Star Wars: The Clone Wars Does Not Hold Up (Part 1)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 тра 2024
- I've been working on this video literally the entire year so it'd better do well!!!
Part 2: • Star Wars: The Clone W...
George Lucas on balance in the Force: • George Lucas Explains ...
Relevant channels:
The SEA: / @theseaempire
The Jolly Chap: / @thejollychap
Southpaw: / @southpawlp
TK-9851: / @tk-9851
Actually Andrew: / @actuallyandrewyt
Sheev Shuts His Mouth: @sheevshutshismouth4516
The Jedi Archivist: @thejediarchivist2720
Logan Kelley channel: @logankelley99
Patreon: patreon.com/user?u=79059960&u...
Twitter: / sheevtalks
Instagram: / sheevtalks
Sheev Talks Discord Server: / discord
00:00 - Introduction
12:10 - Anakin
1:04:03 - Ahsoka
1:44:46 - Obi-Wan
2:01:09 - Outro - Фільми й анімація
Guys it's imperative to me that you stop missing the point of the slavery argument.
You got it
What's being missed exactly? I figured the point was that Anakin's history as a slave should inform his character a little more than not at all, which doesn't seem all that contentious to me. All it amounts to in the prequels is effectively the need for a pod race scene to get him off Tatooine, and obviously TCW did nothing but tease the thought of doing something with that part of his life.
I do have a bit of a bone to pick with the idea that slavery should necessarily be portrayed as 24/7 suffering all day, every day. The fact that slavery is fundamentally distasteful to our individualistic values leads to a lot of misinterpretation and misrepresentation of the actual practice.
The only slaves that were actually treated like dirt 24/7 were mining and farming slaves, and that's because they were used for mindless labor anyone with working limbs could do, so they were a dime a dozen and needed to be worked like dogs to get your money's worth considering their "maintenance" costs.
Household servants and especially skilled craftsmen, however, often had standards of living not all that different from their free citizen counterparts. You can't just whip a blacksmith into working faster or better because you don't know the craft and can't really tell if he's making the best he can or intentionally sabotaging a product because he hates you, and if you could tell then you wouldn't need the slave in the first place. You could hire a free blacksmith to oversee his work, but at that point why not just hire him to DO the work? Paying a dude to run around with a whip to keep several dozen laborers in line is a far cry from paying a skilled craftsmen to oversee a single/small number of crafstmen because you feel like working them 20hrs a day regardless of the quality of their work rather than treating them like a human. The economics just don't work out.
It's also a pretty bad idea to make the people serving your food and medicine and who are intimately aware of your personal life hate you. So when it comes to, say, Anakin, who does menial tasks and skilled mechanical work, Watto really doesn't benefit from just beating him senseless and making his life a misery to satisfy some petty power indulgence. He's a businessman and wants his slaves productive, there's no reason their relationship HAS to be antagonistic just because Watto technically owns him.
This is all to say that we shouldn't be reducing slavery in fiction to, "it's always bad and nothing but bad, the end". There's WAY more we can do with the subject, even if there's also plenty to do with the unjust aspect of it that should be a primary motivation for Anakin given that he becomes a man characterized by a pathological/authoritarian obsession with order and justice.
When Anakin reunites with Watto in AotC, Watto seems genuinely happy to see him. He probably saw himself as something of a father figure to him, not at all unreasonable considering that he factually was his most prominent male role model. It's perfectly believable that Watto might've treated Anakin more fairly/nicely than other slaves because whatever his moral failings, he probably still has SOME capacity for empathy and a desire to not make the lives of fatherless slave children any more miserable than they need to be.
You can do something with that. Have Anakin be way more vindictive about their former relationship than Watto is. Anakin obviously has justification for it given he was the slave, but make it clear that he's just flat-out misrepresenting their history to justify his anger. Watto can bring up how Anakin's childhood wasn't nearly as bad as it could've been with a different owner and that there were plenty of non-slave children on Tatooine that had it as bad or worse. He can bring up a whole bunch of little things he did for Anakin at no benefit to himself because like any normal person he doesn't like to see kids hating their lives. He can mention all kinds of facts and Anakin just doesn't care. He doesn't want to hear it. Slavery kept his mother from him for most of his life and Watto facilitated it, so he's the villain.
That scene can be used to showcase the whole reason he turns to the dark side: he is personally traumatized by injustice such that he closes himself off from all the nuance that needs to be considered to actually solve it and just divides the world into just and unjust; that which must be preserved and that which must be crushed.
Or you could do something entirely different. Have him be a labor slave living in absolute misery 24/7. Have the jedi be absolutely horrified that such a thing is happening anywhere in the galaxy and free him as a moral imperative to do SOMETHING against it while they're on Tattooine. Have them genuinely want to go back to free his mother at the least, but by the time the jedi council can convince the slow, bloated bureaucracy of the Republic to fork over the cash, she's already been worked to death. He could easily conclude that his mother died because the Republic wasn't invested enough in imposing order and justice on lawless worlds. That the greatest tragedies of his life never would've happened if Tattooine was forced to comply with Republic law by whatever means necessary. That every second spent considering the complexities of expanding Republic rule effectively and efficiently is another second of pointless suffering for millions of people on lawless worlds.
The point being, there's much more to slavery than mistreatment by owners and thus much more that can be done with it.
not all forms of slavery has to be whipping and chains. indentured servitude was more common practice than chattel slavery in times of antiquity
I Love Sla.... Democracy
Uh oh, the ''slavery wasnt always bad'' bros are already here I see.
This is gonna piss off a lot of people. Including me. Can't wait.
I’m already pissed. LETS GO!!!
Not me. I've always thought the Clone Wars TV show was a little bit overrated.
@@SpFlash1523Same. I figured that it's mostly popular because of nostalgia.
This is gonna be so much fun to watch unfold
@@Lobsterwithinternet Yeah shows mostly had through the first two seasons save for a couple arcs.
It's funny because on one hand the show bends over backwards to make sure anakin never meets grievous all because of one line in the movie. On the other, they have no problem making anakin and obiwan fight dooku multiple times despite the movie inferring they haven't fought him together since episode 2.
To be fair the "you're shorter than I expected" line in episode 3 was pretty bad
Well that's true, but at the same time, it's only a nit pick. Nit picks are nit picks, and they're easy to ignore or not even notice in the first place.
@@XavierDaSalla Nah, the “shorter than I expected” line was pretty cool, mostly because of Hayden’s delivery
@@KingSlayer_.That's not a not pick kiddo... That's a pretty big issue for the canon....
@@KingSlayer_. It completely invalidates a line in the movie. You're right in that it doesn't ruin the enjoyment of the scene, but it shows how lopsided their creative priorities were.
Bringing Maul back from the dead actually WAS shocking and interesting at the time and Maul was completely underutilized and in doing this they gave him a lot more time to establish himself as a character. Unfortunately… every character now lives through lightsaber wounds and it cheapens everything.
Maul still should've never returned. It was interesting to see him back because he had a cool demon design but outside of that he was just a one note character George literally made to just function as a final boss that dies.
I mean, it might've been shocking to the teenage audience who already thought the "red double lightsaber man was totes rad and cool", sure. But there's nothing to be gained by bringing him back from the dead except a revenge arc (yawn) or a redemption arc (no way that was happening). He's designed as a one dimensional character for a movie fight, and they brought him back under such awful pretenses and gloss over how he survived such a ridiculous scenario as being literally bisected and then fall down a miles long tube with "well too angry to die dark side powers lol".
Like, the whole "too angry to die" meme with certain characters like Doom Slayer is funny because it's baked into their core as a character. But Maul didn't have ANYTHING to work with as far as the movies were concerned. And the show doesn't do him any favors going forward.
Absolute lame fan service.
@@PANCAKEMINEZZ"Too angry to die" has its place in Star Wars. It's sort of par for the course for Dark side users. I mean, just look at Sion from KOTOR II. Dark side users are repeatedly and consistently mutilated or chopped up yet continue to persist because of the Dark side (or I guess because the plot demands it)... yet you can have people like Qui-Gon who is just stabbed in the tummy and dies, so I don't think Maul surviving is as far fetched as you're implying.
Though I do agree with what OP is saying, it's a bit silly how everyone can survive lightsaber wounds and/or comes back to life. I'm sure that eventually we'll see Mace Windu returning, somehow.
@@pyerackI’m glad he returned because of that
@@Dylan-xx2tk bad comparison. Sion from KOTOR II is a totally different beast from Darth Maul the Sith assassin who was literally cleaved in half and had blood spatter out from his intestines. Bringing him back was stupid, shoddy storytelling and screams of creative bankruptcy, which we now know is par for the course with Dave Filoni. TCW turned Star Wars into Marvel, when Star Wars was never Marvel and never meant to be Marvel.
Something that I wish the show touched on more is the fact that clones are slave child soldiers literally bred for obedience and war. You would think that Anakin would have more of a problem with that.
Also I wish there was more exploration of the mirror relationship between the clones and droids. Both are mass produced and considered expendable. Their creation is artificial and purpose is solely for war. Both are sentient beings (idk if it’s canon but the droids in Star Wars are certainly presented as such) yet have no freedom.
I remember how during the Inhibitor Chip Arc that Fives was with that droid the entire time and I thought they were going to touch on the similarities between the two. While I think it was IMPLIED at the end, they never really adressed it like I hoped they would. Just a single short convo about it would have been enough but they didn't. I've noticed that that's kinda the problem with most of star wars. A lot of motivations and development seem to be implied but never properly adressed, and with some slight tweaks it would improve the franchise so much.
It’s made for kids, not for boring adults, who peel it apart with logic…
@@MappingEagle thats what andor does so well. Actually treats you like an adult. Good stuff
@@ncard00 how does wanting logic and depth in stories= boring? How old are you? 8?
@ncard00 for kids? That is a pathetic argument. Batman TAS was 4 kids but it was not bloody boring!
Can we talk about how inconsistent Bo Katan was as a character? Like she goes from a willing murderer to suddenly having a conscience
That's how many characters are in the Disney shows: Boba Fett, Fennec Shand, Reeeva, Bill Burr. Even that robot in Mando.
We should not forget Vader himself, too.
Kylo Ren. (I literally had to look that up because I forgot his name, and plus I don't even know what was going on in the last movie so I'm not sure whether he turned good.)
@@-taz- even in the clone wars bo becomes a different character
If she had a conscience she would have killed herself after the bullshit she had caused.
I can't wait for you to talk about General Grievous. He was originally a sort of tragic villain. His original accident was secretly caused by the Separatists, and during his reconstruction surgery they gave him aggression implants against his wishes or knowledge.
Despite this he maintained a sense of honor and would allow clone troopers to live if he felt they fought bravely enough and it wouldn't ultimately affect the war by doing so. He struggled against his aggression spikes and wondered what was ultimately done to him on the surgery table.
His hatred for the Jedi was justified since the Jedi sided with the species that enslaved his race and killed his mate during their war so after becoming a cyborg he hunted them and collected their lightsabers.
They turned him into a boring static mustache twirling incompetent buffoon.
Thanks Dave.
It was frankly bizarre how underdeveloped he was in TCW, it legit felt like Feloni and friends flat out hated the character or something. Not only was he a one-dimension mustache-twirler who ran away at every chance he got and was a horrible commander despite supposedly being a tactical genius, but he can't even fight worth a damn. It was to the point where I was genuinely surprised when he managed to defeat Kit Fisto's padawan.
But frankly for a show that loves to point out how flawed the Jedi are, you'd think that a character who has a deep seated hatred for the Jedi as a result of their blindly carrying out the Republic's orders instead of understanding the situation would be a fantastic way to showcase how the Jedi have lost their way and how they created one of their worst enemies through their mistakes. Hell it could also serve as an interesting tie-in for Rush Clovis's arc. As someone who is dedicated to the Banking Clan and believes those who raised him are good people, how would he react to the revelation that Dooku and the Banking Clan intentionally crippled Grievous in order to turn him into their loyal enforcer, selectively picking which memories he was allowed to keep in order to ensure he was singularly focused on destroying the Jedi.
And they retconned mace crushing his chest into that gungan bullshit
I mean, the character was pretty consistent to what Lucas had him be in Revenge of the Sith. Honestly, I want to say that the EU material involving him that came out pre-RotS played a major part in giving people the wrong idea about him, especially since the guys working on that EU material wouldn't have known much aside from whatever concept art of the character was finished at the time.
Creative divergence spun from a lack of communication that can be somewhat pinned on Grievous still being under development at the time with nothing precisely concrete.
@@diegokeyz219 Also, they retconned nothing aside from Grievous always having a cough, which isn't even a retcon to begin with since the idea in Revenge of the Sith was that he was an imperfect cyborg; more or less created as a mirror in general for what Anakin would become in that regard, which I've seen someone make a case for Dooku and Maul being that as well.
Have you ever heard about the tragedy of General Greivous the Clankest? Its not a story TCW fans would tell you. He was able to onetap Sha'agy, but he couldn't save himself from the gungans and younglings.
I’ve ALWAYS felt that way about Anakin’s character in The Clone Wars being completely different from Hayden’s portrayal, but I’ve never heard it articulated before
Trust me he ain’t the only one besides you who sees it 😂 I been saying this to people for years
We should give him is own moniker like “jake sky walker” or something
I think that’s because Hayden’s portrayal sucked. It was acceptable in Episode 3 and horrendous in Episode 2. CW’s interpretation feels different and seems closer to what Lucas intended for Anakin but couldn’t execute
Thats my favorite part of the show, i feel he is done way better here, kinda sad they cant finish his arc cause that happens in ROTS
They tried to make anakin cool, but to me he never need to be. He is not supposed to be "cool" he is supposed to be tragic and socially awkward
I still haven't forgiven Clone Wars not giving us Durge just because he would of been a nightmare to animate in 3D.
Man…Durge was so cool lol
Instead we have to read comics :/
They didn't have the budget
Didn't they create Cad Bane to kinda replace that wild mercenary character that would have been Durge? What a fucking downgrade man
@@RingoSkye because they didn't have the budget to do durge
To be fair during the Slave arc, it may seem Anakin is flirting but no he’s just manipulating her. Kinda playing it cool until he can figure out how we’re getting out of here.
But I totally agree that the scene makes it seem sad when she dies and we’re supposed to feel sad. They totally messed that up. And yes totally agree that Anakin should have gotten mad at the Jedi for getting involved with freeing slaves now only because this planet was part of the Republic before it got invaded.
Lol yes, Duel of the droids arc is cringe but a lot of episodes in the first two seasons aren’t that good to be fair.
Love the Clovis arc. Criminally underrated
Because Anakin is such a good undercover agent, am I right? That's why he isn't let in on the whole Hardeen debacle, because he has such good control of his inner feelings....... oh
I thought they made the scene seem sad was because before she died, she claimed that Anakin was still a slave. It was more towards his feelings towards the order
@@helenwhs Comparing some random slave queen bitch to the death of his master, brother, and best friend? They wanted to keep Anakin in the dark because they knew how he'd react. It would sell the idea of Kenobi being dead even more. Lying through their teeth when they said "he wouldn't be able to control his emotions".
He LITERALY says that he doesn't care about this slaver scum.
@@shadowmandeathstroke8232 That’s actually a good point. That is true because Anakin is always a slave. He’s not free until he kills the Emporer
A note on Anakin killing the younglings, I feel a good alteration to show how far he's willing to go is to have him see them be chased into a room with troopers. Anakin sees it and initially goes to intervene but halts, knowing that if he does this, it will stop Palpatine from telling him how to save Padme. So he just turns away as the door closes and theres the muffled sound of blaster fire.
That way, it still holds the idea of Anakin throwing away his innocence (As shown with Sors) but still keeps it relatively distant to not have it be such a fall. That there's that resistance in him and recognition that its wrong but he has no choice.
Fire idea. I wish there was more justification behind that youngling scene. I like that Anakin himself had to do something absolutely irredeemable personally, but like... it just came out of no where, as Sheev said, lol
@@techzone1552I disagree. There's mulitple ways to justify it. Anakin could think there’s no way to save the younglings, because they'll either be hunted down by the clones or others. Or that he thinks that the Jedi are so bad that the only way to "save" the younglings is by killing them, in a very twisted view of saving them. Or maybe he just hates the Jedi that much already.
Interesting thought but in the end your idea just waters down the stronger concept of Anakin just doing it himself. Your idea is more like when Kylo was about to kill Leia, but decided not to, but then the other fighters do it anyway. It would have been better to just have Kylo do it.
@@-Patali- the difference is that Kylo seemed to not fire at the last second. Whereas here, with Anakin, hes stopping himself from actively stopping the troopers. Perhaps even have one of the padawan call out to him, which causes him to start to move only to stop and realise that he cant. He needs to save his wife so he let's the troopers kill the padawans. That theres evidently conflict but the idea is that, unlike Kylo who stopped himself from killing his mother, Anakin stopped himself from saving the padawans
I can't believe it needs to be said, but when he kills the younglings he's Darth Vader, not Anakin. Not that it really matters, because Anakin was an asshole all along.
If anything is wrong about the legacy of the Anakin Skywalker story at all is that he's seen as sympathetic. He's not, he's a monster and was always going to be one. He was a feckless, weak murderer. He always was, but when he becomes Vader there's no remorse. There should be no excuses or apologies for him and it's pretty sickening how far people will bend over backwards in an attempt to do so.
She was barely legal in most systems..
She wore a mini skirt everyday so we told her there were no panties in space
A fine piece of jail bait in a more civilized age.
@@loserinasuit7880 💀
My God man, get help.
This is a reference to the Obi Wan AI generated video of him talking about Ahsoka 😂
George was right when he wanted Ahsoka to die. This would greately explain why Anakin didn't trust JO and wanted to protect deeply those he was attached with.
It’s such a good idea. He suffers a tragedy in war…classic set up for a fall to the dark side. Literally the entire premise of the KOTOR games.
Clone wars really did Luminara dirty huh.
Back in legends she was actually really chill and she and Barriss were much closer. Luminara shared a lot of the cultural heritage of their species with her student and admitted that she sometimes treated Barriss more like a daughter than as an apprentice.
Side note, did no one think it was weird that Barriss was aged down so much in TCW? She looks very different from her film version.
Especially since ashoka already had a friend in the lore (scout).
I didn't even know that barris was in the movies.
@@matthiuskoenig3378 Who is her friend?
So weird. Just give her a new Apprentice?
@@Grandof-the-PentastarAlignment scout aka Tallisibeth Enwandung-Esterhazy
Anakin and Bariss are the same age. It...annoys me they made her Ahsoka's BFF; if anything, it should've been Bariss's padawan and not Bariss herself, since her previous backstory was as Anakin's friend. Having Anakin interact with Jedi who he genuinely is an equal to (i.e., not Obi-Wan) would've been great and it would've also still let the contrast between Bariss's more orthodox approach and Anakin's looser teaching style.
Soooo true. It would have been so much better and make more sens
Not anymore, thanks to retconning Filoni. Barriss is now 14, not 19. WHYYYY?
That's right. "Improve the prequels" would've included showing a realistic network or potential to have a network, and maybe his lack of friends (that don't just stroke his ego and bring out the good in him) could've been a part of his fall.
That's another weird thing about the Clone wars I will never get. Jedi are growing up around each other, and would share similar interests and values, and would naturally be friends. -- And I don't want to hear some retard say that isn't allowed: 1) Buddhist monks make friends in the temple, 2) Luke was never told to not have friends. --
Or assassinating her character entirely with the temple bombing.
@@ECSOrder66Filoni likes em young
My biggest problem with TCW always was (and still is) the removal of nuances of Dooku, Grievous and the CIS as a whole. Instead of using the justified parts of their existence and choices to show that they are actually some kind of "misguided beta-version of the rebellion", the whole separatist side got downgraded to "discount empire with droids".
There is just one single episode showing the "good" side of the CIS with "heroes on both sides", but even that is completely lacking any consequences. Ahsoka says "the war is more complicated than i thought", but this never leads to any plot point or character development at all. You can literally skip this episode and nothing would feel off.
The republic on the other had is always depicted as "the good guys", unlike the old EU canon they never commit any war crime (and even if they do, like fake surrender, its played as a joke). This is also why many of the stories like the republic military investigating against Ahsoka or all the anti-clone demonstrations from the people miss their mark: We never see the republic being in the wrong and therefore never can understand any critics of the republic, Jedi or clones. People in the show only say "oh i blame the Jedi for the violence", but we never see *how and why* this could be justified. They are missing the classic "show, don't tell"-rule. We are never given any reasons to doubt the Republic or Jedi, since all "evil republic" story arcs are always self-contained and committed by isolated traitors, but are never caused by established structures of the Republic or Jedi. There is nothing like the tragic and nuanced battle of Jabiim from the classic EU in this show. Nothing at all.
This black-white-view of the Clone Wars ripped this era of so much nuance and tragedy. Dave Filoni is clearly a fanboy of the Republic and the Clones (i think in some interview he even admits that), and his views are imprinted all over this series. And it is hurting the show.
Along with that, they grossly diminish the CIS as a legitimate threat by having the Republic constantly win over the course of the series. How are we supposed to be intimidated by an antagonist who can’t gain a full victory half the time? It’s pretty much the same problem Kylo Ren had on a much bigger scale
CIS legit just enslaves every planet that sides with them, they're as evil if not more than the Empire lol
The changes to the clones and Geonosians felt pretty cowardly. Order 66 had the complicated morality of child-soldiers (who kind of seem like indoctrinated slaves) turning on comrades in the name of the government whose allegiance was drilled into them from birth. (Or from cloning pod. However you call it).
The issue is that George Lucas never intended for the clones to be the unironic heroes in a children’s show. (Or if they were, this wouldn’t be the first time he didn’t think out the ethical implications of something in his movies). They were suppose to be a warning about people being raised like the Spartans of old would end up becoming tools for fascism. Instead, we got an Evil Mode biochip. The scenario becomes the Treehouse of Horror skit with the Krusty Doll. No morale questions or logic, just a switch set to “kill.”
The Geonosians started as a species of individuals who just happened to be insects. CW turned them into a “Queen leading a hive mind” setup. Besides that being SO played out in sci-fi, it’s just a cop-out so the protagonists can kill them without looking bad. And it doesn’t match up with why their leader is clearly and old male like Poggle.
I’m fine with making the CIS look evil, so it will make sense that the Jedi would fight them, but the Republic was literally supposed to be “becoming the Empire” during the Clone Wars. It should become progressively more and more authoritarian, until you can tell that it’s just like the Empire.
Yeah, as much as people say it “isn’t a kids show”, they definitely stripped away much of the nuance from everything
I’ve even heard a theory that TCW is actually a Republic propaganda show to make the CIS look incompetent and evil, and the Jedi and Republic look good (obviously certain scenes like Palpatine being evil wouldn’t be included)
Lucas has said multiple times that “balance” means no dark side. The dark side is a corruption of the force and “balance” is the light existing uncorrupted.
And that is something that Dave Filoni chooses to ignore. That’s why I dislike The Father as a concept…
@@paradox2210 the whole mortis shit is super lame and breaks so much canon. Easily the worst part of TCW.
@@keshonhend2047 Yeah. Filoni wants us to believe that The Father being 'balance' means he’s 'not light and not dark and just in the middle' or something stupid like that. We’re also expected to believe that The Son, being an embodiment of darkness, had lived 100% peacefully with The Daughter, an embodiment of light, for THOUSANDS OF YEARS before Anakin shows up.
@@paradox2210well, they did, it’s in the show
@@soybajo-kira8585 What kind of argument is that? Just because the show says something doesn’t mean that it makes logical sense.
The Father conceptually makes no sense as he is designed based upon the false notion that 'balance' in the force is both light and dark when balance is actually a complete absence of darkness.
The Son and The Daughter having lived peacefully for thousands of years makes no sense as the darkness and the light are supposed to always be in conflict until the light surpasses the dark.
Edit: fixed spelling
The Last time Ahoska saw Bo she burnt a village in front of her eyes. Why would she help her.
Plus it was Bo who helped bring Maul to Mandalore in the first place
Because "plot"
Because she changed and is trying to stop Maul now.
You sure? She never wanted him to rule it.
finally someone said it, thank you 🙏
Bo is just racist to Zabraks
True. True. True
The 2003 series feels a lot more consistent with the movies tbh. It doesn’t have Ahsoka in it, but rather focuses more on how Anakin and Obi-Wan’s master-apprentice relationship develops and Anakin being rushed into knighthood. It connects Anakin’s character in ATOC and ROTS much more organically. Not to mention the superior grievous
Grevious in Tarkovsky was an absolute BEAST!
Agreed. And it makes me sad that so many people are unaware of it or just disregard it as "TCW, but with less content." Genndywars feels like a true Star Wars 2.5, and was created within that context. TCW feels like an excessively long fanfiction by comparison
They should have retconned the war lasting more than 3 years. I mean, conquering and liberating hundreds of planets take some time anyway. In this case we could have kept a large chunk of the 2003 cartoon (until Anakin becoming a Jedi Knight), then we could have introduced Ahsoka and starting the animated series. . If I remember correctly, there's already a time jump between knighting Anakin and the Outer Rim sieges that is immediately before episode 3, so there would have been room to expand the original idea further instead of rewriting the whole thing. I don't exactly know how much such a change (the war lasting for 5 years instead of 3) would have altered what the other media established (books, comics), but I personally headcanon things like this to be honest and it also makes the war more bloody and mentally/phisically tolling, creating the illusion of a really endless war (Palpatine is in charge of both parties, so time doesn't really matter to him I guess.), not to mention character developments. Also, considering WW1 lasted for 4 years (+2 years of chaos) and WW2 lasted for 6 years (+2 years of chaos), a 3-year-long galactic war that changed the entire history of the galaxy so drastically just doesn't seem to be... realistic for me. Not to mention Anakin fought on a different planet in every 2 or 3 episodes simply because they won on the previous one. Like how?
fr. Tho that's most likely cuz it was made before Star Wars 3
Well too bad you're wrong the 2003 series is garbage 😊
Dave Filoni: "What is Star Wars but a bunch of MYSTERY BOXES?"
Hey hey JJ Plagiarisms!
This is JJ Abrams
@@user-ux8ey5oi5i lol
The slavery thing always bothered me too. How tf can the Jedi claim they are keepers of the peace if slavery is widely accepted and ignored issue in the Republic? I know Tatooine is considered to be outside Republic jurisdiction, but in the Clone Wars they violate that jurisdiction all the time.
You could argue that slavery doesn't really violate "peace", honestly. Trying to abolish slavery across a galaxy though...
But regardless isn't it kinda the point that the Jedi are kinda hypocrites? Or at least just not being as good as they should be.
Because the Jedi are beholden to the senate and not their code after the Vallorum reformations
Because the republic is corrupt and the Jedi have grown complacent. That’s why the Jedi were destroyed in the end
Name a single free society that never owned slaves
@@anon2427 By society do you mean a continuous government? Because there are plenty of governments out there that have never owned slaves in their history.
Ahsoka to Rex: "They may be willing to die, but I am not the one who is going to kill them"
Earlier, Ahsoka to Maul: "Now, go cause some chaos. It's what you're good at"
Maul to himself: "I'm gonna fuck this ship up and kill everyone I see"
Maul: "Door goes woosh/slice lol"
Ahsoka Wayne: "I won't kill you. But I don't have to save you."
😂😂
“I won’t kill the clones, but I will release the dude who staged a coup and took over the legitimate government of Mandalore, ran a criminal empire, and brutally killed more people than I can count. Because I’m a good guy!”
yeah maul kills them not her XD completely different... kinda
As a huge clone wars fan, I kind of agree. I had no idea the ROTS novelization had so many good extra details
The details in the novels retcon the movies, though, same as Clone Wars. Having Anakin demand to be a Master because of secret Jedi knowledge to save Padme makes him more reasonable, but Anakin already said as early as AotC he hates the Jedi because they won't treat him like he's special and give him a promotion.
The novel makes him sound like he's worried about Padme when the previous movie shows he primarily craves power and status and privilege.
This is a huge problem with using the novels as canon. They rewrite Anakin as much as the animated series does.
Sheev Talks is confused about Anakin killing Jedi children, but notice how he readily admits Anakin MURDERED ALL OF THE TUSKEN CHILDREN. The point of him killing Jedi children is that Anakin is already the kind of person who will kill your children in revenge for something you did. The Tusken children are just as innocent as the Jedi children and Anakin doesn't care.
It's also coloring how Sheev Talks discusses Palpatine as "leveling" with Anakin. Palpatine isn't being honest, he's telling Anakin what he wants to hear because the truth is that Anakin is a terrible Jedi.
This also kind of ruins the reading of Mace. Mace keeps being treated as embodying the failures of the Jedi, except Mace is the only Jedi to protest them being conscripted into the military to fight a war. His distrust of Anakin is completely valid because teenage Anakin is a serial killer who hates democracy.
That RotS novel is absolutely amazing. Unfortunately, it has to kinda play fast and loose with the story depicted in the movie because it's trying to make sense out of the sheer nonsense of the movie.
Yeah, I said it. RotS is a bad movie. The only reason why people praise it is because it's a 6/10 whereas tPM and AotC were 4/10 at best.
@@MrBazBake unaliving younglings made way less sense than unaliving Tusken children, though both are of course morally depraved. Anakin really should have seen himself in those younglings, while Tusken children just looked like his mother's killers (afaik he didn't know any Tuskens). ig my best explanation (not having read the novelizations) is that Anakin was just willing to follow through with anything Palpatine told him to do because of his lies about saving Padmé.
why is hating democracy deserving of distrust? late Republic-era Star Wars does a pretty good job of showing the many faults of democratic government. Windu himself would be a bit loony if he had no misgivings about the structure of the Republic following the beginning of the Clone Wars that u rightly admit he opposed as well as the concentration of power in the Chancellor.
i do agree with u overall that the Star Wars canon is a complete mess and seems to have been a free-for-all since the original trilogy. can the countless contradictions even be described as retcons? does the 2008 series overtake the prequel films where they seem to contradict?
@@MrBazBake”the novel makes it sound like he’s worried about Padmé when the previous showed he primarily craves power, status, and privilege”
he spends the ROTS movie being worried about Padmé anyway, that’s literally his whole motivation for the things he does during it
@@syedshahrukhraza2923
"...it's trying to make sense out of the sheer nonsense of the movie."
No, it doesn't. The novel was released before the movie.
One thing i find funny about the jedi temple bombing is that of all the characters they could have chosen, they chose a hijabi
General Grievous was an absolute MISS in this show. He’s a force of nature, unfeeling, and can take on SEVERAL JEDI AT ONE TIME. But he can be beat by a GUNGAN. 😭
Says who
The revenge of the sith novel, in the deleted scenes, he is responsible for the death of jedi master Shaak Ti, the battle of hypori, hundreds of lore battles were ignored which showed the ruthless and capable commander @@SamuelCollins
My main problem with this show was that Filoni had this thing where he'd say, "Let's use legends stuff!"
And then he'd use that stuff in a way that broke continuity, like having the Nightsisters be witches instead of force-users and having them die off thirty years before the book that introduced them; having Barris go from jedi healer with her own book series to "HAHAHA BOMB STUFF", and having Yoda somehow know who Darth Bane was despite the guy going out of his way to ensure the Sith were thought dead.
Also, planning to kill characters like Aurra Sing who had been established as surviving until after the Vong Wars; or retconning the entire lore of Dengar, Bossk, and several other background OT characters so you can use them in a poorly written episode of Prison Break or have them protecting a train for a culture capable of spaceflight . . . or my personal favorite, having someone bisected by a lightsaber come back in his original form instead of using your witchy characters to "resurrect" him.
I mean yeah it’s fine to like EU over TCW but you do realize there’s an official pre-Disney canon hierarchy right? Movies then shows then books
Yes but that was put in place specifically so Filoni and the show could do whatever they wanted. It should be removed from the Legends continuity and left in only the Disney canon
@@peetsaman8889 Sure, but when you work something into your continuity so you can completely retcon how it functions within the universe at large- for example, retconning the Dathomiri to be their own species instead of a colony of tribal humans, and retconning the Zabraks to be from here instead of Iridonia- which did all kinds of chaos with the lore of Eeth Koth, Maul, the Nightsisters, and the old Republic continuity- you've basically used the lore to desecrate the lore. Like how modern Star Wars tries to claim Thrawn is still the terror he was in legends, but they've removed what made him that way: his anonymity, his wealth of knowledge, his secret manipulation of the existing imperial factions, and his ingenuity with technology like cloaking shields and life-forms like the Noghri and the Ysalimiri.
While it is irritating, Lucas did it all the time. He did have final say on what did and did not go into the show. And before anyone says something, no, being the creator doesn’t make it okay to break your own continuity.
@@user-pv3nh5rd1m Ridley Scott: :\
BTW I completely agree.
The sad part is… you’re not wrong, I agreed with most of your points entirely. I just enjoy the show and find it whimsical enough to overlook the issues you pose more easily than you do and just enjoy the fun parts. I still like it, I will even still say I think it’s good. But it’s no where near elite level character development or story telling, so I understand if that’s the criteria why it fails to please.
Oh, good. Now you understand why I and many others like The Last Jedi.
@@Halo_Legend as a stand alone movie it’s fine, as how it fits into the trilogy, or even just follows up on the what was built by TFA if you wanna make the same argument in its defense against Rise (which is an even worse movie tbf) it’s just shit
@@Halo_LegendI’ve got a brother who enjoys and defends the sequels, especially the last Jedi, so I understand that people can enjoy the movie, however I cannot see myself ever having fun with it, it’s not even dumb nitpicks or even actual plot criticisms that stop me I just have some sort of adverse reaction to the movie, it’s the only Star Wars movie that makes me actively mad watching it…
So good on you that you don’t have that problem and can enjoy it while I am cursed to despise it.
@@loganmapes2307 Honestly, looking back on it, it should have been its own one-off movie. Like literally everything inside the movie was set up and resolved, the thing that made it hated was because it messed up the trilogy that was set up by being smack dab in the center when it carries more of a finale vibe. I mean imagine if instead of making the second part of the doomed sequel trilogy, Rian was set to direct a stand alone story that doesn't directly involve our favorite characters (kind of like Rogue One) and did his subverting of expectations there? The blow would have been much softer due to it being a stand-alone story, heck, Star Wars fans might have been more fond of it if it was just a stand-alone story about one ship trying to escape the first order.
@@bananarama1425 agreed
Killing Ahsoka would of been a great way to bridge the Jedi’s distrust of Anakin, he’s given a Padawan due to the war and need for more Jedi but he’s unprepared obviously and ends up guiding her down a path that isn’t inline with the ways of the Jedi due to his own disliking of their rules (as shown in the films) thus resulting in either her death or a turn to the dark side then her death and from then on the Jedi’s opinion of him is completely muddled between people like obi wan who still sees some good in him as he believes the council promoted anakin to quickly and the rest of the council who solely blames Anakin for what happened ostracising him. Then heads into ROTS
You could also add some parallels to Padme’s death, which would give Anakin something more solid than “it was revealed to me in a dream”
You know what's weird? Ahsoka was promised to be killed by Season 2's end. It was in the Star Wars insider, she was specifically stated in it with an interview with Lucas that she was supposed to be killed off as 'internal closure for Jar Jar and Little Anakin haters' when the show came out. The interviewers even stated she was 'intentionally annoying' etc.
No I actually like the original idea, that she survives order 66 by nothing but an ironic twist of fate.
@@WereScrib Season 2??? 😂
@@harrambou9468Yep, literally. She was supposed to die in 'season 2' according to early interviews (Mind you I think it was planned that the series was only going to be three seasons long)
I also think that one of the biggest issues with the show is the fact that every episode is condensed to fit a 30 minute time slot. I feel like this causes the show to always simple "get to the point" and put a lot of other details on the backburner.
Ahsoka being Obi-Wan's apprentice always made more sense. Having them set up as siblings, having Anakin resent the license Obi-Wan gives her (older vs. younger kid syndrome), having Ahsoka be more of a model Jedi because she was raised to it and he wasn't, is a much more interesting dynamic. Bonus points for having him kill her during the Temple Raid, because *that* would be something that would have Obi-Wan completely willing to write him off. You can tweak the scene itself when Obi-Wan really sees what he did very easily: Obi-Wan can watch Anakin massacre Jedi after Jedi on the holopad, only for Ahsoka to enter the frame, and *that's* when he says "I can't watch anymore."
I don't mind that Anakin has an apprentice and they actually do have a pretty good reason for why. In-Universe, it's to teach Anakin to be more patient and to let go of attachment. Out-of-universe, it's to make Anakin more likeable due to his bad reputation from the movies and much more of an "older brother" figure to the young audience.
The problem is that Anakin's voice and personality is inconsistent. His personality in TCW is a mix between Luke Skywalker and Han Solo. That's actually the direction they told Matt Lanter (Anakin's voice actor) to go with.
Anakin from the movies and CWMMP is introverted and mentally unbalanced, while the Anakin in TCW is down-to-earth and extroverted. Anakin in the movies has a much higher voice with slight mid-atlantic accent and a monotone speaking pattern to the point of nearly mumbling, while Anakin in TCW has a deeper voice with a typical American accent and speaks much more confidently.
To make a comparison, Movie Anakin is the shy bookish type while TCW Anakin is the star quarterback of the football team.
@cantnevercould9660 j See, I can't see the Canon reasons as sensible. They're in a war. It's just a terrible time to become responsible for a child in general, and I don't know how giving someone care of a person they *must* be attached to for that person's own healthy development is going to help someone overcome attachment. I can't think of a culture that gives young unstable soldiers needy children to care for over a period of several years as a way to help them learn to let go. Unless we're going super dark here and the whole point was for ahsoka to die.
Teaching a padawan is heavily implied to be a decade long investment at the least. Obi-Wan was still a padawan at 23-ish. And since padawans follow their masters everywhere, it's a full time, fully-dedicated, long term important commitment.
Also, this is just my personal take. But I always read movie Anakin more as sullen than shy. He's pretty outspoken, to me, it's just his voice isn't loud or harsh. But he never seemed shy or studious to me. I always saw him as reckless, stubborn, impatient, greedy, and insecure. That was always just my personal read on him - but I agree that tcw Anakin is a whole different person sort of sharing his backstory.
Holy moly this would’ve been so much more interesting than what we ended up getting in the show
@@cantnevercould9660 The dude who plays Anakin in TCW played a rapist murderer football player on Heroes, which makes that comparison a little too apt.
Okay, this would be amazing, especially if Obi-Wan basically dumps Ahsoka onto Anakin at every opportunity to teach him responsibility, only for Anakin to view every interaction like he's babysitting her.
Haven’t finished the video yet, but on Anakin:
I was in the weird position to have watched the Clone Wars before I watched the prequels and the OT, as I expected that Anakin (and this show in general) was going to be a lot better than the prequels due to some cultural osmosis.
When I watched the prequels, I ended up actually enjoying the flaws of Anakin as a character more. He’s “whiny”, yeah, he’s a “brat”, but I loved seeing him in this more genuine light. He’s not always quipping and smooth talking and kicking ass, instead he’s a quiet and serious person who’s left out of the bigger equation by the rest of the Jedi council, trying to figure out who he is and what he wants. It makes sense why someone as unsure as Anakin in the prequels could turn into Vader, at least to me. Like you said, Anakin in the Clone Wars is a lil too stable and reasonable for me to believe that.
Clone Wars Anakin shows a very ‘objective’ view of Anakin instead of an empathetic one, which IMO also weakens the emotional reaction to him turning into Vader.
There’s a huge jump between episode 2 and 3 in his character that definitely should’ve been explored instead of trying to make Vader be more believable as Anakin.
I showed my wife the prequels and TCW in order, TPM, AOTC, TCW, and finished with ROTS. She agreed with all your points, she liked Anakin MORE in the movies than the show.
THANK YOU! Anakin wasn't a stable-minded war hero; he was a man who was traded from childhood slavery to abiding by the rules of strict space monks. He just wanted a normal life with a wife and kids, but he was being manipulated into believing that it would be taken away to the point where he did things that led to it out of his own lust for power.
He had a tragic story because he wanted his own personal happiness, but everybody else wanted him to play their desired roles for him in the bigger picture.
Side note: bringing Maul back was another mistake. He wasn't meant to be a fleshed-out character because he was merely a tool for Palpatine's plan. Before it was retconned, Obi-Wan was promoted to Jedi Master BECAUSE he'd killed the first Sith in 1,000 years.
I still say Clone Wars radicalized Star Wars fans at the worst possible time.
When we're watching in the news that Americans are torturing people, often innocent, and experts keep repeating that torture is useless and the CIA reveals that torture revealed no actionable intel, The Clone Wars steps in two years later and says, "Torture and war crimes are good actually, see how much fun Anakin and Obi-Wan are having committing war crimes and crimes against humanity?"
Filoni was the wrong guy to handle this material because he walked the fanbase back into Vader apologia through his BS destiny nonsense until fandom decided Anakin is the hero actually and nothing he did was bad 🤢🤮
I agree. The flaws he already had were okay. It made it believable that he was susceptible to the dark side, and how Palpatine was able to prey on his uncertainty and need for affirmation.
Plus, at least in my opinion, the prequels are meant to work in context with the originals, because if you know the warnings and trials Luke faced (in Return of the Jedi), it's easier to see how Anakin failed. So that's why on their own the flaws of the writing make the story totally incoherent.
Anakin seemed stable to you in TCW? He certainly had a veneer of confidence, but that seems pretty easy to read as him putting on a front he learned to help keep up morale. Or maybe he did become genuinely confident for awhile only to get worn down by things like how strained his relationship with the order had become and worries about the visions he was having regarding Padme's death and withdraw into himself and become sullen. I feel like the way he was acting during the first act of RotS is pretty close to how he acted in the TV show, for example. With him showing off and being hyper confident about things like being able to pull off the maneuver he used to scrape those droids off Obi-Wan's ship. But yeah, he definitely was not stable. Look at things like him snapping and giving a prisoner of war a beat down to compel him to give out information, for example. His old flaws are still there in TCW, he just momentarily managed to get into a mental space where he could somewhat handle controlling them.
tartakovsky's still holds up
Agreed!
I mean it’s kinda hard for it NOT to lol
It's the surperior version of CW for me.
It's so good and connects beautifully with the films without changing them.
You can never go wrong with Genndy!
Not only that, it’s…fucking awesome.
I appreciate that the Clone Wars was my first introduction to military sci-fi. However, it's quality leaves something to be desired.
The 2003 micro series is THE Clone Wars series to me. Characterizations and stories that naturally bridge Episodes II and III, an Anakin that actually feels and even sounds like movie Anakin, and is just better all around despite being way shorter.
I love the microseries. So good. 👍
The Multi-Media Project was good as a whole. Quinlan Vos>>> TCW’s version.
NGL, the fight between Ventress and Anakin being set on Yavin 4 is a really nice touch. The same worlds conquered by Jedi-turned-Sith like Freedon Nadd and Exar Kun. Both ambitious men that Anakin would eventually resemble.
Give Gendy Tartakovsky (also responsible for Samurai Jack) the credit he deserves as an artist, amazing series and one of the best Star Wars pieces of media EVER. It's amazing how that series, as a bridge between ep. 2 and 3, managed how to tell amazing stories in a short amount of time, before ep. 3 even released, what a great preparation.
That series did more with Grievous in a 20-second training sequence than TCW did with 6 seasons. The most obvious criticism of it is that it is mostly an excuse for action scenes and yet it STILL manages to have more substance than FIloni's version and fit in better with the established canon.
You sir are 100% right
My favorite part about the Onderon arc being not that great (besides things like half their training being under the assumption that droid AAT tanks don't have hatches that lock like every other tank ever does) is when the second episode begins with the rebels killing droids and firing weapons in highly populated areas. And then they're all confused why the citizens of Iziz are scared of them and instead of considering how they committed acts of terrorism in broad daylight, they come to the conclusion that "the people don't believe we can succeed". Like they're completely desensitized to violence.
dont forget the part where ahsoka took a droid gunship blaster shot and just shruged it of like it was nothing
I think you missed the point. Saw Gerrera is portrayed as a densitized himbo who can’t make sense of why the people aren’t rallying with them. His sister obviously realizes the distraught the violence causes but does not want to bring Saw’s spirit down by telling him this or waste their time complicating the matter so instead she makes up the point of ”They do not believe we can succeed.” in order to channel Saw’s energy and effort better and solely to the cause without interruption.
She is an effective leader and the person who understood how Saw thought and could control and channel his thoughts. After he lost her, he also started to slowly lose the plot as well.
@@kungolaf4499 I'd agree with you if it wasn't for that later in the episode,Steela was proven right. They said the power generator was responsible for powering the droids, and that destroying it would bring the droids to a standstill. They didn't mention that the generator was _also_ powering the whole city, and destroying it caused a citywide power outage. Hospitals, food storage, and everything else was without power for who knows how long. Despite this, the citizens were now cheering for the rebels doing the same thing as before, but at night.
Your analysis isn't wrong, though, I'd just say that moment is a weak example. The himbo to Forest Whittaker pipeline is very real though, check on your himbos.
@@lokay7233 the shot from the droid gunship wasn't at full power, but I bet it definitely still hurts.
@@merafirewing6591 dumbest explanation ever
IMO the mistakes were:
1) Make Grievous a joke! He is the predecessor to Darth Vader! And the original clone wars did everything right, he doesn’t have Asma by default! It was cause of Windu!
2) The stupidity of the Jedi order. So much teasing about order 66… to show the stupidity of Jedi.
3) While Asoka is a great character, she became Asoka Wars. People who follow Star Wars after the TLJ disaster do hate Disney, but talk about Asoka as if she was the savior of Star Wars. When she is none-existent outside these animated series. No film representation until episode 9.
And 50/50 on the truth of the matter”chosen one”. The father, daughter and son are actually a tease to the previously introduced Mother that Luke fought.
Finally, someone who speaks my language.
It's also really funny how so many people are like, "Filoni is a genius! He made Ahsoka purposefully annoying at first because he knew everyone would hate her and over time had her mature, so we'd all love her!" That's literally something we call *a character arc.* The reason why Ahsoka's is so prominent is because none of the other main characters have one. It's a basic writing skill.
Obi-Wan: "I'm sorry Anakin but we simply can't stop by Space McDonald's to get you a Happy Meal"
Anakin: "..."
The Orchestra: *imperial march motif*
The problem with "it fixed the prequel era" is that the clone wars multimedia project already existed and you would have to compare it to that. It doesn't improve the prequel era simply by existing as there was already alot expanded apon in novels and comics. Stuff the clone wars was allowed to ignore and contradict, which it went out of its way to contradict.
Schaffrillas doesn't know this
I'll say that the CWMMP is vastly superior to this Clone Wars TV show by miles
I still can't fathom the hate the prequels get. Frankly i use it as a bench mark for videos like this. If they bash the prequels as if they are terrible movies or at least liked only as a guilty pleasure and yet praise the original trilogy generally the video just misses the mark or is just a bunch of complaining about little things with varying levels of importance. I grew up with the whole 6 movies as star wars; by the time i could even begin to understand a movie i had all 6 on dvd and never had the chance to see any of them in theaters. All that is to say i grew up with star wars as George kinda intended, and i can tell yall right now that the prequels and the originals are the same damn thing. They tell different archetyes of stories with the og being the classic knights tale & heros journey and the prequels being a greco roman tragedy. Both were made by the same guy at the heart of it, and i can say after binging these movies in various orders that they both share the same characteristics. Both have George Lucas's style plastered all over them to the point it's just a pick your prefered flavor situation. I overall prefer the prequels, buts that's because i just enjoy the tragedy more than the heroes journey, because ive seen the heroes journey far too many times in other media. Ill still watch the video cause im sure it was a lot of effort to put the video together and i should respect and honor that, but i just grow tired of the perceived lack of quality between the two trilogies; all its doing is furthering misunderstandings of what star wars is both in the community and the individuals especially.
Anyway back to this video mostly about the clone wars
As someone that likes the Clone Wars and even Rebels to a certain extent, I completely agree with this. Especially considering how much of a hack Filoni turned out to be now without Lucas overseeing everything.
He’s a fraud from the start.
@@mazkeraid4039 True. Looking back at it, it is obvious that his previous worked because of the other people and giving him total control was a mistake.
Filoni getting control of Star Wars has eliminated any hope for the franchise. Star Wars at this point is pretty much a cursed IP.
@@daytonaofcv6856 just like halo lol
Wats funny is ppl say the prequels weren't as good as Lucas didn't have a team that overlooked him 😂. So we need Lucas to overlook filoni who needs to be looked by another team of writers and producers
My biggest bitch about this show is how the former slave Jedi gets handed an army of Slave children and goes “Oh neat” and rolls on.
His separation from the Order SHOULD have started here. Seeing his fellow Jedi just.. using slave children soldiers and not caring.
but clones never saw themselves as slaves. if you never see freedom, you never miss it. clones only knew one thing: white, sterile environment, people telling them what to do, learning how to fight and serve an ominous "Republic". Why would they miss something they dont know?
Clones aren’t slaves?
@Jedi_Johnny Of course a jedi would say that lol
@Jedi_Johnny They pretty much are. They were bred and raised for the sole purpose to live and die serving the Republic. Cut's desertion and Slick's betrayal clearly showed that they do not have a choice in the matter
I hate how I didn’t get a miniscule reaction from Anakin about Slick. He should have some kind of heated argument with Obiwan and jedi council.
Your analysis of the differences between the novelization of Revenge of the Sith, when Anakin is denied the rank of Master, is very good. One way they could have portrayed this is by giving Anakin a change of wardrobe over the 2 films: he starts off with traditional Jedi robes, but over time he dresses down, he wears military fatigues, or casual clothing. When he sits on the council, there could have been a sense of unease with everyone as they see him dressed completely inappropriately for the venue, as if thumbing his nose at them.
I believe they do this somewhat; This might have just been an old SWT video from years ago, but I vaguely remember something about Anakin's ROTS outfit being unfitting of a Jedi, as the dark robes and overall color palette are more befitting of the sith, where as the jedi wear the brown cloak/beige tunic
@@Nickster300003 I think you're sort of right. But when I saw RotS, I assumed they got a better wardrobe stylist, since they were annoyed at how every Jedi was dressed the same in AotC. I know Anakin's dark colours are supposed to be a symbol he's falling to the dark side, but his clothes are still very "jedi-like".
I'm thinking the effect would have been more pronounced if someone (Mace Windu, for example) actually commented on his lack of decorum, or his style choice. Or if Obi Wan said somehting like "the Masters are expecting us, go change and we'll meet there" and then Anakin doesn't change.
Something like that...
This is another reason why I wished they had used armor in Revenge of the Sith like we see them wear in TCW. You can have everyone wear their normal Jedi robes since they're not on the battlefield, but Anakin still wears his armor since he's now more of a warrior/soldier than a Jedi peacekeeper.
@@nagger8216 Yes, excellent point. The costuming should have included them wearing protective armor while on missions, and could have been used to great effect to show Anakin's gradual fall.
The master cat waifu part had me dying.
Took me a long time to work up the fortitude to click on this video
I have warned many about going back through Clone Wars with a fine tooth comb. You may not like what you find.
Same I’ve been rewatching it recently as an adult and it isn’t nearly as good as I remembered
As someone who was too young to grow up with this series, I heard a lot of great things about it. Then I sat down and watched it. It was still pretty good at times, and the last four episodes of S7 were fantastic, but the previous seasons lacked a lot of coherency and overall quality.
@@taliablack4080Yeah. My experience is precisely the same. I really didn’t enjoy it all that much despite what people said.
Bro seriously? I rewatched it like 12 times😂 Shit goes so hard
I just finished rewatching the series in the chronological order, and besides a very few arcs, I enjoyed it more the second time around then the first.
I've been saying this for years. Dave is the litteral embodiment of the meme "OC DO NOT STEAL".
Imagine when Lucasfilm does enter the public domain. Oh Filoni will be malding very badly.
@@merafirewing6591how much longer till that happens?
@@moonshadow0078if it’s ahsoka then not until 2090s but episode 4 will be available in the 2060s im pretty sure
@@sagebaker6426 thanks for responding
As an animated Ashoka fan, she should have died. Maybe if they pulled off the live version it would have been a "Maul like" revival and I'd be thinking differently. BUT her death would have cemented her as a great character IMO.
I have had SO many fucking issues with that Mortis arc for so long and I am just relieved to hear someone talk about it.
For real. Everyone says it's amazing but it really isn't.
You're the first person to explain why it was a bad idea to give Anakin a padawan.
Captain Fordo/Manda-LORE explained that years before this video. Not trying to say what Sheev says is lesser, just saying.
Not really
Not the first, but it's nice to have a solid video take down for the series. It's been on its hollow throne for far too long. About time we got a well structured video that lays out a lot of its big flaws.
Just the first you've seen.
@@PANCAKEMINEZZ Nah that throne is a good one, I think what this needs is a good response really. One that gives counter arguments really.
Ironic, Anakin bent the force to bring back Ahsoka,
Then Filoni bends space and time to bring back Ahsoka.
"It's like poetry, it repeats itself..."
-George
"somehow, Ahsoka came back"
Filoni introduces what's effectively fucking time travel, and something that could easily be used as an avenue for a "What If" series or just a weight to explore alternate story beats at all, and the only two times it's used it to save Ahsoka from death.
5:48 finally... someone who reccognizes the absolute damage Mordis and "The World Between Worlds" caused... and still causes... and more scenes like Palpatine and Yoda fighting before ROTS just.... burns a little... (like Anakin on Mustifar)
Well we're looking through Yoda's perspective and what he was seeing that was in a vision.
The other reason they should have freed Shmi Skywalker is because she HELPED them. Two Jedi and their party of political refugees were on the run from a killer robot army and any potential assassins. They showed up on her doorstep, and she offered what little she had as respite. And let them get her son involved in their long-shot crazy plan to repair the ship. In fact, forget about the Jedi; Padmé Amidala should’ve made sure Shmi got her own private villa on Naboo! I guess that’s just politicians for you.
A more reasonable explanation for Shmi not being freed after the Battle of Naboo could just be losing track of her, on account of it being a huge Galaxy. You could even say Palpatine sabotaged the efforts. Maybe make it seem she and Watto got blown up by random gangsters. Then in Episode 2, Anakin can only find where she REALLY wound up thanks for his Force visions.
Also, until I watched this video, I honestly Mandela'd her name as being Shimi. “Shmi” sounds like an alien name you hear on Rick & Morty, when they’re parodying made-up sci-fi languages.
When you go to the section talking about Anakin‘s immaculate conception, I’m surprised you didn’t bring up what Episode 3 proposed with the opera scene: that Shmi was ‘impregnated’ by Darth Plagueis (or his rogue traitor apprentice). Which would make Anakin less of a sign from the Force or the universe, and more of a genetic experiment achieved through extra-normal tools.
If i recall correctly, the show implied that the Jedi at least learned that it was Dooku who facilitated the creation of the clone army, and the show has us believe that the Jedi decided to just double down their hunt for dooku in the hopes that his capture would stop the sith plan before it was too late, because if they suddenly stopped using the clones, they wouldn't have any army large enough to defend from the separatists attacks.
Personally, while i initially did love those episodes of the jedi almost discovering Palpatine's plan, i think the Jedi not knowing who made the clones fits better with the surprise betrayal of order 66 in the films. Because now it just makes the Jedi look stupid for continuing to trust a genetically modified army made by their enemy and not suspecting even a little bit that they could've been designed to be used against them.
But apparently calling the jedi incompetent instead of their original defeat being a tragedy, seems to be the popular opinion today.
As evidence by the comments below just calling the Jedi dumb.
The Jedi are so incompetent its tragic.
Either way the Jedi were idiots.
I agree.
The fact that the Council believed a jedi ordered the creation of an army was enough. They were not supposed to know who made it and that they were programmed to kill jedi, while season six shows it being outright discovered. It does make the jedi look stupid and *diminishes* the Order 66 scene bcoz they were supposed to be fooled and their best intentions being used against them. It's inferred that Palpatine has strong foresight and has sway on both sides. Also, that the Jedi were distracted by the war and *tragically* destroyed.
The CW series makes the Jedi appear to embody sloth and lack all sense of self preservation bcoz Americans can't get enough of the "Ooh, big bad corporation" trope.
In addition, I dont know if the CW Jedi going out of the Republics territory to resolve things is good or bad. On one hand it shows that the Jedi are taking initiative, but on the other hand it contradicts the whole "The Republic has no power here" line in Phantom Menace and could incriminate the Jedi and their allies. Or maybe Hutt space is worse than Zyggarian space........
...we will never know.
The changes to the clones and their ‘allegiance’ felt cowardly. Order 66 had the complicated morality of child-soldiers (who kind of seem like indoctrinated slaves) turning on comrades in the name of the government whose allegiance was drilled into them from birth. (Or from cloning pod. However you call it).
The issue is that George Lucas never intended for the clones to be the unironic heroes in a children’s show. (Or if they were, this wouldn’t be the first time he didn’t think out the ethical implications of something in his movies). They were suppose to be a warning about people being raised like the Spartans of old would end up becoming tools for fascism. Instead, we got an Evil Mode biochip. The scenario becomes the Treehouse of Horror skit with the Krusty Doll. No morale questions or logic, just a switch set to “kill.”
@@jiado6893 I completely agree
Halfway through so far and your section on Anakin has been brilliant. You’ve voiced a lot of the issues I had with TCW without completely tearing down the parts I liked. Plus the editing is top notch.
I think the biggest issue is that we're supposed to be the Droid army are so powerful and almost WON the war.... yet in every episode they are defeated and look like complete morons it's why i prefer the 2003 version they lose sure but the Republic actually struggled and actually straight up lost at times and grievous is just... why he runs away constantly even when he has an advantage
"The Mandalore arc made Maul an idiot."
Okay, but at what point was he ever *not* an idiot? He was always a violence guy more than a thinker
He was able to run an entire criminal organization while hiding his presence for some time
@@cara-setun quite an achievement for a zabrak man of violence.
I mean that was essentially why bringing him back was stupid because he should have realized that Palpatine is more responsible for his suffering over Obi Wan and he could have easily exposed Palpatine as the other Sith, but doesn't? Like he tries to subtly, (not really) create a criminal empire to rival Palpatine because reasons? Like i couldn't stand Maul because he just makes constant dumb decisions. That however is alot if TCW characters in general.
@@sergioruiz733well Maul was groomed to be an obedient dog. Sith are meant to be evil and harmful to eachother which is what he'd try excuse it.
Him being replaced, any hate Palps would have for him, him being a mad spider for years. All of it lies on loosing to a padawan after killing his master.
Which is his own fault. But he pins it all on Obiwan, because he's still mad.
@@AnonTDegenerate The problem I have with that then is that he isn't really a true Sith then. The Sith are meant to be eventually overthrow another or surpass their masters or die trying. The Master is meant to pass onto his apprentice the knowledge they know whilst also seeking new knowledge to maintain their position. This is essentially why I only see Maul as a Sith Assassin then anything of an extreme power house that people put him on a pedestal for. He was meant to be thrown away considering Tales of the Jedi conforms Palpatine was already grooming Dooku to be his new apprentice but even he sought to eventually overthrow Palpatine via his training of Ventress. And even if he pins it on Obi Wan his actions of creating a criminal Empire and later in Rebels trying to lure Ezra and seeking to try to eliminate Palpatine shows he is aware that Palpatine has caused him harm, I just don't find him very intelligent in both series.
Agreed. Ashoka should have died in Rebels or during order 66. She feels tacked on now.
Rewatched a few episodes the other day, and rushed is a perfect way to describe it. So many episodes, you feel that 30 minute mandate. Things happen so fast, there’s no time to linger. It’s easily the opposite problem so many Disney + shows have.
Same. A lot of the lessons or debates between characters don't even reach a clear conclusion that I remember. There is a physical conflict introduced at the start, it draws people with different views together in the second, but it is often not paid off in the third act. And I was left implying what the point of the debate even was based on the episode's fortune cookie quote at the start. Yeah, rushed
Nah, besides Andor every star wars episode on disney plus feels too damn short.
@@josedavidcastillo9241 For me, it's a little more complicated. I feel like the stretch their run time without adding more good dialogue scenes. This is most noticeable for me with Kenobi, Ahsoka, and BOBF. It's like instead of cramming everything into 25 minutes, they took the same amount of content and stretched it over an hour.
The real "animated clone wars" will always be the 15 minute 2D shorts that came before
@@JC-oq5ex Same. Those are good
I will say gorge is at his best when he's the ideas guy and has people to bounce off of
Characters like Eren Jaeger or Anakin in the EU prove that you can make a character like film Anakin while still making them likable, the show didn’t need to change him as much as they did
How is Eren similar to Anakin?
@@bboi1489 both are whiny kids who feel trapped and want freedom. Both loose their mother and go on rants about “slaughtering them all like animals” (with Eren the titans and with Anakin the Tuskins.) Both show signs of being incredibly violent at a young age (Anakin killing the tuskins, Eren killing the bandits) but these violent tendencies are ignored by the ones around them due to the understandable circumstances. Both are not trusted by their government but are reluctantly put in a position of power out of desperation (with Anakin he’s promoted to knight because the republic needs more generals and with Eren he is essentially dubbed humanity’s greatest asset because they know so little about how to defeat the titans.) Both get glimpses into the atrocities they will eventually commit taking a significant toll on them mentally (Anakin’s vision in the cave in the 2003 clone wars and Eren’s vision at the awards ceremony.) They’re obviously not exactly the same but my point was that they are a similar type of character. A violent kid with a black and white view of good and evil who is meant to turn evil as time goes on. Something like Attack on Titan proves that that concept can work and the clone wars didn’t need to tone down the more violent and psychotic nature of Anakin and mature him to be a big brother figure. A show with a main character like that can work it just needs to be well written.
Imagine needing a guide to enjoy a show
What’s the guide? Did i miss something?
@@SunsetBearProbably the viewing order of the episodes
@@SunsetBear most people who try getting people to watch the show point at some fanmade guide on which episodes to skip and which to watch in what order. This is the only show I've ever seen that has something like this.
@fishybook2055 It's absurd how much homework thus show demands, and how many people refuse to acknowledge how absurd it is.
@@FishyAltFishy The only exceptions I've seen are really in Anime like Naruto, which are loaded with filler, or The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, which was deliberately released out of order to mess with the audience.
I used to love the clone wars until I read more from the Clone wars multimedia project. The Republic comics were S tier and were some of the best Star Wars I’ve read. It really feels consistent with the movies while TCW breaks continuity in bigger ways and does not have the characters translate well to the movies.
The Republic comics should be mandatory to every aspiring SW fan.
Yeah I recently read them and they are great! Siege of Saleucami was my 2nd favorite just behind the Jabiim story!
Quinlan Vos‘ Double Agent Story was hella good too. Also the first battle of Kamino. I used to dislike Rex because I grew up with the comics and Alpha was just such a badass. Also, I’m kinda glad we never got TCW Durge because they just would’ve nerfed him hard.
So true bro
I used to love star wars until I analyzed the prequels and went "tf is going on?" I was told Clone Wars would explain everything and ended up sitting through 5 seasons episodes of inconsistent sludge that I just couldn't tolerate. Glad this videos telling people how Disney didn't just waltz in and ruin everything, no, they gave the fans what they wanted and the fans just gagged it all out.
I liked because you said you loved andor. Your opinion is valid
I like that the people getting mad at you in the comments are giving not a single critique or response to your points and just going "grrrr this guy is such a liar grrr you just didnt get the show"
I have never, ever understood the mentality of Filoni as some kind of Star Wars wunderkin. I got whiffs of fanwankery from him midway through the Clone Wars. I didn't care for Rebels much, save for a moment or two on Malachor, and with Rebels and Ahsoka being intrinsically-linked to TCW, it speaks volumes to me that Dave is only interested in making his boyhood fanfiction a reality, and shows worrying levels of attachment to his OCs - especially Ahsoka.
The funny thing is that usually what fans of the show say are the best Story Arcs weren't even done by him. Lucas himself had a big role in making and approving things and even his daughter wrote a good portion of those story arcs people consider the best along with another guy named Henry Gilroy who never gets any credit for his work on the show. It's funny they always make him to be the sole person who did anything on the show.
I can’t wait for the MCU-esc crossover between Ahsoka, Mando, Grogu, Ezra, Sabine, and probably a fucking resurrected Maul in order to fight off the evil Admiral Thrawn’s rise to power.
Capeshit ain’t got nothing on this. What would be a good name for it? Slop Wars?
@@HamanKarn567 Exactly, Dave doesn't deserve the praise he gets
Pretty much. Dave saw an opportunity to insert his ideas and did not hesitate since DAY ONE. Literally the debut TCW movie introduces Ahsoka in the first few minutes and we've reached a point where she might as well be the protagonist of the series lol.
@@HamanKarn567 Funny since Henry Gilroy wrote the Slavers Arc and was responsible for alot of Season 1 eps, he really knew what episodes would be an interesting topic to discuss and he left after Season 2 which is a shame since i felt his comic did more character development to Ahsoka and Anakin than anything the show had to offer.
I think the two versions of Anakin could have been rectified to one another if you played into the fact that Anakin was a warrior at heart and it was only in war that he truly became himself. A man not made for peacetime - and you could play that into the fact that his purpose in the force was that he was made to battle the light and dark sides of the force and wrestle them back into balance, so naturally he felt most at home in the middle of a chaotic battle. That actually makes him a bit sympathetic and tragic that he couldn't find the peace he was seeking in the Jedi order because peace was inherently out of balance with his nature and what he really needed was true balance within himself. Stimulating battle on the outside so he could right the wrongs of the galaxy as he felt driven to do, and peace on the inside to make him at peace with himself, with one leading into and strengthening the other.
All they'd need to do to accomplish this is to show him whinier at the start of the series as the Jedi are at peace and only beginning the battle, and slowly developing into this noble character (with obiwan noticing and mentioning it to him how proud he is) over the course of a season or so, then into the last season, have his friends begin to die and all the insecurities in his position in the order and with padme start weighing on him and he's worried about his relationship being discovered and watch him slowly break and lose the man he was turning into who could have been the greatest of all the jedi in history, and watch his insecurities start to whisper to him through the dark side as Palpatine weights the scale to pull him in towards him and the Sith order - returning Anakin closer to that insecure man from episode 3.
Perhaps, but I also think that character trope is often lacking, especially since there's not much in Anakin's backstory that would give way to that.
"A man not made for peacetime" usually works best with a person changed by war, who's unable to integrate back into civilian society. Think Rambo 1, the Punisher, or the dozens of stories of veterans who get back from war, then spend a good part of their lives chasing it in other armies or as mercenaries...
I think at least a measurable part of those changes come from the bond experienced in a combat environment, feelings of helplessness in the midst of combat, and a learned proficiency in combat that makes you really valuable on the battlefield, but those skills don't really translate to civilian life, at least not at face value in a way that would be recognized like they would by fellow servicemembers.
BUT, that also gets topics such as PTSD, or at a bare minimum, something learned about oneself in war that in star wars is really only ever explored in the clones themselves (and even still, looking back on the series after going to Iraq, I see that the development of the clones lends itself to oversimplification sometimes, though handled really well at others.)
Also, anakin isn't really setup for that kind of character development, taking those earlier mentioned factors into consideration: anakin doesn't build much of a brotherly bond the way it's explored with the clones, it's comparatively distant. The feeling of helplessness isn't really there either, aside from single comment with the Sith, anakin is pretty much invulnerable and unshaken in the face of combat (there's no baptism of fire moment where he's getting shot at for the first time and internally reflecting later) and he's not really setup for a somewhat lackluster return to civilian society and any dissatisfaction resulting from it leading him back to it...
Overall though. I find issue with the "warrior at heart/man not made for peacetime" trope because there's a poor setup for anakin, opens a can of worms that the show doesn't explore much at any level except for some moments between the clones, and doesn't really impact the rest of his story, it wasn't a learned proficiency for warfighting that lead him to palpatine nor are those traits part of his character... Especially in episode 3 and after.
I'm not much of an example, because I didn't go through the craziness of the earlier years in the middle east and haven't done anything particularly crazy myself... But I did go through the lackluster return to civilian society which returned me to the defense industry, and I've worked alongside dozens of people who did serve when things were hot back in the surge and have met some people that been shaped by their experiences, but there's nothing in Anakin's character that lines up with or sets up that trope across anything in star wars.
George wrote the holiday specials, and people still praise him, it’s truly some kind of sith magic
I had such a massive crush on Ahsoka when I was a kid. It still hurts to see that they've totally ruined her character in the newer shows.
I have never seen an episode of TCW in my life, nor am I even that big of a Star Wars fan. However, I will still watch this entire video from beginning to end because your stuff is just that good.
💯💯👍. Same
What is there to watch? The plot is on par with a fanfiction and the character models resemble toys 😂😂
Clone Wars is very good I reccommend it.
@@anonymous-hz2unIt's got the best 3d rendering of any family cartoon that went for so many episodes. Compare it to any other 3d cartoon on the same networks and it definitely has better lighting, sound, etc. It's as good as it could be at that budget, really. The graphics look wonky simetimes but got better in later seasons.
@@ImCptnAwesome nah, the movements are clunky (esp of the side character) and the face animation's just amateurish. Even the studio seemed to know it, seeing as how all characters have that really over the top body language to compensate for the lack of facial expression. It's even more apparent in Rebels, where everyone wobbles their hands around while they speak. It get's much better by season 7, I'll give you that.
I hate what this show did to my boy Grievous. He was goated in most media and his ROTS appearance can be explained away by his damage by mace windu. Yes i know it was Lucas idea but it was a shit idea.
Greivous was cooler in ROTS than the show, tbh
Yeah, because Legends Grievous was just stupid. He could canonically attack like over 100 times per second with his 4 arms. That was official old lore. 100 lightsaber swings per second. There would never even be a reason to not just replace your arms with mechanical ones.
@@Elfenlied8675309Sure but TCW Grievous was a bit of an overcorrection don't you think?
@@Elfenlied8675309 2003 Grievous was never meant to be taken as literal canon. Its meant to be more of an exaggeration of what happened canonically. What was meant to be taken as canon and is still supposed to be canon is that hes a deadly jedi killer which is never depicted in the show apart from when he cheap shots Nadhar Webb. Even in Canon TCW comics grievous is much more powerful than he is in the show. And also people wouldn't replace their arms because that only worked for grievous because of tech they put in his brain. Also they did do that for Vader.
@@Elfenlied8675309are you saying that the ROTS book is legends?
Prequels has a great story, genuinely think they are good movies, definitely preferable to the other movies.
"She refuses to give Maul a weapon-"
Did she just totally forget that he's not only a potent Force-user but also a master of Teras Kasi, a LETHAL martial art designed to fight Jedi? He admitted that it made him a better Sith Assasin when combined with his mastery of lightsaber combat.
She's not really aware of WHAT she's releasing onto the Clones here. You're more right than you originally thought tbh.
Teras kasi probably doesn't exist in disney, let alone Filoni's mind.
@@fiddlesticks7245Qi'ra uses it in Solo: A Star Wars story. It's canon.
@@optillian4182 Disgusting
@@fiddlesticks7245 Why?
@@optillian4182 That disney shelved the EU in the name of creative freedom just to rip it off every chance they get? Insulting the work of countless writers just to have their ideas recycled by incompetent ones? Yeah I just don't know how that's disgusting.
R2 and R3 is like watching gerbils fight in south park.
Got the pitchforks and torches ready but I know exactly what he's going to talk about
No you didn't. You may know now if you watched it but not before you did.
@@AthEE_One Why not? The show exists in the same way for all people, so it's not unreasonable to think that multiple people looking over it with a critical eye could've noticed the same issues throughout it, especially in a series as long running as TCW.
@@bigchungus6827 That's not what he said though. He said he knew what the video was about. He couldn't possibly have known that before watching the video itself. All he could have done is assume based on his own criticisms, preconceptions and presumptions about Sheev, and then declare that these assumptions must be correct, which is a dangerous gateway to bad faith arguments.
@@AthEE_One Assuming that is kind of a bad faith assumption by itself, though. There's no real way you can 100% know from their wording that it wasn't because they themself recognize many flaws in the show.
@@bigchungus6827 You misunderstand my meaning. You cannot know what someone has to say before you hear them say it. That is completely impossible. I'm not myself, in bad faith, assuming bad faith on the part of OP. I merely point out that his assumptions may be correct, but must not be stated to be correct before they're berified, lest bad faith creeps in.
The real Clone Wars would always be the 2D Clone Wars from 2003, AKA "Star Wars Episode 2.5".
Kind of awkward how Anakin got freed from slavery only to end up a novice in an institution where he constantly has to refer to his superiors as "master."
Anakin and Obi Wan running into Dooku every other episode is stupid. Especially when the show goes at lengths to make sure Anakin and Grievous don't interact. It's pretty stupid.
I thought that anakin´s version in the clone wars was consistent with his version in the revenge of the sith because if i remember correctly he started going "mad" when he started getting those visions about padme right? At the beggining of the movie he was not too different from his clone wars version.
We see anakin in the movies act so "madly" because he is having dreams / visions about padme or her mom, but in parts of these same movies when he is not having those vision or simply has let the event behind we can see him act more like his clone wars self.
He wasn't as deep into it, but he was already very doubtful and unsure about the order as a whole. Imo, that's something that the movies established pretty well. For all the good the Jedi did, their order was fundamentally deeply flawed to the point that it made Anakin very easy to exploit. Padme was the tipping point, sure, but it was not the start of his resentment towards the Jedi. That said, it's something that TCW and the movies should've expanded upon more so than they did. For a lot of it, the Anakins in the movies and TCW feel like entirely different characters.
@@bigchungus6827 Yes Anakin in TCW does also not trust the council he always disobeys them and critize their choices that is way he is not different from the Anakin we see in the starting of revenge of the sith.
@@gonzaw8539 Eh, to me personally it felt more arrogant and confident in TCW, than in RoTS, or rather it felt off to me because Anakin in TWC felt far more confident and self assured.
@@bigchungus6827 I do think so as well but just a little bit because I think that at the beginning of ROTS Anakin and obi wan talk about something in an elevator (I'm no completely sure if that is the part) an he tells him how he has a charm with women or something like that. IMO if ROTS was longer they would have definitely touched more on Anakin's arrogance and confidence.
It seems someone actually understands the characterisation levied in TCW. This is absolutely the case. It's a derivative from his ROTS iteration, before he experiences traumatic problems again.
1:58:46 Forget the fact that he got shot, that fall would 100% kill him!
Not for force users
But we can all agree that Star Wars: Clone Wars holds up, right?
I think sheev really underestimates what having no attachments really means
The Satine arc with ObiWan only feels good because it's just a boneless Siri Tachi arc. And with her death, you actually get Anakin say Obi Wan never loved her or he would have wiped out everyone involved.
INDEED, Siri deserved more respect
TCW has so many of the same problems as post-Disney Star Wars, where they took better stories, filed the serial numbers off, and pretended it was their own work.
@@AJadedLizard THIS EXACTLY
Yeah, Satine is a really weird case.
I mean....THAT is the woman that you would have left the Jedi Order for, Obi-Wan? Her? Seriously?
They are not remotely the same, what?
Any artist who says "ooh I'm not going to TELL you what my art means, you have to work it out for yourself" absolutely does not have a satisfactory answer to any questions about the interpretation of their art.
Spoiler alert: Darth Maul died in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace. 😏
Thats makes Episode 1 a worse movie for me. The fact they killed such a character with great potential so
EMBARASSINGLY
Like Maul literally dies because hes fuckin stupid, Obi wan jumps up and he has 0 REACTION TIME
0 reaction time for the APPRENTICE of SIDIOUS
Yea no, sorry, thats stupid
@@a_agadir3964great potential? Why? Because he looked cool? He served his purpose and served it well, he didn’t need to become a character, there are bound to be stories where characters are one-dimensional and serving a very utilitarian purpose. No need to arbitrarily assign importance to somebody because they looked neat.
@@TheSEAempire That my friend, thats is called being lazy
If youre gonna make the main antagonist of your film a nobody that has a really cool fight scene that pops up out of nowhere
What reason does Duel of the fates exists other than a way to kill Qui Gon? Tell me, look at movies like Lord of the Rings, where every character has the proper development in order to build up stakes
When your antagonist pops up out of nowhere to fight and just die, that my friend, thats lazy writing
Thankfully, his character potential was fully realized, he didnt have potential because he “LOOKED COOL”. He had potential because he was a SITH LORD, under the most powerful Sith in the galaxy.
Tell me, why did George Lucas want Maul back in the clone wars? Why did George Lucas want Maul in HIS SEQUEL TRILOGY.
The reason for duel of the fates is in the name. Its a duel for the fate of Anakin, if Qui-gon lives he trains Anakin and he doesn't become Vader, if Qui-gon dies the timeline goes as it did
As someone who wishes to one day become a great writer, looking back on a series that you used to see as great when you were younger and starting to notice that it has many flaws worries me because it means that I have to analyze how I write and how this show may have influenced that. I want to one day be able to tell great and noteworthy stories, and critical analysis of other works and one’s self is necessary. I’d like to thank you for this channel Sheev, because you’re one of the last people I can think of who is trying to do that still with Star Wars, a great series that has been brought down because no one seems to want to treat it to the standard it should be held to.
Just start writing man
@DmanDmythoDlegend As someone who is also in the process of writing, I don't see any issue with you reevaluating what you like and figuring out if it's good or bad. For example, I still love Ben 10(the original series and Alien Force's first two seasons) but it's riddled with problems and inconsistencies; elements I didn't notice when I was younger but now being more attentive can pick up. If anything, seeing this stuff could help you improve for you know what not to do.
For example, I recently rewatched Incredibles and it was fantastic. The movie is written so air-tightly from a plot and character perspective that it motivated me to pay more attention about my own work. John Lassenter was a perfectionist and while he's had his duds(Cars), there's a reason why those early Pixar films were so good. He obsessed over the projects, breaking them down, figuring out the individual pieces and putting them back together.
If you care to listen to my advice, just take your time. Go through your work, figure out what you want to do, and get meaningful feedback. If something sucks, figure out a way to make it good or start over. For example, I noticed in my outline for my work a big plot hole I hadn't accounted for and I managed to fix it and adjusted things to account for it.
Because the goal of any writer is make everything you write count. Every plot beat, scene, dialogue etc. When you take those small details seriously, it shows in the craftsmanship. And also don't be afraid of feedback. We all make mistakes and constructive criticism is what can help someone become a great writer.
This dude youre watching is a huge nitpicker lol. You shouldn't take into consideration that much he says.
@@arthurg.calixto3338 pretty braindead take ngl, critiquing something does not equal nitpicking if you don't agree with the critiques
@@revengeofthesith.the channel’s description is literally, “professional nitpicker”
I feel like I'm about the only one of my friendgroup who prefers the CW Multimedia Project content instead of TCW so this is bound to be cathartic. Love a Sheev upload.
Clone Wars was so much better than The Clone Wars, part of why was because everything was exaggerated so you didn't have to take everything literally.
The Clone Wars seems to be a 1:1 story that's supposed to be taken seriously 100% of the time and it really fucked with the lore, especially the Kaminoans.
Changed them from a Nazi-esque eugenics oriented species to a bleeding heart hippy species.
Old canon wouldn't have had a hunchback clone, he'd have been killed offscreen before he made it out of the cloning tube.
The OG Clone Wars is vastly superior 💯
The multimedia project is far superior. I get people like the clones in TCW, but Filoni does the Jedi dirty. In the Republic comics for example, the Jedi are far more complex, and you get the sense that they aren’t just a bunch of fools. They’re normal folk struggling to do what’s right and that sense of right leads them right into Palpatine’s trap. They’re intelligent, which makes Palpatine even more intelligent. In TCW they have almost no redeeming qualities.
CW is so cool
you are not alone, bro! Multimedia-Project over TCW ANYTIME!!! We might be fewer, but we have higher standards!
Jango wasn’t a Mandolorian in Almec’s eyes because he was apart of the True Mandolorians.
There was supposed to be 8 seasons of Clone Wars so we could have had such a better explanation for the Anakin's change into what he is in the third movie, and so much else, but DIsney has to Disney as always.
one of my favorite things about clone wars was how one line from Revenge of the Sith they worked around the entire show because one line where Anakin told Grievous "I expected you to be taller" THE ENTIRE SHOW THEY NEVER MET FROM ONE THROW AWAY LINE
It ain't perfect but it's LIGHTYEARS ahead of Disney Star Wars
“disney bad, give likes”
@@ToasterLad_ Shove your likes where the sun don't shine but yes.
Disney, their copyright lobbying and all of their bullcrap has been bad for decades
@@ToasterLad_ "Somehow Palpatine Returned"
@@Noelll"I don't like sand."
@@optillian4182
‘But we can’t turn back, fear is their greatest defense, I doubt if the actual security there is any greater than it was on Aquilae or Sullust and what there is is most likely directed towards a large-scale assault.”
Recent filoni verse slop has been so dreadful that I'm actually willing to entertain this idea and sort of agree without even having watched this video yet.
To be fair, when Ahsoka releases Maul, she’s got no idea about the inhibitor chips and the fact that the clones are being forced to do this against their will. At that point she may have assumed they all betrayed her.
Once she realises later with Rex that the clones have all been programmed to carry out the order, she decides to try and minimise casualties.
I would agree, except that the Tup and Fives Arc exists and the Jedi are just actively blinding themselves regarding the Clones after that.
"At that point, she may have assumed they all betrayed her" Before the horrific inhibitor chips, that's because they did. In the Prequels, there are no inhibitor chips, they all betrayed the Jedi because they believed the Jedi became their enemies. The clones had this nuance of killing the good guys because they believe the Jedi are actually the bad guys, when in truth, the clones have become the bad guys, and the clones don't realize it, due to them being conditioned to be less independent than Jango himself, with little free will to decide for themselves they are doing the wrong thing.
@@helenwhs She wasn’t there for those arcs.
@@ECSOrder66 Which again doesn't make sense since they could see the jedi themselves...after years they wouldn't just blindly believe that. They always had some free will though...and they aren't dumb either.
@jaydenc367 Yes, they had some free will. SOME. Only enough for the clones to make their own decisions, but not enough to refuse to carry out an order. It makes perfect sense, no, they are not dumb, but they have been conditioned to blindly follow orders. There is no "But they wouldn't do that" They HAVE to do that, there is literally no way to refuse. They were created to be totally obedient. You're looking at this through the eyes of a normal human. They are not normal humans, they are supersoldiers loyal to the Republic that are guaranteed to be 100% obedient to their superiors. They don't think the same way we do. The only reason they can still think is so they are not human droids. But they will always be obedient.
There's nothing wrong with a show like this being episodic, but it can't turn into a sitcom, you can't just return everything to zero after every episode. As much time and opportunity as this show had to develop its characters in meaningful ways, most of it is wasted. As you pointed out, Barriss was one of the most interesting 'premises' for a character in the whole show. Had they actually developed her properly and followed through on her character she could have been an amazing foil to Ahsoka. Would've really liked to see her return somehow in the Ahsoka show but uh, clearly my expectations were wayyy too high for that.
As an adult I enjoy the politics of this show for how it relates back to America, but I can see so many ways in which this show could have been better, plus about 1/3 of it is just straight-up irrelevant or unwatchable in its own right like the droid and Jar-Jar episodes. Also the show introduced a lot of concepts that would later pile onto the downfall of Star Wars, as well as breaking pre-established canon to have the Talz be savages when there was a very prominent Talz Jedi in the '03 show, etc.
You've done a great job with this so far Sheev. Can't wait for part 2.
Edit: You maniacs! You had 35 minutes to make a show about Barriss and you wasted all of it. Damn you all to hell!
"You can't just return everything to zero after every episode"
Yes, you totally can. When you think about it, the whole war itself doesn't really matter one bit. The only thing that's relevant was how it started and how it ended - the prequels skip the whole in-between part without missing anything. The whole show is just a giant bloated filler where Dave Filoni plays with his favourite action figures.
That's why it's best to watch it in the chronological order
@@spartanx9293 That's the only way I watch it anymore.
Not all Talz have to come from that one planet or that one tribe. It's like with the Zabraks on Dathomir instead of just Iridonia or how humans are the predominant species on most planets, there could be several possible explanations as to how these lifeforms ended up there and living some place else simultaneously.
@@Grandof-the-PentastarAlignment I believe that is the current lore explanation, but that episode went out of its way to make the Talz seem like a new species just so they could do a crappy colonization episode (one of the weaker eps in season 1 for me, and that's saying something).
General Grievous was one of my favorite villains in the franchise, and I really liked his 2003-2005 era backstory. I really didn’t like his portrayal in the 2008 series because they made him more of a Saturday Morning Cartoon “mustache twirling” villain. Where in the 2003 show he was absolutely terrifying. And in his backstory for the time he was a somewhat tragic figure who had been manipulated into his role as this monstrous machine… not a guy who wanted power so he made himself a robot.
The level of quality in your videos is outstanding. You're a very underrated youtuber.
I had no interest in the 3-D Clone Wars, but the 2-D one from the Samurai Jack animator was awesome.
It's good, Republic Commando is good, Star Wars Republic is fantastic. There was so much good in the Multimedia Project.
@@AJadedLizard Well I did try watching it, but I couldn't really get into it. The 2-D really gave me high hopes for Episode II, but then Episode II sucked IMO. Grevious who was soooooo awesome in the cartoon was lame in the movie. :(
@@-taz- Same, I found it insulting to my intelligence.
@@extantfellow46 It was "a long time ago," and I was quite interested in watching the 3-D Clone Wars shows. (I got a stair stepper, and needed something to watch!) That was after I enjoyed the first run of The Last Airbender. The Clone Wars, even though I really love the animation style, didn't have much going on with plot or characters. Plus the movies, even the prequels, really pushed me away from Star Wars. I'm not saying it's bad. (Disney Star Wars is bad. Beyond bad.) But it just doesn't pull me in.
@@extantfellow46 3 episodes maybe. I also started watching Bad Batch since a coworker recommended it.
Another thing wrong with that obi wan faking his death arc is that jedi can fucking sense life and death.
There is no question in my mind that Anakin would not be fooled for a second. He would be able to see through the doppleganger tech with empathetic force powers and know obi wan wasn't dead when it looked like he died.
The star wars media never goes deep enough into the implications of essentially being psychically bonded to all living things. An older and wiser kenobi can even tell exactly when the people of allderan died from across the galaxy.
For all we know Jedi and Sith can suppress/hide their force and life energy. Palpatine is a example of that.
@@user-ol7bt4wp1j If you're gonna just pretend that Anakin couldn't sense Obi-Wan's death, a very distinct sensation that's so potent Yoda and Obi-Wan both reacted to despite being light years away from the actual events, you are arguing disingenuosly.
@@fiddlesticks7245
Another simple answer is Anakin at the moment of obi wans death was simply so pre occupied with him being dead that he simply didn’t check wether he was dead or alive with the force
Listen kiddo, we can just as easily argue as to why the show did hold up as we can that it didn’t. Current Star Wars lore and canon is janky and inconsistent enough either way.
Okay but he doesn’t do that in show, so clearly he couldn’t sense it
A much younger and less experienced Anakin was instantly able to sense two tiny venomous worms entering Padme's chamber through a wall multiple feet away, but couldn't sense Obi-Wan not dying right in front of him.
Filoni doesn't understand Star Wars.
Anakin fulfilled his destiny in episode 6 until.. somehow Palpatine returned
is everybody just gonna ignore how Asoka literally let her personal connections, cloud her judgment to the point where the whole galaxy got enslaved by the Empire for over 20 years