Love you guys! I'm a house painter and spend hours upon hours listening to history podcasts and learning foreign languages and your pod is at the top of the heap!
Listening from Germany, looking out of my kitchen window at the Buchenwald concentration camp, only 8 km away! What an awful time in history. Absolutely brilliant historians these two men.
Stop living with shame and guilt. You've nothing to atone for from those days. Nothing your grandparents are accused of is anything novel, the British and Americans had done similar things all over the world to different people. Reject the programming your enemies have given you.
@@DanSam48....the Holocaust was quite unique. There have been many genocides of varying degrees, notably what the Ottomans did to the Armenians, but the Holocaust and now the Jihadist want to kill every single Jew and its is written into their ideologies, hence the 'quite unique'. It's not those today need to feel guilty of, but the past should be a teacher for today and it's clear that those marching the street today are ignorant of the history.
"Latently genocidal" Dominic nails it right there. I dearly hope that these terrificaly researched and important videos get as wide an audience as possible.
What a harrowing series. It wasn't easy to listen to. But thank you for telling it. Please keep telling stories that are hard to listen to because we need to hear them, even if they make us feel uncomfortable. You are doing great work 👏
I saw an interesting take that Goering disapproved of Kristallnacht as a waste of valuable artifacts that he intended to pilfer. Such a humanitarian..... The whole ratcheting of persecution by the Nazis epitomizes "boiling the frog". The spillover to any other minorities or dissenters was very chilling. By the time they realized the state they were entrapped into, it was too late. When the genocide started in earnest, im sure the rarionale for the Nazis was: "We warned you to leave." Great series, really fills in the narrative.
First of all, I want to commend both of you gentlemen for an incredible series. I knew some of what led to Hitler doing what he did, but the depth you went into boggles my mind as to how this could have happened. I wasn't going to mention this, but when I remember the post that so-called "actress" Gina Carano made about Republicans and being a Republican being tantamount to being a Jew during World War II just makes me so angry. She posted a photo of a Jewish woman who'd been stripped to her bra, underwear and garters being chased by a bunch of young German kids as her "proof" of "history repeating itself." She clearly has absolutely no idea or compassion about what was done to the Jews at this point. The chronic infection of dehumanization that was evident in the German mindset, and their ability to just sweep this matter under the proverbial carpet just makes my heart ache. That Miss Carano seems to think there is a parallel is just so astounding. I've posted how I detest Miss Carano for her words to various social media outlets to show how malignant her thinking is. The next time I'll just post a link to this episode and tell whoever to just come here and watch, then come back to me and justify defending Miss Carano. You gentlemen need to do Stalin now.
So much respect for your work, beautifully delivered. Takes me back to my undergraduate days, adding details and individual histories to what I learned back then.
If people doing.... ANY!!! degree don't listen to this channel. Then they are doing themselves a massive disservice. The way the boys present arguments are the keys to any akedemic paper! I'm bloody 43 now but finally I understand how I'm ment to form ideas arguments and structure essay!!! Thankyou and kind regards from New Zealand 🇳🇿 😊
'Kristall Nacht', to the Jews to whom it was directed, must have been absolutely terrifying. Can you imagine having an assault and invasion on your home and trying to summon help from the Police only to find there was no one there to help you? That is why during the recent riots there was a clip, I think in the North East, where some louts are walking down a street of terrace houses, in an Asian area, breaking the front living room windows of the houses. That must have been terrifying.
This is what Trudeau is doing to Albertans, that is, his own version of Crystal Night. All that is required for people to do evil is for good people to refuse to oppose the perpetrator.
@@JuneAdams-li9sy Get lost, June. Are Albertans having their businesses, homes, hospitals, schools and places of worship ransacked, demolished and burned down enmasse? Has Trudeau had 91 Albertans murdered? Has Trudeau had tens of thousands of Albertan men arrested and dragged off to concentration camps? What, no? He hasn't? Then keep your mouth shut about something you don't understand.
@@JuneAdams-li9syOn a long list of contenders, you’ve managed to say to stupidest thing I’ve seen on UA-cam today. Congratulations. Your platinum cock award is in the mail. We’ll do our best to have it match the one on your forehead.
The many Jewish shopkeepers whose premises were ransacked on the night of broken glass - how had they kept open through five and a half years of boycott, harassment, etc? Only other Jews would have been "freely" shopping with them, one might think, but the diminished Jewish minority would never have offered enough custom to keep their shops running. Were there enough "Aryans" brave/foolish enough to defiantly cross their thresholds in support of their Jewish neighbors and keeping them afloat? It seems likely, but I've never seen it suggested.
@3:00 Was the Yorkshire Post not making reference to the dissolution of the monasteries in England where the state grabs the riches of a religious group from outside the ruling elite, in this case Catholics.
Being a person who would not take the NRMA I was forced to sign contracts treated like a lepper, so can it all happen again? Definitely the government were even talking about incarceration. In no way is this on the same level as the Jewish people of Germany buy the beauracrats were eagerly loving their new powers.
17:35 speaking as a Canadian, that makes no sense as a premise. They tried to come here, and we turned them away. Sent them back to their deaths. Fucking shameful.
One of the really extraordinary things about the past year or so is that when prominent ministers in the UK government led by Rishi Sunak started ratcheting up the rhetoric about the country being invaded by migrants, echoed faithfully by wide sections of the right-wing media, there was a tweet by Gary Lineker, ex-footballer and now sports presenter with the BBC. He made a parallel between the hate-fuelled speech directed towards foreigners and the plans recently announced to have illegal migrants deported to Rwanda, and what was happening in Germany in the 1930s. Outrage followed from wide sections of the press and all those who love to hate the BBC. And what do we learn from this excellent podcast? That the Nazis were talking to the authorities in Madagascar with a view to shipping off vast numbers of unwanted Jews to a place well outside Europe. It would be wrong to make a direct parallel between British Tories in government and the Nazis, but the sentiments and the ideology underpinning those sentiments are virtually the same.
Thank you for your great work. I very much enjoy all your videos. However, I think your characterisation of Herschel was lacking. I believe that his own personal anger due to lack of a life caused him to do what he did. He was an illegal in France and therefore had no right to work. His uncle was poor and could barely support him. He had to do a menial job working for his uncle on the sly. Coupled with his age and what was happening to his family and Jews in general, I think this would have caused a kind of death wish in which he never properly considered the consequences of his actions. I feel very sorry for him.
Have you ever thought of the hypocrisy of the people who say we should not generalize when talking about the atrocities committed by the Nazis in world War2, that “there were some nice and decent people among the Germans”, and no doubt there were? And therefor it is wrong to generalise? However amongst those millions of people who went along with Hitler, giving him the Nazi salute, when he was ranting about how evil the Jews were, even gave thought about “generalisation” that there might be nice and decent people amongst the Jewish people of the world? If they did they certainly were not very visible, to offer that little bit of understanding, for even the innocent children? How lucky they were that thinking people did win the war, or generalising would have continued to be a normal way of thinking, for the “MASTER RACE”…… A conclusion, of a conclusion….lest we forget….or remember
It doesn’t mean the over dramatic “night of broken glass” It simply means “glass night” And it happened because a French dew murdered a member of the German Embassy. Israel’s response to Oct 11 is far worse.
I'm so sick of hearing about all of this. It's just so nauseating. What's the point in learning about the past if we just allow history to repeat itself? Out of all the modern day nations, the one that resembles 1930-1949 Germany is... You guessed it, Israel.
Bit disappointed. I put up a post giving a measure of support for Sueyourself - of course Israel isn't as bad as the Nazis but even the IJC says there is plausible evidence of genocide in Gaza happening as we speak- but for some reason it's been deleted. Hope my favourite podcasters weren't responsible.
What about The Weimar Republic? Not saying the nazi were right. But from what I understand it was pretty awful. Things I can not mention here. Berlin was a cesspool. It makes SF, Chicago, NY, and DC look like Sunday school.
It boggles my mind how this isn't the biggest shortish history pod on UA-cam
It’s the biggest history podcast, on Apple, in the world and has only recently started being uploaded to UA-cam.
They've only recently started making videos to go with their podcast
I believe it is?
Love you guys! I'm a house painter and spend hours upon hours listening to history podcasts and learning foreign languages and your pod is at the top of the heap!
Painter? You're not Austrian are you? 😟
Haha same. I play their podcasts for hours while I’m painting and decorating.
Thank you for keeping this truth alive
Listening from Germany, looking out of my kitchen window at the Buchenwald concentration camp, only 8 km away! What an awful time in history. Absolutely brilliant historians these two men.
I agree - from Berlin.
Stop living with shame and guilt. You've nothing to atone for from those days. Nothing your grandparents are accused of is anything novel, the British and Americans had done similar things all over the world to different people. Reject the programming your enemies have given you.
Did they make your grandparents walkthrough the camp so they could show them what their government did?
@@DanSam48....the Holocaust was quite unique. There have been many genocides of varying degrees, notably what the Ottomans did to the Armenians, but the Holocaust and now the Jihadist want to kill every single Jew and its is written into their ideologies, hence the 'quite unique'.
It's not those today need to feel guilty of, but the past should be a teacher for today and it's clear that those marching the street today are ignorant of the history.
@@DanSam48the two commenters just said it was a terrible time in history. They didn’t express any guilt.
"Latently genocidal" Dominic nails it right there. I dearly hope that these terrificaly researched and important videos get as wide an audience as possible.
Hooray! I'm enjoying this mini-series... Always surprised by how little love these two get on UA-cam.
How can you “enjoy” a massacre of innocent people?
@@decimustv4257it's not a massacre, it's a podcast. Please do grow up.
Amazing pod. Can't stop listening.
That was a brilliant series. So thoughtfully and carefully presented. Many thanks.
What a harrowing series. It wasn't easy to listen to. But thank you for telling it. Please keep telling stories that are hard to listen to because we need to hear them, even if they make us feel uncomfortable. You are doing great work 👏
I saw an interesting take that Goering disapproved of Kristallnacht as a waste of valuable artifacts that he intended to pilfer. Such a humanitarian.....
The whole ratcheting of persecution by the Nazis epitomizes "boiling the frog". The spillover to any other minorities or dissenters was very chilling. By the time they realized the state they were entrapped into, it was too late. When the genocide started in earnest, im sure the rarionale for the Nazis was: "We warned you to leave."
Great series, really fills in the narrative.
Excellent series, it's really a shame that most of what the two of you have discussed isn't more widely known.
First of all, I want to commend both of you gentlemen for an incredible series. I knew some of what led to Hitler doing what he did, but the depth you went into boggles my mind as to how this could have happened. I wasn't going to mention this, but when I remember the post that so-called "actress" Gina Carano made about Republicans and being a Republican being tantamount to being a Jew during World War II just makes me so angry. She posted a photo of a Jewish woman who'd been stripped to her bra, underwear and garters being chased by a bunch of young German kids as her "proof" of "history repeating itself." She clearly has absolutely no idea or compassion about what was done to the Jews at this point. The chronic infection of dehumanization that was evident in the German mindset, and their ability to just sweep this matter under the proverbial carpet just makes my heart ache. That Miss Carano seems to think there is a parallel is just so astounding. I've posted how I detest Miss Carano for her words to various social media outlets to show how malignant her thinking is. The next time I'll just post a link to this episode and tell whoever to just come here and watch, then come back to me and justify defending Miss Carano.
You gentlemen need to do Stalin now.
So interesting, great dispersal of all the details. Appreciate your work.
Wow what an incredible series of podcasts to have stumbled across. Thank you so much.
So much respect for your work, beautifully delivered. Takes me back to my undergraduate days, adding details and individual histories to what I learned back then.
New member here, what an incredible show. Thankful i have found it. Will support the channel fiscally shortly- Australia
Amazing series.
If people doing.... ANY!!! degree don't listen to this channel. Then they are doing themselves a massive disservice. The way the boys present arguments are the keys to any akedemic paper! I'm bloody 43 now but finally I understand how I'm ment to form ideas arguments and structure essay!!! Thankyou and kind regards from New Zealand 🇳🇿 😊
'Kristall Nacht', to the Jews to whom it was directed, must have been absolutely terrifying. Can you imagine having an assault and invasion on your home and trying to summon help from the Police only to find there was no one there to help you? That is why during the recent riots there was a clip, I think in the North East, where some louts are walking down a street of terrace houses, in an Asian area, breaking the front living room windows of the houses. That must have been terrifying.
This is what Trudeau is doing to Albertans, that is, his own version of Crystal Night. All that is required for people to do evil is for good people to refuse to oppose the perpetrator.
@@JuneAdams-li9sy Get lost, June. Are Albertans having their businesses, homes, hospitals, schools and places of worship ransacked, demolished and burned down enmasse? Has Trudeau had 91 Albertans murdered? Has Trudeau had tens of thousands of Albertan men arrested and dragged off to concentration camps? What, no? He hasn't? Then keep your mouth shut about something you don't understand.
@@JuneAdams-li9syOn a long list of contenders, you’ve managed to say to stupidest thing I’ve seen on UA-cam today. Congratulations. Your platinum cock award is in the mail. We’ll do our best to have it match the one on your forehead.
Really great episode. Well done
Distressing listen and some disturbing parallels with current markers.
The many Jewish shopkeepers whose premises were ransacked on the night of broken glass - how had they kept open through five and a half years of boycott, harassment, etc? Only other Jews would have been "freely" shopping with them, one might think, but the diminished Jewish minority would never have offered enough custom to keep their shops running. Were there enough "Aryans" brave/foolish enough to defiantly cross their thresholds in support of their Jewish neighbors and keeping them afloat? It seems likely, but I've never seen it suggested.
Also hundreds of thousands of jews served in the wermacht in ww2. We've been told lies about ww2 so much hard to make sense of it
@@Puffball-ll1ly Lies, you say. And what lies might they be?
@@Hartley_Hare have you ever heard the saying the 1st casualty of war is the truth?
@@Puffball-ll1lyYes I have heard of that and no, it doesn't mean the Holocaust is a lie.
Brilliant. Subscribed.
The system generated subtitles are hilarious. "Mine camp", FGS 😂
Brilliant.
Great content, keep it up
11.25 "put every kind of pressure on to get them out" tax bills, bureaucracy etc and a generally hostile attitude - Windrush.
Thank you, it was interesting
Love listening to this while studying ❤
@3:00 Was the Yorkshire Post not making reference to the dissolution of the monasteries in England where the state grabs the riches of a religious group from outside the ruling elite, in this case Catholics.
Possibly, but I think the point Tom was alluding to was that that happened during the Renaissance, not the Middle Ages..
Oops, yes, that makes sense now!
Why does Dominic have so many copies of the same books behind him 😂 is that just GLORIOUS PROMOTION 😍?????
Could it be stage managed by people of a certain point of view ?
This is so god damn depressing
And to think, this is the cheery happy time compared to what came next
What else could it be?
@@KimMarsh-c4n arousing, I suppose
Do love this podcast but for some reason my comments keep disappearing.
Being a person who would not take the NRMA I was forced to sign contracts treated like a lepper, so can it all happen again?
Definitely the government were even talking about incarceration.
In no way is this on the same level as the Jewish people of Germany buy the beauracrats were eagerly loving their new powers.
17:35 speaking as a Canadian, that makes no sense as a premise. They tried to come here, and we turned them away. Sent them back to their deaths. Fucking shameful.
One of the really extraordinary things about the past year or so is that when prominent ministers in the UK government led by Rishi Sunak started ratcheting up the rhetoric about the country being invaded by migrants, echoed faithfully by wide sections of the right-wing media, there was a tweet by Gary Lineker, ex-footballer and now sports presenter with the BBC. He made a parallel between the hate-fuelled speech directed towards foreigners and the plans recently announced to have illegal migrants deported to Rwanda, and what was happening in Germany in the 1930s. Outrage followed from wide sections of the press and all those who love to hate the BBC. And what do we learn from this excellent podcast? That the Nazis were talking to the authorities in Madagascar with a view to shipping off vast numbers of unwanted Jews to a place well outside Europe. It would be wrong to make a direct parallel between British Tories in government and the Nazis, but the sentiments and the ideology underpinning those sentiments are virtually the same.
God, when it mentioned Catholics that they were talking about Northern Ireland....
Napoleon was the first European leader who treated the Jewish people with reapect
May a new Sviatoslav come forth.
Thank you for your great work. I very much enjoy all your videos. However, I think your characterisation of Herschel was lacking. I believe that his own personal anger due to lack of a life caused him to do what he did. He was an illegal in France and therefore had no right to work. His uncle was poor and could barely support him. He had to do a menial job working for his uncle on the sly. Coupled with his age and what was happening to his family and Jews in general, I think this would have caused a kind of death wish in which he never properly considered the consequences of his actions. I feel very sorry for him.
@34:00, bitte, is it more "horrifying" than Roman children despising Carthaginians?
Excellent series on the Nazis
Sounds eerily similar to Israeli action and doctrine, very sad and ironic
Well they were socialists .
Comments are all very similar……hmmmmm
Hareqwd will never Win, only Love
This was difficult to listen to.
History is repeating itself in Gaza! This time most of the leaders are complicit and take a huge part in it!!
Yes there was sexual violence.
🤣Oh, please!
Nope, it's reformation. Just like Christianity. It looks similar to the Dark Ages.
yess
WOWWWW ✌️ ✌️ 😊❤😂
lol
I just gotta say watching him read this my first thought was "this guy gets zero kitty"😂😂😂
Have you ever thought of the hypocrisy of the people who say we should not generalize when talking about the atrocities committed by the Nazis in world War2, that “there were some nice and decent people among the Germans”, and no doubt there were? And therefor it is wrong to generalise?
However amongst those millions of people who went along with Hitler, giving him the Nazi salute, when he was ranting about how evil the Jews were, even gave thought about “generalisation” that there might be nice and decent people amongst the Jewish people of the world?
If they did they certainly were not very visible, to offer that little bit of understanding, for even the innocent children?
How lucky they were that thinking people did win the war, or generalising would have continued to be a normal way of thinking, for the “MASTER RACE”……
A conclusion, of a conclusion….lest we forget….or remember
It doesn’t mean the over dramatic “night of broken glass” It simply means “glass night” And it happened because a French dew murdered a member of the German Embassy. Israel’s response to Oct 11 is far worse.
It happened because thugs wanted an excuse.
I'm so sick of hearing about all of this. It's just so nauseating.
What's the point in learning about the past if we just allow history to repeat itself?
Out of all the modern day nations, the one that resembles 1930-1949 Germany is... You guessed it, Israel.
Liar
@@titmus312she needs friends
The parents of the 10,000 children slaughtered by the Zionists might beg to differ with you, Titmus
heh...im starting to resent the mainstream media for brainwashing these idiots... 🐑
Bit disappointed. I put up a post giving a measure of support for Sueyourself - of course Israel isn't as bad as the Nazis but even the IJC says there is plausible evidence of genocide in Gaza happening as we speak- but for some reason it's been deleted. Hope my favourite podcasters weren't responsible.
What about The Weimar Republic? Not saying the nazi were right. But from what I understand it was pretty awful. Things I can not mention here. Berlin was a cesspool. It makes SF, Chicago, NY, and DC look like Sunday school.
You mean four of the most sought after cities in the entire US? What point are you making here?
'Not saying the Nazis were right' is the reddest of red flags.
First minster of scotland uses hateful rhetoric.