Calcutta HC Raps Elect Comm, You Lost Trust !

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 68

  • @subratachakraborty7405
    @subratachakraborty7405 Рік тому +32

    WB and Pakistan's all condition are same condition ,only difference on court system . Otherwise Gon case ..

    • @citizenkolkata6255
      @citizenkolkata6255 Рік тому

      Are you a pakistani ?

    • @subratachakraborty7405
      @subratachakraborty7405 Рік тому

      @@citizenkolkata6255 , if I Pakistani, then ? You know how much Pakistani live in Kolkata? Pakistani can gets job in teacher position in your state, also can ... MLA, MP or election campaner,even also voters ..... then ask yourself , it's wrong or right?

  • @arindamdas395
    @arindamdas395 Рік тому +21

    Long awaited slamming from Honourable High Court, State EC needed a strong revocation, for being politically motivated by the state machinery.

  • @dawawangdi5358
    @dawawangdi5358 Рік тому +22

    Law of Land is Supreme than any citizen and politician. Namaste 🙏

  • @sanjay7pisces
    @sanjay7pisces Рік тому +20

    Elections in other states inspire aspirations, meanwhile in WB...... Inspires a different tale😨😱😨😱. The Hon'ble CJ has made some compelling and scathing observations. State election machinery should not be subdued by state governments. One yearns the presence of great T N Sheshadri in such a scenario.

    • @divyasatheesh2529
      @divyasatheesh2529 Рік тому +2

      Freebies and giving money for votes must not happen

    • @citizenkolkata6255
      @citizenkolkata6255 Рік тому

      @@divyasatheesh2529 what about freebies to big business houses?

  • @parthar8491
    @parthar8491 Рік тому +8

    Finally good sense has prevailed …the entire Bengal state machinery is compromised not sure anything will work even if the political bosses change as commi mindset is deep rooted… all babus need to be retired not transferred.

  • @p.s.gopalakrishnan2956
    @p.s.gopalakrishnan2956 Рік тому +16

    Supreme court nailed EC and state govt. 🎉

  • @LawChakra
    @LawChakra  Рік тому +5

    There is stillness in some parts of the video. This came from original feed.

  • @ashokbraroo8845
    @ashokbraroo8845 Рік тому +6

    Better to stop election and remove CEC and nominate someone by HC

    • @marutanray
      @marutanray Рік тому +2

      it is the state EC not CEC

  • @arindamdas395
    @arindamdas395 Рік тому +14

    When State Election Commission under some highly politically motivated top level bureucrat act in a biased way, these kind of observation and judgements are welcome and appreciated from Hon'ble My lordships

    • @pathsala3712
      @pathsala3712 Рік тому

      Same might happen with the lordship, we have seen such acts out of anguish against state government. This same election commission were blind when people were forced to left their home. Democracy is always on the side of powerful until Unless people choose to rise and change the regim .

    • @pathsala3712
      @pathsala3712 Рік тому

      And lasty if all violence are happening because of election commission supporting tmc party ,then how on the earth same logic don't apply by this court during general election which was conducted by election commission ,real election commission of India।

    • @arindamdas395
      @arindamdas395 Рік тому +1

      @@pathsala3712 if anyone has any complaint against the lordships he or she or a group may move to Hon'ble SC in a democratic set up court of law and judiciary is the place to protect Fundamental Rights and uphold constitutional values . But any kind of violence or mal intent against the judges out of any frustration is not an answer or solution.

    • @arindamdas395
      @arindamdas395 Рік тому +1

      @@pathsala3712 File a PIL regarding the matter and question proper authorities and respective constitutional bodies.

    • @arindamdas395
      @arindamdas395 Рік тому +1

      @@pathsala3712 one or more than one wrong in past can't be a justification or precedent for present wrongs and chaos.

  • @tarunkuwar1978
    @tarunkuwar1978 Рік тому +6

    Mumtaz begum sooiked WB

  • @debayandas4641
    @debayandas4641 Рік тому +2

    Very rightly. Call the person in the court and slap him tightly in open court. Then they may wake up.

  • @arnabkumarbanerjee8150
    @arnabkumarbanerjee8150 Рік тому +1

    Yes election commission lost trust. But what is the penalty for it ?? Why no penalty and only scolding??

  • @nationfirst6817
    @nationfirst6817 Рік тому +1

    Court appears awakening or it is pretending, courts are not reforming to the needs of public hardship faced. collegium system must go,unless courts will not reform, there's no accountability for them against Corruption inside judicial system,njac must be brought to enforce.

  • @srinivasanr1565
    @srinivasanr1565 Рік тому +1

    What are they trying to discuss? The last day fir nominations has already expired? Unless the central forces are deployed and they confirm the stability of security, the last date for nominations must be atjeast would be 15 days after that.
    Not before.
    If not done, its utterly useless.

  • @biswanathbhandari7028
    @biswanathbhandari7028 Рік тому

    It is highly mysterious that almost all the verdicts of a particular single bench are in favour of a particular political party and when challenged at higher benches are being rejected .This has a serious negative impact on the impartiality and credibility of the bench concerned Law must be dispassionately and impartially interpreted and applied. Law must be a powerful pillar of truth.which disallows individual whims and caprices.The purity of purpose is the main criteria.There must not be any compromise with that.

  • @chanukyanuthalapati6553
    @chanukyanuthalapati6553 Рік тому +4

    Mere comments by hc doesn't mean much on the ground. Address the governance issue.

  • @subbaraotanguturu9271
    @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому

    But why SEC is like that.Number of booths where elections are conducted in a phase?

  • @ashokbraroo8845
    @ashokbraroo8845 Рік тому +2

    Why there are killings in Kerala, w. Bengal, Bihar remains during elections. Jihad mindset of opposition parties leaders. Then they will cry evm bakwas

  • @sundarrao535
    @sundarrao535 Рік тому

    Does judges of Madras H.C. have guts to question the rulers of TAMIZAGAM

  • @moushumibaruaroy5582
    @moushumibaruaroy5582 Рік тому +2

    Nobody is above law law

  • @ge4517
    @ge4517 Рік тому +1

    Mamata Begum West Bengal state under human rights questionable by voters. Shameless lady

  • @GamingBeyondBorders
    @GamingBeyondBorders Рік тому +2

    Dictator he mere state me ek .. opposition agr milke isko P.M bana Diya to India malum chal jayega Hitlar Germany me kese Kam karta tha.

  • @avishekhbanerjee2729
    @avishekhbanerjee2729 Рік тому

    @4:41 the amount of "my lord" said by the EC representative, its clear that he is definitely reading from scripts in under pressure

  • @professional.on-line
    @professional.on-line Рік тому +1

    Hello who so ever the lawyer due respect.
    Hoodwinked is an English word yes.
    34 years communists rule Hoodwinked everything
    Under the disguise of labour unions social justice and by anti capitalist sentiment people view wealth creation and possession as evil 😈 yet money and wealth is needed and a criteria or standard index for development and wellbeing in an market driven competitive economy..
    I am not a lawyer yet I request judiciary to view this into account (condition).
    As your security and wellbeing (lifestyle and social status) is being maintained by Central government.
    Do people on the street have it. Its(luxurious). By all standards isn't it.
    People haven't changed only the rulling party has.
    It's panchayat where primary wealth (cultivation) creation happen .
    Best regards

  • @maheshraj2771
    @maheshraj2771 Рік тому

    So Milords woke up with recordical slap with the word ‘hookwink’😏

  • @ManikLalBanerjee-i3q
    @ManikLalBanerjee-i3q Рік тому +1

    Is there any law against enticing the mass through announcing freebies in the constitution??Bribery is legal? Plundering is legal in Islam.

  • @mssumitrapal
    @mssumitrapal Рік тому

    Wr are still delay dalliying , using beating around the bush tactics, situation in bengal is so bad HC shld ask prez of india for prez rule, human life, sanctity of land is higher than any court or law, and that can be restored only with military discipline, but in india we are scared to say that, good luck hindu bongs of bengal. Btw i am a hindu bong, where my great grandfather was senior minister to King of Tripura, our house was in coumilla which was gjven to the muzlims so we moved out, i dont c any fture for indian bengal unless there is timely military action

  • @akashdeep3141
    @akashdeep3141 Рік тому

    It’s actually the death of democracy in WB

    • @narenpun9935
      @narenpun9935 Рік тому

      Not only wb in whole India

    • @patils5410
      @patils5410 7 місяців тому

      @@narenpun9935 dhruv rathi ke follower ho na sachai kabhi dekh nahi paoge ,

  • @samirpanda9982
    @samirpanda9982 Рік тому

    With influx of outsiders, West bengal is going to be another J&K

  • @hometotheworld
    @hometotheworld Рік тому

    waste bengal is a sheer waste hopeless

  • @madhugaganam9845
    @madhugaganam9845 Рік тому

    WB need NRC...as soon as possible get find of Bengladesh , mayanamar muslims B@.......ds and get our of our country's than only WB will be peace and harmony and then only mamatha bi.....ch loss shes position

  • @mohanbist3826
    @mohanbist3826 Рік тому

    Bangladeshi Mamta ko hatao

  • @mdumairmdumair5183
    @mdumairmdumair5183 Рік тому +6

    Please take independent action like this in BJP ruled states

    • @vijayhuawei8219
      @vijayhuawei8219 Рік тому +1

      . Bengal has gone to dogs under the rule of tmc

    • @ishivamrai
      @ishivamrai Рік тому +1

      Abe madarsachaap . Rahega modi he aur bjp . Tum logo ko bahot zaroori hai

    • @Ronifromearth
      @Ronifromearth Рік тому +9

      BJP ruling states does not have election violence and it's performing very well except Manipur where a court decision to provide reservation has caused riots

    • @mdumairmdumair5183
      @mdumairmdumair5183 Рік тому

      @@Ronifromearth 😂😂😂 because there were no agencies there to take action and why Manipur is an exception to you the central government is not even ready to make a statement on it more than 1200 have been killed Bengal riots is nothing in front of it

    • @Ronifromearth
      @Ronifromearth Рік тому +4

      @@mdumairmdumair5183 oh really where did you get this 1200 number from ?
      Madrassa news agency?
      And its not iam rejecting there is no problem in Manipur..cause that would be a wrong thing to do ..
      But that does not concern me as I am not from Manipur but I do sympathise with them, but
      West Bengal's situation concerns me as iam resident of Bengal 😑...
      And everything here is 10 times worse than what's happening in Manipur if you see the ground reality

  • @Vicky-b7i3t
    @Vicky-b7i3t Рік тому

    President rule necessary in bengal