianised town centres. When I visited the US for the first time I was shocked how huge everything was, wide roads and urban environment designed for motorists.
This reminds me of the English High St. By the 80's the locally owned high street shops were being replaced with large chain stores and the owners who used to live above them no longer did so but to this day the layout of every high street in England has a lot of similarities to their Japanese equivalent. Back in 1980 the UK did not yet have out of town malls or supermarkets and local people who lived in walking distance of their local high street did pretty much all their shopping there.
That's untrue. We did have "out of town malls" but we refer to them as shopping centres, along with the inner city shopping centres, and they were pretty rare. Not far from me, there are 2 major "out of town malls". One is the Metrocentre located in the outskirts of the teams, Gateshead. There's also Dalton Park located in Durham.
There's also 3 major inner city shopping centres and like 10 smaller inner city shopping centres near me. the big 3 include The Galleries (Washington, sunderland, though this could also be cast as an "out of town malls" cause of the lower living density of washington itself), Eldon Square, Newcastle City Centre and Grainger Street Market ( A permanent indoor market that usually has the same independent* shops inside)
The only issue, unlike over the pond, these were never cheap, so the only places that could afford it were the national and international chains (Like McDonalds, greggs, Next, Curry's, JD Sports etc.) and thus were usually limited in number.
Metrocentre opened it's doors in 1986. What you probably meant, though, was that until the '80's the UK have very few "out of town malls" and the ones that existed were usually located in the south-west of england.
* Most of the stores inside are independant with 1 single exception. Marks and Spencers (Known globally as M&S) was founded there as Marks and Spencers Penny Arcade** and still retains that store to this day.
**a Penny Arcade used to refer to a small independant budget orientated store, much like a modern day poundland/home bargains/poundstretcher/herons/b&m, 100 yen store or dollar store but more independant (as these are national chains as far as I'm aware).
PS Metrocentre (or officially The Metrocentre before INTU's acquisition and then later liquidation of the shopping centre) is indeed one word, I had to double check, as spell checker doesn't identify it as a word.
This market stuff is common everywhere in Eastern Europe and Asia.
I was thinking that it's more like a shopping arcade. There still around in a lot of UK cities. Lots of them have small clothing shop, craft stores and fabric markets. 🙂
Sister knows how to enjoy life and tea guy and mother combo so funny. Regards from Malaysian utuber
My towns high street is still like this 85% independently owned stores and thriving
Walking around shotengai was one of the best parts of visiting Japan. I wish we could have more of a walking-city culture in the US, having to drive everywhere gets so boring and you miss out on the chance to happen upon something you've never seen before
I have to say, I’ve been with your channel since WAY early on and watching your videos now is like watching a professional documentary. Production value has gone way up and it’s just incredible to see how far you’ve come.
Thanks for always uploading such high quality videos on my favorite place on earth :)
The quality of Greg's videos on this channel went from good to great. These aren't "like watching a professional documentary". These are professional documentaries.
The only real problem Greg stumbles over is choosing what to focus on. He needs a marketing consultant/researcher to help him find interesting subjects and stories.
I suppose this channel would be averaging 1 million views per video... if Greg presented more interesting subjects and stories.
It's not a trivial problem to solve, but it's not difficult. Greg simply needs to find the right person to do the job.
@@yekutielbenheshel354 If he were to focus on catering to masses, then we wouldn't have extremely interesting niche and rarely spoken about topics like these. As far as I'm concerned, he should do just what he likes to study about.
@@recyclebinladen5903 If he's content with his current view count then this niche seems reasonable. But there's huge potential to increase viewership. The topics he chooses are generally too boring for many people.
His ramen shop video was great and probably appealed to a wide audience, yet I would guess probably appealed to you too.
@@yekutielbenheshel354 Ah, I see. I wouldn't call them boring though. I really like his videos on zoning, town planning, homelessness and other stuff outside of normal food videos. I absolutely loved his video on Muslims in Japan - and I hope he can do more of such niche topics.
There are so many food oriented content creators out there, I doubt we need any more.
@@recyclebinladen5903 Did you watch the Ramen shop video? It wasn't about food; it was about the struggles of a small businessman trying to earn a living. It was great and extremely popular.
I thought the zoning and homeless videos were great too... but those aren't going to appeal to large numbers of viewers. The best videos for a channel like this are, "Here's what life is like for person A, or person B, or person C" where person A, or person B, or person C live a life that is different and interesting compared to life in, say, the West.
I love seeing Ako in your videos, she always seems so happy and lively. Like a big kid being excited by everything, it's a joy to watch.
Greg really lucked out on her :). It must be a joy to have such a traveling buddy.
Another superbly shot video, thanks.
@@rinu1 I think he’s her sister-in-law?
She seems to be really happy and a very nice friend🥂🥗💫
i'll say, these are just the kind of things that international tourists LOVE to visit. Tourists don't wanna go to the mall, they want something they can't get back home and Shotengai are exactly that. I think if the owners want to counteract the big malls, they need to cater to tourists as something special and unique about Japan. I'm sure many shotengai already cater primarily to tourists anyway.
These businesses need local repeat customers. Tourists only stop once or not at all. Most tourists have a been there done that, so many places to explore, no need going back to the same place and if they do come back to a particular store it will be a year or 3 years gap. They can't depend on tourists traffic.
My all time favourite video of yours was the one about Tokyo Zoning so I’m stoked to see this one! Awesome work as always
Glad you're enjoying!
Really enjoyed this video.
While I love the shotengai's atmosphere, I agree that having places to eat and a toilet nearby is key to keeping the crowds coming back. It was an unusual experience having to hunt for a McD for some bladder relief.
Yeah, chains are good for finding a place to relieve yourself! My other go-to's are parks, convenience stores and department stores.
Can you share where the tea shop at the beginning of the great video is or is called?
@@khuynh1987 Darumaya (だるまや餅菓子店) @ Jujo Ginza Shopping Mall
The convenience of living next to so many useful shops and restaurants is exactly what I'd wish for. I love the idea of having my favorite eateries and snack shops just outside my door.
I love that this channel is a mix of walking and interviewing people - my two favorite Japan-related genres on UA-cam!
These walks for me are fascinating, seeing how communities from foreign shores live and where they do their daily shopping 🛍 in Japan. I'm so glad your able to enjoy showing us these amazing places thanks, I just love these walks.
When I lived in Auckland, New Zealand, there was a Queen's arcade at the end of Queen St. in downtown Auckland that had a lot of locally owned shops and only a few brands. I loved walking there and browsing and it had an old records shop as well as a Tabletop game store (located quite appropriately in the basement). If you're ever in Auckland, spend a bit of time there.
I find a unique charm in all of the smaller independent shops that have a story to tell and have unique things that not many chain stores can replicate!
Thank you for this fascinating in-depth look at the issues surrounding shotengai. I lived for several years in Okachimachi, near Ueno, just steps from Satake Shotengai (said to be the second-oldest in Tokyo) and everything you discussed could be found there--including shuttered shops, new arrivals, big apartment buildings, and issues with a lack of foot traffic (it's about a 10-minute walk from JR Okachimachi Station). The older shopkeepers say the area used to be much more bustling. Where I live now in Toyama, the situation is even more dire, and I'd say at least 50% of the shops in our neighborhood shotengai are now permanently shuttered. An Aeon Mall located a 20-minute drive away hasn't helped the situation.
I got the idea to make the video after you all watched the videos about a typical Tokyo neighbourhood ua-cam.com/video/TheOkz8oF_I/v-deo.html and zoning ua-cam.com/video/wfm2xCKOCNk/v-deo.html It was fun to explore all the different shops in the local shotengai.
😂 my comment just mentioned these past videos you did!
You should do a collaboration with the guy from the Not Just Bikes channel. He's also from Canada and loves walkability considerations.
Hi,
I loved your video
Whst’s the name and adress of the tea shop where you tasted gyokori tea
I want to buy some tea in this shop as I am in Tokyo ..
A truly great, inspirational and knowledgeable made video👏👍
I get the feeling of being right there and learning a lot at the same time🌤️👏😀
High quality as usual, Greg. I’ve always enjoyed wandering around ‘shotengais’, especially the ones in Nagoya and Osaka (the nearest big cities from me). Here in Mie, they’ve been steadily dying since the 90s. BUT, have actually been getting a bit popular again since the pandemic started. My favorite local one (in Yokkaichi) has a craft beer bar that kind of expands out into the street, like a covered biergarten. Well-ventilated, social drinking for the pandemic era! 🍻
I think shotengai provide something we’ve keenly felt the loss of and need for during the pandemic: community. When the shop owners live where they work, they are part of the community. There is much more exchanged than merchandise and money. I don’t think we realised how much we, as humans, need that until a couple of years ago.
@@user-no2mz9hl4f Agreed!!
I'm loving Akoさん in these videos! Miss the kids, but I'm glad they're doing what they want to do.
5:25 i hope that guy gets to share his tea with the world that made me happy
The business hours of locally owned shops are so real. I still remember the fried chicken place that was on our way from the airbnb to Dotonbori. We walked by it the first time and it was opened but every subsequent day whenever we walked by it was closed. We left Osaka after a week without knowing how that fried chicken shop taste lol
True, true. I now use Google Maps to check out the shops, their hours, and reviews, especially when I'm visiting an area for the first time.
In my country (Singapore) it's a similar phenomenon with food hawkers (many of whom are selling in purpose-built buildings, while those operating on the streets only do so temporarily e.g. for night market bazaars). On the flip side for shops in shopping malls, their tenancy contract may stipulate when they need to be open
I used to live in Kawasaki while I was studying in Japan, and would often enjoy walking around the local shotengai near the station after classes. About 80% of the stores are local mom-and-pop stores, I think. And some of the best ramen I had can usually be found in these independent stores.
Your videos are absolutely out of this world, they make me feel tocuhed, relaxed and willing to overcome my fears, thank you for this hardwork you put into everything you do! ❤
Cheers Ako 🍺 thank you for showing us around 🙏🙂
I wanna go to Japan and visit all these places so badly. They put so much care and love into what they do. It’s so nice to see. We should support them all we can!
I love shotengai but they do need to have places to sit, talk, and eat. In that sense, they will need to evolve. People want something that is the street equivalent of a friendly neighborhood coffee shop.
Now that I think about it, Tokyo doesn't have much in the way of public spaces, does it? Is that more of a Tokyo, or a Japan thing? I can't recall seeing many public benches, and certainly no parks or squares with a bunch of seating. I also don't remember seeing any outdoor dining. For some reason I'd never thought about it till now.
@@SnakebitSTI I think it is only the super busy places. Even in America and Europe, the busy places to this: Move people in and out fast. There are other locations to hang around though. Japan actually has amazing public spaces. This includes Tokyo. There are giant parks to sit around and various other squares and plazas to hang out at. It is just that busy businesses might not have the space to just let people hang out. I think this means that just as in any city, just be aware where the public spaces are and take your food and friends there. Or find a less busy coffee shop, though businesses might not always want people just loitering around.
Please never stop making these video.
10:00 This seems a good suggestion. Imagine a place where instead of a shop it was a resting area with tables where people can eat what they bought. This would decrease the problem of "not knowing what the shops have to offer", customers could see what other customers are buying and share recommendations.
edit: oh, by the way, what are shopping streets like were I'm from? Hum... I think here in Brazil we have two types. One is called "Calçadão", that it's bunch of streets close to the traffic with shops only. It's not as organized was these shotengai looks but it works. On Calçadão there may be big chain stores but most are small stores with all it's attractions, and because the streets are narrower and cozier and there aren't nearly as many as like shotengai those places tend to be very, very crowded. Maybe because of this the inverse is happening, the Calçadão that I know and frequent is becoming to crowded to the point you could call it hellish, hard to shop there.
The other type is "Marcadão". It's usually a covered area with stores, usually more traditional and handmade stores. It's common for these Mercadão to concentrate shops selling products from other regions of the country, most of them from the North and Northeast.
My wife and I was fortunate to visit Japan before the pandemic. Grew up in NYC, visited Europe, and now living in the Midwest of the U.S. Japan is still my favorite.
These sort of small shopping street is just so comforting to see!
I really do like shotengai and arcades. They have such a unique feeling to them and sometimes a little magical.
In my area, we do have a couple of streets that have a mix of chain stores and smaller local stores, but nowhere near the same feeling.
the type of shops that will be able to survive was that izakaya you showed because of their dynamic nature of dishes with respect to the season plus they feel comfartable.
As time is changing shotengai need to adapt to their audience/consumers.
I hope they keep existing as they are a part of history
Here in the uk, we have a similar concept called High Streets, which are streets dominated by or exclusively shops. In the UK, unless it is located in a speed zone (which is an area of a town or city that is set to 1 specific speed limit. In most cases this is 20 or 30 MPH (AKA 32 or 48 km/h). Examples of large High Streets near (but not close to) me would be Birtley Highstreet (Located along Durham Road in Birtley Town Centre) Chester-le-street Market Place (in County Durham) and Newcastle Northumberland Street/Grey Street/Market Street (In newcastle city centre) Usually the biggest high streets are in cities, with exception of super large towns like birtley or civil parishes that cover a largely populated area like chester-le-street. Most towns with have a smaller High Street with say like 5 businesses and a Aldi and/or Lidl. Wrekenton Highstreet is an example of a smaller high street. Gateshead High Street & Trinity Square is another.
I'd like to experience them some day!
I haven’t watched this channel in years. I remember her being camera shy. It’s nice to see Ako comfortable on-camera, smiling and enjoying herself.
A fascinating story, because I live in a small city in the western US, near a shopping street like this, although very American in its operation. When I was young, this street had many small businesses patronized by locals, mostly white-owned. Since I have grown up, most of the businesses have been taken over by Southeast Asian immigrants, usually operating their own style of business. They have brought their own cultures, including New Years celebrations, and they are responsible and progressive business owners. There is a large mall and chain stores nearby, but they persist, and have dealt with the growing community successfully.
Arigatogozaimashita Greg-san for the video. Excellent content! 👍P.s.Thanks to Ako-san as well for her contribution.
I live in Osaka and shoutengai are probably my favorite part of living in here. I've been known to walk a few kilometers out of the way to visit a new-to-me one. Sometimes I'm pleasantly surprised like the Komagawa Nakano shoutengai, which became our main produce shopping spot, and sometimes I'm sad and disappointed like the Hirano shoutengai, where most stores have been closed for around 20 years. Some are great people watching places like the longest in Japan, Tenjinbashisuji and others are modern malls like Shinsaibashisuji.
If you want to get the pulse of every day life in Japan, visit and shop the shoutengai. The owners are always willing to help and Osakans being much friendlier than Tokyoites, will go out of their way to chat you up and try to make you laugh.
14:01 beautiful mural and a great idea, more boring grey shutters should be painted!
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. If you're going to have your shutters closed, it'd be nice to have something on them that'll help brighten up the place.
I don't know why but whenever I see Japanese street or sky it facinates me..
Shotengai would definitely take off here in the states as many of our malls are being converted into being less shopping mall and more shopping street (my local mall has a tech fix place, cafes, and even a dentist office and another had one of it’s anchor spaces converted into a school). In fact the only difference between American shopping streets and Japanese shopping streets is that American shopping streets include places to eat/rest and public toilets.
Great video. Also, the tea expert was so right. Your sister in law has an truly amazing and warming smile.
Places like these are the flames keeping the sense of community warm and alive. We have similar streets where I'm from but more about hustle and bustle.
Thank you Greg for showing us the Shotengai.
Wow wish I had this here! So interesting!
Shotengai might be something we could try with a little more effort here in North America. It could be a way to revitalize downtown areas.
A thoroughly enjoyable look at old and traditional Japan. Good interviews and excellent content, not to mention the contributions of Ako who seemed to be enjoying herself 🎉. Good work, Greg!
Amazing video as usual.
I think these shotengais offer a unique experience where every shop has its own signature. I hope that all of these shotengais will continue on in the future.
The little life scenes at the end were exquisite
Another thing I want to go to Japan for! I love the atmosphere of Shotengai whenever they're shown in videos, movies, anime, etc.
Thank you so much for this video!
This exactly why I try to shop at independently owned shops! We call them Mom and Pop stores here in Hawai’i !
They have character and take the time chat with Customers when time permits. It gives a Human Touch compared to chain businesses which is all about the bottom line! Our world is becoming robotic with the addition of self checkout and I refuse to use it!
SHOP MOM AND POP!
the video felt so fun to watch, the fact u interviewed them all added so much, knowing what their opinions are and more!
ty for making this video
love the quality of this video, no click-bait, no annoying music, well-edited and well-researched, thanks Greg
I loooooved walking along and buying random foods in the Shotengai when I was in Japan in 2017. I wish Japan would fully open again soon to tourist.
I think its fully opened now!
@@nanamiharuka3269 right in time for inflation
Funnily, I've seen a couple of other vids on Jujo in the last couple of weeks--probably a result of observation bias--but yours, Greg, is the deepest and most informative. Thanks again for your great work!
My wife and sister-in-law contacted a few shotengai and we were able to get an interview with them, which is a big reason why we went there. It was a great experience. But there are so many shotengai that it is surprising that you saw a couple other vids in the past couple of weeks.
This is kind of how bazareks look like in Poland, on a much smaller scale and with less variety of shops but it's pretty close. They are often combinad with farmer's markets. It's usually fruit and veg stores (either run by farmers themselves or imported), small grocery stores (sometimes with imported foods, usually from Germany or Ukraine), butchers, clothes stores (often cheap clothes but it CAN be niche chain shops as well), cafes, bakeries, patisseries, toy stores, healthy food stores, medicine shops etc. Pretty much anything can be bought there.
Ah, interesting!
Oh yes, trying your first jeans on, standing on a piece of cardbord, hidden from the rest of shoppers by a blanket of curtain - unforgetable.
we have a lot of shops that have closed on our shopping street, but I love the atmosphere these places have. We still have a traditional 雁木通り, maybe the oldest or longest in Japan. That could be an interesting video, too 😊
Shotengai looks so cool.I wish I had places like these in the States and it could help benefit small businesses even more.
Thanks for showing these and explaining everything about them, it’s one of the reasons why we wanna move
I love love love shotengais in Japan! Every time I visit a new city in Japan, I visit the local shotengai!
Informative and educational even for Japanese.
Each private shop in shotengai has a unique taste and vibes.
Thank you for sharing. 👍👍🌸🌸
I finally have time for watch whether I want and I really enjoy and appreciate your videos ♡. Thank me so much ✨
I loved this video. I felt nostalgia for the UK high streets of old before every street became the same with chain stores which are also now failing.
I love your content and channel. Keep up the great work. Much love from NYC!
That was a great vlog for many reasons, thanks.
Hey, you must have been in my neighborhood, Greg! I recognized the 東十条銀座商店街 which I pass through every weekday, in the video.
And as always: great work, great video!
Every video of yours is a full on documentary, it's just so impressive. Well done.
This was very interesting! Thank you for creating this video. 🙏
Wow. Shotengai sound (and look) fabulous. I wish we had them in the Midwest. Shopping Streets don't exist here. Today I got up at 7:45AM to catch the bus downtown. I got off the bus at the last stop and walked 5 blocks for coffee and breakfast. Then I walked 8 blocks back the other direction past where I got off the 1st bus and caught bus #2 to go to the 2nd biggest chain store in town, which is 30 minutes away on that bus. Done there, I caught bus #3 to cheap chain store and cheaper chain store, then caught the return trip of bus #3 back to where I got off bus #1. I then walked 5 blocks to catch bus #4 to the 2nd outlet of the cheapest chain store and went for lunch at the fried chicken place across the busy highway from that store. Shopping done for the day, I caught bus #4 again so I could make the connection to bus #5 and head home. I could have caught the return trip of bus #4, but that route is really bumpy and winding and it makes me sick. I wish I did not go on that bus before lunch, but after lunch would have been worse. At the last stop back downtown for the #5 bus, I exited bus #5 expecting to catch the return trip of bus #1 home, as it's supposed to go 5 minutes after the time bus #5 dropped me off. But it didn't go, so I waited 30 minutes in the 95 degrees Fahrenheit blazing sun, sweating, getting hotter by the minute, and blinded because it was so bright. I felt half dead by the time bus #1 showed up to go home at 5:41PM. So, in all, I went to 5 stores and 2 eating places, and it took me 10 hours, about half of which was actually on the buses. And there was a bus between bus #2 and bus #3 which I didn't count because it's just a route to connect between bus #2 and bus #3 because there's more than 3 miles between the transfer points and it's too far to walk.
The culture and community of shotengai are especially enjoyable at holiday/matsuri times.
I LOVE this protecting of small shops and businesses!
Tiptop video as usual Greg. Thanks for sharing.
As always, you have done a very thorough job of explaining things. Thank you.
If those shuttered shotengai spots can be converted to rest stop areas with seats n vending machines, this could be an income stream without active participation, especially when it’s a busy shotengai without areas to sit and rest.
You made my day. I’m obsessed with shotengais 😂
Awesome video, thank you
fantastic. thanks greg!
I really enjoyed seeing and listening to the owners of these street level independent stores. It will be testing for those associations to find ways to attract customers. I hope there will be positive outcome for the owner-occupiers.
I wonder if you could find an owner that would be willing to show how one would build a new home inside the Shotengai itself.
Also your sister-in-law was thoroughly enjoying herself, well done.
VERY enjoyable, and informative video! I’ve been a subscriber for about three years. This is one of my favorite videos of yours. Keep up the great work. Thank you.
Thanks!
This was a great video; thank you!
This is probably your best video yet. I love everything about this. The topic, the picture it paints, the experience, the shots, the interviews and the relevant information and history sprinkled along the vid. Masterful work.
Thanks for the wonderful vid
Can’t wait to visit Japan and explore !
Thanks for the guidance X
I’ve always been fascinated with shotengai and I’m so glad to learn about them more! Thank you this is so interesting!
very informative, thank you for sharing.
Great video as always. Love the idea of shotengai and am so tired of our sprawl of big box chain stores and parking lots here in the states.
Wandering around shotengais has always been my favorite activity whenever I visit Japan. There are so many delicious foods and random stuffs that I can find when I visit these mom-and-pop shops. While the shop owners might not be able to speak English, I find them very friendly and proud of their products. The experience is very wholesome, unlike visiting large shopping malls or chain stores.
Sad to know that these shotengais might not exist in the future :(
5:40 😂 She definitely knows something we don’t lol!
Shame to see so many shotengai going under in favor of generic, chain stores. As someone living in Canada where everything looks the same in the suburb (in Ontario), I prefer these types of streets much more the separated houses and malls we have due to zoning. They build a local community and these types of stores always have products you can't get elsewhere.
Beautiful work - always a pleasure to watch !
This episode is very fun and warm. Thanks!
Reminds me of Tamako Market!!
I would be stopping to check out everything 😍! The culture, the people, the language (the collective history!) just all create such a unique experience.
Great video! I enjoyed it thoroughly 😌
It makes sense that the owners would live above their shops. It is totally convenient for them to do so.
Here in Australia shopping streets seem to co exist with malls OK. The road tends to be wider then in Japan and more cars mean less closed streets but not everything happens at a mall.
The demographic angle and land planning aspects added to this I found very interesting. I almost didn't watch it. ALL of Greg's vids are interesting, I will keep this in mind. 😁
An especially enjoyable episode! It reminded me of actually being in Japan, a country really quite unlike any other I have visited.
Reminds me of Pike Place Market and I love them. Shotengai are awesome.
I really love your videos. Highly informative and makes me love Japan more and more.✌
Great video, Japan is such a unique & amazing country. The food alone is worth going and a ticket to a Perfume concert FTW!
Excellent documentary video yet again! Thank you!