Mr p r sundar's videos are for free(No viewing changes), putting things in to awareness is not for monitizing, he is well aware of earning avenues far better than you pointed out.
@@sathi.manikantareddy9703 whats the use of knowing all this anyway? To trade like them and manage risk, one needs an upfront capital of atleast 10 CRORE
@@sathi.manikantareddy9703 moreover, if you have an upfront capital of 10 crore....what will 99.99% of people do ? Put in FD,MF,Gold,property etc . Even with modest return of 7%pa....that is monthly income of 5-6 LAKH !!!!!!!! SO TELL WILL U PUT IN STOCK MARKET AND GAMBLE IT?????
@@JohnDoe-vh7vc so what should we do???is option staragies & adjustment is waste....then is it enough to follow technicals & naked postions as per technicals.... As we have low capital
The 30 odd people who must have disliked the video must be brokers...Saying that the dialogue computer does not make mistakes in giving us the broker's money was a savage one! Long live Sundar Sir 😁
Why don't nse directly give chance to trade through nse Or BSE without brokers? At least allow if a person have more than 10L and this will help lot of people
This unethical approach of the brokers, clearly says that , sir , it is high time you start a brokerage house. You said once that you are going to start one. I am eager to know the progress on that.
Hi, is there any service available from a firm for Indian markets, to whom you pay the capital, and they make the investment. And if yes, how much they charge? And what has been your experience? Is it profitable? Please share. Thanks.
I'm from Canada, I used to take loans from banks for survival but after trading with expert ms elizabeth walker. I've been on amazing returns to help myself out.
.Surprised seeing "elizabeth services" here honestly🥺... she's played a vital role to I and my family honestly. She helped me recover my loss ever since my wife died. With my recent investment months ago I was able to pay off my son's lingering tuition fee debt. Now my son goes to a better college
Tha... Thalaivan vechi senjittaan. Zebu calls me to open account. Perae sari illainnu avoid pannittaen. This calls for strict SEBI regulation in Brokerages. HNIs and people with influence like PR Sundar sir can push for more regulations.
Sir, why you didn't complained about all these things? You are 1 of the best trader, sebi must listen to you and ultimately it will work in favour of retail investors/ traders also.
*in my 8 months of journey... i lost 2 lakh rupees.... . out of these 2 lakh.... i paid 1.1 lakh as charges...*.. . though I'm using zerodha... .. it's day light robbery by government,brokers,and sebi...
mind opening video by the way . most of the youtube channels that i know never made a video on this topic . many beginners & also seasoned traders will pay attention now . hope so we do . Dirt is in details . one just has to carefully read it and dig it out
Zerodha is transparent. Using it for 1.5 years....... You should maintain a manual ledger in excel .... Then you can understand how much you have been charged .... I think you are doing overtrading.... And your win loss ratio and risk reward ratio is not good...
Hello sir, how to calculate the overall charges with using total amount traded for the day ourselves just to cross check everyday 🙏🙏🙏 Sir u have to raise a query/complain to Sebi and urge to make a proper transperant system where the retail traders can calculate the brokerage on daily basis. We get daily mails and specified files regarding charges but I have seen most of the time the charged amout is different from what I get in mail.
Sir zebu is ur sons company how can u show all this being a father. Sir I can say with full confident if u open a brokerage in ur name 90% retailers will join u
What is the reason for not allowing direct trading with traders in share market? I do think, Brokers they are making us more complications on every trading. If the CDSL is controlling our account, so that the brokers are not necessary to play with in the future trading. Atleast not necessary for domestic trading people
Thanks for the this awareness. Sir please also comment on the increased margin for open position despite no trade is taking place and last traded price remain same. In this way Zerodha is blocking lot of margin money with 50% being cash they must be making crores of profit in unfairway.
I am new comer to market I don't know how many type of charges are charging by broker's on trading tq 🙏🙏🙏 for your explanation of the charges levied by brokers on trading in stock market this video. This video is eye opener to me. Tq 🙏
Dear Sir, I am Beginner of Stock Market.I need Some Big Clarification. 1)net margin=Rs=8762/= But My Ledger(Open Bal= _1000.49 and Closing Bal= _51,304.00) GHVC 32%. Debit fund Rs=49024/Collateral stock value=Rs=63,476/=what about my stock growth?My Portfolio Value=Equit+MF=76,000?=Need your Help.
Sir, I seek your guidance...My broker auto squared off my Stock.August Futures..at 3 pm...though I had sufficient margin..I converted Delivery Position into Intraday in the morning...again I tried to convert from Intraday to Delivery ...the system did not allow. ..Immediately called the broker and informed about issue. I also sent a mail at about 2.15 pm...alerting the team about issue...they said it is converted and it will carried forward. But to my surprise, the position was squared off and I was put to loss....please guide the remedies available ...regards Kumara Swamy
This time you have taken the name of the broker as per your wording in the last video regarding the charges..Well said and you made us to alert on this.
Why SEBI,NSE,CDSL or NSDL don't want take action against them? They can bring strict regulatory rules about this issue but they will not do because they also corrupted and some benefits getting from this brokers.
Those who are with very low capital, even with Rs 1000, I can help them with bank nifty option clues. I will put spot price level to be long in call or put. For tomorrow buy call option if spot keep 36040. Buy put only if market moves down 36040. See how it goes.
Angel broking is one more cunning broker..They squared off my position after pledging of shares although there was enough margin available..with an excuse that MTF (margin trading fund) should be approved after every 7days.. Once the shares are pledged, why do we need to approve the pledged shares again and again...be careful guys, with Angel broking.. Don't pledge your shares, and if you do be ready for heavy charges for pledging and unpledging and then there are issues of your positions getting squared off
How many times a person can find faults in his ledger, then get a refund from broker? Its like we have to take law into our own hands. So many govt bodies are there like SEBI, CDSL, NSDL st stc. but no body responsible to check these frauds. If govt make another body to check this, then total charges paid to new body will be more then the brokers. So let the brokers loots us. Its more cheaper for us.
In my school life, my English teacher quote, " In India everybody is dishonest unless it is proved". Now viewing this video, it is still working.
Our law and system is like that. We need to adjust accordingly. Don't expect this to change in this generation.
Brokers: We'll charge you unreasonably.
P R Sunder: I'll make your malpractice public and recover it from youtube monetization. 😛
Mr p r sundar's videos are for free(No viewing changes), putting things in to awareness is not for monitizing, he is well aware of earning avenues far better than you pointed out.
Ye sahi tha guru🔥
In India only P R Sunder talking about Brokerage rest all talking about how make money but retailers lossing yet....☺️☺️👍👍
Watch Day Trader Telugu He was also Told about Charges
@@sathi.manikantareddy9703 whats the use of knowing all this anyway?
To trade like them and manage risk, one needs an upfront capital of atleast 10 CRORE
@@sathi.manikantareddy9703 moreover, if you have an upfront capital of 10 crore....what will 99.99% of people do ?
Put in FD,MF,Gold,property etc . Even with modest return of 7%pa....that is monthly income of 5-6 LAKH !!!!!!!!
SO TELL WILL U PUT IN STOCK MARKET AND GAMBLE IT?????
@@manikanta.6638 that is only for telugu people not for any other people 😭😭😭🙏
@@JohnDoe-vh7vc so what should we do???is option staragies & adjustment is waste....then is it enough to follow technicals & naked postions as per technicals.... As we have low capital
The 30 odd people who must have disliked the video must be brokers...Saying that the dialogue computer does not make mistakes in giving us the broker's money was a savage one! Long live Sundar Sir 😁
i laughed loudly on hearing that epic dialog
5 paisa is expert in charging hidden charges.
Fantastic word, There is no difference between cheating and business.
Also 5 paisa do that
@@bhardwaj525is 5 paisa have payout charge ??
@@selvakumar_sk No but despite that they have many as I mentioned in one of my comment ..
6lakh charges are not even close to the capital of 90% of your subscribers (individual).
hahha....6 lakh is his STAMP DUTY....lol
6 lakhs wrong charges under 1 head 😄
Why don't nse directly give chance to trade through nse Or BSE without brokers? At least allow
if a person have more than 10L and this will help lot of people
You can buy leased line from nse. I think with all infrastructure it will come to around 1cr. Then you have to manually do clearing and settling
“There is not much difference between Cheating and Business” - Sums it all up.
Zebu is probably going to charge you something for this now 😆
If the blame is based on facts which can be easily proven. They can't do anything.
SEBI should come up with some serious laws on brokers, something similar to what IRDA does on insurance companies.
yes....they should immediately CANCEL their broking license. then they will learn
BEBI get money from them.
This unethical approach of the brokers, clearly says that , sir , it is high time you start a brokerage house. You said once that you are going to start one. I am eager to know the progress on that.
Sir. I would like to suggest that start a brokerage firm 👍. We will support you 👍
i think zerodha is the most genuine broker out there
Upstox💥
@@midhunsanthosh9582 Zerodha 🔥
Obviously! Zerodha is the one & only broker in India as RCI management which means Ritualistic Continuous Improvement.
Agreed. Zerodha is the best, as of now.
Kotak has good transparency
Fantastic sentence
There is not much difference between cheating and business
Sir is great..such complex things put in such simple words
Thanks for sharing your bitter experience with the brokers. Eye openers for innocent , novice investors. SUCH BROKERS SHOULD BE PUNISHED SEVERELY.
Best video of all time sir . It’s good that you brought these scamsters to light .
Please list those brokers that charge hidden charges sir.
It is Zebu
@@aravintht5137 zebu means zherodha
@@askarsaidu3353 NO
stt and gst more than brokerage charges in zerodha 😂😅
Not just in zerodha, STT is applicable for all platforms. Stt is common across platforms and has to be paid by all traders/investors
@@ashwinsnmv I have said that more than brokerage I know it's must
@@sanjaythirumaran5078 you said in zerodha. In almost all broker stt will be more than brokerage. unless your broker charges enormous brokerage
@@vinaybhat7670 SAME 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I HATE THIS
Thank you Sir. I have never checked my ledger. Will start checking on daily basis. Thank you for this eye opener video.
Since you have capital, y can't you start your own brokerage firm? With fair charging system?
Hi, is there any service available from a firm for Indian markets, to whom you pay the capital, and they make the investment. And if yes, how much they charge? And what has been your experience? Is it profitable? Please share. Thanks.
I'm from Canada, I used to take loans from banks for survival but after trading with expert ms elizabeth walker. I've been on amazing returns to help myself out.
.Surprised seeing "elizabeth services" here honestly🥺... she's played a vital role to I and my family honestly. She helped me recover my loss ever since my wife died. With my recent investment months ago I was able to pay off my son's lingering tuition fee debt. Now my son goes to a better college
Nice one, I stake with ms _elizabeth@tradewithelizabethwalker_ on- telgm
So exciting to see others who made move. I'm currently on my 7th trade with her and my portfolio has increased.
Zebu 👍👍
Too much funny video 📹 sir ji 😀
very useful Thala. we must check daily contract note.
You r right i have been trading from 2017 my loss is around 5 lakh when i chek out of 5 lakh 1.87 lakh was my charges and brokerage
There is no difference between business and cheating now a days - well said, Mr Sundar. 😂
Tha... Thalaivan vechi senjittaan. Zebu calls me to open account. Perae sari illainnu avoid pannittaen. This calls for strict SEBI regulation in Brokerages. HNIs and people with influence like PR Sundar sir can push for more regulations.
There is SMS charges monthly Rs. 117.00 for me
That is why bank stocks are increasing nicely as they charge these many charges. Thank you for all these details sir and it is very helpful
Sir, why you didn't complained about all these things? You are 1 of the best trader, sebi must listen to you and ultimately it will work in favour of retail investors/ traders also.
Please make a video on how to read ledger and statements🙏🙏
Yes.... specially with different brokers...
Zerodha is No1 broker . Only issue is some time technical issues
honest person....
We need to have a transparent broker. It will be revolution.
*in my 8 months of journey...
i lost 2 lakh rupees....
.
out of these 2 lakh.... i paid 1.1 lakh as charges...*..
.
though I'm using zerodha...
..
it's day light robbery by government,brokers,and sebi...
Be careful you're indulged in over trading
So you have lost 2 lakh... Now how do you see your trading journey ahead
@@devendrapratapsingh4405 i turned out to be a option seller..
@@sae6969 great... So how much have you recovered your losses
@@sae6969 can an option buyer have successful trading life..
Very honest video by Sundar sir. Thank u sir.
Sir if you start your own brokerage firm, i will be your first client.....
Since you have larger subscriber base it is worth giving a shot....
Sir you are great 😂 this video sponsored by 5paisa (big fan) 🙌
All brokers are cheats except 5paisa because it is sponsor😅🤣
Pr sundar you are the Candle of my life in darkness 🕯️🕯️
Great sir u wear white shirt today... Looking very good
So starting a brokerage firm is profitable than Trading
If you new to trading, broker will eat your profits.
Setthanda zeu bue
Ini oru paya trade pannamatan
Acc open pannamatan
5paisa charges 0.06% per day to utilise pledging money. It is horrible. But other brokers are not charging such. Please tell me sir.
Sir why don't you start a brokerage company
Thank you sir for your valuable words of advice.
Super information thanks for sharing sir
What about 5 paisa?? Is it honest???
They don't even respond ,if we call them
Thank you sir.. Very true
Please open Brokerage company sir. We want to open account with the Brokerage firm from Mr. Sundar.
sponsored by 5paisa😂😂
All the charges list @7:55 looks like hotel/Restaurant menu.. But PR sir u r great 👍.. u absolutely nailed it 🙏🏼👍..
Great explain, cheating brocar to us
My broker Kotak securities is charging interest even on the 50% collateral against shares for providing margin to trade in F&O
Sir make a video on how to read and analyze ledger from different brokers sir.. It would be so helpful so that we don't get looted by brokers
We all must file PIL in supreme Court against such type of cheating.
mind opening video by the way . most of the youtube channels that i know never made a video on this topic . many beginners & also seasoned traders will pay attention now . hope so we do .
Dirt is in details . one just has to carefully read it and dig it out
Is Zerodha a good broker? Because in just 3 months they have charged me around 50k brokerage 🤕
I also use zerodha. I spent around 45K total charges including stt,gst etc. How much you made by paying 50K?
Zerodha is transparent. Using it for 1.5 years....... You should maintain a manual ledger in excel .... Then you can understand how much you have been charged .... I think you are doing overtrading.... And your win loss ratio and risk reward ratio is not good...
Zerodha also charge payout fees
@@satyamagrahari2968 no payout fees in zerodha, how much you got charged?
@@satyamagrahari2968 Don't spread false info.... There is no such charge....
I was asked to open in both brokers. I avoided those
Thanks for the update
Hello sir, how to calculate the overall charges with using total amount traded for the day ourselves just to cross check everyday
🙏🙏🙏
Sir u have to raise a query/complain to Sebi and urge to make a proper transperant system where the retail traders can calculate the brokerage on daily basis.
We get daily mails and specified files regarding charges but I have seen most of the time the charged amout is different from what I get in mail.
Great Sir 🙏
I earned 12k profit and paid 9K brokerage charges
....overall only 3K profit.....its3%
Sir zebu is ur sons company how can u show all this being a father. Sir I can say with full confident if u open a brokerage in ur name 90% retailers will join u
What is the reason for not allowing direct trading with traders in share market? I do think, Brokers they are making us more complications on every trading. If the CDSL is controlling our account, so that the brokers are not necessary to play with in the future trading. Atleast not necessary for domestic trading people
Thank you PR Sundar
Indeed very powerfull video....
Thanks for the this awareness. Sir please also comment on the increased margin for open position despite no trade is taking place and last traded price remain same. In this way Zerodha is blocking lot of margin money with 50% being cash they must be making crores of profit in unfairway.
I am new comer to market I don't know how many type of charges are charging by broker's on trading tq 🙏🙏🙏 for your explanation of the charges levied by brokers on trading in stock market this video. This video is eye opener to me. Tq 🙏
Sir i will suggest to start one firm from your side we will definitely support you
Thanks for knowledge sharing
Promoting 5paisa . Common Pr sir
Yes .. I face the same... and i SUPPORT 1000% when you say...90% of the brokers are dishonest in India....
Zerodha??
Sir, Angle broking charged Rs.12000.00 from me as margin short fall penalty .....I always maintain the margin money in my demat account
Does Zerodha do any of these ??
Nice video sir thank you 🙏🏻
Zerodha-best
No negative news yet
No sponsors for this video. Makes sense
Thank you for this video , need to keep aside an hour every weekend to go through the week's Contract Notes
no point in looking at contracts; make sure every Sat/Sun; you go through your ledger and take a screenshot of your funds at the end of every day;.
Sir, why can't you become as a broker... ? That will help us a lot... We will shift to your brokerage firm...
Well said sir, day by day lot of new gen brokers are emerging and what is the reason behind, if check one by one charges, will come to know.
Dear Sir, I am Beginner of Stock Market.I need Some Big Clarification.
1)net margin=Rs=8762/= But My Ledger(Open Bal= _1000.49 and Closing Bal= _51,304.00) GHVC 32%. Debit fund Rs=49024/Collateral stock value=Rs=63,476/=what about my stock growth?My Portfolio Value=Equit+MF=76,000?=Need your Help.
Thanks Sir.
Sir which of these hidden charges are not applicable to a person buying and selling shares on delivery basis, not doing f&o?
People like u should talk about it in media
,
Plz try to remove this kind of non sense from business
Much appreciated for enlightening us on such nefarious activites of Brokers and exposing Zebu
Sir, I seek your guidance...My broker auto squared off my Stock.August Futures..at 3 pm...though I had sufficient margin..I converted Delivery Position into Intraday in the morning...again I tried to convert from Intraday to Delivery ...the system did not allow. ..Immediately called the broker and informed about issue. I also sent a mail at about 2.15 pm...alerting the team about issue...they said it is converted and it will carried forward. But to my surprise, the position was squared off and I was put to loss....please guide the remedies available ...regards Kumara Swamy
Why do you work with shitty brokers like Zebu?
Thank you very much sir 🙏💐
Computers will make mistakes only for traders but they work fine for brokerage accounts ,😂
This time you have taken the name of the broker as per your wording in the last video regarding the charges..Well said and you made us to alert on this.
100% viewers like required for this video..!
How about Zerodha?
Why SEBI,NSE,CDSL or NSDL don't want take action against them? They can bring strict regulatory rules about this issue but they will not do because they also corrupted and some benefits getting from this brokers.
super sir very usefull video
Those who are with very low capital, even with Rs 1000, I can help them with bank nifty option clues. I will put spot price level to be long in call or put. For tomorrow buy call option if spot keep 36040. Buy put only if market moves down 36040. See how it goes.
Angel broking is one more cunning broker..They squared off my position after pledging of shares although there was enough margin available..with an excuse that MTF (margin trading fund) should be approved after every 7days.. Once the shares are pledged, why do we need to approve the pledged shares again and again...be careful guys, with Angel broking.. Don't pledge your shares, and if you do be ready for heavy charges for pledging and unpledging and then there are issues of your positions getting squared off
How many times a person can find faults in his ledger, then get a refund from broker?
Its like we have to take law into our own hands.
So many govt bodies are there like SEBI, CDSL, NSDL st stc.
but no body responsible to check these frauds.
If govt make another body to check this, then total charges paid to new body will be more then the brokers.
So let the brokers loots us. Its more cheaper for us.
Sir ....who is the broker who took payout... Bcoz this is unfair ..same happened with me also... With me and my mother's account